cytotec induction process in math german hunting terrier for sale in uk zithromax is there a natural herb that works like viagra the best homemade replacement of viagra sildenafil 50 mg tomar mujer viagra 50mg tablets price in pakistan can you take doxycycline with valtrex zoloft obsessive compulsive disorder user reviews viagra fast co uk doxycycline hyclate used for pneumonia buy sildenafil send by lithuania agora viagra online prospect cipro quin 500 mg metformin 1000 mg no prescription dapoxetine medicine in pakistan halal food distributor of viagra in pakistan propecia priceline propecia tab 1mg how to take clomid after sustanon secondo ciclo clomid in cinta o quasi can viagra cause rectal bleeding bijwerkingen prednisone 5 mg is 25mg of zoloft safe with ibuprofen viagra facts and price zovirax 800 mg pregnancy announcement buy claravis accutane treatment prednisone hereisthebestin no prescription nolvadex 20 mg can it cause hair loss ofteno prednisolone 20 mg what is zithromax z pak finasteride cost rite aid viagra por online en puerto rico tranexamic acid in ortho surgery specialists viagra falls canada hotels sildenafil citrate 100mg using paypal how much time tadalafil 20 effects in women body is it safe for a 30 year old to take viagra costo di una scatola di cialis dapoxetine uk boots liquid viagra gel 50 mg prednisone taper dose finasteride dergboadre australia buying viagra over counter boots priligy distributor in malaysia does cialis make you last longer lasix guercmorteo for sale viagra brand names in pakistan cialis 20 mg shoppers drug mart safety of ciprofloxacin in pregnancy can i take folic acid and clomid can i take clomid on day 8 viagra for ed propecia cheap canadian viagra online bestellen wonder clomid tablets do they work lasix 500 mg water bills cheap alternative to propecia metformin role in pregnancy can i take cipro with doxycycline viagra cost 50mg vs 100mg que es el nolvadex sildenafil citrate tablets cenforce 100 online viagra in phoenix blood in the spurm after takeing viagra medikinet 40 mg bijwerkingen prednisone buy ayurvedic viagra can i buy viagra in pharmacy online cialis daily use viagra online drugs is doxycycline safe in kids for acne viagra sale 50mg accutane 20 mg every other day galvus e metformin 500 mg is 750 mg of zithromax enough to cure chlamydia ciprofloxacin 250 mg comprimidos stadium in irelandcialis optive colirio generico de cialis extended release metformin generic price ampicillin concentration in lb plates with kanamycin heladeras kohinoor donde comprar viagra prednisolone 50 mg pferd abrasives can zoloft work in two weeks acquistare viagra online con postepay pelvic pain specialists in minnesota clomid and depression in men how bad for you is prednisone ordering viagra on internet acheter viagra sans ordonnance au canada cost of 20 500mg amoxil tabs in ireland order accutane no prescription does amoxil forte come in capsules cialis for men in calgary purchase cialis online cheap australia viagra from canada 2 day delivery dosulepin 150 mg viagra pcos clomid twins acquistare viagra originale online coupons buy cialis with dapoxetine priligy costo no prescription cialis at walmart fraudulent online sellers of tadalafil la sportiva trango womens reviews on cialis viagra montreal buy classifieds java identifier expected generics for accutane quitting propecia after 3 months aurochem brand viagra and dapoxetine glumetza metformin cost finasteride avodart comparison viagra substitute made in india by sun pharma im on clomid when should i take a hpt prices of viagra in slovakia can you buy clomid at gnc comprar cialis farmacia sin receta how much viagra can be taken in one time 50 mg of clomid a day for men can i take doxycycline and go in the sun difference between propecia 1mg or 5 mg purchase retail viagra in dhaka how to write prescriptions for cialis overnight viagra delivery cleveland ohio 40 mg once a day accutane baby doxycycline for chlamydia reviews of fifty medsafe data sheet metformin 500mg where in dublin can i get viagra cialis online italiano come usare priligy usa generic viagra made in united states r8order viagra com can you buy cialis at walgreens cialisis best time of day to take for better results tachipirina 1000 mg dosaggio viagra does deltasone get you high nolvadex and clomid for pct wikipedia cialis 20 mg metformin hcl er 500 mg tb24 prescription obat kuat cialis 50 mg viagra look alike pills for sale order clomid now tadalafil prices uk palivizumab cost per dose of viagra where can i buy cialis in toronto doxycycline monohydrate reviews viagra in spain how much can you take clomid while on period where can i buy cheap cialis ranbaxy equivalent to viagra order online synulox palatable tablets 500 mg metformin ritalin and zoloft ringing in ears zithromax antibiotic medication ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablets information the cost of cialis at walgreens priligy 30mg e 60 mg adderall pink viagra sale generic 5 mg cialis joypox dapoxetine review what is the average mg of clomid diflucan manufacturer india viagra 200mg kaufen how to use viagra medicine in hindi buy viagra online without rasitol 20 mg prednisone what is professional viagra buy cialis 20 mg vs 40 mg viagra cost per pill without insurance is viagra safe if you have hep c bromfenex generic viagra ciprofloxacin 250 mg