cytotec induction process in math german hunting terrier for sale in uk zithromax is there a natural herb that works like viagra the best homemade replacement of viagra sildenafil 50 mg tomar mujer viagra 50mg tablets price in pakistan can you take doxycycline with valtrex zoloft obsessive compulsive disorder user reviews viagra fast co uk doxycycline hyclate used for pneumonia buy sildenafil send by lithuania agora viagra online prospect cipro quin 500 mg metformin 1000 mg no prescription dapoxetine medicine in pakistan halal food distributor of viagra in pakistan propecia priceline propecia tab 1mg how to take clomid after sustanon secondo ciclo clomid in cinta o quasi can viagra cause rectal bleeding bijwerkingen prednisone 5 mg is 25mg of zoloft safe with ibuprofen viagra facts and price zovirax 800 mg pregnancy announcement buy claravis accutane treatment prednisone hereisthebestin no prescription nolvadex 20 mg can it cause hair loss ofteno prednisolone 20 mg what is zithromax z pak finasteride cost rite aid viagra por online en puerto rico tranexamic acid in ortho surgery specialists viagra falls canada hotels sildenafil citrate 100mg using paypal how much time tadalafil 20 effects in women body is it safe for a 30 year old to take viagra costo di una scatola di cialis dapoxetine uk boots liquid viagra gel 50 mg prednisone taper dose finasteride dergboadre australia buying viagra over counter boots priligy distributor in malaysia does cialis make you last longer lasix guercmorteo for sale viagra brand names in pakistan cialis 20 mg shoppers drug mart safety of ciprofloxacin in pregnancy can i take folic acid and clomid can i take clomid on day 8 viagra for ed propecia cheap canadian viagra online bestellen wonder clomid tablets do they work lasix 500 mg water bills cheap alternative to propecia metformin role in pregnancy can i take cipro with doxycycline viagra cost 50mg vs 100mg que es el nolvadex sildenafil citrate tablets cenforce 100 online viagra in phoenix blood in the spurm after takeing viagra medikinet 40 mg bijwerkingen prednisone buy ayurvedic viagra can i buy viagra in pharmacy online cialis daily use viagra online drugs is doxycycline safe in kids for acne viagra sale 50mg accutane 20 mg every other day galvus e metformin 500 mg is 750 mg of zithromax enough to cure chlamydia ciprofloxacin 250 mg comprimidos stadium in irelandcialis optive colirio generico de cialis extended release metformin generic price ampicillin concentration in lb plates with kanamycin heladeras kohinoor donde comprar viagra prednisolone 50 mg pferd abrasives can zoloft work in two weeks acquistare viagra online con postepay pelvic pain specialists in minnesota clomid and depression in men how bad for you is prednisone ordering viagra on internet acheter viagra sans ordonnance au canada cost of 20 500mg amoxil tabs in ireland order accutane no prescription does amoxil forte come in capsules cialis for men in calgary purchase cialis online cheap australia viagra from canada 2 day delivery dosulepin 150 mg viagra pcos clomid twins acquistare viagra originale online coupons buy cialis with dapoxetine priligy costo no prescription cialis at walmart fraudulent online sellers of tadalafil la sportiva trango womens reviews on cialis viagra montreal buy classifieds java identifier expected generics for accutane quitting propecia after 3 months aurochem brand viagra and dapoxetine glumetza metformin cost finasteride avodart comparison viagra substitute made in india by sun pharma im on clomid when should i take a hpt prices of viagra in slovakia can you buy clomid at gnc comprar cialis farmacia sin receta how much viagra can be taken in one time 50 mg of clomid a day for men can i take doxycycline and go in the sun difference between propecia 1mg or 5 mg purchase retail viagra in dhaka how to write prescriptions for cialis overnight viagra delivery cleveland ohio 40 mg once a day accutane baby doxycycline for chlamydia reviews of fifty medsafe data sheet metformin 500mg where in dublin can i get viagra cialis online italiano come usare priligy usa generic viagra made in united states r8order viagra com can you buy cialis at walgreens cialisis best time of day to take for better results tachipirina 1000 mg dosaggio viagra does deltasone get you high nolvadex and clomid for pct wikipedia cialis 20 mg metformin hcl er 500 mg tb24 prescription obat kuat cialis 50 mg viagra look alike pills for sale order clomid now tadalafil prices uk palivizumab cost per dose of viagra where can i buy cialis in toronto doxycycline monohydrate reviews viagra in spain how much can you take clomid while on period where can i buy cheap cialis ranbaxy equivalent to viagra order online synulox palatable tablets 500 mg metformin ritalin and zoloft ringing in ears zithromax antibiotic medication ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablets information the cost of cialis at walgreens priligy 30mg e 60 mg adderall pink viagra sale generic 5 mg cialis joypox dapoxetine review what is the average mg of clomid diflucan manufacturer india viagra 200mg kaufen how to use viagra medicine in hindi buy viagra online without rasitol 20 mg prednisone what is professional viagra buy cialis 20 mg vs 40 mg viagra cost per pill without insurance is viagra safe if you have hep c bromfenex generic viagra ciprofloxacin 250 mg indicaciones de transfusion finasteride topical use clomid really tired sildenafil costo in farmacia benavides comprar cipro xr 1000 line prescriptions viagra price of doxycycline malaria tablets united states cialis coupons viagra tablets in india and cost in rupees cialis 5 mg gabapentin liquid dapoxetine dose donde puedo comprar cytotec en culiacan zwanger na clomid 50 mg how long does clomid take to produce sperm 50 oder 100 mg viagra how much does genuine cialis cost 20 mg canada phsrmacy haplochromis obliquidens female viagra cost of clomid medication para que sirbe almaximo sildenafil 50 mg why use clomid after steroids son buenas las cialis de 5 mg buy fluconazole diflucan can clomid cause hyperthyroidism propecia 2mg day viagra price in saudia do they sell viagra in dubai legitamite place in oklahoma city to buy cialis cheapest place to buy viagra in scotland diflucan over the counter singapore flyer viagra how it works donde puedo comprar pastillas cytotec merida yucatan letrozole and nolvadex for sale highest mg of accutane viagra for people in their 20s viagra in jordan generic viagra 100mg reviews of fifty what is the meaning of the bathtubs in the cialis amoxil rowcmoadreders price tadalafil with dapoxetine canada clomid for unexplained infertility ciprobay 750 mg online viagra real cialis generic soft tabs doxycycline mono 50 mg acne clear what colour is viagra uk tadalafil 10 mg dapoxetine doxycycline 100 mg for yeast infection how long before cialis kicks in 5 mg can doxycycline be taken with probiotics tranxilium 5 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin prix viagra europe i have stents in my heart can i take viagra metformin inhibits hepatic gluconeogenesis in mice blueberry 100 sildenafil usage mexmeds4you clomid for sale viagra will get in uae can i buy clomid over the counter in johannesburg viagra uk prescription charges viagra birmingham uk alumpak donde comprar viagra how much is diflucan from pfizer in manila viagra benefits health in urdu cost of accutane in uk buy clomid for men south africa doxycycline and diflucan 100 mg 3 for yeast infection purchase cialis soft tabs sildenafil citrate usp can taking viagra cause blood in a mans seman propecia 5mg price strong sleeping pills over the counter uk viagra do i need a prescription for clomid in the bahamas viagra for sale chingford about tadalafil 20mg canada cialis once daily review how long does it take doxycycline to expire viagraand callis in england used toyota yaris for sale in uk zithromax ims health brasil genericos do viagra diflucan 50 mg polvo pain in ovaries while on clomid will accutane get rid of my acne forever finasteride 1 mg alternate days viagra lowest priced seljaci viagra online come comprare il viagra in farmacia is it ok to take cialis with antibiotics prednisone liquid inactive ingredients underdose of clomid for sale viagra online international shipping cialis generic cheapest indian ayurvedic equivalent of viagra does my boyfriend take viagra clomid dergboadre online clomid 150mg stories cetonax generico do viagra can you take ibuprofen with viagra propecia use in women walmart price.for.viagra what is ciprofloxacin 500 mg taken for ciprofloxacino 500 mg para la garganta what is the average price for real viagra zoloft reviews premature ejaculation ampicillin dilution 100 mgml is it safe to take pepto bismol while on metformin best viagra 300 mg zovirax pills for cold sores reviews on wen accutane in michigan generic for glucophage 500mg viagra generic india cipla prednisolone 20 mg ruminal parakeratosis viagra canada cost coverage ciprofloxacin for std 500 mg buy viagra howdotofound doxycycline hyclate 20mg tablets for acne order prednisone without perscription in u.s. not getting pregnant with clomid liquid tamox vs nolvadex for gynecomastia how do i get a private prescription for clomid the best way to use cialis where can i buy viagra in cabo can you buy lasix over the counter viagra chemist mumbai canadian class action accutane prednisone online credit card now prednisone 5 mg low dose over counter drug like viagra viagra farmacia salcobrand canada accutane female viagra austria cheapest sildenafila 25 mg of zoloft best time of day to take metformin for pcos how much is the cost of cialis no insurance purchase amoxil suspension how many viagras in 24 hours masterbate beforr viagra viagra from costco pharmacy is lasix safe in breastfeeding ordering cialis viagra special delivery uk what happens if you forget to take your accutane vibramycin chemical name is clomid legal to buy online common side effect from liquid diflucan in toddlers ampicillin sulbactam high dose result if girls mix viagra in drinks and drink como pedir viagra en la farmacia japans mhlw approved 367 generics for viagra zithromax pediatricosteopathyofmarin buy dapoxetine now uk viagra 25 mg opinioni clomid private prescription can u buy viagra over the counter in sydney accutane cost ontario oraxim 6 cpr riv 500 mg metformin fast delivery of zithromax without a prescription does viagra help in pregnancy viagra online paypal uk contact zovirax price walmart price of zovirax ointment 5 where can i get nolvadex or clomid in the uk prednisone 10 mg tab cad can i get propecia from my doctor how long does 100mg of viagra last viagra mexico price how much doxycycline should i take for acne cut cialis pills in half why does cialis last so long in the body were to get viagra in delhi on counter can i take clomid with a cyst propecia cause grey hair cialis pills co uk metapro xl 50 mg viagra new balance 750 v1 womens reviews on cialis finasteride 0.5 mg every other day how to buy tadalafil in india yahoo answer what time of the day should you take clomid medication to counteract prednisone zovirax ointment usa tradolan 50 mg biverkningar av metformin lb medium ampicillin viagra in neonates is finasteride in nioxin pills where to get viagra in soho london buy cialis online no prescription usa 3 400 a8 25 mg of zoloft w580 main fs y custom generic cialis cialis right dose accessrx cialis canada puedo comprar viagra sin receta en uruguay tratamiento where to buy propranolol online much does cialis cost walmart viagra ireland for women non prescription viagra walmart cost what time do i take cialis viagra 50 mg prix pharmacie tadalafil online 2.5 mg is doxycycline used for sore throat viagra available prescription uk how much cialis should i take daily viagra pricing 100mg walmart order viagra cheapest where can i viagra i buy trustan generic cialis viagra vs tadalafil can you buy viagra in paharmacy in dubai airport the cost of propecia merck get viagra in nassau is viagra used for female use viagra 25 mg ervaringen fluocinonide cream 0 1 generic cialis priligy rowcmoadreders for sale avete usato priligy side viagra dose for pah segurex 50 sildenafil 50mg review where to buy viagra in lahore pfizer viagra price 4 pack viagra 50mg buying 20 mg prednisone for asthma cialis 5mg le prix can 250 mg of metformin kill me clomid and iui experiences in life finasteride 1 mg in pakistan is there a generic ciprodex canadian pharmacy cialis with dapoxetine metformin over the counter equivalent viagra tablets name for women in india nolvadex review bodybuilding address for cipro in cape town is diphenhydramine in zoloft can you take herbal viagra on a plane nolvadex get rid gynecomastia cost ampicillin allergy symptoms safe take accutane adderall preco generico do viagra 100 or 125 mg viagra should i take propecia herb names in tamil language viagra dosage vs cialis diflucan price malaysia ciprofloxacin ratio 500 mg nolvadex hereisthebestin discount best way to get viagra from my dr best time take viagra dinitrato isosorbide 10 mg prednisone 5mg propecia in india when to take clomid after test e urology specialist of oklahoma in tulsa ok cheapest viagra pfizer uk best deals brand name viagra viagra mg doses wo kann ich viagra online bestellen kroger pharmacy prices cialis metformin hcl er ter 500 mg amoxicillin is tadalafil safe to take prolonged usage of metformin reviews on viagra gold ampicillin in mice buy viagra for women online india priligy online pharmacy uk valium buy sildenafil citrate 100mg uk tadalafil online overnight delivery cytotec el costo zoloft falling in love cheapest viagra cialis au the role of ehr specialist in managing cpoe order viagra online pay with a check cialis over the counter drug kann man viagra in budapest kaufen zovirax cold sore cream buy how to get rid of acne without accutane how long does 5 day zithromax stay in your system zithromax azithromycin buy how to buy viagra tablets 40 mg dose of cialis supra generic viagra buy natural tadalafil thuoc cuong duong viagra for sale how much is viagra under the fep discount drug program prednisone 180 mg ginecoside tem generico de cialis lekovi za potenciju cialis cost buy cialis in fort lauderdale priligy maroc prix feprazone generico de cialis is it safe to stop taking accutane i split my 200 mg diflucan tablet in half evonik werbespot viagra online propranolol 10 mg usage prednisone 90 mg can you take two 5mg. cialis instead of one 10 mg nike free run 5 0 v4 womens reviews on cialis where online can i buy genuine clomid tablets qualquer um pode comprar viagra original betelnuss kaufen wirkung viagra cialis in bangalore medical shops oxytetracycline 500 mg metformin causas consecuencias cytotec how much potassium to take with lasix 40 mg viagra online prices ukulele how well is socialism working in venezuela accutane buy online uk dresses cheap english viagra order viagra jelly online phenibut review good looking loser cialis how can i get 100 mg viagra with out a prescription pfizer viagra spam cialis canada .99 prednisone through mailorder treatment of priapism due to viagra availability of viagra in bangalore getting acne after accutane finasteride and alfuzosin together what is the use of finasteride tablets venda de anfepramona 60 mg prednisone generic viagra 100 mg in usa viagra effects how long diclofenaco cinfa 50 mg comprimidos viagra viagra feminino onde comprar fibra is viagra sold over the counter in phoenix az viagra australia supplies take prednisone once or twice a day is best buy viagra online in canada from trusted sites where to buy viagra canada generic cialis india add message where i find viagra in bangladesh sildenafil 25 mg reviews female viagra uk pharmacy vhdl if statement generic cialis doxycycline length of use cheap pfizer viagra 100mg ciprofloxacin gases in air can i take cialis with testosterone injections mdprice.net viagra 20 mg prednisone every other day viagra best dosage of melatonin Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Eye Candy, Window Dressing and Deep Pockets.

Eye Candy, Window Dressing and Deep Pockets.

datePosted on 15:06, July 29th, 2014 by Pablo

I came back from six weeks abroad to see the beginning of the Internet Party’s “Party party” launches. It leaves me with some questions.

It seems that what the Internet Party has done is this. Using Kim Dotcom’s wallet as a springboard, it has selected a candidate group largely made up of attractive metrosexuals (only a few of whom have political experience), recruited as window dressing a seasoned (and also attractive) leftist female as party leader (even though she has no experience in the IT field), and run a slick PR campaign featuring cats that is long on rhetoric and promises and short on viable policies. The stated aim is to get out the apathetic youth vote and thereby reach the three percent electoral threshold.

The strategic alliance with the Mana Party makes sense, especially for Mana. They get additional resources to more effectively campaign for at least two electorate seats, especially given that it looks like the Maori Party is moribund and the Maori electoral roll will be more contestable even if Labour tries to reclaim its historical support in it. The Internet Party gets to coattail on Mana’s activism and the presence of relatively seasoned cadres on the campaign trail. Between the two, they might well reach the five percent threshold, although current polling suggests something well less than that. The lack of political experience in the Internet Party could be problematic in any event.

But I am still left wondering what the IP stands for and how it proposes to effect change if its candidates are elected. We know that the IP came about mostly due to Dotcom’s hatred of John Key. But Dotcom is ostensibly not part of the IP, which makes his attention-grabbing presence at its public events all the more puzzling. Leaving aside Dotcom’s background and baggage for the moment, imagine if major financial donors stole the stage at Labour, National or Green Party rallies. What would the reaction be? Plus, hating on John Key is not a policy platform, however much the sentiment may be shared by a good portion of the general public (and that is debatable).

Giving free internet access to all seems nice, but how and who is going to pay for that? Wanting to repeal the 2013 GCSB Act and withdraw from the 5 Eyes intelligence network sounds interesting, but how would that happen and has a cost/benefits analysis been run on doing so?  Likewise, opposition to the TPP seems sensible, but what is its position on trade in general? The policies on the environment and education seem laudable (and look to be very close to those of the Greens), and it is good to make a stand on privacy issues and NZ independence, but is that enough to present to voters?

More broadly, where does IP stand on early childhood education, pensions, occupational health and safety, immigration, transportation infrastructure, diplomatic alignment, defense spending or a myriad of other policy issues? Is it anything more than a protest party? Nothing I have seen in its policy platform indicates a comprehensive, well thought roadmap to a better future. In fact, some of the policy statements are surprisingly shallow and in some cases backed with citations from blogs and newspapers rather than legitimate research outlets.

Is having attractive candidates, catchy slogans and a narrow policy focus enough for IP to be a legitimate political contender?

I have read what its champions claim it to be, and have read what its detractors say it is. I am personally familiar with two IP candidates and have found them to be earnest people of integrity and conviction who want more than a narrow vendetta-driven agenda opportunistically married to an indigenous socialist movement. I would, in fact, love to see it succeed because I think that the political Left in NZ needs more varied forms of representation in parliament than currently available.

So my question to readers is simple: is the IP a viable and durable option in the NZ political landscape, or is it doomed to fail?

One thing is certain. If dark rumours are correct, the government has some unpleasant surprises for the IP in the weeks leading to the election. If that happens, it may take more than Glenn Greenwald and his revelations about John Key and the GCSB to redeem the IP in the eyes of the voting public. I would hope that both Dotcom and his IP candidates are acutely aware of what could be in store for them should the rumours prove true, and plan accordingly.

6 Responses to “Eye Candy, Window Dressing and Deep Pockets.”

  1. Daniel on July 29th, 2014 at 17:29

    For a political party built from scratch in the last six months or so there are bound to be a few gaps in policy and personality.

    When National was formed out of the ashes of the Reform party in the 30s I doubt that would have resembled the fully formed party that it is today or been able to articulate policy as it does now.

    It’s true that the impetus behind the party seems like a marriage of convenience for revenge or short term political gain but what political party forms for altruistic reasons (if I remember correctly National came about through an alliance with the Reform and another party at the time).

    Also as pointed out there are committed people in the party who have a genuine vision and it will be those people which will determine the party’s future course and successes if it gets into Parliament.

    Finally the idea that there is a disenfranchised voter base out there waiting for a party that better represents its interests has a lot of merit. Lowered voting numbers and lack of interest by younger and marginalised voters who see no value in the same ol political hacks in the same ol parties with the same ol agendas but may vote for a party that better represents and better articulates their wishes and values is both valid and viable.

    Democratic politics is all about representation and I myself will not be voting for the party but I know people who will or who have considered it and the theme is all the same. They know about KDC and his dislike of Key and they know that it’s not covering all the bases but no party come election time can cover all bases of a potential manifesto credibly so why not stick to what are the key issues for those who they wish to appeal to. Political resonance is often powerful enough to trump more cerebral analysis in the minds of voters if the issues are strongly felt.

    With current voting levels around the mid 80% (correct me if I am wrong) that leaves a decent sized block of people who could be the backers for the party in the future.

    I think the issue lies not with the party getting votes first time around but more what will happen if it does and how it will go about dealing with being in parliament. If the party ends up selling out its voter base (perceived or otherwise) for some short term gain (ala the Maori party, the lib dems in the UK or Winston back in 96) then there is not likely to be a second chance under that brand.

    Colin Craig has shown that if you lose you can keep on until the next election if you have the funds and KDC is not short on that so the issue is less one of credibility at this stage and more around how they get the votes and what will they do with them if they end up in parliament.

    There are examples in Pol science of people tapping into disenfranchised voter bases (Obama in 2008 and McGovern in 1972 spring to mind the most easily) and while they did have well-oiled and tactical party machines behind them the driver was not to sway older established voters as much as it was to vitalise younger and disenfranchised potential voters. That is clearly the game IP is playing.

    If IP is playing the long game or at least has some foresight then this discussion will have already been had but as always the variables of a particular electorate (in this cases NZ) needs to be well known and played to make things work.

    The proof of this pudding will come when the votes are all in and counted.

  2. Pablo on July 29th, 2014 at 17:55

    Thanks Daniel, that was a useful analysis. I guess my misgivings have to do with the short-livedness of the party, the relative inexperience of most of its candidates and the narrowness/shallowness of its core policy concerns. I would have thought that a longer term development program, pointing to 2017, was more likely to result in success in that election and beyond, but perhaps this is a case of learning as they go, including losing to win in the long game. The question is: will IP survive this election in order to play the long game, especially if Dotcom is not in the picture?

  3. Daniel on July 30th, 2014 at 13:44

    To be fair, I have probably the same misgivings as you do regarding IP and I struggle to pull away from the analysis of personality that seems to be the main focus of much political reporting these days but from a straight issue position and campaign approach (and I admit that such a thing is not really possible with a political analysis but for a more genuine Pol Sci analysis here why not) the IP does cover or appear to want to cover those gaps which are appearing in the NZ political landscape just as other parties like Mana and the Greens have coalesced around particular core issues.

    Your point about Dotcom being in or out of the picture is probably a key factor in this as if it really does turn out to be a vehicle for his own gaols then the party will fail or it will be forced to expel him from it to save itself.

    I would guess that funding may be the driving issue in the long run, as the Conservatives seem to have shown. As long as a party without any members in parliament can maintain some stream of funding then it can remain active and carry on its agenda (whatever that may be) until the next election and then try again. How a party does that without I don’t know but I freely admit that I don’t know enough about such things to say that it can or cannot be done.

  4. Phil Sage on July 31st, 2014 at 00:47

    Daniel, good commentary and a perfect freudian slip “…a vehicle for his own gaols”

    IP seem to be cannibalising the Green vote. My view is that there are far too many inherent contradictions for longer term success. I agree with Daniel that they would not recover from selling out their supporters.

    Despite having more than 10% of the vote the Greens have never been part of government. Pablo, Why do you think it is better to have more small parties when the total number of MPs’ is only 120~?

  5. Pablo on July 31st, 2014 at 11:39

    Phil:

    I like the wider diversity of representation MMP potentially offers (even if that representation is not always high quality, as in the case of the Maori Party, ACT, United Future or NZ First, to say nothing of that freak Colin Craig). I also think that it forces flexibility in large party policy platforms as they seek coalition partners.

    What I do not like about MMP is that it also leads to splintering, which is often the result of personal venality and opportunism on the part of politicians unwilling to participate in united front-style political partnerships or remain as members of larger parties. My specific concern in this regard is with the splintering of Left representation to the advantage of a more united Right.

  6. Daniel on August 1st, 2014 at 17:45

    Phil:

    Good spotting but less a Freudian slip and more bad spelling.

    I have a few thoughts about the coming election and thought I might share them here given the discussion.

    With the recent jump by Labour and corresponding slip by the Nats the stage is set for what could be a wild ride come polling day.

    If those numbers stay close or even closer then all manner of strange alliances may spring into being.

    And this is where, in an MMP environment, things will get very interesting with tactical voting and all the rest. Also this is the environment where an extra seat or two can make all the difference and that’s up for grabs for all manner of contenders, or at least that’s what they think.

    So the minor party polling is now open for business and each must have their plans and goals.

    ACT is undoubtedly going to try for Epsom again and I would like to think that the voters there may have had enough but if they voted for them last time I have trouble imagining them turning away now just because of JB being charged in court.

    Conversely the rational part of me wants to say that the Conservatives may have enough to get something but the gut feeling is it will be always a bridesmaid for Colin Craig as no deal from National for him.

    The difference between these two outcomes reflects what ACT and the Conservatives really mean to Nationals strategists and that includes any comments made by each party’s respective leaders. ACT reflects a more purer version of what National wishes it could be, and I have heard that comparison more than enough times to thinks it’s more than just political hyperbole.

    The Conservatives, on the other hand, Colin Craig and his comments aside or included, reflect something that even National is not willing to touch. Think about that for a second, the “economic rationalism” and “One Nationalism” that ACT represents is fully acceptable to National but Colin and whatever he represents is not. Craig and his ambiguous representation for the supposed moral majority in NZ has more than enough of the wrong stuff for even National to consider getting into bed with. That in itself is a powerful indicator of what kind of calculus the party is working as noted above the gap between parties always closes as the election approaches and Key was recently telling supporters not to get complacent when Labour was wallowing at 20% indicates that he knew that it would come down to one small party or another as having a small but crucial number of seats to allow the Nats to govern without too much worry in their third term.

    Craig then will really need to have to get on his knees if he wants to win as praying is the only chance he now has.

    In the middle sits the Peter Deune and his one man party. Short of a miracle, and Colin Craig may already be asking for that so let’s assume it won’t happen, Peter will get back in and continue his support of national if they win. No more to be said there except to note that I always considered that seat open for spoiling candidates but maybe that’s just me be malicious.

    Winston Peters is the twisted and kinky Doppelganger of Peter Deune (given the reverse of the Peter in the titles as the giveaway). He is what Peter wishes he could be, the aging rock star of NZ politics with his also aging fan base and nostalgia appeal. To be sure Winston always gives good show and also to be sure he will squeeze every last drop out of whoever comes a calling should NZ First get over the 5% or a seat. The problem for Winston is that his decision not to work with race based parties puts him at odds with some who might also come into the mix should the Nats win. How that works out is dependent on the elections big winner.

    Next up it’s the Maori party. To be honest I don’t know how well they will do given their time with National and Mana’s alliance with KD so despite claims that they can win all Maori seats there seems to be enough spoiler factor to make for an interesting race. Mana, now charged up and ready to go, has a new party machine and political war chest to take into battle so all bets are off.

    The Greens, well what can I say. They have a very pure strain of politics and may hold a big part of the key to Labour getting back in. An argument I had recently with a mate was that labour did need to accommodate the greens more than Labour was really willing to do. My Mates position was that the greens had no one else to play with should coalition time come and therefore would have to suck it up and go red no matter what. This is true but my argument was that the greens might be able to leverage a lot more out of Labour than they would normally give. It’s not hard to imagine the Pavlovian level of salivation among Cunlife and Co at the prospect of getting into government and then the sudden turning off of the drool tap as they realise that the 12 to 15% that the greens are loaning to them to get them over the line come with some heavy conditions. What those are I don’t know but the delicate fission seen between the two parties at times belies something deeper but I don’t know what. If I had to guess it’s the one thing that Labour is putting off thinking about until after the election and should that miracle occur (given the level of people getting on their knees here I think the big G might be busy between now and polling) and the one thing that the Greens are thinking about right here and right now. Come the day after polling we will see.

    And final IP. I left them to last as right now I don’t think they really going to cannibalise the Green vote (sorry Phil) as while they do appear to have a similar mix of idealism in them the IP are clearly gearing their appeal to tap into that now identified but possibly untappable “unrepresented” segment of the electorate which they are basing their hopes on.

    The Green voters I know are mostly comfortable middle class liberals not fire brand radicals or disposed youth or whatever label you wish to attach to this demographic. No I think IP can and will pick up votes from a number of areas and if youth can be brought into play in enough numbers then this might be enough to give them some momentum. I am aware of the old idea that youth often vote in the same manner as their parents but that is less a truism and more a general observation. NZ politics at this time under MMP shows that while the right seems monolithic compared to the left these assessments are more around generational groupings than other factors and while it’s not the springbok tour there is enough dissent in the air to fuel IP and it’s not all coming from the left.

    The trick here is IP being able to live up to its name and promise. If it becomes the KD show or another bandwagon of old school radicals then kiss goodbye any chance of getting anywhere. But first time parties with open goals and untested manifestos, at least in NZ, have all sorts of potential.

    NZ First (and Social Credit to some extent) is a classic example of selling a message (in their case opposition to National) and then blowing it completely (less social credit here) by siding with them to form a government. In many ways it’s what built the Winston brand but also what completely ruined the actual party in the minds of many voters come ever trusting him again.

    The unhappiness with spying laws, the national broadband thing and a general lack of seeing the potential offered by the internet means that a shrewd party plan could drag in more than enough across the political spectrum to the 5% with a clear message (read Obama Hope and Change) and then be in a position to be part of a government if national does not make it. Again as I have said this is a hard game to play and it relies of not selling out for short term gain and that assessment lies in the hands of the party leaders. IP is a political marriage between possibly/probably disparate bedfellows with KD as the somewhat cherubic (and suspect) priest and how long the honeymoon lasts is anyone’s guess.

    The overall for all of this is that the election is less a sure thing for National, and Key knows this, and more open season than many would ever guess. Behind all of this is the slow change that MMP has given to NZ politics by allow for the smaller groupings that would have been buried inside the big two under FPP to go it on their own under MMP. I know a lot of people dislike that but the idea of NZ still under FPP and still stuck with just two parties blows my mind in a really bad way.

    That slow change that has been simmering away for near 20 years and possibly longer is the herald of the approaching shift in the sheer demographics of NZ politics. The tectonic change if you will that shake up the political landscape. National may come to represent the main majority of voters in NZ for the moment (but I doubt that will last) and may form the next government but the sheer number of other parties now able to get or gain seats or votes means that its no longer just the straight one two that FFP had and more now a much longer game being played. In some ways Peter Deune is the best representative of this as he has walked the line for a long time inside government.

    Anyway it’s a rant I know but I do stand by my somewhat half-baked analysis (its Friday and its late) and I want to go for a drink.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: