25 mg zoloft works on what receptors doxycycline 100mg photosensitivity viagra feminino online zithromax whartisthebestin discount is viagra safe for a 30 year old cialis online with a prescription propranolol 60 mg extended release ratings best lip balm while on accutane propranolol half life 40 mg lisinopril doxycycline usp capsules 40 mg viagra buy in switzerland metformin medicine for pcos buy online can i pay for viagra from paypal account dapoxetine india buyers quale cialis comprare buy nolvadex in canada how long do viagra pills take to work pgd zovirax 400 mg zoloft make you sleepy generic cipro baownbeuv metformin glycomet for reducing weight usda generic viagra klamath lake blue green algae 500 mg metformin donde comprar viagra en temuco cheapest viagra no prescription nz why is cialis so expensive in canada viagra in pakistan use told me urdu necon 135 generic version of viagra use of metformin in gestational diabetes mellitus abilify 10 mg bijsluiter viagra clomid pregnancy symptoms assunzione di zoloft in gravidanza fake doxycycline for sale online kuwait over the counter viagra propecia kaufen europa can you buy viagra over counter congress poland diflucan 100 mg prezzo con ricetta prednisone tablets in pakistan best dose finasteride how does cialis work in body viagra feminino como comprar what are the best cycle days to take clomid buy generic cipro online kamagra uk viagra buy cialis mail online genric viagra in canada viagra kaufen biz viagra walmart mexico deactivated mp40 for sale in uk zithromax all brand names of metformin sildenafil 50 mg comprimidos accutane dose for 120 lbs when does accutane really start working how much is cialis at chemist viagra sale point in pakistan 20 mg cialis discount prices india viagra cialis vicodin safe lower price viagra total de mensajes dermatone 20 mg cialis can you eat foods high in vitamin a while on accutane utente generico de cialis accutane causes scars walmart pharmacy cialis tablets how much would a pill of cialis cost retail cost for metformin viagra super active discounter bewirkt viagra for sale tadalafil brands in india does clomid cause ovarian pain 440 50 mg zoloft tadalafil 20 mg softgel under tongue all kind of viagra prices perte blanche cremeuse sous clomid virtual world real risks of accutane viagra safety excedrin sinus headache generic viagra cialis tablets in multani clomid success rate in pcos ciprofloxacin in urinary tract infection how to find viagra in abu dhabi buy clomid online yahoo answers daily cialis from india how to order cialis canada hexal viagra kaufen schweiz ciproxin 250 costo sans ordonnance cialis generic will clomid help you get pregnant imflac 25 mg of zoloft viagra online praha compra cialis paypal vrste viagra online sildenafil 20 mg pfizer doxycycline injection australia manufacturers of sildenafil in india pros and cons of socialism in africa panrazol 20 mg prednisone historic price sildenafil fildena 100 vs viagra tub ceev xwm viagra cialis online acquisto viagra causas consecuencias can i take cold medicine while taking clomid can i take 10 mg cialis twice a day lasix safe for weight loss cialis from canadian online pharmacy no prescriptions do you have to take estrogen with clomid buy ciprofloxacin hcl without prescription tatanol 500 mg metformin doxycycline tablets reviews best way to lose weight with metformin lactic acidosis price of viagra 100mg in canada viagra sold over counter quebec 20 mg cialis how long in system viagra price in nepal motorcycle buy viagra in czech republic cialis 5mg daily use reviews cheap drugs net product viagra side proteine in polyvore effetti collaterali zoloft purchase viagra in ireland comprar cytotec barquisimeto herbal viagra in thailand bad zoloft generic brands can cialis cause blood in the semen is taking viagra 2 days in a row safe best place buy viagra uk does lasix cause drowsiness cuanto dura el efecto de sildenafil 25 mg vidalista tadalafil 10mg generic running 60 mg of nolvadex to reduce gyno cialis 5 mg how long till it kicks in generic cialis cost ireland zithromax in saudi cialis 20 mg p cialis 50mg canada online doctor fast cialis delivery how to get viagra online without prescription brand viagra no rx too young to use viagra main ingredients in viagra costo de la viagra en panama viagra prices in ireland generic cialis from usa buying cialis in puerto vallarta mexico cloranfenicol 500 mg metformin zoloft pill stuck in throat burning after vomiting viagra advantage in urdu clomid in men sidw effects anger generic viagra and rapid heartbeat treating low progesterone with clomid when is the best time to drink clomid cialis tablet in bangalore cytotec pills for sale dubai shopping doxycycline dosage available can you take viagra sublingual cheap pfizer viagra for sale acquistare cialis generico con paypal generic viagra really work prednisone versus corticosteroid nilotinib generic cialis best way to take ciprofloxacin clomid price in nigeria conflict viagra without prescription in the us where i buy viagra in kuala lumpur where to get finasteride phone number order cialis can i cut in half the 2.5 cialis can you take viagra and cialis in the same day kann man viagra rezeptfrei bestellen zoloft during pregnancy cause add in fetus can you buy viagra from berlin viagra rosa vendita online what is in viagra that makes it so useful where can i buy viagra in newcastle upon tyne buy zoloft yahoo strongest viagra available in india viagra effects on women in urdu canadian generic cialis pharmacy cipro dosing in ckd medical abbreviation mechanism of action of glucophage accutane causes hirsutism in men clomid stay in your system find cialis in hong kong buy viagra supplements buy cialis 40 ciprofloxacin price in irish pharmacy discrete viagra australia how to get viagra in switzerland canadian overnight pharmacy products cialis free chances of pregnancy on clomid 100mg obat zithromax 500mg online methylprednisolone equivalent in prednisone viagra equivalent medicine in india zoloft negative reviews i used clomid to get pregnant effetti collaterali viagra 50 mg doxycycline treat balanitis viagra over the counter la metformin 500 mg xr images viagra toronto address canada cipro hexal 500 mg preis walgreens viagra 100 mg retail cost enterococcus faecalis treatment ampicillin nolva clomid and hcg where to buy in uk metformin brands pakistan generic viagra complaints pritor 40 mg nebenwirkungen viagra viagra farmacias online rite aid in eureka viagra how much does clomid cost at dischem south africa low dose accutane rosacea redness generic sildenafil citrate overnight when should i get period after clomid best place to buy generic viagra is metformin safe for gestational diabetes plaquenil nombre generico de amoxil viagra prices for clomid take in morning or night viagra soft reviews when to take robitussin on clomid cialis online basso prezzo nolvadex for sale no rx doxycycline hyclate versus monohydrate price viagra review7 metformin weight loss success stories cialis 2 5 mg online cialis nose bleed sildenafil citrate discover card overnight can you take viagra without prescriptions selamectin buy online uk viagra pijn in onderbuik na clomid where can i buy tadalafil in powder form online pharmacy no prescription 1gm zithromax how do you get viagra uk how much did viagra cost when it first came out tadalafil by cipla review splitting cialis 20 mg can i cut my zoloft pill in half vildagliptin metformin cipla india buy cialis vietnam montelukast 10 mg tablet interaction with viagra can i take my clomid at night clomid 100 mg como tomar cytotec puede causar luego un obito fetal when should one take clomid can a person with diabetes take viagra dividere finasteride 5 mg pastillas ciprofloxacina 500 mg xetec 10 mg prednisone cialis black online price cialis on health card what is sildenafil 20 mg tussionex pennkinetic susp generic viagra cialis 5 mg per prostata viagra in peds viagra dicks in action can you take biotin while taking accutane saferxmd viagra buy hebal viagra dose of metformin in type 2 diabetes cipro antibiotic buy in mexico cheap viagra online from canada glucophage 850 mg fait il maigrir des clomid price pakistan metformin 850 mg abnehmen cialis 20mg 5mg website reviewed must you declare viagra when entering australia is it easy to get viagra from your doctor cialis once day generico cialis coupon online anyone bought generic viagra over internet viagra works best when taken as rectal suppository ketorolac tromethamine inj 60 mg prednisone ciprofloxacino 500 mg para que se usa doxycycline hereisthebestin dosage viagra package insert pdf viagra use in young people new chapter in my life is about to begin clomid klara inderal generic how can i buy generic cialis in canada viagra probepackung bestellen pain in breast propecia cheap metformin tqeovertoz glipizide metformin 5 mg 500 mg viagra suppliers with a canadian address priligy where to buy singapore cialis 10mg cost how much does it cost for one women viagra buy nolvadex online australia shopping how long do you have to take propecia viagra schweiz online vendita online cialis originale price of viagra keeps going up safer alternative to prednisone purchase clomid online shelf life of prednisone 20 mg tablets is it safe to take ampicillin while breastfeeding can you cut tadalafil 20 mg cialis prix allemagne positive metformin reviews tadalafil in karachi 10mg lexapro equal 50 mg zoloft high ciprofloxacin 500 mg yeast infection viagra price 25mg walmart cheapest and best 150mg viagra pills price of cialis without insuraunce best time to take doxycycline average age to take viagra para que es amoxilin 500 mg ciprofloxacina gp 500 mg period late because of clomid cost ofcialis daily use what happens if a 15 yr old takes 500 mg of viagra best packs fifa 15 reactions to prednisone cipro india sams club viagra price best pills you net buy clomid que pasa si usas viagra cialis online postepay metformin 500 mg tablet cipro 200 mg flakon canadian pharmacy nolvadex no prescription kamagra man co uk tadalafil tablets pfizer viagra 50 mg how to buy viagra in mumbai buy clomid international otc drugs like viagra ciprodex otic suspension 7.5 ml nolvadex tabletas 10 mg buy football boots online india cheap viagra clomid one month in one month off daily low dose viagra propranolol 80 mg sustained release buprenorphine generic finasteride mexico supplier of viagra in the philippines generalist vs specialist in criminal justice prednisolone zentiva 20 mg orodispersible film buy liquid propecia generic viagra cambodia 25 mg zoloft enough for anxiety sildenafil canadian drugs 10 mg prednisone 15 days sinus infection not responding asics gt 1000 3 womens reviews on cialis bank rakyat inderal mahkota pahang tourism 100mg clomid 4 8 prednisone taper mg sly bald guys propecia reviews best medicine than viagra sildenafil dapoxetine tablets india priligy wo kaufen is viagra prescription in australia orjinal shop net viagra prix cialis 20mg quebec are you allowed to buy cialis in the pharmacy in kuwait lowest price on cialis prednisolone teva 20 mg orodispersible nombres genericos del viagra en mexico prednisone and birth control pills donde puedo comprar viagra usa zithromax 1 mg is there generic for viagra which shop can buy viagra in amsterdam vonau flash generico de cialis metformin 850 mg and clomid is it legal to order viagra online in the us como usar cytotec aborto is it illegal to buy viagra australia liquid cialis dosage instructions best way to lose weight with metformin lactic acidosis liquid viagra in delhi viagra without prescriptions in usa best way to administer doxycycline to my pigeons clomid tablets to buy in uk should i take propecia or not using lasix in chf equivalente del viagra playboy viagra for sale get cialis prescription 60 mg prednisone for bronchitis what is socialism today in real terms propecia long term effectiveness does doxycycline hyclate treat chlamydia vitalikor vs viagra using cialis 5mg as 20 mg viagra overdose in women pastilla viagra costco what is viagra wholesale cost viagra en mexico precio ampicillin mk 500 mg cialis as needed vs daily delivery system is liquid cialis illegal cialis in johannes burg viagra and online pharmacy metformin hcl er 500 mg. daily dose causing dizziness when is the best time to take propecia metformin 500 mg wirkstoff comprar zithromax sin receta safe place buy viagra online price of cialis 2.5mg viagra production in bangladesh viagra uit india in holland viagra kaufen 50 mg sildenafil canada japan cars for sale in uk zithromax quanto costa un pacco di cialis where do i buy cialis in amsterdam actavis finasteride bestellen purchasing cialis in melbourne cialis no prescription needed master card can u buy viagra in australia buying sildenafil in mexico viagra tablets online uk ciprofloxacin 250 mg ratiopharm arena cialis 20 mg dosierung como comprar viagra ou cialis generic peptazol 20 mg effetti collaterali zoloft doxycycline and tetracycline use diflucan 150 mg once a week clomid ovulation late in menstrual cycle viagra sex drive can you take 150 mg of viagra glucophage 750 xr price buy tadalafil prescription medication real viagra for sale uk small viagra rate in chennai sildenafil 100mg suomi cialis starting dose viagra 100 mg duration of cold effects of metformin in triglycerides wartec generico do viagra maximm safe cialis dosage my friend put viagra in my drink cialis bertibarots online anti malaria pills doxycycline cialis and ginseng together watermelon pomegranate viagra deltasone hereisthebestin no prescription generic cialis 20mg express shipping viagra price in hyderabd in inr cipro bad taste in mouth how to get viagra in uk with doxycycline hyclate pregnancy viagra through the paypall diflucan 800 mg iv how safe is buying clomid online prednisone 40 mg 5 days no taper tell counterfeit viagra diflucan 10 cps 100 mg prezzo can you take more than 2 viagra in a day where can you buy priligy where can i buy nolvadex steroids.con is it safe to take panadol with cialis counterfeit cialis daily 100 mg zoloft viagra mee in vliegtuig cost of 500mg of cipro in malaysia metformin in losing weight desi viagra 50 mg most common dose of viagra negative reviews on accutane viagra taking directions online viagra no generic cialis online patika what is in cialis ingredients cialis 10mg opinion clomid taste in mouth pilule viagra prix du kamagra 100 mg oral jelly sildenafil how do i get a viagra sample what does canadian manufactured cialis look like is it safe to cut zoloft in half sildenafil 25 mg kaufen translation clomid uk boots store 100mg sildenafil tablets carbamazepine 200 mg indicaciones metformina discount viagra sales is there an over the counter equivilant to viagra will two 10 mg cialis equal 20 mg zovirax boots uk ricetta medica cialis online temazepam 20 mg bijsluiter cialis procerin vs propecia reviews side can lasix cause uti clomid ovulation calculator online retinal specialists in surprise az bird antibiotics doxycycline finasteride 1mg mexico cialis generico es fiable ciprofloxacino 250 mg via oral how to take prednisone 4 mg for 6 day pack ciprofloxacin hcl 250 mg tab para que sirve cialis 5 mg how long until it takes effect how long does liquid zithromax stay good viagra ireland boards herbal viagra uk cheap buy viagra over the counter australia metformin hcl 500 mg versus metformin buy claravis accutane discount how much is nolvadex in india price why use clomid for pct clomid test ovulation Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Double impunity

Double impunity

datePosted on 23:18, August 15th, 2012 by Lew

Social Development Minister Paula Bennett has been said by the Director of the Office of Human Rights Proceedings, Robert Hesketh, to have breached the privacy of Natasha Fuller by making private information about her public in 2009.

Bennett does not accept Hesketh’s “opinion”; in a letter released by Hesketh she expressly states that “I do not believe I have breached privacy.” Moreover, she goes on to explain that she still considers such a strategy — of releasing private, confidential information about a member of the public to make a political point — to be perfectly legitimate.

And, really, why the hell wouldn’t she? It worked. Not only has she not been found to have done anything wrong, but she has suffered no consequences for those actions. No sort of reprimand has been issued, nor obeisances levied. Hesketh’s “opinion” — with which the minister is free to disagree upon no grounds whatsoever — is not in any way binding, and as such, has exactly as little value as mine. All soft speech and no big stick. It has taken three years and change to get to the point where the massed battalions of our much-vaunted system of civil liberties have been able to issue nothing more robust than a statement that the situation has been resolved “to the satisfaction of all parties”, apparently notwithstanding the stark disagreement between the positions of Hesketh and Bennett.

In a political environment where ministers are required by their leader to employ whatever means they can get away with to achieve their KPIs, we can’t really blame Bennett for doing so. She has proven extremely adept at this sort of machine politics, running decoy lines when other, less-adept, ministers find themselves in trouble — the most recent example of which having also emerged today: that there really was no clamour from employers to drug-test beneficiaries. So we can’s blame Bennett; she’s just following the incentives. Similarly, we can’t blame John Key — after all, his ministers are getting results, and his polling is holding up, so he’s just following the incentives as well. I do not know their mandate, but we may be able to lay a certain amount of blame at the feet of bureaucrats like Robert Hesketh. However, given Bennett’s and Key’s demonstrated ruthlessness, perhaps such a supine position is understandable. Had he caused too much trouble his office might have been gone by lunchtime, or redeployed to some higher-priority task like finding technical justifications for Special Tactics Group action against Kim Dotcom.

But regulatory or statutory means are weak when it comes to punishing ministers for their misdeeds. Since procedural decisions governing what action could and would be taken against a minister in such as case are themselves determined by ministers, the Iron Law comes into play: Unless forced, a Cabinet will never implement measures that might seriously constrain it. The main function of regulatory recourse, then, is not to impose actual, “hard” strictures on members of the executive, but to provide their opponents with opportunities to attack them, either on political or ideological grounds, or on grounds of character or competence. These are “soft” constraints on behaviour, in that they are normative rather than objective, and they rely on tactical factors and on a high degree of competence and tenacity — as well as measures of opportunism and ruthlessness — on the part of opposition politicians. Impunity that arises from hard constraints as I’ve discussed here, and as Pablo has written about previously, is unfortunate but understandable; the lack of soft constraints is less so. Bennett has not suffered any consequences of her actions because she has not been made to suffer them by the only group that might viably do so: the New Zealand Labour Party.* So I return to an argument I’ve made before: the government gets away with all this is because the opposition lets it. In this case, Bennett took a calculated risk and released information in a way that nonpartisan experts consider to be obviously unethical and an abuse of her position. She didn’t even calculate it very hard — she took no official or expert advice before releasing Natasha Fuller’s private information, she just knew she could get away with it. Not only did Paula Bennett enjoy the ordinary sort of impunity that comes from being a minister of the crown, she also knew that she enjoyed the double impunity of being virtually unopposed at the political level.

She had good grounds to know this. The Labour party, even as far back as mid-2009, had been so dysfunctional and so ineffective for so long that it could hardly come as a surprise. How many times, over the past five years, have Labour supporters seen some egregious outrage from the government and thought, “this time — surely even this lot can’t screw things up! If they can’t make the government pay for this, they don’t deserve to win!” I know I have written these sentiments many times, and spoken them aloud countless more.

And yet they keep failing. As long as they keep failing, these outrages will still happen. Even if not for its own sake, Labour owes the people of New Zealand a duty of competence that it is not currently fulfilling.


PS: Given this result and Bennett’s refusal to rule out such actions in the future, here’s a handy thing that Anita wrote at the time, expressly forbidding Bennett or anyone else from releasing our, or your, information for such purposes.

* But what of the Greens? I hear you ask. And fair enough — the Greens have in many ways been doing a better job of being a functional opposition than Labour have. But the Greens cannot apply direct zero-sum electoral pressure on National — they cannot hope for parity, and they cannot threaten the Treasury benches. The Greens are important as a source of pressure on Labour, but only Labour can pressure National.

19 Responses to “Double impunity”

  1. Sanctuary on August 16th, 2012 at 08:40

    And today we have…


    Paula Bennett discovers that Stephen Colbert’s “truthiness” does away with the need to actually do any research before imposing draconian new measures on a large segment of the population. Any decent media would have a field day with a ministerial admission that she doesn’t need any evidence to enact a policy, but in this country this spiteful and vindictive woman simply gets away with it.

  2. Lew on August 16th, 2012 at 08:43

    Why is it the media’s job to put in the big hits when the opposition won’t?


  3. Sanctuary on August 16th, 2012 at 09:04

    I don’t think it is an either/or proposition…

  4. Lew on August 16th, 2012 at 09:20

    It’s not an either/or proposition. The media follow the opposition’s lead on matters like this. To an extent they need to, because taking a hard line against a minister when the official inquiry (weak though it might be) has come back saying the matter is closed seems partisan.


  5. Gerry Seal on August 16th, 2012 at 10:06

    I find it interesting that John Key and John Banks can flaunt themselves in front of the media, then demand the privacy of their words while the cameras roll with their consent less mere metres away, under threat of police action.

    The distinction between that episode and Paula Bennett escapes me other than to say that Bennett’s invasion of privacy was far more egregious.

  6. martin hector on August 16th, 2012 at 11:53

    Mrs Bennet should of done what has being done for years and get the reporters to ask the complainants permission to release their details to enable a balanced story. Its the threat that her and other ministers said on the news last night they would do it again instead of the proper way reminds me of a dark veil that once grew in europe that began with people nopt being ableto speak out. And yes i agree with the comments the media is useless at reseaching important points along with the labour party

  7. DeepRed on August 16th, 2012 at 15:50

    @martin #6: At best, Minister Bennett fits what Chris Hayes describes as an out-of-touch meritocratic-turned-plutocratic elite, in his latest book Twilight of the Elites.

    At worst, Bennett fits at least the following traits as defined by Umberto Eco:

    3. The cult of action for action’s sake
    4. Disagreement is treason
    5. Fear of difference
    6. Aappeal to a frustrated middle class
    10. Contempt for the weak
    14. Newspeak

  8. sammy 2.0 on August 16th, 2012 at 16:05

    Well said, Lew.

    Back in April you wrote here:

    “The past four months have been what another lot of military jargon would refer to as “target-rich”, and Labour largely refused to take advantage of it.”

    Back then you (like most of us, I would guess) suggested that we needed a little more patience – after all, Shearer was new and the summer cricket pitches had not yet sprouted rugby goalposts.

    Now we’ve had another four months, the targets have kept coming, and yesterday’s was only the latest (and one of the easiest). Labour continue to fail, badly.

    Along with Labour MPs, we should not absolve Labour “loyalists”, who are too willing to blame others (the media, or left-wing critics of Labour) rather than face up to the glaringly obvious. It is a failure of leadership, and it is not resolved by a quick stand-up and garbled sound bite in the corridors of Parliament.

    Another four months will bring us to the end of the year. By then, Labour MPs will have changed their dismal performance, or changed their leader. My money’s on the latter.

  9. Ken Martin on August 16th, 2012 at 19:50

    Hmm, how long will it be before anyone receiving any money whatsoever from the government will have their privacy breached should they be bold enough to challenge an uncaring government and it’s bureaucracy?

    A whif of fascism I think.

  10. DeepRed on August 16th, 2012 at 20:37

    What next, if the Opposition can’t or won’t act? Wear black triangle badges in protest? Set up tent cities outside Parliament or a certain house somewhere in Waitakere or Parnell?

  11. martin hector on August 16th, 2012 at 22:44

    Hi Ken, i definitely got that whiff from my tv yesterday, i was quite surprised by it as ive never seen anything like that here before, ive seen arrogance but this was different- the way they all spoke shortly and with ease about doing it again

  12. Ken Martin on August 17th, 2012 at 00:32

    Hi, Martin,
    we live in interesting times, some on the Right say what’s going on is acceptable, others there are uneasy, but mute, just as their predecessors were under Muldoon, who I think actually had a heart, and cared about the Kiwi Battler. Never voted for him, though. The Right could not give a toss presently. The Labour party are really just National-lite. That is part of the reason why they are so feeble in opposition. And of course, democracy is best served by a strong opposition. The Nats know they can get away with virtually anything. And they do. Just like in Europe pre WW2. Cheers.

  13. martin hector on August 17th, 2012 at 08:40

    Hi Ken im quite on the right and i deteste this. I agree about opposition too and i also very much blame the media, ive seen John Key develop the tiniest but noticable look of pleasure when he realises the media dont have a clue at all about asking him the proper questions to put him on the spot. Its as though prior to the ridiculous questioning being posed you can see him waiting nervously for the obvious question that will get him. The massive problem now is he has gotten quite rightly assured that they wont come

  14. pete on August 17th, 2012 at 13:46

    “The media follow the opposition’s lead on matters like this. To an extent they need to, because taking a hard line against a minister when the official inquiry (weak though it might be) has come back saying the matter is closed seems partisan.”

    Have I misread your position? The media should make the appearance of non-partisanship a higher priority than, say, “speaking truth to power”?

  15. Lew on August 17th, 2012 at 22:29

    Pete, nah — the media have covered the situation, its facts and context, and statements from either side, and generally reported the news. But their job generally is not to turn an issue like this into a crusade — that’s the opposition’s job. One motivated editor or columnist may do so, but — like with the “DEMOCARCY UNDER ATTACK” thing with the Herald re the EFA there’s a risk attached to doing so, and they can hardly be blamed for not making a big deal out of a partisan issue that partisans can’t really organise itself in behind.


  16. Lew on August 17th, 2012 at 22:29

    DeepRed, what next? I really don’t know, but I do trust that nature won’t permit such a vacuum to remain for long.


  17. Lew on August 17th, 2012 at 22:37

    Sammy, my sense is that if the summer recess is Shearer’s watershed. If nothing changes between now and then, the narrative going into the break will be “a year in and still useless”, or perhaps more pointedly “into his fifth 90-day trial period”.

    Elections aside, the period immediately after the summer break is when the big agenda-setting moves get made in NZ politics, and the danger is that if Shearer doesn’t give people a reason to pay attention, they just might not notice him coming back. He failed badly at this task in early 2012, and as they say, once is understandable, but twice looks careless.


  18. K on August 20th, 2012 at 20:14

    Lew, I agree with your opinions relating to Labour’s programme of appeasement, but disagree with your point that the media’s ‘job generally is not to turn an issue like this into a crusade’.
    News items especially on TV these days seem to be larded with shallow editorialising, more often than not, from my observation. The problem I observe is that the said editorialising is usually puddle deep. I assert with respect that it IS the job of media to cry foul when governments abuse their power and/or undermine the rights of citizens through action or neglect.If it takes crusading to address instances of government malevolence or opposition ineptitude, then so be it.

  19. Lew on August 20th, 2012 at 21:23

    K, I don’t dispute that the media has a responsibility to do this, but theirs is not the primary responsibility, and if the parliamentary opposition (whose responsibility it is) aren’t prepared to fight for it, why should the media do so on their behalf?

    Of course, Labour haven’t been entirely lax in the tactical sense — they try. But the trouble is that over the past 5 years and more they’ve played themselves into a position where they risk being seen as “soft on bludging” or “obsessed with trivialities” if they do. They’ve ceded the agenda, they lack cohesion, and because of all that they lack credibility with the media and the public. That all makes it hard.


Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)