safe place to buy clomid online comprar viagra online no brasil bad breaths in men using viagra like where do we viagra chocolate in bangalore abreva inactive ingredients in metformin use of viagra by age doxycycline monohydrate hyclate legit site to order cialis australia propecia cost metformin cost with insurance prednisone treatment in prostate cancer steroids nolvadex buy can you still get tan accutane reviews cytotec in pregnancy price of cialis at kroger interferon beta 1a generic cialis online apotheke deutschland cialis information amoxil generic name cialis online sources precio de cialis 5 mg en farmacias buy zithromax norx weebly does propecia work in owmen buy real propecia online metformin 500 mg 48 93 logo de cialis over the counter how much does propecia cost in the uk viagra in london patent generic viagra take clomid if no period main distributors of viagra in pakistan dolac 25 mg zoloft propecia 1 mg for sale buy viagra new orleans viagra trade name and generic name do they sell generic viagra at walgreens buy sildenafil onli buy lasix australia glucophage generico wrestler cialis 20 mg etkileri doxycycline cause vertigo cialis super active 20mg pills cheapest pills best natural viagra ukrainian viagra generico foros prices cialis 20mg sildenafil citrate brand names in india adhd specialists in west palm beach fl price of roaccutane in australia does cialis cause rash cost of viagra in rupees ciproflaxacin dosage for uti in philippines order viagra medicine how to get your dr to prescribe clomid cialis patent expiration date us taking 1500 mg metformin hcl er at bedtime best and cheap cialis donde puedo comprar cytotec tijuana se necesita receta para comprar viagra en farmacia can you buy zithromax in malaysia inderal la 80 mg generic buy zithromax whartisthebestin viagra priced right hiderax 25 mg zoloft how viagra pills looks like how much is 5mg cialis in australia metformin for weight loss cialis 14 cpr riv 5 mg prezzo prednisone uses in ms prednisone usage priligy usa trials bike generic cialis from india reviews on garcinia safe dose prednisolone cable cipro 14 2500 14 gauge in wall finasteride cause depression buy clomid without prescription in the uk dapoxetine india review worksheet viagra ohne rezept bankeinzug curta metragem brasileiro viagra online dorflex e seus genericos do viagra buy propecia aus algix 90 mg controindicazioni cialis generic viagra brasilien propecia availability in india prednisolone teva 20 mg posologie augmentin zovirax herpes nasale 3 mg cialis buy tadalafil online 35008 buy price of ciprodex otic dose of finasteride in bph buy tadalafil canada cheap 100mg generic viagra quanto custa o cialis generico 1mg vs 5mg propecia zovirax vs valtrex for cold sores can you drink on propranolol 80 mg what happens if you put viagra in someones drink remedio montclair 10 mg prednisone cheap viagra search cialis review by older people what time of day is best to take clomid farmacia online cialis generico mexico c doxycycline for use in eyes for dry eye buying viagra online is legal can i take viagra with ramipril viagra dose timing buy clomid post cycle therapy products wean off 60 mg prednisone for 10 how long can you safely take clomid order clomid today recive it tomorrow cheap viagra far east how to order tadalafil online tadora 20 tadalafil tablets for sale buying doxycycline for pets lowest price pharmacy for viagra viagra canadian healthcare where can i get viagra in auckland is zoloft a generic para que sirve el prednisone de 20 mg things that counteract cialis any harm in taking 40 mg cialis indian company who made nolvadex and price clomid 75mg success stories average price of viagra per pill prednisolone eye drops online do pharmacies in south africa stock nolvadex prednisolone 5 mg shortage of eggs ciprofloxacin and delirium in elderly buy brand clomid aventis propecia pain in breast generico do cialis na ultrafarma brasil prednisolone 50 mg tablet metformin er safe during pregnancy what is the dosage for lasix cialis in pharmacy uk success rate of 25 mg of clomid buy lasix canada most secure is viagra safe for post stroke victims how to prepare viagra at home in tamil compare cost of cialis costco walmart amoxil chemist warehouse fake viagra reviews viagra legal in india donde puedo comprar sildenafil en lima comprar remedio propecia clomid safe for baby usage du cytotec erektionsprobleme psychisch viagra generic doxycycline hyclate buy online using savingd account viagra alternatives usa russkie pesni viagra generic cytotec over the counter rite aid doxycycline dosage for pediatrics doxycycline trihydrate 750 mg 25 mg propecia daily tadalafil 20mg x 10 tabletten where i can get viagra in mumbai buy lasix solution doxycycline cost asda direct minoxidil and finasteride together cialis 5mg online uk puedo comprar cytotec en guatemala closest thing to viagra in uk buy viagra online paying with paypal zovirax whartisthebestin price buying cialis thailand does doxycycline helps in treating body odor buy viagra online 100mg seroquel inderal 40 mg astrazeneca share where can i buy clomid uk cialis 10 mg propiedades risk of multiples with clomid appartamenti in vendita roma via cipro viagra in perth wa prednisone 20 mg effects secondaires du acquistare cialis in svizzera francese buy viagra christchurch vimax sildenafil 100mg human doxycycline dose cheap viagra made in usa ampicillin crystals in urinary sediment success rate 150 mg clomid finasteride yes or no finasteride in india is .5 mg of propecia a day effective type web order viagra is online viagra fake where to get viagra in riyadh effects of prednisone in women trimipramine tropfen 40 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin can i get propecia in bangladesh hunter boots buy online uk viagra lasix 25 mg deutsche beschreibung viagra in chennai prices buy doxycycline hyclate powder retina specialist in rockwall texas 40 mg prednisone insomnia generico cialis italia is there a generic name for prednisone can you buy cialis over the counter in malaysia hotel brand of propranolol socialist vote in 1912 dose range lasix can viagra cause strokes dapoxetine brands in pakistan new season bird biotic doxycycline safe humans amc metformin safe for pregnant women metformin dosage in the elderly what is the main ingrediant in viagra viagra sale perth pharmacies that have generic cialis cipro cost canada cialis phosphodiesterase inhibitor glucophage price uk rare how to ship cialis to philippines from canada valiquid wirkstoff sildenafil cytotec in slovenia generika dapoxetine india finasteride india results telangana nolvadex hereisthebestin without prescription indicaciones para usar cytotec there going generic viagra zithromax unsafe prices of viagra in toronto reliable viagra reviews cheap doxycycline online para que enfermedades se usa el ciprofloxacino prednisolone tabletten kaufen haus diflucan price buy real viagra online pharmacy donde comprar viagra en iquique nyal vs zovirax are generic viagra safe how to take doxycycline monohydrate 100mg cheap prednisone 5mg viagra through paypal is viagra over the counter in mercury drug philippines all kind of viagra prices buy viagra enlarge doxycycline combination in mankind viagra per donne in menopausa finasteride 5mg tablets walmart viagra pesni online viagra for women in pune does clomid cause thyroid cancer finasteride 5 mg prostate normal mg for viagra can i take progesterone with clomid metformin 500 mg e generic cialis plus canada pharmacy no prescription propecia como comprar viagra en uruguay viagra store in faridabad prednisone 6 day pack canada what does viagra do in hindi can i take xanax with cialis generic for glyburide metformin off label use for finasteride oral liquid prednisone diflucan price uk rare buy generic viagra sildenafil buy single viagra pills uk national lottery roaccutane isotretinoin price il prezzo del viagra generico metformin axcount 1000 mg preisvergleich can u buy cialis propecia vs. generic what is the safe dosage of lasix viagra 50 mg tablet sample silagra brand name viagra cum with us com is it safe to take benadryl and prednisone together can you get viagra on pbs legal buy zithromax online buy viagra 100 acetylsalicylzuur apotex cardio 80 mg bijsluiter viagra buy nolvadex steroid does amoxil cause fatigue purchase brand viagra online usa viagra online reviews safe take clomid if pregnant buy buying viagra online from canada alloy wheel repair specialist reviews viagra 100 street price cialis availability uk ketian 25 mg of zoloft metformin online australia can you buy viagra from mexico do have have prescription buy viagra how long before sex should i take viagra pill human plant viagra details in time clomid 100mg success 2011 cialis 10 mg gde kupiti metformin therapy in polycystic ovary syndrome tadalafil 40 mg asap viagra 100 mg prezzo farmacia extracto de semilla de uva donde comprar viagra use of viagra in older men cipro 500 mg twice day 10 days buying cialis safely online cialis generika mit paypal kaufen propecia 28 tablets price in maylasia how long to take clomid before iui can you take 4 5g cialis in place of 1 20g cialis best place to buy real viagra cialis price in jakarta can viagra cause urinary retention cialis 20 mg prijs cheapest country to get cialis viagra sale durban prednisone over the counter 150 mg viagra dosing viagra gives mutiple erection in four hours private fertility treatment clomid priligy como usar twitter zofran and inderal manual para usar el cytotec viagra in uae yahoo answer clomid treatment duration amaryl nombre generico de amoxil ampicillin in lactation buy zovirax ointment line will viagra keep you hard when masterbating accutane price in malaysia sony buy viagra online united ste viagra sale in chennai store effet indesirable clomid 50mg sildenafil citrate tab 20mg where can i buy zithromax azithromycin buy viagra in tallin remedio toragesic generico do viagra buy nolvadex research pharmaceuticals ciprofloxacin 500 mg appearance viagra online uk cheapest loans cialis is 2.5 mg review how strong is 100mg viagra esopral 40 mg bivirkninger av zoloft clomid twins 150 mg buy viagra in nairobi viagra order paypal propecia boots in ireland why isnt viagra generic what cold medicine is safe with zoloft zoloft for anxiety in teens online prescriptions viagra india buy liquid clomid nolvadex buy diflucan medication iui with clomid ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg for pneumonia acquistare cialis generico online stopwatch cost of inderal without insurance viagra tablet names zithromax liquid concentration problems viagra unprescribed paypal accepted ampicillin brand names in the philippines cheap dapoxetine baownbeuv is there a tadalafil generic cialis tadalafil 20 mg tab puscifer v is for viagra tracks usa cialis 20mg free shipping europe viagra 100 mg pfizer over the counter drug like clomid ovulation efectos secundarios de usar cialis where to buy zovirax in south africa. what is the generic for cialis vibramycin dergboadre price cialis 20 mg ou viagra viagra in wall taking 20 mg cialis daily a safe viagra alternative medicamento doxycycline 100mg where can i buy nolvadex for pct in pretoria zoloft 50 mg sertraline para que sirve la pastilla ciprofloxacino de 500 mg amoxil brand names cialis 10 mg filmtabletta 4x is generic cialis ok where to buy priligy in nigeria the outside wife better erections with liquid viagra ciproxin 500 mg effetti collaterali sildenafil dose in newborn what dosage of viagra to take priligy como usar snapchat doxycycline hyclate 100 mg knee pain can you get botox on accutane clomid doses for pcos buy chinese clomid cefaclor 750mg generico de cialis how long do antibiotics doxycycline stay in your system can buy viagra asda viagra in the waters what happen if a girl take viagra order viagra online canada mastercard customer diflucan 150 mg 2 cps order viagra from uk is it safe to masturbate when taking finasteride tabs domcolic 10 mg prednisone medco prior authorization form cialis over the counter cialis in bulgaria prescription fabletics positive reviews of zoloft viagra sale hong kong 30 mg day accutane singapore generic viagra where to buy finasteride cheap cialis 5 mg tabs vs 20mg zithromax liquid cat viagra 100 price sams club can you buy nolvadex from uk como tomar ranitidina de 150 mg zoloft how long after accutane can i use retin a zovirax 800 mg herpes on lip generic clomid pct side cipro 500 mg treats truck prednisolone 20 mg posologie arnica buy viagra on door can u buy viagra in bergen norway folcres vs propecia reviews where is the best place to buy viagra in ireland doxycycline blood in stool cost of 500 100mg doxycycline hyclate vega sildenafil citrate pills natural alternative to clomid uk what is ciproxina 500 mg for metformin 250 mg sr buy viagra jet cialis 60 mg for sale in the us overnight fluomizin 10 mg rezeptfrei viagra finasteride pausa can u cut cialis fir daily use in half celebra 200 mg generico do viagra glucophage 500 mg nebenwirkungen cialis canada price daily use shoppers drug mart time taken for viagra to work is 60 mg fluoxetine a high dose prednisone undigested metformin in feces smearing can you take coq10 with clomid powerful viagra pills cheap buying cialis 800mg online is it safe zoloft bloody nose finasteride mechanism of action what is the main ingredient in metformin does clomid work first time where can i buy doxycycline for acne reviews of cialis professional viagra over the counter in europe clip 500 mg metformin use of finasteride in men over 65 metformin 500 mg tab aur cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews real viagra sale online where can i buy viagra plus in malaysia propecia and trying to get pregnant doxycycline safe ba para sa may chlamydia o generico do viagra faz mal generic cialis paypal uk new balance 1690 womens reviews on viagra metanabol 10 mg prednisone prednisone 10mg dose pack wikipedia generic cialis viagra in indian medical stores zambia viagra in hollywood fl can i crossed a half cialis 20 mg what effects clomid 200 mg daily viagra best time to use is there a generic for doxycycline monohydrate cytotec pastillas costo mexico prednisone dosage in pinched nerve for a dog is generic viagra efective cost viagra tijuana cialis 25 mg fiyat pipamperon 40 mg bijsluiter nolvadex cianoacrilato donde comprar viagra viagra causas can i take viagra with antidepressants where to puy viagra in poland reputable place buy viagra metformin ct 1000 mg filmtabletten get cialis samples finasteride generis 1 mg ciproxin indications in urdu comprar viagra embalagem discreta generico del viagra dr simi provera and clomid buy online in uk prednisolone salbe ohne rezept kaufen como se deben usar las pastillas cytotec propecia pricing walmart where to buy priligy in penang cialis at riteaid price propecia and biotin in effect can doxycycline hyclate treat a yeast infection canadian pharmacy otc viagra is allegra safe to take with zoloft is it safe to take ampicillin while pregnant viagra supplier review sildenafil 110 mg troche dose of doxycycline for sinus infection zoloft hydrochloride 50 mg cialis prostate disorders can clomid cause blighted ovum cytotec medicine price in pakistan iphone pay for viagra with paypal tadalafil sales in brazil nolvadex 10 mg 30 tabs Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Nothing Left

Nothing Left

datePosted on 10:13, January 20th, 2014 by Pablo

Judging from recent events, the New Zealand Left is spent as a political force.

Some Left media types jumped at the opportunity to work for Kim Dotcom’s Internet Party (which is clearly based on the Pirate Party model, originally from Sweden but now with an international dimension that is anything but working class based). Material and personal motivations rather than ideological affinity apparently pushed these people to violate rudimentary conflict of interest and ethical standards.

That is symptomatic of the fact that the political (as opposed to cultural) Left is well and truly dead in New Zealand. The association (supplication?) of these “progressives” with a cowboy capitalist who has zero Marxist inclinations is a travesty if not treason to any working class cause. In one case the class betrayal had a specific dollar amount and a proposed political candidacy attached to it.

That some on the Left would countenance Dotcom as a tactical ally (in that his party is supposed to siphon young urban professional votes away from National) demonstrates how bereft of ideas, agenda and praxis they have become.

But what about the rest? Surely the foibles of a few cannot condemn the many to political oblivion? With apologies for any offense caused, let us not mince words and cut to the chase.

There is no viable Left in NZ politics. The Labour Party gave up any pretense of being grounded in socialist principles decades ago when it embraced market-driven economics, and the CTU-led union movement are the embodiment of Robert Michel’s notion of the “iron law of oligarchy:” the purpose of the organization is to serve itself, and if that means playing the role of “responsible” corporate toadies, then so be it. The one true Left union, UNITE, has some decent socialists in it and working class interests at heart, but it is also  fronted by several unsavory characters with Trotskyite and Stalinist inclinations (among other unpleasant traits), so its appeal is limited.

The Greens have stripped out the Red in their watermelon ranks in order to become a Blue-Green alternative with a lunatic fringe that can work equally comfortably with the two big parties (by ignoring that fringe). The Maori Party is basically single issue in that it only focuses on things it perceives to matter to Maori and was never progressive or working class oriented in any event. Winston First is a personality cult wrapped in nationalist populist rhetoric and Mana is a personality cult posing as an indigenous socialist movement. The Alliance is dead. Social Credit is no more.

What passes for an armed Left is no more than a bunch of bumbling fantasists who make Kyle Chapman look like a strategic genius.

There are plenty of armchair leftists in academia and the commentariat (I shall include myself among them). Some of them are very good at offering trenchant critiques of the system as given, but they have no political consequence. Likewise for the scads of po-mo hipsters, dandies and PC twitterati who denounce oppression by clicking “Like” on Facebook pages but who have no sense of what is involved in the commodity chain that brings them their mochachino low fat skim milk lattes. There are plenty of bullhorn activists, some of them righteous and others not so much, who like to burn flags and march about denouncing the global zionist-imperialist conspiracy. But they have zero political weight and are more a nuisance than a threat to the status quo.

The most earnest and legitimate political Leftists are rank and file union and interest group activists, but their energy and commitment is all too often stymied and diluted by leaders more interested in themselves and their positions than the “cause.” Put differently, many of the Left political elite prefer to maintain their positions in the status quo rather than heed the demands of their grassroots to push for fundamental change. Their concerns are about the distribution of power and resources–their own and that of the organizations they front–within the system as given, not about changing the system.

The chattering Left is as divided as the political Left, in part because they overlap: feminists accuse others Leftists of being patriarchical, GLBT activists accuse other Leftists of being heterosexist, Anarchists see other Leftists as sell-outs or authoritarians (and all of these complainants have a point). In general the Left argues more amongst itself than it does with the Right. Not surprisingly, the political Left is fractured, with activists all too often splintered into narrowly focused groups that do not share either strategic or tactical concerns with other Left movements. Worse yet, much political Left rhetoric is simply devoid of grounding in reality, be it from 9/11 conspiracy types to those who think that the Rothchild Trilateralists control everything.

More fundamentally, although many on the Left can offer informed and uninformed critiques of capitalism and the current status quo in NZ, none have been able to provide a coherent, much less publicly supported agenda for change.  That is its fatal flaw: the political Left in NZ are seen more as naysayers and whingers than proactive and reasonable “doers.”

These are, of course, generalizations that are bound to twist the knickers of some of those just mentioned. I use them to make the point that the NZ political Left is increasingly the province of self-interested opportunists and vainglorious charlatans, some with sociopathic tendencies and others divorced from the practicalities involved in confronting a capitalist-dominated political system that has overwhelming popular support.

It would be useful then, for those of us who pontificate on such matters, to take stock of what it means to be a sincere and viable political Leftist in a country where the very mention of such a term elicits derision or disinterest on the part of the majority of those who should find socialism, or at least social democracy, to be the natural political choice.

For a start, it might be wise to put distance on the delusional sociopaths and self-interested opportunists and charlatans that give the political Left its bad name. Having done that, the legitimate Left can begin to craft an agenda for change that is more than just the piecemeal undoing of the market-oriented policies in place since 1985.

Ot it could simply admit defeat.

categoryPosted in Democracy, Politics | printPrint

19 Responses to “Nothing Left”

  1. Sanctuary on January 20th, 2014 at 12:17

    So let’s accept your contention that the political left is dead. That the elite and the establishment political parties are champions of the neo-liberal order. Let’s also accept your contention, made elsewhere, that they NZ establishment is self-serving, secretive, out-of-touch and colonial in it’s mindset. What, then, is left that might discredit the NZ establishment, to undermine it with revelations and shake the current order to it’s foundations? Consider what success for Dotcom might mean. Reversing the surveillance laws, leaving the Five Eyes alliance and disbanding the GCSB would be the most significant blow our colonialist political establishment has ever suffered. If Dotcom can damage the the NZ establishment like that then by all means park reversing neo-liberalism for another three years. The Dotcom sprat might be destabilising enough to allow the opportunity for the left to catch a mackerel.

  2. Graham on January 20th, 2014 at 15:28

    The aims and objectives of Marxist Revolution are outdated and not relevant today. Socialism is about creating a new society based on a vision of freedom and democracy. The problem with the 21st Century (extreme)Left (is this where you are?)is the inability to see that both the Labour movement and Communism are redundant forces that have failed to dismantle and socialise the state. The only alternative for the Left is to reform the system from within rather than trying to get rid of it. This means compromising its extreme views if it ever wishes to gain power.
    That is where the intelligent Left is today, even if you fail to recognise it.

  3. Pablo on January 20th, 2014 at 15:33

    So Graham, what you are proposing is to fight an effective counter-hegemonic war of position (I assume that you know the difference between this and a war of maneuver). Who, exactly, among the “intelligent Left’ is doing that?

  4. Brian on January 20th, 2014 at 17:06

  5. Valerie on January 20th, 2014 at 19:04

    Well said Paul, a trenchant and utterly spot on appraisal of where things are at. Maggie is dead, but TINA is alive and kicking.

  6. Pablo on January 20th, 2014 at 19:15

    Ha Ha Valerie, that is a good one. The white surrender flag has replaced the red flags of yore, at least when it comes to real politics (as opposed to symbolic politics).

  7. mickysavage on January 20th, 2014 at 20:11

    So Pablo which class do you put yourself in?

    From my point of view there are plenty of on the ground activists trying to improve things and struggling to counter both the right with their concentration of power and the intelligencia left who keep saying that it is all too hard and because individuals falter the movement is doomed.

    Your generalisations do twist the knickers. Mainly because you fail to understand the importance of community and you see things with 1970s spectacles on.

  8. Edward Main on January 20th, 2014 at 20:36

    I don’t think it matters what ” ist ” people associate themselves with – monarchist, capitalist, communist, socialist, marxist etc they are nothing more than forms of social control. All are affected by wealth, power and influence.

    So I put it to you that ** both ** the political left and right in NZ are dead. They are now both one in the same. Neither side of the political spectrum has any vision

  9. Pablo on January 20th, 2014 at 20:48


    Re-read the post. I mention grassroots activists and include myself in one of the inconsequential categorizations. Plus, you are wrong on two counts: I do understand community (hence my concern with agent/principal issues) and I gave up the 1970s spectacles a long time ago.

    Edward: The modern Left is not reducible to an “ism,” but it sure could use some overarching unifying principles (or meta-narrative if you prefer) that are grounded in the practicalities of the moment rather than dogma or doctrine.

  10. helenalex on January 22nd, 2014 at 10:09

    I’m curious about what you think a viable left movement would look like. You’ve mentioned a number of things that it can’t be (Trotskyist, Stalinist, overly preoccupied with identity politics, overly pragmatic, personality-based, environment-focussed), but I don’t have much sense of what you think should be happening, other than perhaps that it should be based in some way on Marxist theory.

    I broadly agree with your critique of the left, although personally I think that the armed left being ‘no more than a bunch of bumbling fantasists’ is a very good thing, for the left and society in general. But it would be good if you had some suggestions as to what people should be doing and how.

  11. Tiger Mountain on January 22nd, 2014 at 11:33

    If post colonial Māori have not yet utilised the stinger or carbomb we shall obviously be waiting a bit longer for the other 99%ers to get effectively politically organised. Terrorist acts can be both a frustrated substitute for lack of mass political struggle and a pre emptive pointy end of the spear tactic.

    Your rather defeatist piece Pablo illustrates again the discord between the objective societal requirements for a strong left push and the substantially subjective reasons it does not happen. Hey boxing day sales man! aren’t the unions dead?

    There are glimmers, taking politics to where the people are, doh, the beach in summer, like GreenPeace did with the no drill day. The small left sects still keep the marxist flame flickering like sleeper agents and they will be needed one day soon enough as we move closer to the futurist scenario of movie “Elysium”.

  12. Pablo on January 22nd, 2014 at 14:22


    I was focusing on issues internal to the NZ Left and not the host of negative externalities working against it.

    To rephrase something Draco T Bastard said at the Standard (in a thread on Open Mike on Jan.21, 2014): in order to overcome addiction, addicts need to first acknowledge their weaknesses. That is not being defeatist, and as I said later in that particular thread, “we have met the enemy and s/he is us.” My post is about acknowledging the obvious in order to overcome self-inflicted wounds. Resorting to terrorism is not a viable way of overcoming them and in fact will result in terminal defeat.

    helenalex: That is why I agree that it is a good thing that the so-called armed Left (such as it is) are inept. This is not the moment for armed struggle, nor will there be anytime soon.

    However, without elaborating too much in answer to your question about how I would approach the “What is to be done” conundrum, let me point out the following:

    For nearly 60 years the capitalist democratic world operated under variants of the Keynesian consensus. That in turn fostered the replacement of politics of class conflict with the politics of class compromise, which is why the ensemble held for so long.

    The advent of neoliberal economics, first trialled in authoritarian settings, replaced class compromise with class conflict in liberal democracies. It was not an armed conflict, but it was and is a war nevertheless. This new class conflict was initiated by the upper bourgeoisie in order to strip away working class political and economic power in an effort to “race to the bottom” with regards to input costs in a globalized market.

    The first course of action was to attack union power in order to atomize the working classes. This was done via the enactment of regressive labour laws under the banner of labour market “flexibilization.” Having done that, political elites could then move on to thing such as trade liberalization (such as under TPP), self-offs of state assets, privatization of welfare and health markets etc.

    That strategy was accepted and endorsed by both National and the NZ Labour Party and has been very evident and effective in NZ as a result.

    Thus the first thing to be done is to return to a working class focus. This does not have to mean a strict return to traditional bread and butter issues such as wages and working (OSH) conditions, but to so-called post-modern concerns like work/life balance, workplace autonomy, flexi-time, worker ownership stake in firms etc. To these can be married other progressive causes such as mori sovereignty, environmental protection, extension of basic human rights etc.–but always with working class political and economic interests in mind.

    In order to do so the NZ Left has to create its own version of the United Front (I am thinking in a neo-Maoist way here, which means distinguishing between strategic and tactical allies), and given its current institutional make-up and leadership structures, that will be a very tall task to achieve.

    There is much more to the solution set but that is a starter.

  13. helenalex on January 23rd, 2014 at 07:48

    In that case the first step is creating some degree of class consciousness. The issues you talk about probably affect a large majority of the workforce, but relatively few people in NZ would consider themselves ‘working class’. According to the 2006 census, people in traditional working class jobs (labourers, machinery operators and drivers, and technicians and trade workers) collectively made up 29% of the working population. That’s a fairly substantial chunk, but not enough to change society, particularly since some of them will never support socialism no matter what (particularly tradies, who in many cases are actually small businessmen). So the first step is convincing desk jockeys, shop assistants etc that capitalism is dicking them over. Occupy had a decent crack at this but then their solution was to camp in public parks, so people ended up ignoring them.

  14. Pablo on January 23rd, 2014 at 08:30


    Your points are very well taken. A key to a revival of the Left is to expand the notion of “working classes” to include white collar, service, part time and other casual labor, including all forms of unorganized wage labor, in order to instill that notion of class consciousness you mention. That might include a re-identification so as to refer to these groups as “productive classes” in order to avoid the prejudice associated with the terms “blue collar” and “working classes.”

    There are many examples of forward thinking labor movements that have responded well to the impositions of early 21st century capitalism. A cross-national comparative perspective might illuminate some of the possibilities that may heretofore be unknown to the parochial NZ Left.

  15. John Kerr on January 23rd, 2014 at 14:30

    For an analysis of how capitalism is changing and how and why it’s still kicking off ‘everywhere’ (except NZ…) see Paul Mason.

    Start with this 18 minute clip from his address to Futurefest in Shoreditch last year

    and then this clip from the Global Uprisings Conference in Amsterdam

    And the 90 minutes of the best TV you’ll see all year

    Or you could just read his stuff – start with his books. Essentially he’s saying what this blogpost is saying.

    I tried to summarise Mason last year at the anti ERA changes rally in Christchurch. See

  16. Phil Sage on March 15th, 2014 at 01:14

    Ah Pablo, I wish I had seen this before to comment on it. It is a superb analysis, lacking only a view on the reason why.

    My view is that it is simply a triumph for moderation. NZ has a decent democracy with limited corruption. It is quite egalitarian and people respect most of those who have earned their wealth.
    There is no reason for class warfare. Anyone who has travelled and seen real slums will realise that GI and Otara are nothing of the sort. NZ politicians are simply posturing over scraps in comparison to the battle between the likes of Thatchet and Scargill
    In fact the world would be a wonderful place if it looked a lot more like NZ politically.

  17. […] has snookered the New Zealand left by simply doing what it said it would do, and as Pablo argued persuasively at the start of the year, that makes clear how lacking the New Zealand left is in its strategic vision. They — Labour […]

  18. Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Left in tatters. on September 21st, 2014 at 12:14

    […] while back I wrote a post arguing that the NZ Left was in serious disarray. Various Left pontificators fulminated from the […]

  19. […] posts began before and concluded after the 2014 election and can be found in chronological order here, here and here. There were plenty of people who disagreed with my take on things, with the most […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)