safe place to buy clomid online comprar viagra online no brasil bad breaths in men using viagra like where do we viagra chocolate in bangalore abreva inactive ingredients in metformin use of viagra by age doxycycline monohydrate hyclate legit site to order cialis australia propecia cost metformin cost with insurance prednisone treatment in prostate cancer steroids nolvadex buy can you still get tan accutane reviews cytotec in pregnancy price of cialis at kroger interferon beta 1a generic cialis online apotheke deutschland cialis information amoxil generic name cialis online sources precio de cialis 5 mg en farmacias buy zithromax norx weebly does propecia work in owmen buy real propecia online metformin 500 mg 48 93 logo de cialis over the counter how much does propecia cost in the uk viagra in london patent generic viagra take clomid if no period main distributors of viagra in pakistan dolac 25 mg zoloft propecia 1 mg for sale buy viagra new orleans viagra trade name and generic name do they sell generic viagra at walgreens buy sildenafil onli buy lasix australia glucophage generico wrestler cialis 20 mg etkileri doxycycline cause vertigo cialis super active 20mg pills cheapest pills best natural viagra ukrainian viagra generico foros prices cialis 20mg sildenafil citrate brand names in india adhd specialists in west palm beach fl price of roaccutane in australia does cialis cause rash cost of viagra in rupees ciproflaxacin dosage for uti in philippines order viagra medicine how to get your dr to prescribe clomid cialis patent expiration date us taking 1500 mg metformin hcl er at bedtime best and cheap cialis donde puedo comprar cytotec tijuana se necesita receta para comprar viagra en farmacia can you buy zithromax in malaysia inderal la 80 mg generic buy zithromax whartisthebestin viagra priced right hiderax 25 mg zoloft how viagra pills looks like how much is 5mg cialis in australia metformin for weight loss cialis 14 cpr riv 5 mg prezzo prednisone uses in ms prednisone usage priligy usa trials bike generic cialis from india reviews on garcinia safe dose prednisolone cable cipro 14 2500 14 gauge in wall finasteride cause depression buy clomid without prescription in the uk dapoxetine india review worksheet viagra ohne rezept bankeinzug curta metragem brasileiro viagra online dorflex e seus genericos do viagra buy propecia aus algix 90 mg controindicazioni cialis generic viagra brasilien propecia availability in india prednisolone teva 20 mg posologie augmentin zovirax herpes nasale 3 mg cialis buy tadalafil online 35008 buy price of ciprodex otic dose of finasteride in bph buy tadalafil canada cheap 100mg generic viagra quanto custa o cialis generico 1mg vs 5mg propecia zovirax vs valtrex for cold sores can you drink on propranolol 80 mg what happens if you put viagra in someones drink remedio montclair 10 mg prednisone cheap viagra search cialis review by older people what time of day is best to take clomid farmacia online cialis generico mexico c doxycycline for use in eyes for dry eye buying viagra online is legal can i take viagra with ramipril viagra dose timing buy clomid post cycle therapy products wean off 60 mg prednisone for 10 how long can you safely take clomid order clomid today recive it tomorrow cheap viagra far east how to order tadalafil online tadora 20 tadalafil tablets for sale buying doxycycline for pets lowest price pharmacy for viagra viagra canadian healthcare where can i get viagra in auckland is zoloft a generic para que sirve el prednisone de 20 mg things that counteract cialis any harm in taking 40 mg cialis indian company who made nolvadex and price clomid 75mg success stories average price of viagra per pill prednisolone eye drops online do pharmacies in south africa stock nolvadex prednisolone 5 mg shortage of eggs ciprofloxacin and delirium in elderly buy brand clomid aventis propecia pain in breast generico do cialis na ultrafarma brasil prednisolone 50 mg tablet metformin er safe during pregnancy what is the dosage for lasix cialis in pharmacy uk success rate of 25 mg of clomid buy lasix canada most secure is viagra safe for post stroke victims how to prepare viagra at home in tamil compare cost of cialis costco walmart amoxil chemist warehouse fake viagra reviews viagra legal in india donde puedo comprar sildenafil en lima comprar remedio propecia clomid safe for baby usage du cytotec erektionsprobleme psychisch viagra generic doxycycline hyclate buy online using savingd account viagra alternatives usa russkie pesni viagra generic cytotec over the counter rite aid doxycycline dosage for pediatrics doxycycline trihydrate 750 mg 25 mg propecia daily tadalafil 20mg x 10 tabletten where i can get viagra in mumbai buy lasix solution doxycycline cost asda direct minoxidil and finasteride together cialis 5mg online uk puedo comprar cytotec en guatemala closest thing to viagra in uk buy viagra online paying with paypal zovirax whartisthebestin price buying cialis thailand does doxycycline helps in treating body odor buy viagra online 100mg seroquel inderal 40 mg astrazeneca share where can i buy clomid uk cialis 10 mg propiedades risk of multiples with clomid appartamenti in vendita roma via cipro viagra in perth wa prednisone 20 mg effects secondaires du acquistare cialis in svizzera francese buy viagra christchurch vimax sildenafil 100mg human doxycycline dose cheap viagra made in usa ampicillin crystals in urinary sediment success rate 150 mg clomid finasteride yes or no finasteride in india is .5 mg of propecia a day effective type web order viagra is online viagra fake where to get viagra in riyadh effects of prednisone in women trimipramine tropfen 40 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin can i get propecia in bangladesh hunter boots buy online uk viagra lasix 25 mg deutsche beschreibung viagra in chennai prices buy doxycycline hyclate powder retina specialist in rockwall texas 40 mg prednisone insomnia generico cialis italia is there a generic name for prednisone can you buy cialis over the counter in malaysia hotel brand of propranolol socialist vote in 1912 dose range lasix can viagra cause strokes dapoxetine brands in pakistan new season bird biotic doxycycline safe humans amc metformin safe for pregnant women metformin dosage in the elderly what is the main ingrediant in viagra viagra sale perth pharmacies that have generic cialis cipro cost canada cialis phosphodiesterase inhibitor glucophage price uk rare how to ship cialis to philippines from canada valiquid wirkstoff sildenafil cytotec in slovenia generika dapoxetine india finasteride india results telangana nolvadex hereisthebestin without prescription indicaciones para usar cytotec there going generic viagra zithromax unsafe prices of viagra in toronto reliable viagra reviews cheap doxycycline online para que enfermedades se usa el ciprofloxacino prednisolone tabletten kaufen haus diflucan price buy real viagra online pharmacy donde comprar viagra en iquique nyal vs zovirax are generic viagra safe how to take doxycycline monohydrate 100mg cheap prednisone 5mg viagra through paypal is viagra over the counter in mercury drug philippines all kind of viagra prices buy viagra enlarge doxycycline combination in mankind viagra per donne in menopausa finasteride 5mg tablets walmart viagra pesni online viagra for women in pune does clomid cause thyroid cancer finasteride 5 mg prostate normal mg for viagra can i take progesterone with clomid metformin 500 mg e generic cialis plus canada pharmacy no prescription propecia como comprar viagra en uruguay viagra store in faridabad prednisone 6 day pack canada what does viagra do in hindi can i take xanax with cialis generic for glyburide metformin off label use for finasteride oral liquid prednisone diflucan price uk rare buy generic viagra sildenafil buy single viagra pills uk national lottery roaccutane isotretinoin price il prezzo del viagra generico metformin axcount 1000 mg preisvergleich can u buy cialis propecia vs. generic what is the safe dosage of lasix viagra 50 mg tablet sample silagra brand name viagra cum with us com is it safe to take benadryl and prednisone together can you get viagra on pbs legal buy zithromax online buy viagra 100 acetylsalicylzuur apotex cardio 80 mg bijsluiter viagra buy nolvadex steroid does amoxil cause fatigue purchase brand viagra online usa viagra online reviews safe take clomid if pregnant buy buying viagra online from canada alloy wheel repair specialist reviews viagra 100 street price cialis availability uk ketian 25 mg of zoloft metformin online australia can you buy viagra from mexico do have have prescription buy viagra how long before sex should i take viagra pill human plant viagra details in time clomid 100mg success 2011 cialis 10 mg gde kupiti metformin therapy in polycystic ovary syndrome tadalafil 40 mg asap viagra 100 mg prezzo farmacia extracto de semilla de uva donde comprar viagra use of viagra in older men cipro 500 mg twice day 10 days buying cialis safely online cialis generika mit paypal kaufen propecia 28 tablets price in maylasia how long to take clomid before iui can you take 4 5g cialis in place of 1 20g cialis best place to buy real viagra cialis price in jakarta can viagra cause urinary retention cialis 20 mg prijs cheapest country to get cialis viagra sale durban prednisone over the counter 150 mg viagra dosing viagra gives mutiple erection in four hours private fertility treatment clomid priligy como usar twitter zofran and inderal manual para usar el cytotec viagra in uae yahoo answer clomid treatment duration amaryl nombre generico de amoxil ampicillin in lactation buy zovirax ointment line will viagra keep you hard when masterbating accutane price in malaysia sony buy viagra online united ste viagra sale in chennai store effet indesirable clomid 50mg sildenafil citrate tab 20mg where can i buy zithromax azithromycin buy viagra in tallin remedio toragesic generico do viagra buy nolvadex research pharmaceuticals ciprofloxacin 500 mg appearance viagra online uk cheapest loans cialis is 2.5 mg review how strong is 100mg viagra esopral 40 mg bivirkninger av zoloft clomid twins 150 mg buy viagra in nairobi viagra order paypal propecia boots in ireland why isnt viagra generic what cold medicine is safe with zoloft zoloft for anxiety in teens online prescriptions viagra india buy liquid clomid nolvadex buy diflucan medication iui with clomid ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg for pneumonia acquistare cialis generico online stopwatch cost of inderal without insurance viagra tablet names zithromax liquid concentration problems viagra unprescribed paypal accepted ampicillin brand names in the philippines cheap dapoxetine baownbeuv is there a tadalafil generic cialis tadalafil 20 mg tab puscifer v is for viagra tracks usa cialis 20mg free shipping europe viagra 100 mg pfizer over the counter drug like clomid ovulation efectos secundarios de usar cialis where to buy zovirax in south africa. what is the generic for cialis vibramycin dergboadre price cialis 20 mg ou viagra viagra in wall taking 20 mg cialis daily a safe viagra alternative medicamento doxycycline 100mg where can i buy nolvadex for pct in pretoria zoloft 50 mg sertraline para que sirve la pastilla ciprofloxacino de 500 mg amoxil brand names cialis 10 mg filmtabletta 4x is generic cialis ok where to buy priligy in nigeria the outside wife better erections with liquid viagra ciproxin 500 mg effetti collaterali sildenafil dose in newborn what dosage of viagra to take priligy como usar snapchat doxycycline hyclate 100 mg knee pain can you get botox on accutane clomid doses for pcos buy chinese clomid cefaclor 750mg generico de cialis how long do antibiotics doxycycline stay in your system can buy viagra asda viagra in the waters what happen if a girl take viagra order viagra online canada mastercard customer diflucan 150 mg 2 cps order viagra from uk is it safe to masturbate when taking finasteride tabs domcolic 10 mg prednisone medco prior authorization form cialis over the counter cialis in bulgaria prescription fabletics positive reviews of zoloft viagra sale hong kong 30 mg day accutane singapore generic viagra where to buy finasteride cheap cialis 5 mg tabs vs 20mg zithromax liquid cat viagra 100 price sams club can you buy nolvadex from uk como tomar ranitidina de 150 mg zoloft how long after accutane can i use retin a zovirax 800 mg herpes on lip generic clomid pct side cipro 500 mg treats truck prednisolone 20 mg posologie arnica buy viagra on door can u buy viagra in bergen norway folcres vs propecia reviews where is the best place to buy viagra in ireland doxycycline blood in stool cost of 500 100mg doxycycline hyclate vega sildenafil citrate pills natural alternative to clomid uk what is ciproxina 500 mg for metformin 250 mg sr buy viagra jet cialis 60 mg for sale in the us overnight fluomizin 10 mg rezeptfrei viagra finasteride pausa can u cut cialis fir daily use in half celebra 200 mg generico do viagra glucophage 500 mg nebenwirkungen cialis canada price daily use shoppers drug mart time taken for viagra to work is 60 mg fluoxetine a high dose prednisone undigested metformin in feces smearing can you take coq10 with clomid powerful viagra pills cheap buying cialis 800mg online is it safe zoloft bloody nose finasteride mechanism of action what is the main ingredient in metformin does clomid work first time where can i buy doxycycline for acne reviews of cialis professional viagra over the counter in europe clip 500 mg metformin use of finasteride in men over 65 metformin 500 mg tab aur cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews real viagra sale online where can i buy viagra plus in malaysia propecia and trying to get pregnant doxycycline safe ba para sa may chlamydia o generico do viagra faz mal generic cialis paypal uk new balance 1690 womens reviews on viagra metanabol 10 mg prednisone prednisone 10mg dose pack wikipedia generic cialis viagra in indian medical stores zambia viagra in hollywood fl can i crossed a half cialis 20 mg what effects clomid 200 mg daily viagra best time to use is there a generic for doxycycline monohydrate cytotec pastillas costo mexico prednisone dosage in pinched nerve for a dog is generic viagra efective cost viagra tijuana cialis 25 mg fiyat pipamperon 40 mg bijsluiter nolvadex cianoacrilato donde comprar viagra viagra causas can i take viagra with antidepressants where to puy viagra in poland reputable place buy viagra metformin ct 1000 mg filmtabletten get cialis samples finasteride generis 1 mg ciproxin indications in urdu comprar viagra embalagem discreta generico del viagra dr simi provera and clomid buy online in uk prednisolone salbe ohne rezept kaufen como se deben usar las pastillas cytotec propecia pricing walmart where to buy priligy in penang cialis at riteaid price propecia and biotin in effect can doxycycline hyclate treat a yeast infection canadian pharmacy otc viagra is allegra safe to take with zoloft is it safe to take ampicillin while pregnant viagra supplier review sildenafil 110 mg troche dose of doxycycline for sinus infection zoloft hydrochloride 50 mg cialis prostate disorders can clomid cause blighted ovum cytotec medicine price in pakistan iphone pay for viagra with paypal tadalafil sales in brazil nolvadex 10 mg 30 tabs Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » A Turn to Mean.

A Turn to Mean.

datePosted on 14:04, April 12th, 2012 by Pablo

As I watched various labour conflicts over the past few months, then took in accounts of greed-mongering of various types (the wheel-clamping rort being the latest), I set to wondering if things have turned mean in NZ. I tend to think so, and believe a lot of it has to do with National’s presence in government as well as the increasing stratification of NZ society–something National’s policies tend to exacerbate. Some of this collusion is obvious, such as changes to labour laws that strip worker’s of collective rights while enhancing employer prerogatives when hiring and firing (under the banner of so-called “flexibility”). Some is less so, such as in the “look the other way” approach to the conditions that led to the Pike River and Rena disasters and the hands-off government reaction to them. But the trend towards meanness began well before National returned to government in 2008 even if it has gotten worse under it.

It strikes me that the syllogism involved goes something like this: increased employment precariousness born of economic recession in climates of market austerity premised on cost-cutting in both the public and private sectors leads to increased anxiety, then desperation amongst the salaried classes as their life opportunities narrow. In the measure that collective means of defense and redress are also pared down and stripped of legal cover, agency takes precedence over principal to the point that individual rank and file interests are sacrificed in favor of continued union bureaucratic presence (however diminished) in those economic sectors that remain at least partially organized. In the measure that workers realize that their agents have adopted the “iron law of oligarchy” where bureaucratic self-interest and survival becomes the primary objective to which rank and file interests must be subordinated, notions of collective solidarity are abandoned in favor of individual self-interest. Since this is the dominant ethos at play in unorganized sectors of the economy and amongst the managerial and financial elites, the move to survivalist alienation becomes endemic (and indeed pandemic, if we include the fact that immigrants are socialized into the culture of meanness, thereby propagating the “disease” beyond its original culture). The original agents of transmission, in any case, would appear to be the market ideologues who have metastasized into the managerial elites of the present day.

When survivalist alienation becomes endemic, cultural, ethnic, religious and other forms of ascriptive categorization are used to justify the “me first” approach to social intercourse. Until then people may just be bitter. But this is the point when things turn mean.

I could be wrong and this has always been the case in NZ. My impressions are formed since 1997, so perhaps what existed before was indeed a land of milk and honey. But it seems to me, beyond the inter-generational inevitability of the trend towards hyper-individualism there lay a number of accelerants that have made things worse in the last ten years.


27 Responses to “A Turn to Mean.”

  1. Peter Dyer on April 12th, 2012 at 14:25

    “…the market ideologues who have metastasized into the managerial elites of the present day.” Well put.

  2. Hugh on April 12th, 2012 at 19:22

    Didn’t you ask this same question like three years ago?

  3. Pablo on April 12th, 2012 at 19:36

    Not that I remember, at least not in this specific way. But even if I did then perhaps it is because the question is well worth repeating.

  4. Hugh on April 12th, 2012 at 19:48

    Well probably not exactly the same question but I do remember a post back when I lived in NZ and you lived in Singapore about how it seemed, from your vantage point, that New Zealand society was getting more conflictual and cleavage-d (forgive the PoliSci lingo). At the time I and a lot of other commenters said that you might have been getting fixated on the negatives, which is always tempting even when your perspective isn’t from outside the country.

    I’ve just spent the last twenty minutes trawling through the archives trying to find it, with no luck, though… although it was an interesting review of your Greatest Hits.

  5. Hugh on April 12th, 2012 at 19:50

    But yea I suppose a few years is enough time to ask again. Although for the record, I think that New Zealand society has been slowly becoming more economically divided since the 1970s, with all that a Marxist view of history would derive from that. And that while it is probably worse than it has been, there hasn’t been any major turn for the worst in the last year or so. It’s always tempting to see the latest outrage as a sea change while forgetting the sea changes we identified a year or two ago.

  6. DeepRed on April 12th, 2012 at 19:53

    Once again, it brings to mind Robert Reich’s , href=>The Truth About The Economy video. Weaken a nation’s middle class, and it’ll get antsy and defensive, and vulnerable to finding a scapegoat. Crank it up to 11, and you get a Weimar Republic.

    In a variant of a post-Great Recession joke, here’s how trickle-down economics works:

    A banker, a battler and a beneficiary are standing beside a table with a large pie cut in 12 pieces. The banker takes 11 of the pieces and whispers to the battler, “Careful of that parasite. He’ll kill you for your piece.”

  7. Hugh on April 12th, 2012 at 19:56

    @DeepRed: Yeah, that’s who to be concerned about. The Middle class. *Rimshot*

  8. DeepRed on April 12th, 2012 at 22:12

    Gack. Mangled link…

  9. Tiger Mountain on April 12th, 2012 at 22:14

    Yeah, you unfortunately arrived some years too late Pablo, the 70s were great in many places in this country. Norm Kirk’s social democratic 1972 government actually funded Ohu, or communes, alternative living communities fer crissakes. Norm also said “take the bikes off the ‘bikies’ (bikers in modern parlance) but as many motorcycles got confiscated as Crusher Collins has managed to crush Evos in reality. And Norm also said no to apartheid rugby.

    A few certain senior civil servants even served as public intellectuals IMO. Union density was higher but union radicalism was never that great, restricted to the marxist influenced or led unions, which by the way achieved some handy reforms like sick pay, Northern Drivers Union vs Winstones quarry 1968, and redundancy pay-combined unions Mangere Bridge dispute. People that hate or ignore unions still want redundancy pay these days.

    Some of the answer lies in the identifiably concrete, and some in the murky malaise of Aotearoa’s still unfolding post colonial situation–dark kiwi, ‘man alone’, ‘dont know, don’t wanna know denial’ and stratification to the miniscule degree which could also be called parochialism in earlier terminology I guess. Rural isolationism etc. Rugby; one writer reckoned was somewhat homoerotic, that ostensibly straight guys without women had some physical touch with other people. Pushing it a bit maybe but… (no pun etc.)

    Lew in his various posts is correct that those that fail to deal with the challenges of post colonial life here just degrade themselves, cheating and leaning on the vulnerable is the finance capital model.

    It is interesting though that Māori have not indulged in the car bomb methodology as other opressed peoples around the world have. In Latin America plain genocide and marginalisation seems to be the rule for indigenous peoples, not too many Waitangi tribunals there. So yes NZ is an interesting case.

    One dictionary of New Zealand History has some great insights. The highest concentration of war memorials in every tin pot hamlet imaginable is in Taranaki, which also over the years has been one of the most racist anti Māori areas.

    To sum up…
    • Surface egalitarianism, glee glee kiwiana, but class system business as usual. $1.8 Bill to South Canterbury Finance bailout, but ‘can’t afford’ to fund improved parental leave.
    • All New Zealanders are immigrants one way or another.
    • Atomisation of communities into individuals and commodity fetishism has ramped up under neo lib for almost 30 years
    • “rabi blancos” are still in charge of most things
    • The pressure is coming down on most people but the means of support or resistance have been depleted
    • The defensive actions of several sections of unionised workers in response to opportunistic employer militancy in a high unemployment environment, supported by the central labour organistion (NZCTU) of this country give some hope: you don’t have to take it.
    • There is marked crossover and combined action among hard and social democratic left groups since the formation of Te Mana Movement

  10. Lew on April 12th, 2012 at 22:50

    Pablo, and I think this is a good alternative — or complementary — explanation for the phenomenon some folks describe when they talk about how middle New Zealand hates, and does not sympathise with, the working classes since Rogernomics. How they resent the guilt they feel at the hardship caused by those reforms, and rationalise it by blaming the working class for having forced the government into such a position.

    I’m not entirely persuaded by that argument, but I do see the reasoning.


  11. Hugh on April 13th, 2012 at 01:28

    ” In Latin America plain genocide and marginalisation seems to be the rule for indigenous peoples”

    [Citation needed]

  12. Tiger Mountain on April 13th, 2012 at 10:41

    @ Hugh: I am not an academic, so you can keep your “citation”. I made a number of generalised asserstions so what interests you about the South American one?

    Each country is different, Bolivia with over 60% of the population identifying as indigenous and Argentina under 2%. Following the Spanish invasions there are numerous examples of whole groups being wiped out for various reasons or confined to woeful conditions in Andean enclaves. It is all there in scores of reputable books. Plus I am in current contact with various South Americans via union business and I have asked questions about this matter.

    Now back to Pablo’s post, NZ unionists have noticed a similar phenomenon to “last place aversion” as referred to in the piece linked to below, where somewhat unexpected people oppose an increase in the minimum wage.

  13. Hugh on April 13th, 2012 at 13:05

    I’ll let Pablo deal with that one Tiger, he’s the Latin American expert. (Although also an academic, so you might not be interested)

  14. ihatenz on April 13th, 2012 at 20:49

    Ridiculous post, White NZ has always been like this. Possibly in the past they saved their mean-ness for people outside their own group (white pretend-rural heterosexual men) but they were always ‘mean’ to the rest of us. As for the assimilsation of immigrants, I don’t think so, not all of them. Polynesia is taking these islands back and various other communities take care of their own members egalitarianism exists outsisde ‘mainstream’ nz. White culture will not be the dominant culture in nz in the future, they know it, that’s why they’re trying to cling to their ill-gotten privileges scared somebody will take away their precious white-supremacy. They or their descendents will get over it when they find out real equality isn’t a threat.

    @tiger mountain: white settlers in nz killed 80% of the Indigenous population and stole 95% of the land. Some Indigenous people in South America still have land and resources to be stolen, that’s the difference. Also don’t know where you got your information about Maori refraining from arson and resistance, but it is a good example of how settlers prefer their own myths over anything ressembling reality. NZ’s opinion of their own egalitarianism and non-‘meanness’ when they were wipng out Indigenous culture, colonising the pacific and enforcing the ‘white NZ’ immigration policy is another example. What else happened in the 1970s you think were so great? Homosexuality was illegal, wife-beating was acceptable, Polynesians (and Maori mistaken for immigrants because they were brown!) were terrorised with dawn raids, English immigrants were allowed to over-stay but they were attacked in the streets, many rural Maori lived in actal 3rd world conditions, etcetc. I can see why you prefer the myth.

  15. Andrew Sheldon on April 14th, 2012 at 09:45

    The problem with this article is that the there is no analysis of human nature; thus no understanding. Oh, also no causation; just correlation with the National Party. Well, you could correlate it to failure of Labour to offer an alternative as well. So is the solution to vote labour, or spurn representative democracy.

  16. Pablo on April 14th, 2012 at 10:17

    Andrew: If you had taken the time to actually digest the post you would have seen that it is posed as a speculated syllogism. It is not an article, and I certainly was not going to set out to analyze human nature (as if!). Nor is there a correlation with National–I started the post by just pointing out things have gotten worse under its rule, but that the trend I was speculating about began earlier.

    Your concluding sentence makes no sense in the context of the post. Rather than critical thinking, you appear to have just stumbled in, read the first paragraph, and burped up some unreflective sophomoric retort. I suggest you go back to reading the NBR and keep that so-called investment advice of yours to other right-wing charlatans.

    NZhater: I do not want to indulge the thread-jack regarding indigenous Latin Americans, but it is ludicrous to equate the relative plight of Maori with the mass slaughter and dispossession of entire populations–including most of the great civilizations of the Inca, Aztec, Auracano, Mapuche, Guarani, Ahumara and Patagones–with the colonial and post-colonial experience of Maori. There was no Treaty for the Latin American indigenous. There was and is instead forced conquest. They were forced off their land, forced to abandon their traditional lifestyles and even killed with impunity well into the 1970s (and 1980s in Central America), and in remote parts of Brazil, Peru, Ecuador and Colombia, they continue to be be so to this day. Their legal rights and entitlements not only pale in comparison to those of Maori; those that they do have have are haphazardly and grudgingly enforced at best.

    Hell, just a cursory look at the current dispute between Mapuche and loggers in Patagonian Chile would give you an inkling as to how much worse things are on the other side of the Pacific (and I should add that NZ-based Fletcher has been an accomplice in the logging industry’s destruction of indigenous land in Chile). So you need to get a grip, at least comparatively speaking, before you set to typing senseless fusillades against the White Man.

    In other words, your rant, while amusing, rests on a profound ignorance of the comparative plight of Maori relative to other indigenous groups around the world. That is not to minimize Maori grievances, but it certainly helps to put them in perspective.

  17. Andrew Sheldon on April 14th, 2012 at 11:32

    Pablo, you offer the option of placing a website,and deflect from your argue to spurn my website, and disparage me ‘NZ hater’. Why don’t you visit my Australia or Japan, or Philippines, then you will see I’m a “hater” of those cultures as well. The National govt, and I’m not a fan of them, have overseen an earthquake and global recession. Are they great? No, they are best the system will offer, so I say change the system.
    You are right; based on the problems I had with your first paragraph, mostly with the values conveyed, so I lost interest in the rest. I’ve certain standards. They are mine; and to be fair, the quality of my content is dubious at times as well. They reflect my priorities.
    Maori-Latin America; really off topic; but I see no point in drawing lines about levels of suffering; since suffering is personal, not collective, and dead people do not talk.

  18. Pablo on April 14th, 2012 at 12:34

    Andrew: You have confused my response to you with my response to the commentator “iihatenz” at 20:49 yesterday. I replied to you both in my last comment. I am glad that you recognize that reading one paragraph and then stopping leaves you open to critique.

  19. Andrew Sheldon on April 14th, 2012 at 15:09

    Point taken…I thought I was ‘NZ hater’ because I critique a great deal of things, including NZ values. :)
    I don’t think its wrong to read just one paragraph; any it does not say anything really, since my motives are not open to you, and my standards or expectations are not yours. Just to clarify. Love that your an idealist; just think you are on the wrong path.

  20. DeepRed on April 14th, 2012 at 18:29

    TigerMountain: “Now back to Pablo’s post, NZ unionists have noticed a similar phenomenon to “last place aversion” as referred to in the piece linked to below, where somewhat unexpected people oppose an increase in the minimum wage.

    This kind of reverse tall-poppy syndrome also brings to mind Paul Graham’s essay Why Nerds Are Unpopular“:

    Another reason kids persecute nerds is to make themselves feel better. When you tread water, you lift yourself up by pushing water down. Likewise, in any social hierarchy, people unsure of their own position will try to emphasize it by maltreating those they think rank below. I’ve read that this is why poor whites in the United States are the group most hostile to blacks.

  21. Andrew Sheldon on April 14th, 2012 at 18:38

    Don’t disagree with you DeepRed; but I wouldn’t make a principle out of it (i.e. the moral relativism aside). Kids are like that because they have a poorly developed value system. But you probably know that. :)
    So ‘some’ kids persecute….and its a rather empty type of ‘better’…because you all end up drowning. Same for American poor whites.

  22. DeepRed on April 14th, 2012 at 22:02

    Andrew: The big problem is when people don’t grow out of it, and cling to puerile and monochrome world views in a grown-up shades-of-grey world.

  23. Andrew Sheldon on April 14th, 2012 at 23:46

    Exactly my point….which is why I had to add some context lest they see your greyness.

  24. Ihatenz on April 17th, 2012 at 15:09

    Ridiculous comment @pablo, there are many complicated and differences between various parts of S America and NZ. Completely irrelevant, but tbf so was the original post. Sorry, this blog was advertised as “left wing”, obviously falsely. What happened in NZ is called “settler colonialism” fyi. The tactics vary from place to place but the purpose is always to eliminate the native and replace them on their own land. White people in NZ own all the land, there are no more independent tribes here to be wiped out or resources to be stolen, this didn’t just happen, NZ isn’t exceptional in this. White settlers in NZ want to congratulate themselves for being less “mean” than Spanish settlers in America whatever. this isn’t a percieved grievance or a competition between colonised people for the acknowledgement of our colonizers, it is a worldwide phenomenon and pretty well understood by most people who have any claim to be “left wing”. Idon’t know why you are writing about nz if you don’t know anything about NZ’s history. Anyway, please stop advertising this blog as left wing and wasting readers’ time. one thing South America is far ahead of NZ when it comes to any kind of left politics. I’m out.

  25. Hugh on April 17th, 2012 at 15:58

    “The National govt, and I’m not a fan of them, have overseen an earthquake and global recession. Are they great? No, they are best the system will offer”

    I have to disagree with this.

  26. Tiger Mountain on April 17th, 2012 at 18:30

    Some of the comments above I must say have pushed this initially contemplative Pablo post towards mescaline craziness. “ihatenz”, fer crissakes, I ‘hate’ very little personally, but severe inability to comprehend the written word nudges the threshold.

  27. DeepRed on April 24th, 2012 at 01:29

    I’m no psychologist, but I just came to the realisation that the “last place aversion” syndrome TigerMountain linked to is a subset of that hoary old chestnut called the Inferiority Complex. At school our headmaster told us it was one of the obvious traits of a bully.

    It spans a wide gamut – it’s also the underlying mentality of “keeping up with the Joneses”, kicking away the ladder (a la Paula Bennett and the TIA), the sour grapes towards the Ports of Auckland union, the fiscal cargo cultism of the Smiling Assassin, and the poor whites in “Why Nerds Are Unpopular”.

    Arm it with a gun, and you get Anders Breivik. Arm it with a million guns, and you get the dictatorships of 1930s Europe.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)