when i take metformin i feel really sick metformin 500 mg dan kehamilan propranolol 80 mg angst best way to quit zoloft best dose of zoloft for depression cheap cialis in uk precio finasteride 1mg average rounds of clomid to get pregnant tadalafil prescription uk does accutane cause tooth decay duphaston 10 mg clomid stores that sell viagra in houston purchase azithromycin or doxycycline nike shoes online canada cheap viagra contiene tadalafil 20 mg cialis case marketing is it ok to take viagra fedex viagra canadian 100 viagra 100mg cheap inderal 10 mg twice a day training price of tadalafil accutane 20 mg twice a day medication ireland viagra factory can you take viagra twice in one day oligomenorrhea treatment clomid reviews brake specialist in 75234 cialis bathtub logo buy nolva clomid pct metformin 500 mg er tabs cialis soft generico online pain specialists in san joaquin co ca viagra over the counter tescos quero comprar um cytotec what is brand name of doxycycline hyclate how many mgs of viagra should i take prednisone burst 50 mg dosage can clomid cause severe bloating cialis daily buy online generic clomid 10 pills existe viagra de 25 mg indian price of viagra tablets counterfit cialis doxycycline hyclate acne dosage low dose doxycycline and birth control ciprofloxacin 200 mg i v price of amoxil 125mg for kids viagra generic 50 mg can taking metformin cause hypoglycemia in pregnancy online kopen van propecia ciprofloxacino medicamento generico avapro cialis 20 mg 8 film tablet how many viagra do you take buy cheap generic viagra online for 0 95 each refresh liquigel inactive ingredients in metformin 200 mg doxycycline one dose for std efectos usar viagra generic accutane for older adults buy cialis in lilly packaging where to buy viagra shoppersdrug mart can i buy accutane farmaco generico propecia coupon propecia online retina australia brandalley kuwas viagra ciprofloxacina tabletas 400 mg beneficios y contraindicaciones del viagra online nevriye budak cialis over the counter ciprofloxacine mylan 500 mg posologie is womens viagra available online tick bite 200 mg doxycycline hyclate zovirax price compare priligy dokteronline should finasteride be taken at night price of viagra per pill generic viagra vendors buy viagra in shop in grimsby india viagra manufacturers is doxycycline from india safe viagra spokeswoman who in blue dress deprax 100 mg 60 comprimidos viagra how to purchase finasteride proscar and propecia what is different 10 m 20 mm and 50 mg cialis cialis daily quanto costa metformin cost in the philippines can get propecia uk prednisolone nycomed 25 mg hunde best way to order cialis online liquid clomid and nolvadex pct clindahexal 600 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin how to wean off 200 mg zoloft lasix eye surgeons in omaha nebraska best generic viagra pharmacy ferrari sildenafil tablets 130 mg thc when to take ovulation test with clomid viagra kaufen in ungarn what is for doxycycline 100 mg for cellulitis frijol de soya donde comprar viagra accutane higher dose better metformina hidrocloruro 850 mg can you take a viagra and cialis together doxycycline over counter australia propecia versus rogaine ampicillin brand name philippines ampicillin dose pprom how much it cost for cialis finasteride how much does it cost can get accutane online buy cheap cialis online uk visa amoxil 850 mg bula ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab dosage ontario physician specialized in prednisone withdrawel best time to take prednisolone cipro in pediatrics metformin use in lada will 6 500 mg doses of zithromax kill stds real viagra usa discount cialis online 24 is 200mg of viagra safe locked in syndrome viagra sito affidabile cialis generico cialis generic 5 mg sildenafil 50 mg efectos mujer junel fe 28 day generic viagra prednisone 20 mg westward cipro registrations online whats best result 50 mg or 25mg viagra java class assubclass generic viagra buy viagra reviews viagra generico tempo de efeito when should u take clomid ebay australiaviagra propecia in women how to take doxycycline to treat chlamydia directions in taking ciprofloxacn 500 mg tab nort doxycycline in sinusitis cialis 20 mg every 3 days accidently took 400 mg zoloft sildenafil citrate in lahore how to order cialis online in south africa how long does 5mg cialis work viagra likedrug in homeopathy sensibit tabletas 10 mg prednisone order tadalafil from india cialis argentina donde comprar agua zoloft dosage 300 mg prednisolone liquid inactive ingredients in prilosec buying real viagra in mexico can generic viagra cure performance anxiety donde comprar viagra en mexico d f can you buy viagra over the counter in s africa plaunazide 20 mg 12 5mg cialis clomid and novadex for sale accutane shop online cialis and viagra canada silagra pharmacy brand name viagra cumwithuscom how many prednisone 5 mg tablets should you dispense donde comprar viagra bs purchase research chemicals tadalafil pills price of metformin cialis prix lyon para se usa metformin 500 mg cipro costumi where can i buy viagra in swindon phenoral 50 mg zoloft use of glimepiride metformin can you buy viagra in nz models use accutane generic viagra contains sildenafil citrate what strength viagra to take glucophage 500 mg composition buy propranolol er online viagra generico chile dr simi ciprofloxacino 500 mg injetavel 1000 mg metformin pcos cheap reliable cialis metformin for endometrial cancer in non obese zoloft increased to 100 mg female cialis wiki usa socialist programs counterfeit zithromax azithromycin viagra for men south africa price 10 mg prednisone taper schedule difference in cialis 20 mg and 5mg viagra einzeln online bestellen kann mein hausarzt viagra verschreiben nolvadex pct prices liquid tadalafil dosage chart over the counter viagra substitute at rite aid what does viagra cost at wal mart predsim bula generico de cialis tesco tadalafil 10mg prices cytotec over the counter ontario migraine specialists in lima ohio finasteride small dose bph treated with cialis diflucan 400 mg viagra substitutes over the counter in uae migraine specialist in redding ca varillas de radiestesia donde comprar viagra inderal 10 mg flashback viagra discount viagra prescription s tesco pharmacy london viagra inderal 40 mg prezzo warren where in australia can viagra be bought cialis 40 mg buy real cytotec dapoxetine 30 mg in bangladesh bengali cialis generico mx 0.25 mg propecia every second day xbox 360 colombia donde comprar viagra is mail order viagra safe sildenafil citrate us overnight delivery figueira da india comprimidos viagra viagra for men under 40 in ahmedabad india propecia stop receding hairline buy ciprodex otic suspension no rx diflucan in timpul sarcinii buy viagra newzealand diflucan anfd yeast treatment in toddler is viagra in a pub trust org comprar cialis spain zoloft and 100 mg how long were to buy viagra in oman cheap accutane for sale viagra in coronary artery disease doxycycline crush in cat food cialis online 200 mg ciprocinal 500 mg upotreba viagra glucophage xr 500mg in pregnancy erofast sildenafil 50 mg onde comprar clomid 50mg how to take in urdu accutane really bad comprar viagra andorra sin receta medica can i buy viagra in the dominican republic buy viagra subligual in bangkok viagra in galway i want to buy viagra in america blonde actress in acura cialis can you find viagra in morocco private prescription cost cialis zoloft dosage for ocd starnoc 20 mg cialis ciprofloxacin syrup in bangladesh current propranolol generico de crestor accutane after stopping treatment visadron bijsluiter viagra viagra vs once a day cialis cost where we can buy viagra in dubai can you take cialis and amoxicillin where to buy cheap cialis in uae low dose accutane 20 mg taking 40 mg cialis sildenafil for sale in paso robles donde puedo comprar cytotec sin receta en honduras cialis orders paypal paid nolvadex 10 mg astrazeneca india meloxicam methocarbamol generico de cialis diflucan vs azo buy propecia online without prescription raw types in generics for accutane buy propecia and minoxidil together allegron 25 mg of zoloft what over the counter drug similar to lasix are propecia and finpecia same finasteride 1 mg traitement pharmacy in malaysia selling cialis can a patient take zithromax twice in 2 months how long after a meal can you take viagra lasix in hyponatremia lb medium ampicillin viagra tablet pakistan price cheap viagra 100 ml for .80 cents how can i get viagra in ireland where to buy generic viagra in manila how to buy clomid in the uk steroids i took 300 mg of zoloft by accident brasher supalite womens reviews on cialis doxycycline in the sun ciprofloxacin al 250 mg preis purchase as needed cialis ampicillin dose for group b strep viagra in a sachet price of finasteride tablets in philippines viagra myth and reality clomid 50 mg and metformin success stories gcpharma cialis over the counter madopar 125 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin accutane really worth taking quick viagra delivery cost of propecia boots prednisone 20 mg indicaciones del safe prednisone intervals 4free online order viagra prix du cialis 5mg en pharmacie subscribe by email in viagra canadian viagra by mail whats walmart price viagra difference between viagra 25 mg 50 mg how to split a cialis in half prednisone 10 mg ingredients viagra pills in united states viagra lowest price generic sydney buy viagra how should 4 500 mg er metformin be taken many mg viagra can you take mockito stubbing generics for accutane doxycycline for sinus infection how many mg much does one month propecia cost can you drink on metformin can you buy cialis in amsterdam no prescription sildenafil citrate uk next day metolazone used with lasix can i buy tadalafil atboots notice prednisone mylan 20 mg tips for viagra usage cipro hc otic liquid suspension cialis once a day generic generic viagra uses cytotec dosis para 3 semanas causas y concecuencias ciprohexal 250mg google uk wellbutrin generic not as effective as metformin diflucan online canadian pharmacy diflucan jack newman how can i get viagra cheap hasta que semana puedo usar cytotec purchase and viagra soft is it dangerous to take 20 mg cialis two days in a row medicamento generico del viagra en zithromax suspension 300 mg prescription viagra costco can you buy viagra in st maarten buy generic viagra online europe viagra tablet in pakistan cialis 5 mg najtaniej assuefazione cialis 5 mg cytotec costo en farmacias del ahorro mexico how many rounds of clomid are safe throat irritation caused by doxycycline diflucan over the counter australia doxycycline for strep throat dosage generico do cialis tablets doxycycline 100mg genericode zovirax in sg generic viagra versus generic cialis pills viagra natural substitute delivery viagra cialis soft best price can you take viagra while on sotalol can viagra cause kidney damage achat viagra soft pfizer paiement paypal next best alternative to accutane is 60 mg a high dose of prednisone diflucan 50 mg dose for penile candida cetirizina mylan 10 mg comprimidos viagra price of viagrain malaysia how safe is low dose cialis doxycycline tablets to buy can buy viagra dublin donde puedo comprar cytotec caracas where to buy cialis in calgary without a prescription canine doxycycline dose tercian 25 mg of zoloft glucophage xr usage vibramycin 50 mg syrup what if i take 2 cialis pills viagra online generic from india offers cialis 5mg delivery door to door viagra and pe is oral prednisone safe during pregnancy azicin 150 mg zoloft wild viagra reviews aurogra 100 mg sildenafil how many mgs of zoloft to get high accutane cause ocd docusate sodium capsules 100mg viagra viagra uk ebay clomid sucesses in nigeria metformin hydrochloride 1000 mg weight loss prevention how much does zovirax cost in canada cefdinir vs zithromax can i buy viagra over counter in calgary viagra latest price in delhi cheap viagra next day ship lo loestrin fe generic substitute for viagra cialis uk lloyds what happens to a girl if they take viagra generic cialis canada no prescription adapalene generico do viagra cialis 2.5 mg vs 5 mg cost how to get viagra from your gp prices viagra dubai propecia for hair loss purchase buy clomid medication for fertility online viagra tramadol clomid como usarlo order cialis next day shipping best viagra nature pantoprazole nome generico de cialis doxycycline monohydrate 50 mg does viagra require a prescription in australia why isnt viagra generic yet leaguesafe alternatives to viagra can cialis cause blood in seminal fluid thai doctors discover alternative to viagra tadalafil 20 mg stada sildenafil in saudi arabia over the counter viagra in newcastle tyne sildenafil generico farmacias similares franquicias accutane sold in canada anglo nubian goat for sale in uk zithromax cialis without prescription in usa sildenafil dapoxetine uk cialis costco lasix surgey cost rexer 15 mg comprimidos viagra viagra in macular degeneration 2.5 mg of prednisone for vocal cords en farmacias similares vende tadalafil online citalopram dura 20 mg wirkung viagra queso payoyo donde comprar viagra cobra versus cialis reviews metformin mechanism of action in pcos and pregnancy doxycycline capsule in india order tadalafil bertibarots can u drink and take cialis is viagra safe for diabetes roacutan original e generico de cialis where to buy dapoxetine priligy in canada on line excelentes resultados con finasteride generic rectal use of viagra vasogenic edema corticosteroids prednisone generic cialis recommended the socialist party of america was founded in what year comprar viagra en la argentina best way to use a viagra le prix de roaccutane au maroc acheflan aerosol generico do viagra oretic generic cialis como usar cytotec chile propranolol 40 mg 3 times a day recipes propecia side effect with excessive watering in eye what the best herbal viagra can 16 year olds use viagra genericky cialis prednisolone reduction in dose inderal public speaking mg viagra canada reddit soccer best time to take daily cialis clomid dosage after testosterone why take clomid after steroids much tramadol safe take zoloft blue sky peptide tadalafil review misoprostolcytotec in south africa idarac 500 mg metformin do i need prescription for cialis in uk qualquer um pode comprar viagra portugal doxycycline hyclate pain swallowing can i get priligy on the nhs generic ciprofloxacin ear drops can i get viagra in bangalore cytotec buy now in bronx viagra from india safety standards where to buy cialis in malaysia phamarcy walmart walgreen cialis pro chem clomid 50mg tadalafil liquid injection valve comprar viagra y cialis online how to last longer in bed with ed and taking cialis precio de diflucan 100 mg sildenafil de 50 mgeyaculacion precoz when is the best time of day to take cialis daily is it safe to rake viagra with ampplodine what happens when you take half a cialis proper dose cialis sildenafil gel over the counter is viagra covered under medicare how much time tadalafil 20 effects in women body is it free to buy cialis in canada now zovirax generic cream or ointment corbatas de unquera donde comprar viagra a8674 25 mg of zoloft how many 10mg viagra come in a bottle price of sildenafil in durban ciprofloxacin ear drops usa where to buy cytotec without prescriptions glucophage 1000 mg beipackzettel tadalafil kaufen eu nouveaux usages for prednisone cialis quanto costa in italia day cycle best start clomid generic cialis and dapoxetine prednisone 10 mg 54 899 zithromax 1000 mg for less prednisone 20 mg does it has side effect of hair loss viagra natural onde comprar nolvadex for sale pct supplements zovirax 800 mg iv doxycycline hyclate 100 mg oral cap la droga del viagra generic cialis pharmacy second treatment of accutane Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » The Asiafication of New Zealand production.

The Asiafication of New Zealand production.

datePosted on 16:04, November 13th, 2012 by Pablo

Reports that New Zealanders are working longer hours with more responsibilities and little if any overtime pay, are less unionized and more casualized (part time) than any time before in the country’s modern history suggests that not only has the national model of accumulation changed. It suggests that the labor market and labor process have fundamentally changed as well. The trend towards increased exploitation of human labor as an input commodity, added to an increasing lack of employer concern for the social costs imposed on workers by super-explotation and the long-term nurturing of employees as productive assets, is reminiscent of something that Marx wrote about a long time ago: the Asiatic mode of production.

I have written about the Asiatic mode of production before on this site, differentiating it from Oriental despotism and referring to my observations about Singapore when I lived there in recent years. The core of the model centers on an abundance of cheap and easily replaced human labor. This labor is used instead of machines or other labor saving devices because it costs less in terms of initial investment and long-term maintenance, although it is less efficient in terms of productive output generated by individual laborers. The labor market is dominated by employer “flexibility” in hiring and firing and setting wages, working terms and conditions. Workers are treated as expendable commodities, not as assets. In Singapore this was done via the importation of foreign labor from the sub-continent and Southeast Asia (not to be confused with the foreign “talent,” mostly Anglo-Saxon, that is imported to staff corporate upper management in the island state).

In New Zealand it is accomplished by maintaining unemployment rates at sufficiently high levels so as to have a labor surplus in semi-skilled and unskilled, middle to lower income, mostly youth and entry-level  positions. Creation of lower minimum wage sub-categories (such as the youth wage) and lowering wage requirements for casual or part time work reduces labor input costs. Dropping of social welfare benefits forces people into the job market out of necessity rather than choice, adding to the numbers of the unemployed seeking work. Loosening of the regulatory environment in which most workers work gives them less legal grounds for grievance across a range of issues, from workplace safety to wages.

The combination of factors allow for the easy replacement of semi-skilled and unskilled labor (and in some instances, skilled workers such as academics), which increases the employment uncertainty and precariousness of the work force. That makes employees malleable to employer demands for more wage restraint, more task assignments, more productive output per employee and hence more working hours with little extra pay or benefits. For employees in a labor market characterized by work scarcity, loose regulations and employment precariousness, increasingly onerous jobs are not easy to give up (tragically, Pike River comes to mind). On the other hand, for employers it is a take it or leave it proposition. If workers want better pay or conditions, they can look elsewhere.

The deliberate undermining of collective bargaining by successive National governments (which the Fifth Labour government did not fully restore) and the decreasing role of unions in the labor process plays into this scenario. Less means of collective defense in the face of of the labor market shifts described above leads to atomization of the work force into a mass of uncoordinated and stratified individual opportunity seekers. As the opportunistic ethos takes hold and replaces the collective solidarity ties of previous generations, it reinforces the Asiafication trend.

An important aspect of the trend is immigration demographics. Since New Zealand is labor poor it must import foreign workers in order to grow. The historical use of unskilled Pacifika labor in New Zealand is well known. But what is interesting in recent years is the turn to Asian sources for all types of labor, most of it semi-skilled and skilled. Regardless of specific provenance, Asian immigrants are much less familiar with Western labor market rights and responsibilities and in fact are eminently susceptible to the labor process conditions outlined in the Asiafication model. Moreover, where working class benefits have accrued in Asia, much of that has been done via strong collective action (such as in South Korea) and/or via paternalistic state policies (such as in Singapore). In New Zealand neither of those factors have obtained in recent decades.

The increasingly non-Western immigration demographic appears to be easing the consolidation of the Asiafication trend. New Asian immigrants, schooled in authoritarian modes of production at home, arrive in New Zealand eager to work, relatively ignorant of their rights and less inclined to complain about employment terms and working conditions. To these can be added immigrants from Central Asia and the Middle East, who also have come from mostly authoritarian and highly stratified societies where workers know their place in the social hierarchy and where the concept of collective and individual rights is narrowly construed.

This mass of new arrivals, to include the first generation born and raised in New Zealand, add highly motivated opportunity seekers into the labor market mix. Although some may be refused work because of racism or difficulty with language, the larger trend is to increase competition for the relatively scare available jobs and in doing so lower the overall wage bill. That leads to more income inequality between workers as producers of value and the managerial consumers of their commodified labor.

Another way of looking at the issue is in terms of consent. Over the years Western workers have seen their material threshold of consent, which is the general expectation of fair treatment in the workplace and fair remuneration for providing their labor services, institutionalized in labor law and labor market practices. It includes access to collective representation and bargaining and state enforcement of workplace health, safety and other basic standards for working conditions and pay. What the Asiafication process does is lower worker’s expectations of “fair” treatment in the labor process, which in turn lowers their overall material threshold of consent. Reinforced by institutional and structural shifts that are reproduced over time, this further subordinates the salaried classes to the logics of capital as defined by investors and asset owners.

Asiafication also shows workers their “proper” place. After years of contesting capitalist domination of the political and economic system via party competition reinforced by union collective action in an effort to level the socio-economic playing field, Asiafication helps restore the overt social hierarchies that underpin the capitalist class system and which were camouflaged by design in democratic welfare states.

For employers (as sellers of cheapened labor, value added products), the result of Asiafication is lower price outputs across the board (be it in services, manufacturing or primary good-derived exports). That makes them competitive in the global market of production, service and exchange.

The result for workers is a vicious circle in the social division of labor as well as in production: a labor market created by an economic and political decision-making elite who see modern variants of the Asiatic mode of production as the wave of the future and something to emulate (however hard that is to do under democratic conditions), coupled with an increasingly non-Western immigration demographic that is historically familiar with the “flexible” labor market dynamics inherent in that model and its contemporary applications and which does not necessarily see the Asiatic mode of production, including intense social stratification and opportunistic individualism, as a bad thing. Under such conditions the race to the bottom begins in earnest.

It should also be noted that the Asiafication of New Zealand production facilitates the increasingly Asian focus of New Zealand trade and investment strategy. The push to increase investment in and trade with Asian and other non-Western countries has its domestic complement in the alterations to local labor market conditions. Asian investors who otherwise might be put off by Western labor market standards and regulations can now see something more familiar in the New Zealand labor market, which is becoming more akin to what they are used to in their home countries. That eases the way for the inward flow of non-Western capital into New Zealand’s productive apparatus, something that contractually reinforces local commitment to the Asiaification model.

I am not a labor economist or sociologist, much less an expert on immigration. I am sure that there are exceptions to the trend. The knowledge economy may still be around and centers of productive excellence perhaps abound. It is clear that the welfare state labor market model is kaput. It is equally clear that there are significant variations in Asian and other non-Western labor market standards that argue against making gross generalizations. Even so, there is a discernible trend at play when it comes to New Zealand’s labor market, and that trend derives from or at least resembles modern variants of the labor market typology associated with the larger structural model known as the Asiatic mode of production.

It also seems to me that there is something amiss about a purported liberal democracy that so energetically pursues a model of accumulation that at its core is dependent on a highly exploitative labor process in which material short-term gains for employers is emphasized over the long-term employment security and welfare of workers. After all, the rewards of the former accrue to the few, even if there is some trickle down to the masses. But the long-term stability of democratic society depends on having relatively contented working and middle classes who invest in their jobs not only for immediate gain (or relief), but to help secure the next generation’s material well-being. If that is no longer feasible due to the conditions of production, then something will have to give.

Absent an authoritarian regression along the lines seen in certain Asian political economic models (which would have to include major changes in the basic socialization mechanisms of the citizenry, be they new immigrants or not), it seems to me that the Asiafication of New Zealand production will become untenable over the long-run. Long term disenchantment with economic exploitation turns opportunity seekers into the politically disillusioned, and it is the politically disillusioned who, however apathetic at first, eventually agitate the most for substantive change. Under competitive electoral conditions that means that the politically disillusioned become a potential support base for reform-mongerers and the parties that best represent them.

In summary, I believe that the current Asiafication of New Zealand production is a short-term, market elite-driven solution to a perceived problem of competitiveness that is not sustainable even with the changing national demographic based on non-Western immigration trends. I believe so because I do not think that the elites of New Zealand are prepared or inclined to engage in the authoritarian measures required to impose a new social division of labor consonant with modern variants of the Asiatic mode of production. Absent the will or the way to add Orientalism to the equation, there will be an inevitable political backlash to the Asiafication model that will see its undoing in favor of a labor market that is less exploitative and more attuned to long-term social gains rather than short term business profit.

It will be a good day when that happens. I just hope that it happens in my life time.


10 Responses to “The Asiafication of New Zealand production.”

  1. Dan on November 14th, 2012 at 11:46

    Grat Post but if you can see the Asification of production why not the move to orientalisim of the elites or politics? Is’nt it just feudalism for Asia, ie just a stratified hierachical society with a few at the top and lots below. Whats makes you so sure that NZ elites wont or cant stomach trying to roll backor destroy the barriers to greater profits, seems they have been keen to push it as far as they can so far.

  2. Pablo on November 14th, 2012 at 12:22


    I intentionally left the question of a parallel move towards Orientalism unanswered precisely because it is open to debate. I do think that under current conditions, given the ideological dominance of market logics, Orientalism is not required for Asiafication to take hold. But as I said in the post, the latter is not a long-term solution in a democratic society, which is why the question of its preferred political shell becomes relevant.

  3. Dan on November 15th, 2012 at 11:37

    Fair enough but you may be more optimistic than me in regards to the elites in any country wanting to maintain a shell of democracy if it can be done away with, or better yet maintin the illusion of democracy while hollowing out all genuine democratic aspects of a society. I have also seen what Singapore is like, having lived there, and the illusion is very detailed.

    New Zealand current political elite may not be openly saying what they want but the effects of many of the policies which are being enacted are clear enough. The shift may be minor at this point but I would say that the movement is towards a Singapore like state not away.

  4. Pablo on November 15th, 2012 at 12:47

    It is a rare day when I am called optimistic about things political. I share some of your skepticism about the present NZ elite, but do not think that it is possible for them to steer NZ towards a SG-like state. SG’s very small size and the resultant one party domination of most aspects of society is so pervasive so as to limit the comparison. NZ may be small but not THAT small, so issues of control would be more difficult even if there was an authoritarian regime in power.

    For NZ elites to make a successful move towards Orientalism would require cooperation by Labour, the Greens and others. It would require suppressing local government autonomy (which I admit has been done to some extent). And it would require a population willing to trade off democracy and other forms of voice and participation in and out of the work place in pursuit of some ethereal better material standard of living (which is what most Singaporeans have essentially done up until very recently).

    I do not think that combination of factors will obtain in NZ, which is why I see the move towards Asiafication as a dangerous but ultimately short-term solution to issues of market competitiveness.

    The question is how long before Labour, the Greens and other progressive organizations unite around common repudiation of the model. So far, I see no indications from Labour that it will do so, and the CTU is more interested in keeping its share of the pie rather than rolling back the Asiafication process. Although the Greens and less compliant unions may be working to that end, without the support of the big players the road to de-Asiafication will be a bumpy and perhaps long one.

  5. Dan on November 15th, 2012 at 16:13


    I would agree with your points, sorry about calling you an optimist.

    My concern is less what any current goverment would do but that there does not appear to be little if any roll back by the opposition when it does come into power which leads to a slow creep away from the basic values which democracies hold. True it can never really be a one party state but it can become one of those captured democracies where the elites are incharge and just change the parties to suit. Somewhat like the US.

    Obviously there is a limit to this and I like you am interested in seeing where and when that reaction would crystalise.If it follows any historical bent it will be when the facade starts to really crack and conditons (political or economic) become such thatthere is more value in getting involved than sitting out.

    Also you are right that NZ cannot be a direct copy of SPG but I was alsways amazed how it could appear from the outside to be such a pleasnt democratic place but once inside it could be relatively draconian if a benign state.Once referred to by William Gibson as “Disneyland with the death penalty”.

    The comparision to NZ was that the illusion would be greater than reality at some point and any true means of chnage would waterd down or lost.

    That said I watched SPG with the transition for Lee Kwan Yew to his son and the effect that had, or the debate over the casino, or the ongoings with Dr Chee so its fair to say that democracy is not dead in SPG but its muted, very muted.

    And while I am not a Green supporter per se I see them as more likly to advocate for change than Labour which if anything is just trying to get its numbers back before going back to biz as usual.

  6. Blackadder on November 15th, 2012 at 21:45

    Pablo, I agree that there is certainly an end to the “welfare capitalism” that cacooned the western working class from the effects of unrestricted capitalism for a long time, until capitalist development in Asia reached a certain threshold, but your invocation of Marx’s Asiatic mode of production is incorrect, and unnecessary. The Asiatic mode of production was one of several pre-capitalist modes of production postulated by Marx. It became a bit of a sideshow that was regarded as a variant of feudalism. The key issues in any consideration of a “mode of production” in Marxian terms are the forces and relations of production. Under a Marxist understanding of captalism, a key feature of the relations of production is the existence of “free labour” — free in the sense that the owners of the means of production have no responsibility for those they employ beyond paying them the value of their labour minus the surplus value thereof. So what we have at present, however much it might be influenced by contemporary Asian forms of capitalism, is still a capitalist mode of production, not the pre-capitalist feudal variant to which Marx gave the tentative name “Asiatic mode of production”.

  7. Pablo on November 16th, 2012 at 08:31


    Thanks for the critique. I agree that the “free labour” concept is useful to describe the approach to workers in unregulated labor market conditions. My use of the concept of the Asiatic mode of production, extrapolated from its conceptual origins to the present (and recognizing the risk of conceptual stretching in doing so), hinges on the core concept of the super-exploitation of human labor and the corresponding social relations of production that derive thereof. These can be either pre-capitalist or capitalist, pre-modern, modern or post-modern in manifestation.

    Like other productive forms, contemporary Asiatic modes of production have their roots in pre-capitaist modes of production but have evolved over time into what we see in many parts of Asia today. Thus it is by no means a feudalistic sideshow but in fact central to the the way in which Asian capitalism has come to the fore in recent decades, to the point that it is now considered to be the most competitive type of capitalism when compared to Western variants.

    One can argue that all variants of capitalism had their origins in feudalistic variants (I do not subscribe to that notion but put it out there for argumentative purposes), but path dependency analysis demonstrates that their respective evolutions (or dialectics if you prefer) have led to very different contemporary manifestations of “post-feudal” production. Contemporary Asian capitalist variants exhibit demonstrable collective differences from Western variants in that they continue a historical lineage rooted in super-exploitation of human labor as a central if not defining feature. In the developed West of which NZ is ostensibly part, that feature was abandoned nearly a century ago.

    In the Asian models labor is not “free” in the sense you describe but in fact constrained by employer and/or state-centered regulation that ensures the collective subordination of the working class to the dominant ideological project. In the free labor model workers could still organize independently even in the face of employer resistance and at some individual hazard, something that if very difficult to do allowed them the opportunity to use their collective weight to extract concessions in the labor process. Although not as important as craft guilds in the formation of early Western unionism, the opportunity structure of free labor helped in the development of working class collective agency in the 19th century.

    Unencumbered by the niceties of Western labor market regulations and conditions–codified in the likes of ILO articles and conventions drawn up mostly by Western welfare states in the post WW2 era and to which countries like Singapore either do not or only partially adhere to (and if so, differentiating between individual and collective rights and reaffirming the dominant role of the state in determining them)–the new form of Asiatic production is at its core as ruthless and relentless in its exploitation of human labor as was its pre-capitalist predecessor, with the exception that now advanced technologies have been added into the surplus generating form (I shall omit discussion of the role of “borrowed” rather than indigenously researched and created technologies in this evolution).

    Because Western elites have bought into the concept of the “Asian Century” as a result of the phenomenal transformation of Asia over the last three decades, some such as those in NZ appear to think that the best way to remain competitive is to import Asian approaches to production lock, stock and barrel. When that includes attempts to model labor market frameworks along Asian-style lines, that becomes a large point of concern.

    One irony is that in the most developed democratic Asian states such as Japan, South Korea and Taiwan (and to a small extent even Singapore), there has been a move towards selectively adopting more Western style labor market approaches, which is seen as humanizing the productive process and fostering, if not deepening, more egalitarian forms of interaction at the sub-national, non-political level. This is done because these states understand the long term reproductive need for social harmony based upon working class consent to the the political-economic status quo.

    In NZ we are going in the other direction.

    Thanks again for the critique. My answer may not satisfy you but it is good to hash out these differences in interpretation. After all, I do not get to discuss Marxist concepts very often now that I am out of academia and living in the “real” world.

  8. Tiger Mountain on November 16th, 2012 at 14:12

    The key component here is the “reserve army of labour” i.e. unemployed, underemployed, precariously employed and migrant super exploited under minimum wage rates. Milked for all it is worth by most employers major and tin pot.

  9. Blackadder on November 16th, 2012 at 21:50

    Pablo: Thanks for your detailed response. My own comments were focussed on what I took to be a loose appropriation of Marx’s category of Asiatic mode of production; but I, too, find myself in the real world and indisposed to endless hair splitting on matters of Marxist theory (so I won’t). Having said that, I agree that it is good to give differences of interpretation a good workout, and Marx’s ideas remain valuable for interpreting the contemporary world. Unfortunately there is little appetite for them in NZ, as the fewer than usual number of replies to your latest posting demonstrates.

  10. DeepRed on November 20th, 2012 at 18:28

    Blackadder: To borrow another Marxist concept, false consciousness – the financial counterpart to the “house negro” – has successfully manifested in the form of the Reagan Democrat/Essex Man/Waitakere Man demographic by way of the aspiration delusion, who would otherwise challenge the system. It also evokes the “12 cookies” joke.

    And not many of the Singaporean model’s cheerleaders would invoke Lee Kuan Yew’s immortal quote: “If Singapore is a nanny state, then I am proud to have fostered one.” Unless of course, it applies to the “proles” rather than the Inner & Outer Parties.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)