what happens if you take more than 1 viagra in a day is proscar cheaper than propecia we can reduce finasteride taken once in a week where can buy propecia in singapore cost of lasix medication where i can get viagra in vancouver b.c clomid 125 mg getting viagra in south africa cytotec ohne rezept kaufen viagra samples generics viagra online.at vesicare 5 mg bijsluiter nolvadex how can we find viagra in shoppers drug mart viagra online without prescription maestro card cost doxycycline tablets uk prix viagra pharmacie maroc want viagra in kolkata socialist organization in 60s 70s in calif pyralin en ec 500 mg metformin the discovery of viagra dapoxetine india pharmacy no script how much does 25mg viagra cost tadalafil 25 mg kaiser price for cialis menhancer viagra online why did accutane get recalled comprar viagra por internet en chile dias ns1 comprar propecia net is it safe to take viagra when you have gout what is the difference in male and female cialis lasix 40 mg para q sirve achat viagra 100mg does accutane cause birth defects later in life finasteride generico italia 100 mg clomid werkt niet pfizer viagra prices online viagra pfizer tablets que es ciprofloxacina 500 mg y para que sirve viagra price in australia who is the viagra woman in the blue dress purchase azithromycin or doxycycline why increase clomid dosage para que sirve cialis 10 mg buying viagra in lanzarote buy cialis en doha quelle est le prix du viagra en pharmacie prednisone and singulair viagra australian actress robbie cipromed ciprofloxacin 500 mg cipro otic dosage viagra online pens brand names for finasteride how much is viagra in tijuna falcon brand prednisolone eye drops misoprostol cytotec in riyadh consigo comprar viagra na farmacia guadalajara 1 month accutane results in a month cialis generica for you metformin for weight loss safe viagra soft tabs kaufen where to buy 5 mg brand cialis finasteride therapeutic use tadalafil 2.5 mg testimonials buy zithromax locally prednisolone in india viagra 12 mg comprar cialis contrarembolso clomid to get twins is legal to order generic viagra cytotec price in mercury drugstore philippines hiring estimated date for generic viagra how to get viagra in the uk prednisone 10 mg 54 899 pfizer generic zoloft price will one 20 mg cialis lower bp how much for exam pfizer viagra overnight delivery cialis and vwalmart zovirax price compare rayos prednisone reviews for back how soon before should i take viagra viagra tunisie prix how much does cialis cost after insurance ciprodex otic bayer suspension cost good viagra online cost of tadalafil at walmart buy cialis dapoxetine order doxycycline hyc 50mg cap mutual qty 20 costo cialis nelle farmacie comprar propecia en mexico viagra pfrzer ireland can i take ambien with viagra propranolol 40 mg 3 times a day recipes nu doxycycline 100 mg cytotec in italia viagra for sale craigslist how many pills in viagra stock bottle assistance in paying for cialis doxycap doxycycline capsules bp 100mg kann man viagra rezeptfrei in apotheke kaufen extenze or viagra ampicillin 250 mg 5 ml is viagra covered under medicare cheap generic black cialis can you get viagra in boots ciprofloxaxin name in bahasa indonesia buy sublingual cialis authentic brand viagra for sale will propecia keep hair in the front paypal viagra payments generic lunesta myonlinemedsbiz propecia viagra buy viagra calgary counter shelves how long does zoloft stay in the body zithromax online europe pharmacy 250 mg viagra on line viagra online shipped monthly prednisolone 50 mg preisvergleich waschmaschinen clomid como usarlo is viagra legal in peru come comprare viagra o similitude cheapest viagra on the internet metformin 250 mg 1 x day viagra in india stores in dallas how much mg of viagra should i take zoloft generic brands of vicodin buy propecia online without prescription can i buy doxycycline buy lasix overnight patient reviews of accutane vetprofen generic propecia doxycycline discount prices use mastercard bizcochos de soletilla donde comprar viagra will the cost of viagra go down viagra in apotheke metformin 500 mg buy in usa canadian propecia online zovirax in pill form cost cialis 20 mg information prednisone pred 10 corticosteroid nasal spray cialis 100 mg mi 20 mg mi cialis perda de visao swidar 500 25 mg zoloft where can i buy genuine clomid viagra delay spray kaufen price list of of zoloft in philippines where to buy cialis in sa voli low cost per cipro da venezia diclocil 500 mg bivirkninger av prednisolone fertility clinic london clomid twins buying viagra online is it safe canada cialis fast shipping why propranolol is contraindicated in diabetes mellitus how much money does clomid cost success of clomid at 100 mg uk finasteride dr singh generico do viagra onde comprar livro generic propecia review opinion buy ciprofloxacin cream can buy cytotec philippines 10 buy mg nolvadex comprar cytotec brasil how many mg prednisone for poison ivy review zoloft for anxiety viagra tablet name for men in kolkata viagra cialis on usa rx generic viagra cost to produce best face wash use while accutane metformin er dose folgard rx generic viagra is 20mg cialis be split cialis market priligy buy online singapore pharmacy how long is a viagra prescription good for in ny many mg viagra can you take what is propranolol used for in humans erofast sildenafil 50 mg onde comprar how long before cipro kicks in pneumonia accutane roche usa can i get priligy on the nhs viagra websites that accept paypal cost of iui with clomid and hcg what happens when you take half a cialis pil biru viagra usa is filagra really a viagra subsitute counterfeit viagra test kits zithromax 1000 mg uses review sildenafil actavis 100mg can u buy viagra at convenience will i get into to trouble for buying viagra online buy generic dapoxetine virtual viagra review fitoestimulina generico de cialis finasteride reviews bodybuilding is it safe to take doxycycline with food karsivan 100 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin wall green generic viagra bula cialis generico portugal neonatal lasix dosage v herbal viagra alternative canada can i buy cytotec over the counter in the philippines zovirax tab 500 mg is it safe to rake viagra with ampplodine where to buy propecia in philippines will i have to take viagra forever average price of diflucan sildenafil kaufen apotheke generic viagra combo pack donde puedo comprar cytotec en villavicencio finasteride patient reviews sildenafil citrate cost in india is it safe for diabetics to take viagra amoxil use by date comprar cialis sao paulo qu est ce que zithromax how soon should i take cialis propecia cost london kolonada wafers buy online uk viagra prednisone pressure in eyes cialis compare price viagra 100mg yahoo answers lasix is used to treat what prednisone in the treatment of ulcerative colitis cialis 5 mg tadalafilo metformin in colon cancer treatment viagra and cialis in combination generico do viagra 2012 viagra free delivery uk is viagra safe with avalide buy doxycycline online without a script carvedilol generico de cialis 10 mg of prednisone cause water retention where can i get cialis in sydney dipidolor 15 mg bijsluiter cialis metformin hydrochloride 1000 mg weight loss prevention diklofenak t orifarm 50 mg biverkningar av metformin generic cialis professional 40 mg comprar viagra pelo correio where to buy cialis uk how long does viagra stay in a 12 yr olds system free cialis tablets free free trial viagra paypal cialis 20 cut in half how long does it last can a man take more than 100 mg of viagra uses of ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg generic name zoloft zovirax cold sore cream australia how long does it take for zithromax to work doxycycline mono 100 mg cap lose weight ontario physician specialized in prednisone withdrawel cialis tablets price in pakistan n8 not ovulating on clomid 150mg viagra 50 mg cpr4 bula sildenafil anvisa nerve pain in back from prednisone tadalafil and dapoxetine reviews on washers bagomicina 100 generico do viagra clomid 50 mg dawkowanie tranu is it safe to conceive while man on viagra generic viagra vendors online viagra reviews uk thuoc largactil 25 mg of zoloft can you take zoloft in the morning and at night who has taken accutane lasix medicine uses canada online pharmacy propecia where can buy viagra in belgium over counter viagra and cialis discount generico da pomada zovirax internet pharmacy cialis buy online generic finasteride work for anyone where is the cheapest cialis generic fin vs propecia clomid for men take in morning or at night is celerity stand viagra safe father indian pharmacy viagra locasalen salbe beipackzettel ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin 750 mg indications for pacemaker what are the ingredents in cialis is there a generic drug for zovirax thuoc acetyl leucine 500 mg metformin zithromax pos 600mg 15 ml mercury amoxil safe in breastfeeding why did the price of diflucan go up viagra taken with l arginine clomid iui costs sildenafil gel over the counter comprare cialis thailandia locked in syndrome viagra retail cost for viagra half life of clomid in men propranolol 60 mg be split in half are mexican viagra safe buy viagra co uk best moisturizers for accutane phenoral 50 mg zoloft can you take clomid if you have pcos viagra 50mg price in egypt finasteride 5 mg for women hair loss studies cialis 20 comprar wirkung viagra nach samenerguss in der how dose the five mg cialis work sildenafil use in pulmonary arterial hypertension what happens if a young male takes viagra cialis overnight online tadalafil 5mg cheapest place to buy it us viagra price metformin 1000 mg daily zithromax 500 mg effet secondaire top 10 viagra like foods high in protein natural equivelant ingredient in sildenafil where to buy cialis in calgary without a prescription can accutane cause eczema can you get viagra in stores propecia in new where can i buy lasix on line without a prescription ritemed metformin 500 mg where i can buy cialis in dubai ovulating on clomid but not getting pregnant why ayurvedic substitute for viagra packungsbeilage cialis 20mg cialis black online mastercard canada correct dosage for doxycycline where can i buy cheap propecia tablets is 40 mg a high dose of prednisone how to get viagra in denver can you split 20mg cialis how many clomid cycles is safe places in melbourne wher cialis is sold ciprofloxacin in prima luna de sarcina tadalafil mechanism of action in bph icd doxycycline safe kids can we get original cialis in thailand socialist party ireland sildenafil sandoz 100 mg tableta viagra generic buy american express ordering viagra pills generico do viagra qual melhor non prescription diflucan 150 mg oral tablet canadian cipla viagra red viagra gialis 200 mg uses online viagra shopping india propecia online dream pharmaceutical viagra from doctor uk achat de cialis online cost of lasix surgery finasteride 5 mg film coated tablets for sale cheapest cialis generic intitle posting and toasting viagra in australia online degree doxycycline whartisthebestin uses safe daily dosage prednisone zithromax liquid refrigerate or not order cialis on line viagra female effects cipro xr 500 mg viagra purchase paypal payments unitidazin 10 mg prednisone key viagra online inderal la and exercise review lasix online tablets c can 40 mg prednisone cause heart problems vibramycin safe during pregnancy clomid working but not getting pregnant patient reviews of viagra canada no prescription cialis ampicillin allergic reactions indian brands tadalafil and depoxitine buy genuine clomid online red dragon viagra user reviews buy viagra chennai zovirax 800 mg price uk rare 100mg zoloft 300 mg wellbutrin for anxiety where can i buy viagra in portugal buy viagra in perth australia time is two year old cialis safe to take aval 320 mg generico do viagra 20 mg prednisone moon face syndrome how long does zoloft stay in your body samples of generic viagra sildenafil 100 mg pharmacokinetics diuretic lasix cost cost of viagra tesco como se usa clomid buying cipro without prescription with mastercard optimax duo 500 mg metformin results of taking 200 mg of viagra buy cialis 10 ml in new jersey ci cipro mg doxycycline mylan 100 mg posologie liquid cialis research chemicals alldaychemist cialis over the counter viagra prise en charge high power viagra tablets in india viagra online super active amoxil suspension 250 mg dosis jewelers cialis 5mg se puede usar con doxyciclene doxycycline price increase reasons prednisone 5 mg ivf due buy viagra reviews glimepiride metformin hydrochloride tablets comprar viagra mercado libre citalopram for anxiety 10 mg prednisone doxycycline effects in pregnancy viagra upset stomach viagra buy singapore condo would zoloft show up in a drug test doxycycline hyclate price in philippines purchase sildenafil pills finasteride online without prescription cialis mit paysafe bezahlen cialis once daily 2 5 mg viagra cost walmart canada long term use of finasteride taking 40 mg cialis artical que es amoxil 500 where to buy cialis c10 pills how much is clomid in canada ubat metformin 500 mg much does one month propecia cost propecia receding hair generika viagra preisvergleich success rates of iui with clomid ucinok viagra generic buy real cialis online canada how to buy tadalafil from india how to purchase viagra with paypal cialis 5 mg werking donts in taking viagra getting a doctor to prescribe viagra online fosforos carlos herrera viagra online high on prednisone doxycycline used to treat heartworms what is thw work of sildenafil tablet 120 mg viagra for sale without press ciprofloxacin 500 mg 100 count bottle rocket cipro 500 mg dis iltihabi prednisone 5 mg moonface blonde actress in acura cialis quantos anos pode usar viagra ricetta prescrizione viagra for sale where to find viagra in vegas genericos if sildenafil 20 cheap zovirax bertibarots lowest price for cialis 20 mg cialis and viagra used together misuse of doxycycline zovirax labiale in allattamento si anglo nubian goat for sale in uk zithromax sildenafil 50 mg works good premature ejaculation mercedes benz c55 amg for sale in uk zithromax viagra in einer apotheke kaufen low dose accutane 40 mg cheap viagra in us does 80 mg modified propranolol help with hot flushes can you buy prednisone in the airport in turkey viagra sildenafil citrate tablets amoxil 400mg tid price over the counter options to viagra purchase viagra in kolkata generic tamoxifen vs nolvadex during cycle accutane shop online chinese herbal viagra ireland efectos secundarios viagra generico viagra cheap toronto natural alternative to propranolol cialis in tucson top viagra store online com how long does 60 mg of propranolol last paying with paypal to order viagra types of viagra in india wiki answer can propecia cause mood swings osteoform 70 mg generico de cialis viagra in galway dapoxetine india sun pharmacy sildenafil axapharm kaufen is there generic for viagra with caremark estrangulamento de la pela tadalafil 20 mg genuxal 50 mg zoloft can propecia cause shedding positive clomid reviews acquisto viagra online realtor online prescription for priligy generique viagra 100mg accutane 40 mg 5 months zithromax 100 mg per teaspoon how much does propecia cost on the nhs online sildenafil uk does prednisone show up in drug tests how much is zithromax in pakistan top level domain generic viagra ciprofloxacin 500 mg from canada nombre generico de viagra uses of ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablets viagra vs cialis dosage chance of twins with clomid 50 mg precio de diflucan 100 mg how did pfizer market viagra viagra tablets name list cost of propranolol 120 mg trapped gas in stomach after taking doxycycline hyclate zithromax 250 mg price in malaysia teva prednisone 5 mg effets secondaires Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Resentful reactionary ethnocentric cultural protectionism

Resentful reactionary ethnocentric cultural protectionism

datePosted on 18:55, August 17th, 2009 by Lew

Buy Robyn Kippenberger an atlas, and a history of New Zealand. The chief executive of the RNZSPCA was on The Panel (audio; starts at about 06:15) this afternoon talking about the killing and eating of dogs, as opposed to other critters. Quoth Ms Kippenberger:

I think it’s generally agreed that we have companion animals in European countries, and we don’t eat them. […] I guess that New Zealand is a country that is largely European, and Māori, and none of us eat our dogs. And we’re also … and that’s the main culture in this country. […] I mean, if you want to eat dog, then go to Viet Nam, or go to China, or indeed, maybe go to Tonga.

In the immortal words of that noted killer and eater of critters, Barry Crump: hang on a minute mate. I have a few questions for Ms Kippenberger. In no particular order:

  • Who’s this ‘we’ you’re presuming to speak for, again, and who gave you the right to speak for them?
  • Since when was New Zealand a ‘European’ country? It’s in the South Pacific; the same part of the world as Tonga, incidentally.
  • Given that Māori brought dogs with them to Aotearoa for the express purpose of eating them, how exactly is it culturally offensive for Māori?
  • Upon what basis do you define ‘New Zealander’ as excluding Chinese, Viet Namese and Tongan people?
  • Why do you presume to go on the radio and talk about matters on which you are clearly not informed (viz: geography, Māori history, cultural identity and multiculturalism)?

She goes on:

What we’re saying is, it’s culturally insensitive to do it here. Other cultures tell us what is culturally insensitive to do in their countries. I don’t think that it’s anything other than giving people the heads-up that if they live in this country, actually, we don’t like what they’re doing if they do that.

The underlying discourse here is something along the lines of:

The whole world is PC and everyone gets to have their meddling way, telling us what we can and can’t do, so us whitebread suburban honkey hand-wringers are going to take this chance to draw a line in the sand, to the north of Asians and Islanders, and to the south of Māori (but not Māori as they actually are; but only as we feel like we are supposed to think of them, as rather like us, only brown).

(My words, not hers).

Yes, many New Zealanders object to the killing and eating of pets, particularly dogs. But liberal, multicultural society is quite capable of handling these differences internally. The SPCA is not an agency of cultural arbitration; as Ms Kippenberger has so aptly demonstrated, it is not equipped to be such an agency. Even the CEO doesn’t have the skills or inclination to come up with any better argument than assimilative monoculturalism, and can’t even get the most basic facts and logic of that feeble and reactionary argument right. Its mandate should be limited to those things it knows about – advocating against cruelty to animals while they’re alive, for example. There’s no argument here that the animal was treated cruelly, so the SPCA has no business being involved.

Animal rights and welfare activists should be likewise angered by this. Ms Kippenberger, who ought to be a champion of your cause, has demonstrated that it is led by fools whose attitude to cultural difference is ‘go back to the Islands’.

L

33 Responses to “Resentful reactionary ethnocentric cultural protectionism”

  1. Matty Smith on August 17th, 2009 at 18:59

    “cruelty of animals while they’re alive.”

    Nitpicking, but animals are alive when they’re killed. :P

    Otherwise, in total accord. Good post.

  2. Lew on August 17th, 2009 at 19:05

    Thanks Matty, you’re the accidental subeditor. “Cruelty of animals”? Even I wouldn’t know what the hell I meant. Duly edited.

    L

    (N.B: Nitpick ignored :)

  3. Adolf Fiinkensein on August 17th, 2009 at 19:47

    Gives a whole new meaning to ‘hot dog.’

  4. Matty Smith on August 17th, 2009 at 19:55

    A very small note in Kippenberger’s defence, she did also raise concern about the hygiene of the meat, raising the spector of the dog’s ‘worm load’. Stray cats and dogs are pretty fetid, so it seems a reasonable point. She probably could have built a whole argument around health and safety. The SPCA has actually contacted the NZ Food Safety Authority, but unfortunately it sounds like they’ve requested a set of ‘do not eat in NZ’ species, and not clarification on health and safety.

  5. O on August 17th, 2009 at 22:00

    Greetings – long time lurker, first time poster here.

    I too had the misfortune of hearing this afternoon’s ‘Panel’. (Why Julia Hartley Moore continues as an occasional panelist after her drubbing at the hands of ‘Mediawatch’ amuses me no end. Her contributions to the dog discussion made Kippenberger appear positively balanced. [And get a load of what she had to say about Bennett’s latest targets!])

    Wikipedia tells me a kip is a type of cat. It is therefore clear to me that Ms Kip-in-burger is in no position to lecture anyone on the rights and wrongs of pet-eating!

    Seriously, however, it must also be pointed out that the SPCA has never, ever championed the pursuit of animal rights (as opposed to the exploitation-laden notion of animal ‘welfare’).

    Underlying discourse to my mind also consisted of “don’t expect ‘our’ national values to change in the slightest as a result of the gradual accrual over time of new residents.”

  6. millsy on August 17th, 2009 at 23:50

    If you really want to go down a certain road, it might be worth pointing out that Robyn Kippenberger used to be Robyn McDonald, New Zealand First member of the 1996-1998 cabinet.

  7. Pat on August 18th, 2009 at 07:31

    Eating Pit Bulls seems like an excellent idea, and addresses two problems at once. We should encourage the killing and eating of any unregistered Pit Bull found wandering the street.

  8. SeaJay on August 18th, 2009 at 07:41

    Matty Smith: Mr Taufa’s ‘too skinny dog’ does sound rather wormy.
    It would appear this poor animal is better out of it, but does the spca need to look at the lifestyle of this dog (what was its name?) prior to conversion from pet to meat.

  9. Lew on August 18th, 2009 at 09:51

    Matty, SeaJay,

    If the dog was unwell or a health risk, then that’s a matter for consideration by (either) the SPCA before its death or food safety authorities afterwards. But as I understand, you can pretty much feed your family what you like, and long may that remain.

    Kippenberger is just stretching for any pretext she can in order to prevent her cultural attachment to widdle doggies from being offended.

    L

  10. Lew on August 18th, 2009 at 09:58

    O, welcome.

    Seriously, however, it must also be pointed out that the SPCA has never, ever championed the pursuit of animal rights (as opposed to the exploitation-laden notion of animal ‘welfare’).

    A very good distinction, yes.

    It’s easy to get people to donate money to an organisation which argues that little doggies and kitties and bunnies should be treated nicely, and not so easy to get people to donate to an organisation which argues that doggies, kitties and bunnies, not to mention lambies and piggies and calfies are morally or ethically equivalent (or near-equivalent) to humans – as PETA and SAFE and associated groups have found out.* The question of animal rights implies much greater responsibilities and lifestyle changes than folks are prepared to accept. Animal welfare, on the other hand, is easy to feel good about and doesn’t require anything much other than an occasional donation.

    Underlying discourse to my mind also consisted of “don’t expect ‘our’ national values to change in the slightest as a result of the gradual accrual over time of new residents.”

    Yes, exactly. I wonder how that balance would change if (when) NZ was (is) more brown than white?

    L

    * Although I would add that PETA and SAFE are their own causes’ worst enemies at times.

  11. Boganette on August 18th, 2009 at 10:10

    Why is having a cultural attachment to dogs less valid than not having a cultural attachment to dogs? I’m sorry if I’m misreading it but I think it’s kind of rich saying that this man’s cultural belief that it’s OK to eat dogs is just dandy but SPCA woman’s cultural belief that it’s not OK to eat dogs is evil.

    I mean granted she’s an idiot and she’s not helping herself or the SPCA by saying stupid idiotic things on the radio (and the TV and in print) but still…why is her cultural view on dogs so unacceptable but his isn’t?

    And do the SPCA really deserve SO much criticism just because one of their reps is kind of slow in interviews? The SPCA does alot of good shit. I certainly wouldn’t want to be a front-line worker dealing with abused animals.

  12. Lew on August 18th, 2009 at 10:28

    Boganette,

    I’m sorry if I’m misreading it but I think it’s kind of rich saying that this man’s cultural belief that it’s OK to eat dogs is just dandy but SPCA woman’s cultural belief that it’s not OK to eat dogs is evil.

    It’s not her cultural belief that I’m objecting to – it’s her forcing it on people whose beliefs differ, and trying to define her belief as a NZ norm without consideration of the fact that she doesn’t have the authority to do so.

    And do the SPCA really deserve SO much criticism just because one of their reps is kind of slow in interviews? The SPCA does alot of good shit. I certainly wouldn’t want to be a front-line worker dealing with abused animals.

    This isn’t ‘one of their reps’, this is their CEO. And I’m usually not in the habit of giving agencies a pass for idiocy because they sometimes do other good things or because their front-line workers have it tough.

    L

  13. Boganette on August 18th, 2009 at 10:47

    “It’s not her cultural belief that I’m objecting to – it’s her forcing it on people whose beliefs differ, and trying to define her belief as a NZ norm without consideration of the fact that she doesn’t have the authority to do so.”

    I’d agree with that. I do think she’s completely out of line with 99% of the things she’s saying.

    And fair point on your last comment too. I must have missed that she was the CEO I thought she was just a spokesperson. And yep I agree they shouldn’t get a free pass because of the good things they do. Though I do think on the whole the SPCA do get it right. They’ve just been incredibly cringe-worthy on this issue.

  14. NiuZila on August 18th, 2009 at 10:48

    I am a Samoan, born and raised in New Zealand. I was very disheartened to read the CEO’s comments. I thought we had moved on from mono-culturalism to at least bi-culturalism. It appears as though multi-culturalism isn’t part of the SPCA’s vocab.

    Apparently the incident happened in February, but imagine if the media hadn’t plastered it over the air-waves and newspapers – people would’ve continued living their lives.

    That’s the difference between Mr Paea and Mrs Kippenburger. Mr Paea wasn’t forcing other people to follow his culinary recipe. Mrs Kippenburger on the otherhand wants everyone to follow her moral upbringing.

    Although as a Samoan eating dog is not a delicacy, I want to defend Mr Paea, because for all we know he is a New Zealander just like you and I. And as a New Zealander we can’t be ignored and made invisible by the CEO’s comments. If she represents New Zealanders, then she should represent me AND Mr Paea, not just the white ones.

  15. Neil on August 18th, 2009 at 11:22

    It’s not her cultural belief that I’m objecting to – it’s her forcing it on people whose beliefs differ, and trying to define her belief as a NZ norm without consideration of the fact that she doesn’t have the authority to do so.

    but it is true that in NZ it is not normal to eat dogs.

    That we eat certain animals and not others is not some sort of random cultural aberation. Sheep and cattle are herd animals whose behaviour has been utilised for domestication. Dogs and cats are very different. Monkeys are very different.

    Mass producing those sorts of animals for food would require cruelty as they would be kept in conditions very different from their natural conditions.

    Maori may have eaten dogs initially but that didn’t last past the introduction of European domestic farm animals.

  16. What would Hayek say on August 18th, 2009 at 12:48

    This post and comments inspire me to shed a bit of culinary info – some readers appear not to be aware of the vast array of flora and fauna consumed in NZ’s history (and rather recent history at that).

    The SPCA CEO should read A DISTANT FEAST: THE ORIGINS OF NEW ZEALAND’S CUISINE, by Tony Simpson, FIRST CATCH YOUR WEKA: A STORY OF NEW ZEALAND COOKING. Mrs Beaton’s book on household management is historical magistry on things cooking and practical (like what to do when your rent is overdue).

    Anyway heres one updated classic receipe to have alongside hot dog.

    CASSEROLE OF POSSUM
    PREPARING THE POSSUM
    1 possum, smallish female if possible.
    Skin and bone the possum (use only the best meat for the casserole, ie: the strip loins and hind quarters, cubed). Reserve the carcass and trimmings for stock.
    INGREDIENTS
    • 1 onion
    • 1 clove garlic
    • Clarified butter and olive oil (enough to brown meat without becoming dry)
    • 1 cup dry red wine
    • Flat or field mushrooms sliced (big meaty ones)
    • 2 tblspns fresh herbs – a mix of rosemary, thyme, marjoram, dill and parsley
    • 1 tblspn tomato puree
    • 1 cup dark beer
    • 1 cup brown possum stock
    • 1 tblspn Marsala
    METHOD
    1. In a heavy pan, heat the clarified butter and oil
    2. Sauté onion and garlic. When onion is clear, remove to casserole
    3. Dust the cubed possum with flour and brown in batches. Add to casserole.
    4. Melt a little more clarified butter and sauté bacon and mushrooms. Remove to casserole
    5. De-glaze pan as necessary with red wine – add this to casserole together with herbs, ground pepper, tomato purée, beer and marsala
    6. Stir, cover and cook in slow oven for 2 -3 hours, adding more possum stock if necessary.
    SERVING SUGGESTION
    Top with pastry or serve with little caper dumplings made with gnocchi mixture
    Garnish with lemon zest and chives

  17. DeepRed on August 18th, 2009 at 13:03

    If you really want to go down a certain road, it might be worth pointing out that Robyn Kippenberger used to be Robyn McDonald, New Zealand First member of the 1996-1998 cabinet.

    Now the jigsaw pieces are falling into place.

  18. Lew on August 18th, 2009 at 13:33

    Neil,

    but it is true that in NZ it is not normal to eat dogs.

    Is ‘not normal’ grounds for prohibition?

    That we eat certain animals and not others is not some sort of random cultural aberation. Sheep and cattle are herd animals whose behaviour has been utilised for domestication. Dogs and cats are very different. Monkeys are very different.

    Dogs and cats are animals whose behaviour has been used for domestication, as well. In fact, the dog has a much longer history of being domesticated than any herd animal.

    Whether we eat them or not is a cultural question, not a question of biolological or evolutionary determinism.

    Mass producing those sorts of animals for food would require cruelty as they would be kept in conditions very different from their natural conditions.

    Keeping other animals for meat doesn’t require cruelty? You don’t believe that. I accept it might be more cruel, but that’s a very tricky argument.

    WWHS,

    Possum is good eats. Doesn’t taste like chicken though.

    I’ve seen that recipe, and have been trying to catch the central ingredient for it, who lurks around my house. No concerns about poor diet or ill heath here, I know what the bugger eats: pohutukawa flowers, two kinds of apples, plums, nectarines and banana passionfruit from our trees.

    L

  19. What would Hayek say on August 18th, 2009 at 14:18

    I tried deep fried spider in Cambodia – kinda gooey is the best I can say – but hey for a time it was a protein source for very hungry people.

    The history of french peasant food would be a fun PHD history thesis – identifying just how hungry you have to be to eat snails, and then do so often enough to figure out how to make them pleasant to eat.

    Hedgehog I’m told is best cooked by wrapping it in clay and then baking in a fire, that way the spines come off when you crack open the clay wrap.

    For your possum problem, have you tried a Timms possum kill trap with a slice of apple in it? Generally effective – a friend has recommended also using dehydrated mashed potato as a bait. Need to be careful about domestic pets if your in an urban area.

    You could also try a multi purpose trap, which doesn’t kill the possum – but then you have to figure out what your doing wuth it afterwards, and generally releasing a pest out into the wild again would defeat the original purpose.

    By the way I’m jealous that you have banana passionfruit growing – have not been able to cultivate them.

  20. Neil on August 18th, 2009 at 15:42

    Dogs and cats are animals whose behaviour has been used for domestication, as well. In fact, the dog has a much longer history of being domesticated than any herd animal.

    Whether we eat them or not is a cultural question, not a question of biolological or evolutionary determinism.

    There’s a very good reason why we farm cows for food and not dogs. It is about evolution – see Jared Diamond.

    Is ‘not normal’ grounds for prohibition?

    I have no problem with it being pointed out to people that in NZ it is not normal to eat dogs. Banning eating pets might make sense. Humans often do not do very well caring for pets, raising pets for food just makes matters a lot more complicated.

    Dog owners are particularly prone to having very little understanding of the evolved behaviour of their pets – often with tragic consequences. I doubt that any one who wants to eat their pet dog has a great understanding of those issues. In this case the dog had already been ill-treated.

    Raisng animals for food should be left to professionals and even then we do like to have that closely monitored – eg pig farming. And those preofessionals I doubt will opt for cats or dogs.

  21. Lew on August 18th, 2009 at 16:12

    Neil,

    There’s a very good reason why we farm cows for food and not dogs. It is about evolution – see Jared Diamond.

    Again with the ‘we’ – who?

    The bare fact is that dogs have been domesticated for food (among other purposes). Arguing Diamond to say that they’re not ideally suited to it (and I agree!) doesn’t negate the reality that it actually factually happened, and still does.

    L

  22. NiuZila on August 18th, 2009 at 16:29

    Hi Neil and Lew

    I can’t help but feel that Neil (and others) thinks Mr Paea is not part of New Zealand. Mr Paea maybe from Tonga but it is most likely he is now a citizen on New Zealand. Just as I am from Samoa, but born and raised in New Zealand, I too have cultural differences to other New Zealanders.

    The discussion seems to be about ‘them’ and ‘us’, but New Zealand is not a homogeneous society and never was (apart from pre-European times). We are all part of New Zealand.

  23. What would Hayek say on August 18th, 2009 at 16:38

    Cat, dog etc are simply a form of game meat. Moving on from possum stew we now offer:

    BEER ROASTED CAT
    1 cat cut into roast
    1 can of Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom soup
    1 cube of beef bouillon
    1 clove of garlic
    1 Fine Stout

    Cover and soak cat roast in salt water for 24 hours. Drain water and then cover and soak in beer for 6 hours. Drain and place in crock pot with your cans of soup. Add a clove of garlic, and a cube of beef bouillon. If you start to slow cook your cat in the morning with your Cooker (or it’s ilk), you’ll have finely cooked feline in time for supper.

    If a slow cooker is not available, a cat can be baked at 350 degrees for 2-3 hours in a conventional oven and still come out pretty good. Beer Roasted Cat is fantastic served with mashed potatoes, collard greens, and fresh, homemade egg rolls. When planning a full meal just remember- cat is a course best served hot!

    Cat may not be the most glamorous, or tastiest of game meats, but with a little thought and preparation, Baked Cat can make the belly of the persnicketiest diner glow with home baked goodness

  24. David on August 18th, 2009 at 19:32

    As were talking about eating pets!

  25. Lew on August 18th, 2009 at 22:06

    WWHS, I can’t believe anyone would consider making a home-cooked meal based around a ca…

    …n of soup :)

    L

  26. Lew on August 18th, 2009 at 22:27

    NiuZila,

    I don’t think that’s quite justified – to my eye Neil isn’t so much arguing that the whitebread suburban honkey hand-wringer (hereafter WSHHW) cultural practice be implemented as of obvious right (as Kippenberger is); he’s advocating that it form the basis for policy; the implementation of an actual regulation to give effect to the cultural practice.

    Thats’s a whole different thing, and democratically valid – if the populace of the country was sufficiently riled by this dog-eating business to lobby parliament to pass a law to ban it, with due consultation and discussion of the social and cultural ramifications of that, then fair enough. I would still disagree, but at least he’s not using his elite status as the CEO of a very prominent and well-regarded NGO to beg the question and promulgate assimilationism dressed up as common sense.

    L

  27. Neil on August 19th, 2009 at 08:24

    The bare fact is that dogs have been domesticated for food (among other purposes). Arguing Diamond to say that they’re not ideally suited to it (and I agree!) doesn’t negate the reality that it actually factually happened, and still does.

    how was this dog “domesticated for food “? If this dog was well taken care of and fed properly it would have cost a great deal more than going out and buying half a lamb. Most likely this dog was left to scavanage around the neighbour uncared for. Calling it a “pet” is stretching it saying that this dog was bred for eating is unbelievable.

    i think this notion that dogs are bred for food is a myth. They occasionally get eaten but most often in the Pacific pigs are bred for food. Dogs are pathetic creatures that scavange round the villages and don’t make particularly good eating.

    If someone wants to go out and shoot wild dogs and cats in the bush I have no problem, if they wanr to cook them up over a campfire that’s fine – but I suspect that they have no great appreciation of food.

    In the city it’s quite different and there’s enough of a problem getting dog owners to treat their dogs well as pets let alone as food.

  28. Neil on August 19th, 2009 at 08:57

    It’s the innate socialisation patterns of animals that have led to their domestcation for particualr roles. Dogs were domesticated not for food but for hunting.

    They are social animals that bond – and bond with people. A well cared for dog will have bonded with its owner. And a good owner wil have bonded with their dog. Eating your “pet” dog is good evidence that the dog was ill-treated.

    As a general side note on people and pets, until proven otherwise I assume a dog is more intelligent than its owner.

  29. Lew on August 19th, 2009 at 08:58

    Neil you can think it’s a myth all you like – the fact is that they are bred for food – I’ve seen (and smelt) it with my own eyes (and nose); it’s very well documented and frankly beneath debate.

    As regards the definitions of ‘pet’, see my response to Boganette.

    L

  30. Neil on August 19th, 2009 at 09:46

    bred for food in the Pacific? Maybe before pigs.

    OK so in South Korea they raise dogs for food – and as you detail it’s not a pleasant sight. But that’s my point – raising sheep and cattle for food does not necessitate cruelty since the process utilises their innate behaviour patterns. Farming dogs can only ever result in dog prisons as you describe in SK.

    Dogs are not the same creature as sheep. They were domestciated for different purposes and were able to be domesticated for different purposes because of their quite different innate socialisation patterns.

    I should probably have made a clearer distinction between “raised” and “bred”.

    Pet animals are very different from farm animals. Farmers don’t actually eat dogs in NZ although they will eat “pet” sheep. Show me a farmer that eats dogs and I’ll show you someone who is cruel to animals.

  31. Neil on August 19th, 2009 at 12:27

    but to summarise, I think that there are very good reasons bassed on biolgy for treating some animals differently to others.

    It’s not merely a a matter of a culturally arbitrary sentimentalism a you suggest Lew.

    The reason I oppose whaling is not because I have some logical oppostion to eating whale meat but because the practicalities of getting that meat onto ones plate cannot avoid the torture of an animal to death. And the Japanese govt are very keen to charaterise anti-whaling views as culturally arbitrary sentimentalism.

  32. Matty Smith on August 19th, 2009 at 16:45

    @Neil

    We’ve bred dogs to ape our emotional cues – as companions – and they’ve adapted to exploit that relationship with us. That doesn’t mean we have not also bred them for their meat, and it does not mean farming dogs is any more cruel than farming any other intelligent mammal.

    In the Pacific Islands dogs don’t serve as ‘pets’ in the way I think of the word. They fill a very similar function to pigs. They’re valued less than pigs. Generally, they’re allowed to roam free, they get a limited amount of affection, and they end up on plates. Just like pigs, they’re clearly cared for and bred with food in mind.

    Pigs and sheep are both extremely intelligent, social mammals. Pigs are certainly more intelligent than dogs, and sheep have intricate social lives. Their ‘innate behaviour patterns’ conflict with the the way they are treated and sometimes with the ways they are confined. These animals don’t submit lightly or happily to been torn from their young; having pieces chopped off them with pliers while they’re in infancy; being confined when they are inclined to roam; being man-handled, herded, and chased; being trussed up; being transported from place to place smeared in their own shit; and then being killed despite making their best efforts to avoid it (if they possibly can). If you name a way of procuring meat that doesn’t violate the animal’s clearly expressed will, I’ll fire up the barbie and supply the beer. In mean time, farm animals suffer a happy life punctuated regularly with unnecessary torture, horror and fear, ending in the ultimate deprivation.

    Your reasons for opposing whaling are my reasons for opposing meat in general.

    I worked closely with farm animals for the first 18 years of my young life. You are romanticising both familiar livestock and current farm practices for the sake of your argument.

    (It strikes me that conservation might be a better tack for you to take, if you’re looking to eat meat AND oppose whaling. Whale numbers aren’t too crash hot, and with ocean acidification and depleting fish stocks, they’ll need all the help they can get over the next few hundred years.)

  33. Neil on August 20th, 2009 at 08:08

    @Matty

    I agree with a lot of what you say. I suppose I’m arguing about degrees of mistreatment. That with some animals using them for meat necessitates a greater amount of mistreatment.

    But you’re right, any meat has a price to pay into terms of animal welfare.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: