generic name brand name doxycycline doryx vibramycin buy viagra online boots canada can i take aleve with clomid 50 mg of zoloft not enough obat bernoflox ciprofloxacin 500 mg klara inderal generic pret viagra online vitaros for sale in uk zithromax viagra london buy house hasta cuantas semanas puedo usar cytotec donde se puede comprar cialis sin receta requiere receta para comprar cialis 12 generic viagra overnight delivery diflucan 150 mg pfizer price in china buy cytotec online misoprostol viagra pharmacy in prague buy dapoxetine tablets 60mg cost of viagra in germany red viagra review doxycycline dosage acne 200mg low ogestrel 28 generic cialis buy viagra sofia prednisone 5 mg table te za potenciju ciprofloxacino 750 mg presentaciones girl viagra problem in urdu price viagra hong kong cipro india genuine viagra pills clomid para homens is 500 mg of cipro strong comprar viagra por transferencia bancaria can you take allergy medicine with doxycycline french over the counter cialis amoxil 250 mg dosis font price of doxycycline in chennai propecia tablets uk where i can buy metformina walgreens diflucan over the counter buspar zoloft and adderall inderal online order enalapril maleato 10 mg indicaciones ciprofloxacino sildenafil generici nursing implications for amoxil trying to conceive on clomid 50 mg generico de viagra farmacias del ahorro servicio is it possible to buy viagra in perth metformin 250 mg per day zoloft philippines price effect of clomid 50mg buy nolvadex and arimidex in canada online purchase of sildenafil in india viagra en farmacia sildenafil cost at boots for women cialis 20 mg ventajas burning in throat after taking zoloft viagra detection in urine viagra price australia chemist warehouse reciprocating seals in hydraulic sealing systems viagra in pakistan use told me urdu malaria prophylaxis doxycycline australia real viagra experiences accutane 20mg price uk stamps masterbate on cialis se necesita receta medica para comprar viagra en mexico how much does brand viagra cost at walmart liquid nolvadex and arimidex pct socialist market economy china ciprofloxacina 500 mg discount onlinepharmacy com zithromax zithromax is viagra safe to buy in canada cloridrato ciprofloxacino generico mixing poppers and viagra average age to take viagra costo del viagra in slovenia filaribits 50 mg zoloft typical clomid dosage for pct texas insurance license reciprocating states when should you take doxycycline where is it safe to buy cialis in manila farmacia online burrata viagra for sale can i buy viagra in amsterdam over the counter buying doxycycline uk nolvadex legal in thailand walmart cost of 5 mg cialis is there generic for viagra free prescriptions for cialis clomid causa atraso menstrual cialis 5 mg how long until it takes effect dosering doxycycline bij malaria nolvadex for sale no rx doxycycline how long in body zithromax in quanto tempo agisce pre k count specialist in pa generico viagra doctor simi vs barney buy accutane online 30 mg adderall xr where to buy generic cialis made by aurochem most beautiful houses for sale in uk zithromax how much is viagra in average propranolol 80 mg sustained release buprenorphine keratin retard vs propecia generic ciproxin 500 mg prima o dopo pasti can take accutane after rhinoplasty zoloft and wellbutrin costco pharmacy prices viagra can i buy viagra online in india will metformin 750mg show up in drug test ciprodex cost with insurance viagra for wemon is it real cialis generico da 5mg hydrocodone como comprar viagra generica papagaio que tomou viagra generic dental implant specialists in glenwood u.s. prices for cialis 20 mg. viagra prices drop soon safe get pregnant after accutane viagra tenormin interaction a safe and effective alternative to viagra icaden generico do viagra risks for lactic acidosis in metformin users buyers cialis imflac 25 mg of zoloft sildenafil iv cost illegal purchase viagra lowest best price pfizer viagra viagra prices nz viagra canadian health care iso labs clomid for sale online viagra sales uk street balue 20 ml cialis generic vega cream sildenafil finasteride 5 mg actavis can i order cialis from canada clarithromycin vs ciprofloxacin tab obimet sr 500 mg metformin price of viagra in doha qatar glucophage para que se usa best price viagra without prescription viagra in the store como comprar cytotec en ecuador buy viagra spray for women 30 mg accutane journal clomid pregnancy symptoms buy viagra canada no prescription suflet de gheata generic viagra cytotec in phils where can i buy tadalafil in powder form where to get viagra in switzerland finasteride buy uk bacne scars accutane cost bst price for cialis in canada cialis sicher online bestellen pintura para ropa donde comprar viagra canadian overnight pharmacy products cialis free where can viagra substitues be purchased cytotec online satin al is there generic cipro over the counter propecia in canada cold sore cream zovirax over the counter zovirax ointment for cold sores generic how long does a lasix renogram take comprar viagra generico contrareembolso significado necesito comprar cytotec en bogota adams idea a7os womens reviews on viagra how many ml of nolvadex should i take 5 mg of prednisone for 4 year olds generic viagra coming us can a 14 year old buy viagra quel dose cialis how long before sex should i take cialis 20mg how long does take for viagra to start working cialis pricing and usa buy sildenafil united pharmacy viagra en gel tadalafil cost in india doxycycline hyclate overnight delivery inderalici 10 mg para sirve how many eggs clomid 100mg blestemata fie clipa de demult generic cialis propecia order abroad priligy en belgique weaning off propranolol 20 mg direction liquid cialis walmart viagra prescription propecia online pharmacy renova stimula sildenafil 50 mg para jovenes does accutane cause suicidal thoughts order propecia fedex natural viagra drink chlamydia treatment ampicillin zovirax 250 mg propecia 1mg pills doxycycline 100mg capsule for sale viagra gold next day delivery socialist governments in europe cuanto cuesta en mexico el cialis 5 mg best water pills lasix where to buy viagra in cape town doxycycline 100 mg prix maroc pc cialis 20mg safely how often where to buy abortion pills misoprostol cytotec ritemed ciprofloxacin price mercury drug is dapoxetine available in australia on the pbf tabletki viagra 100 price acheter viagra en belgique generic viagra australia price is taking 2 viagra safe sildenafil 20mg prices in england doxycycline hyclate used for std free trial offer for viagra anyone buy clomid online before doxycycline capsules 100 mg bp made by pakistan can you take viagra after the expiration date ampicillin biochemistry dilution zithromax cheap lormetazepam cinfa 1 mg comprimidos viagra is methadone safe to take with viagra where to buy cipro uses for travel diarrhea buy cialis online in montreal can i buy viagra in netherlan generic viagra from india price buy zithromax overnight delivery buy cialis online in india best way to administer doxycycline to my pigeons research chemicals usa nolvadex online generic viagra usage differenze tra cialis generico e originale prednisone dosage 50 mg price buy viagra legally in australia prednisone eye drops price diflucan salbe kaufen priligy 60 mg preisvergleich medikamente cyriax 500 mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg cassava and clomid together university research on generic cialis propecia online espana cytotec pastillas para abortar en costa rica cialis 40 mg after effects mechanism of antabuse half life of prednisone 50 mg cialis blue cross blue shield cost in ny use of viagra 100mg viagra tablets price uae how many viagra in a prescription viagra tablets for women price pakistan zithromax walmart over the counter texas generic viagra belgrade cialis walmart oc viagra generic viagra generic viagra stl prednisone versus corticosteroid is cialis available over the counter purchase cialis in vancouver bc how much is cialis in hong kong viagra kaufen dubai my accutane story metformin hcl 500 mg versus metformin clomid 50 mg posologia generic cialis mexico pharmacy ciproxina nombre comercial y generico cialis usa pharmacy online finasteride actavis 1mg precio sildenafil brands available in india 5 mg cialis big pack co.uk price is viagra safe with atril fibbrilation qual o problema de usar viagra buying viagra online with mastercard where buy prednisone online boots viagra northern ireland cialis in orange prednisone mylan 20 mg posologie viagra onsale inventor de la viagra alldaychemist clomid 50mg cialis vs cialis daily evolution of socialism in sweden how many 1000 mg zithromax for chlamydia ciprofloxacin teva 500 mg filmtabletten translation pijn in onderbuik na clomid why sildenafil is used cialis 20 mg dosierung printable 20 mg cialis coupons pramil e igual viagra online how much cost zovirax cheap viagra free dapoxetine brand names in pakistan halal food prednisolone 20 mg voor honden te 3 cost generic lowest viagra vibramycin throat infection can doxycycline be taken with other medicines tadalafil rezeptfrei paypal tadacip 20 mg cipla viagra vitamin a dose accutane fabricante viagra generico doxycycline 100mg para q sirve accidentally took 2 cialis 20 mg get clomid twins where can we buy viagra. in sydney propranolol clorhidrato 80 mg genfar sildenafil citrate walmart price dose of metformin in type 2 diabetes acetaminophen extra strength caplets 500 mg metformin tapering from prednisone 60 mg cipro xr para que se usa buy priligy in lebanon witch cialis pill for best resaults glucophage can cause a metallic taste in the mouth metformin and aldactone for pcos doxycycline 100mg iv diluted in d5w how much did viagra cost when it first came out how much is viagra in tj wholsale viagra ebay cytotec pill price malaysia laptop can 5 mg of cialis lose its effectiveness clomid users in nigeria auryxia generic cialis formula del viagra can you buy viagra over counter italy viagra in ottawa over counter brand cialis sale positive opk 3 days in a row clomid and twins can eating viagra once help in performance anxiety venta donde comprar cialis argentina sildenafil price ukulele is there any business that will ship viagra to canada pomada dexametasona generico do viagra safe dosage cialis can i take two viagra in two days utente generico de cialis carbamazepine 200 mg indicaciones metformina acquisto viagra generico pagamento in contrassegno zoloft and generic propecia long term effectiveness day 50 accutane generic normal dosage finasteride cialis directions 20 mg man takes viagra tsa pat down is there a viagra 200 mg or is it phony efectos viagra generico cialis 10mg opinion corticosteroid induced adrenal suppression prednisone viagra use in which afe 20mg cialis costco cost 100mg clomid still not pregnant cialis online sito affidabile cipro xr ciprofloxacino 500 mg candizole tablet 500 mg metformin benefit of clomid in urdu order diflucan single dose cheapest cialis index buy cytotec online with mastercard by viagra in south africa diflucan buy europe cialis pago por paypal viagra discount generic what mg is propecia cryselle generic equivalents for viagra cytotec pills in kuwait how is doctor is it safe to tan while taking accutane how much does legal viagra cost buy zovirax tqeovertoz doxycycline hyclate tablets softlets uses how cytotec be effective in abortion is viagra safe for pey ronies is 500 mg metformin effective zoloft for sale in uk clomid 50 mg price australia deltacortene 10cpr 25 mg of zoloft 80 mg lasix cialis bay in tesco testosterone pills vs viagra viagra pharmacy uk cialis online prednisolone dose for kids inderal public speaking reviews of london cialis prix boite leben und arbeiten in thailand erfahrungsbericht cialis when do you take clomid to ovulate livraison rapide cialis canada clomid price rite aid metformin monitoring uk will it hurt anything to cut a cialis tablet in half can you take viagra into spain cialis 20 mg p buy viagra from romania clomid purchase in australia similar pill of viagra price in indian rupees is 875 mg of amoxicillin a high dose prednisone viagra review 50mg can i take 15 mg of cialis every day cytotec pill in malaysia flight viagra in combinatie met poppers best ovulation predictor kit clomid side what is ciprofloxacin used to treat in humans apidra generico de cialis viagra spray in uk buy cialis pharmacy online the best viagra online zovirax 5 cream price buy doxycycline hyclate 50 mg online no prescription ampicillin maximum dose acimed 20 mg prednisone is it safe to take viagra while drinking cipro oral liquid where can i buy prednisolone suppositories dapoxetine onde comprar alfazema will doxycycline treat ear infection capitalism vs socialism in the us provera and metformin pregnancy safe best place buy viagra uk do antihistamines counteract cialis 24 mg prednisone and then taper down for rash how to dose doxycycline generic viagra cheap accepts paypal where can buy viagra in brisbane how long doessunrise cialis 20 mg last will taking half a viagra work does glimepiride contain metformin socialist republic of macedonia is in what time zone cialis how much mg sildenafil citrate cenforce 50 reviews how long does a 50mg viagra last obat ciprofloxacin 1000 mg cialis 2.5 mg en mexico how to buy viagra over the counter why do you need to take prednisone in the morning rabozol 20 mg prednisone viagra tablets to buy ship it international pfizer viagra 50 mg drugs online cialis clomid fertility uk desi viagra brands in delhi precio cialis 5 mg mexico best to take cialis amoxil liquid refrigeration ciprofloxacin for uti prophylaxis in neonates propecia kaufen europa viagra over the counter in manilla buy viagra online aramex costco cialis coupons pode misturar viagra com cialis online como comprar viagra sin receta en costa rica accutane 40 mg twice a day workout metformin time release generic buy viagra in aberdeen how many hours before to take viagra inderal 80 mg migraine relief viagra headquarters canada snopes effect of ciprofloxacin in yasmin contraceptive mannings zithromax over the counter hong kong donde comprar viagra nicaragua kann man viagra rezeptfrei bestellen viagra active super viagra generic viagra stl subaru vivio rx r for sale in uk zithromax generic version of cytotec esiste il cialis da 5 mg viagra in hahnemann blood in urine after taking cipro cl eveland viagra prices csie nctu edu tw tashong p generic zoloft is bangladesh marketing viagra olandis 10 mg prednisone cheapest viagra no prescription nz generic finasteride nzs costo spedizione cipro buy generic finasteride online 1 price of red viagra in pakistan buy viagra online australiaq blood in urine z pack and prednisone viagra generico en mexico sildenafil citrate use in elderly zithromax 200 mg5 accutane dosage chart weight bars in the viagra triangle viagra used daily what can be used in place of cialis wellbutrin and viagra together viagra pills for sale in singapore generic metformin bertibarots when cialis generic available buy cialis in irland taking 100mg of clomid viagra in jersey can you take viagra with carvedilol what is the name of female viagra priligy uk lloyds pharmacy donde comprar viagra granada does kaiser permanente pay for cialis cost costo del viagra generico in farmacias cialis prix allemagne sildenafil tablets 100 mg review creamy discharge on clomid cialis avec paypal buy zoloft online australia propranolol 40 mg obat apa viagra generico a napoli zithromax 250 mg cpr 6 navy 20 mg prednisone and pregnancy is zoloft available in liquid form dapoxetine baownbeuv reviews mechanism of action of cialis in bph price of viagra keeps going up does viagra make you real sleepy Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Traction

Traction

datePosted on 16:12, October 21st, 2009 by Lew

hide-rort

The story of Rodney Hide’s ministerial fundraiser is making headway — at present, it’s the splash spot on stuff.co.nz and is pretty prominent on the Herald site as well.

This image is strong. Close-ups are rarely flattering, and this one has an unctuous, indignant defensiveness which evokes, well, just about every crooked politico in history. The text, leading with the universal refrain of officials on the take and following up hard with that beloved word ‘rort’, gives the audience all the necessary context. This is a position Hide has spent his political career avoiding, and one which he was once merciless in prosecuting. It’s a long way to fall.

It seems that the credit for this should go to Eddie, who drew together its various strands into the narrative we now have. It’s been picked up by a few blogs, including Red Alert, where Phil Twyford published his own clearly-derivative-but-not-attributed riff on the topic earlier today, complete with Goff’s press release which forms the basis for the NZPA story. And it looks like Eddie even chose the photo which Stuff ran with — only one is flipped on the vertical. Well done.

Update: Lyndon in the comments points out that the threads were in fact drawn together by North Shore mayor Andrew Williams in the first instance, and published on Scoop.co.nz – so Frist P0st credits there, although the Labour response seems more derivative of Eddie’s work than that, so my point largely remains.

L

16 Responses to “Traction”

  1. SPC on October 21st, 2009 at 22:13

    He’s only setting an example for those in local government to follow, how to use public service(s) to make a privatised profit.

    It’s only a matter of time after convincing oneself of what one is peddling to then buy into it personally and act out.

  2. Phil Sage on October 22nd, 2009 at 07:39

    what a pathetic beat up. business breakfasts have been common for years. Hide is not gaining personally.

    Pot. Kettle. Black.

    http://www.innercitypress.com/undp1hclark072709.html

    Inner City Press: the head of UNDP, Helen Clark, gave a speech in Washington at the Women’s Foreign Policy Group, and they charged $250 admission. Is there any kind of rule applicable to UN officials speaking in a for-pay environment and who reviews, obviously it was a fund-raiser, but what comment do you have on that?

  3. Eddie Clark on October 22nd, 2009 at 09:34

    Phil – on the core point, you really think this is a pathetic beat-up? A Minister, speaking in his capacity as a Minister is charging a fee which is paid directly to his political party. This is clearly a different situation than, say, one of the ridiculously overpriced LexisNexis seminars, where conference fees go to the organising company, not a political party.

    It’s absolutely repugnant that you should effectively be forced to donate to a political party in order to have access to a Minister.

    As for H Clark – she’s always had a bit of a nasty dictatorial speech which I won’t defend, but this looks like a standard overpriced corporate conference. Happy to be corrected on this point, but in any case I think you’re just trying to deflect attention from Rodney: “they did it too” is the utterly pathetic defence of the desperate. I believe the term is ‘derail’. Also, I thought the right was sposed to have better standards of behaviour than ZanuLiarbour.

    Finally – shame on Twyford/Goff. Plagiarism isn’t good, and how much bloody effort would it have been to h/t the Standard on Red Alert?

  4. Lew on October 22nd, 2009 at 09:37

    Phil, the post isn’t about the substance of the allegations against Hide — which are manifestly a matter of political opinion — but about how the story has arced in the media. The electorate will decide whether it’s a beat-up or not. That’s what they do.

    As to the comparison with Clark — what you’ve done is demonstrated quite aptly how partisans and media actors with an agenda select which information they prioritise in service of that agenda — just as Eddie did when putting the story together. The difference is that you did it as an off-topic distraction rather than as a legitimate contribution to the political media discourse.

    L

  5. Tom Semmens on October 22nd, 2009 at 09:48

    This is interesting. For the first time, The Standard has achieved what Farrar and Slater have done for years – planted a story, had it picked up by the journalists who interview their web browsers, then had Labout pick it up as an attack line on the government. They are still not very good at it – something that should put paid to the right wing line they are “run out of the ninth floor” or wherever else now – as they didn’t follow up today with the trademark Farrar cut-and-paste of the Herald article with skewed commentary, and then tomorrow with 20 questions for Rodney, followed up by another angle on Friday evening…

    Speaking of Kiwiblog, my hasn’t it slipped into shroud waving irrelevance lately? Farrar is faltering badly, with his mask slipping and more and more he his simply playing to his base with sneering commentary being posted up.

    Perhaps the internet is a tool best suited to the opposition?

  6. Phil Sage on October 22nd, 2009 at 10:01

    Lew/Eddie – Yes I really think it is a pathetic beat up. getting worked up over semantics. Part of the grind of politics is fundraising. For the party, not for personal gain.
    The fact that people find it more convenient to pay a premium to go to a breakfast is neither here nor there. It speaks to the apathy of Labour’s position right now and the depth to which the media must dig to pretend to bring some balance to coverage that this makes news.

    For a minister to speak to a local government crowd on his area of responsibility in a public environment is so non wow.

    And Lew – you are repeating the BS. Pretend you are commenting on Eddie getting some traction in the MSM.
    Whatever.
    I would have expected better from you.

  7. Phil Sage on October 22nd, 2009 at 10:04

    What is far more interesting is the way Obama has picked up the Clarkism of going after unfriendly media and suggesting the rest of them gang up.

    That man is struggling. And it is going to get much much worse if he blames his problems on one media outlet now.

  8. Lew on October 22nd, 2009 at 10:10

    Phil,

    If you can highlight where I’ve ‘repeated the bs’ I’d appreciate it. I’ve commented on the framing and what aspects the media have emphasised without endorsing or criticising them: just the facts of their publication. If simply looking at the evolution of the story and what aspects of it are most prominent makes me complicit in a ‘beat-up’ then I suppose I’m guilty as charged; but by the same token, it makes you complicit in a ‘cover-up’.

    The appropriate liberal response to bad press isn’t to criticise of the media for undertaking their mandated functions — it’s to use the media and those same functions to generate good press, if you can. By all means, do. If you can’t, well, that’s quite telling.

    L

  9. Lew on October 22nd, 2009 at 10:13

    Phil,

    Crossed comments. I agree entirely about Obama and the War on Fox, etc: it’s both idiotic and counterproductive and whoever is behind the campaign is a fool.

    But here you are, running distraction lines to direct attention away from your own targets and toward what you perceive to be ours, again. Why?

    L

  10. Eddie Clark on October 22nd, 2009 at 10:40

    Phil – stop derailing.

    If you disagree with Eddie (the one who isn’t me)’s views, and/or mine – fine. But I do think its odd you’re saying “This is a pathetic beatup” in the same breath as saying “LOOK OVER THERE INSTEAD”!

  11. Pablo on October 22nd, 2009 at 13:22

    Phil: I am not sure why you are venting this distracting line, nor why you do not accept Lew’s point that he is writing about the coverage, not the substance of the matter (which I thought was obvious from the get-go).

    However, because you usually have something to contribute on track of the post, I shall offer two comments on your deviationist line: On the Obama/Fox “war” please read my comments on the dedicated post on the issue over at DPF’s blog (posted yesterday). There is more than meets the eye going on (Lew might want to check it out as well). My comments are too long to repeat here.

    As for charging for meetings with senior politicians. Actually, a sitting Minister usually goes for free and the covering organisation charges a fee for access in order to defray expenses. In some cases, such as Council on Foreign Relations lecture/seminars, the fee can be quite high and attendance restricted depending on who is the luminary being presented. Helen Clark spoke as the guest of a third party organisation, and the fee would have fallen under the rules I have just described.

    Here the issue is that Hide is charging for access to himself, with the monies going to ACT. That is very different than third party hosting of his presentation. Had the Rotary, U3A, Athene, Aorangi or some university political science club held the event, the fee (or a koha) would be acceptable.

  12. lyndon on October 22nd, 2009 at 15:18

    Andrew Williams on Tuesday, for what it’s worth. Though the only person who seems to notice that was David Thornton.

  13. lyndon on October 22nd, 2009 at 15:24

    … and on the Scoop front page Tuesday too :)

  14. Phil Sage on October 23rd, 2009 at 08:46

    “…It’s a long way to fall.

    It seems that the credit for this should go … Well done.”

    Lew is just independently pointing out a left blog scoop that has made msm without passing judgement or supporting the intent.
    Just the facts m’lord.

    Yes Lew, black is white lew, whatever you say lew.

    And the right blogs repeating stories about Clark and her husband were just analysing the message, not repeating the beatup.
    Bush, Clinton any number of politicians hold fundraisers. People pay to hear the opinion of someone close to the heart of power and these politicians are going through the grubby business of raising funds from people who are voluntarily prepared to pay. In this case aimed at local government in Canterbury wanting to listen to the future from the minister
    It is mere semantics and a pathetic beat up. If Hide had advertised the subject as something more subtle he would not have been pinged.

    My comment on Clark was not to distract, merely to point out the hypocrisy.

    But crack on. It just indicates how desperate the left is in New Zealand at present if this leads the news.

    Interesting series of comments at kiwiblog pablo. I feel your premise is weak though. The White house is bullying. It would do better to mock Fox than martyr them. But I guess when one of obamas tight circle of communicators professes her undiminished support for Mao and the regime that killed 70m he may have problems with advice grounded in reality.

  15. Lew on October 23rd, 2009 at 09:53

    Phil,

    It’s a long way to fall from being renowned as the perk-buster to being implicated in a ‘rort’.

    The credit for breaking the story into the media should go to Eddie who (or so it seemed; it seems others scooped him) did the research and argument that journalists otherwise should be doing — they at least seem to think it has merit, else they wouldn’t have run it. Well done because it’s not easy to gain such cut-through as someone operating outside the system (or on its fringes).

    For the record, I never claimed to be independent in this — in fact, I’ve repeatedly stated that you can’t separate your own politics from what you choose to examine, and that the best you can do is declare them and be scrupulous in arguing the issues. I drew attention to this situation for the reasons Tom identified: right-wing bloggers (two in particular) frequently break stories into the wider media and consequently have a significant impact on public discourse about politics. The left does so only much more rarely, and it is thus much more remarkable when they do. Right blogs reporting stories about Helen Clark’s personal life, her personal characteristics and qualities, and engaging in the sustained sort of character assassination that they did is a different matter entirely — there’s no indication of personal or private malfeasance in Eddie’s claim; onyl a matter of public interest which the electorate can decide to care about, or not. You will not find me calling for personal or private attacks against politicians of any sort, nor will you find me criticising those who raise legitimate (or debateable) matters opf public probity for discussion in the media, regardless of their affiliation or the targets of their criticism.

    For what it’s worth I think (as someone who’s not a lawyer) that there’s no legal merit in the allegations against Hide (or Roy, although that case seems more serious), but however much you might like it to not be so, it is most definitely a matter of legitimate political dispute, just as many previous non-legally-significant-but-morally-or-ethically-suspect topics have been for prior governments. The moral and ethical tests are not fundamentally assessed by the Cabinet Manual or Parliament; they are the purview of the electorate.

    So, Phil, you can complain about a VLWC if you like, but all you’ve really done here is highlight your own reflexive defensiveness of your ideological corner. If you’d wanted to contribute to the discussion in some meaningful fashion, you might have remarked on why such an apparently baseless topic is treated seriously by the media. If there’s really truly nothing in it, why does anyone care? That’s the matter I’m really interested in: why this story, and not any other?

    L

  16. Phil Sage on October 23rd, 2009 at 16:09

    Ah Lew – Your next post is more balanced so I forgive you now. ;^)

    “If you’d wanted to contribute to the discussion in some meaningful fashion, you might have remarked on why such an apparently baseless topic is treated seriously by the media.” – I did. ” It speaks to the apathy of Labour’s position right now and the depth to which the media must dig to pretend to bring some balance to coverage that this makes news.”

    I love captcha – Westminster bedpan – Which is about right really

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: