buy cialis daily in hong kong 2i honours degree indian equivalent of viagra buy viagra canada fast shipping no pharmacy red viagra cobra 120 mg summary i viagra last 2 days in a row natural sources of tadalafil buying viagra otc in france bula do pramil sildenafil 50 mg finasteride priceline hotels propak propecia purchase cialis 10mg vs viagra 50 mg online viagra soft inderal 40 mg prezzo voucher reviews cipla sildenafil prednisolone brand names in india cost of zovirax in the u.s how long does finasteride stay in your system for best natural viagra uk london cvrge viagra online doxycycline dosage weight como usar um viagra bateria generic accutane doxycycline online nz viagra cost per pill 100 mg morphine pills cialis 40mg india buy cialis from australia getting pregnant with just clomid klaricid ud generico de cialis zovirax 200 mg dispersible tablets definition viagra in farmaciile din turcia zoloft in treatment of bipolar metformin shell in stool best time day take prednisolone viagra pills on ebay is 25 or 50 mg of viagra better price of finasteride 1mg tablets seoul korea nolvadex online bodybuilding supplement 20 mg prednisone dosage for adults efficacia cialis 10mg se necesita receta para comprar viagra en chile rojo female viagra drug cost of viagra canada shoppers drug mart side affect of cialis in women propranolol modified release capsules 80 mg adderall is the purchase of generic viagra illegal sombrero vietnamita donde comprar viagra cost of cytotec in louisiana alguien ha tomado cialis generico farmacias online fiables cialis side take 2 50mg clomid finasteride dosage dht sildenafil citrate tablets for women in india zenegrabuy sildenafil without prescription cialis brand price diflucan for yeast infection dose pharmacy has best prices viagra cialis generic viagra canadian online pharmacy acetato de ciproterona 50 mg real viagra sale online parenergeies viagra online american average wholesale price for viagra sildenafil patent expiry in the uk generic cialis international shipping how much does cialis cost in united states what does viagra cost in melbourne in chemist cialis in cabo san lucas mexico pharmacies how many mgs of viagra to take prednisone 7.5 mg po diario percentage people initial breakout accutane cost can apo metformin 500 mg helps me get pregnant msds for doxycycline hyclate 200 mg tablets order zithromax 1 gram does clomid have progesterone in it where u buy viagra in glasgow genericos de viagra en mexico doxycycline monohydrate 100 mg lyme disease 1000 mg metformin and clomid to get pregnant best price propecia online where can you buy cialis or viagra in dubai digoxin 0 25 mg obat apa methylprednisolone what is the cost of viagra in delhi priligy costo en peru diflucan 200 mg medicament aliviar 50 mg viagra secadora cytotec online 5mg propecia better than 1 mg viagra best buy computers cialis come comprarlo canada pharmacy lasix does viagra generics work generic cytotec 200 mcg best place order cialis online equivalent dose of lasix to torsemide kitapen 25 mg of zoloft does cialis build up in the system medical liquid cialis can you get viagra in spain did he take viagra can i split cialis 20 mg in halves or quarters ampicillin dosing in renal failure otc pills like viagra 5mg propecia india viagra 50 mg cpr4 metformin with benfotiamine tablets proper dosage of doxycycline was sind viagra generika can you get finasteride over the counter viagra over the counter in france farmacia online italia cialis dosage whats works best propecia or minoxidile kamagra cialis online where can i buy viagra over the counter in hamptonva top quality viagra items in karachi where to buy zovirax cream does metformin have a generic triflucan 50 mg zoloft buy viagra online without doctors prescription i want to buy viagra online in nz viagra prix pharmacie quebec viagra online legitmate canada what happens after accutane treatment viagra names in india doxycycline and breastfeeding viagra online is safe clomid male dosage canada viagra women how far in advance for cialis cost generic sildenafil is generic cialis safe and effective for bph quanto costa viagra in svizzera ciprofloxacin 500 mg indication anybody using propecia in singapore by viagra in penang history of socialism in the united states famous works doxycycline duration for acne treatment uses of cialis in urdu generic viagra without medical tadalafil liquid injection socialist government in eastern europe how many mg of finasteride in propecia viagra buy in qatar doxycycline oral dosage how much money costs cialis how long take for accutane to work brand cialis professional 20 mg why is viagra prescription only how many mg of sildenafil citrate should i take cialis generika in deutschen apotheken kaufen ampicillin resistance gene in puc18 dna cost of herbal viagra in delhi finasteride howdotofound price how to get rid of doxycycline rash zoloft pmdd review real results from finasteride cialis si vende in farmacia brandon santini doblaje cipro reviews of canadian pharmacies that sell viagra online propecia mechanism of action indian zithromax finasteride hair loss dose can i use aha while on accutane cialis kopen in duitsland can accutane cause yellow teeth le nouveau prix du viagra buying viagra in nigeria athens viagra home delivery pediatric prednisone dose dosis recomendada de propranolol40 mg generic medicine dapoxetine generic lang ru pillola viagra generic comprar sildenafil online is it safe to take prednisolone blueberry 100 sildenafil safe amoxil pediatric dosage viagra across counter without prescription in dubai ativan overdose mg amount of prednisone metformin lich 500 mg best case opening reactions to prednisone glucophage 500 mg prospecto 100 mg clomid what will it do can i buy cialis in dubai viagra reviews old men dosage doxycycline malaria can you buy viagra in seoul prednisone 6 pack safe discount viagra in the uk brand viagra singapore how many mg should take viagra cheapest place to buy clomid metformina clorhidrato 850 mg efectos blue pill viagra buy now cialis coupon for canada has anyone brought viagra of craigslist in vancouver bc can viagra cause pain in testicles 11 dpo 100 mg clomid buying viagra canada legal clomid dosage and multiples doxycycline taken with orange juice cialis coupons and discounts how to buy cipro online accutane rowcmoadreders reviews viagra in perth w.a. zoloft safety risk pregancy pfizer viagra prescription nolvadex in kerala available 20mg cheap cialis indice zoloft and increase in blood pressure protandim positive reviews of zoloft metformin in pregnancy ready not how to buy viagra without seeing a doctor in canada doxycycline reviews malaria directions for taking prednisone 10 mg nexium mups 20 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin what happens to a woman that takes viagra scared to take accutane prednisone 10 mg 5442 cost per month of cialis for daily use viagra tab in hyderabad cialis online mit rezept farmacia online cialis generico usa brooks running shoes womens reviews on viagra brand cialis 5mg online where can i buy male viagra in cape town 150 mg generic viagra capsule is it safe to take paracetamol with viagra how to buy cialis in mexico is there generic form of viagra viagra soft tabs 100 mg cialis online with maestro cialis and nitrates in food sildenafil kaufen paypal how to use generic cialis e20 buying propranolol uk cheap cialis in the united states cialis to buy without prescription sildenafil en gel viagra in cabo san lucas uses of metformin hydrochloride l.p. 500 mg viagra from australia suppliers price of accutane in singapore diflucan e xanax cost of ciprofloxacin dexamethasone ear drops cistitis tratamiento antibiotico ciprofloxacin 500 mg tomar 40 mg de cialis cialis sold in makati viagra online canada overnight camps can you take accutane once a day viagra in saudi a can i buy sildenafil in sams club tomar glucophage xr 500 mg can ovulation take place while taking clomid lasix per eliminare liquidi live poultry chicago cialis generic doxycycline price rise cialis online uk with paypal comprar zoloft sin receta corticosteroid abrupt withdrawal of zoloft cialis paypal accepted paypal generic cialis pay with mastercard zithromax sirop 300 mg what can i buy in singapore cialis doxycycline dosage for sinus infections donde comprar cytotec en merida venezuela is online viagra real silymarin 80 mg prednisone costo sildenafil doc 1500 mg metformin a day acetaminofen con codeina nombre generico de amoxil no prescription prednisone paypal buy propecia online pharmacy cialis 36 hour pill prices how long does doxycycline take to work for rosacea mirtazapine hexal 30 mg nebenwirkungen viagra generic viagra special buy cialis in nyc altri usi del viagra generic zoloft safety breastfeeding desi viagra for men price where to buy viagra in store where can i buy cialis in las vegas using less than 1 mg propecia propranolol drug bank gemfibrozil metformin prescription rxusa net ciprofloxacin solubility in dcm online pharmacy prescription viagra cialis prix bas canada inderal buy can metformin hcl 500 mg be used for pcos ordering tadalafil with paypal injection viagra in peshawar stores buying viagra in northern ireland will adderall 10 mg effect prednisone sildenafil 50 mg low dosage 10 pills propecia baownbeuv reviews viagra in sacramento decapeptyl 3 75 mg effetti collaterali zoloft cost of doxycycline from boots is it bad to take doxycycline with milk tadalafil for bph reviews on garcinia is is safe to take 40mg of cialis accutane for women reviews can viagra be used for bodybuilding treatment for doxycycline chest pains propecia mg dosage nolvadex dischem chemist zovirax cream price i dk apotek online medical store viagra viagra receta costa rica como usar 1 dosis de cytotec where to buy generic cialis phoenix az viagra50 in india ingredients in finasteride is 1000 mg of metformin twice a day safe bali cialis real price of viagra 25mg accutane 20mg price in malaysia nikon best viagra for men online when does viagras patent rights finish in canada how many hours before to take viagra deramaxx 50 mg zoloft best viagra alternative gas station 200 mg doses of viagra serve ricetta per viagra generico zovirax tabletten kaufen metformin and acanthosis nigricans in dachshunds prix du viagra en europe burning sensation in chest zoloft withdrawal buy half inderal 80mg if 5mg cialis does work can i up another 10 mg chloramine tablets 500 mg metformin omepramix generico do viagra waar kan ik cialis kopen viagra pills in karachi does metformin cause problems in pregnancy inderal prescription uk what can we use instead of viagra in womens generic amoxil capsules 500 mg virtus what if a woman takes cialis tablete cipro tradus in romana doxycycline mechanism of action how long does sildenafil stay in body is the use of viagra dapoxetine safe buy propecia coupon weight loss viagra coupons cheap cialis bought over the counter in canada cost of cialis at sams club metformin hereisthebestin reviews luggage acnexpert donde comprar viagra greenstone and generic zoloft how much is viagra in nz dapoxetine australia pbs adhd retail cost of doxycycline viagra super active low price dapoxetine brand in india prices on viagra 100 cialis stuttgart kaufen buy tadalafil citrate viagra pricing at costco viagra dealer in abudhabi zithromax 500 mg gonorrhea symptoms socialism in america original publication price amoxil 250 susp how many clomid tablets to take a day can viagra 100 mg tab be split dealers for sildenafil in india amoxil dosage per kg price of generic zoloft without insurance viagra tablet usage can you take viagra twice a day cialis 5 mg mexico precio how to get prescription for clomid where can i get viagra in montreal buy cheao cgeap kamagra uk viagra finasteride and ketoconazole best dose of cipro for uti 6 failed rounds of clomid for sale best time of the day to take clomid pct where to get viagra in cancun cheaps place to buy viagra sildenafil brands in the philippines about viagra medicine in telugu script are there any generics for viagra farmacie online affidabili viagra for sale price in indian rupee for viagra indian pharmacies patent viagra does vibramycin make you tired zovirax cream safe in pregnancy 5mg generic cialis online blood in stools while on accutane ebay viagra generico viagra over the counter italy france who is the black lady in the cialis tv add where i get viagra in calcutta cdiscount cialis accutane after use doxycycline 100 mg once a day deltasone dose pack 5 mg 6 day directions how long after accutane can you go in sun dose ampicillin neonatal sepsis taking cialis for best results chemist warehouse viagra 50 comprar cialis fiar generic cialis australia today socialism in america date of first publication zithromax online from canada cialis timing for use prednisone tapering schedule canine from 10 mg can clomid be taken in early pregnancy doxycycline dose for chalazion purchase viagra van ness how much cialis is it safe to take doxycycline 40 mg kill what ethacrynic acid vs lasix generic buy sildenafil online australia visa typical dose of accutane buy viagra online overnight mustafa durgut viagra for sale clomid cause bladder infection doxycycline for dental infection dosage comprar viagra generico sin receta medica metformin brands in nigeria viagra in powerade prank is abra sildenafil citrate real xs effective viagra reviews viagraother pills viagra in pakistan home delivery insulin resistance metformin pregnancy safety fertility clinic london clomid and iui do you take clomid on an empty stomach what does metformin do in pregnancy trankimazin 0 50 mg comprimidos viagra drugs in combination with metformin generic of glucophage xr viagra meaning in marathi language cialis online malaysia machining specialist uk effect of clomid drug in an oligospermic man brand name of cialis nombre generico del viagra en colombia los objetos propecia price in pakistan ipad viagra cheap legal buy clomid online no prescription philippines how many mg of propranolol for stage fright cialis sample coupon kann wien viagra kaufen what medicine can you not take with viagra tadalafil megalis 20 online order doxycycline hyclate 100mg discounts comprar priligy en barcelona canada soft tablet tadalafil lasix dosage for fluid retention ethinyl estradiol and norgestimate generic cialis delivery generic overnight viagra wanneer in aanmerking voor clomid tadalafil citrate 20 mg erfahrungen zithromax tablet 250 mg kopenick 160 mg lasix what does that mean viagra online rezeptfrei com any site i can get viagra shipped to canada cialis for daily use cost vs how can buy viagra from chemist in hong kong what is the normal dose of cialis chi ha usato zoloft india generic viagra reviews distribuidor de viagra vegetal en usa 5 mg cialis lasts glucophage xr vs generic pharmacy does doxycycline cause heartburn viagra 100mg or 50 mg cipro in hemodialysis online cialis from india diflucan long term viagra buy singapore shops genuine 100mg viagra prices uk reciprocation states for nj nursing licenses viagra shops in bangladesh metformin extended release mg how much are the propecia pills at costco medicine cialis tablets can i buy viagra in stores in nyc 50 vs 100 mg clomid tadalafil target walmart research chemicals tadalafil veloxin 25 50 mg zoloft clomid iui treatment viagra medicine in pakistan triluma clomid working but not getting pregnant cialis with dapoxetine generic viagra online form india prednisone in treatment of serous otitis getting pregnant while on finasteride starlix and metformin best liquid cialis how much a month cialis cost ciprofloxacin made in india glucophage breastfeeding safety best acne medication other than accutane long term viagra prolonged usage clomid pct dosage after anavar cost of once a day cialis Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Lessons from The Hobbit: more unionisation, not less

Lessons from The Hobbit: more unionisation, not less

datePosted on 17:59, October 22nd, 2010 by Lew

The Hobbit saga has been an ugly but edifying lesson in the realities of how industrial action interacts with political posturing and national identity. My own view is that Actor’s Equity did their industry and their country — I would say ‘their membership’, but when they set this ball rolling they didn’t have one — an enormous disservice. Lacking a mandate and any legal standing, they undertook almost the worst possible course of action of calling an international SAG boycott. They attempted to hold a national icon and his nationally-iconic production to ransom at the apparent behest of an Australian union (the MEAA) with a history of this sort of aggressive mismanagement and who stands to gain from any reputational damage suffered by the New Zealand film industry. Their cause is worthy, but they picked the wrong fight with the wrong person at the wrong time, on the wrong basis, employing the wrong tactics, and did so without the support of their industry. Almost everything they could do to lose this battle, they did.

But too much has already been written on that topic, and I won’t add to it any further. The point I’d rather make is that the incompetence shown by AE in this dispute would never have thrived in a more robust industrial relations culture: that is to say, one in which union membership and participation was the norm rather than the exception, in which more workers had an understanding of what their union was there for and the union in question understood their industry’s needs and agenda better.

Fundamentally, the entire problem here is AE’s lack of a mandate: even leaving aside the fact that they had no legal standing as a NZ union until this time last week, the trouble is that they represent a tiny fraction of the actors who form a tiny fraction of those responsible for the production of any film, and yet they have the apparent ability to blacklist that entire industry (whom they don’t represent). Even the most ardent trade unionist can surely see the moral hazard here. All those who we’ve seen fronting AE have been the best-respected and most-established actors; actors whose careers aren’t in material danger regardless of the outcome of The Hobbit. But what of those actors who are genuinely struggling, whose faces don’t appear in tens of thousands of living rooms every Tuesday night, and who don’t top “best-of” lists? And what of the silent legions of drivers, designers, artists, labourers, riggers, electricians, carpenters and caterers who are the real motive engine behind the film industry? Are their needs well-served by the actions of a few prima donnas who represent them without their consent? Apparently not, which is why a thousand of them turned out to protest the actions of that unelected few. Orcs, Chris Trotter called them; useful idiots said Idiot/Savant.

To an extent it’s their fault for not being adequately organised to mount a counter-insurgency against AE’s hijack of their industry. And that’s why my suggestion is for film industry workers to arm themselves and prepare to fight for their needs. Whether it’s in separate unions by sector or a single, unified screen workers’ union doesn’t much matter, as long as there is strong and robust organisation behind it which elects leaders who hold a genuine mandate to speak for the real needs of their industry. Nature abhors a vaccuum, and the only way that a handful of pretty faces and household names with little or no industrial relations experience and an Australian carpetbagger with a reputation for mischief-making get to speak for an entire industry is when the alternative is nothing. Conventional wisdom — particularly from the government — is to de-unionise, and already the veiled threats about the consequences of a general strike during the 2011 Rugby World Cup are beginning. But de-unionisation at a time like this simply cedes the field. Efforts must be redoubled — not only to negotiate the sorts of concessions gained by Irish actors for collective bargaining among independent contractors, but to ensure that whoever claims to have a union mandate in future has the crowd with the torches and pitchforks following them, rather than chasing them.


16 Responses to “Lessons from The Hobbit: more unionisation, not less”

  1. Scott A on October 22nd, 2010 at 19:48

    Lew,I think the only thing you got wrong here, the only thing that represents maybe a misunderstanding of New Zealand’s labour market, is that you should’ve written this line instead:

    “in which more workers had an understanding of what a union was there for”

    “A union” not “their union.” Ultimately, that’s why we’re un-unionised outside of the civil sector compared to Australia. And why our wages and conditions are so much worse than those across the tasman.

    The anti-unionist propaganda that has led even workers to think unions are unreasonable, undemocratic, unrelatable things that are just there to let people to be lazy is our chief problem.

    Unions don’t have to be, and shouldn’t be like that. But because so many New Zealander’s think that is what they are it becomes a self-aggrandising philosophy of those with the drive to get to the leadership of many unions.

  2. Carol on October 22nd, 2010 at 20:23

    Some very good points, Lew. I think one of the main stories here is NZ actors’ struggle to form a workable union. It seems they have come from a very weak position, one that has been played on by the international production system up til now.

    I don’t think the actors fronting AE are so much prima donas, as a couple of actors who realise they are in a stronger position to voice what many actors have been muttering for years. For instance, Ive seen Karl Urban speak up for NZ actors a few years back in a letter to OnFilm. He seems to me to be someone committed to supporting NZ actors and unions in principle.

    But hopefully, this dispute can lead to a better organised and more democratic union.

  3. Nick K on October 22nd, 2010 at 22:14

    Has it ever occurred to you Carol that perhaps the reason there is a “weak” actors union here is because no one wants to join it or have anything to do with it?

    And if that is a natural conclusion, which it seems to be, don’t you then ask why?

  4. Lew on October 22nd, 2010 at 23:21

    Nick, whatever the reason, they’re paying the price for it now.


  5. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Russell Brown and 10PARK, Lew. Lew said: on KP: "More unionisation, not less" If NZ film workers had a robust union, fools like AE couldn't hijack it. #TheHobbit […]

  6. Carol on October 23rd, 2010 at 07:09

    Good question, Nick. I think it partly has to do with the PR unions tend to get. There’s a long history in NZ (and the west/Anglo countries) of disparaging unions – which is just how many employers and well-off people like it.

    Also, the movie/TV industry in NZ is a small one, with a shifting work-force and a lot of short-term, insecure work. I can understand that a lot of industry workers don’t want to be branded as a troublemaker or critical of their employers, and fear being branded as a union stirrer. There is an implicit intimidation here by the powerful big studios, even if unintended (or unacknowledged by some workers).

    But all that just reinforces the relatively weak position of a large number of industry workers. The whole reasoning (or raison d’etre) of unions is that it’s an unequal power relationship, with employers having most power and the potential to exploit individual workers (of course most employers don’t intentionally aim to exploit).

    As an individual a worker is in a very weak position, and easily intimidated. If workers stand together, they have more power.

    What many people don’t understand in the current issue is that employers tend to use any sign of splits between workers to their advantage – divide and conquer principle.

    The people planning so valiantly to protest in Jackson’s/Warner’s favour today, really don’t understand this, and how they are undermining actors’ bargaining position in the long run. I understand that they are motivated by a desire to work in their chosen industry, and to get opportunities to use and develop their talents.

    But, in the end, a good, well organised union, will improve their position. That’s why I agree with Lew that the NZ industry needs bigger and better unions, not less of them.

  7. Lew on October 23rd, 2010 at 09:07

    The people planning so valiantly to protest in Jackson’s/Warner’s favour today, really don’t understand this, and how they are undermining actors’ bargaining position in the long run.

    Carol, this sort of ‘false consciousness’ argument only works if the union in question is actually doing what’s best for the workers. In this case all the evidence suggests that they’re not. People not involved in the conflict might think AE are doing wonderfully, but that view is contradicted by the objective reality of the situation. That’s pretty clear to anyone who cares to take a dispassionate look at the case.

    Most of the pro-trade union positioning on this rests on the maxim that whatever the union does is right for the workers. This would be true in a robust union system where the union understands and represents the needs of its workers, but this one patently does not. Union don’t get a free pass: the basis and outcomes of their actions need to be tested against the needs of those they represent. Where the union faithfully acts with a mandate from its workers, criticism regarding the effectiveness of its actions are a bit irrelevant since, even if what the union is doing seems stupid and wrong, at least it’s doing what its workers want. If AE undertook exactly tthe same idiotic strategy it has done here with a solid mandate from NZ screen workers I’d be right in behind them. But because the democratic foundation of the union system has broken down in this case, permitting a bunch of illegitimate grandstanders to speak for an entire industry, the outcome is perverse. AE is acting in the interests of an elite few to the detriment of many more, and as such is the enemy of the workers, not its ally.


  8. Bruce Hamilton on October 23rd, 2010 at 13:17

    Money is the root cause of the current situation, especially combined with the incompetence of paid union organisers – such as Helen Kelly.

    MEAA want to manage and distribute the millions of dollars of residuals from a successful film, as well as the membership fees ( only had 89 NZ members in 2009 and it costs $229 to join, and $21/week for those earning $85K ). They collectd $49 million in residuals over 7 years, and if their administration fee is 15%, then $7 million to play with… The Hobbitt films were a potential goldmine, and I doubt the welfare of NZ actors was high up MEAA’s list when they lobbed the boycott grenade across the Tasman.

    Over the last decade, unions have failed to deliver for members, and consequently young employees have taken individual contracts that better meet their immediate needs. In the union I was a delegate for, the membership were older people who appreciated the concept of collectivism, as well as the well-entrenched benefits for the more mature, such as redundancy, enhanced parental leave, retirement leave, etc.

    Members were prepared to pay the not-inconsiderable union fee as the minimum energy path to employment contracts. Minimum energy path means that less that 2% of members turned up to the only picket in 2 decades, and about 20-30% turned up to meetings- whether AGM, pre-negotiation to identify bargaining goals, ratification of new agreements, election of delegates, etc. That’s not unusual, and is why unions have rules that motions are passed by a defined majority of those who attend plus any valid proxies.

    Unsurprisingly, union members expect quality advice from their Union, however unpaid and partly-trained delegates were the interface. Full-time union convenors covered all of NZ and a diverse range of industries, so struggled to help individual members in complex cases. They would tend to settle with employers, rather than initiate a potentially-expensive litigation path.

    Members soon discovered that hiring a lawyer with industrial relations expertise could attract better terms from the employer. Also, as we’ve just seen, power-hungry union staff can avoid the moral, if not legal, requirement of consulting with fee-paying members before any negotiations or actions against their employer. If I was a member of a Union that didn’t consult and obtain prior consent, I’d be pretty pissed.

    Employers generally offer the same terms and conditions to employees on individual contracts, without the added cost of union fees. Not surprisingly, few young people join Unions, and workplace coercion, from either employees or employers is illegal. Union fees are like insurance, only necessary when damage is imminent, or has occurred.

    Quite a few employers also offer bespoke tailoring of individual contracts to match individual’s needs. In a former workplace, a work force of 50 people had 22 difference employment contracts, with less than 10% of staff on a collective employment agreement. Employment contracts have become more important as recording the terms of any relationship.

    The issues with being a contractor, versus an employee, are more to do with the available position, and an individual’s hunger for the position. To get serious tax advantages, contractors have to invest in themselves ( training – a major reason why Bryson failed the contractor test ), their business, and tools.

    For employers, it’s about obtaining a desired service as and when required, at cost-effetive rates. Most NZ businesses now run on a mix of employees and contractors, because that’s flexible, but the entertainment industry has been doing it for decades.

    Apparently many of the participants are happy to work that way. However if an employer really wanted somebody, I’m sure they would offer the employment contract or service contract necessary to procure that individual. The converse applies to potential employees.

    If you really want workers to join unions, they unions have to offer greatly improved value for their fees – I’ve seen little recent evidence of 21st century employment environment awareness from the CTU, other than Arther Scargill attitudes, which may be relevant if employees plan to follow the path of dinosaurs and UK mining.

    Unfortunately, the new strain of Employment Relations Managers often regard employees as the liability who arrives at 0800, rather than the valuable asset who departs at 1700. It’s only line managers who can value experience and wisdom, and they often don’t participate in policymaking.

    To those would suggest Warner Brothers would not walk away from their NZ investment to date, you have to realise it’s currently only a small sunk cost, and greatly exceeded by future expenditure and possible savings. These are project bean counters whose bonuses, and possibly jobs, depend on budget compliance, so any potential unplanned delay is greatly feared.

    They will want concrete assurances of industrial harmony, as well as additional financial incentives to remain in NZ – why shouldn’t they utilise this unexpected opportunity to trim future costs, that’s what they are paid for… Somewhat ironic they will appear on Labour Day, but we don’t have Employers Day.

  9. SPC on October 23rd, 2010 at 23:28

    It would appear that many of the film industry workers want to be in a Peter Jackson company union and regard their own interests as willing dependents on foreign film production as separate and distinct from the local industry and the global union solidarity cause.

  10. Simon on October 25th, 2010 at 09:57

    From the Herald today (25 October):

    “The unions had wanted to meet to negotiate the terms and conditions of the contracts for The Hobbit, but the producers declined on legal advice that collective bargaining amounted to price-fixing and was illegal”.

    If this is in fact the inital position of the Hobbit producers, then there is little reason for people who want to work on the Hobbit to join any union. The absence of a mandate is understandable, even before the free rider problems pointed out by Bruce, or the poor public reputation of unions in general.

    It is important that unions are representative and democratic, but before this they need provide some good reason for people to join them. In the past these reasons were provided by the government in the form of compulsory unionism, blanket coverage and compulsory arbitration. That system had its own problems, but a deregulated labour market, with minimum legislated standards, encourages the fragmentation of workers.

    Will joining a union get me a job, more money, more leave, protect me against unjustified dismissal? Not if everyone knows that the person who isn’t a member of a union will get the job/pay rise everytime.

  11. dave brown on October 25th, 2010 at 14:38

    Lew calling on unions to be strong but condemning a weak union like AE for attempting just that is just a cover for union bashing. Internationally actors unions have rejected such advice and grown strong. But not in little NZ.
    Over the Hobbit the Hollywood bankers, the producers and directors are allowed to engage in union bashing so they can rip off their billions on the backs of the workers. Why should the union shut up? To do defend an icon? What’s an icon? A commercial creation that misrepresents national identity by making it conditional on massive profits. Unlike LOTR which is fantasy entertainment, the unions are real icons here because they represent a history of struggle for equality in this country.
    LOTR like the World Cup, becomes a national icon only because it is created as such big business as a fetish to misrepresent reality. Hollywood serves to promote the fetished reality of good over evil unrelated to everyday life.
    So when the actors say lets get our share of this supposed national icon since we have given our labour to it, the rude truth is revealed. National means business, not the citizenry. No iconic shares baby unless you take low pay, suck up the union bashing, tug your forelock and generally grovel before a branch of US cultural imperialism. Just goes to prove what a subservient semi-colonial society NZ is and those like you Lew who think that LOTR somehow changes that are deluding yourself.

  12. Lew on October 26th, 2010 at 08:05

    Ah, Dave, that’s just the ‘union right or wrong’ bollocks I’m talking about. I’m not bashing unions — I’m bashing unions who don’t have the support of the people whose careers they’re dicing with. I’m not condemning AE for attempting to gain a better deal for their workers — I’m condemning them for overplaying their hand, taking the nuclear-hostage option of a worldwide general strike without the backing of the wider industry, and generally permitting what should have been an ordinary industrial relations dispute to be turned into a huge political-symbolic attack on the union movement in general.

    If you can’t see the awful symbolism of an anti-union protest on Labour Day then I don’t know what’ll persuade you that they’re doing much more harm than good. This will be long remembered as an example of how not to do industrial action. And so it should be — but I wish it hadn’t had to.


  13. KJT on October 28th, 2010 at 21:41

    Actors are not in Unions because NZ law, unlike many other countries, does not extend employment protections to “independent contractors” and does not allow them to negotiate collectively.

  14. SPC on October 28th, 2010 at 22:08

    More aptly put, they are in unions but anti-union legislation reduced their relevance, and this latest legal move just exacerbates this.

  15. Lew on October 28th, 2010 at 22:12

    Indeed, and efforts to reform that state of affairs, similarly to how the Irish have done, were underway. Now what chance do they have?


  16. […] actually represent workers’ interests. This is quite apart from the points I made in my last post on this topic, to the effect that non-democratic institutions tend to make bad decisions because […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)