buy viagraa discreeetly viagras prix lerk jet sildenafil yahoo real estate can we get viagra pills in hyderabad where can i buy zithromax powder in brooklyn prednisolone liquid inactive ingredients in crest dosages for cialis generic zovirax pills doxycycline ulcerative colitis mail order real viagra from vipps zithromax 500 mg azithromycin side sorel boots buy online uk viagra buy cialis at walmart weaning off 25 mg zoloft desowen cream generico do viagra repeated use of doxycycline 77canadianpharmacy com buy zoloft cialis 5 mg x 14 viagra generico bonifico cipro pregnancy safety car get pregnant first course of clomid 0 5 mg di finasteride 5 zovirax patches ireland sildenafil se puede comprar sin receta medica can i get viagra over the counter in australia herbal viagra buy in sri lanka white and blue generic cialis address for viagra in lahore pakistan accutane two pills a day best price for cialis 25 mg can i buy a generic viagra in london viagra online with american express sildenafil vega extra 130 mg is how many ml generic cialis from india orange round prednisone steroid sale 5mg tab vs. 1 mg propecia tatanol 150 mg zoloft cytotec seller in qatar loxapac 25 mg of zoloft stopping zoloft at 50 mg generic 2.5 cialis propranolol in first trimester examples of writing prednisone prescriptions deutschland online apotheke cialis for daily use clomid ovulation kit can lasix and bumex be given together how to treat accutane hair loss does 5mg of cialis last as long as 20 mg what is the best dosage for zoloft pediatric dosage amoxil medexpress viagra reviews can you take viagra with amoxicillin donde puedo comprar cytotec en cartagena soft generic viagra sales ampicillin for gbs uti in early pregnancy nausea and accutane viagra for women available in ahmedabad buy zovirax generic online how soon does cialis take effect zovirax purchase on line take diflucan two days in a row cipro 5oo mg cytotec online from canada what happens when mixed viagra in someones drink cipro low cost voli zoloft for extreme social anxiety disorder buying generic doxycycline without a prescription round blue generic viagra paediatric dose of amoxil glottal 500 mg metformin viagra phizer buy cost viagra nigeria donde comprar viagra en andorra clomid 50 mg men 5 mg prednisone pregnancy side buying viagra online safely clomid uses and dosage metformin 500 mg b12 canada order prednisone csnsda can i take viagra with verapamil liquid doxycycline allergic reaction the price of propecia get viagra in edmonton quando il cialis generico viagra luxemburg rezeptfrei price of cialis per pill in us splitting 50 mg zoloft zovirax ointment cheap diflucan 150 mg e gravidanza paypal viagra spanien beta blocker propranolol reviews anxiety buy ciplai cialis ampicillin 500 mg instructions can i buy real cialis online clomid and ovidrel costs generic daily cialis 2.5mg zithromax azithromycin 1.0 gm 4 x 250 mg a single dose 5mg cialis not working clomid 50 mg tablet price in india is prednisone 10 mg safe for liver patient how to get hard with viagra cialis generico 20 mgrs. viagra generic any good registrazione utente generico de cialis best diet on zoloft when is a generic for viagra coming out how to buy viagra at singapore cialis lilly uk cheapest price for accutane dosage for sildenafil citrate do walmart sell clomid cialis reviews for older men how much rand does viagra cost in joburg s.a sildenafil otc products where to go to buy viagra in singapore sildenafil citrate tablets delgra 50 digoxin and lasix how can i buy cytotec is viagra available in swiss tadalafil cost europa orange colored tadalafil tadalafil sublingual 20 mg is it legal to buy viagra online from australia offbrand viagra reviews buy generic viagra in hyderabad blue zeus viagra review is ciprofloxacin safe to take while breastfeeding tamil doctor in viagra metformin uk pharmacy chains propecia warning label buying viagra frankfurt average cost melphalan and prednisone sildenafil in heart is it dangerous to take more than 20 mg cialis at once how much does viagra cost at walmart ca take 2 cialis 5mg ofirmev generic viagra can one take 2 cialis in 24 hours can i take viagra into the us es muy peligroso usar cytotec fake and real cialis cialis buy online in australia indian brands tadalafil and depoxitine viagra liquidian cipro 500 mg tab bayer ndc number viagra pills in delhi with price dapoxetine price in pakistan of lg sildenafil eciwlcodkedefe for sale cialis 20mg south africa how much does it cost cialis generico comprar en sevilla comprar cytotec en chihuahua doxycycline hyclate 100 mg efectos secundarios metformin upset stomach can you buy zithromax high doses of lasix qual o generico do clomid is cialis safe to take with hepatitis c viagra uk multiple orgasm male lasix para q se usa ovulate twice in one cycle clomid pregnancy how do i know if he has taken viagra indications for metformin zoloft 50 mg insomnia propranolol er for anxiety clomid 50mg success rate buying generic viagra online legal viagra order it cialis tables 20mgs how much to buy viagra free nhs prescription can a doctor refuse to prescribe viagra australia viagra buy from bangladesh diflucan 50 mg posologie definition viagra type drugs in india half inderal for anxiety propranolol 160 mg tablets propranolol for hemangioma in adults pharmacokinetic of tadalafil 20 mg tablet price of doxycycline malaria tablets pentasa generic alternatives for viagra can you buy viagra from canada dapoxetine 60 tablet name in mumbai cialis daily dosage metformin 250 mg day how far in advance should i take a viagra pill prednisone 20 mg indicaciones de afumix i want buy doxycycline in durban cialis delivery peru prednisone out of system use of zoloft in elderly can clomid cause period pain i want to buy viagra from rayh healthcare india alchemist viagra cialis original 40 mg ciprofloxacina in inglese fenprocoumon 3 mg bijwerkingen cialis tadalafil use in bphc metformin best time to take it is it safe to order viagra from canada on line uk generic zovirax pills sirve igual el generico de cytotec amoxil bd 400 mg 5ml buy viagra on line at tesco siti sicuri dove comprare cialis zithromax 250 mg dosage chlamydia symptoms se puede comprar viagra sin receta en francia experiencias usando cytotec zithromax london viagra india quora login breaking 100mg viagra half in de morning zovirax 800 mg spcc cialis generic 2.5 ciprofloxacin genericon 500 how much does viagra cost in the united states cipro hc ear drops sale generic viagra good brand name where to buy cialis in london cialis 5mg preis clomid 200 mg twins buy in person viagra melbourne cheapest india amoxil 500 purchase viagra in us cipro for india travel does cialis build up in system over time to work price of viagra in domincan repubic can you get high from zoloft 100 mg how long does a 100 mg viagra last for diclofenac 150 mg dosierung viagra skoda vrs for sale in uk zithromax low priced propecia free price viagra viagradrugs net how long does antabuse stay in your system cost for cialis canada is buying doxycycline online safe sildenafil citrate in pphn bekomme ich cialis in luxemburg amoxil dose for ear infection best serm clomid busik online viagra cialis 5mg daily loading dose 20 mg msds finasteride tablets usp 5 mg prednisolone acetate cost doxycycline many mg acne asphalt shingle price increases for viagra uk sales of viagra hatena 25 mg zoloft are metformin and actos in the same family ampicillin concentration liquid culture charleston comprar cialis generico 10mg valium doxycycline 100 mg tablet wsw what is the street value of a 50 mg viagra cialis 2 5 mg cpr 28 prix carburant que contiene la viagra ciprofloxacin buy prednisone and lasix is it safe to take nifedipine together with amoxil 1 tolindol 150 mg viagra diflucan tablete 50 mg nipple thrush aprovel 150 mg generico de cialis order finasteride rowcmoadreders buy cialis in singapore and address propecia generic effectiveness cheap viagra no prescription needed average price per pill of viagra cuanto vale el viagra en mexico where i can find viagra in japan is it safe to take ambien while on prednisone cialis daily new zealand ist viagra in italien rezeptpflichtig can i buy clomid from jhb pharmacy propecia get uk can i use viagra more than once a day priligy reviews name viagra tablet india will ampicillin treat a bladder infection zithromax mims thailand online arthrotec 75 mg pfizer viagra amoban 10 mg prednisone cheap viagra from canadian pharmacy buying viagra with pay pal doxycycline 50 mg acne effectiveness is viagra safe to use for a 18 year old lower dose of viagra best moisturizer to use on accutane can you take viagra if you take amlodipine tadalafil otc in florida generico de viagra en venezuela medida viagra female uk oraxim 500 mg metformin samsca 15 mg fiyati viagra ciprodex generic name cosco pharmacy price cialis can buy cipro over counter viagra cost decrease is viagra safe with depresion medication ladies viagra tablets name how long does viagra take to work in a 35year old male buy online generic propecia finpecia fincar com can ciprofloxacin 500 mg cure clap pfizer viagra purchase clomid uk pharmacy medicines nolvadex and arimidex together costo del viagra generico in farmacia guadalajara where to buy viagra over the counter in seattle buy viagra aberdeen scotland prolonged use of propecia tadalafil not working prednisone long safe take buy dapoxetine in pakistan hyderabad cheap cialis prices australia sildenafil home delivery in india diflucan price philippines nokia prednisone 10 mg 6 day directions for gout cheap generic viagra oscimin generic cialis prices in rupee of indian viagra diflucan 150 mg 1 dose of dmt que es misotrol cytotec online finasteride recommended dosage for hair loss abnormal menses accutane reviews zovirax cream glaxosmithkline philippines price costo de la pastilla cytotec lasix 40 mg dosierung tadalafil other brand name nolvadex pct dosage where to get cytotec pills in malaysia cialis 5 mg double obat diflucan 150 mg tablet viagra 50 mg keine wirkung buy 200 mg sildenafil cost of ciprofloxacin ear drops without insurance cheap viagra .99 cialis daily vs one time can you trust buying viagra online is cipro toxicity real roche glucophage no rx how to take prednisone for asthma prednisone 5 mg 12 day dose pack directions yahoo lasix 70 mg geriflox caps 500 mg metformin classification of glucophage is doxycycline safe for nursing mother is it ok to take viagra once comprare cialis opinioni inderal night sweats amoxil 500 is used for accutane buy online australia visa la spezia cap generico do viagra si joint specialist in chicago illinois propecia cost in nz i want to buy diamond viagra zithromax baownbeuv price nolvadex 20 mg astrazeneca teva canada viagra generic reviews of antabuse generic viagra canada legal pot what is the best way to buy viagra sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg buy silver medsafe data sheet metformin dosage health canada metformin socialism in bible glucophage in renal failure buy viagra brazil ciprofloxacin in pregnancy medscape zoloft and aricept cheap online pill viagra viagradrugs net how much does one pill of viagra cost with no insurance buy pfizer viagra online usa comprar pastillas cytotec en medellin scrub typhus treatment doxycycline nolvadex tamoxifen b p 10 mg how can i get some viagra i accidently took 2 25 mg cialis polls priligy originale online where to buy cialis online in germany dose of prednisone in sarcoidosis over the counter vitamins better than viagra doxycycline hereisthebestin online no period when do i take clomid how long for amoxil to take effect does viagra maintain an erection after ejaculation compra priligy online viagra sales in nigeria conflict accutane australia can metformin be used in chronic kidney disease finasteride trade name viagra and plants phenergan walmart otc viagra can you take more than 20 mgs of cialis riomet generic cialis zithromax suspension price walmart cipro hexal 500 mg und alkoholi pastillas cytotec costovertebral tenderness denavir vs zovirax vs abreva reviews clomid use in women who ovulate lasix water pill dosages how long can you take cialis is cialis safe in hep c 2g amoxil sachet australia bula do selozok 50 mg zoloft how much viagra can i bring into australia will taking 40 mg cialis work better indian cipro doxycycline cause gerd wal mart cialis price 5mg sildenafil package insert lasix without a prescription overnight delivery viagra other names viagra sold in mexico purchase cialis canada cialis bph study generic propecia from india propranolol 20 mg in morning withdrawal prednisone 5 days 10 ml toddler amoxil 500 mg glaxosmithkline bridges zovirax ointment for sale propecia si trova in farmacia india brand viagra cialis generika preiswert hixizine generico do viagra propecia generic walmart sleep buyingcialis for womenuk cost of cialis in manila dapoxetine available in pakistan lahore purchase dapoxetine hereisthebestin finasteride 1 mg safe faer pharmaceuticals cialis over the counter safe take klonopin zoloft cialis 5 mg 28 composite how much cialis 10 mg cost finasteride reviews for hair womens viagra wholesale suppliers canada viagra 50 mg in half doxycycline antibiotics uk fitness metamorfoza cialis cost is 100 mg too much prednisone for hives cialis pill wholesale enantone lp 11 25 mg of zoloft doxycycline and prednisone taken together pirbuterol generic viagra viagra sale online india low cost viagra free shipping cialis while trying to get pregnant what happens if you take 2 viagra in less than 24 hours do not take clomid is 1000 mg zithromax safe generico de cialis en farmacias similares matamoros order generic zithromax cialis how long before it kicks in sildenafil sale cipa propranolol hcl cap 60 mg cr viagra for men in which use it is came lowest price candian viagra how long does it take clomid to raise testosterone pill identifier lasix 40 mg why does clomid cause miscarriage mercedes benz c55 amg for sale in uk zithromax dosteril 10 mg prednisone cytotec monterrey costo can buy viagra duane reade how much is generic finasteride in the us finasteride 1 mg tablets inderal 40 india cialis lily buy how long is diflucan in body viagra in thailand rezeptfrei viagra off counter from walmart diflucan over the counter philippines airlines doxycycline treatment chronic fatigue syndrome prednisolone 20 mg effet secondaire vit propranolol 10 mg nhsp cialis generic cialis cost zovirax 750 mg musaril tetrazepam dosierung ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin 500 mg administrare finasteride dosage transsexual buy diflucan inj cost viagra super active plus 24 hour delivery original viagra price in pakistan cialis 5 mg brand name for sale prednisone 10 mg cost can clomid cause hypothyroidism mepartricina generico de cialis is it ok to take accutane at night drinking in clomid propecia the crack ho ciprofloxacin meaning in urdu 5 mg propranolol for heart how to order cialis online inderal 10 mg erfahrungen how much does a month does cialis cost cialis 5mg price in ksa farmacia online italia cialis dose where can i buy viagra in delhi miglior cialis generico prednisone 5 mg taper instructions drugbank metformin er can i take propranolol and metoprolol in a day promius pharma accutane cost cialis cost me cada cuanto tiempo se puede usar viagra ciproxin 500 mg e cistite Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » bin-Laden bites the dust.

bin-Laden bites the dust.

datePosted on 19:01, May 2nd, 2011 by Pablo

Osama bin-Laden has met his maker, facilitated on his journey by a US Delta Force operation (which would have involved a SEAL fire team–SEAL Team Six, specifically– Air Force special operations platforms for insertion and extraction and US Army special forces and CIA paramilitaries doing the human, signals and technical intelligence to pinpoint his location and guide the fire team to the target, and which appears to have involved the fair use of deception in order to divert Pakistani attention elsewhere). Militarily, it is a tremendous achievement and underscores that the US military has become the most experienced and dangerous military force on earth (after all, it has been continuously at war for most of the last three decades, in both high and low intensity operations, and has developed a full spectrum skill set that no other military can match). It tells the jihadist movement that, as in the case of the old Nazi-hunter’s approach to fugitive war criminals, they can run but they cannot hide. It tells would-be adversaries such as the Chinese and Russians that they have a long way to go before they can militarily challenge with any hope of prevailing. As for the likes of the leaders of Iran and Venezuela, it tells them that reckless provocations can have unpleasant consequences even if they hide amongst wimin and children. In a word, the US is unsurpassed in projecting force, which means it is dominant in any battle field, even if it takes some time for it to adjust to the tactical exigencies of the moment (this, however, does not mean that it can politically prevail in every instance, which ultimately is the determinant of overall victory in war. Political issues, rather than military balances, are what make the Afghan conflict and Pakistan’s instability so intractable).

The significance of killing of bin-Laden is more symbolic and ideological rather than practical. After all, al-Qaeda has been fragmented and forced to devolve into decentralised small unit and self-radicalised “lone wolf” operations that cannot alter the strategic equation that runs against them. It can lash out and cause damage in restricted tactical operations, but it is no longer able to mount big symbolic attacks such as the 9-11 and 1990s US embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania (reports of a hidden al-Qaeda nuke in Europe notwithstanding). Strategically, AQ is not a game-changer.

The killing of bin-Laden is the second ideological blow to al-Qaeda that has terminally weakened it as a global political force. The first blow was the Arab Spring, currently ongoing, in which al-Qaeda is a non factor. Instead of rebelling in support of Sharia rule, fundamentalist interpretations of the Koran and the extension of the Caliphate, the Arab street has risen up against tyranny in favour of democracy, free speech, popular vote, government accountability and better equality of opportunity. These are “Western” values that al-Qaeda explicitly rejected, so the ideological repudiation of its vision of the preferred Muslim society is near complete. With the death of its symbolic leader, the futility of its fight is made apparent.

This does not mean that AQ is not dangerous. Ayman Al-Zawahiri, al-Qaeda’s operations director and the person with the fixation on airplanes and transportation hubs, is still alive. Small-scale operations, to include inevitable revenge attacks, will continue for some time to come, if not forever. But as a fighting as well as ideological force, al-Qaeda is spent.

However, another can of worms has been opened by bin-Laden’s killing. His location in a modern constructed (2005) fortified compound with 3-5 meter walls topped by barbed wire located 40 miles outside of Islamabad suggests complicity by at least some elements of the Pakistani state in sheltering him. Although President Obama has said that he consulted with Pakistani authorities and that they “collaborated” in the operation, the truth is more likely that such statements are designed to save Pakistani face and that if anything, the Pakistani authorities were alerted only once the operation was over. The civilian government is weak, fractured and does not control either the military or the intelligence services (ISI). one would think that at least some elements of Pakistan’s security forces would have to have been alerted to the construction of the compound and the unusual nature of its occupants. The Pakistani state is fractured and acts as a sieve when it comes to information leaks, unless the subject matter is too important for some state actors to divulge because their own core interests are involved. Thus it is improbable that the entire Pakistani security complex had no idea of bin-Laden’s whereabouts.

The Pakistani authorities are now confronted by a dilemma. They have repeatedly complained about drone strikes as violations of territorial sovereignty, and most recently ordered the expulsion of dozens of CIA agents. Yet the raid on bin-Laden, so deeply into Pakistani territory–over 120 miles from the Afghan border (or more than 250 miles if the assault came from the Arabian Sea) and so close to the Pakistani capital–is a direct and measured assault on the sovereignty of the Pakistani state. It tells the Pakistani authorities that they do not have a monopoly on security within their borders, and that they are not trusted to share intelligence on critical subjects within those borders. This will leave them embarrassed and seeking a way to placate what will be inevitable domestic protests against the raid and supposed Pakistani collusion with it.

Under such conditions it is not implausible to speculate that some elements of the Pakistani security apparatus will attempt to stage a honor-restoring diversion so as to appease public unrest and re-establish some measure of self-pride. This could be focused on India or Afghanistan as easy targets for unconventional or proxy warfare. It could involve diplomatic retaliation such as a turn towards China. But is seems inevitable that the Pakistani State will be rendered by this event, and that the consequences of that destablisation may be anything but positive.

Hence, jingoistic flag-waving in the US notwithstanding (and some will say that the flag-waving is amply justified), the death of Osama bin Laden may bring some degree of closure but it is not the end of an era. It could well spark an uprising of extremist Muslim resistance that is reinvigorated by its  symbolic leader’s death. It will force a change in US-Pakistan relations and in the way Pakistan behaves as a geopolitical actor.  Whatever the consequences, this is just the end of one chapter and the beginning of another in a story yet to be concluded.

42 Responses to “bin-Laden bites the dust.”

  1. […] “Pakistan either had a direct role in the risky, bloody raid … or no role at all.” Kiwipolitico’s Pablo has an excellent essay, in which he also argues that “…the truth is more likely that […]

  2. Robert Winter on May 2nd, 2011 at 20:27

    “Oh, say, can you see, by the dawn’s early light…..etc etc”

  3. Sanctuary on May 2nd, 2011 at 22:22

    Knowing what we now know Obama knew, watching him joyfully and savagely skewering and mocking Donald Trump at the press club dinner takes on a whole new dimension. All the Palinesque, Tea Party attack memes have been killed stone dead:

    Angry Tea Partier: “he’s a Kenyan traitor selling out America to the Muslims!”

    Average American: “Dude, he killed Bin Laden. STFU.”

  4. Hugh on May 3rd, 2011 at 06:11

    A Pakistani turn towards China? I don’t think it’s possible for the two countries to be any closer than they already are!

  5. […] Pablo at Kiwipolitico has expanded on this and I will lean heavily on his analysis  but could I recommend that you follow the link and read his blog. […]

  6. kiwi in america on May 3rd, 2011 at 06:55

    Excellent analysis Paul

  7. Hamish on May 3rd, 2011 at 07:02

    ” The killing of bin-Laden is the second ideological blow to al-Qaeda that has terminally weakened it as a global political force. The first blow was the Arab Spring, currently ongoing, in which al-Qaeda is a non factor. Instead of rebelling in support of Sharia rule, fundamentalist interpretations of the Koran and the extension of the Caliphate, the Arab street has risen up against tyranny in favour of democracy, free speech, popular vote, government accountability and better equality of opportunity. These are “Western” values that al-Qaeda explicitly rejected, so the ideological repudiation of its vision of the preferred Muslim society is near complete. With the death of its symbolic leader, the futility of its fight is made apparent. ”

    A point so obvious that I totally overlooked it and probably the most important point you make. I have to wonder how Koran burnings and mock trials of Muhammad in Florida look in context with your observation.

  8. Phil Sage on May 3rd, 2011 at 09:19

    Hooyah!!!
    Well done the Seals.

    Well done Obama.

    Great analysis above, it seems we are in agreement.

    There will be much bs written about how Pakistan must have slipped up but the reality is that it was a very well chosen spot. It would be impossible to spot someone who never went out in public but always stayed behind secure high walls. Just down the road from Pakistan’s West point would be a great place to hide in plain sight.

    The war on jihadism is won. now we are on mop up. This is the time for magnanimity and plenty of funding as happened with the Marshal plan.

  9. George D on May 3rd, 2011 at 09:56

    it is no longer able to mount big symbolic attacks such as the 9-11 and 1990s US embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania (reports of a hidden al-Qaeda nuke in Europe notwithstanding).

    Is this really the case? McVeigh committed alone (conspiracy theories notwithstanding) what was at that time the most significant act of terrorism on US soil with just a truck and agricultural chemicals. Now, it is the case that these have been restricted in recent years, but they’re certainly freely available. That low quality attacks have not been committed in the last 10 years suggests either that they have been defeated by intense surveilance, or that they have difficulty in recruitment.

  10. Regan on May 3rd, 2011 at 10:52

    If you truly believe that the War on Terror is over you are mistaken. You are right that Al Qaeda has decentralised its structure but that is a good thing for them because it means they are no longer reliant on one man for leadership. Bin Laden has only been a figurehead for the last few years, players like Anwar Al-Awlaki are now taking the lead on planning terror attacks. They may not have succeeded as yet but they have managed to get terrorists onto US planes and close enough to cause a real threat.

  11. bradluen on May 3rd, 2011 at 11:30

    Interested in what Pablo and others think will be the impact on Afghanistan. The US now have less incentive to be there (or at least have an excuse to get out); will they be able to turn this into greater pressure on Karzai to reform?

    Also don’t know what will be the effect on Taliban recruitment and retainment; can see arguments for effects in both directions.

  12. Pascal's bookie on May 3rd, 2011 at 13:27

    Bradluen;

    Marc Lynch gives his take here:

    http://lynch.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/05/02/islamist_politics_after_bin_laden

    and Fred kaplan here:

    http://www.slate.com/id/2292774

    With some differences, they agree that it all depends, but that there are opportunities, and risks. ;)

    Both well worth reading though, FWIW.

  13. Sh on May 3rd, 2011 at 16:44

    From a former journalist that posted on my facebook wall:
    “Some technical clarifications: ACE (formerly called Delta) and DevGru (informally called Seal Team Six), as well as the spec ops air units, are sister units and are part of SOCOM.

    The CIA wet ops is the SAD.”

  14. Pablo on May 3rd, 2011 at 17:08

    Sh.: SOCOM is the Special Operations Command based at McDill AFB in Tampa. The raiders are part of a JTF (not sure which number) set up in Jalalabad with the explicit mission of hunting high value targets. They are indeed a joint force of sister units, with the AF component home-based at Hurlburt Field (FL) and the Army SF component HQ’d at Ft. Bragg (NC). This time their joint training and ops paid off big time.

  15. Andrew W on May 3rd, 2011 at 21:56

    Are you ruling out the construction of the compound simply being successfully portrayed as a legitimate home for a wealthy man?
    So rather than lots of blabby Pakistanis being in on OBL being there, I wonder if perhaps the compound was financed through family connections, with the only local people who were aware of who lived there being a very few al-Qaeda. That is after all how terrorists usually operate, very much on a need to know basis, why did anyone in the Pakistan government or military need to know?

  16. Andrew W on May 3rd, 2011 at 22:09

    To put it into terms people in NZ would find easier to judge, if I were a notorious but wealth criminal wanting to live in style in NZ with minimal risk of being caught, I’d buy or build a flash walled rural mansion in the name of a foreigner, and use just one or two close aids to transport me there. Now, as long as I stay behind the walls, my close aids keep their mouths shut, and no one links those aids to me I should be safe. If I let anyone else in on the secret, especially bureaucrats, I’m doomed.

  17. Bruce Hamilton on May 3rd, 2011 at 22:18

    I assume that the very highest security Pakistanis were aware of the operation, but perhaps not knowing who the high value target was. The muted and rapid government responses suggest at least a prior inkling.

    The public also would be aware such understandings exist, hence the absence, to date, of significant demonstrations. OBL’s death was an expedient solution, probably welcomed by most Pakistanis, if they cared.

    However, any Pakistani openly acknowledging prior or actual knowledge of the USA raid would become a high value target of the many USA-hating factions active in Pakistan. “Ignorance” is mutually beneficial.

    The USA has, over the last couple of years worked quite hard to cultivate Pakistan, who happen to have also suffered large numbers of civilian deaths from various terrorist factions. Many citizens feel their sacrifice is unappreciated in the West.

    Pakistan has quite an effective military, as they provide support for several Gulf states, and are relatively well trained, and the USA seems to want them inside the tent. I doubt any “honour-restoring diversion ” is required.

    Also, anybody who has travelled in Pakistan would be aware that high-walled compounds are common, because of purdah. Wealthy families, especially from the north, will spend money to completely protect their women, so this compound may only be exceptional because of the extra security and perhaps wall thickness, not design or wall height.

    Only Americans and fellow-travellers would imply the compound’s acceptance was evidence of complicity.

  18. Pablo on May 3rd, 2011 at 22:32

    Bruce:

    Abbottabad is an Army town and the compound was located 200 meters from the entrance of Pakistan’s most elite officer’s academy. It had no phone or internet connections. It was built in 2005 in the midst of the most intensive man-hunt ever mounted. It received couriers but no other visitors. Even the rubbish was not put out for collection.

    Under those conditions do you not think that someone might have wondered who the “big wig” was? Given that Pakistan operates under martial law, would not some authority have looked into who the occupants might be? Your argument about purdah is crassly simplistic and does not cut it as an explanation. Likewise your claims about the Pakistani military display an appalling level of ignorance about its internal factionalisation and divided loyalties. Thankfully you did not refer to the ISI, who you must assume are also paragons of virtue.

    It is not just “Americans and fellow travels” who have suspicions about official complicity in bin-Laden’s ten year refuge. So keep your veiled insults to yourself.

  19. Andrew W on May 3rd, 2011 at 23:47

    It’s about 800 metres from the academy, the compound is one of numerous similar compounds in the area, and there was no mystery about the ownership (from the Guardian): “Nobody, of course, had ever seen Bin Laden. “Never in my wildest dreams would I have dreamed he was inside,” said one neighbour. But many knew two Pashtun men who owned the house – possibly Bin Laden’s trusted courier and his brother who unwittingly led American spies to their quarry last August.

    The Pashtuns kept to themselves, people said – burning their own rubbish, sending children to buy food at the shops, attending daily prayers but spurning small talk. Nobody seemed to know their names, or where they came from – some thought Afghanistan, others said Waziristan in the tribal areas.”

    So, for now I’ll accept the hiding in plain sight without the Pakistani army knowing, as you said “The Pakistani state is fractured and acts as a sieve when it comes to information leaks.” I’m sure OBL also knew this.

  20. Andrew W on May 4th, 2011 at 00:02

    Thinking about it some more, given OBL’s success in avoiding capture for so long, especially given the effort that’s been put in to getting him, it just does not seem even remotely plausible that he’d be foolish enough to trust the knowledge of his where-abouts to the Pakistani army. It’d be a mad scramble to get the reward.

  21. Pablo on May 4th, 2011 at 00:03

    Andrew W.:

    The “hiding in plain sight” theory requires the willful suspension of disbelief. You and Bruce may prefer to do so, but by nature and training I do not. You will be proven wrong.

  22. Bruce Hamilton on May 4th, 2011 at 00:23

    Abbottabad was the major tourist centre for the region, the area is quite beautiful with plenty of relatively-expensive compounds. Plenty of Pakistani tourists were there, very few foreigners.

    It was known as the “city of schools”, with rich parents campaigning to get their children into one of the top schools. Lots of nice compounds in many of suburbs, as with many other similar areas in Pakistan.

    I was curious about the high walls, and had to be reminded of purdah. Most Pakistanis I met wouldn’t want to be curious about owners of any nice compounds in the region, drug and arms traders aren’t very tolerant.

    Media is focusing on the presence of military academy, but I don’t recall exceptional activity, just the typical checkpoints.

    It’s on the Karakoram Highway, and was one of many British Hill Resorts/Cantonments in desirable climates, with high value properties.

    There may be other reasons to suspect official complicity, but I clearly noted that, from my experience there, the compound’s unquestioned existence isn’t a good one.

    You decided to extend the scope so, if insulted, it’s self-inflicted.

  23. Pablo on May 4th, 2011 at 00:42

    Bruce:

    Leaving aside your gratuitous insult (which was in no way way invited or self-inflicted, and which will not be tolerated henceforth), do really think that gaining title to the land, securing power and water, contracting builders etc would have escaped anyone’s notice? In the middle of martial law? In the middle of a massive man-hunt? Even if all of the above was done by third parties, do you really believe that no local or national authority would have taken some interest in the who/what of the compound? in a city that has been heavily militarised in recent years? The level of incompetence you suggest defy credulity, and the fact that the Pakistani government has launched an inquiry indicates that they have reason to think that something more than “local” support was in play.

    Your anecdotal recollections are no substitute for hard analytic facts, so I suggest you desist with this line of argument until conclusive proof comes out one way or the other.

  24. Phil Sage on May 4th, 2011 at 01:33

    Pablo – Whilst sharing your disdain for Hamiltons not so veiled insult I agree with his point. Occams razor.

    I am quite happy to be a fellow traveller with a democratic system that has brought freedom to millions. Better that than a misogynist apologist for theocratic fanatics.

    For a comparison, think Waco Texas. People were obviously aware of it but there was a reluctance for years to act.

    Take it as given that Osama would never have been seen in public. Take it as given that any low level enquiries would be met brusquely without identification of who was there.

    Take it as given that the complacency of hiding in plain sight for 5 years is what lead to his downfall.

    But that does not mean that Pakistan does not have some very robust questions to answer.

    There was apparently a huge trove of intelligence. I look forward to McChrystals teams rolling up a few more jihadists in the coming days and weeks. My guess is there is panic in the world of AQ.

  25. SPC on May 4th, 2011 at 02:38

    Phil, I am not sure that it’s being an American or fellow traveller with Americans that is the point at issue – but to associate being one or the other with then being likely to make false assumptions.

    Time will tell whether there is any evidence that Pakistani intelligence etc knew of bin Laden’s location. That they did is a presumption.

    This reminds me of the time when Iraqi refusal to allow arms inspectors to do their jobs was exploited to overthrow the regime. One the one hand, it was a breach of cease-fire terms with the UN and on the other it raised the threat of a WMD capability existing or being developed. Clearly it was all a ruse to imply a capability to cower local opponents and also Iran – and one suspects the West secretly knew this and yet in a bold double bluff exploited this post 9/11 to justify regime change (knowing there was no WMD threat to invading forces).

    But can one prove this, similarly can anyone prove elements within Pakistan knew of bin Laden’s location?

  26. Keir on May 4th, 2011 at 02:38

    But there has to be a pretty big gulf between “OBL’s in there”, and “there’s a guy in there who’s probably on a bunch of watchlists and probably doesn’t want the Americans to know too much”. I wouldn’t be surprised if various people took care not to know much more than the second option.

  27. Andrew W on May 4th, 2011 at 09:08

    Pablo said: “The “hiding in plain sight” theory requires the willful suspension of disbelief.”

    Why? What mechanism would lead to the discovery of his presence under that scenario? What would give him away?

    I find the “hey, lets live within easy reach of the Pakistani military, and tell them there’s a pot of gold for the taking” – and then those in the Pakistani army in the know manage to keep it secret for five years – theory more implausible; not quite as implausible as the “Bush did 9/11” theory, but getting there.

  28. Pablo on May 4th, 2011 at 12:02

    No bribery involved? No curiosity about the placxe on the part of any security agency for at least six years? No interest in the comings and goings of couriers (even if they were working for drug lords)?

    I think Keir’s point that it may have been a case of people deliberately looking the other way, rather than directly assisting OBL, is the more alternative plausible theory.

    Since this has now diverted from the more important parts of the post I suggest we just wait and see what eventuates.

  29. Andrew W on May 4th, 2011 at 13:15

    $25 million US, dammit, if only I’d known..

  30. Pablo on May 4th, 2011 at 23:36

    Well, whaddya know. The Pakistanis have just said that they alerted the US to the compound in 2009, but left it to the US to figure out who was in it. The art of double-talk looking doubly weak just took another step forward.

  31. SPC on May 5th, 2011 at 02:55

    Their statement

    “As far as the target compound is concerned, ISI had been sharing information with CIA and other friendly intelligence agencies since 2009. The intelligence flow indicating some foreigners in the surroundings of Abbottabad, continued till mid April 2011. It is important to highlight that taking advantage of much superior technological assets, CIA exploited the intelligence leads given by us to identify and reach Osama bin Ladin, a fact also acknowledged by the US President and Secretary of State, in their statements”.

    It’s just the we knew nothing line, with added awareness of the coming into the residence and going out of the residence of people of sufficient note as to pass on the information – suggesting a certain level of competence and inter-agency co-operation. It compares reasonably well with intel flows (unacted upon) in the USA pre 9/11.

  32. CM on May 5th, 2011 at 08:21

    With respect Pablo, I think you’re probably wrong. The Guardian’s Jason Burke said this in response to a reader asking whether or not the Pakistani Army knew:

    “I honestly don’t know. I doubt it. I’ve spent a lot of time with Pakistani soldiers, officers and other ranks, and though anti-americanism is rife, and anti-semitism, anti-zionism, a particularly vicious tendency to accept the worst conspiracy theories and a range of other unpleasant ideas/beliefs as well as a broad conservative islamism, i don’t think they supported bin laden. mullah omar and the taliban, yes. lashkar-e-toiba, perhaps. but not OBL.”

  33. Pablo on May 5th, 2011 at 13:33

    CM:

    You could be right (although the views expressed are alarming enough) but that still leaves the ISI.

  34. Tom C on May 5th, 2011 at 19:05

    On a different tangent, Pablo, do you think the US intended to assassinate Osama – or would they have taken him alive, if possible?

  35. Pablo on May 5th, 2011 at 20:16

    Tom:

    Quite frankly I believe that it was a kill mission. Only if he had knelt down and surrendered would they have had to consider the capture option. The reason is that trying to bring him to justice would be a nightmare. Heck, the US cannot even get Sheik Khalid Muhammed to trial in NYC, so you can imagine what would happen if OBL was brought to GTMO. The ICC could have been an option given its success in prosecuting human rights abusers, but the Europeans did not want a bar of him fearing reprisals, civil unrest etc. In fact, holding him would have invited the taking of US or other Western hostages as pawns in a swap, and these would be killed off in the measure that the US did not agree to release him. Moreover, in prison he would be a more potent symbol of resistance than in hiding or dead.

    The upshot is that there was too much downside to a capture to make it feasible.

    As for the justification for a “kill” mission, let me explain the concept of “outlaw” (I originally posted this as a comment over at DPF’s troll farm). The concept is applicable to OBL. An “outlaw” is someone who has violated societal norms to the point that s/he is placed “outside” of the law–-that is, the person has forfeited the right to legal protection. This leaves him/her at the mercy of any countervailing force and completely self-reliant in terms of physical security and defense. The person is, in other words, fair game (which is where bounty hunters came into the picture in the US West). The designation of outlaw status comes from appropriate legal authority, which in this case was the US government but could have been the UN as a result of its post-9/11 security council resolutions authorising the use of force against AQ and the Taliban.

    I am not fan of wikipedia but its description of “outlaw” is succinct on the matter: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outlaw

    By any definition OBL was an outlaw, and the fact that he declared holy war on the US made him a legitimate military target.

    I shall leave aside the responsibility to protect, lesser evil and preventive war justifications for the raid, but basically they boil down to doing small harm to prevent greater harm from happening or continuing. In the measure that the US can argue that killing bin-Laden disrupts AQ’s ability to continue to harm innocents, then it has its legal grounds covered within the context of “just war” theory.

  36. Pablo on May 5th, 2011 at 20:19
  37. Luke on May 19th, 2011 at 23:01
  38. Andrew W on May 20th, 2011 at 10:44

    “Doubting commentators: thee be rebutted!”

    I read all that and just found more of the same.

  39. Luke on May 21st, 2011 at 08:10

    Andrew W, please enlighten me re your credentials or provide some supporting evidence for your pov. Here we have Pablo, a respected academic with considerable first hand experience within the US intelligence field and Lawrence Wright an acclaimed author and journalist (Pulitzer prize for NF, Overseas Press Club Award, National Magazine Award to name a few) and fellow at the Center for Law and Security at the New York University School of Law offering up detailed and evidence backed arguments.

  40. Andrew W on May 21st, 2011 at 09:13

    As to the question of whether or not the Pakistani military or intelligence knew OBL was there; I don’t think anyone has offered anything that could be called “evidence”, it’s all conjecture, to me though it seems really unlikely that someone who operates covertly, as terrorists do, and has done so for so long, who had $25,000,000 on his head and who avoided the huge US efforts to get him for ten years, would have been foolish enough to trust the Pakistanis. Especially given that even those who think they did know he was there are adamant that no one can trust the Pakistanis.

  41. Luke on May 21st, 2011 at 11:49

    Pardon me ‘evidence’ was poorly chosen; I meant supporting opinion (preferably informed). Thank you for taking the time to read Wrights essay.

    I don’t think anyone sensible is suggesting that ‘the Pakistani military or intelligence knew OBL was there’. Pablo says it better than I could [that the location, construction, security practices etc] ‘suggests complicity by at least some elements of the Pakistani state’

    Wright mentions ‘Within the I.S.I., there is a secret organization known as the S Wing, which is largely composed of supposedly retired military and I.S.I. officers. “It doesn’t exist on paper,” a source close to the I.S.I. told me. The S Wing handles relations with radical elements. “If something happens, then they have deniability,” the source explained. If any group within the Pakistani military helped hide bin Laden, it was likely S Wing.’

    and

    General Hamid Gul director general ISI 97-89 (fired for allegedly engineering a coup “helped oversee the creation of the Taliban, reportedly using mainly Saudi money. The I.S.I. openly supported the Taliban until September 11, 2001. Since then, the Pakistani government has disavowed the group, but it is widely believed that it still provides Taliban leaders with safe harbor in Quetta, where they stage jihad against Western forces in Afghanistan.

    And of course OBL was a veritable gravy train of US ‘aid’ for Pakistan (and it’s intelligence apparatus).

    Wright again “In 2009, Senators Richard Lugar and John Kerry, recognizing that American military aid had given the Army and the I.S.I. disproportionate power in Pakistan, helped pass legislation in Congress sanctioning seven and a half billion dollars in civilian assistance, to be disbursed over a period of five years. Pakistan’s Foreign Minister, Shah Mehmood Qureshi, apparently at the direction of the military, flew to Washington, and insisted that his country would not be micromanaged. So far, less than a hundred and eighty million dollars of that money has been spent, because the civilian projects require oversight and checks on corruption. The Pakistani military, meanwhile, submits expense claims every month to the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad; according to a report in the Guardian, receipts are not provided—or requested.”

  42. Luke on May 21st, 2011 at 11:56

    btw notwithstanding Pablos aversion to Wikipedia the page on Hamid Gul still makes interesting reading.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: