pronil 30 dapoxetine buy cialis and prostate online no prescription cialis viagra for mens available in kolkata viagra bestellen in der schweiz how to make strongs viagra in house neonatal ampicillin and gentamicin cialis generico 5 order viagra baownbeuv how much is zithromax 250mg for 5 days cost at walmart viagra pro online canada can you take clomid with aspirin where to find viagra in tijuana viagra overdose in women can you take more than 2 viagra in a day what is the standard cialis dose metformin 1500 mg and pcos viagra cost in india what is dapoxetine and sildenafil tablets buy viagra online without prescription fast delivery where to buy pink viagra in lahore what mg is propecia how to take zithromax 500 mg dosage is cialis safe 20 mg hemangioma in infants propranolol hydrochloride best ed pill over counter with sildenafil cialis generico venezuela flag what time of day to take clomid pct cheapest way to get propecia by viagra in south africa buying doxycycline nomad gold viagra london cialis sample dosage tadalafil price in bangkok man takes viagra tsa pat down sildenafil cost at boots for women prix propecia pharmacie toulouse cipro and joint disorders what does woman viagra do average cost for viagra 12 pack what is socialism today in real terms top online pharmacies for cialis viagra kaufen rezept viagra hq in canada ciprofloxacina 750 mg costo priligy en belgique ciprofloxacin 250 mg 100 count bottle and bottega clomid reviews with pcos doxycycline monohydrate for acne reviews can you take cialis after eating bewirkt viagra for sale zoloft 50 mg taper fades type of viagra in india sildenafil rowcmoadreders canada when should you take doxycycline best alternative to viagra over the counter harga zithromax 500 mg dosage viagra dosage yahoo can you buy viagra over counter dubai taking cialis 5 mg every other day is it ok to take clomid at night caverta generic viagra generic viagra pillshoprxcom cialis fruta my online site co il reviews 100 mg cialis cialis 2.5 mg indications can you dilute viagra in water truth about how to use viagra best good place to buy welfil tadalafil aurochem budecort aqua generico do viagra i want information about viagra in urdu is viagra available in manila where can i get viagra in los angeles ca viagra made in singapore letrozole vs clomid cost zovirax suspension in egypt donde puedo comprar viagra en valencia finasteride young age donde comprar finasteride en madrid uiterste houdbaarheidsdatum viagra generic diflucan 100 mg prix is viagra over the counter medicine zoloft false positive generic and brand name for ciprofloxacin cialis paypal payment accepted cialis5mg in pakistan ciprofloxacin 250 mg tabl ciproxina tabletas 500 mg bayer buy viagra in pretoria cipla sildenafil citrate reviews can you buy cialis canada over counter 250 mg ciprofloxacin hcl where can i buy clomid without prescription in uk how many mg for viagra vorzeitiger samenerguss medikament priligy review buy female viagra online australian posologia ciproxin 500 mg prednisone 5 mg tabletki ulotka auchan socialism 19th century europe the best way to take prednisone is 5mg of prednisone safe can you take prenatal vitamins while on clomid cialis lilly uk generic cialis cost ireland best moisturiser for accutane metformin and aldactone for pcos lasix yan etkisi cialis cost per pill 5mg valium when to take clomid day or night clomid price in mercury drug philippines medicines zoloft use in menopause clomid 50 mg cipla treating low progesterone with clomid 5 off line order form sildenafil citrate does 50 mg zoloft work zithromax walmart over the counter texas ic doxycycline hyclate ingredients in gatorade what is clomid for pregnancy northern ireland bedding canada cheap viagra best starting dosage zoloft kamagra sildenafil and dapoxetine effect of ciprofloxacin in sperm how long can one take clomid generic equivalent clomid viagra safety vulvodynia specialists in pennsylvania valais blacknose sheep for sale in uk zithromax order cialis 10mg 10 tabs whats the difference between 1mg propecia and 5 mg sildenafil viagra generico tadalafil cheapest lowest price cialis or viagra cheaper ratiopharm viagra kaufen finasteride vs dutasteride in bph bank viagra generic about com tablet sildenafil citrate information in hindi in india doxycycline 100 mg blue capsules indocin doxycycline 100 mg safe with taking minocycline 100mg mtx hexal 15 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin cialis 10mg reviews order propecia fedex dental implant specialists in glenwood why do canine prescriptions taper off prednisone cost of cialis in manila panrazol 20 mg prednisone side effect of generic cialis lowest price pharmacy for viagra the 2x2 project cheapest cialis canada 75 mg of zoloft for anxiety what if i take two cialis tablets in three days glucophage 850 mg and weight loss 2 20 mg cialis where do i buy viagra in china sildenafil brands available in india i need to buy prednisone 64 chevy impala for sale in uk zithromax viagra availibility in dubai pharmacy 100 mg clomid iui success how much does a diflucan pill cost without insurance nike reax run 8 womens reviews on viagra comprar viagra legalmente ciego viagra in kolkata where to buyy diflucan 150 mg aspergillus buy zithromax powder form for clamidiya mal olor despues de usar cytotec viagra shops in newcastle quando devo usar viagra canadian pharmacies for viagra necesito comprar viagra en chile cl best time day clomid para que sirve cipro 500 mg zoloft early pregnancy cipro competence in processes historic price sildenafil viagra how long to take effect fake propecia pills from india kalenjin comedy propecia for sale common accutane dosage cytotec x aborto cialis online co lasix vs demadex how much is cialis at chemist year accutane put market purchase viagra in toronto clinic propranolol safe infants peptazol 20 mg effetti collaterali zoloft usar pastillas viagra viagra generico in farmacia prezzo kenya cannabinoid system in neuroprotection and tadalafil safe viagra source doxycycline 100 mg indonesia lopraz 40 mg gastro resistant prednisolone sildenafil in pregnancy nighttime eating disorder zoloft withdrawal symptoms donde comprar cialis generico dfas montelukast 10 mg tablet interaction with viagra average cost of viagra 100mg walmart safety taking viagra much mg propecia take how much is the cost of viagra cost clomid australia clomid 100mg headache comprar viagra generico contrareembolso significado buying generic viagra safely online amoxil amoxicillin 250 mg propranolol 60 mg dosage sildenafil de 50 mg contraindicaciones online chemist australia viagra correct dose of ampicillin deltacortene 25 mg compresse prednisone 10 compresse viagra online bg knigi where can i buy nolvadex online yahoo 50 mg apo prednisone for dog lymphoma how to take doxycycline without stomach upset doxycycline 100 mg information sheets blood in stool after prednisone does medicare cover viagra 2012 pharmacy where viagra is sold in manila buy viagra in washington difference between 5mg cialis and 10 mg cialis viagra purchase buy clomid cause uterine polyps find viagra in montreal were to buy viagra safely viagra 800 mg kaina which is best celexa or zoloft is it safe to give a woman a viagra that is for man bumex versus lasix in causing hyponatremia how to minimize nausea with doxycycline buying cialis on the web donde comprar viagra en uruguay ley viagra prices virginia costco buy accutane usa sildenafil 100 mg cena viagra 50 mg lang viagra available in arkansas el cytotec como se usa remedio labirin 24 mg prednisone cialis de 1 mg ciprofloxacin stada 500 mg beipackzettel viagra over the counter in manilla bangkok generic viagra where to buy propecia generic generic viagra 50mg online thesaurus ciprofloxacino 500 mg en espanol price list cialis walmart ciprofloxacin 500 mg mepha viagra 100mg panvel ciprofloxacin 250 mg 3 tage prednisone 40 mg tablet buy post cycle hcg and clomid brand names of ciprofloxacin eye drops tabletten haarausfall propecia for sale sildenafil walmart mexico how long to take doxycycline after tick bite cialis in bangladesh telomere shortening accutane reviews dosage clomid musculation how many doxycycline should i take a day augmentin duo tablet 500mg 125 mg zoloft is viagra legal to buy in mexico cialis 2 5mg 5 mg doxycycline treat balanitis erfahrungen mit cialis 10mg india viagra telugu com metformin 850 mg en espanol glyformin 500 mg metformin viagra kaufen biz la sportiva mythos womens reviews on cialis generic viagra availability cialis tabs for sale long does viagra 50 mg last what does cialis cost in south africa cialis de 5 mlg 20 mgs cialis online cialis generic buy cheap cialis 5 mg testimonials is cialis 20mg better than 10mg reviews where to get nolvadex clomid how to calculate accutane dosage prednisolone 20 mg und alkohol test viagra tablets in india online what happens if a girl uses viagra cialis 20 mg as needed propranolol 60 mg twice a day antibiotics generic viagra 50 mg 50 doxycycline salet is in which tablet finasteride taken with flomax priligy dapoxetine review canada pharmacy clomid is there an over the counter safe medicine like viagra bijsluiter ciprofloxacine sandoz 500 mg cheap generic online viagra soft tabs how to take 20 mg prednisone side ringing in the ears with ciprofloxacin eyedrops need viagra pills metformin 500 mg ttc trip tablet lesuride 25 mg zoloft apo prednisone 1 mg is it safe to take viagra 2 times a day when to take lasix are generic viagra pills full dtrength donde comprar sildenafil en buenos aires sin receta how long does viagra stays in your blood prednisone 22 10 mg pills dosage can you buy viagra in vietnam nombre de cialis generico en mexico cialis buy from medco where i can buy viagra in kolkata cialis da 10 o da 20 mg prednisone 5 mg while dog is pregnant gibt es viagra ohne rezept in der apotheke where to buy viagra over the counter in johannesburg assunzione di zoloft in gravidanza metformin in coronary artery disease blood in urine after taking cipro prix boite de cialis brand viagra pills where to buy cialis in china 25 to 50 mg zoloft pregnancy can i take viagra if im 25 getting pregnant with pcos clomid pantopan 14cpr gastr 20 mg prednisone doxycycline disp 100 mg bijwerkingen cocaine propecia kaufen europa biotech ciprofloacin 500 mg viagra in indian book through vp zoloft 200 mg daily for years accutane in my 40s cytotec for abortion online books doxycycline 100mg per day acne creamy discharge on clomid sildenafil generico cinfa pharmaceuticals delgra 100mg sildenafil from canada trying to conceive multiples clomid online cialis 5 mg acquistare propranolol safe during pregnancy class action against accutane canada would democratic socialism work in the us how was viagra first discovered buy generic viagra online delivery fast 300 mg of doxycycline acne 5mg generic cialis without prescription amoxil price ireland 20 mg prednisone and pregnancy generic viagra cheap accepts paypal can a girl use viagra clarinex redi tabs generic viagra how to order cialis canada what day did you ovulate on 100mg clomid buy cialis in portugal accutane dosage chart weight viagra safe epileptics red viagra 200mg tadalafil 20mgdapoxetine tadalafil 2.5mg pakistani brands why sildenafil is used price of zovirax buy liquid propecia walgreens how much does cialis cost telefono para comprar cytotec vermouth yzaguirre donde comprar viagra voli low cost per cipro da venezia generic cialis shipped from usa best face cleanser while on accutane order lasix no prescription wholesale cialis manufacturers zithromax price 2gram where you buy viagra in stores gkh pharmaceutical clomid for sale buy viagra lloyds pharmacy london viagra 100mg safeway svt in toddlers getting off propranolol generic cialis is good viagra causing infertility in males sildenafil hormosan 100 mg filmtabletten tmf heart specialist in tyler tx cost of cialis at osco bruno generic viagra prednisone buy uk karsivan 50 mg dosierung viagra 200 mg viagra pills is there an over the counter equivilant to viagra is it safe to cut zoloft in half propranolol anxiety mg trying to conceive on clomid 50 mg viagra clinic in indonesia pharmacy boots price of viagra order zithromax without a prescription propecia in female hair loss can you bey viagra over the counter how long does prednisone stay in system dog viagra india pill what all ingredients are in viagra walmart finasteride 1mg unchecked cast generics for accutane buy propecia and anavar zoloft mg daily accutane causes fibromyalgia ciprofloxacina clorhidrato 500 mg para que sirve viagra pfizer 100mg ohne rezept fda approved tadalafil canada prix du medicament propecia generic cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews canadian drugstore viagra cialis tbl 4x 20 mg anti malaria pills doxycycline is silagra as good as viagra cialis online statistics usage cialis mg price india viagra generic reviews buy cytotec abortion pill malaysia lupa de relojero donde comprar viagra viagrahome office in toronto canada best acne medicine other than accutane birth comprare viagra pagamento contrassegno disabili finasteride buy australia splitting cialis 20 mg viagra in gibralta asics gt 1000 3 womens reviews on cialis second round of accutane results reviews dosagem de lasix para caes viagra and pay with mastercard canadian healthcare viagra where can we buy viagra. in sydney amoxicillin 750 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin how long before sex should i take viagra 100mg nolvadex pct ebay review forms of viagra liquid is it legal to order viagra online in the us ciprofloxacin 250 mg 5 ml equals how many teaspoons is 30 mg of accutane enough 25mg generic viagra price of viagra in doha qatar zithromax online info best time to take glucophage for bodybuilder quality vibramycin online bye cialis montreal zoloft or lexapro for panic disorder can i cut 10mg cialis in half viagra buy shops prednisolone soluble tablets viagra herbal for men in bangalore dosage of doxycycline for uti generic viagra in india over the counter lovenox generic form of zoloft generic vega cream sildenafil online viagra jual viagra off brands of soda when is best time using cialis purchase doxycycline hyclate buy liquid cialis online movement in vision viagra pomada acheflan generico de cialis clomid 250mg fertility how to get viagra in a couple of days ul li doxycycline for pets over the counter alternative shipping to canada cialis buy cialis bulk effects of prednisone in canines prednisolone 15 mg5 ml dosage viagra active ingredient how well does generic propecia work dapoxetine working time how much the price of viagra in hongkong prednisone usage pregnancy zoloft has really helped me through onde comprar viagra no df comprar zithromax sin receta cialis women australia how much does prescription propecia cost ciprofloxacina teva 500 mg posologia 100 mg vs 50mg viagra zovirax generic form comprare viagra chiasso buy viagra online buy original viagra ohne rezept viagra works best when taken as rectal suppository prednisone in pregnancy ulcerative colitis ciprofloxacin mechanism of action drugbank finasteride donde comprar en chile ciprofloxacin and tinidazole wiki what if a healthy man takes viagra do need buy viagra when does propecia really start working viagra sale in malaysia pharmacy amoxi clavulan stada 875125 mg nebenwirkungen viagra metformin in hemodialysis patients propecia generico foro sol dbol cycle with nolvadex online medicamento magnus sildenafil 50 mg common viagra dose can you take probiotics with doxycycline premature ejaculation drug viagra australia kee klamp cheaper alternative to viagra where i can find viagra dublin sildenafil citrate 4 tablets 25 mg uk what is like to masterbate on cialis how much viagra in toronto the price of cialis comprar viagra online seguro Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Why Does Class Matter? Contemplating Left praxis in a po-mo age.

Why Does Class Matter? Contemplating Left praxis in a po-mo age.

datePosted on 16:41, January 27th, 2014 by Pablo

My posts on the demise of the political Left in NZ have elicited a fair bit of debate, which is good. However, there are two main areas of misunderstanding in the debate that need to be corrected. The first is that that by repeating my oft-stated claim here and elsewhere that socio-economic class, and particularly the working classes, need to be the central focus of Left praxis, I am ignoring the productive and cultural changes of the post-industrial, post-modern era. The second is that I dismiss the entire Left as ineffectual losers.

Let me address the latter first. When I write about the “political” Left I am speaking strictly about those parts of the Left that directly involve themselves in politics, either institutionalized or not. In this category I do not include the cultural or activist Left that engage in direct action in non-political realms such as poverty alleviation, human rights protection, diversity promotion, etc. These type of Left indirectly address political questions and therefore have political import but are not immediately involved with or primarily focused on political matters (say, by acting as parties or running campaigns, among many other things). Some of their members may be, but the Left agencies involved are, first and foremost, non-political in nature.

In a way, these non-political Left entities act much like non-Left charities: they provide direct assistance to the disadvantaged or vulnerable, have clear political content in what they do, but are not political agencies per se.

Thus I recognize the good works of the non-political Left and even see them as providing potential foundation stones for effective Left political activism. But as things currently stand the interface between the non-political and political Left is largely skewed towards diluting the socialist content and neutering the working class orientation inherent in many forms of grassroots Left activism. And where the interface is direct (say, Socialist Aotearoa), the message is too vulgar and the agents too shrill to make their points effectively.

This may sound harsh but that is the reality. The larger point is that I am not dismissing the entire Left as “dead” or moribund. I am confining my diagnosis to the contemporary political Left, narrowly defined, and it is not defeatist to point out what I would have thought was glaringly obvious.

With regard to the second accusation, this has been the subject of much debate here at KP. Lew and Anita have both eloquently written on identity as a primary focus. I accept their arguments but also think that class matters when it comes to a Left praxis. To that end, let me reprise a statement I made in response to a comment made by reader Chris Waugh on the previous post.

Some people mistakenly believe that because I believe that a Left praxis has to be rooted in class consciousness I “dismiss” or neglect superstructural issues like gender, ethnic identity, environmental concerns and sexual preference.

I do not. However, I do not give these superstructural factors primacy in my thought because all of those forms of identification or orientation are non-universal, whereas insertion in a capitalist class system rooted in the exploitation of wage labor is a universal constant. Hence I see modern Left praxis as rooted in a working class consciousness, broadly defined to include all forms of non-managerial wage labor and all ethnicities, genders and preferences.

Put it this way: consider a situation where there is a female hourly worker and a female CEO of a major firm. What identification comes first when they meet each other in the social division of labor? Will identifying as female be so strong that it will bridge the class gap between them? Or will their class determine their relationship in the first instance?

Perhaps gender solidarity will prevail, as could be the case with being gay, Indian, bisexual etc. But I am simply unsure that these identifications universally supersede the class element and therefore should replace it as a focus of Left praxis.

So there you have it. Not all of the Left is ineffectual but the political Left certainly is. A working class orientation is necessary and central to any Left praxis but not sufficient to encompass the myriad of non-class progressive causes that make up the post-industrial Left. Resolving these issues and reconciling the dilemmas inherent in them are what must be done for the Left to regain a significant place in the NZ political arena.

19 Responses to “Why Does Class Matter? Contemplating Left praxis in a po-mo age.”

  1. Tiger Mountain on January 28th, 2014 at 11:33

    add this one to the mix–

    “praxis” to me sounds like good old dialectics
    (Gramsci ref.)
    Reflection without action = verbalism
    Action without reflection = activism
    Action + reflection = praxis

  2. Pablo on January 28th, 2014 at 11:45

    Praxis=Theory (reflection) plus action.

    One has to have a strategy before action can take place successfully, and strategy is a coherent set of principles outlining achievable long and short term objectives using viable tactics and methods based on well grounded theory revised in light of reflection on past action.

    Theory without action is navel gazing. Action without theory is mindless venting or posturing. Strategy is what binds them both in effective praxis. That is what seems to be missing in the NZ political Left.

  3. Yoza on January 28th, 2014 at 11:46

    I think to understand why the politics of gender, race and sexuality are necessarily promoted as defining the impetus on which the Left should found its program we need to consider the effort corporate propagandists devote to defining what society should think about and how they see those subjects. From the corporate perspective ‘gay money’, ‘Maori money’ or ‘woman money’ is indistinguishable from ‘straight-white-male money’; profit extracted from sexually, racially or gender-specific marginalised groups is no different than profit extracted from anyone else. As a consequence the politics of racial, sexual and gender equality is acceptable from a corporate point of view.

    This is, of course, perfectly excellent. Discriminating against someone based on their sexual preferences, gender or race is wrong. The problem of accepting the corporate paradigm without question is its inherent bias against the marginalised majority – the working class. There has necessarily been a conscious and concerted effort to expunge class identity from public awareness, ‘working-class’ has become an un-word in the corporate vocabulary. The only time the elite allow use of the term ‘working class’ is when describing the history of some corporate functionary who is promoting the interests of big business – there is no shortage of stories gushing over the working class roots of the likes of John Key, Paula Bennett or , the latest to draw attention to her under-privileged past, Hekia Parata. What is not acceptable is using the term ‘working class’ in conjunction with words like Maori, women or homosexuals, these are all regarded as monolithic entities whom tend to be represented in the media by spokespeople who conform to corporate sensibilities.

    The modern class structure being promoted through the mainstream begins with the beneficiary then jumps to the middle-class, which is pretty much anyone who isn’t on a benefit. This achieves the goals of marginalising those on benefits while attempting to portray the working class as a group that has a shared identity with the coordinator class – cleaners are lower-middle class, John Key is upper-middle class. Anyone on a benefit is ‘one of them’ and not ‘one of us’.

    I haven’t analysed any media to see if the term ‘working class’ has been disappeared in the manner I have suggested, but I imagine if anyone were to scrutinise most aspects of the media over the last thirty years or so they would find the use of the term has diminished dramatically.

  4. Pablo on January 28th, 2014 at 12:26


    Thanks for the thoughtful comment. I would add that the promotion of individualism, multiculturalism and other non-class forms of identity serves as a very effective divide and conquer or atomizing mechanism that helps perpetuate the subordination (in democracies; in capitalist dictatorships the word is “subjugation”) of all forms of wage labor to the market driven dictates of capital, foreign and domestic. That is why working class consciousness, broadly defined, is needed as the hub binding the other non-class identifications in a common progressive project (and praxis).

    One other thing. It would be good to focus on the “working poor:” those that work one or two (often casual or part time) jobs at close to the minimum wage who may or may not receive limited welfare benefits.They all too often get overlooked in the mainstream discussion and are the people in most need of effective collective action of their behalf (and honest agents to represent them).

  5. Daniel on January 28th, 2014 at 13:24

    Half the problem with the Left/Right definition of politics and class is that it implies and portrays some sort of idealized and level playing field in politics or class. Its a bit to cut and dried to really demonstrate where a group or individuals lie in modern society.

    Perhaps better terms (and I am just making these examples up, feel free to come up with your own,) could be Supporting Business interest, Non Supportive and Neutral/Apathetic. At least then the position of the individual or group would be easier to understand.

    Your final point in the original post which started all this, referring to the Change Labour made in 1984 pretty much answers any real questions about how dead the political Left in NZ are. Dead and buried!

    The other non-political left types probably dont need (or may not even want)to be labelled in the left/right vein anyway, why not just say socially conscious or something, again more descriptive.

    The left/Right paradigm has always been problematic and may not even be relevant any more, its not always been around and if the left is dead in NZ then leave it be, Labour may rediscover some form of original core motivation but again simply re-labelling it Left is just rebranding what could be communicated much more eloquently and effectively. My guess is that Labor will never get back what it has lost and such a fate may be for national too when a suitable party that represents the interests of certain constituents better comes along (like ACT for example, or maybe not ACT for example, ok not the best example).

    Further, is the Right so monolithic and united as it seems or is portrayed. I suppose if the actual size of people that vote National who are also business owners was added up they wouldn’t not be so much of a percentage in the actual number of people who vote National. People have long memories, longer than they are given credit for and Labour and NZFirst have that taint about them because they claimed to represent one group/s and then did the opposite when the time came to actually stand up and be counted. And yes I voted NZFirst in 96.

    The point I am getting to in this semi-rant of mine is that if the Left/right debate is the best means to portray our political system, given that in the struggle between Business and Worker (or whatever you call it) is currently being dominated by Business, then the reason the Left is dead is clear, as you have pointed out, lack of heart, lack of theory, lack of action and just beaten down and having lost the struggle (and also having committed suicide in the afore mentioned 84 failure).

    The conditions way back when which helped created the political structure we have today, saw the struggle between Business and worker different than we have now (and its not the time or the place to get into that here) and the advantage to the non-Business class is long gone. Trying to make the average person in NZ care about any party along ideological or class lines makes no sense. I think that’s ascribing a lot more clear headed and informed political/social rationality to a voting public which is mostly caught in media manipulation, fear mongering and hand-outs of $$$ in one form or another from those trying to gain power for their own interest and also with enough memory to remember a party who helped to gut the socialist sate back in 1984.

    And in that struggle, the party that represents the rational/self-interest, in an age of rational/self-interest, is going to win (National), helped of course by labours actions in 84 and hindered to some extent by MMP.

    Am I advocating individual maximization and sheer core self interest in this, NO I am not but in a society with more than two potential points of reference/grouping having a binary/linear model doesn’t seem to help. That’s trying to ascribe people to the either/or camp and in NZ MMP has opened up the political landscape to a lot more than just either/or.

    Which also makes it clear that such a right left monolithic spectrum set of labels doesn’t even really reflect the situation in NZ. Are the greens really on the Left? Really? When the left/right dichotomy was first created, I don’t think environmental interests were being taken into account. Would the greens really be on the left if they could find another group or ally to work with (apols to Dr Norman for making him sound so Machiavellian).

    Also are people joining the internet party that much of a bunch of sell-outs as is being portrayed? Again perhaps that party does a better job of serving its constituents, who in an information age, may be less aligned by right/left political/class (or at least the old class distinctions) distinctions and more identifying with a party with a technological bent. Again was the original right/left distinction ever created to represent such a group or ideal?

    The political Left in NZ is dead, but then so is the Right. They have no more ability to inspire or lead than the left does (National parroting the BRT line or whoever else is feeding them their economic cue cards). The new landscape, under MMP, and in a globalised age is less left /right than something new and not so defined. I don’t have names for them but its clear that this is new territory in politics in NZ today.

    The OP in dissecting the death of the left was entirely correct in doing so but is (I think) wrong in their hope that the Left can come back. Necromancy is not a political skill that’s seen in the beehive much these days.

    Better we get on with creating the new political organs for the body politic than trying to revive the old. And in that respect what rises new from the Ashes of the Left may in fact be better suited for the politics of the 21st century in NZ than National which is holding on and holding out like the big blue (soon to be extinct) dinosaur it is.

    My only caveat to all this is that if Labour suddenly found some gumption and decided to just go with it they could probably win back a lot of ground in the coming years. Obama won big on “Hope/Change” and then squandered most of it by not following through (read making changes rather than trying to make friends).

    Labour/Cunliffe could in time and with some guts be the party/leader that taps into the same semi simmering discontent in NZ that mars so much in politics here, but it would require a commitment that’s lacking in most politicians and as you point out a plan. And that is the bitter trademark in NZ politics today, an absolute lack of a plan, its blow with the wind and short term point scoring (ala the share market) rather than longer term strategic plans.

    The Left is dead and Right is dying. Time for some better labels.

  6. John on January 28th, 2014 at 16:03

    Excellent post.

    What does the lesbian, Samoan cleaner on the minimum wage have in common with the lesbian, Samoan lawyer on a six figure salary aside from their gender, sexuality and ethnicity?

    When it comes to the crunch, class is what matters.

  7. peterlepaysan on January 28th, 2014 at 22:39

    “Class” is an elusive word. When Marx and Weber wrote about it the social/cultural/economic milieu was very different today.

    There are “class” structures in most societies (human or otherwise).

    Whether the powerless should be bullied by the powerful is at the heart of democracy.

    Hawaiian wall street traders are not appropriate persons to set ethical standards for us kiwis.

    “workers ” may well have had a resonance in the industrial era of mines and factories within national boundaries.

    I doubt class means anything to anyone these days.

    Perhaps the 5% and 95% do?

  8. Pablo on January 29th, 2014 at 10:57

    Thans Daniel, John and peterlepaysan for those excellent comments. Much food for thought in them.

    Again, I think that the concept of working class to be expanded to include all wage labor, be it white collar, casual, part time, youth, service etc. Perhaps more importantly, a “rebranding” of the term “working classes” might help refocus the thrust of class consciousness that is so important for Left praxis. Thus we could use the terms “productive classes” or “producers of wealth” versus “parasitic” or “exploitative” classes or “appropriators of wealth.”

    Also, as has been mentioned in the comparative labor relations literature, workers can be defined as consumers of services as well as producers of wealth. That allows for the incorporation of citizen rights and expectations into any Left project above and beyond the relations in and of production.

  9. Daniel on January 29th, 2014 at 11:30

    Probably good to be clear.

    I think class exists in the various stratas that a society may have but that in terms of identifying a class the title “working class” may be a difficult one as its so very very broad and also somewhat conotation laden from previous eras..

    The Middle class in NZ is being squeezed given the forces being put to work on the middle section of society but short of some reference point in a semi socioeconomic discussion or as an indicator of origin even middle class is nt used much in NZ.

    I like the 5% – 95% label to some extent as it very clearly sets the lines but again beyond that its vauge.

    The “consumer” title also works to some extent, we all may be part of the consumer class but even here we need some degree of internal stratification.

    The average Kiwi marks their socio economic territory through things like regional identification, trade vrs non trade, sports, ethnicity etc.

    The Lesbian Samoan Cleaner point may have been in jest to some degree but it has a point in that in NZ that would be a viable lable, obviously no one that is used to introduced ones self or background, “Hi I am a …” etc.

    Under our K1W1 tag we all like to bear those distinctions of class do crop up (sporting/cultural/regional etc).

    I remember how common the idea in NZ was that it was a “classless society founded by those seeking to escape the class distinction of the old world” and in some ways thats why we have the non class classes that we do now.

  10. John on January 29th, 2014 at 16:00

    Paul Mason argues ‘To anticipate where today’s revolts may lead, we need to avoid two mistakes. The first would be to ignore the classic dynamics of revolution – to imagine that the material antagonism between the democratic business class and the workers can remain suppressed forever. The second mistake would be to think there is nothing new, seeing only the parallels with what came before and ignoring…changes in personal identity. knowledge and behaviour’ in ‘Why It’s Still Kicking Off Everywhrre (2013).

    He’s saying that the personal and the cultural character of today’s uprisings are central and that makes it harder to distinguish the economic causes and political effects. Where they are uprisings in support of democratic change that makes the ‘democratic’ aspect complex – most recently we’ve seen that in Thailand and the Ukraine but a couple of years ago it was across North Africa.

    In 1848, and in 2012-13, once the workers started to fight for social justice the business class and radical journalists who had led the fight for democracy turned against them, seeking to use dictatorial forms of repression to put them down. Let’s see what happens in Kiev and Bangkok.

    So when it came to the crunch, class mattered.

  11. Yoza on January 30th, 2014 at 06:52

    Are Kiev and Bangkok examples of popular revolt? The Thai ‘uprising’ seems to be the consequence of the traditional established elite being unable to maintain political domination through the ballot box and the protesters in the Ukraine appear to be an ethnically right-wing nationalist group opposed to those of Russian descent controling the parliament there.

    In both instances the ‘protesters’ give the impression they want an autocratic regime sympathetic to their agenda.

  12. John on January 30th, 2014 at 09:36

    There are far more groups and interests involved in both Thailand and the Ukraine than those you identify Yoza.

    Whilst some of the protesters are bent on autocracy others are on the streets for different reasons. I think this is what Mason is saying – the nature of the uprisings are multi-faceted. See Mason’s talk at the Global Uprisings Conference in Amsterdam

    He explains it far better than I can.

  13. John on January 30th, 2014 at 09:37

    There are far more groups and interests involved in both Thailand and the Ukraine than those you identify Yoza.

    Whilst some of the protesters are bent on autocracy others are on the streets for different reasons. I think this is what Mason is saying – the nature of the uprisings are multi-faceted. See Mason’s talk at the Global Uprisings Conference in Amsterdam

    He explains it far better than I can.

  14. Chris Waugh on January 30th, 2014 at 11:56

    @Yoza: Simon Grigg has two good articles on the Bangkok situation here: and here: He adds a lot more context than you’ll see in the mainstream media. It certainly seems to be a class thing.

    As for Ukraine, I’m certainly no expert, but from what I’m reading (mostly what comes up in Al Jazeera and a few other media) it seems to be a combination of a nasty hangover from Stalin’s redrafting of the borders of the USSR’s constituent republics – Russia gifted the Crimea to Ukraine, yeah right. The Ferghana Valley is another good example of this. Also, Russia trying to maintain its imperial prestige and the Ukrainian nationalist reaction to that. Internally ethnic Russians traditionally loyal to Moscow vs ethnic Ukrainians trying to expand their long-hoped for independence. It’s also a little reminiscent of the contest in Russian Imperial days between pro-Westernisers (Peter the Great being the most famous – note how he gave his new capital the decidedly Germanic name Sankt Peterburg (St Petersburg in English, natch)) and Slavophiles who preferred to carve out an identity separate from Europe (the name of the capital had to be changed to the more Slavic Petrograd (meaning Peter’s City – more or less the same meaning as St Petersburg) with the outbreak of World War 1.

    Naturally, take all of that with a hefty grain of salt. It’s been a Really Long Time since I studied Russian language, literature, film or history. Anybody who actually knows the area will be able to pick more than a few holes in the above.

  15. Blackadder on January 30th, 2014 at 21:01

    I take Daniel’s contribution as a starting point for my intervention in this important and useful debate started by Pablo.

    Daniel notes the idea of classlesness that has imbued the New Zealand collective consciousness. This has been based on British, un-Marxist notions of class where class membership is defined by pre-capitalist, feudal, class relationships.

    It didn’t take long for capitalist class relationships to develop in New Zealand, due to a necessity, noted by Marx himself in relation to early colonial-capitalist New Zealand and its need for “free labour”.

    Working class settlers from Britain might have thought they were escaping the English class system, but they weren’t escaping capitalist relations of production and the associated class structure.

  16. […] Kiwipolitico, Pablo asks Why Does Class Matter? Contemplating Left praxis in a po-mo age, My posts on the demise of the political Left in NZ have elicited a fair bit of debate, which is […]

  17. Craig Y on February 2nd, 2014 at 11:56

    As someone who believes in the existence of economic inequality, the continued salience of class as a political constituency and analytical category, I think one way out of the impasse might be to take a look at how supposed “superstructural” identity politics really plays out. For example, what about the fact that denying abortion rights means that working-class and impoverished women die? What about the marginality and social exclusion that face Maori and Pacific Island transgender community members, leaving many with no choice but street sex work? What about the increased threat of surveillance and security-based technologies to police dissent against neoliberalism?

  18. Pablo on February 2nd, 2014 at 16:27

    Thanks Craig Y, for those very useful illustrations of how identity and other superstructural issues can be grounded in class consciousness.

  19. Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Left in tatters. on September 21st, 2014 at 14:53

    […] A while back I wrote a post arguing that the NZ Left was in serious disarray. Various Left pontificators fulminated from the depths of their revolutionary armchairs against my views, denouncing me for being defeatist. I responded as politely as I could. […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)