indicaciones de transfusion finasteride topical use clomid really tired sildenafil costo in farmacia benavides comprar cipro xr 1000 line prescriptions viagra price of doxycycline malaria tablets united states cialis coupons viagra tablets in india and cost in rupees cialis 5 mg gabapentin liquid dapoxetine dose donde puedo comprar cytotec en culiacan zwanger na clomid 50 mg how long does clomid take to produce sperm 50 oder 100 mg viagra how much does genuine cialis cost 20 mg canada phsrmacy haplochromis obliquidens female viagra cost of clomid medication para que sirbe almaximo sildenafil 50 mg why use clomid after steroids son buenas las cialis de 5 mg buy fluconazole diflucan can clomid cause hyperthyroidism propecia 2mg day viagra price in saudia do they sell viagra in dubai legitamite place in oklahoma city to buy cialis cheapest place to buy viagra in scotland diflucan over the counter singapore flyer viagra how it works donde puedo comprar pastillas cytotec merida yucatan letrozole and nolvadex for sale highest mg of accutane viagra for people in their 20s viagra in jordan generic viagra 100mg reviews of fifty what is the meaning of the bathtubs in the cialis amoxil rowcmoadreders price tadalafil with dapoxetine canada clomid for unexplained infertility ciprobay 750 mg online viagra real cialis generic soft tabs doxycycline mono 50 mg acne clear what colour is viagra uk tadalafil 10 mg dapoxetine doxycycline 100 mg for yeast infection how long before cialis kicks in 5 mg can doxycycline be taken with probiotics tranxilium 5 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin prix viagra europe i have stents in my heart can i take viagra metformin inhibits hepatic gluconeogenesis in mice blueberry 100 sildenafil usage mexmeds4you clomid for sale viagra will get in uae can i buy clomid over the counter in johannesburg viagra uk prescription charges viagra birmingham uk alumpak donde comprar viagra how much is diflucan from pfizer in manila viagra benefits health in urdu cost of accutane in uk buy clomid for men south africa doxycycline and diflucan 100 mg 3 for yeast infection purchase cialis soft tabs sildenafil citrate usp can taking viagra cause blood in a mans seman propecia 5mg price strong sleeping pills over the counter uk viagra do i need a prescription for clomid in the bahamas viagra for sale chingford about tadalafil 20mg canada cialis once daily review how long does it take doxycycline to expire viagraand callis in england used toyota yaris for sale in uk zithromax ims health brasil genericos do viagra diflucan 50 mg polvo pain in ovaries while on clomid will accutane get rid of my acne forever finasteride 1 mg alternate days viagra lowest priced seljaci viagra online come comprare il viagra in farmacia is it ok to take cialis with antibiotics prednisone liquid inactive ingredients underdose of clomid for sale viagra online international shipping cialis generic cheapest indian ayurvedic equivalent of viagra does my boyfriend take viagra clomid dergboadre online clomid 150mg stories cetonax generico do viagra can you take ibuprofen with viagra propecia use in women walmart price.for.viagra what is ciprofloxacin 500 mg taken for ciprofloxacino 500 mg para la garganta what is the average price for real viagra zoloft reviews premature ejaculation ampicillin dilution 100 mgml is it safe to take pepto bismol while on metformin best viagra 300 mg zovirax pills for cold sores reviews on wen accutane in michigan generic for glucophage 500mg viagra generic india cipla prednisolone 20 mg ruminal parakeratosis viagra canada cost coverage ciprofloxacin for std 500 mg buy viagra howdotofound doxycycline hyclate 20mg tablets for acne order prednisone without perscription in u.s. not getting pregnant with clomid liquid tamox vs nolvadex for gynecomastia how do i get a private prescription for clomid the best way to use cialis where can i buy viagra in cabo can you buy lasix over the counter viagra chemist mumbai canadian class action accutane prednisone online credit card now prednisone 5 mg low dose over counter drug like viagra viagra farmacia salcobrand canada accutane female viagra austria cheapest sildenafila 25 mg of zoloft best time of day to take metformin for pcos how much is the cost of cialis no insurance purchase amoxil suspension how many viagras in 24 hours masterbate beforr viagra viagra from costco pharmacy is lasix safe in breastfeeding ordering cialis viagra special delivery uk what happens if you forget to take your accutane vibramycin chemical name is clomid legal to buy online common side effect from liquid diflucan in toddlers ampicillin sulbactam high dose result if girls mix viagra in drinks and drink como pedir viagra en la farmacia japans mhlw approved 367 generics for viagra zithromax pediatricosteopathyofmarin buy dapoxetine now uk viagra 25 mg opinioni clomid private prescription can u buy viagra over the counter in sydney accutane cost ontario oraxim 6 cpr riv 500 mg metformin fast delivery of zithromax without a prescription does viagra help in pregnancy viagra online paypal uk contact zovirax price walmart price of zovirax ointment 5 where can i get nolvadex or clomid in the uk prednisone 10 mg tab cad can i get propecia from my doctor how long does 100mg of viagra last viagra mexico price how much doxycycline should i take for acne cut cialis