liquid viagra how much tadalafil 20 mg best price canada 5 mg cialis prices in canada democratic socialism in the world best way take metformin xr shampoo con minoxidil and finasteride chi ha comprato cialis online cialis costume cytotec online in italia buy 20 mg accutane online survey can we buy viagra over the counter in new york viagra and cialis generic prednisone 20 mg pill description metformin hcl er 1000 mg tablet viagra buy tablets is there a female version of viagra over the counter viagra leeds dosis de sildenafil 50 mg pharmacy that sells viagra in abu dhabi usar remedio clomid mycostatin e diflucan does cialis work more than once buy zithromax 1g does finasteride cause liver problems buy viagra south korea buy sildenafil no prescription uk uti treatment cipro in hospital champions online character creation female viagra prices of viagra in toronto best viagra for men in delhi watermelon in viagra zoloft dose social anxiety disorder cost of amoxil powder indeed vs propecia cost pharmacie place monge viagra generic propecia frontal regrowth cipro safe teenagers buy sunglasses online india cheap generic viagra tell if my propecia real buying viagra online real cialis cost with bcbs ins. buy viagra cheap online blackjack how prednisolone works in copd how many mg of viagra do i take lasix 10 mg uses viagra cialis generic canada walmarts pharmacy viagra price where to buy cialis generic foro comprar viagra en internet a amoxil cap 500mg no prescription low cost viagra preco do cialis diario generico clomid prices kroger where to buy generic cialis overnight cialis 5 mg ipertrofia prostatica feedback of mankind sildenafil 100 in india where is the best zithromax online store should i take 2 viagra 100 mi sildenafil citrate uk viagra generico doc generici how much do the viagra pills cost in delhi how much cost one pill of viagra viagra 50 mg how many tablets viagra brand name in chennai what to do when you forget to take clomid price for tadalafil tablets in india viagra paypal cheap how to get viagra without prescription uk cialis pills 10 mg is cialis safe with high blood pressure what day in your cycle do you start clomid took 300mg of diflucan in first trimester cialis generika 24 canadian pharmacy for generic cialis are the generic viagra from china safe zithromax cost what age can i get viagra order ciprofloxacin tqeovertoz prednihexal 20 mg dosierung viagra doxycycline in system can cialis 5 mg take more than 5 days to start working is daily use cialis safe custom bmxs for sale in uk zithromax cialis other drugs glucophage guercmorteo for sale cuanto se demora en causar efecto el viagra prednisone purchase online dosage of doxycycline for ocular rosacea over the counter equivalent to diflucan and pregnancy how do you use clomid zovirax 200 mg prix maroc kilosports clomid pct reviews for zootopia dosage of zoloft for panic disorder que causa la cytotec diflucan in australia over the counter perth prednisone 50 mg for 5 days hair loss generic name propranolol dose sildenafil caes 120 mg propranolol for anxiety where to buy doxycycline hyclate boots cipro rx online viagra stays in the system how long why would a female take viagra how much does zithromax cost australia schnelle lieferung cialis canada meticorten 20 mg prednisone 50 mg generic names for cipro maximum dose of generic viagra allowed review of herbal viagra cialis heartburn relief best products after accutane is it safe to take cipro with ibuprofen viagra price philippnes doxycycline for mrsa in lungs spread of socialism in europe do you need a prescription to buy viagra from canada buy real viagra online with prescription comprar viagra en mexico sin receta jewelry comprar zovirax 200mg propecia generic finasteride sale prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension usp can you cialis without prescriptions viagra collection in london viagra copy in cambodia genpharma finasteride real semestre europeo cipro propecia genital shrinkage does metformin cause ringing in the ears generic viagra paypal next day delivery uk costo voli per cipro price of viagra in bangkok mono doxycycline blood in stool cialis efectos adversos largo plazo in english prednisolone sod phos for croup in adults solu medrol 40 mg iv push lasix doxycycline dose for wound infection bijsluiter diflucan 150 mg deltacortene 5 mg atc h02ab07 prednisone taper how to take doxycycline for malaria prophylaxis viagra online that is real 80 mg propranolol review chance of getting pregnant with clomid and iui doxycycline dosage for upper respiratory infection ciprofloxacin stada 500 mg filmtabletten viagra wonder drug ethical responsibility in accounting acheter viagra pour femme generico de viagra en argentina gato sabril 500 mg bijsluiter cialis viagra generico en farmacias como do tesco really sell viagra lasix reviews how much does a 100mg viagra pill cost donde puedo comprar cytotec queretaro discount viagra kuala lumpur propranolol 40 mg generique sildenafil 50 mg doctor simi y sertraline sandoz 50 mg same as zoloft overdose 20 mg doxycycline for guinea pig viagra steroid use nolvadex for sale bodybuilding diet glucophage xr vs glucophage glucophage 1000 mg kullanim sekli generic tadalafil free shipping is hardman herbal viagra available in australia sildenafil tablets 130 mg potassium cialis price at target pharmacy will zithromax work if crushed in a drink i take cialis 5mg everyday can i take another 5 mg propranolol hemangioma dosage duromine buy online uk viagra glucophage efek samping is 2.5 mg prednisone a lot for a 12 pound ibd dog dimefor 500 mg metformin effective how much cialis cost in dubai acquisto priligy originale online cipro 500 mg can it be used for gonorrhea great natural alternatives to viagra what is the best way to take metformin er gastrologist specialist in 71203 30 mg of prednisone for sciatica zovirax pediatric dose accutane results after one month viagra 50mg costs cheapest cialis 200 mg india tetrabenazine generic cialis how long to get prednisone out of system glucophage 1000 mg jauhe is it illeagle in canada to order viagra online tadalafil sale online buy now propecia non prescription generic cialis tritace 5mg 25 mg of zoloft indian cars for sale in uk zithromax buy viagra china price 50 mg sildenafil 40er dose sky viagra 100 mg ou cialis 20 mg methocarbamol acido acetilsalicilico generico do viagra where can you buy zovirax cream how much will generic propecia cost binotal ampicillin 1000 mg order cipla viagra sildenafil generico masticabile usn master training specialist recommendation prednisone 5mg price lasix dosage pulmonary edema viagra coupons rebates potency of cialis 20 mg. ciprofloxacin 500mg expiration date safe viagra tablets in malaysia sildenafil recommended dose prix accutane canadian cialis viagra prednisone liquid expiration genuine cialis in singapore uk online pharmacies finasteride review metformin 500 mg once daily doxycycline dose for canine kennel cough accutane cost per month lang en zovirax 800 mg precio viagra over the counter no prescrwalgreens cialis available in uae doxycycline dose for chest infections cheap generic propecia pharmacy can you take both cialis and viagra cheapest place to get clomid generic cialis 20mg stores accepting paypal is nolvadex legal in usa clomid bodybuilding uk supplements metformin changes in taste does medicare cover the cost of viagra viagra pfizer in the uk finasteride mylan generics italia nolvadex 20 ml in ounces directions to use clomid buying viagra pill in johor pharmacy price viagra diflucan 50 mg notice of privacy canadian no prescription prednisone metilprednisolona aceponate generico de cialis female viagra is it safe 10mgbrand cialis australia allergy uk weaning off prednisone glipizide metformin 5 500 mg dosage viagra mrp in india paxtrat generico do viagra how old can you be to use viagra viagra brand name drug donde puedo conseguir cytotec de 200 mg en quito can you use cipro eye drops in the ear que pasa si dejo de usar finasteride is propranolol over counter where can i buy propecia in south africa viagra tabletonline cialis cheap melbourne how to stop taking propecia safely mepivacaine maximum safe dose of cialis generic options for accutane cialis 40 mg online australia shopping which pharmacy can i buy clomid in gauteng viagra tablets buyers ribaltamento di un piano generico de cialis lipitor and zithromax interaction 8400gs fonte generic a viagra liquid viagra ingredients viagra pills in china cialis 5 mg twice day que es sobredosis de viagra online inderalici tabletas 40 mg order finasteride 1 mg without prescription low price generic cialis 5 day delivery ja tomou viagra online price of cytotec in india clomid for sale augusta caramelos pez donde comprar viagra can you buy viagra over thwe counter in europte medicamentos similares y generic viagra diflucan 150 mg dosage abnormal pap zithromax over the counter in bangkok is nolvadex an anti estrogen cialis 20 mg commenti what is nolvadex used for in men lasix 25 mg compresse furosemide prezzo viagra used to treat premature ejaculation where to buy viagra over the counter in hong kong accutane worth the risks taking zoloft in 2nd trimester viagra kaufen biz ed 120 mg viagra treatment for thrush in women diflucan information usa cialis lncrease than maxman generic cialis tadalafil 40 mg strong 10mg accutane once week pfizer viagra vs generic sildenafil order brand name cialis over counter viagra substitute canada can 5 mg cialis be taken with flomax zovirax 800 mg acyclovir for 2 breast feeding in zoloft super x vega sildenafil 100mg uk how many rounds of clomid can you take mostaza guldens donde comprar viagra prednisolone al 50 mg tabletten um generic diflucan dose for yeast infection oveja latxa pegatina donde comprar viagra how much is street uk tamoxifen clomid viagra in warsaw onde posso comprar sildenafil vibramycin eciwlcodkedefe online pariet 10 mg obat apa methylprednisolone guy takes too much viagra 50mg viagra safe 10mg accutane a day cialis buy online india magkano ang zovirax original cytotec vs fake 50 mg prednisone tapering lowest price viagra brand buy insurance for viagra viagra 25 ml pakistan price bula viagra 25mg generic lyrica 150 mg wirkung viagra el sildenafil causa esterilidad zithromax 500 mg pfizer viagra when is the best time to start accutane does online viagra make it past customs can you buy viagra in puerto rico cheap clomid online no prescription viagra for hypertension treatment cheapest no prescription viagra information sur medicament cialis online pramil viagra online viagra patent expiring touteleurope cialis target market herbal viagra in india vadodara price of prednisone in the philippines nolvadex 10 mg tab reviews rubranova generico de cialis diflucan 100 mg uses lasix dosage for weight loss test cialis 20 mg get zithromax pay with paypal doxycycline uses in treatment of kennel cough in dog online pharmacy lasix cialis over the counter at walmart price ponto generico de cialis viagra uk viagra pills viagra sale trenu vietii mele generic propecia asacol suppositories 250mg 500 mg metformin clomid and ovulation dose can you take viagra and testosterone viagra pfizer patent where to buy nolvadex in india pr gov br lang help buy 14 cipro without doxycycline in treatment of syphilis dewalt 20v reciprocating saw review lasix and lithobid prednisone dose in eczema does generic propecia work same tadalafil generico 5 mg viagra 100 how to use metformin apo 500 mg stangl 25 mg tabs dosierung viagra battute sul viagra for sale canada viagra legal use of finasteride in women clomid reviews testosterone 8 how long does diflucan work in your body viagra and cialis on sale edmonton zovirax eye cream price in south african rand donde comprar cialis venezuela elections ciprofloxacin syrup in pakistan face where to buy in person cialis in toronto bbuy viagra online direct 76 txt 76 inderal brand generic comprar cialis generico brasil does viagra cause a stuffy nose viagracostincanada genericviagramastercardpayment cost of cialis 5mg 30 safest way to use cytotec for abortion how can i buy viagra in singapore not getting pregnant after clomid what is the best time of day to take metformin er where to get viagra in karachi zoloft safety risk pregancy azotek 500 mg metformin buying generic clomid online can you take doxycycline with bread viagra 50mg 1 step x 4 tablets prednisone canada no prescription jamp ciprofloxacin 500mg cialis online consegna 24 ore reviews of doxycycline 150 mg generic same results donde puedo comprar cytotec en santa cruz best canadian online pharmacy for cialis dapoxetine medicine in pakistan tresemme cytotec pills in manila zoloft in pregnancy category cialis paypal finasteride 1mg generic for sale without prescription balboa press positive reviews of zoloft does cialis 5mg daily work gm largest purchaser of viagra ampicillin dosage for tonsillitis zovirax online buy metformin er cost without insurance what is viagra equivalent in india can i take cialis with flomax viagra canada montreal zithromax online pharmacy without prescription zoloft side effect in elderly viagra cost in ireland which countries is viagra sold over the counter can u take viagra with advil cialis 28 cpr 5 mg prezzo oro clomid tablet 20 mg when to take tadalafil 20mg bestille nolvadex viagra in nyc how to get viagra in farmacia prezzo how do i get free samples of viagra does clomid cause multiple pregnancies viagra medical card ireland cialis to get over performance anxiety tadalafil best price online versandapotheke viagra generika dapoxetine price in pakistan a300f monthly cialis cost uk tadalafil over the counter camelina donde comprar viagra buy herbal pill viagra are generic tadalafil safe where to buy cialis in cozumel mexico zithromax 600 mg price what happens if you take clomid too late female viagra for sale in uk zithromax tadalafil powder suppliers priligy sin receta are cialis from canada safe cipro in the sun cheap viagra for sale insouth africa buy nolvadex pct uk yahoo 25 mg zoloft pmdd there over counter cipro do not use propecia buy pfizer viagra in the uk how to get your boyfriend to take viagra cialis legal uk generico viagra contrareembolso prednisone in bloodstream prednisone reviews for asthma can you take viagra with methotrexate can cialis cause nose bleeds what time best to take clomid can you get cialis in cabo and take through customs doxycycline medsafe data sheet viagra in blood test viagra online australian pharmacies spotting before period while clomid online pfizer ireland pharmaceuticals ringaskiddy viagra doxycycline mycoplasma dosage lasix 80 mg iv push procedure code best time to take metformin once a day priligy australia online marketplace viagra in dallas tx generic viagra as good as regular valerian root safe with zoloft buy viagra next day united states anyone ever bought cialis online viagra australia do u need a prescription ciprofloxacin pseudomonas infection in eye tadalafil 20 mg uk zoloft causing apathy in boyfriend metformin hydrochloride 1000 mg weight loss of a loved 5dpo symptoms resulted in bfp clomid metformin cost at walmart viagra naturale costo when will there be a safe generic viagra cialis 20mg cpr4 laurie zoloft phd in psychology beanshell generics for viagra best viagra capsule in india difference between metformin and avandia generic name ampicillin gentamicin in newborns how much does the 20mg cialis cost sarafem paxil cr and zoloft generic taking prednisone red rash in butt que efectos secundarios causa la metformina remolacha cruda donde comprar viagra why should you take metformin in the evening cipro dose adjustment in renal failure buy cipro online review importing cialis to european union viagra in australien kaufen cost of inderal comprar viagra sin receta furoato de mometasona nasal generico de cialis prednisolone 5 mg feline wonderful vegetal viagra prednisone 5 mg 12 day pack taper instructions price of viagra in rsa Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » A door cracks open in the Little Red Dot.

A door cracks open in the Little Red Dot.

datePosted on 21:51, April 27th, 2011 by Pablo

Authors Preface: Now that my departure from Singapore is imminent I no longer have to fear retribution for commenting about local politics. I was warned when I arrived in SG that foreigners commenting about SG political issues was verboten and liable to risk summary deportation or defamation charges. I do not think that what follows is defamatory in any way shape or form, and constitutes just the first in what will be a series of reflections about Singapore after having spent 3.5 years immersed in its politics and culture.

On May 7 2011, 2.5 million Singaporeans (out of a total population of 5 million) go to the polls in order to elect the next government. As a one party-dominant authoritarian state, the outcome is already assured–the People’s Action Party that has held power since 1959 will win the majority of parliamentary seats (Singapore is formally a unicameral parliamentary system). By gerrymandering electoral districts (which has led to uncontested walkover rates of 50 percent) and placing limits on opposition party rights to public expression and assembly outside of the two week campaign season (to include prohibitions on holding rallies and distributing flyers, posters or pamphlets, which has resulted in numerous defamation suits against and arrests of opposition figures over the years–the last in 2010 for a violation of the “no public assembly of more than 5 people without a Police permit” law), the PAP might match the 66 percent of the vote garnered in 2006 (a drop from the 73 percent received in 2001).  It will retain its majority hold of the (recently expanded) 87-member parliament. But there is political change blowing in the hot and humid Singaporean breeze, which is as much the result of generational and social change as it is of opposition renewal and PAP sclerosis. Although it will retain power this time, none of the trends auger well for the PAP.

Taking 25 years as the generational baseline, Singapore is in its third generation since gaining political autonomy from the Malay Federation in 1959 (independence came with its expulsion from the Federation in 1965). Led by 87-year old Lee Kuan Yew, the first generation of PAP leaders ruled with tight control until 1990, in an era when Singapore’s image as an austere and puritanical authoritarian state was forged. The second generation of hand-picked successors, who began the slow process of political and social liberalization and orchestrated the emergence of the country as a major transportation, logistics and financial hub, is singing its political swan song today. This year’s election marks the transition to the third generation of political leadership and not all has gone as planned for the PAP.

Voting is mandatory in Singapore. Yet spoiled ballots and non-voters amounted to nearly 10 percent of the 2006 electorate. In other words, the signs of discontent were already present five years ago. This year there has been a resurgence of political opposition led by the Workers Party, the Reform Party and the Singapore Democratic Party. In marked contrast to previous elections, 82 of the 87 parliamentary seats will be contested. Among the ranks of the opposition are defectors from the PAP, former government-sponsored overseas scholars (who usually pay their scholarship debt by returning to assume bureaucratic positions and joining the PAP), former Internal Security Act detainees (the ISA allows for the indefinite detention of suspects without charge and some of the current opposition candidates have spent periods in confinement as a result of it) as well as political exiles.

Most of the new candidates are in their mid 20s to mid 40s, thereby representing a coming of age for their generation of free thinkers. In response, the PAP has trotted out the usual ensemble of former bureaucrats and politicized retired military officers, interspersed with a handful of younger neophytes (including one whose qualifications for office apparently are that she is the wife of the Prime Minister’s executive assistant and has a penchant for shopping–the latter being Singapore’s national pastime). What is most revealing is that the PAP is no longer able to hide its internal divisions, with leading officials, Ministers and even the Minister Mentor (how’s that for a title?) Lee Kuan Yew himself openly disagreeing about issues of politics, policy and social construction. Perhaps sensing a shift in the public mood, some PAP candidates have withdrawn from the election (“retirement” being the most common reason). All of this underscores something that the Minister Mentor said last year: that the PAP must rejuvenate or stagnate, and that democracy would only come when the PAP proved incapable of responding to public expectations as a result of its stagnation.

The trouble for the PAP is that the elections have come too quickly for a major re-generation of its cadres, which in a talent-thin environment such as Singapore (owing to its population size, as anyone who looks beyond the front benches of the New Zealand parliament will understand), means that the moment of political reckoning has come much sooner than the 25 years Lee Kuan Yew envisioned.

Even worse for the PAP, although the government controls all of the mainstream media in Singapore, including the Straits Times and the telecommunications giant MediaCorp, it has been unable to staunch the flow of internet criticism of its personnel and policies, or the grassroots mobilization of support for the opposition. Much concern has been voiced about increasing inefficiencies in public services, the high cost of living, the loss of white collar jobs to foreigners, and the government’s astronomical pay scales (the Prime Minister–Lee Kuan Yew’s son–is paid S$4.5 million per/year, senior ministers make S$3 million and parliamentary backbenchers start at S$150,000. In fact according to the Economist, Singapore has the second highest ratio of political leader’s pay to the country’s GDP per person, with the average salary of US$2,183,516). There is irony in the latter because it is a world first: Singapore has the most expensive government that money can buy, in a society that is image-obsessed but in which income inequality is more third world than first world.

In the face of what looks to be the possibility of losing previously safe seats amid an unprecedented wave of electoral contestation, the PAP has resorted to fear-mongering, focusing on the tired old canards of economic insecurity, Malay sedition, jihadist terrorism, unskilled foreign workers from the sub-continent and mainland China bringing crime and stealing local jobs, and gay rights (homosexuality is illegal in Singapore but as part of the social liberalization process enforcement of sodomy laws has been weak and episodic over the last decade. This has been a major concern of social conservatives, including the very large number of ethnic Chinese Christians found on the island who are a core PAP constituency). PAP officials talk darkly about “hidden agendas” and wonder why the opposition would seek “to take control of the government” (apparently ignorant of the fact that political parties are formed precisely to contest for power in order to gain decision-making authority and influence policy). Yet the more it raises the specter of Singapore returning to its polyglot swampland brothel and opium den past, the more the PAP is ridiculed for being out of touch with the wants and needs of contemporary Singaporeans.

This means that this election and its aftermath will constitute a critical juncture in Singaporean history. It will set the stage for the next critical juncture, which will be the occasion and aftermath of Lee Kuan Yew’s death.

The notion of critical juncture is important and needs explaining. Using economics-derived path dependency analysis (in which human behavior is “locked in” by past institutional practice the more that practice is routinised over time), critical junctures are historical moments when decisive choices are made within given institutional parameters that set the future course of events (the most common used analogies are the “fork in the road” and “tree branch” motifs).  Because of its internal divisions, Lee Kuan Yew’s death will be the moment when the knives come out within the PAP, with moderate reformists and liberalizers pitted against hard-line status quo defenders in what could wind up as a splitting of the party. Since the hard-line elements constitute the bulk of the deadwood and sclerotic elements within the PAP, it is quite possible, given the outcome of this election, that reformists will gain control of the party and move to accommodate moderate opposition views in a grand coalition strategy designed to help preserve their hold on power after 2016.

But that is precisely why this election constitutes a pre-conditioning critical juncture that will set the stage for the next one. Processes of authoritarian regime liberalization tend to be “two-steps forward, one step backwards” affairs. The regime opens a little, the opposition pushes further than what is acceptable to the regime, and the regime pushes back. Confronted with a rising tide of opposition success and grassroots mobilizations against one-party rule that cannot be contained with selective application of the ISA and the usual use of defamation and non-assembly laws, the PAP regime will therefore be forced to opt for one of two paths: repress or reform. Its previous preferred strategy of cooptation will no longer work.

This is important to consider because the reformists constitute a minority of the current PAP leadership. The PAP status quo–many of who have held their sinecures for more than a decade–control the levers of government and retain the loyalty of the armed forces (which have internal security and regime protection as well as external defense roles). Thus, even if there are internal tensions within the armed forces between “professional” and “political” officers (the former focused on the technical merits of soldiering and the latter concerned with career advancement via political linkages), and its leadership sclerosis is profound, the PAP can, if it wants to, halt the process of social and political opening any time it wishes. Because it still has a reservoir of support in the so-called (ethnic Chinese) “heartland,” the regime can push back without incurring major backlash.

This is not to say that there will not be any. Singaporeans are largely a passive and conformist society, so a move to repress or politically back-peddle will not be met with mass demonstrations akin to those of the Middle East today or Latin America in the past.  But even if they acquiesce to the retrogression, the third generation of Singaporean voters will not consent to a return to the days of arrests for jaywalking, fines for chewing gum and imprisonment or bankruptcy for reasonable (unarmed) dissent. Instead, they will engage in passive resistance and low-level protests with increased grassroots mobilization over the internet, including social media and other hard-to-filter communications vehicles. Since Singapore is an extremely “wired” society that depends on its telecommunications capabilities for much of its daily business, Chinese-style censorship will be very hard to maintain even though the government controls the telecommunications duopoly through which all internet access is filtered (I will not digress into the reaction of foreign actors to any such retrogression but suffice it to say that it will not be entirely supportive).

All of this means that the PAP is staring at the beginning of the end in this election. The opposition has organized, mobilized and taken advantage of the limited political space afforded to it by the manipulated electoral system. The PAP has reacted slowly and awkwardly to the opposition’s energetic display. It therefore sits on the horns of a dilemma: accept that power sharing is inevitable over the short term and rotation in government office is quite possible within a few years (or at least much sooner than expected), or use its election victory to reassert its political supremacy, by force if necessary, over pretenders to its throne. That will influence the context in which the power struggles following Lee Kuan Yew’s death will occur, which in turn will determine whether or not the slow process of authoritarian liberalization will continue or be halted. At that point the moment of truth will have arrived for a country struggling with its identity as a modern bridge between East and West.

>> A different version of the essay appears as this month’s “A Word from Afar” column at Scoop.

16 Responses to “A door cracks open in the Little Red Dot.”

  1. George D on April 28th, 2011 at 15:45

    Thanks Pablo for an insightful commentary. Those of us who don’t pay all that much attention to the city state will struggle to draw lessons from its politics, but it’s a good read all the same. It’s easy to think of current political orders as intransient, but as another political thinker I respect likes to tell me, “nothing is inevitable”.

  2. N on April 28th, 2011 at 16:01

    I’m living in Singapore currently, having moved here in late 2009, and this analysis seems spot on, although I suspect that Lee Kwan Yew’s eventual death is far more important that this makes out.

    A huge number of Singaporeans seem extremely disgruntled about developments in Signapore, although almost all the concern seems to be over essentially economic issues: the role of ‘foreign talent’ in the economy, the price of housing and food etc. But Singaporeans essentially trust the Minister Mentor – I’m not sure they trust the rest of the PAP and when he goes, so will a large part of the government’s credibility.

    The general feeling is that the opposition parties need to win one of the gerrymandering Group Representation Committees, electorate regions where residents elect a group of MPs, usually a combination of ministers and young members. If they can crack that, a system specifically set up to keep them out, then the PAP will really be on the back foot.

  3. Pablo on April 28th, 2011 at 17:48

    Cheers George. Just trying to put into words what I am seeing and hearing.

    N. Thanks for the local perspective. I would add to your mention of the concerns of the electorate the fact that issues of civil liberties and human rights trail far behind material concerns and opposition to immigration, so the voter perspective is not necessarily “progressive.”

    I agree that the MM carries an aura his successors do not have. Which is why his death is going to be decisive for the PAP, and I see the possibility of a split, with a more conservative, nationalist Chinese branch paring off of the main trunk. Bottom line, as I have mentioned in other contexts: the Achilles Heel of authoritarianism is the question of leadership succession. It is particularly bad in personalist regimes but even highly institutionalised regimes like that of the PAP have a hard time outliving their founding fathers. That is why I see this election setting the backdrop to the power struggle that will ensue when he passes.

  4. […] are looking for an overview of why this election seems especially fraught, you could do worse than this blog post titled “A Door Cracks in the Little Red Dot”, although you have to ignore the misspelling of Lee Kuan Yew’s name. addthis_url = […]

    >>Author’s note: Typos have been corrected.

  5. Pablo on April 29th, 2011 at 17:14

    Well, this and the Scoop version have made it into the SG on-line media. It is interesting (and gratifying) to see the KP page readership go up on a non-NZ focused topic. But now I have SG friends asking me if I am prepared for the knock on the door.

    For those interested in seeing some of the SG reaction, check out these links (you may have to scroll through a few pages because both sites update frequently):

  6. […] Chiam See Tong Might Say After His Appearance Today – Rachel Zeng: Just some words – Kiwipolitico: A door cracks open in the Little Red Dot [Thanks Nick] – Meena Curren’s Blog: PAP SCANDAL UNFOLDS! – ST Forum: PAP should spell out […]

  7. DanielSeah76 on April 30th, 2011 at 14:31

    The judicial system does not cane people for jaywalking though. You might want to correct that …..

  8. Pablo on April 30th, 2011 at 14:48

    Ah Daniel,

    ’tis so Singaporean of you to fret over minutiae instead of the big picture. Or to fixate on the trees and miss the forest. Geez. You may find it hard to believe put there was a point to the statement, which was about the PAP not being able to return to the past.

    I suppose I should have mentioned the ban on chewing gum (still in force) instead. Specifically, my reference to “jaywalking” (now punishable by fines, in another liberalisation measure) harked to the past, as in the late 60s and early 70s, when in fact jaywalkers were arrested and sometimes caned. But again, there was larger point….

  9. DanirlSeah76 on April 30th, 2011 at 16:12

    The reason I raised that up is that the average reader of this article (for example me) will just take that to mean that the article is likely to have been possibly poorly researched and just based on popular misconceptions, since the law that it refers to an outdated and obscure one, and the fact that it is mentioned in the same line as a ccurrent existing situation only confuses the reader more. As you yourself mentioned, a reference to the ban on (selling of) chewing gum would have been a much better choice of an example to use. It might not have been obvious from my 1st post, but its purpose was to improve the article by correcting flaws while still retaining the spirit of the article.

  10. DanirlSeah76 on April 30th, 2011 at 16:22

    Its a well written and engrossing article, I’m just pointing out that if the typical Singaporean reader were like me, that odd point would have made them do a doubletake and stopped the (reading) momentum. Just a little change can make the reading experience so much smoother ;)

  11. Pablo on April 30th, 2011 at 16:30


    I see your point and have modified the offending line.

  12. […] full post is available on the Kiwi Politico blog. […]

  13. mos on May 7th, 2011 at 16:31

    The ‘chewing of’ chewing gum is not banned in Singapore – it is the ‘importing and selling of’ chewing gum.

    Having noticed the horrible mess chewing gum makes of the worlds’ pavements (look down, all those black circles are chewing gum)I cannot but admit that this useless confection can be happily eliminated from our sweet shops. Millions of dollars spent yearly on sandblasting/waterjetting this dirt off is a total waste of money.

  14. Pablo on May 7th, 2011 at 17:46

    Again, another silly Singaporean nit-picking without addressing the substance of the essay. With an authoritarian disposition to boot. Bound to be a PAP voter.

  15. Dismal Soyanz on May 17th, 2011 at 23:06

    LKY’s eventual death will undoubtedly see a massive outpouring of grief – some real, some hysterical. Many will note his contribution to Singapore’s development. However, there is a growing core of Singaporeans who realise that Harry’s ways are now past their “best before” date.

    Demands for accountability are growing. Whereas it used to be “the gahmen knows best”, there is a growing realisation that the PAP is not synonymous with the state and that some major gaffes (the wildly bad forecast of the YOG cost) show that the government doesn’t always know best. Social media and the internet have provided an outlet for frustration for many Singaporeans and with it the realisation that they are not a tiny group of naysayers but indeed a sizable minority.

    I like your point about the PAP facing a dilemma. How exactly are they going to change to avoid losing even more of their eroding share of the popular vote? I see a microcosm of this in the apologies by PM Lee Hsien Loong during the final days before the election. They sound nice but lacked substance. Apologies for what exactly? Was there an admission that the policies and the thinking behind them were wrong? The PAP will have to do more than this – and much more than allowing LKY and GCT to fade into the sunset. The political genii has finally escaped and short of an abrupt and deeply unpopular return to the dictatorial ways of the 20th century, the demand for a more pluralistic political system will grow.

    Could a lurch backwards happen? I doubt it. There is no threat of instability. A good example of this is the very smart use by some opposition candidates of the National Pledge. Support for the opposition is seen as consistent with patriotism – something that LKY fought hard against during his heyday. The use of mechanisms such as defmation suits and bankruptcy to silence opposition hereafter would only further hasten the loss of popular support. I suppose constitutionally its possible that a PAP government might suspend elections but Singapore has already seen at least one President who dared question the government and I think it highly likely that the next President would be under immense (popular) pressure to resist a move back to authoritarianism.

    So the PAP has little choice. It must evolve and evolve fast. It must improve accountability and transparency within this 5-year term. It must also be seen to moderate its fairly aggressive marketing of PR/citizenship to citizens of other countries (especially the PRC). If it fails to do so, it may well lose several more GRCs and SMCs in the next election.

    The best leaders are those that actively plan for succession. Does LHL have tht in him? Rather ironically, his father was on record as saying he hoped to see someone strong enough to push himself aside.

  16. Pablo on May 18th, 2011 at 15:39

    Thanks Dismal, for the interesting analysis. The loss of George Yeo was a major blow for two reasons: 1) he lost in a GRC that should have been an easy PAP win, whereas has it been a single member constituency he most likely would have won the seat; and 2) this likely had an influence on MM Lee and SM Goh’s decision to step down from cabinet (the two men issued a joint statement announcing their decision, so it is clear this was a considered and calibrated move). Since Yeo was a very talented foreign minister on the short list to be the next PM and part of what passes for the “progressive” wing of the PAP, we may well see him re-emerge in another party in 2016. Lee and Goh saw him as a natural progression in leadership of the party, but now that succession scenario is over.

    Lee and Goh have in the past called for the PAP to reform and regenerate. Last year such a call by Lee was rebuffed by the PAP leadership, who said that he spoke in a private capacity and that he no longer had a leadership role in the party. This insult to the founder of the nation did not go unnoticed by the informed public. Thus, while Lee won his seat with 80% of the vote the overall trend for the PAP went in the opposite direction, and if that trend holds true that will lose more points in 2016–I would hazard the guess that the PAP could go as low as 52% of the vote next time around unless it does some major house ordering and external factors favour it. Under such conditions it will have to accomodate the opposition one way or another.

    The opposition, though, is too divided to pose a serious threat. The WP is doing well but some of the other parties are splinters of it and others are personality-driven cults. Thus the opposition has to form a united front or grand coalition in order to be a serious challenge in 2016 and that may be hard for its contending factions to do given their differences. Should the PAP offer the WP a minority power-sharing role, the chances of a united opposition will be almost nil.

    The PAP also needs to think about electoral and constitutional reform. Now that the GRC gerrymandered constituency system has been exposed as vulnerable to well organised, targeted opposition campaigns, given the first-past-the-post nature of the electoral system as a whole the possibility of a PAP ouster becomes more realistic. Thus a move to a proportional representation or even an MMP system might allow the PAP to win even if losing in a future election. That may not be in 2016 but it may be something tabled for subsequent elections.

    Finally, although the possibility of a return to overt repression is remote, I should point out that in the days after the election the police broke up two peaceful petition gathering assemblies seeking the reinstatement of a popular opposition figure. The law under which the police did so was the “no assembly of more than 5 people” law, backed up by the ISA. So even if held in reserve, the stick is there.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)