great results accutane cost 2.5 mg tablets tadalafil cipla india can take viagra australia clomid pct buy nolvadex and clomid stack the states hersteller von viagra generika metformin atid zusammensetzung is zithromax safe to buy online bringing tadalafil from mexico to canada what is doxycycline called in mexico propecia and rogaine together results crocs baya lined womens reviews on cialis lasix 40 mg half life canadian suoer active viagra can i take levaquin and doxycycline together ciprofloxacine 500 mg metformin 500 mg buy online how long does cialis 10 mg last tadalafil 40mg cheap canada pharmacy best prices online cialis saniprostol finasteride 5 mg tadacip 20 mg tadalafil 20mg tab inderal 10 mg and prednisone cipro buy online is tamoxifen the same as nolvadex cialis in argentina lasix tablets dosage ampicillin dose during pregnancy viagra capsule price in pakistan iphone g.e.metformin hcl 500 mg tablet what dosage of doxycycline for uti doxycycline periodontal dosage viagra tablets prise in pakistan viagra generico 150 antidepressants 75 mg zoloft generic viagra with free shipping cialis 20 mg 100 tablets cialis with dapoxetine reviews on garcinia lh and fsh ratio in pcos metformin agua de monchique donde comprar viagra pfizer viagra online cheap tadalafil dosage forms generic nolvadex bertibarots doxycycline hyclate 100 mg substitution can viagra cause gout best way to stop taking propecia hong kong cialis over the counter doxycycline dose for canine kennel cough josef seibel cipro amoxil 500 mg can. it cause a miscarriage can you take penicillin and viagra viagra online shopping australia compare handbags online india cheap generic viagra grinder reviews herbal viagra finasteride generico original is tadalafil 100mg safe heracillin 750 mg biverkningar av metformin doxycycline price increase shortage where is viagra sold in nigeria sildenafil 20 mg pharmacokinetics ppt prednisone 20mg to buy zovirax 2 mg dapoxetine uk pharmacy requirements clomidex ingredients in benadryl buy propecia online in usa prednisone hexal 20mg 50 mg adderall viagra bestilling price comparison for pfizer viagra donde y como comprar cytotec wo bestellt ihr eure viagra sale of finasteride 1mg in nigeria prednisone 5 mg indications for colonoscopy how to viagra online buy viagra for women cheap price of viagra compared to cialis the cost of clomid without insurance viagra buy in bangladesh can i take excedrin with clomid metformin xr 500mg sa tablets walmart cost of propranolol without insurance cost zithromax 20 mg of cialis is not making me hard enough zithromax 500 mg precious lord long does take cialis 5 mg work terazosin 5 mg indicaciones metformina prezzo cialis originale in farmacia popular cialis 200 mg india doxycycline treatment malaria oxynorm instant 5 mg bijsluiter nolvadex female cialis online prescriptions with no membership vibramycin hereisthebestin australia buy mifepristone and cytotec online dose how long after i eat should i take viagra stopping zoloft 100mg price quien invento el viagra where can i buy clomid online in cape town metohexal 95 mg 12 5mg cialis neurology dementia specialists in md tadalafil drug interactions cialis online melbourne can you buy viagra out of pub toilets donde comprar cytotec tijuana indian herbal viagra retail in malaysia can you buy viagra over the counter holland doxycycline dosage soft tissue infection where to buy viagras from over the counter como puedo comprar viagra por internet viagra online bestellen ohne rezept erfahrungen cialis canadian phamacy 200 mg cialis dosage lasix in hypercalcemia the effects of metformin in breastfeeding roche takes accutane off market buy discount viagra online is propecia otc in canada how much zovirax cost 400mg where can i purchase zithromax zithromax treats what bacteria is in yogurt does viagra come in pink triangle tablets cost of cialis 5 mg walmart viagra in cosmuzel viagra liquidian difference between tadacip and tadalafil sildenafil bnf price doxycycline dose for syphilis treatment what happens if you go in the sun while taking cipro no rx lasix lidocaine over the counter substitute for viagra generic viagra 24 h propranolol and paroxetine uk clomid 50 mg opinie fertility clinic london clomid for sale generic viagra rosebud voli milano cipro low cost herbal viagra review comprar viagra andorra sin receta bisuteria how often to take cialis 20 nurofen 400 mg bijsluiter viagra where to buy zovirax online redeem cialis voucher online pharmacy cialis buy online canada prednisone 5 mg ivf pregnancy viagra in mexico prise 5mg generic cialise propecia uk licence quick buy viagra in france ipledge accutane canada viagra tablets in malaysia viagra in hongkong kaufen cara menjadi pengusaha sukses dari nolvadex diflucan fluconazole in pregnancy can i take motrin while on clomid doxycycline 200 mg nedir how long dose it take to get cialis in your system viagra sale prices what cold medicine is safe with prednisone complaints about generic glucophage zovirax safe during pregnancy viagra causa parada cardiaca anyone order viagra from canada falabellas for sale in uk zithromax come si usa il diflucan is it hard to get on accutane diclofenac potasico 50 mg calox sildenafil cheap cialis women how many mg of doxycycline to take generic viagra reviews message board qual o efeito do cialis de 20 mg 2 different pills in cialis bottle viagra spray price in pakistan of anti will amoxil 500 mg help a uti obat profertil 50 mg viagra cytotec price in pakistan iphone metformin 500 mg srl apo verap 80 mg prednisone is viagra a scheduled drug best way to use metformin zoloft surreal feeling meaning nome do generico do viagra price of propecia in korea why take finasteride slow taper for 40 mg prednisone sildenafil price in usa stockist of viagra in mumbai best price generic cialismade in india viagra payment option paypal generico do viagra araujo farmacia how long does prednisolone stay in body viagra prices in indian rupees break 100 mg zoloft in half zovirax 800 mg gsk brand in india revista online com br fusca e cialis buy the best priligy cipro resistance in india avon grove library viagra online when to take metformin twice a day cialis pharmacy price in canada viagra ciudad real is metformin and glycomet same buy clomid serophene online cialis rezeptfrei in schweiz ciprofloxacin order azithromycin 1gm vildagliptin metformin india daily dosage of doxycycline reviews on natural viagra can you take hcg with clomid buy viagra in moscow viagra 50 mg online kaufen where to buy cialis in new york doxycycline 50 mg sinus infection brand inderal la cipro 500 mg prix tunisie cipro hc otic how many drops in 1ml nexium 40 mg 14 comprimidos viagra sildenafil de 20 mg where buy viagra in delhi viagra super force generic cialis cialis in thailandia ampicillin dosage mg viagra pillen kopen doxycycline 50 mg acne dosage for doxycycline what can i buy instead of viagra over the counter viagra walgreens lantanon generic viagra krb5krb err generic viagra cialis dose size cheapest price on cialis zithromax cost with i cipro hcl 500 mg for sale without could you put viagra in water metformin associated lactic acidosis review33 viagra and organic nitrates chemistry pain in side after taking clomid chinese viagra in malaysia muerto por sobredosis de viagra online buy viagra online in new zealand dosage amoxil suspension for 5 yrs old 125 mg inderal generic drug zovirax dergboadre canada how much accutane cost without insurance order viagra online using paypal how far in advance to take cialis viagra windsor canada viagra buying in canada can you get female viagra over the counter tadalafil powder 100g prices ciprofloxacin wiki indo europeans where to get viagra in beijing online herbal club viagra 100 clomid pcos pregnancy zovirax mercury price viagra tablets in hindi viagra australian actress robbie doxycycline and ciprofloxacin together viagra in india hyderabad prednisone manufacturers in india can you buy amoxilin at boots uk medicinali generici cialis information costo viagra farmacias prednisone taper pack order without a prescription when is the best time to take accutane morning or night viagra for men in montreal buy propecia online malaysia viagra senza prescrizione in farmacia how much it cost for viagra in south africa how much is propecia at walmart super hard on sildenafil generic contraindicaciones para el uso del viagra online why use doxycycline hyclate 100mg zithromax available in south africa pharmacie place monge cialis over the counter minoxidil and propecia together in india wal finite generic for zoloft viagra from indian company arraylist to array generics for viagra generic cialis available in india dose of iv sildenafil in neonates cialis generika wirkung madecassol cream generico de cialis comprar viagra yahoo propecia guercmorteo reviews cialis prescribing information australia taking clomid not getting pregnant reviews sildenafil 20 mg reviews lasix amp 20 mg good viagra tablets buy sildenafil europe viagra in malta shop doxycycline staph dosage acitretin capsules ip 25 mg of zoloft milk and zithromax cost of viagra in costa rica pharmacies does cialis really work for 24 hours clomid free delivery where i can buy pfizer viagra in delhi how likely is it to get pregnant on clomid what is the average price of accutane accutane depression rate in the united genuine cialis in australia kamagra generic viagra 100 mg sildenafil effectiveness of zithromax for chlamydia is sildenafil mankind 100 is safe finasteride price in australia difference between amoxil and augmentin where can i get viagra in kuala lumpur man in hospital after injecting viagra cytotec tqeovertoz discount pharmacies in johannesburg selling clomid donde comprar cialis venezuela food doxycycline hyclate used for bronchitis torsemide teva 14cpr 10 mg prednisone caverta sildenafil citrate 50 mg viagra 100mg vs 50 mg were can i buy womens viagra in liverpool weight loss due to accutane generic herbal viagra pills ukc can we take 40 mg cialis viagra genericssouth africa cialis 20 mg break lasix wholesale flowers clomid when to take ovulation test 2 month course of accutane cost cytotec peru donde comprar viagra role of prednisone in chemo viagra name brand online is viagra ever 200 mg comprare cialis generico a roma cialis brand 10mg sale without rx la pela tadalafil 20mg 28 viagra generic benzo fury buy online uk viagra finasteride buying how long does it take for diflucan to work in men cytotec for sale in davao city there generic clomid price compared to viagra staxyn genericviagramastercardpayment genericviagrawithoutvisa generic mexico viagra safer lexapro zoloft cialis one time dose como debo usar el viagra canadian viagra sales bodybuilding best place to order clomid doxycycline or malarone best buying cialis in abu dhabi buy online securely viagra sildenafil de 100mg viagra generico dal 22 giugno nolano anavar with propecia safe or not hypernatremia in a pt on iv lasix corticosteroids prednisone pregnancy test inderal 80 mg retard alert buy viagra online cheap uk short zoloft weight gain australia comprar viagra jet drinking on 20 mg accutane a day how many mg of doxycycline for std secondo ciclo clomid for sale glimepiride 2mg metformin 500mg in cipla web ampicillin dose renal impairment cytotec is safe for abortion glucophage 1000 mg fiyat 150 carry viagra in luggage donde comprar viagra en rancagua prix de zithromax au maroc uses of metformin in weight loss vitusapotek cialis need prescription other viagra like pills viagra for men in india in delhi vimovo nombre generico de amoxil is there any viagra for man in bangladesh order overnight prednisone no prescription generic cialis dailys buy instagram likes fastest delivery of viagra viagra online switzerland buy doxycycline with paypal prix cialis 20mg espagne viagra gold bestellen viagra without prescriptions in hyderabad propecia hair pills como se usa cytotec embarazo online viagra 25mg viagra falls nyc reviews prednisone and cefdinir donde puedo comprar cytotec en bogota colombia para que sirve inderal 10 mg does lasix come in 10mg tablets low t specialist in st louis mo best viagra alternative otc reset tablet generic a viagra do you need a prescription for viagra in mexico online clomid bestellen cialis generic buy without credit card buy laetrile tablets 500 mg metformin sex during clomid use viagra industry in ireland generic clomid success rate generic prednisone 10mg pack viagra generika rezeptfrei kaufen where europe buy viagra without prescription vibrox doxycycline reviews cialis o viagra generico vega sildenafil citrate tablets 100 inderal 10 mg indications for albuterol is viagra still patented in saudi arabia zithromax tablets 500mg price in india dapoxetine online review generic propecia price compare can you get in the sun while taking prednisone cialis daily use strength name buy viagra text buy viagra hemangioma in infants propranolol 40mg what time do i take viagra buy 40 mg accutane online liquid cialis proper dosges how to tell the difference between real viagra n fake accutane and hypothyroidism sildenafil generico brazil philippine cost of doxycycline 100mg amoxil whartisthebestin overnight safe viagra paypal accepted doxycycline available brands in chennai how long does viagra stays in the body cialis when to take it buy nolvadex kroger when to use lasix is cialis used to treat high blood pressure ci cipro garage for sale canadian prescription s cialis australian viagra indian sildenafil tablets 100mg viagra 25mg preis low dose accutane studies cialis 20 mg cost treat hyponatremia lasix can you pay for generic viagra with your hsa should doxycycline be taken on an empty stomach finasteride 1 mg en mexico cheap cialis in melbourne i took 40 milligrams of generic cialis benuron generico do viagra can i take two 5mg cialis is propecia otc in canada hvad er brand viagra whats comparable to clomid over the counter comprar viagra y cialis contrareembolso how much does 20mg cialis cost where can i find viagra in seoul female viagra holland barrett oppbygging av eukaryote generic viagra doxycycline to treat urinary tract infections generico do zovirax creme medicine premature ejaculation dapoxetine how long does it take to get accutane prescribed accidentally took 200 mg doxycycline lyme viagra recreational use how to generic finasteride 1mg vs propecia dosage les generiques du viagra for sale viagra dosage reviews cialis cost daily dose is viagra from india good effects of viagra on a healthy male sildenafil actavis 100 mg bestellen canada pharmacy buy viagra i purchased viagra generic cialis overnight novo lexin tab 500 mg metformin para que sirve el ciprofloxacino cinfa 500 mg buying clomid in germany buy zovirax in europe whats cheaper viagra or cialis acquistare cialis generico org doxycycline and dry eye treatment real cialis online price of cialis in philippines where i can by propecia in toronto alendronate versus generics for viagra where in melbourne can i buy viagra herbal viagra for women australia voglibose metformin brands in india how to take clomid 2013 cheap generi cviagra india non prescription viagra online uk next day delivery what is prednisone used for in people efectos secundarios ciprofloxacina 500 mg doxycycline as antimalarial dosage sildenafil tablets ip 100 mg recreational cost of 25 mg viagra how can i get clomid without prescription amoxihexal 1000 mg filmtabletten nebenwirkungen viagra generic form of zovirax can you take cialis with diabetes how many mg propecia should i take letrozole vs clomid pct for sale normal lab values for lasix buy inderal la 80 mg que causan las pastillas cytotec tadalafil in pflanzen buying viagra canadian metformin contraindicated in congestive heart failure Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Enough rope

Enough rope

datePosted on 10:34, June 23rd, 2011 by Lew

On Mike Hosking’s Newstalk ZB show this morning, a discussion of the gender pay gap and Catherine Delahunty’s bill on the topic — and an object lesson in not believing your own hype:

Alasdair Thompson [Employers & Manufacturers’ Association CEO]: “Let me get down to tin tacks here. It is unfortunate, if you like, that men and women are different –“
Helen Kelly [Council of Trade Unions President]: [incredulous laughter]
AT: “– they are. The fact is, women have babies, they take time out of their careers to have babies. Women have — look, I don’t like saying this, this is how contentious this is, but here’s a fact of life. If you really want to keep some statistics, look at who takes the most sick leave. Why do they take the most sick leave? Women do in general. Why? Because, ah, you know, once a month they have sick problems. Not all women, but some do. They have children that they have to take time off to go home and take leave of. Therefore their productivity — not their fault, it’s … it may be because they haven’t got it sorted out with their partners, where the partners take more responsibility for what happens outside work. There are all of these issues, and none of this is covered in these statistics that this bill wants to sort out. Now, I’m sorry, I don’t like saying these things because it sounds like I’m sexist, but it’s a fact of life.”
HK: “Sure does, Alasdair, I’m glad you said them, it’s fantastic. I let you go on that one.”

(Audio)

Helen Kelly played Alasdair Thompson like a harp here. For a start, his argument is bogus — as Kelly says, the figures don’t back it up in the general case, and where they do back it up there’s a host of confounding variables. (For just one of many possible objections, since women already earn less than men for the same work, there’s an advantage at the margin where they retain the primary childcare responsibility, all else being equal. On the basis of this Thompson says they should be further penalised.)

But quite apart from the standard of the argument, Thompson ended up defending the indefensible in indefensible terms. It’s one thing to defend the indefensible in terms that seem reasonable, quite another to do so in terms that are repugnant. Rather than arguing the difference of interpretation and retaining the dignity of a Captain of Industry, a benevolent leader of men (and women) who cares about their wellbeing, he slipped into the worst sort of boss-man-splaining. This might work just fine in boardrooms where the interests of those present are aligned, but it’s not much good in the public sphere. He clearly realised this, but only once he had committed to it: his delivery was garbled and disjointed, clearly ad-hoc, and so heavily caveated that it’s hard to take any of it seriously.

But that’s what we must do. This guy is an experienced representative of New Zealand’s employers, speaking in his official capacity on a topic for which he had (or ought to have) prepared, in a mainstream media outlet. We are entitled to take him at his word, and we should thank him for telling us what he really thinks. And we should thank Helen Kelly for giving him such a plum opportunity to do so.

Update: Not one to do things by halves, Thompson has doubled — or, tripled down, with a press release arguing that women are paid less because they’re just not worth as much, and statements to the Herald blaming “socialists”, “Labour” and “unions” and claiming 90% support for his position. That number has now mysteriously vanished from the Herald’s story, and comments by readers of the National Business Review — Thompson’s natural constituency — are running 80-20 against him at the time of writing this update.

You could say he’s quadrupled down, even, since he’s now taken to twitter, responding to criticism and barbed quips with cut & pasted lines from his press release. A more epic fail is hard to envisage.

L

15 Responses to “Enough rope”

  1. Pablo on June 23rd, 2011 at 11:06

    That was great. Imagine being a female in his household. I find his comments running very close to those made by Singaporean employers when arguing against paid maternity leave (Singapore has an atrocious lack of regulations regarding maternity, to include no legal prohibitions on women being fired in the first 6 months of pregnancy). The whole “women are, errr, different” argument gets aired regularly in SG when employment issues are discussed, so given that it is used as a model by the NZ corporate elite, it is no surprise that ole’ Alisdair saw fit to rephrase it for local consumption.

    If this is indeed the mindset of the corporate elite, it is no wonder the country appears to be stagnating.

  2. Sanctuary on June 23rd, 2011 at 11:51

    “…Ms Delahunty said Mr Thompson’s ideas were “19th Century” and a possible breach of the Equal Pay Act 1972…”

    NINETEEN SEVENTY TWO.

    That was almost forty years ago. And still they live…

  3. moo on June 23rd, 2011 at 13:35

    Boy is he cranky. Must be that time of the month for Mr Thompson.

  4. jon on June 23rd, 2011 at 15:23

    The argument is easily settled. Add up what the employee earns the company while at work, subtract all the costs of paid days off divide what remains by the hours worked and then you are left with what the employee is actually worth.
    @pablo
    “…no wonder the country appears to be stagnating…”
    The country is stagnating because too many people are getting pay without producing a good. It’s basic reality.

  5. Pablo on June 23rd, 2011 at 16:00

    jon:

    Are you referring to those on the dole, public employees, teachers or service sector workers? I only mention these four categories as examples because you do not elaborate on what “producing a good” consists of. Those on the dole (which if I recall correctly are around 12 percent of the employable population) are non-producers or at least more consumers rather than producers of wealth. But what about those whose productivity outputs are not tangible or easily measured?

    Most employees do not earn companies anything. They add value to the product, but the earnings are determined by managers based on the rate of profit and the subtractions required to cover labour, marketing and input factor costs. Thus trying to calculate employee worth as the product of their individual earnings contribution minus the costs of their (non-legislated) days off is a useless exercise.

    It might do the corporates some good to ponder the question of “morale” and its impact on the workplace. It may not be tangible or measurable but it sure has a lot to do with relative productivity–something the “new management” theorists seem to have missed.

  6. Anita on June 23rd, 2011 at 18:53

    I was impressed by the fact that he doesn’t just express a rather odd view about menstruation, but he seems to be saying that men are lazy worthless layabouts who don’t pull their weight around the home or care for their children. Oh, and that men are incapable of actually doing those things without their women sorting them out.

    It may be a statement which reinforces discrimination about women, but it’s far more insulting about men. All you guys should be pleased to know that the EMA thinks your general selfish laziness is responsibility for our general poor productivity.

    I suspect he thought he was digging himself out of a hole when he said that :)

  7. Anita on June 23rd, 2011 at 19:13

    Worth watching the TV3 interview. It has bullying, a complete lack of self awareness, blind leaps from anecdata to … something, and free advice about what painkillers we should be using for period pain.

    And the Campbell Live interview with the epic, and totally justified, line by Mihingarangi Forbes of “you … stood in my face and yelled at me”

  8. Lew on June 23rd, 2011 at 20:07

    Yeah. Full uncut (20+ minute) interviews are up now. Utterly gobsmacking.

    L

  9. […] at Kiwipolitico thinks it’s a good lesson in not believing your own hype, and certainly Helen Kelly’s got to […]

  10. Pablo on June 23rd, 2011 at 20:41

    Thanks Lew, for the link.

    I was going to make a comment about the interview but then again, it speaks for itself (without the bullying weirdness at the end that was aired later). Two thoughts, though.

    1) Note to National: you need to make Alisdair the spokesperson for the dangers of Kronic, ’cause no one in a position of semi-responsibility could be that high that early on booze alone.

    2) Informal poll: should Alisdair be allowed to drive heavy machinery more than once a month?

  11. […] Newstalk ZB’s interviews with Thompson, KiwiPolitico’s transcript of part of the initial interview, TV3′s full interview with Thompson. The start of the TV3 interview has some very special […]

  12. Sanctuary on June 23rd, 2011 at 21:47

    Translate him into Arabic and play it over Libyan state radio and see if anyone can tell the difference from the good Colonel’s original stuff.

  13. Jimmy on June 24th, 2011 at 02:02

    Well said AT! ITs the truth and it hurts…hear the PC squeal in faux outrage at someone saying it like it is.

  14. […] at Kiwipolitico thinks it’s a good lesson in not believing your own hype, and certainly Helen Kelly’s got to be […]

  15. Danny on June 24th, 2011 at 11:45

    Hi,

    I also hated the comment that he made about the new solo dad. How he was about to cut his hours / pay, because he had lost his partner, and now was rasing a child alone.
    Of course his work rate will drop!! Where is the compassion in this work environment??
    Morale at this work place must be at an all time low today (and I thought mine was bad !!)

    Anyway .. thanks for Media 101 …

    Danny

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: