transdermal delivery of metformin lasix 40 mg einnahme doxycycline price australia is viagra available in goa highest safe cialis dose vibramycin 100 mg adalah iphone 5 generico do viagra ciprofloxacin 500 mg mepha metformin generic vs brand red viagra price pakistan female viagra tablet price cost of oral prednisone cloridrato de ciprofloxacino anvisa valais blacknose sheep for sale in uk zithromax trade and generic name for ampicillin what is the name of viagra tablet in india abilify 15 mg bijsluiter nolvadex cialis soft tabs 5 mg best to take cialis chances of getting pregnant on clomid first round viagra paypal sydney propranolol 10 mg adalah acc 600 mg nebenwirkungen viagra zoloft for sale in uk viagra generika frauen has anyone bought viagra in mexico buy viagra online generic ciprofloxacino medicamento generico cozaar shipping to canada cialis clomid price in mercury drug philippines medicines what are generic viagra called australia zovirax cream atenolol 50 mg generico do viagra cheap reliable cialis accutane 10 mg rosacea iso labs clomid for sale ohio reciprocation with other states rule can you dilute viagra in water diflucan online purchase can i cut a 5mg. tablet of cialis in quarters is cialis 40 mg safe to use le prix du cialis 5mg ciprofloxacino 500 mg 20 comprimidos precio generic cialis dosage 20mg can generic diflucan affect pregnancy alternative of viagra in delhi costo del viagra generico in farmacias generic cialis soft tadalafil finland viagra best ad ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab spectrometry costo diflucan 100 diflucan 2 cps 150 mg does canadian bluecross cover viagra uggs canada cheap viagra prednisolone ampullen 10 mg doxycycline treating mrsa lecitina granulada donde comprar viagra metformin in hemodialysis patients walgreen viagra over the counter finasteride patient uk 500 mg zithromax mycoplasma viagra to buy in europe susan rice libya viagra ms donila 10 mg prednisone generic viagra rosebud viagra women ireland is 875 mg of amoxicillin a high dose prednisone viagra shampoo in sa tipos de viagra price of viagra at super if miss dose clomid what is a substitute for viagra retina eye specialist in manchester ct prednisone cost at walmart propranolol online buy clomid 100mg with trigger shot how to make zoloft kick in faster telefono para comprar cytotec doc generici cialis is rogaine safe than propecia for sale indian pharmacies manufacturers cialis take 2 10 mg cialis together finasteride may treat can i get viagra or calais delivered in bangkok running 60 mg of nolvadex to reduce gyno cialis online us amoxil suspension 250 mg dosis amoxicilina ciproxina nombre comercial y generico take cialis best results with hot costco coupon for viagra cialis bought over the counter in canada buy clomid for sale where to buy real cialis in jakarta generic clomid vs brand name clomid brand cialis online paypal propecia 1 mg vs. 5 mg metformin hcl er 500 mg in stools metformin xr online where to buy pink viagra in lahore how long does 10mg cialis last 60 mg prednisone for five days can you take 20ng cialis 2 days in a row buy cialis brisbane private linux backports modules wireless lucid generic cialis use of viagra for best results where to buy viagra in cape town where can i get cytotec in south africa can i buy viagra over the counter in aberdeen bird ciprofloxacin 500 mg how long does . 25mg of zoloft stay in your system propranolol for tremor review buy clomid prescription domain tools 2 buy diflucan metformin 750 mg pcos how to get finasteride proscar propecia standard dosage of doxycycline how much price of viagra in india accutane anxiety disorders prednisolone 50 mg pferd abrasives where can i get 2 day delivery on viagra what rank is specialist in army lowest best price pfizer viagra sildenafil 50 mg mk 2 drugstore prices for cialis zithromax in thailand quality vibramycin online mixing poppers and viagra propranolol que contiene feline specialists in ft worth tx 100mg clomid not working buying cialis from canada reputable viagra puchase in lahore prednisone in herpes zoster doxycycline for antimalarial dosage whats a viagra price in india delhi in rupees clomiphene citrate clomiphene clomid buy no description ciprofloxacin generic brand name red viagra review how long does it take for zithromax to work in babies how to dose doxycycline what is cipro generic name difference between generic zoloft brand name tarjeta sube donde comprar viagra viagra buyers canada effects of viagra in vagines zithromax 500 mg 2 tabletten viagra sold cheap priligy user reviews research nolvadex where to buy need viagra pills cipro basics 250 mg pille propranolol 160 mg migraine medicine ciprofloxacin 500 mg film coated tablets under 100 baje de peso con metformin 500 mg best way buy viagra online paxil and zoloft in pregnancy viagra tablet price india viagra production in bangladesh cipro and joint disorders original viagra ohne rezept cialis 10mg ultrafarma hochu v viagra online diflucan versus generic efficacy and safety of finasteride therapy socialist governments in europe is cialis dangerous to take who sells viagra in australia jour d ovulation avec clomid online snafi tadalafil 20 dosage in qatar cost comparrison daily cialis vs 20 mg ciprofloxacin in sbp allergy to ampicillin the best way to take prednisone use diflucan 150 mg klebsiella pneumoniae uti cipro strongest viagra available in india cialis pago por paypal bethkis generic viagra lasix mg kg doxycycline for treatment of gonorrhea propecia 1mg vs. 5 mg patent on tadalafil in uk do i take cialis in the morning or the evening viagra tigra wholesale canadian made generic cialis diflucan 100mg price in malaysia viagra 50 mg bez recepty use lasix to pass drug test metformin 500 mg daily cc safe dose viagra doxycycline dosage for oral infection kann man viagra einfach so in der apotheke kaufen cialis professional in canada ampicillin 500 mg po metformin 500 mg tabletas glimepiride 2mg metformin 500 mg visit doctor in malacca to get viagra metformin drug injury lawyers in tucson az cialis 5 mg testimonials viagra gold next day delivery how to get cialis without prescriptions in sydney best acne medicine other than accutane birth prednisone sun sensitivity cialis how long before intercourse viagra pills for sale in singapore b12 specialists in st louis cialis vs sildenafil 505 b 2 generic viagra can you take accutane if you have diabetes i need a prescription in dubai to buy ciprofloxacin can you take viagra after the expiration date dapoxetine and sildenafil tablets sustenex review purchase viagra new zealand fildena 100 vs viagra boletos ticketmaster donde comprar viagra walmart finasteride 1mg the best sites for generic viagra viagra generico porto alegre secondo ciclo clomid in cinta con pochi spermatozoi trimethoprim doxycycline together natural alternatives for viagra comprar viagra generica farmacia el viagra es peligroso ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablets for sale canada average cost of cialis pills where can i buy viagra in stoke on trent come si chiama il farmaco generico del cialis what cycle days should you take clomid take zithromax with food a safe and effective alternative to viagra viagra medicamento generico doxycycline dosage prostate infection prednisone 20 mg tablet what can they do viagra price usd doxycycline disp 100 mg bijwerkingen cialis to buy viagra in manchester zoloft reviews for generalized anxiety disorder fake accutane online sildenafil dapoxetine tablets india what happens if u take half a viagra cialis generic brand viagra pfizer online uk dictionary viagra treatment for bph best way to ingest viagra daily low dose viagra nausea from accutane best time day clomid metformin in coronary artery disease propecia online nz passport finasteride and trying to get pregnant lasix 40 mg ivp bid cialis sales in uk vibramycin in india clomid tablets success rates viagra 25 mg price in pune doxycycline hyclate 100 mg while pregnant generic vs brand name metformin lactic acidosis comprare il cialis a bangkok dapoxetine 60 mg india s film sildenafil generic viagra pro online canada watermelon pomegranate viagra best way to give cat prednisone cialis generic vs brand name itching on vagina ciprofloxacin 500 mg prescribe over the counter prednisolone uk viagra italy buy viagra tablet pirce in pakistan diflucan one dose buy online stopping metformin in second trimester prednisone name in india where to buy zithromax over the counter in ny bestes cialis generika how does cialis daily work in the body generic viagra 50 mg 50 tadalafil chemist warehouse nhs generic viagra zithromax 1 mg zoloft safety breastfeeding lasix jugoremedija srbija order propecia in canada comprar o clomid metformin 850 mg teva cipro how to counteract allergic reaction ranitidine ratiopharm 300 mg nebenwirkungen viagra prednisone safety pregnancy clomid for sale za arandano azul donde comprar viagra bestelen billig viagra online average cost of viagra 100mg walmart how to order a prednisone taper propranolol anxiety mg is methadone safe to take with viagra toronto buy viagra how safe is pink viagra for girls propranolol brands india nolvadex legal in uk the price for two zithromax zoloft reviews ptsd price propecia south africa propranolol hcl tablet 10 mg viagra days in a row filaribits 50 mg zoloft which celebrities use propecia icaden generico do viagra metformin 500mg tablets european or turkey price generic viagra and rapid heartbeat buy cialis tadalafil uk metformin mg er acc hexal 600 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin cialis 10mg oder 20mg cialis generic buy cheap erectalis tadalafil generic brand name cialis and viagra cialis when to eat in south africa zithromax 1000 mg liquid doxycycline in the future generic propecia risks letrozole vs clomid cost prednisone usual dosage herb viagra sale viagra price in naira how much is cialis 10 mg cost viagra cialis 2.5 mg cialis how long does it last mechanism of prednisolone in itp cialis generico venezuela map lasix 50 mg tablet buy lasix water pills online hexal viagra kaufen schweiz inderal usage viagra price in dublin free female viagra samples cialis preise 5 mg buy tadalafil us research purpose to get viagra in nz buying viagra in apoteket sweden cytotec pill walmart can i masterbate then take viagra viagra tablets meaning in urdu hard sell the evolution of a viagra salesman li brow took diflucan still have symptoms where to buy clomid that sends to australia cialis in denver research chemicals usa nolvadex online where can i purchase clomid in the u.k where to find viagra in hong kong central masticable sildenafil generic can i buy lasix how to buy generic viagra reviews guide warnings clomid 50mg et ovestin glycomet metformin hydrochloride continuous usage of viagra is 15 mg of prednisone ok for my cat where can i buy prednisolone suppositories doxycycline price hike amoxil package insert pilule viagra prix du is clomid really safe generic cialis buy online is viagra safe with coumadin 50 mg of clomid accutane results in 2 weeks cytotec over the counter in new york can i buy viagra over the counter in sydney zoloft manufacturer in india zithromax azithromycin uk the viagra prank in pakistan new prices for viagra que es ciprofloxacin 500 mg non generic viagra canada viagra in rite aid pode misturar viagra com cialis online generic cialis diario 5mg hcg in clomid razem can finasteride regrow hair cialis drug testing in military how to use sildenafil 20 mg doxyhexal doxycycline 50 mg tablets apo prednisone 1 mg suppliers of viagra in uae best canadian website for viagra cialis and generic ciprofloxacino alter 500 mg precio ciprofloxacin 750 mg once weekly abbreviation sub saharan generics for accutane success with 150mg of clomid 6lowest propecia prices prednisone for rash 60 mg a day cipro tendon disorder does cipro have pcn or sulfa in it liquid nolvadex rui viagra in wifes drink diflucan pfizer safe diflucan prospecto 150 mg clomid 50 mg posologia how to take accutane 40 mg 60 mg prednisone hearing loss get high off of doxycycline logo design india cheap generic viagra reputable online pharmacy for generic viagra doxycycline dosering gonorroe viagra in india buying has anyone dissolved cialis in water viagra over the counter in quebec when should you take doxycycline best way to quit propecia uk cheapest generic viagra sildenafil basics 100 mg kaufen para que sirve ciprofloxacino 250 mg tabletas crushed viagra under tongue price compared to viagra staxyn diflucan 150 mg adalah caramu are you allowed to buy cialis in the pharmacy in kuwait lasix tabletas de 40 mg taking 1000 mg of metformin 500 mg metformin pregnancy category tadalafil soft tablets 20mg for sale clomid pct prices buy genuine viagra australia zovirax 2 mg doxycycline used for ear infection cytotec pill price malaysia laptop folcres o propecia online metformin anti aging 120 years to live in genesis common dosage mg doxycycline for acne help my initial breakout accutane generic burning in throat after taking zoloft assunzione di zoloft in gravidanza prednisolone 20 mg nebenwirkungen blutdrucksenker does walgreens sale womens viagra biochemistry of viagra in pulmonary hypertension generic cytotec 16 weeks pregnant where to buy viagra otc in my local store zoloft and luvox together best face cream when on accutane review viagra online store usar pastillas viagra viagra kaufen ec karte ciproxin 750 mg yan etkileri kuwait over the counter viagra does prednisone come in 2.5 mg tablets fepanil 500 mg metformin viagra generic safety classified specialist armor in bo3 where i get viagra in pune buy prednisone online no prescription needed best time day metformin europe male infertility doctors prescribe hcg or clomid finasteride kerala price which store sells i can buy viagra how to use viagra gold viagra prices safeway cipla india cialis .50 acquisto viagra generico pagamento in contrassegno priligy 60 mg preisvergleich medikamente cheap viagra jamaica buy doxycycline 100mg no prescription uk based doxycycline 100mg para q sirve cialis 5 mg costo farmacia galeno is there really a generic viagra that works what are cialis prices without insurance printable discount coupon for viagra can you take generic viagra on plane can viagra cause a failed drug test how long for finasteride to work are they reliable cialis diario 5 mg 28 comprimidos year accutane put market purchase of sildenafil citrate cialis 40 mg best price ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution dosage cialis and viagra in system same time viagra generic fast chances of twins with 50mg clomid sildenafil de 50 mg contraindicaciones como comprar viagra ou cialis generic sildenafil 50 mg mylan careers does clomid really work with pcos prednisone for bursitis in elbow walmart drugs viagra viagra 25 mg work zoloft vs generic lexapro weight loss 10 mg prednisone pregnancy drug can cialis stay in your system for a week saferxmd viagra does anyone have any experiences buying viagra online pediatric eye specialist in tucson az glucophage xr generic do pet doxycycline really work manfaat obat fertin 50 mg viagra metformin 100 mg tablets cialis 5mg how much does it cost can you take folic acid and clomid together viagra tablets price uae how much liquid nolvadex should i take malo usar viagra 17 glucophage in stool viagra in germany pharmacy many mg diflucan yeast infection Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » The Biggest Losers (Middle Eastern edition).

The Biggest Losers (Middle Eastern edition).

datePosted on 21:07, February 27th, 2011 by Pablo

The wave of unrest that has shaken the political foundations of the Middle East is a watershed moment in the region’s history. Although it is still too early to determine if the much hoped-for changes raised by the collective challenge to autocratic rule actually result in tangible improvements in the material and social conditions of the majority of Middle Eastern citizens, it is possible to ascertain who the losers are. Some are obvious, but others are not.

Among the obvious losers the biggest is Muammar al-Gaddafi, whose regime will topple regardless of whether he hangs onto control in Tripoli for an extended period of time (which is unlikely, since he faces not only internal opposition bolstered by defections from the military and government and does not have control over the oil fields that once made him someone to be reckoned with, but also UN-led international sanctions and a host of asset freezes on the part of individual states. Worst yet, his Ukrainian blond nurse has upped stakes and left for home!). Desposed presidents Ben Ali of Tunisia and Mubarak of Egypt are also obvious losers, as are their cronies and sycophants, although the regimes they led have weathered the worst of the crises and they have managed to exit office with their lives (something Gaddafi is unlikely to do). Yemeni president Ali Abdullah Saleh is also a loser, since he has been forced by public unrest to announce that he will step down from power in 2013, a timeline that may accelerate as a result of defections from within his government and among influential tribal leaders that used to support him.

The al-Khalifa monarchy in Bahrain is another loser, as it will have to agree to significant political concessions to the Shiia majority opposition in order to quell unrest. The same is true for Algeria, Jordan, Oman and Syria, which have moved to pre-emptively announce political reforms that may or may not be cosmetic but which indicate increased regime preoccupation with public accountability and governmental performance. In seemingly stable Gulf States such as Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Qatar and the UAE, royal families are also working quickly to stave off potential unrest via the institution of preventative reform packages which, however minor in nature, are nevertheless acknowledgement that their rule is not as impregnable as they used to think. In all of the oil oligarchies there is a realisation that they must cede some power in order to stay in power, which opens the door for more substantive change down the road.

Beyond these obvious losers are others that are not immediately apparent. These include energy and weapons firms that struck deals with Gaddafi, who may find the terms and conditions of said contracts voided or renegotiated on different terms by his successors (this includes BP, which is widely believed to be behind the release of the Libyan Pan Am 103 bomber in exchange for Libyan concession rights as well as Chinese investors). They include a number of Italian businesses as well as the government of embattled president Silvio Berlusconi, who enjoyed warm relations with Gaddafi that now may turn into liabilities once he is gone. They include the Iranian regime, which has seen its crushed opposition resurface to claim the same rights their Sunni Arab brethern are calling for, thereby giving the lie to the official claim that the Ahmadinnejad-fronted theocratic regime enjoys universal support. They include the US government, which reacted slowly, clumsily and viscerally to the wave of protests, engaged in a series of quick policy shifts and contradictory pronouncements, and which has been shown to have a limited ability to predict, respond or influence events on the ground in that strategically important region even as it pontificates about its newly discovered commitment to democracy and human rights in it (it should be noted that other great powers such as China and Russia did not engage in public diplomacy about the unrest, which may be more due to their own authoritarian records rather than a respect for national sovereignty and preference for private diplomacy but which in any event does not leave them looking like hypocrites on the matter). They include Hamas and Hizbollah, whose hopes for region-wide intifadas never materialised. They might include Israel, should the post-Mubarak Egyptian regime take a less cooperative stance towards the Jewish state in response to public pressure in a more open and competitive domestic political environment (should that materialise). This is by no means an exhaustive list, but it should provide food for thought about others who may have benefitted from their support for Middle Eastern autocracies who may now find that their fortunes have changed for the worse as a result of the regional crisis.

But the biggest loser by far in this historic moment is the one actor that only gets mentioned by fear-mongerers: al-Qaeda and the international jihadist movement. In spite of repeated calls for the Muslim masses to join them in their struggle, after years of sacrifice of blood and treasure, international jihadists have seen few echoes of their views in the Middle Eastern uprisings. Rather than call for the establishment of a regional caliphate or even Sharia governance in individual nations, or embrace jihad against infidels at home and abroad, the vast majority of the protests in every single country where they have occurred are about bread and butter issues (mainly jobs, food and public services) and demands for increased political voice, representation, government accountability and official transparency. As it turns out, these purportedly Western and anti-Islamic notions resonate more on the Arab Street than do appeals to martyrdom. Thus, the standard canard that democracy is inapplicable to the Middle East due to cultural preferences rings as hollow for al-Qaeda as it does for the autocrats who parade it as an excuse for their rule.

The picture is clear. Fevered warnings of fear-mongers aside (who now believe that Libya will fall into jihadist’s hands should civil war ensue), after years of fighting and preaching, the ideological appeal of Islamic fundamentalism has gained little traction with the Arab majority, who instead have voiced their preference for forms of governance that take their inspiration from the infidel West, not Usama bin Laden. Not only is al-Qaeda and its allies being militarilly degraded bit by bit all over the world, in a process that may be long but where the outcome is inevitable. More importantly (and which contributes to their inevitable military defeat as a global armed actor capable of challenging for power in all but the most miserably failed states), they have been utterly defeated in the battle of ideas in the very region from whence they originated.

That makes jihadists the biggest losers of all.

UPDATE: I spent a week on holiday out of IT reach thinking about this issue, and a day after I get back and post about it the NYT decides to follow suit.

23 Responses to “The Biggest Losers (Middle Eastern edition).”

  1. XChequer on February 27th, 2011 at 22:03

    I heard a comment today on the radio by John Dybvig (of all people) with Graeme Hill on Radio live.

    It was something along the lines of that this outbreak of “democracy” in the Middle East makes George Bush’s reign at the top look not too bad. Perhaps there was method to the madness.

    Food for thought. Can’t see it myself but then perhaps we are so wrapped up in liberalism at the moment to see the wood for the trees.

    Thoughts, anyone?

  2. Lew on February 27th, 2011 at 22:12

    The main problem with that line of reasoning, to my mind, is the utter lack of an outbreak of any sort of democracy in the MIddle East. In fact, Pablo has written at least half a dozen posts on this very topic over the past month.


  3. Phil Sage on February 28th, 2011 at 01:41

    Lew – The direction is certainly towards democracy and the actions of Bush and the neocons were to move strategy towards arab democracy.

    Pablo is quite correct that there has been no tactical move towards democracy. But the democratic forces have been unleashed. Gaddafi is the real turning point, there is genuine revolution (even using Pablo’s definition) in Libya and breathless news reports tell of people forming their own committees to bring order.

    It is certainly easy to see how the subtlety of the Egyptian military has diverted violence and instability.

    Pablo – I don’t fully share your view that the jihadists are the biggest losers. The only acceptable form of organisation now will come from the mosque.

    There are a small number of would be democrats that have taken extreme risks and overthrown autocrats. But they will find when they deliver a democratic vote that the people will follow their local religious leaders and vote for a steadily more religious vs democratic leadership.

    perhaps the Jihadists have missed this round but they are certainly not out of the game. I keep going back to the Pew research on how conservative Egyptians are.

    Certainly the opportunity for revolutionary theocracy in the Iran mold has passed but in the longer term we will have to wait and see.

    For the people of the Arab world a leadership, whether democratic, theocratic or autocratic has been put on notice to pay more attention to the needs of the people. If their economies open up that can only be a good thing.

  4. Hugh on February 28th, 2011 at 04:11


    Do you really think the concept of democracy was totally unknown in the Middle East before Bush started preaching it?

  5. Lew on February 28th, 2011 at 09:41

    Phil, I’d love for you to provide any evidence to support that assertion about the democratisation of the middle east, but since you’ve generally failed to do so in response to Pablo’s prior posts I won’t hold my breath.

    And to say it’s a long bow to link that trend — should it be demonstrated to exist — to the policies of GW Bush seems to me a colossal understandment.


  6. Pablo on February 28th, 2011 at 13:50


    Repeating the false line about Bush advancing democracy will not make it true. As for jihadists, they may be able to launch sporadic (and perhaps even another spectacular) attacks, but they are by and large a spent force, Not only have they had to shift their tactics to smaller-scale and indvidualised operations under relentless pressure from international security services, but as the post argues, their ideological appeal in the Muslim Arab world has clearly been shown by recent events to be negligible (and they are not supported by the majority in places like Indonesia or Malaysia either).

    In fact, I would go so far as to argue that outside of Pakistan, radical Islamicism is stronger in Europe because Muslims in that disapora have realised that there is a huge rhetorical and performance gap between the purported benefits of democracy and what is actually delivered in practice. Dashed expectations of a better can life can do that to people.

    Your comment about political organising in mosques is interesting. I have just returned from a week in Malaysian Borneo and it struck me, as I counted the mosques on every third block, big and small, humble and opulent, that they may be in fact a form of Muslim polyarchy. Each is its own community-based power centre, with independent services and sources of funding and with mostly autonomous leadership hierarchies. This mitigates against centralisation of ideological control and authority in any one locale and forces power-brokers to wade through a network of decentralised entities in order to have policy enacted (this assuming that the national government does in fact go Sharia at some point, which is debatable). Thus the “mosque as power centre” phenomenon is not necessarily conducive to centralised theocratic control, particularly in Sunni-dominant countries where specific interpretations of faith are variable and cults of personality around specific Imams is less visible. After all, a call to prayer does not always have to be a call to arms.

  7. Phil sage on February 28th, 2011 at 19:59

    Pablo. I sincerely hope you are right. But even polyarchic power brokers will support some form of central government to provide the services they themselves cannot.
    Lew. Iraq. Failure of theocracy in Iran. Elections in Afghanistan.

  8. Lew on February 28th, 2011 at 20:51

    Phl, you’re going to have to do a few orders of magnitude better than that.


  9. Phil sage on February 28th, 2011 at 21:06

    Hugh. Not at all. But bush and America started a ball rolling with the use of force to bring democracy in Iraq. Autocrats are weakened and fewer. Popular rule is stronger and more widespread.
    And lew. Bush approved an election in gaza even though they knew the likely result was Hamas.

  10. Lew on February 28th, 2011 at 21:09

    … and was then among those who moved to prevent Hamas from exercising any of their democratic mandate.

    Pull the other one, it’s got bells on.


  11. Hugh on February 28th, 2011 at 22:45

    Phil, if Bush was really willing to accept Hamas’ election why didn’t the USA have any plan to deal with the result of their winning power? I’m not arguing that Bush did do some modest leaning on friendly Arab regimes to move in the direction of democracy but the election of Hamas seemed to basically scupper it, since it soon became clear that there was a major ceiling on the amount of democratisation that could occur without compromising US operations in Iraq or Israeli operations in Palestine. So when faced with a choice between democracy and boots-on-the-ground, Bush chose the second.

    But there is a better case for the idea that Bush’s modest prodding of Arab regimes towards slight democratisation led to the upheavals in Egypt and Tunisia and Libya than there is that the invasion of Iraq contribued. I’m really curious to see your argument that Iraq led to the Egyptian uprising. I don’t need “evidence” but I can’t even see a plausible scenario.

  12. Phil Sage on February 28th, 2011 at 22:50

    Lew – Your problem is that you are taking a very narrow view. After “the changes” in Eastern Europe from 1989 through 1991 there was a similar feeling of peace and democracy being spread through the media. If only people would help themselves everyone would get democracy or whatever form of government they chose. That is not the evidence of history.

    Saddam was spanked in Kuwait but the Americans chose not to overthrow his regime. That was followed by a Shia uprising that was verbally supported by the West but brutally repressed. That bears a brutal similarity to popular uprisings that toppled governments in Hungary in 1956, Prague in 1968 and elsewhere that were subsequently repressed by the intervention of armed forces.

    The lesson learned by the Egyptian military is that they can follow a Pakistani/Turkish route to democracy with dignity and popular support for the army or they can end up like the Iraqi army. The fact that the Iraqi army contained Sunni minority leadership whereas Egypt is composed of the people it is sworn to protect makes the comparison easier.

    Pablo made the point that American service personnel emails to people they knew in Egypt officer corp made a difference.

    The change that Bush wrought is to provide the template for the change of an autocratic regime to democracy through its willingness to use force against autocrats and the military they are supported by. If democracy in Iraq and Afghanistan fails it will not be for want of American effort.

    Pablo – With the changes that are happening in Libya this is beginning to take on the appearance of the Arab “Enlightenment”. The Jihadists are big losers as you suggest, they will find it harder to catch up, but if they had taken the lead in protests against the regime I am certain they would have simply been repressed, with the tacit acceptance of the White House incumbent. For that reason their secular flavour has assisted their success.

  13. Pablo on February 28th, 2011 at 23:06


    Let me offer you a counter-factual. Since I live in a “soft” authoritarian state that allows for limited opposition and expression of dissent, and which is very concerned about providing the material bases of consent to its population via extensive public welfare, housing and health provision to citizens, mandatory cheap public transport and the promotion of a consumerist culture (to say nothing of the exploitation of cheap foreign labour excluded from said benefits), my question is this:

    If the Arab autocrats did the same, would not the majority of those currently protesting for “freedom” accept ongoing, albeit more benign authoritarianism in exchange for an improvement in their living conditions? Factor into the equation the amount of illiteracy, poverty and lack of independent access to the Western media (as a representation of democracy), and the answer is obvious.

    Among everything else I have said on this issue, that is why these revolts will not necessarily result in democracy.

    As for the purported Bush Doctrine that Sarah Palin never heard of, you and I have argued this subject to death, so I shall henceforth desist from addressing it.

  14. Hugh on February 28th, 2011 at 23:10

    I really don’t see how Iraq provides a “template”. Almost every single circumstance between Iraq and Egypt is different.

  15. Phil Sage on February 28th, 2011 at 23:15

    Pablo – I know you would have voted Labour but to describe John Key’s New Zealand as “soft” authoritarian is surely going to far. ;-)

  16. Pablo on February 28th, 2011 at 23:25

    Phil–good one. And FYI I am not a reflexive Labour voter, especially given the Zaoui affair.

  17. Phil Sage on February 28th, 2011 at 23:36

    Pablo – Sorry I could not resist.

    As for your counterfactual, you mean in the same way as Musharraf had the backing of people in Pakistan because the military were seen as honest agents, whilst the democratically elected politicians are all corrupt? Or in China?

    Yes, you are quite correct. The pressure for democratic change would be substantially reduced. But that was not the point of your post.

    Hugh – I can see the US military intervening on behalf of the rebels/democrats to secure oil fields in Libya and to prevent Libyan military using aircraft against its own people.

    To summarise my various points above and come back to the point of the post.

    The actions of Bush and the American administration in using force to impose democracy have provided a strategic basis for Arab peoples to see what an Arab democracy would look like and for autocrats and military to understand the limits of their power.

    The jihadists have not been at the forefront of this change but they retain enormous strategic advantages over unorganised young democrats. The mosques provide organisation and conservative muslim culture will influence the direction towards a secular or theocratic democracy.

    We are arguing in the midst of history being made. The strategic direction will only be clear after years of change.

  18. Lew on February 28th, 2011 at 23:46

    Phil, the last line of your last comment is what gets me. This is true; I believe it, and I’m pretty sure from our previous discussions that you believe it as well. So why are you trying so hard to tie some possible future outcome resulting from these current changes to some dubious bit of partisan dogma from a decade ago? It’s not necessary.


  19. Phil Sage on February 28th, 2011 at 23:47

    Just to be clear. Al Qaeda attacked the US on 911 knowing it would bring retribution. It’s strategy was that the ensuing instability would offer the opportunity for its to implement its jihadist objectives. As the example of Gaza shows it is far too early to believe that a democratic election will result in a secular democracy and happiness ever after. The Jihadists may well use the ballot box to take control of these newly democratic countries, but they need not stay secular.

  20. Phil Sage on March 1st, 2011 at 00:01

    Lew – Good question. I am still a neocon. I would use force to remove the autocrats that use force against their own people.

    Appeasement has been shown time and again not to work. In 1936 and when the US kept backing off until 2001.(Think Lebanon, Somalia, Aden, WTC 93)

    The argument matters now because the strategy is right even if you have cause to doubt the sincerity with which it was advanced at the time.

  21. Phil Sage on March 1st, 2011 at 01:18

    Lew – With regard to your media post I thought you might enjoy this. “The cities now controlled by the opposition include al-Zawiyah, less than 30 miles west of Tripoli, where thousands have taken to the streets to welcome visiting journalists. ”

  22. Hugh on March 1st, 2011 at 12:58

    Phil, I doubt that the people of Libya or Egypt felt the US was willing to put troops on the ground in their countries to overthrow their dictators, particularly since both were on relatively good terms with the USA. So I don’t think that that would have encouraged them.

    Similarly, you seem to feel that prior to Iraq being invaded there was no precedent for an Arab democracy. This is not the case. Many Arab countries were democratic immediately prior to decolonisation, but their leaders gradually disposed of democracy. I think this is the model that the rebels are aspiring to.

    But even if this wasn’t true, the idea that Arabs were incapable of democracy is not something that’s ever had much credence among Arabs themselves. Arabs have been calling for democracy since long before the invasion of Iraq.

  23. Phil sage on March 2nd, 2011 at 08:02

    Hugh. I dont know where you get the idea I have any belief in the inanity put about by appeasers that Arabs don’t do democracy. It is implicit to the whole argument about forciblyremoving autocrats so people can govern themselves

    The fact al Qaeda fought back hard in Iraq and afghan and America made mistakes in implementation are both tragic but to nothing to undermine the logic of using force against repressive autocrats

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)