pills in half why does cialis last so long in the body were to get viagra in delhi on counter can i take clomid with a cyst propecia cause grey hair cialis pills co uk metapro xl 50 mg viagra new balance 750 v1 womens reviews on cialis finasteride 0.5 mg every other day how to buy tadalafil in india yahoo answer what time of the day should you take clomid medication to counteract prednisone zovirax ointment usa tradolan 50 mg biverkningar av metformin lb medium ampicillin viagra in neonates is finasteride in nioxin pills where to get viagra in soho london buy cialis online no prescription usa 3 400 a8 25 mg of zoloft w580 main fs y custom generic cialis cialis right dose accessrx cialis canada puedo comprar viagra sin receta en uruguay tratamiento where to buy propranolol online much does cialis cost walmart viagra ireland for women non prescription viagra walmart cost what time do i take cialis viagra 50 mg prix pharmacie tadalafil online 2.5 mg is doxycycline used for sore throat viagra available prescription uk how much cialis should i take daily viagra pricing 100mg walmart order viagra cheapest where can i viagra i buy trustan generic cialis viagra vs tadalafil can you buy viagra in paharmacy in dubai airport the cost of propecia merck get viagra in nassau is viagra used for female use viagra 25 mg ervaringen fluocinonide cream 0 1 generic cialis priligy rowcmoadreders for sale avete usato priligy side viagra dose for pah segurex 50 sildenafil 50mg review where to buy viagra in lahore pfizer viagra price 4 pack viagra 50mg buying 20 mg prednisone for asthma cialis 5mg le prix can 250 mg of metformin kill me clomid and iui experiences in life finasteride 1 mg in pakistan is there a generic ciprodex canadian pharmacy cialis with dapoxetine metformin over the counter equivalent viagra tablets name for women in india nolvadex review bodybuilding address for cipro in cape town is diphenhydramine in zoloft can you take herbal viagra on a plane nolvadex get rid gynecomastia cost ampicillin allergy symptoms safe take accutane adderall preco generico do viagra 100 or 125 mg viagra should i take propecia herb names in tamil language viagra dosage vs cialis diflucan price malaysia ciprofloxacin ratio 500 mg nolvadex hereisthebestin discount best way to get viagra from my dr best time take viagra dinitrato isosorbide 10 mg prednisone 5mg propecia in india when to take clomid after test e urology specialist of oklahoma in tulsa ok cheapest viagra pfizer uk best deals brand name viagra viagra mg doses wo kann ich viagra online bestellen kroger pharmacy prices cialis metformin hcl er ter 500 mg amoxicillin is tadalafil safe to take prolonged usage of metformin reviews on viagra gold ampicillin in mice buy viagra for women online india priligy online pharmacy uk valium buy sildenafil citrate 100mg uk tadalafil online overnight delivery cytotec el costo zoloft falling in love cheapest viagra cialis au the role of ehr specialist in managing cpoe order viagra online pay with a check cialis over the counter drug kann man viagra in budapest kaufen zovirax cold sore cream buy how to get rid of acne without accutane how long does 5 day zithromax stay in your system zithromax azithromycin buy how to buy viagra tablets 40 mg dose of cialis supra generic viagra buy natural tadalafil thuoc cuong duong viagra for sale how much is viagra under the fep discount drug program prednisone 180 mg ginecoside tem generico de cialis lekovi za potenciju cialis cost buy cialis in fort lauderdale priligy maroc prix feprazone generico de cialis is it safe to stop taking accutane i split my 200 mg diflucan tablet in half evonik werbespot viagra online propranolol 10 mg usage prednisone 90 mg can you take two 5mg. cialis instead of one 10 mg nike free run 5 0 v4 womens reviews on cialis where online can i buy genuine clomid tablets qualquer um pode comprar viagra original betelnuss kaufen wirkung viagra cialis in bangalore medical shops oxytetracycline 500 mg metformin causas consecuencias cytotec how much potassium to take with lasix 40 mg viagra online prices ukulele how well is socialism working in venezuela accutane buy online uk dresses cheap english viagra order viagra jelly online phenibut review good looking loser cialis how can i get 100 mg viagra with out a prescription pfizer viagra spam cialis canada .99 prednisone through mailorder treatment of priapism due to viagra availability of viagra in bangalore getting acne after accutane finasteride and alfuzosin together what is the use of finasteride tablets venda de anfepramona 60 mg prednisone generic viagra 100 mg in usa viagra effects how long diclofenaco cinfa 50 mg comprimidos viagra viagra feminino onde comprar fibra is viagra sold over the counter in phoenix az viagra australia supplies take prednisone once or twice a day is best buy viagra online in canada from trusted sites where to buy viagra canada generic cialis india add message where i find viagra in bangladesh sildenafil 25 mg reviews female viagra uk pharmacy vhdl if statement generic cialis doxycycline length of use cheap pfizer viagra 100mg ciprofloxacin gases in air can i take cialis with testosterone injections viagra 20 mg prednisone every other day viagra best dosage of melatonin Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » On Israel-Palestine, Obama between a rock and a hard place.

On Israel-Palestine, Obama between a rock and a hard place.

datePosted on 14:24, May 24th, 2011 by Pablo

One axiom of mediation is that the parties sincerely want to settle their dispute and realise that mutual concessions will have to be made in order to do so. Another is that the mediator has to be procedurally and substantively neutral–s/he has no interest in the specific terms of the result and is bound to procedurally enforce the rules on negotiations as well as externally enforce the settlement (which in effect makes the latter a contract between the disputants).

This is why Barack Obama’s latest attempt at mediating the Israel-Palestinian conflict is doomed.

In order to establish a semblance of neutrality, he proposed that Hamas recognise Israel’s right to exist in exchange for Israeli acceptance of the (post-conflict) 1967 borders as the basis for negotiations on a two-state solution. He said that mutually agreed upon land swaps would form the basis for the contract. Neither Hamas or the Israeli government accepted the offer and instead rejected it outright. Although it is possible that Obama’s initiative is just the opening gambit in a more delicate elaboration, it is also quite possible that this was his best offer, which is now dead in the water.

The problems with the proposed deal are many. With regards to the US, it is clearly not an impartial mediator. Whether the administration of the moment wants to or not, the power of the pro-Israel lobby and Israel’s strategic connections (intelligence sharing, weapons acquisitions and covert political maneuvering) ensure that the US will support it as the default option. To that can be added the fact that the US has designated Hamas as a terrorist organisation and openly supports Fatah as the legitimate representative of Palestinian interests even though the latter lost its electoral mandate to Hamas some years ago. By any measure the US is not impartial, neutral or objective, so its role as a mediator is reduced to pressuring Israel to engage limited concessions in the hope that Hamas will take the bait and offer significant concessions of its own. That will not happen. And yet no other country has offered to step into the breach, and it is doubtful that any other country (the UK? Germany? France?) would be acceptable to both parties.

As for the principles, they have no real interest in cutting a deal that binds them over the long-term. Politics in Gaza and Israel are dominated by fundamentalist discourses that see the conflict as a zero-sum struggle where the “other” is seen as sub-human and inherently evil. Both governments are divided and weak, the Palestinians visibly so but the Israelis no less so in spite of their veneer of unity. Corruption has become a major problem on both sides, which delegitimates their standing as honest interlocutors and representatives of their respective constituencies.

Moreover, both Israel and the Palestinians have foreign partners who overtly or covertly work to prolong the impasse and low intensity warfare because it is seen as serving their geopolitical objectives (Iran and Saudi Arabia come to mind). Then there are the weapons merchants and others who see profit in fighting and who do not wish to see the source of that profit end. One might argue that there even are NGOs and humanitarian agencies that have a vested organisational interest in an unresolved armed standoff that provides them with the opportunity to “do good.”  In other words, the constellation of interests that favour the continuation of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict outweigh those that sincerely seek a durable peace.

Which is why Obama’s initiative will not prosper. But there is a factor now at play that may make the US role irrelevant and actually force a hole in the diplomatic logjam obstructing resolution of the Palestinian “question:” the Arab Spring. Although it has yet to result in democracy anywhere in the Arab world, the groundswell of popular protest against authoritarianism has been a game-changer (of sorts). The change is in the acceptance of non-violent mass resistance as the preferred method of voice and redress. Not only does this strategy explicitly turn its back on jihadism. It also forces regimes to either up the ante and engage in mass repression (such as in Syria), or attempt to reform-monger in a way that maintains elite interests while offering more avenues of representation and service to the populations in question. Most importantly, though, it forces the Arab world to reappraise the regional status quo, specifically with regard to the status of Palestine, in such a way that it will make it increasingly less tenable for Israel to continue its policy of illegal settlements and armed force. With popular demands for a harder line on Israel emerging in places like Egypt, the pressure is on for the “reformist” leaders to reconsider the options with regard to Palestine. In addition, the use of (mostly) non-violent passive resistance against Israel such as the Nakbar protests on the Israeli-Syrian border forces it to show its authoritarian stripes (as it did in killing a half dozen of the cross-border protesters) or live up to its supposedly democratic principles when confronting unarmed protest.

Given Israel’s current political climate, it may well ignore all democratic pretense and fire away at will against peaceful demonstrators. But that is a short-term solution. The longer-term impact of the Arab Spring will be to force increased accountability on Arab regimes, which in turn will require them to adjust their approaches to Israel and Palestinians in ways that will not uphold the status quo ante. Should that happen, then it will be Israel that will be forced to make the first significant move with or without US backing, and it will do so not out of a sense of idealism but because it has pragmatic self-interest in doing so. After all, Israel is the stronger actor in this conflict. It has less to lose and much to gain when offering a genuine unilateral concession, in the beginning of what game-theorists call a “tit-for-tat” strategy (that is, it opens with a cooperative move then mirrors the adversaries’ response). It may take a few iterations and more concessions to elicit a cooperative response from Hamas, and the outcome could still result in failure, but that is how the game will have to be played if there is any hope of reaching a negotiated compromise.

Hardline Zionist talk notwithstanding, the best guarantee of Israel’s long term security given the changes underway in the Arab world is not superior counter-force as a deterrent. Instead, the solution that guarantees Israel long-term security is diplomatic, and that involves over-riding hardline interests in pursuit of diplomatic flexibility. There will be domestic consequences when it does make the first move, which will have to involve the unilateral eviction and withdrawal of newer settlements on occupied Palestinian land (think of the precedent of violent resistance by illegal settlers to the limited evictions undertaken by the Israeli government to date), and Hamas and Fatah will have to agree on a commensurate response if negotiations are to advance to the point of establishing a blueprint for dual statehood (which is the only realistic option and where recognition of Israel’s right to exist comes in). None of this will be voluntarily generated by the elites currently in office, not will it be the US that breaks the impasse and brokers the deal. Instead it will be the extension of the Arab Spring into Gaza and Israel that may offer the best hope for a diplomatic opening in pursuit of a durable peace, and should that opening come, it will be endogenous rather than exogenous in nature.

Although it is hard for the Obama administration to do given the imperial hubris that infects US domestic politics and foreign policy, the best thing it can offer is to quietly encourage the Arab Spring, openly condemn repression, seek broader international consensus and let events take their course. Or, as a senior Israeli intelligence official told me a few years ago (and I roughly paraphrase from memory here), “although conditions are not favorable to negotiations at the moment, there will come a time when both sides realise that theirs is an unhappy marriage, but it is for the children’s sake that they stay in it and make it work.” That moment may shortly be upon us, and it will be the “children” who force the issue.

21 Responses to “On Israel-Palestine, Obama between a rock and a hard place.”

  1. SPC on May 24th, 2011 at 22:43

    The Palestinians are going to the UN and seeking General Assembly recognition, so I suppose they accept that it’s only via international deligitimisation of American support for Israel that they can make real progress.

    When the UN was set up in 1945, it was supposed to usher in an era of collective security for peoples and nations. There was acceptance in 1949 that the ability of nations to seize territory by facts on the ground created by military conflict was a potential way for this to be undermine this UN polity. So they made the acquisitioon of territory by conquest illegal.

    However since 1967 Israel has annexed East Jerusalem and settled occupied territory. Asking Palestinians to negotiate land swaps/their new border to help provide Israel with more security – trade areas settled during the occupation in return for some areas without people Israel or a few Israeli Arab settlements is to legitimise the breach of the intent of the 1949 decision. Palestinians are being expected to accept this (denial of their right to collective security)
    in return for their state on the conditions set by their occupier and its principle backer and enabler.

    This is not the way to a just peace. It’s not meant to be. It can only result in Palestinian rejection and attempt to marginalise the American support for this approach. Of course they will say the Palestinians are rejecting a chance for peace and Israelis will occupy more and more West Bank land while this continues.

    Ultimately the only chance for epace is strong advocacy for 67 borders and a security fence relocated there. That means people on either side of that historic line are in one state or the other by residence (Jewish settlers should be able to remain in the WB in return for their back-rent etc if that is what they want). That should be the position of the UN.

    The only exception to that is a united Jerusalem that is capital of two states – that will probably mean a security perimeter to that city. As for refugees, well … an economic union allows for workers to travel to work and maybe even live as migrant workers who are not local citizens, as occurs within Europe or for locals here in Oz etc. Thus a right to refugee return to Palestine but also a right to work and live in Israel.

  2. Pablo on May 24th, 2011 at 23:03

    Thanks SPC, for the overview and analysis. I find it hard to disagree. It reminds me of what Chris Trotter said about the Treaty–it was meant to be broken. Just remember that under international law, territory acquired as part of the defense against preemptive aggression is considered valid conquest. That is why the post-67 as opposed to pre-67 borders are what matter, Netenyahu’s remonstrations notwithstanding. The post-67 borders are defensible, but it will take an Israeli withdrawal for that to occur (and it can).

    I was just thinking of the initial quid pro quo, but your comment illustrates the complexity of the specifics involved. Thanks for that.

  3. Phil Sage on May 25th, 2011 at 00:40

    Interesting comments both. The Haaretz article illustrates the problem Israel faces this year

    The really interesting outcome of Netanyahu insulting Obama in public, again, is whether it will lead to US diplomatic soft pedaling on the recognition of Palestinian statehood.

    Israel faces the very real possibility that Europe will unanimously back that statehood. Obama just needs to refrain from using a veto. I cannot see any reason why Obama would back Israeli intransigence under the current circumstances.

    It is fairly obvious that Britain and France are stepping up to the mark in Libya. That will end with Qaddafi leaving power in the near future. Particularly with the stepping up of helicopter and special forces attacks.

    Backing Palestine now would be strategic genius. It would support the intent of the Arab Spring and take the sting out of so much Jihadist anti Western propaganda.

    The tone of British foreign policy pronouncements are very much more balanced in favour of Palestine compared to past public discussion. The reality now is that it is strongly in the European national interest to promote the Arab spring, stability and democracy in North Africa. The reality of instability is politically unacceptable increased illegal immigration.

    So under the guise of promoting Western values Palestine will achieve statehood with the backing of Europe. Obama cannot tack back on his many statements promoting the emergence of Europe alongside American power.

    So the question becomes what will be the impact of Palestinian statehood on Obama re-election prospects in 2012. To me the arguments against Palestine statehood are too subtle to resonate with voters. That leaves only Jewish money. Does Obama calculate he can do without that money?

    The resignation of Marshall who was in favour of restarting the peace process and the pre-eminence of pro Israeli Dennis Ross does not seem to suggest that Obama has a clear internal strategy regarding the issue.

  4. SPC on May 25th, 2011 at 01:02

    Pablo, I was under the impression that any territory taken by military force was unable to be annexed and this applied to both parties whether aggressor or otherwise. And that this applied to pre-emptive response to any threat also.

  5. SPC on May 25th, 2011 at 01:33

    The position taken by Obama is a quite traditional one.

    Secretary of State Dean Rusk commented on the most significant area of disagreement regarding the resolution (242):

    There was much bickering over whether that resolution should say from “the” territories or from “all” territories. In the French version, which is equally authentic, it says withdrawal de territory, with de meaning “the.” We wanted that to be left a little vague and subject to future negotiation because we thought the Israeli border along the West Bank could be “rationalized”; certain anomalies could easily be straightened out with some exchanges of territory, making a more sensible border for all parties. We also wanted to leave open demilitarization measures in the Sinai and the Golan Heights and take a fresh look at the old city of Jerusalem. But we never contemplated any significant grant of territory to Israel as a result of the June 1967 war. On that point we and the Israelis to this day remain sharply divided. This situation could lead to real trouble in the future. Although every President since Harry Truman has committed the United States to the security and independence of Israel, I’m not aware of any commitment the United States has made to assist Israel in retaining territories seized in the Six-Day War.[9]

  6. Hugh on May 25th, 2011 at 04:37

    “de” in French does not mean “the”, it means “of”.

  7. Phil Sage on May 25th, 2011 at 18:06

    Pablo – I just heard a very interesting profile of the Turkish Gulan or Himset movement on BBC radio by Edward Sturton. Described as Islam Inc. I would be interested in your views.

    I found the whole thing tremendously optimistic. People with strong family and conservative values who believe in education, giving back to their community and espouse the separation of politics and religion. In that respect very similar to large chunks of America and Europe.

  8. Pablo on May 25th, 2011 at 18:11

    Thanks Phil, I’ll look it up. It may take a while because I am in the process of moving between countries.

  9. Phil Sage on May 25th, 2011 at 20:25

    Actually its Gulen not Gulan. I got spelling wrong. With your favourite source as a place to start

    Good luck with the country move.

  10. Serum on May 25th, 2011 at 21:40

    If it is any help here is a background to Fethullah Gülen at
    A quick read suggests that he is the leader of a shadowy Islamist sect with aspirations for transforming Turkey into Islamist Turkey ruled by Shari’a (Islamic law) and judging present day Turkey he has had a marked effect.

  11. Phil Sage on May 25th, 2011 at 23:36
  12. Pablo on May 26th, 2011 at 11:10

    Serum: Thanks for that. A friend of mine in Istanbul says that the creeping Islamisation of the public space is alarming.

    Phil: You have to rub it in, don’t ya? But yeah, given electoral dynamics in the US it was inevitable that Obama would drift rightwards on foreign policy.

  13. Serum on May 26th, 2011 at 14:16

    Attaching hope and faith in the so called Arab Spring as a catalyst to resolve the M.E. problems and ultimately the Palestinian “question” is possibly misplaced optimism for a movement that is currently running out of effectiveness in the political arena, as it is in Egypt the largest populated and most important Arab country.

    The “children” or more appropriately described as moderates initially driving this revolution in Egypt show no sign of organizing serious political parties to contest the up and coming elections to be held in September of this year. Instead of getting into gear they are procrastinating and complaining, while alongside this, four radical, anti-American, passionately anti-Israel political forces are active and organizing, namely: Radical nationalists, Left-wing neo-Marxist parties, Radical Islamist parties (Salafists) and the Muslim Brotherhood (M.B. should get 1/3rd or more of the seats and is contesting half of them). There will probably be a number of independents who will be courted and won over by one of these groups. As a guide to Egypt’s political parties so far, here is an excellent guide noting that there isn’t a single serious moderate party. Obamas’s favourite, Muhammad ElBaradei, isn’t doing anything but complaining.

    This all points to an election where Egypt will vote in a radical, anti-American, hate-Israel parliament which will then sit down and write the country’s new constitution marking a turning point in M.E. history at odds with Obama’s assurance where nothing can go wrong that everything is great with the “Arab Spring”, an expression of a yearning for prosperity and freedom.
    With the high probability of this scenario becoming a reality, Egypt although not immediately, eventually will morph into an Islamist state governed by Shari’a (Islamic Law) as the Muslim Brotherhood inevitably gains more influence and more votes in future elections. The peace treaty between Egypt and Israel will be torn up and thrown into the dustbin of history and the effect of this on furthering a resolution of the Palestine/Israel conflict will be disastrous as Hamas, the offshoot of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, gains support from its senior partner to devour Fatah and extend its hegemony into the West Bank making it more likely to launch terrorist attacks into Israel.

    A good background (a fairly long article) to what the Muslim Brotherhood is all about see:

  14. Hugh on May 26th, 2011 at 15:49

    @Serum: LOL.

  15. Serum on May 26th, 2011 at 19:56

    The internet address in my posting above for the guide to Egypt’s political parties contained in the following sentence – As a guide to Egypt’s political parties so far, here is an “excellent guide” noting that there isn’t a single serious moderate party – did not appear. Here is the reference:

    Hugh – Your counter argument has a certain succinctness if nothing else.

    Amr Moussa, who would have detailed knowledge of the local political scene, is standing for the next president of Egypt and predicts that the Muslim Brotherhood will have, along with its allies, a majority voted into power in the up and coming election.

  16. Phil Sage on May 26th, 2011 at 20:56

    Serum – Thanks for the links. The MB primer seemed like a conspiracy theorist rant. The idiots guide describes an entirely different democratic political position.
    “The MB has affirmed that it does not object to the election of women or Copts to the government, although it deems that both are “unsuitable” for the presidency. The group supports free-market capitalism, but without manipulation or monopoly. The party’s political programme would include promoting tourism as a main source of national income. The Freedom and Justice Party says it will base itself on Islamic law, “but will be acceptable to a wide segment of the population,” according to leading MB member Essam El-Erian.”

    To me it seems entirely reasonable that Muslims might wished to be governed democratically in accordance with the tenets of Islam. In the same way as America demands religious following of its politicians and the Christian democrats play a leading role in Germany.

    The political situation in Egypt is undoubtedly chaotic after 30 years of dictatorship. But that democratic chaos is a wonderful thing. Stability will take time.

    As with Gulen I find it difficult to criticise organisations that engage non violently with modern western society whatever their long term goals may be. The christian churches would like the world to believe but they have failed. I see no reason that Islam will be different.

    Having said that attempts to force change from tolerant liberal society like the Netherlands and much of the UK should be resisted. In much the same way as the conservative christian opposition to swearing and liberal attitudes has been overcome.

    Turkey is well on the way to a stable democratic nation guided by its dominant faith and the conservatism of its people. Who are we to judge people who freely believe in their faith?

    As I have said previously on this blog I can see Egypt following the same path as Turkey. The military offering a guiding hand as democracy develops. The military power in Turkey seems to have been sufficiently constrained now by their relatively prosperous stable democracy. A resurgent Turkey will certainly have a moderating effect on Islam over the longer term.

    The jury is still out on the MB in Egypt but perhaps we should be patient and judge their actions rather than condemn them on the basis of individuals that obviously became radicalised.

    Pablo – Sorry mate I could not resist the headline as Obama has just been here in the UK.

  17. Phil Sage on May 26th, 2011 at 20:58

    spam check please

  18. […] Yet it is precisely these kinds of difficulties that, according to Lucas, make studies of political warfare so potentially fruitful. In common with other students of Cold War history, Lucas argues that a scholarly division currently exists. On the one hand are those works which stress the conflict’s diplomatic, economic, military and political dimensions, typically privileging the state and emphasizing questions of geopolitics and national security (which he sees as the dominant complex of ‘diplomatic’ approaches). On the other are those studies which focus on such things as ethnicity, race, gender and the media in relation to the Cold War, works which for some critics attend less to agency or causation than context and discourse (in his view a marginalized, ‘cultural’ set of approaches developed in more recent years). By focusing on the ways in which during the 1940s and 1950s a public–private alliance came into being, motivated Additionally you can check out: […]

  19. Serum on May 27th, 2011 at 20:08

    Phil – Thanks for the input and your thoughts on the situation developing in Egypt. Of course you are correct in that we will have to be patient, for a while yet, to see which way the political pendulum swings. However, your opinion that the M.B. primer is a conspiracy theorist rant appears to be at odds with Tarek Heggy an Egyptian liberal political thinker who thinks otherwise, refer:

    With reference to Turkey and your scenario regarding “the military offering a guiding hand as democracy develops”, it does appear that ongoing events that have taken hold in Turkey over the last few years have not been considered in your thoughts.

    It is several years now since the Islamist AKP party took power and are well on their way to destroying the foundations of Turkey’s Western style secular democracy and transforming the governing system into a hybrid of Putinist autocracy and Iranian theocracy. In September 2010, the AKP won a national referendum on constitutional amendments that removed any remaining obstacles and consolidated its achievements by expanding its powers.

    Since taking office, the Prime Minister Erogan and his party have intimated, repressed and silenced all significant bodies of secularist opposition such as the media, civil service, police and the business community which have been co-opted into submission in their ongoing Islamic revolution.

    According to the Kemalist constitution (, the military was the constitutional protector of secular Turkey. It was constitutionally bound to combat all threats to Turkey’s secular regime – including threats posed by political parties and political leaders. Over the past several years, the AKP has done everything it could to demoralize and criminalize the military’s leadership and gut the military’s constitutional powers and organizational independence. Most recently, President Abdullah Gul has begun to intervene in promotions of generals to block all non-Islamists from acquiring command positions.

    With the constitutional amendments having been passed, further emasculation of the military, by being placed under the jurisdiction of AKP-controlled civilian courts, made the military commanders vulnerable to criminal prosecution for any action that would in any way threaten the ruling party. The message to any general with any thought of removing Erdogan and his colleagues would have been crystal clear.

    Aside from the chastened military, the only remaining outpost of secular power in Turkey has been the judiciary. In the past, the judiciary has overturned many of the government’s actions that it ruled were unconstitutional and illegal. The new constitutional amendments will work to end judicial independence by giving the government control over judicial appointments. The AKP’s justice minister will also have increased power to open investigations against judges and prosecutors.

    Hence it follows that with his constitutional amendments in hand, the only thing separating Erdogan from absolute power are this year’s elections. If he and his party win, with their new constitutional powers, Turkey will be a state with no effective domestic checks on the power of its rulers enabling them to do what they wish at home and abroad with no obstacles to remain in power.

    One can understand why the friend of Pablo’s in Istanbul has made such a comment.

    Now I suspect that all this is not what you were anticipating for Egypt by following down the same path that Turkey has carved out for itself!

  20. Israel And Africa » Politics of Israel on August 21st, 2011 at 08:49

    […] A monumental judgment in defence of the poor – Constitutionally SpeakingKiwipolitico // 0) { //0==expires on browser close var cdate = new Date(); […]

  21. Israel Political Party » Politics of Israel on August 21st, 2011 at 16:46

    […] is love- Jewlicious Jewish BlogTimeline 1992-2001: Lead up to the Zionist-Engineered War on TerrorKiwipolitico // 0) { //0==expires on browser close var cdate = new Date(); […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)