where to buy viagra on the high street zoloft 50 mg a day el costo de cialis priligy per nachnahme bestellen accutane whartisthebestin canada kamagra generic viagra 100 mg sildenafil what is mexican viagra where to buy viagra in broadmeadows melbourne 1500 mg metformin with pcos buying cialis 80 mg powder cheap free herbal viagra viagra viagra wellbutrin 150 mg and zoloft 50 mg cialis 5mg bph cipro manufacturers india pregnant on 6th round of clomid reviews viagra drugs in chennai is zithromax safe for infants body by vi canada order viagra rxlr generic viagra diflucan and nursing price cialis daily use order cialis 20mg metformin in stroke canadian no prescription prednisone generico del viagra en colombia donde zithromax over the counter in bangkok can you take clomid whilst breastfeeding cialis 5 mg ervaringen camping best price on viagra at walgreens buy generic viagra 139 free delivery cialis 50mg tadalafil finasteride buy online cipla when to take metformin for best results san juan puerto rico purchase viagra doxycycline 100 mg bladder infection ringing in ears zithromax dosage doxycycline hyclate india green tablets cialis 10 mg dividere he usado 6 pastillas cytotec viagra means in urdu is clomid available in south africa what is walgreens retail cost for cialis 5 mg metamizol 500 mg tropfen dosierung viagra doxycycline dosage for severe acne how quickly does viagra kick in metformin leaves a taste in my mouth cialis legal in japan employment specialist jobs in cleveland ohio melatonina pura 5 mg controindicazioni viagra zithromax 200 mg difference between metformin and avandia generic name role of ciprotreatment of chl infection in men viagra original kaufen schweiz generic viagra online pharmacy reviews pantoloc 40 mg wirkung viagra viagra kaufen in regensburg clomid bodybuilding uk supplements generic cialis buy australia comprar viagra en forma discreta does japan sell viagra over the counter mechanism of action of prednisone in cancer buy finasteride uae inderal canada zoloft for teen depression 12 5 mg how often can you take a 4 mg dose pack of prednisone propecia cost in mexico can you take viagra and extenze together boots chemist cost of viagra viagra the facts safe order cialis canada zithromax online uk degrees apodefil sildenafil 50 mg duracion generics viagra in philippines can u get high off of doxycycline hyclate vasque taku gtx womens reviews on cialis doxycycline prix belgique price difference sertraline zoloft prednisolone 15 mg 5 ml espanol can i take propecia with high blood pressure doxycycline tablets boots furosemide lasix price best time take clomid tablets doxycycline 100 mg pregnancy modula cialis over the counter how many errections can a man gey in viagra viagra pills in new zealand cani buy propranolol anxiety online buying viagra over the counter in france can we buy cialis in singapore chlamydia doxycycline treatment dosage brooks ghost 8 womens reviews on viagra viagra buy edmonton will clomid cause gyno top facialist in nyc how to score viagra in kl viagra bd price puedo comprar cytotec sin receta cialis india walmarts pharmacy viagra price finasteride 5mg h 37 price prescription propecia wac pricing for generics for zoloft farmaco generico del diflucan cialis super active paypal accounts how long does it take for cialis 20 mg to kick in generic cialis online price indian viagra hyderabad concentration of ampicillin in agar plate zithromax 250 mg dosage chlamydia test how soon after you take clomid do you ovulate ethinyl estradiol acetate de ciproterona selene costume can fertile woman take clomid what is the medicine doxycycline used for noex 50 mg generico do viagra lasix dosage medscape causes of clomid failure accutane prescription price glucophage 1000 mg leaflet how often do you take priligy propranolol er 80 mg capsule chinese cialis 100mg reviews doxycycline 100 mg cost in india viagra reviews uk ciproxin hc ear drops buy shop canadian cialis viagra tadalafil price in bangladesh clomid twins percentage diflucan one dose buy online se toma cialis 5 mg viagra to get confidence back review on thirty day cialis socialist realist painting popular titles nolvadex paypal betalen nolvadex for sale manila clomid for sale in london cheapest place to get clomid cialis 20 mg oder 10 mg fda approved viagra in india american liquid viagra can i take doxycycline once a day priligy generico comprar carro jcb 540 140 for sale in uk zithromax viagra online sales pfizer reviewson viagra difference in prednisone and methylprednisolone viagra brand name drug how to get clomid without prescription in south africa accidentally took 40 mg of prednisone latisse generic cheap cialis cialis break in half clomid 50 mg gravidanza what is the generic drug for viagra rough nose accutane cost azithromycin 250 mg zithromax prednisone 10 mg dosage directions ovaire multifolliculaire et clomid online buy viagra from local store sacramento metformin hydrochloride sustained release how much potassium for lasix 20 mg el ciprofloxacino causa gastritis amoxil antibiotic price brand cialis online pharmacy cialis generico pago contrareembolso viagra tablets features what say the law in the uk for the clomid sildenafil in sri lanka can you buy viagra over the counter in wallgreens can you take viagra and testosterone diflucan in australia over the counter perth cialis buy in europe priligy 30mg e 60 mg adderall xr propranolol 10 mg 3 times a day in medical terms doxycycline time in system viagra from united states viagra cost nz is 5 mg prednisone enough for a gout flare counterfeit cialis review what is the best time to take cytotec safety of uses of spray viagra 100 mg viagra how long does it take to work order generic cialis canada purchasing viagra usa buy generic viagra 50mg online timer usn master training specialist recommendation taper prednisone 40 mg counseling credit generic viagra cialis 20 mg is ok if drink vodka with that why am i not getting pregnant with clomid super x vega sildenafil 100mg uk 20 mg cialis effects on pregnancy intazin 10 mg prednisone how long does it take to be prescribed clomid buying cialis at a pharmacy. viagra pfizer 100mg canada viagra on line generico brand cialis with free postage tadalafil generico 5 mg preise viagra 100mg sildenafil generico in italia para que se usa doxycycline hyclate 100mg espanol sildenafil symphar 50 mg cena achat cialis paypal euro brand name of glimepiride with metformin what to buy lasix herbal viagra green pill comprar viagra online en chile se inderal 10 mg vs valium 10mg nolvadex 60 count 20 mg was ist brand viagra cheap overnight cialis ejertol sildenafil 50 mg clomid 75mg success stories buy diflucan using paypal can i take viagra with norvasc prednisone 30 mg for 5 days dapoxetine poxet 60 generico do viagra da eurofarma peru metformin review nature box metformin buy online india cuantas pastillas usar de cytotec how long will cialis be in your system is cipro safe for stage 3 kidney disease urology specialist in pleasanton ciproxina comprimidos 250 mg prednisolone liquid strength story amoxil capsules 500 mg viagra from soho london can you buy viagra over the counter in malaysia yahoo does doxycycline treat genital herpes where to buy finasteride and minoxidil metformin 1000 mg ohne rezept ciprofloxacin 500 mg compared to z pack cipro cut in half does finasteride cause liver problems buy viagra or cilas cialis blue round alp 40 mg generic options for accutane cialis generika rezeptfrei bestellen doxycycline acne medication yahoo review natural dht blockers vs propecia cialis generic can elevate psa buy prednisone sold in the united kingdom soft viagra quick delivery clomid tablets information in urdu usar viagra sem necessidade retail price of cialis 5mg trusted pill online buy viagra usa prices of viagra in toronto lovenox price generic viagra farmacie online sicure cialis dosage kelnor generic form of zoloft viagra 100 india sildenafil 50 mg farmacia del ahorro viagra cost per pill at walmart vodelan tabletas de 500 mg metformin prednisone 20 mg po zithromax purchase online canada can i put prednisolone in juice why use lasix can you take doxycycline for gum infection viagra ersatz ohne rezept kaufen viagra auf mallorca kaufen no prescription cialis in united states propecia reviews in women safest viagra alternative safe use zovirax while pregnant best cold medicine to take with zoloft ciproxin da 250 mg soglie in pietra per finasteride accutane causes nosebleeds donde comprar cytotec en morelos is 1mg of tadalafil equal to 1 mg of cialis purchase viagra from tesco how long does prednisone injection stay in your system tadalafil et paypal keflex and prednisone viagra in nashville metformin dangerous in pregnancy getting pregnant on clomid alone buying clomid on the internet genuine cialis in singapore viagra australia do u need a prescription balboa press positive reviews of zoloft viagra online sell old night shipping india generic viagra buy one viagra price per pill usa donde comprar viagra en chile sin receta que contiene el amoxil 500 effects of sildenafil can u take viagra two days in a row tadalafil for sale from india zithromax out of pocket cost user reviews of ciprofloxacin viagra for men how can i get in kuwait where to buy clomid without prescription in london female viagra at low cost at chennai can you get doxycycline over the counter in canada cialis for women costs how much is cialis cost is diflucan an over the counter medication how to treat doxycycline sun rash tadalafil 2.5mg price in delhi ampicillin sodium generic name guantes de vinilo donde comprar viagra can you get viagra over counter ciprofloxacino 500 mg saval viagra 20mg online web md generic cialis zovirax ophthalmic ointment buy viagra for sale usa cheap authentic viagra viagra online bestellen legal guardianship viagra of india clomid canada online azotek 500 mg metformin price compare cialis viagra or dogmatil 500 mg metformin purchase prednisolone online plant viagra in abudhabi generic propecia out yet best zoloft paxil best organic form of viagra will viagra gold 800 my really work best propecia online azamun 50 mg viagra is there hcg in clomid new generic cialis costo de pastillas cytotec en colombia comen remedio levoid 50 mg zoloft can you buy doxycycline brand name for ampicillin and sulbactam cialis safe after stroke alternative al viagra in erboristeria i frutti doxycycline perioral dermatitis efecto de sildenafil 50 mg cloxacillin capsules bp 500 mg metformin name in englis of tadalafilo motiron 10 mg bivirkninger av zoloft sildenafil citrate review picolax suppositories 10 mg prednisone doxycycline 250 mg tablets and jock itch buy viagra in saudi aribia viagra buy tablets priligy whartisthebestin no prescription viagra 25 versus 50 mg cialis 2.5 mg erfahrungen propecia price at boots is it safe to take viagra after heart buypass google fulvestrant generico de cialis how to use in urdu viagra tablets for men ovulation douloureuse avec clomid side effect of long in take of clomid deformed babies from accutane reviews finasteride for hair growth accutane initial breakout 30 mg oxycontin diflucan 150 mg tabs fluconazole hasta que semana puedo usar cytotec can i take two pills of cialis 20 mg zoloft therapeutic dose viagra chi lo ha usato nick villarreal la viagra femenina kamagra cialis biz review zithromax 500 mg indicaciones de ratas viagra blood pressure effects mindiab metformin dosage generic one a day cialis generic metformin zydus phar about zoloft 50 mg doxycycline liquid online zoloft metallic taste in mouth can you use doxycycline for a staph infection viagra usa bestellen can doxycycline be used for strep what time of day is best for taking zoloft diflucan fluconazole cheap diflucan online purchase ukrainian can you use cipro eye drops in the ear costo viagra 100 grammi low dose prednisolone apo prednisone 5mg buy generic cialis in uk side effect of doxycycline bp 100 mg is hair loss 30 mg of prednisone daily with vibramycin how much does nolvadex cost thailand prednisone liquid dosage chart when to take tadalafil 20mg is the generic propecia as effective comprar finasteride generico accutane 40 mg dosage rua sesamo generico do viagra buy clomid tablets from the uk how many viagra is it safe to take in 24 hours cialis 50 mg precio weight gain on 50 mg zoloft for depression lasix baownbeuv cost zovirax dispersable 400 mg para que sirve donde comprar viagra en guadalajara mexico zovirax 200 mg tabletter mot zoloft safety risk pregancy herbal clomid uk sandoz finasteride australia biochemistry of prednisone buy sildenafil no prescription uk safe withdrawal of propranolol only been taking 8wks prednisone in bloodstream liquid viagra recipe chinese viagra in redbox cialis 20 mg com 8 comprimidos lasix 25 mg compresse furosemide prezzo 20 mg viagra cost are cialis from canada safe tab finasteride 1mg india viagra vs kaboom reviews where to buy viagra in singapore airport getting viagra in mexico doxycycline can be taken with milk emblema de remedios generic viagra ciprofloxacin in verbindung mit der pille buy diflucan 100 mg prescription pepcid 20 mg dosing of cipro zoloft in liquid prednisone 10 mg tablets weight loss doxycycline uses in treatment of kennel cough in dog what does viagra and cialis cost prednisone lasts in body generic cialis ervaringen anti online pharmacy india viagra safety how to get viagra sample cialis 80 mg does it existe is clomid safe to use 25 mg viagra generic where to buy propecia in ireland viagra used to work how do you know real viagra metformin mg 500 er weight loss cialis 20 mg 8 tablet fiyati cytotec donde lo puedo comprar where to liquid sildenafil in ladies ciprofloxacin 250 mg 100 count bottle generic cialis with dapoxetine online socialist party usa article price of clomid in mercury purchase cialis on the net sildenafil tablets from india buy viagra paypal australia metformin 500 mg ivf clomid to treat low testosterone in men 10 mg cialis lasts generic finasteride vs propecia safe to drink while on zoloft how soon to take cialis sildenafil patent australia prednisolone liquid enema for kids que es el amoxil prezzo farmacia viagra generico in farmacia tadalafil generico overnight shipping cialis generic cheap generic finasteride uk national lottery where buy cialis inverness metformin hydrochloride india order cialis online no prescription canada doxycycline safe breastfeeding viagra 100 how to use is viagra safe to take before surgery does lilly manufacturer cialis in turkey se requiere receta para comprar cytotec cialis dosage mims glucophage egg quality best cost for accutane 30 mg zovirax cream in india can 100 mg of doxycycline cause pregnancy symptoms dose of cialis for ed comprare clomid online inderal para se usa come comprare pillole cialis twins run in family and on clomid but not ovulating doxycycline buy in eu viagra generico in farmacia quando a chuva walgreens viagra 100mg cost 5 mg inderal metformin pregnancy risk viagra costs per pill usa does viagra cause nosebleeds zithromax cost dosierung capval 25 mg zoloft viagra patent expiring touteleurope sildenafil 50 mg y licor buy cialis in tesco costco mx viagra price propecia india helpline viagra india cart what is the cost of generic viagra doxycycline in veterinary aluprex zoloft generic name prednisone 20 mg three times a day pantyhose best online pharmacies for generic cialis use of viagra in industry cialis 15 mg first time 36 hr dosage name of some viagra in hyderabad 300 mg of viagra Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Where Entitlements become Rights, and Rights Outweigh Responsibilities.

Where Entitlements become Rights, and Rights Outweigh Responsibilities.

datePosted on 20:35, May 16th, 2010 by Pablo

My partner and I are reaching the end of our sojourn in Greece and will be back in SE Asia by the end of the week. Her data collection and interview schedule have provided the follow-up material needed to finish the Greek chapter of her book (which includes Ireland and Portugal as the other case studies, a comparative project she started five years ago and long before anyone else noted some of the bases for comparison that now occupy so much attention). For my part, I have managed to glean some preliminary observations about civil-military relations in this fragile democracy, and in doing so have developed an idea about undertaking a comparison of post-authoritarian Greece and Argentina (although the specific focus of the project is still unclear and it will have to wait in any event until I manage to finish the current, long delayed book project as well as some articles in preparation or revision).

At this point I would like to reflect on an issue that I have previously written about in this forum (Sept 2009): the notions of Entitlements and Rights, in this case as they apply to contemporary Greek democracy.

If one thing comes across to this foreign observer, the Greeks have a tremendously developed sense of entitlements and rights. In fact they see them as one and the same. But they also have little sense of social responsibility. The prevailing attitude appears to be they everyone is entitled to express their opinions however they see fit regardless of whether it infringes on other’s security or dissent.  Everyone is also entitled to extract as much as they can from the state without having to help pay the costs of public goods (say, by paying taxes in full). The expressed view is not only that people are entitled to these attitudes (seen as a combination of opinion and behaviour), but that they have the Right to them.

Of course, this is an over-generalisation. Many Greeks do not impose their views on others and retreat into parasitic survivalism outside of their involvement in the public sphere. Yet at least when it comes to the intersection of political and civil societies, the tone is often “me/us first, the rest of you can get stuffed.”

What is interesting about this phenomena is 3 things: 1) that this notion of collective and individual entitlement is construed as a Right of all Greeks. Although nowhere is it written in the Greek constitution that people have a right to storm parliament, attack the police, property and standers-bye, or thrown molotovs into banks during demonstrations, it is generally accepted that such is inherent in the Greek way of expressing dissent or dissatisfaction with the status quo. These types of direct action are not seen as insurrection or low-level guerrilla warfare, but as something disgruntled Greeks simply do.

This attitude–that Greeks not only are entitled to get agro when they protest but have a right to, and that it is their right to not be held to criminal account for their violent public actions–is a product of the days in 1973-74 when the university student movement was instrumental, via violent clashes with the security forces, in bringing down the so-called colonel’s dictatorship that had usurped Greek democracy in 1967. Many of the leaders of that movement are now senior figures in politics, unions, the civil service and higher education. For them it was the resort to direct action, at considerable physical risk to themselves, that was THE decisive factor that restored Greek democracy. As a result, the role of direct action, including violence, has been mythologised in modern Greek political folklore, and even if stylised and ritualised in many instances, it remains central to the formation and reproduction of Greek political identities. In other words, to be staunch in the streets is to be Greek, and nothing can infringe on this inalienable right of all Greeks (immigrants are another matter). In a country that reifies its warring history regardless of win or loss, this is a powerful glue.

That brings up the second interesting aspect of this entitlements-as-rights phenomena: the government, including security forces, agreement with that logic. It is remarkable how the government accepted, for example, that the attempted storming of the Greek parliament on May 5 was a “right” of the protesters. Although it denounced the murders of three bank workers caught up in the demonstration violence, it did not specifically condemn the burning of the bank in which they were trapped.  Instead,  the government ordered that the parliament building be defended so that the debt rescue package could be voted on, but it clearly instructed the riot police to deal  lightly with the protesters and to not enforce basic criminal statutes outside of the immediate confrontation zone around parliament itself (and as I mentioned in a previous post about the general strike, may have negotiated with the communist-led unions to ensure that this occurred).

Nor was there a massive police cordon erected around the city centre, or police roadblocks and checkpoints erected at major road and rail access nodes to the downtown area even though it was a foregone conclusion that armed fringe groups were headed to the scene (and I must say that some of the Greek militant factions have truly marvelous names, such as the “Conspiracy of the Cells of Fire” held responsible for two bombings this weekend in Athens and Thessaloniki). In other words, with full knowledge of what would happen, the government confirmed the perception of entitlements-as-rights by ordering that security be limited and light.  Hence, for the moment, the military has played no role in internal security, which is left to two layers of riot police (one to prevent, the other to respond to violence), regular cops and plain clothes detectives and intelligence agents. However, if the pace of agitation continues, that attitude of military non-involvement in domestic security could well change (and it does not have to be overt, just decisive).

In effect, all political actors accept this particular interpretation of the Greek “me/us first, the rest be stuffed” broad entitlements-as-rights argument. Perhaps that is because there is also a fundamental Greek belief in the powers of collective and individual self-control. But nothing I have seen in the Greek streets suggests that self-limitation is a widely accepted national trait. To the contrary, the general attitude on the streets, both in the daily routine as well as during demonstrations, is that one gets away with what they can absent countervailing or superior power.  For those who have had the experience with them, Athenian street market vendors and taxi drivers are cases in point (and yet the market for both persists).

To put that in a comparative perspective, imagine any group in NZ claiming the right to throw molotovs, wreak storefronts  and storm parliament, and have that “right” not only accepted by any government of the day but also have that government order the police to refrain from using undue force on said protesters in the event they turn violent (to include limiting the number of arrests). Would that ever be feasible? For those so inclined, spurious comparisons with “wreakers and haters,” spitters, bum flashers, flag shooters and burners or street theater anarchists simply do not cut it.

That brings up the third, and most troubling aspect of the broad Greek interpretation of entitlements-as-rights (which if readers may remember my post on the subject last September are clearly not the same thing, nor should they be). Nowhere in this logic is there any notion of social responsibility, be it collective or individual. The entire argument is framed simply in terms of expected treatment and permissible behaviour, not in terms of social costs or collective mitigation of harm in pursuit of the common good. The absolutism of the claim of entitlements-as-rights and the absolute lack of relativity or regard for consequence are quite astounding. It is remarkable to watch and listen to people proclaim zero responsibility for societal ills, collective dysfunction or personal injury while demanding that their expanded notions of public and private rights be held sacrosanct. For this observer, the gap between what is demanded and what is offered in return is canyonesque.

And that is where my personal disconnect lays. As someone who recognises the legitimacy of violent direct action in the face of oppressive regimes, I fully understand the public need to physically confront the powers that be. But I also understand that there are costs involved in that form of expression. When one contravenes established  criminal law–often on purpose because it is a symbol of tyranny or class rule–one accepts that s/he has placed themselves outside of the law-as-given. One is thus a self-recognised “outlaw,” defined in old American Western parlance as “outside of the law.”  Being outside of the law of course means that one is liable to extra-judicial retribution, or at least criminal charge. Guerrillas  and counter-hegemonic activists of of all stripes understand this as they enter the fray and they fully understand the downside consequences of their decision to act (the Waihopai 3 notwithstanding). Having said this, it strikes me that the Greek state is more obese and arthritic than malignant and oppressive, so the resort to violent direct action on a near daily basis seems symptomatic of  a malaise not solely attributable to the Greek state.

And yet in contemporary Greece most everyone has a state-centred grievance and no one has a a claim on blame (or at least accepts even partial responsibility for social costs involved in the claim to entitlements-as-rights). For Greeks, collective costs are acceptable so long as immediate personal injury is avoided (this applies to bank managers as it does to unemployed youth). Rights of voice and expression are believed to be unfettered and encumbered only by individual preference, the consequences of which are to be borne by others.  Outside of exceptional cases involving ongoing public interest, public or private contravention of the law-as-given is generally held to be non-liable. A petrol bomb here, a bribe there–everyone is entitled to express their self-proclaimed rights in their own way and others should beware and steer clear. There is collective tolerance of that view. Governments come and go indulging such attitudes as the miminal cost of rule. Greeks that understand democracy as a substantive and procedural compromise can only ponder this, shrug their shoulders, and silently weep.

All of that may change now that the crisis is upon the Hellenic Republic. What may have been permissible in better economic times may no longer be so as the burden of sacrifice begins to wear on the fabric of Greek society. As austerity bites into the great mass of Greek workers the resort to survivalist alienation in the private sphere may give way to a defensive overlap between collective and private notions of entitlements-as-rights, drawn along lines reminiscent of 1974. Should that occur (and there have already been calls from ultra-nationalist groups for the military to act), the logic of entitlements-as-rights spawned by the events in 1974 could well be replaced by a military counter-version in which it is entitled, and has the right, to intervene in government in order to “save” the nation from itself, even if on a temporary basis.

Improbable as that may seem (and it is), such could well be the future price Greeks might pay for confusing a broad conception of entitlements with civil rights devoid of civic responsibility. Let’s hope not.

Epilogue: This concludes my posts about Greece. I may have more to comment on this fascinating country down the road but for the time being I must contemplate a return to the authoritarian (yet efficient and clean!) tropics. Which brings up the question: is it better to live peacefully and comfortably without real voice under authoritarian aegis, or is it better to suffer disorder and inefficiency in a democracy in which voice matters more than anything else? That is the perennial question of transitional political societies.

PS: My partner says that the syndrome is much more individual than collective, and that participation in collective action is a convenient cover for individualist self-projection using the ideological justification of rights to unfettered voice (rather than a genuine concern with collective gains). I disagree to some extent because I think that repeated involvement in direct action modifies the very notion of self (for better or worse), but that subject is for another discussion. In the meantime I defer to her superior knowledge of all things Greek.

15 Responses to “Where Entitlements become Rights, and Rights Outweigh Responsibilities.”

  1. Bruce Hamilton on May 17th, 2010 at 10:43

    Thanks for the interesting perceptions. Some Greek attitudes have obviously changed significantly over the last three decades since I spent a month or so there.

    Perhaps some of the angst may be because joining the EC hasn’t delivered obvious and anticipated benefits to those in Greek cities, but has imposed some unwanted community rules?.

  2. Chris Trotter on May 17th, 2010 at 16:09

    Your country’s forebears, Pablo, evinced a less censorious – and more revolutionary – attitude to the rights of free peoples:

    “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, — That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security”

    It would seem the Greeks retain a firm grasp on the right of the citizenry to rebel against “a long train of abuses” – even if some Americans do not.

  3. Pablo on May 17th, 2010 at 18:01

    Geez Chris, you are always good for an insult asnd a laugh, but this time your comprehension skills appear to be muddled. The Greek government may be deeply flawed, Greek elites may be uncaring, and there may be some serious pathologies in the body politic itself, but it is a democracy, not a foreign tyranny imposing its rule on some pluckhardy colonialists (who themselves owned slaves, dispossessed the indigenous and disenfranchised women). Moreover, I never said that resistance to oppressive government was wrong–to the contrary. So the parallel with the US Declaration of Independence is silly at best and stupid at worst–or maybe once again you are just trying to be gratuitously unpleasant. That is unfortunate.

    Oh, and BTW–on the bit about “taxes without representation.” In Greece it is the opposite: there is plenty of representation but virtually no one pays taxes (or at least what they fully owe). So that is another analogy FAIL.

    Bruce: There is an interesting rural/urban and island/city divide in Greece that has been exacerbated by the economic crisis. The irony is that the rural sector and islands are faring better simply because they were and are less dependent on foreign loans for their material well-being.

  4. Kate on May 17th, 2010 at 19:13

    @ Bruce: You raise an interesting point here about the connection between the Greece of 30 years ago (undergoing democratization after the fall of the dictatorship, not only because the colonels were pushed from below, but also because their regime was short-lived, lacked institutionalization, and didn’t have much economic and political elite support anyway), and the political dynamics witnessed today.

    Hellenic experts (both academics and social commentators) inform my understanding here. Many current Greek politicians and business leaders get their legitimacy from the fact that they were student activists during the dictatorship (the most famous instance of resistance being centred at the Athens Polytechnic in 1973). They are represented not only in the ranks of the KKE, but also and more importantly PASOK, which has dominated Greek politics since the early 1980s, calls itself “socialist” but is more a populist party and has at times pursued neoliberal policies (notably under Costas Simitis in the late 1990s in order to join the euro, and is about to do much more of the same). Chris might want to note the parallels here to NZ (with a nod to Bruce Jesson’s Fragments of Labour): ostensibly left-leaning politicians formulated their ideological outlook in the context of “resisting dictatorship” and the pursuit of largely post-materialist goals (Muldoonism and anti-war protests in NZ, the junta and “freedom” in the case of Greece). Yet because in both cases their socialist/left-wing background and understanding didn’t run particularly deep, it was relatively easy for former student leaders in NZ to “sell out” during the 1980s, and Greek student leaders to do likewise by not only shifting to the right in some cases, but also becoming part of the web of corruption and big business-state entanglement and clientelism that is contemporary politics in Greece. (N.B. this is of course not just a PASOK problem; arguably Nea Demokratia are worse. The Socialists are not particularly Socialist and the New Democrats are not particularly democratic.)

    Furthermore, the way in which Greece’s contemporary democracy was born, overlaid on centuries of history of resisting, in both big and everyday ways, foreign oppressors, has implications for the way in which ordinary Greeks think about exercising their “democratic” rights. In many Western democracies, we tend to think of democracy as playing by the rules of an established game in which all parties have a fair chance of winning at some time in the future (so it is worth playing by those rules rather than defecting). Academics extend this to analyzing democracy in terms of the rule of law– empirically, the latter seems to underpin the former. We also think of democracy as finding ways to get along together, framed as tolerance or allowing everyone to have their space. Greeks tend to think of the exercising of democratic rights as the pursuit of (I argue, as Pablo notes, largely individual) interests, even if, and this is the key, it means reducing the rights of others. (Also, given rampant corruption, the rules of the game aren’t necessarily neutral or fair.)

    A few concrete policy examples. (1) The pension scheme, which is pretty notorious at home and abroad. Some people (largely public servants) get very generous pensions, while others get nothing. Numerous attempts to change this framework have failed. (2) University students constitutionally get free education, including textbooks and lunches (!) [remember the role of students in the 1973 uprising and later], but Greece spends one of the lowest amounts on tertiary education in the OECD. The result? Places are limited, and university access for obvious reasons is mostly restricted to the middle and upper classes. Attempts to overhaul this provided the background to the 2008-09 riots, including a physical attack on and hospitalization of the rector of Athens University. (3) Greece has one of the lowest birthrates in Europe. With a very limited welfare state, work-life balance is tough here. Yet family benefits are limited to families with “many children”, meaning 3 or more. Attempts to redistribute these benefits more equally have been met with mobilization on the part of conservative lobby groups aligned with the Orthodox Church (and described by one respectable academic to me as “medieval freaks”). I won’t even get into immigration policy.

    All in all, Greeks are prone to noisy protests, and normally I would argue that this is a Great Thing. But the content of protest matters too– not all social movements are progressive. All the above examples show that key interest groups (aligned with both left and right) have worked to entrench inequalities rather than overcome them. How can these groups, sometimes small and apparently unimportant such as the large family group get away with this? Because politicians are afraid of being labeled as “dictators”, or the removers of (again, largely individual) rights. This is another instance of how contemporary Greek politics is shaped by the events of almost 40 years ago.

  5. Chris Trotter on May 17th, 2010 at 23:26

    Bowing to the diktat of the EU, and agreeing to its demands that extreme financial hardship be imposed on those elements of the Greek population least able to afford it, doesn’t strike me as being in the least bit “democratic”, Pablo.

    The Greek Government had other options.

    In choosing to abase itself before the European Central Bank, however, it also chose to make itself the enemy of its own people.

    It deserves everything that (hopefully) is coming to it.

  6. Pablo on May 18th, 2010 at 02:14


    At least we agree on that much. But as Kate says, if you do not like PASOK, wait until you see the alternatives. The KKE only polls around 7 percent so is not a viable govt contender either alone or in coalition given PASOK’s absolute majority. The rest are a collection of nut bars strewn across the ideological spectrum who do not reach a combined total of 20 percent of the vote. That leaves New Democracy as the only other contender for government, and they would have made the PASOK concessions to the ECB/IMF look mild in comparison. There is where the revolutionary option might fit, but not now.

    Incidentally, and admitting my cynicism regarding it, if you have such a low opinion of Greek democracy, I can only imagine what you must think of the current National govt. Perhaps the Urewera 18 had a preemptive point after all and were just the Kiwi equivalent of the colonial minutemen and wimin! Re-reading your quote from the US founding fathers, could it not apply, in the extremist vision, to NZ itself? >>just taking the piss with that last comment<<

  7. Kate on May 18th, 2010 at 04:46

    Least you’ll think I don’t agree that the Greeks have a lot to protest about, they certainly do.

    Chris: the Germans actually suggested that the Greeks sell off ‘some islands’ as a solution to their woes! The Greek answer beyond WTF? is ‘how about giving us some of the reparations you owe us after the way you trampled all over the country, starved our citizens, etc, during WWII?’ Excellent point.

    However, I’m not exactly sure what the ‘alternatives’ to the austerity measures really are. On a practical level, the only real alternative option seems to be to withdraw from the Euro-zone, allowing local control over the currency rather than aggressive and hurtful deflation measures, but I just don’t see that happening. Why? Because apart from PASOK freaking a bit during the early 1980s, the country has pursued a mildly though not at all smartly executed pro-EU strategy since. It’s been a way to shore up military support for whatever qualifies as ‘democracy’ for a start… without that EU check and balance on civilian control over military activism, things could be much more dangerous right now…

  8. Bruce Hamilton on May 18th, 2010 at 09:20


    Thank you very much for the current interpretation, a great read. The city/country/islands divide was pronounced 30 years ago.

    Some of the younger urban malcontents I talked to were looking to emigrate, rather than stay and wait for change; whereas the younger rural/island people were looking to move to Athens to progress. Perhaps that would exacerbate the difference over time.

    There wasn’t an obvious sense of hope for a bright new beginning in the general populance I talked to.

    The less-than-stellar academic performance is not a surprise, and may be a consequence of the benign-climate culture of style over substance, and the sense of entitlement that Pablo reports.

    I sometimes wonder whether NZ is similar, but the increase in slothfulness after the first generation is masked by continued immigration and the accepted emigration of ambitious high achievers.

  9. Hugh on May 18th, 2010 at 10:00

    I’m pretty sure Greece has already received reparations from Germany for World War 2.

  10. Psycho Milt on May 18th, 2010 at 13:57

    Chris: the Germans actually suggested that the Greeks sell off ’some islands’ as a solution to their woes! The Greek answer beyond WTF? is ‘how about giving us some of the reparations you owe us after the way you trampled all over the country, starved our citizens, etc, during WWII?’ Excellent point.

    Not very excellent, given that Germany not only already paid reparations but has handed over billions of Marks/Euros in aid to Greece over the last few decades. Their reluctance to throw good money after bad is entirely understandable.

  11. George D on May 18th, 2010 at 15:17

    This attitude–that Greeks not only are entitled to get agro when they protest but have a right to, and that it is their right to not be held to criminal account for their violent public actions–is a product of the days in 1973-74 when the university student movement was instrumental, via violent clashes with the security forces, in bringing down the so-called colonel’s dictatorship that had usurped Greek democracy in 1967.

    I don’t know enough about Greece to comment meaningfully, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it was a legacy of the polarisation that followed the Civil War and the period of authoritarian government that followed. As I understand it, the left was left with few legitimate avenues for political expression and the country was bitterly divided. I’m loathe to blame too much on histories, but they do appear important, as Pablo and Kate have both suggested here.

  12. Kate on May 18th, 2010 at 16:40

    About reparations: the main point being that this is what (many) Greeks propose as a (serious) solution to their economic crisis, not the historical accuracy of their claims.

  13. SPC on May 20th, 2010 at 16:53

    The Euro scheme is by its systemic design enabling Germany to get stronger relative to other economies. If the French were not so blinded by their European zeal and Franco-German leadership alliance, they would see the Euro as part of the neo-right “Anglo-Saxon” agenda for the world economy. The collapse of the Euro is simply the other side of the banking crisis and speaks to a neo-right corporatist takeover of the political economy.

  14. Tiger Mountain on May 21st, 2010 at 00:42

    Pablo, you are such a teaser. Vacillation the academic’s curse. Surely it’s ok to say where you stand on Greece, regardless of the seeming rules of engagement between the state and protestors, divisions thereof inclusive.

  15. Joseph P on May 22nd, 2010 at 07:07

    Pilger’s view:

    The Heresy Of The Greeks Offers Hope


Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)