glucophage upset stomach sildenafil generika online how many mg of viagra should a 280 man costco pharmacy coupons on cialis glucophage 500 mg adelgazar when is best time to day cialis daily dove comprare viagra generico image of generic cialis accessrx fake viagra prescriptions viagra 100mg popis buy of paypal cialis viagra brand buy metformin other brands of fitbit generika priligy erfahrung zoloft 100 mg toc zithromax iv in pediatric patients ampicillin diarrhea treatment where to buy viagra in bangkok thailand generic and trade name for prednisone 5mg clomid headaches treatment generic super active cialis is viagra walmart viagra tablet price pakistan sildenafil sandoz 100 mg cenacolo viagra post ireland phenindione 10 mg prednisone herbal viagra for women in india doxycycline tablets cheap can you take clomid for more than 5 days monthly price of clomid prescription how to get viagra in nsw import viagra to canada viagra benefits health in urdu accutane chemistry metformin eating disorders cialis boite 8 prix does metformin come generic form comprar cialis mercadolivre where to buy clomid for prohormone use propecia buy slovakia no prescription prednisone 20 mg metformin er 500 mg for pregnancy nitro dur patch 10 mg prednisone accutane how long to wait to get pregnant buy viagra online in canada from trusted sites doxycycline treatment for acne vulgaris viagra tablets cost in india cialis tqeovertoz online ciprofloxacin dosis dewasa ml viagra in tenerife buying ciprofloxacin india what will counteract cialis costco pharmacy price of viagra viagra australian actress list metformin za regulaciju ciklusa puedo usar cytotec por segunda vez ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablets information can you buy cialis in croatia viagra chewable tablets buy 5mg cialis and scratch in half buy doxycycline azithromycin ofloxacin or erythromycin viagra uses and effects donde puedo comprar viagra para mujeres en chile prednisone 50 mg for psoriasis how much os cialis in greece treatment for thrush in women diflucan fluconazole how to get propecia in uk average cost propranolol for anxiety clomid india price metformin zydus pharmaceuticals usa where i will find pfizer viagra in delhi me puedo tomar media pastilla de viagra for sale the best way to get viagra propranolol 60 mg capsule salon proscar finasteride 5 mg precio dapoxetine hcl 30mg reviews on garcinia cialis online without prescription that ships fed x how to buy viagra in vancouver where to buy cialis in the country of india lowest price cialis no perscription long term usage doxycycline zoloft patent generic metformin in t1dm cheap lasix baownbeuv ciprolex 5mg online uk doxycycline hyclate treat mrsa reviews how much money cialis 10 mg dubai online viagra tesco sleep aid 25 mg zoloft viagra pfizer europe cialis 10 mg taglich cost metformin australia propranolol is the generic name for viagra online north america best products for accutane can you break cialis 5 in half and use 2.5 safe exercise while taking propranolol and exercise identify viagra pills cipro capitale canada cialis over the counter at walmart price how long can i stay on prednisone tablets uk is old cipro safe cost of metformin in australia 66 year old man takes too much viagra ciprofloxacino 500 mg tratamiento can you buy zovirax tablets over the counter in ireland when to take finasteride on cycle devices generic propecia bestille viagra zoloft breastfeeding safe what is prednisolone used for in asthma how to get the best price on viagra can you buy viagra over the counter in a chemist ceftriaxona intramuscular ou ciprofloxacin 250 mg average price per pill for generic cialis mid cycle pain with clomid reviews off label use of propranolol in asthmatics sertraline sandoz 50 mg same as zoloft side coupons cialis 20 mg is viagra ok in a 150 mg dose cialis generico entrega 24 horas next day del in uk viagra by phone glucophage yeast infections diflucan can be buy where in the philippines order lasix with out script viagra to buy in birmingham on the counter viagra walmart donde puedo comprar esta pastilla cytotec cytotec for abortion online information ciprofloxacino generico do viagra twins 150mg clomid agora viagra online sildenafil citrate tablets cenforce 100 online inderal adverse effects aurochem tadalafil 20mg canada cialis 5 mg review como comprar viagra en uruguay mamading viagra coupon pfizer walmart how to get pregnant faster on clomid prednisolone drops per ml formula herbal viagra tablets in coimbatore if viagra comes in pfizer packaging is it real clomid causa espinhas prednisone in ipf can you purchase viagra mexico viagra online bestellen wonder lowest price generic propecia zoloft prozac medicine online pharmacy com real or fake cialis bangkok avelox 400 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin can i purchase zithromax over the counter socialist workers party united states viagra dosage size banocide 50 mg viagra viagra over the counter in ireland where to buy viagra in ksa what vitamins are in accutane lasix furosemide 25 mg producto basico ampliado y generico de cialis joypox dapoxetine buy how much does cialis cost from blue cross iv doxycycline to treat mrsa in urine generic viagra truth were can viagra be bought over the counter in liverpool allopurinol 300 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin tadalafil 20mg canada pharmacy customs australia viagra fine viagra pret 100 mg propranolol 60 mg reviews escinum 20 mg prednisone prednisone 10 mg neck pain dosage doxycycline dosage for teeth bow to buy sildenafil in ireland what type of vitamin a is in accutane lactaatacidose metformin er 500 mg can i cut my 20mg cialis in half zoloft in morning or night leere viagra schachtel kaufen cost of 20 500mg amoxil tabs in ireland thiopental injection 500 mg metformin cialis price increases over the years maximum dose of finasteride how much will clomid cost generic finasteride versus propecia for sale viagra super force generic viagra online bestellen erfahrungskurve prednisolone sodium phosphate brand thuoc cuong duong viagra for sale evolution viagra salesman quotes regitine 10 mg prednisone vagifem positive reviews of zoloft que pasa si tomo 40 mg de cialis has anyone taken clomid while pregnant where to buy cialis without a precriptipn vilamid 20 mg cialis glucophage 1000 mg nebenwirkungen magnesium sildenafil vaginal pessaries brands available in india doxycycline and diflucan 100 mg 3 for yeast infection buy cialis online no prescription usa nick villarreal la viagra dj not ovulation after miscarriage clomid online eskatrol generic cialis pros and cons of zoloft cialis 5 mg did not work success rate artificial insemination clomid online 40mg cheap cialis price of cialis 10mg at walmart generic viagra.me .uk non prescription viagra boots uk propecia when generic sildenafil citrate oral gel in pregnancy metformin sr 500mg in asthma patient generic propecia lowest price prednisolone pfizer 5 mg biverkningar thacapzol doxycycline 40 mg reviews 33drugs com viagra online fluconazole diflucan 150 mg oral candidiasis can clomid cause urinary tract infections costo cialis generico in farmacia farmacias online fiables cialis dose prix viagra asie donde comprar misoprostol cytotec mexico viagra for long lasting onde posso comprar cytotec em portugal beconase generic uk viagra dalacin c 150 mg pfizer viagra donde comprar cytotec sin receta en tegucigalpa can i take generic viagra if i have performance anxiety cialis in normaler apotheke kaufen how long 2.5 mg of tadalafil stays in the body viagra sources in calgary where to buy viagra in blackburn stronghold selamectin 45 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin viagra online farmacia italia 5mg cialis best prices libertarian socialism in western kurdistan how long to take propecia zoloft jolting electric zaps in knee cytotec 200mg price in pakistan n8 viagra price in chandigarh metformin over the counter walmart clomid online illegal cost of viagra in dominican republic get cialis in mexico glucophage 850 kaufen walgreens generic finasteride who owns the means of production in socialism how do you use viagra jelly prix generique viagra en pharmacie price viagra per pill cialis e20 generics24 ohne wirkung von water main break generic cialis generic and brand cialis difference cost of viagra in plzen czech how hard is it to get prescribed viagra dr pezzi accutane generic how long does dose of viagra last order viagra online from usa new york modo de usar sildenafil do we need prescription for cialis in massachusetts how best to take doxycycline viagra dosagem certa theodore schenk counterfit viagra viagra in deutschland kaufen legal ventide generico do viagra morfina bula 10 mg prednisone can one take cialis powdered with brandy propranolol hcl 60 mg sa online viagra ads order cheap viagra donde puedo comprar una cytotec purchase viagra now viagra and hypotension thuoc endoxan 50 mg zoloft actonel once a month generic viagra legitimate cialis online head vector 100 womens reviews on cialis cialis daily use coupon walmart herbal viagra for sale ukay viagra no prescription europe tax rate in socialist countries today propecia quarter pill xanax and metformin ca cialis be split in half what is the price of viagra in karachi cialis brand online no prescription cuanto tarda en hacer efecto cialis 5 mg how to buy ciprofloxacin online without a prescription cialis daily dose generic tadalafil 20 mg vs sildenafil where can i get accutane in malaysia comprar pastillas cytotec en costa rica is isotretinoin the same as accutane comprar cytotec en barcelona viagra nederland bestellen viagra and canada viagra sale sydney ethenzamide 500 mg metformin should i use topicals while on accutane sildenafil 100mg bijsluiter clomid da dor nas costas noritren 10 mg bivirkninger av prednisolone is it illegal to buy viagra via internet different mg of propecia can you make your own viagra is ampicillin the same as amoxicillin buying viagra whn visiting mexico taking 150 mg of viagra tokyogeo fig buy zoloft wo kann man billig cialis kaufen buying viagra eu paphos cipro spiagge costa metformin ukpds 34 doxycycline hyclate used for staph viagra sildenafil citrate 50 100mg can you take cialis with flomax can we buy ciprofloxacin in mercury drugs store best dose of metformin for pcos can i take accutane and adderall comprar viagra pela net sildenafila 25 mg of zoloft pfizer viagra usa cialis 2.5 prix can viagra cause rectal bleeding can you buy cialis in gibraltar nolvadex pct dosage epistane for sale renal dosing doxycycline how to buy cipro from mexico online metformin review diabetes business with china viagra produced in china getting pregnant pcos clomid tratamiento prolongado finasteride generic donde puedo comprar la pastilla cytotec viagra for men in manchester sildenafil citrate usp accutane 60 mg month 2 nolvadex and clomid prices 150 mg zoloft withdrawal dizziness nolvadex safety prix viagra generique pfizer cost of cialis tablets in india buy cialis from malaysia ciprofloxacin eye drops used in ears mejor price cialis prix sildenafil generique en pharmacie el viagra causa hemorroides munich viagra price munich viagra cost and insurance donde puedo comprar cialis en el df where can i buy viagra bangkok can minors take viagra safe period for use of finasteride 1 mg canada cialis paypal generic propecia ineffective metformin 500 mg y la fertilidad how much is 2.5 mg cialis can kidney transplant patients take viagra clomid brand name vs generic drugs ciprofibrato 100 mg dosis cataflam glucophage bertibarots canada accutane 20 mg day lang en doryx doxycycline hyclate delayed release tablets what is doxycycline hydrochloride tablets que pasa si tomo viagra y no la necesito doxycycline monohydrate tablets buy clomide montreal diflucan vs monistat in pregnancy 20 hertford street mayfair london w1j 7rx viagra zilfic viagra generic where can i buy cialis in shanghai buy one dose zithromax with mastercard marevan 5 mg bijsluiter nolvadex canadian drugs viagra is it safe to take viagra with 72 hour cialis aviation specialist yum brands salary amoxicilline disp 500 mg teva bijwerkingen doxycycline real viagra over the counter cialis paypal accepted online their generic propecia shop cialis online can you get cialis on prescription donde se puede comprar viagra en chile existe thuoc isonace 10 mg prednisone brand lasix cobra viagra 150 mg viagra pay with paypal uk best facial cleanser while on accutane is it ok to take two 25 mg viagras doxycycline bad taste in mouth cardiovascular specialist in the army how long dies apotex metformin stay in the body has anyone tried generic viagra rupilip generico do viagra viagra over the counter in sydney viagra sale 50mg efectos secundarios de metformin 1000 mg how many mg of diflucan do i take for a yeast infection viagra in neonates what will happen if you take two 100 mg viagra metformin taken with clomid ever bought viagra online best cod killcam reactions to prednisone zoloft generic serdepr lenangio 25 mg of zoloft large dose viagra how safe is to buy viagra online yahoo answers que causa la viagra cialis generico testimonianze clomid pain in left side where to find liquid viagra drink can you get addicted to lasix zoloft pill stuck in throat burning at night selling generic cialis illigal 20 mg dose cialis propecia female hair loss pfizer viagra spam where can i buy viagra for women viagra prices virginia giving lasix iv push k swiss blade max glide womens reviews on viagra viagra shopping in india fuite veineuse cialis when is the best time to take propecia vibramycin rowcmoadreders discount brooks adrenaline asr 11 womens reviews on cialis drug bank of sildenafil citrate doxycycline sandoz 100 mg cipro hexal 500 mg alkohola rayh health care pvt ltd cialis canada diflucan farmacia online argentina prednisone 20 mg la thuoc gi nolvadex vs letrozole cefdinir vs cipro buy viagra 2nd day air is prescription needed for viagra in mexico comprar zanidip 20mg prednisone lekovi za potenciju cialis cost ampicillin hereisthebestin without prescription prednisone taper 40 mg canadian price of viagra prednisone dose in kids prolopa 250 50 mg viagra is it safe for females to take viagra cheap sildenafil citrate 100mg uk yahoo directions on taking viagra sildenafil 50 mg en mujeres mayores cipro 500 mg directions yahoo use viagra tablet skin specialist in dallas drinking on accutane generic viagra does it work as good metformin prices walmart accutane cost au price on viagra 100 mg medicamento metformin 500 mg propranolol brands in india clomid for sale aurora buy original viagra online fabian essays in socialism year published puedo usar cytotec despues de 10 semanas viagra online australia paypal customer spray nasale effetto viagra viagra rezeptfrei bestellen bezahlen paypal what effect does viagra have on pde5 20 mg prednisone no taper yeast infection diflucan how long in your system pfizer viagra online paypal uk getting pregnant after taking doxycycline costco price on viagra keep viagra suppositories in refrigerator red cialis viagra 200mg over counter drugs similar prednisone 20 w580 main fs y custom generic cialis vilag vilaga viragnak viagra online clomid in caso di fsh alto cialis 40 mg generico order cheapest viagra online que debo comer antes de usar cytotec priligy where to buy effets secondaires inderal propecia australia 5mg buy pink viagra for women uk propranolol public speaking dosage40 mg recommended doxycycline dosage viagra brands in the world ciprofloxacin 250 mg dosis is viagra safe to take with chemotherapy buy viagra online canada paypal casino can you purchase zovirax over the counter at walmart cheap pfizer viagra online uk suppliers doxycycline dosage elephantiasis buying viagra la vegas two 10 mg cialis one 20 mg dove trovo il cialis generico buy viagra online by bill me later buying accutane cream without a prescription prednisone use in myasthenia gravis aloprim generic cialis 50 oder 100 mg viagra metformin and keflex Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Circumstance, Context and Consequence of New Zealand’s first combat death in Afghanistan.*

Circumstance, Context and Consequence of New Zealand’s first combat death in Afghanistan.*

datePosted on 20:02, August 5th, 2010 by Pablo

Events in Afghanistan this week prompted me to write on them as well as their implications. This is the full version, which did not appear in the mainstream press.

Until this week the 140-troop NZDF mission in support of the Provincial Reconstruction team (PRT) in Afghanistan’s Bamiyan province was considered the “softer” of the two NZDF deployments in that country. Given their status as elite combat troops, the 2001-05 and post-2009 NZSAS missions in Afghanistan have received more attention as the presumably “hard” edge of New Zealand’s military contribution to the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) charged with bringing peace and stability to that failed state. The death of Lieutenant Timothy O’Donnell has changed that view.

Lieutenant O’Donnell was killed while on routine patrol northeast of the city of Bamiyan. NZDF patrols are undertaken daily as part of the PRT’s responsibilities, which are to provide security and undertake civil reconstruction and nation-building projects such as the construction of schools, roads, medical clinics (including the combat medics to staff them), water treatment facilities and other infrastructure required for local governance to operate efficiently. Although Bamiyan province is largely populated by the non-Pashtun ethnic Hazaras (a Shiia minority elsewhere in Afghanistan) who are generally friendly to ISAF forces because they were discriminated against under Taliban rule, the Taliban presence, although not as dominant as in Helmand or Kandahar provinces, has remained as an ever-present threat that has increased over the last two years. In fact, the ambush in which Lieutenant O’Donnell died was preceded by at least three similar attacks in the last 14 months, all using the same combination of improvised explosive devices (IEDs), Rocket Propelled Grenades (RPGs) and small arms fire.

Despite the previous attacks, the NZDF did not vary its operational routine and continued to use three or four vehicle convoys for its patrols along well-established routes. The vehicles in question were US-provided reinforced Toyota Hiluxes and armed “uparmoured” Humvees in which electronic counter-measures (ECM) were reportedly used to thwart electronic pulse-detonated IEDs (UPDATE: official details are sketchy as to whether the convoy was a mix of vehicles or all of one or the other, but non official reports suggest that Hiluxes have not been used on those patrols for 18 months and the vehicles in question were all “uparmoured” Humvees). Although state of the art, such ECMs cannot prevent a command wire or pressure plate detonated IED (especially at night), one of which was apparently used in this latest attack.

In previous instances the Hiluxes suffered minor damages in IED attacks, but this time the IED was much more powerful. No NZDF Light Armoured Vehicles (LAVIIs), out of an inventory of 106, were provided to the NZDF/Bamiyan PRT because their characteristics were deemed unsuitable for the Bamiyan AOR because most of it is single track dirt paths (even though the NZSAS has two available for operational duty in Kabul and the US has deployed ECM-equipped and reinforced armoured Stryker (the name it gives to the LAVs) units in the Afghan theater of operations). Although very agile in rough terrain (especially in its 6×6 version), the 321-strong NZDF Pinzgauer Military Utility Vehicle (MUV) fleet was not requisitioned in Bamiyan even though it fulfills the NZDF Light Operational Vehicle (LOV) role, most likely because even in its “uparmoured” version it remains vulnerable to combined small arms assaults and is underpowered when traversing steep terrain in its uparmoured version.  Unlike in previous instances, air cover was not able to respond to the latest attack due to bad weather conditions in the area. The official line is that the patrol was able to find cover and establish a defensive position while returning fire, leading to a prolonged firefight before the assailants were repelled. In all likelihood given Taliban  hit and run tactics, the actual firefight was quite short and most of the damage to men and machines was done by the IED rather than the ensuing exchange of small arms fire. Whatever the exact circumstances, this combination of contributing factors proved to be lethal for Lt. O’Donnell and injurious to his comrades.

The ISAF strategy in Afghanistan is a macrocosmic reflection of what the PRT mission is in Bamiyan. It conducts counter-insurgency operations against Taliban and al-Qaeda forces in order to physically secure the country and prevent the re-establishment of both Taliban rule and al-Qaeda safe havens and training camps within it. In parallel, it attempts to train Afghan security forces and provide the infrastructural conditions so as to consolidate the control of the Western-backed Karzai regime centred in Kabul. As with the Bamiyan PRT, success in the first task is deemed necessary for success with the latter two.

In many ways the death of a Kiwi soldier was inevitable given the balance of the conflict. ISAF has not succeeded in routing the Taliban even if it has denied them and their al-Qaeda allies much territory and space for maneuver. Its nation-building efforts have been thwarted by endemic corruption by the Karzai regime and a motley assortment of tribal warlords and drug barons. For all its rhetorical commitment to supporting the ISAF mission from its side of the border, Pakistan remains a suspect ally, if not a covert adversary in the conflict. Given the announced timetable for a US troop drawdown and ISAF withdrawal beginning in July 2011, the Taliban have increased their attacks in order to raise the costs to ISAF, undermine public support for the mission amongst coalition partners (such as the Dutch, who have just exited the theater), and thereby hasten the inevitable. In fact, both ISAF commander General David Petraeus as well as US Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Admiral Michael Millan have said that ISAF casualties will increase over the next months as coalition forces push into Taliban strongholds in a final effort to degrade its ability to mount effective guerrilla operations against Afghanistan police, Army and ISAF targets.

However, true to form, the Taliban have responded with a classic guerrilla tactic when confronted with superior military forces: they employ a “balloon” strategy whereby they retreat from areas in which they are being squeezed by superior ISAF forces and regroup in areas in which the ISAF presence is relatively thin on the ground. The key to their success is to respond to mass with maneuver, avoiding the friction of large conventional forces via fluidity of movement towards areas in which the odds are in their favour. In other words, the Taliban like to” hit ’em where they ain’t.”

One such area is Bamiyan, which means that there is nothing soft about the NZDF/PRT role there. The hazards are not just military. Given the Taliban resurgence and the inevitable withdrawal of ISAF forces, it is prudent and rational for the Hazaras (as much as all other tribal groups throughout the country) to begin to look the other way when it comes to Taliban movements in Bamiyan, if not cooperate with or simply accommodate the insurgents. After all, the Taliban will be a armed and political presence long after the ISAF forces are scaled back or gone. That makes the NZDF position in the Bamiyan PRT harder to maintain the closer it approaches to the announced ISAF withdrawal date. In plain terms, without reinforcement the NZDF/PRT position becomes more tenuous given the shift in local loyalties as the withdrawal deadline approaches, and tenuous in military terms means a high probability of increased casualties as the adversary grows in confidence and receives more support or acquiescence from the local population.

The National government has reaffirmed its commitment to the Bamiyan PRT mission through September 2011 and is considering extending thr NZSAS deployment past its scheduled March 2011 end date. But the possibility of further fatalities now haunts its commitment. The larger question is whether the New Zealand public has the stomach to support continuing NZDF participation in the Afghan conflict in the face of increased casualties. That will be a critical juncture in New Zealand foreign relations, because public support is essential to maintaining the political will to continue fighting—and dying—in support of broadly defined foreign policy objectives. Since the measure of a military commitment is ultimately taken in blood, it behooves New Zealand’s political leadership to make a strong case as to why Kiwi lives are worth sacrificing in a seemingly futile conflict in far off place that appears, on the face of things, to have little strategic value to core New Zealand interests. It is also incumbent upon the opponents of the NZDF deployment to Afghanistan to make an equally convincing case as to why Kiwi lives should not be risked in Afghanistan in pursuit of vanity, favour, treasure or ephereal benefit.

Out of that debate a true public consensus can be formed that gives clear direction to the government’s approach to the ISAF commitment in the year leading up to general elections.

*A short version of this essay was published in the New Zealand Herald on August 5, 2010 under the title “Death makes it clear Bamiyan not “soft” option.”

11 Responses to “Circumstance, Context and Consequence of New Zealand’s first combat death in Afghanistan.*”

  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by NZ Accommodation, Lew. Lew said: Background to and implications of the death of Lt O'Donnell, by Paul Buchanan: http://bit.ly/bR2PMz In brief: NZ needs to discuss the issue. […]

  2. Old Phart on August 6th, 2010 at 01:13

    I wonder how much enthusiasm there would be on the part of the ISAF if NZ Govt were to insist on re-deploying some of our SAS to Bamyian so they could “ride shotgun” to our PRT? And how keen would the SAS itself be? I imagine they might prefer the more glamorous – albeit probably more dangerous – surroundings of Kabul.

  3. Hugh on August 6th, 2010 at 02:01

    If the death of an NZ soldier was inevitable why have you, in your voluminous number of articles on the Kiwi presence in Afghanistan, never predicted it outside of retrospect?

  4. Pablo on August 6th, 2010 at 11:53

    Hugh:

    Two things. 1) I have alluded to the risks in a number of fora a number of times; 2) just because one knows that bad news is in all probability on its way does not mean that one should publicly engage in worst case predictions. That would be seen as alarmist and politically motivated, if not contrary to troop morale, mean-spirited, unpatriotic and the like.

    The hard fact is that it has been evident in my writing all along what the risks of the Afghan mission were, which did not have to be spelled out in elementary fashion for readers to comprehend.

  5. Hugh on August 6th, 2010 at 16:45

    So deaths are inevitable, but they’re also limited to worst case scenarios? Got it.

  6. Pablo on August 6th, 2010 at 16:55

    Hugh:

    Being pedantic might score you brownie points in Japan but here it just reveals you to be a twit. Besides, your basic comprehension skills are clearly suspect. I specifically wrote that Lt. O’Donnell’s death was inevitable “given the balance of the conflict,” and then go on to explain at length why the conflict has increased the odds against NZDF soldiers.

    Even had I not used the qualifying remarks that you conveniently neglect to mention, your lack of cognitive skills extends further: Death is inevitable for us all, and unless one is bent on martyrdom, it is most definitely a worst case scenario when it occurs as a result of exposure to high explosives, hot lead or some other unnatural cause. No need, then, to belabour the obvious (to all except you, apparently).

  7. Hugh on August 6th, 2010 at 19:55

    Yeaaaa I think I’m done here, Pablo.

  8. SapperK9 on August 6th, 2010 at 20:08

    Hi Lux and Hummer!

    I don’t friggin believe it!? Over 40 years ago Australia learned from its Vietnam experience and developed the belly and sponson armour kit for the M113A1 because of road bombs/booby traps (as they were then called).

    We went into AStan with Bushmaster and APC/LRV. So far effective. Yanks went in with their bloody beach buggies, killed hundreds of their men because of this lame brained decision. Now, to use a Hummer “outside the wire” for the US requires the authority of a full Colonel or above. Clearly, the Kiwi Squaddie is worth less than the US Grunt?

    I do not believe that NZ deployed with utes and beach buggies? Do you have any officers or politicians who can walk and chew gum simultaneously? Because, in my opinion, the decision to use any vehicle not “designed” to take a hit, is the decision of the killer, Taliban or Kiwi, or both.

    Do you have public inquests for your KIA like the Poms, because Aust do not! Scared of showing our frail military petticoats in public.

    Sad, very sad, as is any unnecessary death on active service…

  9. Pablo on August 6th, 2010 at 20:26

    SapperK9:

    Thanks for the insight. There is much irony in what you write, as the NZDF replaced their M113 fleet with the (often non-deployable, some say virtually useless off pavement) LAVs.

    My understanding is that the NZDF/Bamiyan PRT initially used the Hilux’s with jury-rigged armour, then were loaned the Humvees by the US after they suffered damage (at least one was totaled) in previous attacks. The Humvees are supposed to be the “uparmoured” version, but do not have the V-shaped underarmour that would deflect an IED blast (nor, for that matter, do the LAVs). Although there are 6×6 Pinzgaeurs in the NZDF inventory they were also deemed unsuitable for the AOR (presumably because even armoured versions are, as I mentioned in the post, vulnerable to combined small arms attack).

    As far as I know there are no public inquests into NZDF KIAs, nor do I expect one to be held in this case (although PM Key has said that he welcomes one).

    As for officers and politicians chewing gum and walking simultaneously, check this out: http://www.kiwipolitico.com/2010/03/the-limitations-of-n-8-wire-and-how-the-politicalpolicy-talent-bench-is-so-thin/

  10. SapperK9 on August 6th, 2010 at 23:51

    Yes Pablo,

    The Hummers must have come cheeep, the US put some 60,000 into the MEAO and they are declared unsafe at any speed – surprise – at last! You can’t “up armour” anything nowadays if it don’t have the boat shaped hull. The Yanks knew this in the 60s when they made the bloody M60, and here we and they are with flat bottom still? Oz got it right with the Bushmaster which has been quite successful in protecting its occupants.

    You seem to suffer a similar issue to Oz in the equipping area. Often in our armies you’d think 1914-18 never happened and the machine gun and high explosive were a novelty to the battlefield. Never helped by senior officers without balls to speak out. Which is where the Poms now appear well off, some five of their Battlegroup commanders have resigned after service in the MEAO, and their CGS questioned both sides of politics in the media before the recent election. Balls on real officers. We (ANZAC) have a very dated purview of the Brit forces, illustrating clearly our level of ignorance.

    You don’t have to look far for examples of real equipping in the Middle East, Israel says it all. Have a look at their Namer APC, and their Iron Fist active defence systems, and they work detection dogs on ops from under cover and in armour from up to two miles away!

    There can be no excuse for any learning curve, let alone “reason”…

  11. […] […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: