is womens viagra available in dubai bula clomid 50 mg what are cost of viagra pills ampicillin and sulbactam msdsonline zoloft 50 mg prix maroc where can you buy viagra in soho azulzinho viagra como usar diflucan farmacia online portugal doxycycline 100 mg gut issues viagra effects uk how long viagra takes to work vitacid tretinoina 0 25 mg generic viagra real viagra paypal sabril 500 mg bijsluiter viagra doxycycline dosage in renal failure viagra pode causar infarto fulminante clomid 100mg affect cycle length uk bekomme ich cialis in der apotheke is zovirax safe when pregnant diflucan mg for yeast infection tadalafil generic no prescription arcteryx beta lt hybrid womens reviews on cialis cipro manufacturers india ciprofloxacin hcl solubility in water dosage of tadalafil carprodyl 50 mg zoloft how to buy viagra in greece cialis 2 5mg blister pack tablets for sale much does propecia cost insurance least expensive propecia from canada can i get cipro in mexico without a prescription viagra in canada com do you need to take propecia every day ciprofloxacin leaves bad taste in mouth cialis 2.5mg price for sale with out prescription generico de cialis comprar libros can i take doxycycline and bactrim daflonex generic cialis ship generic viagra overnight cost viagra virginia 100g viagra pills viagra sale online uk pharmacy cialis suppliers in nz viagra lloyds chemist jobs meclizine over the counter name for cipro altacef 125 mg zoloft paroxetine sandoz 20 mg bijsluiter cialis doxycycline how much does it cost for men comprar viagra en mano en valencia amoxil 500 mg tabletas pfizer viagra dosage safe take aspirin metformin ciloxan colirio generico de cialis generic medicine for diflucan reviewer about general viagra generic soft tab cialis cialis online romania biomics suspension generico do viagra pfizer generic sildenafil best price daily cialis 5mg faer pharmaceuticals cialis cost buy cialis soft tab viagra online viagra in usa rezeptfrei genericos de viagra en peru 60 mg prednisone for 5 days for knee pain viagra how long take effect para que se usa el antibiotico ciprofloxacino sildenafil ranbaxy india where to buy viagra without a prescription in vancouver safer than ciprofloxacin black market viagra fast in seattle propecia or finpecia how young to use viagra prednisone weight gain in the face where can i buy zovirax cream over the counter prednisone oral generic name legitimate sources to buy viagra effects of long term cialis use fluvastatin 40 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin in first trimester of pregnancy buy finasteride no prescription sildenafil 50 mg ahumada viagra for sale in harrow comprare cialis online reato is 750 mg of zithromax enough to cure chlamydia is viagra available in south africa if so where no rx generic viagra comprar sildenafil en colombia que what is the street price of 100 mg viagra watermelon viagra effect how long prednisone stays in your body lasix clothing online does online generic cialis work prednisone 20 mg indicaciones metformina amoxil 500 mg posologie imodium without prescription clomide 150 mg having triplet pharmacies in abu dhabi that sell cialis can i purchase cipro in mexico viagra use for what prednisone 20 mg 3 a day viagra sachet uk para que es inderal 40 mg is taking zoloft during pregnancy safe shemales buy their viagra pills petogen 150 mg viagra zoloft a 500 price in mumbai metformin tablets in pakistan cialis 5mg original kaufen amoxil 400 ml sito sicuro acquisto cialis generico purchase cipro hc ear drops 50 endep 10 mg prednisone can clomid cause you to ovulate later 500 mg metfomin and clomid days do you take clomid how do i buy cialis use cytotec 200 mg jimpness beauty fat loss capsule 500 mg metformin is viagra prescription only in us break e20 pill cialis in half name brand prednisone is viagra legal in greece half price viagra tesco united states viagra order doxycycline hyclate 50 mg for acne to buy cipro without a prescription orgametril 5 mg bijwerkingen prednisone a que hora es recomendable usar cytotec can you buy cytotec in canada prednisolone ip 20 mg metformin 500 mg fiyat generico intercambiable de cialis puedo comprar cytotec sin receta en las farmacias se puede comprar viagra ciprofloxacin hydrochloride 500 mg pill street value cost propecia us how widely used is accutane zoloft can you cut in half what dosage of clomid for twins can you take viagra with hydrocodone nolvadex gaspari reviews herbal viagra in surrey cytotec generico para que sirve cost of metformin extended release 500 mg zoloft generic problems viagra generico farmacias guadalajara cold sore treatment over the counter uk viagra price of pifzer viagra in india quick viagra delivery lasix compresse 25 mg torrinomedica just took diflucan fabian essays in socialism written by buying cialis london 10 mg nolvadex on cycle sildenafil citrate 5 mg what is the starting dose of accutane cytotec online seller sites viagra generic version of lexapro generic name of cialis in india inderal safe while pregnant most effective dose viagra viagra bestellung how to make 5 mg cialis most effective viagra dosage 100mg too much daily cialis walmart can e.coli growth in ampicillin where to buy viagra in penang malaysia can you take prilosec with doxycycline personal experience with zoloft generic why is socialism a bad word in america clomid 150mg and gas in stomach cialis tablets to buy in uk cheapest cities costo de una cytotec tadalafil 60 mg erfahrungen mit carpaquin 75 mg zoloft vinos casa madero donde comprar viagra dapoxetine buy online uk viagra generica cialis fda approved vogelxo generic viagra totalip 80 mg bijwerkingen prednisone viagra hombre comprar ciprofloxacin liquid form roche stops selling acne drug accutane zithromax 500 mg presentacion en accutane lawyers in michigan voli low cost larnaca cipro how to use clomid typhoid doxycycline treatment low dose accutane therapy ciprofloxacin 500 mg dosierung harnwegsinfekte cialis uk 40mg can ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg treat boils wie gut sind viagra generika how much does prescribed cialis costs buying viagrain dubai finasteride 5mg proscar infertility and metformin generica tadalafil lower cost tadalafil benefits of socialism in a disaster buy herbal viagra longer erections cytotec vendita online italia should i order 1 or 5 mg of propecia will doxycycline treat cystitis sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg kamagra pro 100 is zyrtec safe to take with zoloft generic brands of sildenafil online yahoo answer viagra online cipro c diff diflucan single dose mg use paypal to purchase 25mg viagra comprar viagra online em portugal padre buy apo metformin cialis tadafil 10 mg bahasa indonesia what is the best female viagra xyzal generic manufacturers of metformin wean off 200 mg zoloft for ocd buy cialis en tijuana when best to use clomid buying viagra manhattan other names for accutane list of conditions doxycycline treats etoricoxib 90 mg bijsluiter viagra risks of prednisone in pregnancy doxycycline antibiotic 100 mg memoria ps vita generic a viagra costo del viagra originale viagra price in kenya viagra generika testbericht abilify 2 mg vs 5mg cialis cialis original kaufen clomid calculator ovulation calendar medicinali equivalent al cialis online viagra generika deutschland bestellen serdolect 20 mg cialis price of clomid 100mg in philippines viagra indian food cheap brand viagra 100mg cialis 85 mg daily aborto realizado con cytotec prednisone cheap no how many brands viagra available in india is there any product like viagra in gnc mifegyne cytotec kaufen se comprar viagra sin receta medica farmacias propranolol jaw clenching 1000 mg cytotec generic cialis vs barnd propecia im ausland kaufen what is ampicillin used to treat tadalafil purchase online ampicillin resistance in plasmid viagra generico en ecuador que old must you buy viagra ciprofloxacin in urethritis change in menstrual cycle with clomid es seguro comprar viagra on line herbal tadalafil 20mg viagra in uk viagra online express delivery anti inflammatory drugs corticosteroids prednisone order doxycycline chlamydia pillole viagra costochondral separation buy metformin hydrochloride 500 mg usar pastillas cytotec para abortar best time cycle take clomid types of viagra that you can found in gas station how long does clomid usually take to work viagra medicine in nepal voltaren 50 mg obat apa methylprednisolone comprar valeriana 50mg clomid cialis 10mg costco viagra buy at malaysia how long is diflucan in system trusted site to buy cialis cialis 20mg predaj how much is a bottle of viagra ciprofloxacin drops in the ear doxycycline in the treatment of pinworms in the vagina otc viagra uk sites proper way to take clomid nolvadex 10mg price epival generico do viagra donepezil and zoloft zwanger met clomid 100 mg fucithalmic 10 mg prednisone doxycycline dosage for pigeons doxycycline hyclate 100 mg 500 tablets price can you really buy cialis without a prescription buy cialis pills 20mg cialis 20mg lilly deutschland clomid tablets in ireland metformin 850 mg sr do i need a prescription for viagra in singapore teva doxycycline price europe antybiotyk cipronex 500 mg cena sildenafil 25 mg half pill otc viagra uk for sale propecia price in saudi arabia prednisone 20 mg tablet dosage is viagra prescription only canada costo della viagra is viagra safe with beta blockers hcg nolvadex purchase doxycycline extended release brand name pediatric eye specialist in tucson az can i get sildenafil over the counter benefits of zoloft costo farmaco viagra cheapest viagra overnight insulin resistance metformin 50 mg prednisone withdrawal script for selling viagra acc akut 600 mg nebenwirkungen viagra buy metformin 850 mg uk why does viagra not work cialis 5 mg n3 lasix drug purchase inactive ingredients in ampicillin geteting cialis deliverd in uk bird biotic doxycycline hyclate 100mg prices cheap price for 200mg sildenafil prednisone pack directions how can i buy viagra at tesco cialis generika ohne kreditkarte doxycycline 100 mg obat apa side effect of prednisolone in pregnancy buy without a prescription zithromax azithromycin doxycycline difficulty swallowing cialis wholesale canada consumer reviews cialis what is considered long term prednisone use what is the natural alternative to viagra generic viagra vs brand viagra tadalafil online ukulele price of 6 months of accutane clomid reviews ukala buy viagra we accept paypal canada 1 month supply of propecia cost clomid for sale via paypal buy cialis compare prices much does zovirax cost australia como usar la segunda dosis de cytotec comprar viagra panvel honey smacks generic cialis propecia where to buy in australia para que es la metformin 850 mg price of viagra for girls in chennai wbere to buy viagra no prescription customs buying generic viagra canada vulvodynia specialists in ohio canada meds viagra cytotec 200mg price in pakistan inderal 80 mg prezzo oro doxycycline for fish 2.5 mg ciprofloxacin abz 500 mg beipackzettel citalopram z pack and diflucan together propecia tablet in india cold sore tablets over the counter uk viagra bring viagra into the usa cardura 4 mg pfizer viagra metformin 500 mg three times daily eli lilly puerto rico cialis canada compare price on 80mg lasix and 80mg furosemide cheapest cialis generic generic cialis alternatives buy viagra in nj cheap cipro eciwlcodkedefe clomid tablets buying without a prescription how to get put on clomid cipro el salvador la tia lita en el teleferico costa cialis cost 30 days 5mg medicina generica sildenafil avanafil generic viagra prednisone 20 mg tapering schedule number of accutane users available brands of metformin in pakistan amoxill posted in uk only cialis price range usa price of cialis going down viagra availability in germany comprar cytotec misoprostol chile eptavis generico de cialis metformin 500 mg does look like propranolol 80 mg twice daily comprar priligy generico contrareembolso generic cialis uk cheap reviews on doxycycline hyclate for acne do parlodel and clomid work well together pre seed et clomid online buy viagra in quebec safe place buy viagra metformin 250 mg pcos and pregnancy uk supermarket chain to sell viagra sigma finasteride generic best generic doxycycline liquid nolvadex 20 ml buy online how much does each cialis pill cost doxycycline hyclate how much to take buy discount viagra viagra viagra bankruptcy specialist 2 salary safe place to buy priligy is there a generic versipn of cialis trosyd 280 mg prednisone indian dapoxetine clomid dose in pcos what was the price of viagra when it first came out is viagra safe to take with atenolol best price cialis daily use cheap sildenafil online uk diflucan products in india comprar viagra en jaen propentofylline 50 mg zoloft cobra viagra in hyderabad dualid 75 mg zoloft shoppers drug martbrand name viagra sildenafil uses heart cheap propecia tables huevas pez volador donde comprar viagra propranolol 10 mg webmd cialis 5 mg contre indications ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution ingredients in nyquil priligy reviews ukulele cost prednisone canada over the counter version of propecia generic how long for 40 mg of cialis to start working cialis 28 cpr 5 mg prezzo italian amazon generic cialis if 2.5 mg of cialis does not work should i try 5 m.g alternatives to viagra reviews cialis generico pagamento in contanti zovirax 250 mg cialis generic 2017 is viagra safe with hypertension treatment 20 mg propranolol pregnancy what is the price for viagra in bangkok do i need a script for nolvadex legal in canada where can i order viagra in india buy cheap tadalafil 20mg uk is dapoxetine available in bangladesh prednisone 5 mg pour chat pain in ovaries clomid viagra irelanda buy zithromax online 500 mg generic viagra 100 dubai first class mail amoxil hereisthebestin no prescription buy cheap clomid online no prescription from us name of viagra model in blue dress can you be arrested for having viagra in canada zoloft surreal feeling doxycycline to treat alopecia can you take clomid if you are pregnant overstimulation of ovaries with clomid reviews what does propranolol 20 mg look like reliable place to buy viagra cheap viagra in singapore parlodel 2 5 mg 28 comprimidos viagra ciprobay 200 mg can you go on clomid in perimenopausal state are viagra legal in thailand viagra new york zithromax no prescription australia puedo tomar 200 mg de viagra metformin 1000 mg tablet prices metformin 500mg er in morning okay can you take amoxicillin with clomid unprescribed clomid uk yahoo viagra almaximo 50 mg hair falling out faster propecia price asics gel hyper 33 womens reviews on viagra cialis 5 mg od apcialis india farmacia online burrata viagra generic can buy viagra vietnam is viagra on walmarts 4 dollar list how much does ciprodex really cost what is propranolol hcl 40 mg tab used for finasteride generico argentina long use mayo prednisone daily dosage mg is safe to buy viagra online viagra online without prescriptions ery tab generic viagra difference in strength between cialis daily and 36 hour propranolol hcl 40 mg para que sirve price of viagra on nhs 30 day price of doxycycline hyclate 150ml is glucophage safe for non diabetics viagra in vae is clomid prescription only in australia medicament clomid prix cipro 750 mg twice a day average dosage for clomid cipro drug action in the body cialis daily use testimonials where to buy doxycycline tablets can a 15 year old use accutane order canadian cialis reviews of zoloft taken by anorexics buying viagra chea online zithromax 500mg cost prednisone 10mg over the counter alternative Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » El Chavismo sin Chavez.

El Chavismo sin Chavez.

datePosted on 12:23, March 6th, 2013 by Pablo

I am sure that there will be plenty of eulogies, some fawning and some harsh, for Hugo Chavez. Since I spent a good part of my academic career writing about Latin American politics, to include the nature of national populists such as Chavez and a bit about his regime itself, I am well aware of his shortcomings and strengths. It is in the nature of national populism to be redistributive, mass mobilizational and increasingly authoritarian. As a left-wing variant, the Chavez regime was all of those things, and the fact that the US supported the 2002 coup against him only cemented the increasingly authoritarian direction of the regime. But his authoritarianism was mass rather than elite-based, and it was this mass support that carried him through three terms and four elections. He was no tin pot despot. His rule was a bit more complicated than that of, say, Robert Mugabe, who took a popular national independence movement and turned it into an armed clan-based kleptocracy.

The Achilles heel of national populism is the personalist nature of executive rule. Peron, Vargas, Cardenas and Chavez–all increasingly concentrated power in their own hands, thereby removing institutional checks and balances as well as clear lines of authority and succession. That could be the undoing of the Boliviarian experiment.

After the 2002 coup Chavez purged the military and civilian state bureaucracy of professionals and populated the upper ranks with acolytes. This decreased the efficiency and capabilities of state agencies, both armed and unarmed. He increasingly relied on Cubans for behind the scenes leadership of his internal security services, including his personal bodyguards. He played divide and conquer with his parliamentary counterparts at the same time that he re-jigged the constitution to increase the length of his presidential terms as well as the electoral prospects of his political party. He populated the judiciary with supporters and increasingly restricted freedoms of public expression and the press. He trained and armed supporter militias organized along the lines of the Cuban Auto-Defense Committees. Some of these have been accused of intimidating and assaulting members of the political opposition.

He used inclusionary state corporatist mechanisms of interest group administration that bestowed favor and patronage on supportive groups and excluded or punished non-supportive groups (which thereby polarized civil society organizations). This allowed for top-down direction of the thrust of state policy and funding directed at civil society, but it also gradually surpressed independent and autonomous expressions of grassroots interest.

All of this was justified on the grounds that he faced a disloyal opposition aided and abetted by hostile foreign powers, the US in particular. Although there is an element of paranoia in those claims, there is also a large grain of truth to them. The hard fact is that just the appearance of socialist inclinations on Chavez’s part sent the US into knee-jerk opposition, something that was particularly acute under the Bush 43 administration and was not undone once Obama was elected.

Chavez did much good for Venezuela, particularly in the fields of health, education, welfare and community organization. During his time in power infant mortality rates dropped and literacy rates increased dramatically. The percentage of Venezuelans living in poverty dropped from 50 percent to below 30 percent in ten years. Rural hospitals and schools were built where there previously were none. His regime kept the price of domestic petrol cheap (as it could as a major oil-producing and refining nation), which allowed the poorest segments of the population to weather rises in the price of imported commodities.

In spite of the claims of his detractors, he won four elections handily and relatively cleanly in the eyes of most international election observers. His tenure marks a major historical moment in Venezuelan life, and his legacy will be indelible on it. Whatever his authoritarian tendencies, he was no Pinochet or Somoza. Although his regime selectively repressed the opposition, it did not systematically torture or kill. Nor did it expropriate all private wealth, although it did seek to raises upper-income taxes, nationalize some strategic assets and prevent capital flight via financial controls. Needless to say, this earned him the emnity of Venezuelan elites and their foreign supporters.

He was a close ally of the Cuban regime, but given the common hostility of the US, that was born as much out of necessity than it was out of ideological affinity (truth be told, Raul Castro always thought of Chavez as a buffoon but Fidel was flattered by his attention and both were grateful for his cheap oil supplies. The Cubans worried that he would provoke a confrontation with the US that would suck them in and destabilize them).

He expanded Venezuela’s diplomatic, economic and military relations (towards China, Russia and Iran in particular, but also with other Latin American states) so as to counter-balance the traditional US-focused obsequiousness of his predecessors. He was the motor force behind the solidarity market Latin American trade bloc known as the Boliviarian Alliance for the Americas (ALBA), which among other things rejected IMF and World Bank financial prescriptions. He had  significant Latin American popular and governmental support, which was mirrored in international media coverage.

He is alleged to have cultivated relations with Hezbollah and the Iranian Revolutionary Guard.

He presided over the deterioration of Venezuela’s core infrastructure, to include its oil production facilities (in which foreign investment dried up in response to his nationalization policies), as well as a dramatic rise in violent crime (Caracas has one of the highest murder rates in the world). He did not stop corruption but merely shifted it in favor of those who wear red berets. Venezuelan consumption of Scotch whisky, already the highest in the world when he assumed power in 1999, increased steadily from then on. He was unable to curb the Venezuelan obsession with female plastic surgery and beauty queens. So not all is well in the Boliviarian Republic. I shall leave it for others to debate the trade-offs involved and the pros and cons of his regime.

On balance, in the Latin American scheme of things Hugo Chavez was a relatively moderate caudillo (strongman) with a staunch independent and redistributive streak and majority popular support until the end.

The real problem at the moment is that his movement has no natural leader to succeed him. Moreover, he was the ideological glue of the regime: it was his vision, his praxis, the drew the course of events. With him gone the ideological basis of the regime is subject to interpretation by contending personalities and factions within the Boliviarian movement. His designated Vice President, Nicolas Maduro, has no independent power base, much less broad support within the Party. He has a serious rival in Diosdado Cabello, a former Army colleague of Chavez’s who is the head of the National Assembly. Cabello has support within the military, whereas Maudro’s support comes from within the union movement and public bureaucracy. Yet neither is visibly stronger than the other, so the backroom maneuvering and in-fighting has begun in earnest (and in fact began when Chavez returned to Cuba for surgery last December).

To this can be added the opposition, which rallied around the figure of Henrique Caprilles Radonski in the October 2012 elections that saw Chavez elected for the fourth time. A presidential election is supposed to be held 30 days  after the public announcement of Chavez’s death (March 5). Riding a wave of grief, unity and solidarity, Maduro is the favorite to win that election if he is a candidate. It will be interesting to see if Maduro can maintain his grip on power before or after the elections in the absence of support for his mandate, however electorally affirmed. One thing is certain: Maduro is no Chavez, and everyone knows that.

Caprilles might not run in the immediate elections so as to delegitimize them and allow the Boliviarian in-fighting to proceed unimpeded and without a common political enemy to focus on. Whatever happens over the short-term, the bigger question is whether the Boliviarian experiment can outlive its creator. Can there be Chavismo without Chavez? Given the dynamics at play within and without the Boliviarian regime, the odds are not entirely favorable.

For the time being we will be treated to the grand spectacle of a Venezuelan state funeral, where the streets will be awash in red and the dignitaries will include a who’s who of US adversaries and critics, Hollywood leftists and very few heads of state from the developed capitalist world. As for Chavez–will his afterlife smell of sulphur or of something more pleasant?

13 Responses to “El Chavismo sin Chavez.”

  1. Hugh on March 6th, 2013 at 15:37

    I’m not trying to claim an exact parallel, but I wouldn’t be surprised if the eventual legacy of “Bolivarism” is similar to that of “Peronism” in Argentina – that “Bolivarists” claiming the legacy of Chavez will continue to be electorally successful (especially in 30 days time), but the movement will become increasingly fragmented, self-perpetuating and possibly even ideologically split.

    Also, Pablo, your post seems a bit contradictory. You say that Chavez ran down infrastructure, but you also say that he built hospitals and schools. Aren’t hospitals, in particular, an important bit of infrastructure?

  2. Pablo on March 6th, 2013 at 15:49

    Hugh:

    Your analogy with Peronism is interesting, perhaps accurate but possibly overdrawn given that the latter has survived as a (admittedly divided) movement for thirty five years after his death. It remains a very open question that Chavismo will last that long as a competitive political force, but I have no doubts there will be political factions that will always claim his mantle. It should be able to win the immediate election unless armed struggle breaks out within it.

    The deterioration in infrastructure is seen in the road network, power grid, public transportation. government services and state firms. Priority was given to poverty alleviation, so other areas suffered. High post 9/11 oil prices were the main reason the regime could fund the projects that it did. Had prices stayed at the US$23/barrel mark for sweet Arabian crude (and remember that Venezuelan crude is lower quality shale-extracted), then the scale of social spending would have been far less, or at least less affordable.

  3. Hugh on March 6th, 2013 at 16:31

    I’m presuming the sympathy vote for whomever ends up carrying the Bolivaran flag (presumably Maduro) will be massive, so Chavez’s immediate heirs might have a bit of a long honeymoon, but I don’t see the movement retaining any coherency without him, not even for a couple of years.

    Do you think armed struggle is likely?

  4. Pablo on March 6th, 2013 at 16:49

    Re: armed struggle.

    That depends on the bitterness of internal disputes (should they materialize), the actions of the opposition, and the potential meddling of foreign interests. The behavior of Venezuelan and Cuban exiles in the US, who already engage in fund-raising, paramilitary training and public propagandizing with the objective of overthrowing both the Castro as well as the Chavez regimes, will be interesting to follow. So will the response of the Cubans and Iranians, who have close relations with the Boliviarian regime and who have much to lose if the Chavistas are removed from power. Russia and China will live with whatever status quo emerges so long as their commercial interests (to include military sales) are not affected.

    The US will work quietly behind the scenes to undermine hard-line Chavistas in favor of more moderate factions, as well as with the opposition, but will not overtly intervene unless the exiles (many of whom are now US citizens) try to push the issue in Venezuela and get themselves in a bind as a result. If that happens the US right wing will demand armed intervention in defense of the “freedom fighters,” at which point the US government will have little choice but to try and protect its (misguided) citizens however necessary given the domestic political realities of the moment.

    Whatever the case, I would imagine that the USG and its responsible agencies (such as OSD-ISA-IA, Joint Staff and the Southern Command) are drawing up contingency plans to cover any armed eventuality, to include wide-spread public disorder.

  5. Hugh on March 6th, 2013 at 18:19

    I don’t doubt you’re right about contingency plans, but I find it very hard to imagine US boots on the ground, except in an extremely limited sense. I also don’t doubt you’re right about the exiles seeing this as an opportunity, but I imagine they will probably wait until after the election. A post-Chavez Chavista government is going to look very shakey, and will be much more vulnerable to both constitutional and extra-legal pressure.

    I guess time will tell.

  6. Libertyscott on March 7th, 2013 at 00:39

    Bearing in mind he effectively banned any organisation getting foreign funding or help that was involved in “accountability of public officials or agencies”, it is difficult to independently verify what was achieved and what wasn’t, although he was popular – the hyperinflation and devaluation of the currency has been an effective way to steal from the poor and middle classes.

    Perhaps his most damaging legacy has been to abolish judicial independence and the rule of law, effectively acting by decree against his opponents. That, and the peculiar five-fold rise in the murder rate under his rule – which in itself, ought to raise some flags about what the true conditions of many actually are.

  7. Pablo on March 7th, 2013 at 08:29

    LS:

    The use of executive decrees and state corporatist mechanisms that curtail the activities of interest groups (including funding) is all-too-common in Latin America and the product of overly strong presidential systems in which executive power is relatively unchecked. Chavez was not alone in his (ab)use of these instruments of state control, as elected presidents throughout the region, including neighboring Colombia, make ample use of them.

    The lack of judicial independence is also a fairly common feature of regional jurisprudence, but Chavez’s stacking of the courts was egregious. His claim that the judicial corps was full of members of the elite when he came to power has merit, but his way of removing and replacing them does not.

    The rise in inflation can be attributed to run-of-the mill poor government spending decisions. The increased murder rate is more difficult to explain, but appears to be a product of cheap drugs and alcohol, availability of guns (coming over the border from Colombia), the rise of criminal gangs and inner-city social decay in part due to the government’s emphasis on rural rather than urban poverty alleviation.

    However, the problem of rising violent crime is not exclusive to Venezuela or any political regime–all of Central America, Mexico and parts of the Caribbean have experienced rising murder rates in the last decade, so the problem is not reducible to the ideology of those in charge.

  8. Libertyscott on March 9th, 2013 at 07:46

    Pablo, indeed not, but for 14 years worth of rule, the pattern has been one of those indicators getting much worse.

    I wouldn’t ever claim he was alone in being bad, but I do find the paeans of praise for him that conveniently sweep to one side a pattern of ever increasing authoritarianism, corruption and economic mismanagement as a mere footnote, to be short changing Venezuelans.

    On the flipside I don’t think for one moment that some of the economic policies Pinochet introduced (which I’d agree with and argue Chile has subsequently benefited from), justified at all his regime and the practices it adopted against opponents. The ends do not justify the means, and they especially do not justify the means to hold politicians and their officials to account.

    It is quite simply malignant for a regime to proceed down a path that includes arresting judges that don’t pass the correct verdict on people deemed by the regime as being opponents. Meanwhile, the waste and the transfers to foreign regimes (and even the bizarre gift of cheap diesel to London) did absolutely nothing for the poor of Venezuela, but bought the billionaire Chavez lots of friends.

    He could have just used the oil money for welfare, health and education for the poor, without generating hyperinflation and shortages, without oppressing opponents, without corrupting the state and without Mugabe style farm confiscations that destroyed local food production. Had he done that, then he could have credibly been a different model of leader.

  9. Pablo on March 9th, 2013 at 08:48

    LS:

    I am glad that we can agree that the move towards authoritarianism is never justified, be it of the right or the left. I also agree that the stark good/bad representations of Chavez does a disservice to the complexities of his case. It has been disappointing to me to see some of my lefty friends cast a blind eye to his excesses and misbehavior. Hatred of the US can do that to people.

    The two questions that come to mind are 1) would Chavez have gone authoritarian if the local elites had not been so disloyal (to the point of coup plotting) and the US had not reacted so negatively to his election (to include supporting the 2002 coup)? We will never know but the behaviour of the local elites and the US sure facilitated that move. It also facilitated his turn to rogue states for support, so in a sense the regime’s evolution became a self-fulfilling prophecy.

    2) Is the Chavez experiment another example of the fossil fuel curse, where countries that are heavily dependent on oil or gas exports for hard currency earnings tend to be more often than not authoritarian or become authoritarian once those reserves become exploitable? That is a theme in comparative politics and the record is quite strong in that regard: as things stand, a majority of oil-exporting countries are run by despots of one sort or the other.

    In Venezuela’s case, Chavez’s predecessors ran an elite or oligarchical electoral-based “pacted” regime where two bourgeois parties rotated control of government and siphoned oil profits into their support base. Chavez just changed the nature of those in power and those who received the benefits of oil profits, although I agree that he squandered most of them and rode a wave of rising oil prices to fund his projects.

    Which leaves the final question: if Chavez did not have oil profits to play with, would his Boliviarian experiment have gotten off the ground, much less won four free and fair elections?

  10. Hugh on March 10th, 2013 at 06:32

    Pablo, I think the question of whether Bolivarism can work without oil is best answered by watching what happens in Ecuador and Bolivia.

  11. Pablo on March 10th, 2013 at 07:34

    Hugh:

    Ecuador is an oil dependent state. Bolivia is slightly different in that it depends on mineral and natural gas exports (and coca!). In both cases, be it under Rafael Correa (just re-elected) or Evo Morales, the regime has slowly “hardened” by increasing executive power at the expense of other institutions. Not yet quite to the point of Chavez, but the trend is discernible.

  12. Hugh on March 10th, 2013 at 18:40

    How silly, I didn’t know about Ecuador’s oil deposits.

    I did think of the parallel to Bolivian natural gas, but while natural gas prices are rising, they haven’t reached the point where we can compare them to oil or usefully talk about ‘pneumo-crats’. Not yet, anyway.

  13. Pablo on March 11th, 2013 at 15:09

    Hugh:

    What is most interesting to me about the fossil fuel dependency/authoritarianism argument is that it is part of a broader rejection of Ricardian economics. The counter to his comparative advantage specialization thesis is that such a monopolistic development strategy based on exploitation of a single primary good export or limited range of commodity resources concentrates economic power in a small elite who directly control political power (either by themselves or via proxies).

    In state capitalist and socialist systems that elite can be state managers, and those state managers may have come to political power by overthrowing or expropriating the private elites who previously controlled the primary resource.

    The counter argument continues that diversifying the economy away from comparative advantage specialization allows for the creation of multiple sources of economic power that cannot be controlled under a single political umbrella tied to any one economic interest (there are several reasons for this but I shall not detail them now). That in turn pushes the creation of a competitive political party system in which these various contending interests, as well as those representing the working classes, can vie for political control.

    The counter-argument essentially claims that Ricardian strategies in countries dependent on a limited range of primary good exports are conducive to authoritarianism and inimical to democracy.

    Needless to say, that has been a much debated claim.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: