viagra price buy online super pro cms singapore buy brand viagra is there cialis 50 mg clorhidrato de clobenzorex generico de cialis glucophage tab 500mg what brand of zithromax cures gonorrhea lasix bestellen ohne rezept the cost of propecia merck lacoste 120 sildenafil zovirax cream cheap trusted online pharmacy viagra everything in minute online sildenafil sildenafil counterfeit 20 mg clomid uk is there a natural herb that works like viagra alternative of viagra in delhi cialis pills co uk what is walmarts price for cialis 20mg generic viagra with greendot card monthly price of clomid prescription come comprare la viagra sildenafil 50 mg en mujeres mayores can viagra cause edema local places in spain to buy viagra buy viagra in ireland online business viagra 800 com india buy clomid online no prescriptions sildenafil stada 50 mg preis propecia generico prezzo vouchers viagra online prescription required purchase gastrologist specialist in bankstown can you get clomid at walmart buy viagra professional cheap why take clomid and metformin viagra pramil como usar whatsapp costco cost for viagra use of viagra in islam difference cialis 10 et 20 mg prednisone 20 mg teva nisopred 5 prednisolone viagra women available india lasix cause kidney stones how long for 2 150 mg of diflucan to work viagra donde comprar en argentina if a teenager takes viagra is it safe viagra effective after ejaculation reviews watermelon viagra effect comprar cialis farmacia sin receta generic cialis guercmorteo viagra for men for sale in mumbai buy viagra in niferia how long does viagra take to work 100mg cavalieri del reale ordine di cipro cytotec price in ghana armond acne treatment accutane reviews and results prednisone costo que es una pastilla de viagra for sale sildenafil 50 mg mkiii what can i buy that just like viagra precio generico viagra accutane micro dose ciprofloxacina 100 mg ampolla tadalafil citrate and purchase zoloft premature ejaculation reviews importing viagra from india is 10mg of accutane enough cheap viagra over the counter uk tresleen 25 mg of zoloft is prednisone safe for your dog pfizer viagra online paypal uk inderal la 80 price ranges can you get high off of doxycycline hyclate 100 mg buying clomid no prescription how much viagra is safe in one day is indian propecia real does clomid cause earlier ovulation cialis online drugs finasteride topical use can cialis cause seizures makan clomid 100mg coupon free cialis 5 mg where can buy viagra without prescription accutane marketing misoprostol cytotec in italia can i buy clomid without a prescription sildenafil stada 100 mg beipackzettel cheapest zoloft without prescription doxycycline how much to take clomid price in malaysia samsung can i buy viagra in cuba is generic for viagra safe how to tell real viagra lasixwatrpills paypal can doxycycline cause yeast infections in women socialism in usa history counterfeit viagra thailand linagliptin metformin generico viagra online is it safe best time take nolvadex cycle doxycycline 200 mg quad tab vets sildenafil kaufen in deutschland best time day prednisone viagra brand buy paracetamol during pregnancy 500 mg metformin can i take 4000 mg of metformin a day where can i get viagra in malta sinot clav generico de cialis sildenafil 20 mg pharmacokinetics in the elderly metformin dosage in renal impairment classification scoliosis specialists in houston tx turkish journalist karakaya viagra for sale msd propecia 1mg best take cialis can you go in the sun if you are on prednisone quanto costa cialis en farmacia prednisone 28 mg po available in etobicoke pharmacy best generic tadalafil viagra on line no rx keep viagra suppositories in refrigerator philippines generic viagra cialis and prices in egypt how well is socialism working in venezuela online viagra comparison best way to get the most out of viagra is daily cialis reviews prix de cialis en tunisie nolvadex whartisthebestin no prescription viagra generico qual nome can i order cialis on line what is liquid nolvadex sildenafil generique canada can you buy finasteride online can you buy over the counter viagra in vancouver canada cost viagra philippines viagra 50 milligrams cost ocupas receta para comprar viagra cost of metformin er 1000 when will the price of cialis come down does walgreens sell finasteride over the counter can i take clomid with a cyst gas lacrimogeno donde comprar viagra viagra pills in the uk cialis prices at walgreen ranbaxy equivalent to viagra order online priligy in dubai how quickly will i get pregnant on clomid what is the mg for cialis daily metformin gliclazide bioequivalence of generic drugs ciprohexal 500 mg filmtabletten buy propecia lloyds pharmacy portland viagra affiliate marketing viagra in magazin bucuresti cipro lyme disease viagra tablet pakistan in price wrinkle rewind and oxygenius donde comprar viagra clomid counterproductive is doxycycline used to cure gonorrhea metformin hcl 500 mg 24hr sa table propranolol public speaking dosage40 mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg 100 count bottle shock can you get nolvadex in australia does cialis work in the first day vitamin a maximum safe dose of viagra buying viagra generics pro e contro del cialis canada reviews on doxycycline for acne buy us viagra online como comprar cytotec campinas doxycycline topical use tokyogeo fig buy zoloft montclair hexal 10 mg prednisone remedio bi profenid 150 mg zoloft red cialis viagra 200mg inderal retard 80 mg biverkningar snus cytotec causa infeccion doxycycline dosage for pid vibramycin 200 mg tabletten voor finasteride proscar bestellen doxycycline vartinary products for sale piroxicam 20 mg obat apa methylprednisolone is cialis safe to get pregnant can u buy metformin without a prescription amoxil next day delivery uk canadian class action accutane zoloft for panic attacks reviews free prescription viagra zithromax 500 mg daily cual es la mejor pagina para comprar viagra sermion 30 mg pfizer viagra cialis online latvija glimepiride 2mg metformin 500mg in cipla india prednisone pregnancy uk cialis e20 generics24 ohne wirkung von viagra gold 800mg for sale clomid and testosterone replacement therapy buy clomid medication maximum sildenafil tablets 130 mg iron tab metformin 500 mg usa propecia tadalafil nhs prescription doxycycline bronchitis treatment nolvadex 10mg manufacturers in uk optimal viagra dose pepto bismol liquid dog dosage prednisone claversal 500 mg wirkstoff cialis amoxicillin 750 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin viagra 50 mg erowid buy uk lady viagra accutane still in body hoodia gordonii donde comprar viagra cialisis best time of day to take for better results tadalafil bulk powder uk how many mg of accutane cost per dose of cialis acetalgin 500 mg metformin which pharmacy sell cialis in kuwait can you buy viagra pharmacy spain nhs provera and clomid online is viagra safe for older men nolvadex in indian market is clomid from india safe can zoloft work in two weeks ormlite dao generic viagra wal mart cialis prices can you take 2 50mg clomid instead of buying 100mg finasteride costs 90 days synulox palatable tablets 500 mg metformin buy viagra shanghai finasteride generico comprar cialis cost hong kong viagra bestellen pillendienst propranolol hcl 20 mg tabs viagra will get in uae sildenafil 20 mg price comparison safety of zoloft otrexup generic viagra come comprare cialis on line 60 mg prednisone for 2 weeks cialis buy from uk glyburide and metformin in pregnancy lowest price viagra with a prescription best ovulation test to use with clomid should i take clomid if i ovulate regularly viagra for women effects viagra timing in urdu zithromax pharmacy uk flomax over the counter equivalent to viagra cost of 30 2.5milcialis tablets generic tadalafil made me sick vanuatu viagra online cipla shop viagra canada is ampicillin safe to take during pregnancy viagra discount on line safe to use viagra twice in the same day finasteride dergboadre australia cipro 500 ml para que se utiliza does amoxil treat pneumonia herbal viagra for women in india viagra kaufen indien cheapest viagra cialis au can clomid cause a cyst to rupture is it illegal to buy viagra online in germany 10 mg prednisone dose best way to lose weight with metformin er is cialis safe to take with oxcycodone new zealand pharmacy viagra prednisone 10 mg back pain sildenafil over counter substitute ciprofloxacin 500 mg n3 fresas cubiertas de chocolate donde comprar viagra can prednisone cause postmenopausal bleeding what category is prednisone in pregnancy how long for finasteride to take effect generico cialis dr siminovitch online sale of viagra in pakistan medical store 3 failed rounds of clomid reviews que pasa si tomo 40 mg de cialis is 750 mg of zithromax enough to cure chlamydia ciprofloxacin genericon nebenwirkungen 20 mg of prednisone make you gain weight sildenafil tablet price metformin solubility in dmf generico de priligy en mexico can u get a tattoo while on accutane can clomid cause urinary tract infections racialist in 1960 who ships cialis to canada review cialis generic 10 23 year old viagra review viagra dosagem certa generic viagra indian fda types of birth defects caused by accutane generic is viagra illegal in the bahamas brand lasix safety of voglibose and metformin combination viagra 100mg ou 50mg beste wirkung von cialis diflucan oral tablet australia massive houses for sale in uk zithromax viagra kopen online gliclazide 80 mg with metformin 500mg and weight individuelt tilskud cialis generic cost in rupees of viagra 200 mg viagraa cialis brand paypal online viagra cost and insurance bedranol propranolol hydrochloride generic written prescriptions for viagra where can i buy cialis in manila how to know if internet viagra is real the best homemade replacement of viagra trittico 150 mg wirkung viagra snafi tadalafil reviews for bodybuilding can you take avodart with viagra fuentes de agua feng shui donde comprar viagra cialis box paypal viagra wall clock is there a generic for tadalafil viagra times of india cialis confiscation canada customs propecia 2mg day nolvadex buying uk 50 oder 100 mg viagra how to take 200mg of clomid reciprocation map ccw between states is it safe to take propranolol long term price of generic cipro user buy viagra propranolol reviews public speaking chlamydia treatment antibiotics doxycycline viagra spray onde comprar produtos venda sildenafil 50 mg viagra price bangladesh where can i get free sample of viagra what is the price of viagra in karachi accutane reviews for women cipro safe take while breastfeeding alternative of viagra in delhi medications with metformin in them buy azithromycin doxycycline sildenafil vaginal pessaries brands available in india generic viagra from walmart sildenafil in pulmonary artery hypertension ct tadalafil tablets 20mg manufactura india venta online de finasteride 20 mg nolvadex 25 mg proviron glipizide metformin vs janumet is it safe to take diazepam and viagra can i purchase zithromax over the counter prednisone effects in men provera 50 mg viagra does cialis affect women in conceiving hareid viagra for sale pastillas viagra generico in italia is viagra safe if you have hep c juegos reunidos geyper donde comprar viagra viagra sale seattle where can i buy cialis in toronto can viagra stay in body for 2 days valor del viagra en chile use viagra tablet target pharmacy price cialis original intended use of viagra when does uk licence run out cialis much does accutane treatment cost cipro offices in durban efectos de sobredosis de viagra online is finasteride available in ireland secalip 145 mg 30 comprimidos viagra apprilon doxycycline reviews katelaris p viagra australia oraxim 6 cpr riv 500 mg metformin lasix 40 mg bijsluiter actonel once a month generic viagra tadalafil online au where to buy propecia 0.5 mg in malaysia cytotec online no rx overnight grepid 75 mg bijwerkingen doxycycline walmart pharmacy sildenafil cost cialis eciwlcodkedefe for sale viagra for sale 25mg buy clomid research chemicals cardiovascular specialist in the army clomid price mercury drug website sos specialist in okc ok use of cipro in pediatric patients cipro 500 mg informacion phototoxicity doxycycline treatment ciprofloxacino 500 mg uretritis cialis 20 mg equal to what in viagra zovirax injection cost viagra by pfizer online sales of viagra statistics how many viagras in 24 hours can i take generic viagra if i have performance anxiety singapore buy cialis buy viagra canada online saroten 25 mg biverkningar av metformin spectrum 500 mg ciprofloxacin side drug bank of sildenafil citrate prednisone 10 mg tab cad sildenafilcalox counterfeit generic finasteride effective is 25 mg of prednisone a lot viagra in bangladesh produced by square customer reviews for viagra urgent delivery of viagra watch viagra blue online sildenafil revatio 20 mg buy chinese herbal viagra duro clomid iui statistics como usar nolvadex en un ciclo posologie zoloft 50 mg best ayurvedic viagra india is clomid used for low testosterone prednisolone nycomed 25 mg tabletten mastiff where to buy viagra in ksa buy zithromax canada pharmacy prednisone prescription price prednisone 100 mg tablet generic cialis paypal isotretinoin roaccutane review how long does 5 day zithromax stay in your system sildenafil kaufen gnstig why prednisolone in the morning viagra liquid form uk corporation viagra buy egypt does doxycycline cause facial hair ciprofloxacin ya and you taking avodart and finasteride together max dose of dapoxetine viagra pay with paypal uk what are the uses of viagra tablet is it safe for females to take viagra zithromax sciroppo costochondral junction nolvadex to reverse gyno cheepest viagra for sale dahlonega 10 mg prednisone cialis shipment from canada doxycycline nausea help take how much viagra propecia 5mg price 20 mg tadalafil or 100mg viagra purchase cialis on the internet cholestat 20 mg cialis can i take doxycycline if i allergic to ceclor metapro xl 50 mg viagra 5 mg prednisone dosage asthma shelf life cipro 500 mg 50 mg prednisone taper dose generic cialis shipped within canada how long can a person take doxycycline clomid preseed instead cup where to buy when will fda approved generic viagra viagra online eczane comparateur prix cialis viagra pills names in pakistan brand names of cytotec where can i buy viagra otc effetti collaterali pillola viagra online viagra model in football jersey name bar how many mg of generic viagra is needed to work order priligy bertibarots orfiril long 500 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin sildenafil generika rezeptfrei when will cialis go generic in usa glucophage 500 mg for pregnancy do many people take propecia in uk zithromax buy online ukash genericos de viagra precios clomid resistance in pcos hidden forest estates cialis doxycycline 100mg dosage std best products to use after accutane dosage of doxycycline to treat acne best places to buy generic viagra ilosone 20 mg cialis safest place for viagra comprar pastillas cytotec en colombia comen prednisone 10 mg 6 day directions for gout why does cialis come in smaller dosages than viagra order cialis cheap online doxycycline dose for urine infection ciprofloxacin 500mg ingredients sale zovirax in der ssw cheap and effective viagra online viagra in 24 hours wats the price of cialis best clomid brand viagra valium kamagra discreet uk europe prednisolone sodium phosphate brand enterococcus treatment ampicillin is viagra otc in saudi riyadh diuretico lasix 40 mg how to take dose of viagra on buy zithromax powder on line cialis generico 24h specialist food shops in helsinki prednisone 10 mg and birth control ineffective purchase cialis online cheap Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Competing electoral insurgencies, in Epsom and beyond

Competing electoral insurgencies, in Epsom and beyond

datePosted on 10:48, July 21st, 2011 by Lew

In this post I argue that ACT’s apparent willingness to undermine the MMP system that has kept them alive isn’t so much a death wish as a wish to be welcomed back into the National party as a faction, rather than a stand-alone party; to ensure influence from within rather than relying on influence without. I wrote most of this late at night and cobbled it together from several pieces I’ve had banging around a while with some more recent stuff appended, so you have my apologies if it’s a bit disjointed.

Fairfax political journalists Andrea Vance & John Hartevelt have a pretty sharp piece up, calling the ACT-National deal in Epsom a shameless power grab. I wrote about this topic a few days ago. Their analysis is pretty good, particularly the argument that National may have difficulty compartmentalising future ACT scandals away from National, having taken such direct responsibility for shielding ACT from the rigours of electoral democracy. They also make the point that I and many others have made about the dual exploitation-illustration of MMP’s flaws:

Double dealing and horse-trading are nothing new in the battle for political survival. Perversely, as we head towards a referendum, this naked and shameless power grab undermines the very system ACT relies on for survival. The ultimate irony is that Brash wants it replaced with the supplementary member system that would probably vanquish his party.

MMP, and particularly exploitation of the free-rider rule, is what has kept ACT alive since the 2005 election, when the party’s support dipped to its record low of 1.5%. Supplementary Member is the system that Brash personally supports, and although there is no official preference, this is widely regarded as being the system most preferable to most National party members and the wider ACT party also. SM, as proposed with a 90-30 electorate-list split, would indeed be worse for ACT as an independent party, requiring it to get something like 3% 2% of the party vote to gain a list seat, even if it continued to win an electorate. Leaving aside for a moment whether this is likely or not (ACT did, in its heyday, poll well), that’s a considerable disadvantage because National would no longer have such a good reason to throw ACT an electorate seat lifeline. National’s doing so is apparently only tolerated by Epsom voters on the basis of the overall positive-sum value proposition made by John Banks: “vote for me, and I’ll bring five MPs with me on current polling”. You’d be a fool to turn that offer down. Reduce the premium to one MP and it suddenly becomes rather less appealing.

So on paper ACT supporting a non-MMP system looks like a turkey voting for an early Christmas. But I think the game goes deeper than that. ACT has in recent years abandoned its claims to being a classical liberal party, and is now basically a more hardline version of National’s dry petit-authoritarian conservatism, with a few casual nods to “freedom”, such as in alcohol policy. In recent months it has been colonised by the former right of the National party (Brash and Banks, most notably; also “National in Gumboots” Federated Farmers former president Don Nicolson). Both the former were until very recently long-standing National members whose tribal loyalty undoubtedly lies with that party. They see it as having strayed from its roots, and while they undoubtedly appreciate its newfound popularity with voters, they have repeatedly expressed strong concerns that the party has lost its way, and an intention to bring it back around by putting “reinforcing steel” into its governments (in the words of John Banks). Both, I think, would join National again in a heartbeat if National would have them, and would permit them any influence. An electoral system switch to SM makes that a more viable possibility, and brazenly exploiting both the two major flaws to which most people object in MMP — the threshold free-rider rule and the “back door” rule that lets a rejected candidate such as Don Brash back in on the list — sets up a reasonably strong case against MMP.

Supplementary Member has the worst features of both FPP and MMP. It has high noise (the variance between the makeup of the electorate’s votes and the makeup of the resultant parliament), delivers huge incumbency advantages to parties that hold many electorate seats (because there are more of them), severely marginalises smaller parties by reducing proportionality, and despite all this does not meaningfully solve the symbolic split between “legitimate” electorate-based MPs and those who ‘only’ come in on the list, nor the threshold, “back door” or “horse-trading” objections that most critics name as MMP’s worst flaws. (BK Drinkwater modeled FPP, MMP and SM against each other using election data since 1996, although bear in mind that for SM, these figures assume a 70-50 electorate-list split, which is considerably more proportionate than the 90-30 proposed).

National holds many more electorate seats than Labour, and has nearly always done so, even when its popular vote has been lower because its base of support is less concentrated in inner-city and suburban electorates. Any system of reapportioning electorates on the basis of population will continue to entrench this advantage. Under MMP, it is not a very significant advantage; under FPP and SM, however, it is. ACT’s electoral support, both in electorates and nationally, is very weak, largely because their policies are purposefully divisive, with the intent of galvanising a small proportion of “right thinking” voters against the mainstream. National’s strategy since 2006 has been to occupy the centre-ground and cannibalise Labour’s votes in a zero-sum fashion. This has been a strategy of necessity — the 2005 election demonstrated pretty categorically that divisive politics, no matter how much money you could throw at it, no matter how favourable the cultural terrain, or how good the propaganda, was not a winner for National in an MMP environment. The incumbency and electorate edvantage delivered by SM, however, would cushion them against voter discontent and permit a more hardline approach: one that included ACT as a faction within the National party, as it previously was. So under SM, ACT doesn’t need National to throw it a bone, and National doesn’t need to rort the system to extract electoral advantage: National under SM will enjoy sufficient advantage to simply absorb ACT and its policy programme, and its governments will be emboldened to enact divisive or unpopular aspects of that programme without the same fear of electoral blowback that now constrains it. ACT’s strategy is therefore an insurgency against National; one that may be permitted by National, contingent upon the adoption of a more beneficial electoral system.

A further comment on Labour’s response in Epsom is also warranted. Arthur (in comments to my post linked above) suggested that the best way to nix ACT in the 2011 election is for all Labour and Green voters to cast electorate votes for the National candidate, Paul Goldsmith, in the hope that this will send a signal to National voters who are unhappy with the horse-trading between ACT and National that it might be worth defecting. This is, in principle, a strong strategy, and it has been picked up by some Green supporters as well. But I think it’s the wrong strategy in this case, for five reasons. First, it’s a complex and counterintuitive strategy, and it’s extremely hard to get so many people (on both sides) to act against their own instincts like that. Second, the value proposition made by ACT (six for the price of one) is simply too good for a meaningful number of National voters to pass up. Third, it would require Labour to publicly endorse a National candidate, which would permit John Key to proclaim that “even the opposition supports the National party”. Fourth, the electorate demographics for Epsom don’t stack up: this electorate bleeds blue and even if a fair proportion of disgruntled Nat voters defected, I don’t think there would be enough Green and Labour voters to prevail. Fifth, it would require Labour to buy into the electoral-system rorting, making them no better than the National and ACT parties.

Labour looks like it will mount an ‘economic dry’ insurgency by standing David Parker in Epsom. This is a better strategy because it is vulnerable only to the objections two and four above (the positive-sum value proposition, and demographics). These will probably still mean that it is unsuccessful in terms of winning Labour the electorate and denying ACT parliamentary representation, but it also has the advantages of fighting the national and ACT parties on their own turf — economic responsibility — and in demonstrating that even when they’re down, Labour fights fair and respects the integrity of the electoral system. Most crucially, however, whatever strategy is adopted by the left in Epsom must be coordinated. The two proposed strategies (vote Goldsmith and vote Parker) are contradictory: one must be abandoned, and soon, in favour of the other. Because if the Green faction goes into Epsom with one strategy and the Labour faction goes in with another, there’s only one winner: ACT.

L

9 Responses to “Competing electoral insurgencies, in Epsom and beyond”

  1. Pascal's bookie on July 21st, 2011 at 11:16

    On labour in Epsom, I tend to agree now. Used to think ‘vote nat’, but the presence of such a campaign would only ensure that Nat voters would be more likely to vote ACT.

    Lab should campaign against ACT, for it’s ugliness. Don’t campaign against mmp. Campaign for electorate votes for labour, against the misogynistic divisive and illiberal ACT party who are trying to take over National.

    Aim to get anti-ACT voters to vote national or labour.

  2. bradluen on July 21st, 2011 at 11:56

    “Second, the value proposition made by ACT (six for the price of one) is simply too good for a meaningful number of National voters to pass up.”

    This cuts both ways, though — preventing ACT from entering Parliament would be a huge win for the left. A back of the envelope calculation says that, in terms of maximising 2011 seats and expecting ACT to get four seats if they made it into Parliament, an additional 5% chance of killing off ACT would be worth about 2000 party votes lost from left to right. This ignores all kinds of things — notably, the chance of killing off ACT is presumably much higher if the election is perceived as safe for National, and I have no idea what the consequences for 2014 and beyond would be. And I don’t have a good handle on how much Labour and the Greens can affect ACT’s chances. But defeating ACT in Epsom isn’t impossible — at least it wasn’t impossible in 2005, though it didn’t work out — and there’s enough to be gained that the left should be thinking very carefully about this.

  3. Graeme Edgeler on July 21st, 2011 at 13:07

    SM, as proposed with a 90-30 electorate-list split, would indeed be deleterious for ACT as an independent party, requiring it to get something like 3% of the party vote to gain a second seat

    I calculate* that a party would receive a first list seat under SM at about 1.7% of the party vote.

    *assumptions: 30 list seats; no artificial threshold; unmodified Sainte-Laguë method.

    Most crucially, however, whatever strategy is adopted by the left in Epsom must be coordinated. The two proposed strategies (vote Goldsmith and vote Parker) are contradictory: one must be abandoned, and soon, in favour of the other. Because if the Green faction goes into Epsom with one strategy and the Labour faction goes in with another, there’s only one winner: ACT.

    The split vote in Epsom doesn’t go the way you thik it will: A fairly large proportion of Green voters, for example, actually voted for Rodney Hide (16.5%) when compare to Kate Sutton (19.9%) and Richard Worth (18.3%).

    11% of ACT Party voters in Epsom didn’t vote for Rodney Hide.

    Of Labour Party voters, more voted for Rodney Hide than voted for Richard Worth.

    I just don’t see strategic voting of this scale actually working.

  4. helenalex on July 21st, 2011 at 13:42

    As I recall, last election Stuart Nash (the Labour candidate for Epsom) encouraged people to give their electorate vote to National. Hide claimed Nash was betraying his party’s heritage or something, but everyone seemed to think it was a reasonable move to make.

  5. Graeme Edgeler on July 21st, 2011 at 14:30

    last election Stuart Nash (the Labour candidate for Epsom)

    AT the last election, the Labour candidate for Epsom was Kate Sutton.

  6. Eric Crampton on July 21st, 2011 at 16:45

    Nice post.

    Of course, if ACT really wanted to fold into National, they’d deliberately scuttle the party such that all the liberals would head over to National, tired of infighting, nonsense, loonie crusades ranging far afield of ACT’s traditional liberal base. If we ever see them start doing this, that might be better evidence for their wanting to fold back into National than that they campaign for electoral changes over which they have little influence.

  7. helenalex on July 22nd, 2011 at 16:53

    My mistake. Nash was the candidate in 2005.

  8. Arthur (AmeriNZ) on July 22nd, 2011 at 16:53

    I appreciate your take on this, but I should clarify one thing: I don’t think that either Labour or Greens should mount a campaign for strategic voting—I think that sensible centre-left Epsom voters should do it on their own.

    For centre-left voters, voting for Goldsmith would be a simple strategic vote to try and remove Act from Parliament. But it would more accurately prevent Act from getting a gaggle of MPs they’d never be entitled to based on their Party vote alone, and that’s a goal that, intellectually, even some National voters would agree with (but probably not act on).

    If all Labour and Green votes went to Goldsmith (unlikely), it then wouldn’t take a lot of National voters to vote for their patsy candidate to defeat Banks.

    Personally, I don’t think strategic voting will happen on a large enough scale to work, mostly because Kiwis seem to resist doing it—probably for some of the reasons you mentioned. However, I definitely don’t see strategic voting as any kind of rort.

    If I lived in Epsom, I would absolutely vote strategically.

  9. Graeme Edgeler on July 22nd, 2011 at 17:42

    If all Labour and Green votes went to Goldsmith (unlikely), it then wouldn’t take a lot of National voters to vote for their patsy candidate to defeat Banks.

    No. It’d still take a lot of National voters: you’d need more than 10k National Party voters to vote for Goldsmith, if he was also supported by all Labour and all Green voters.

    And while I know Hide does not equal Banks, the likelihood of getting ALL Labour voters to support a National candidate is very low. In 2008, more Labour voters supported Hide than supported Worth.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: