A Silly Diplomatic Dustup.

But first, an observation.

In NZ as in elsewhere, it is the era of cantankerous (mostly rich, mostly white) old guys who have no more Fs to give. From Trump to Winston Peters, Shane Jones, Harry Mowbray, Sean Plunket, Michael Laws, Paul Henry, Leo Malloy and Len Brown, crusty curmudgeons pontificate about things that they know and do not know about, foreign and domestic, but mostly related to matters of race, sex, gender, politics, money and social order. They bring a 1950s vibe to their ruminations and they bring it from deeply within, projecting their formed and uninformed personal opinions into the public forum by virtue of their wealth, profile, alcohol or sheer disregard for the impact what they may have to say on others . These are not statesmen or savants. They are showboats, sociopaths and shysters posing as community superiors. They confuse public attention with due respect.

So now we have the spectacle of Auckland Mayor Len Brown, fresh from a trade junket to China presumably paid for by the Auckland ratepayers and/or PRC government, who declared upon his return that democracy has done its dash, the one party authoritarian regime in Beijing is a capitalist exemplar and that NZ should emulate the PRC as a model of economic development. He goes on to say that Auckland is pro-Chinese while Wellington is pro-US, that NZ should sell its seat in the 5 Eyes signals intelligence network to the Japanese as if it were a trading card, and that a local China expert and international relations professor, both academics known for their understanding of NZ-PRC relations, are paid by the US and a “dick,” respectfully, because his business experience makes him more of an expert than them. It probably helps him with his tennis game as well.

It could be that Mayor Brown was just inarticulate when stating something fairly innocuous. Democracies trade off bureaucratic and economic efficiency for civic representation in free and open elections because, among many other things, the latter are part of the system of horizontal and vertical accountability that provide checks and balances on managerial arbitrariness and excess on the part of policy-makers and bureaucratic implementers. He may be frustrated with Wellington red tape when it comes to his pet projects but he confuses what happens in a soft (“elected”) authoritarian regime like Singapore with what happens in a legitimate liberal democracy like New Zealand. Worse yet, he claims that PRC/CCP centralism is the model to be followed, somehow missing fact that the model he is championing prevents people like him from getting elected into positions of power in the first place.

That makes me think that the Mayor either is in the pocket of the PRC as part of some United Front influence operation (as the China foreign policy expert he insulted, Anne Marie Brady, has described the practice of using sister city arrangements) or he is “very naive” (to use the words of that “dick” professor, Robert Patman). Whatever the reason, ‘ole Wayne appears to be stubbie short of a sixpack when it comes to basic understanding of the differences between dictatorial and democratic regimes. In that he seems downright Trumpish.

Thing do not end there. Because US foreign policy under diaper dandy Don is about bullying and threatening, the US ambassador to NZ, a political appointee tapped for the job because he is a donor to Republican causes and Trump’s campaigns rather than a career diplomat, decided to enter the fray and lecture Mayor Brown on the democratic values that he believes are a shared bond between NZ and the US. That’s right, the lead US representative in NZ lectures a NZ mayor about democracy at a time when the US has ICE arbitrarily detaining, deporting and even murdering people from and on US streets (including citizens and children), invaded Venezuela, threatened Canada and Greenland with annexation, blockaded Cuba, cut funding to International aid agencies and is attempts sanctioning members of the International Criminal Court after not recognising it, backs the genocidal and ethnic cleansing practices of the Israeli state in Gaza and the West Bank, is waging a (failure of a) opportunistic war against Iran, curries favour with the PRC and Russia at a time when both are engaged in anti-US subterfuge abroad, and is engaged in a serious roll-back of basic civil rights and public services at home, including engaging in voter suppression, eliminating DEI programs and and re-writing official historical narratives about the country’s past. To say nothing of the corruption that permeates the MAGA administration. If hypocrisy was excrement, this MAGA US ambassador would be covered in flies.

True to form, ever to take umbrage about the slightest thing and never able to leave well enough alone, the Chinese embassy in Wellington, still clinging to its “wolf warrior” mentality while in a small state where it has enormous trade leverage, decided to admonish the US ambassador about non-interference in other countries’ sovereign domestic affairs as well as the need for cordiality and respect between nations. The compounded hypocrisy factor aside, on this the embassy has a point. Not so much that a country should not interfere in another country’s internal affairs, but if it is going to do so best to do it quietly and subtly rather than squawk loudly like the Ugly American US ambassador did. In other words, follow the model of PRC United Front influence operations as an example. Wayne Brown is proof of its effectiveness.

And there is more! Senior Labour MP Willie Jackson decided to come to the party and suggest that the US ambassador be expelled from NZ for offering his fly-infested lecture to the cognitively challenged mayor. Yep, Willie–not known for anything having to do with diplomacy and foreign relations– decided that he would wade into the fray carrying Labour’s banner at a time when the election has not been fully decided and coalition possibilities are being discussed. As they say, timing is everything, so Labour has not been back-stroking away from Willies’ remarks like, well, a Chinese swimmer on steroids.

From that followed the usual assortment of talking heads and lesser lights all bloviating about the pros and cons of the who’s and what’s. What was a tempest in a teacup has now become a diplomatic dust storm.

Although Chinese diplomats may believe that they effectively peed on a post in the far reaches of the US backyard, seasoned diplomats in the US and NZ must be pulling their hair out. The local yokel rube mayor could have been softly cautioned to pull his head in when commenting on diplomatically sensitive issues. Ambassador MAGA boot-licker could have been advised to just let the matter go rather the post on social media. Willie could have been told to go stand in a corner of the caucus room. Although Brady and Patman certainly were worth approaching on the matter, the ensuing media pile-on and pot-stirring was really about turning much ado about nothing into click-bait something.

Hot air diplomatic turbulence has risen from the word whirling on the matter.

All of this will soon pass and the media cycle will move onto other things, mostly insignificant and occasionally important. Famine, drought, AI malevolence, wars, pestilence, plague and more pandemics (measles, anyone?) will cede space to scandals, rugby, cricket and influencers falling off clifftops, getting terminal diarrhoea from street food and/or having really bad cosmetic surgery aftereffects. Meanwhile, trains and buses will run (sort of) but the ferries will not. A government will form and we will all bear the consequences. Policies will be enacted but personalities will be the focus.

Because of this and above it all, the geezers and codgers will decant their accumulated wisdom for the benefit of themselves and the detriment of the rest of us. Time for us to raise our glasses to them because they are the self-professed Kings of our Domain.

Salud!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *