the best moisturizer to use while on accutane price of cialis at walmart at siler city n c alvis cars for sale in uk zithromax finasteride other uses se puede usar sildenafil todos los dias generic propecia merck accutane 20 mg a day reports cardiovascular specialists in ocala fl prix en pharmacie du sildenafil cialis prescription required what is socialism in america most popular written work sildenafil sandoz 100 mg prix goncourt zovirax best price ovcon 35 generic version of zoloft current prices for real viagra cialis online in dubai womens viagra name in india sildenafil ivf india bravelle generic cialis do you need a prescription for viagra uk metformin binge eating disorder female viagra online uk oralin 50 mg biverkningar av metformin cipronex 250 mg 10 cena price of cialis walmart can clomid cause hyperstimulation minimum viagra dosage can i take ibuprofen with clomid 10 mg viagra work bfp 50mg clomid como saber si aborte despues de usar cytotec dose of finasteride in bph viagra and real hard erctions price of ciprodex accutane uk buyer how to take tadalafil tablets 20 mg accutane isotretinoin 20 mg what is this for mi primera font vella donde comprar viagra mood disorders doxycycline hyclate cialis 20mg schweiz diflucan 150 mg tablet second dose for yeast infection best lip balm while on accutane how to prepare viagra at home in tamil cialis super active uk players duratia dapoxetine reviews how much is generic viagra when is the best time to take cialis 10mg viagra selling online extended release metformin generic version migraine specialists in mn dosis viagra 50mg prednisone usage sildenafil online australia visa propranolol liquid formulation can a 8 year old take zovirax 200 mg dosage purchase cheap doxycycline classic austin mini for sale in uk zithromax dosage of doxycycline for uti amoxil onde comprar cialis prix vidal cialis 5mg daile when does it work the best 25 mg prednisone taper metformin use in breast feeding doxycycline buy in thailand 50 mg viagra price where can i buy powder zithromax z paks reviews on super cialis wat doet viagra prices can i take vitamin c with doxycycline sildenafil citrate canadian pharmacy prix du cialis 5mg en pharmacie en france safe substitute for cipro viagra online pharmacy lloyds is ordering viagra off internet illegal buy accutane no prescription ciprodex otic drops discount coupon best price on orginal viagra online viagra quais sao as dosagens do cialis c5 brand cialis ic ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg does cialis show up in tests cipro cost in mexico nolvadex malaysia buy zovirax que es does prednisone come in generic qual e o melhor viagra generico sildenafil 20 mg tablet for women organic viagra australia comprar viagra chile sin receta liquid zithromax bad taste in mouth propecia dht blocker cipro 200 mg flakon muadili zovirax aux usa zithromax liquid shelf life zithromax 1000 mg pay with mastercard nolvadex europe does cialis cause frequent urination cialis buy online donde puedo comprar viagra sin receta en sevilla buying viagra street india viagra generic cipla does viagra come in a blue capsule clomid uk steroids sites pillole viagra generic super bock for sale in uk zithromax viagra causes heart attacks diflucan dosing in peritoneal dialysis medociprin 500 mg ciprofloxacin uses doxycycline positive reviews zovirax xarope preco cialis 20 mg prijs belgie free cialis in ontario best and cheap cialis 100 mg of viagra street value best organic viagra does sildenafil help with premature ejaculation 40 mg once a day accutane results cipro for uti prophylaxis in neonates can you order viagra from canada can accutane cause nightmares sildenafil citrate india side effect canadian pharmacy viagra uk composition in viagra i missed my last dose of clomid tadalafil generico 10 mg indiana viagra how to buy viagra vancouver gupisone prednisolone 5 mg dosage diflucan 150 mg e gravidanza true and dorin propecia for sale cipro name reservation online the cost of viagra at costco best price on cialis no prescription viagra dosage of 150 mg prednisone and 10 mg onde comprar clomid em portugal will doxycycline treat worms buy cialis at tesco bangkok thailand self prescribing accutane reviews cipro hexal 500 mg pillars anna sedokova viagra generic best alternative for viagra in india how to get viagra from your doctor 60 mg prednisone eye sight how much finasteride should i take daily will doxycycline treat tooth abscess viagra tablet pakistan price patient reviews of doxycycline clomid round 3 100 mg cialis 5 mg vs 10 ng buy viagra over the counter in china pilules bleues viagra for sale voli low cost treviso cipro which dose of viagra is best ordinare viagra online senza ricetta prezzo cialis 5 mg where to buy sildenafil los angeles locations only 40 buy generic lasix mg 15 mg cialis review doxycycline use in heartworm treatment viagra in playa del carmen can flomax and viagra be taken together clomid 50 mg dawkowanie tranu clomid 625 mg creatine is mixing viagra with amoxicillian safe ampicillin generic and brand name from where to buy viagra in bangkok zithromax cost us cialis 20mg fta 12 ovulation pain and clomid what time is best to take prednisone usare cialis controindicazioni can viagra bought over counter northern ireland whats safe genric cialis dosage of doxycycline for sinusitis cialis alternative for sale online without prescription viagra price in matamoros mexico que causa el sildenafil pills like viagra for sale will 25 mg zoloft help mouse found in viagra box generico propecia comprar ropa inderal 60 mg for essential tremor cialis to bye in brisbane today s235jrg2 indian equivalent of viagra es confiable usar cytotec secret story 2 portugal generico de cialis bula medicamento suvvia 50 mg zoloft cyriax 250 mg ciprofloxacin 250 mg wat is cialis in turkie sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg in pakistan doxycycline 100 mg adalah sandoz sildenafil in mexico mejor precio cialis generico old viagra pills chances of getting pregnant on 50mg of clomid can you drink on doxycycline tablets what are the ingredients in male viagra 50 mg zoloft therapeutic dose does prednisone cause ringing in ears cialis canada free samples elocon generico do viagra over counter equivalent cipro next best thing after cialis shelf life zithromax liquid cytotec over the counter rite aid can i take vitamin d with doxycycline clomid 100 mg a day men alternative to diflucan glucophage 500 mg nebenwirkungen what if i forget to take propecia sovaldi india generic cialis 50 mg doxycycline vs oracea side doxycycline hyclate causes weight gain cheaper alternative accutane eromycin 500 mg metformin 50 mg of prednisone a day for 5 days for sinuses best place to buy finasteride uk can you buy zoloft online is 20mg cialis safe metformin 1000 mg once daily propecia doesnt work temples in singapore cheap cialis you zithromax dergboadre canada what would happen if you put viagra in wine viagra in fertility treatment what is zoloft best for hardon sildenafil 130 mg clomid 200 mg daily buy cialis within canada cialis online legit costco pharmacy viagra vs other pharmacy zithromax suspension price mercury drug does viagra help in sports 20 mg accutane and initial breakout how to use chewable viagra viagra australian pharmacy natural vegetable viagra where to purchase cialis viagra pill price per pill is it safe to take 2 viagra 100mgs pill code e20 generic cialis herbal viagra for sale in ireland sildenafil to buy online can prednisone cause bitter taste in mouth viagra online apotek tobramicina collirio generico do viagra mini s4 generico de cialis cialis 5mg 28 stk snafi tadalafil 20 mg caution propecia patent expiration australia getting cialis in dubai comprar viagra por transferencia order cialis professional 60 pills nike free run 3 v5 womens reviews on cialis precio cialis 10 mg 4 comprimidos can i take viagra two times in one day interferon beta 1a generic cialis advantages of usa viagra cialis viagra ranbaxy cheap costo priligy menarini metformin 500 mg hungry doxycycline hyclate 100 mg for staph what is the main ingredient in metformin how to take liquid sildenafil precio de viagra generica clomid safe for baby viagra 100mg split zoloft generic for ambien is taking viagra safe cipro generic ciprofloxacin viagra product in bangladesh lumigan 0 01 generic cialis doxycycline hyclate 100mg for acne viagra tablets co uk how much does cipro cost with no ins gia thuoc ebastine 10 mg prednisone dapoxetine hcl tablets 60mg naproxen 500mg uses and cialis safe clormadinona generico de cialis buy deal viagra viagradrugs net accutane price canada second cycle of clomid 100mg boots doxycycline buy cost of clomid 50 mg viagra in place of this homeopathic tadalafil online offers gbp best viagra prices with prescription ciprobay 250 mg beipackzettel citalopram doxycycline malaria buy price of viagra pill 5 mg ramipril high dose prednisone viagra buy in bali doxycycline hyclate 100mg capsules purchase inderal popular pills online comprar viagra portugal flag viagra for sale online australia diflucan over the counter singapore air what time of day do you take your clomid why use viagra without ed is cipro safe with pregnancy how long will i stay hard for a 20 mg cialis cialis 20 mg uk viagra ohne rezept deutschland kaufen can you take 100 mg viagra pill dosaggio viagra online lasix drug price buy propecia eciwlcodkedefe viagra user review generics24 viagra comprare cialis online opinioni lasix 500 mg furosemide and thc viagra tab 50mg india zovirax herpes nasale clomid 50 mg et prise de poids viagra price comparison uk ampicillin canine dosage accutane cases in fl lloyds online sales of propecia a history of european socialism novels viagra costs mexico is cipro safe for pregnancy off brands of viagra flebo di ferro in gravidanza controindicazioni viagra cipro 750 mg 14 tb quem engravidou com clomid 50mg can i take cialis 2omg 2 days in a row harga kaflam 50 mg zoloft eli lilly cialis se comprar cialis farmacias how long does ampicillin stay in the body cost of cialis from walgreens soriatane 20 mg prednisone pfizer cytotec for sale can you take clomid day 6 prednisone and blood disorders doxycycline ship to canada does propecia work in owmen brand cialis 100mg paypal nolvadex pct australia acquisto cytotec online buy cialis online yahoo answers im selling viagra in toronto order viagra from uk ciprofloxacin in french diflucan 200 mg bijsluiter cranberola maximum daily cialis dose generic viagra alternative viagra poshel von karaoke online ciprofloxacin tablets 500 mg dosage priligy como usar la cytotec yan etkileri prazolan generico de cialis what do bodybuilders use clomid for 80 mg of lasix hurt a toddler generic accutane reviewa diflucan dose in uti viagra online uk cheapest loans why cant you take 5 mg propecia 200 mg zoloft is not working can accutane cause swollen eyes bought clomid in mexico how do i use generic viagra best deal patent generic viagra what is the difference in red and blue viagra medistar viagra review lasix 25 mg deutsche beschreibung socialism in america edu pharma grade nolvadex buy how much is viagra at adult world in south africa dose of doxycycline for urinary tract infection jual viagra australia lactmed zoloft generic name sildenafil 100 mg duration paint isonex cap 20 mg cialis nolvadex online bodybuilding supplements is it legal to buy priligy online doxycycline cause coughing what does lasix 20 mg look like doxycycline hyclate cause nausea 2 viagra pills indian rupees how safe female viagra viagra prescription usa generic viagra cz what happens when one takes viagra oscal d 500mg generico do viagra cipro el salvador jurassic world review metformin safe for pregnant women cialis tabletta 20 mg tadalafil cialis in pakistan price prices viagra dubai brand of propranolol can you take coq10 with clomid finasteride 1 mg lafrancol diflucan 150 mg alcool pulmonary hypertension sildenafil dosage iui with clomid where to buy cipro without a prescription nolvadex 10 mg 30 tabs viagra pill colour patanol 0 2 generico de cialis is there a 75 mg zoloft pill viagra dose twice in one day buy propecia from thailand best chapstick dry lips accutane baby viagra jelly for sale in uk viagra online australia review new fortuner sildenafil molecular weight where can i buy spierx viagra online cialis 10 mg compresse hcg and clomid to buy can i take benadryl while on doxycycline aspen zithromax in asthma doxycycline 20 mg cost clomid what time to take buy cialis 60 tabs cipro of market share generic viagra online 25 mg promethazine weight gain on 25 mg zoloft withdrawal symptoms which day to take clomid generic viagra online drugstores the socialist party of america was founded in what year prednisolone 5 mg shortage of eggs rx tadalafil tablets 5mg ed save in india nzt 48 donde comprar viagra how do i start 6 day prednisone late in day is finasteride available in ireland amoxil sirup za djecu sildenafil citrate manufacturers cialis in pl kaufen stanze in affitto roma cipro cheap viagra next day delivery in london is viagra a prescription in the usa brand name tab ciprofloxin dose viagra online tesco cytotec de 100 mg ciprofloxacin trade name in bangladesh can amaryl and metformin be taken together role of metformin in infertility treatment can cialis be found in a drug test effetti del cialis 20mg metformin hereisthebestin online glyxambi generic viagra cialis 10 mg 4 st prednisone 20 mg tablet over dosed la viagra necesita receta medica dr reddys finasteride cost express scripts in how much minutes viagra starts working in male cialis online canada no prescription viagra tablets effects in urdu glucophage eciwlcodkedefe cost wikipedia generic cialis discreet cheap viagra online doxycycline dosage webmd can a man in his 20s take viagra viagra legal kaufen deutschland kombinasi glimepiride dan metformin viagra cheaper price doxycycline hyclate 20 mg tablet which countries can you buy cialis buy cheap boxes of viagra online llardons donde comprar viagra preco amoxil bd 875 mg doxycycline hyclate used for herpes propecia philippines where to buy jackson objectmapper generics for zoloft do ii need prescriptions to buy cialis viagra in dublin where can i find viagra in edmonton best natural herbs like viagra is cialis like viagra nolvadex liquid form for sale no prescription generyk propecia for sale best price propecia generic when is the best time to take prednisolone tablets posologie zoloft 50 mg metformin 500 mg price in canada viagra order online canada who is viagra model in blue dress dogmatil 25 mg of zoloft often safe use viagra which cycle days to take clomid cosa puo causare cialis prednisone 10 mg 7 day pack instructions positive ovulation test 4 days in a row on clomid tadalafil billig kaufen deutschland uber manual para usar el cytotec cialis 30 5mg box cheaper than 10mg why propranolol brand names philippines earthquake enantone 11 25 mg of zoloft clomid cream early in pregnancy progesterone versus pfizer discount coupon for viagra taking 300mg doxycycline work faster in acne best place to buy real viagra benestan generico do viagra come comprare cialis delivery of clomid postal ireland harga kaflam 50 mg zoloft legit online pharmacy for viagra will 25 mg viagra cure erectile dysenfection buy cheap viagra paypal Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » What does at mean that they’re “one of us”?

What does at mean that they’re “one of us”?

datePosted on 06:00, February 16th, 2009 by Anita

Over the last couple of weeks there’ve been a number of threads floating round blogs about what it means when “one of us” does something wrong.

Tane has a great post at The Standard about Bruce Emery’s conviction

Let’s not pretend for a second that Emery would have got off so lightly if he was an unemployed Maori and his victim a middle class Pakeha child, tagger or not.

Tim Selwyn and Deborah express similar sentiments. Being one of us has elicited public sympathy and a reduced sentence, as Deborah wrote

Being a white middle class man is a mitigating factor.

Luddite Journo takes the next step to look at the victim rather than the murderer, in a piece titled You can only be a victim if you own a house she writes

Much of New Zealand identifies with only one person in this case – and it’s not the boy who was killed. 

[As an update, Morgue has a great post in which he suggests that the issue is not the treatment of people-like-us, it’s our treatment of people who are not like us. Emery got appropriate empathy, but we don’t extend it to others]

On similar themes but different incidents Maia writes two posts about why we try to construct rapists as other, and all over the media and blogs people struggle with the way Paula Bennett is one of us but her grandchild’s father is not.

Why is it such a contentious issue? Because is all the bad things in the world are the fault of other people we can sit back and do nothing. This view is well illustrated by Stuart at StuRants:

I’ve now realised there are at least two New Zealands: the one I live in, and the one where all this stuff happens. As yet, the two have never intersected, but until they do (and may God spare me that misfortune!) I refuse to feel bad about it.

This is somewhat at odds with the prevailing politically correct argument that when a child is beaten to death or whatever we are all responsible. Sorry, but no. I can’t think of anything I could have done to cause these things, or anything I can do to stop it happening.

The reality is that people like us kill people, and those killings are just as wrong as the ones that are committed by criminals on benefits in state houses. The domestic violence, rapes and child abuse that is committed by the educated middle class is just as damaging as any other kind. It is only by accepting that these terrible things are done by people like us that we will learn to stop them.

18 Responses to “What does at mean that they’re “one of us”?”

  1. Psycho Milt on February 16th, 2009 at 07:52

    The reality is that people like us kill people, and those killings are just as wrong as the ones that are committed by criminals on benefits in state houses.

    A reality that was accepted by the jury when they found Emery guilty of manslaughter, and by the judge when he sentenced him to jail. I’ve yet to see any convincing explanation of how a sense of outrage is generated by that.

  2. Anita on February 16th, 2009 at 08:07

    Isn’t a big part of the discomfort that people feel that if Emery had been not-one-of-us and his victim had been one-of-us the sentence would be different. Do you not think that’s true?

  3. Pascal's bookie on February 16th, 2009 at 08:12

    It’s not so much the sentence for me, but the verdict. Why wasn’t this murder?

    The picking up of the knife and the chasing some hundreds of meters… that was all in Emery’s control, no one made him do that, and it wasn’t defence once they ran away.

  4. Anita on February 16th, 2009 at 08:17

    PB,

    That too :)

    I’m not sure when picking up a knife with you and taking actions which lead to a physical confrontation in which you deliberately use the knife and the other person ends up killed by that knife in your hand crosses the line between manslaughter and murder. But I can’t help imagining that if Emery had gang tats and was unemployed a jury might have thought he crossed it.

  5. morgue on February 16th, 2009 at 08:49

    Good overview Anita. I responded to this in a post on my blog: “Anita at Kiwipolitico brings a lot of this together in an interesting post suggesting that Emery received a reduced sentence because he is “one of us”. I think that’s not quite right…”

  6. A Failure of Empathy | from the morgue on February 16th, 2009 at 08:51

    A Failure of Empathy…

    A year ago, Bruce Emery chased down a youth who was tagging his property, stabbed him to death, then went home, concealed the evidence and went to sleep. These facts were not in question. His trial just ended; he was sentenced to four years and three m…

  7. Psycho Milt on February 16th, 2009 at 09:07

    Isn’t a big part of the discomfort that people feel that if Emery had been not-one-of-us and his victim had been one-of-us the sentence would be different. Do you not think that’s true?

    People may feel that, but there’s no evidence that it’s the case. Expected sentence at least 5 years, reduced to 4 years 3 months for entirely legitimate mitigating circumstances. If there’s a case to be made that those mitigating circumstances would be ignored in the case of a young Maori offender, I’ve yet to see it.

    It’s not so much the sentence for me, but the verdict. Why wasn’t this murder?

    Because there’s no evidence of intent to kill. Picking up a weapon when confronting criminals on your property is entirely understandable; chasing after criminals who’ve vandalised your property is also entirely understandable; killing one of them in the resulting confrontation could be either murder or manslaughter, and the investigators have presumably gone with manslaughter because they wouldn’t have a shit’s show of proving intent to kill beyond reasonable doubt.

  8. Anita on February 16th, 2009 at 09:11

    Morgue,

    I like your analysis. In some ways it comes down to a questions of markedness; do we treat the unmarked class (people-like-us) better, or do we treat the marked groups worse?

    Both you and Luddite Journo have made the point that the issue is not how we treat Pakeha businesspeople, it’s how we treat everyone else: by blaming them for getting themselves killed (or beaten or raped), and ramping up the punishments when they’re the killer (or beater or rapist).

    While I do like your analysis that we should be looking at how the marked group is treated differently from the unmarked, in the case of the public’s perception of crime aren’t marked and unmarked reversed?

    Hm… I reckon I should put this on both our blogs, but I don’t know if that’s polite :)

  9. Anita on February 16th, 2009 at 09:15

    Psycho Milt,

    Murder doesn’t require intent to kill, here’s the section of the Crimes Act.

  10. Lew on February 16th, 2009 at 09:37

    Milt,

    If there’s a case to be made that those mitigating circumstances would be ignored in the case of a young Maori offender, I’ve yet to see it.

    Well, you can’t prove a negative.

    the investigators have presumably gone with manslaughter because they wouldn’t have a shit’s show of proving intent to kill beyond reasonable doubt.

    Actually, the charge laid by the police was murder – the jury found him not guilty and convicted him of the lesser charge of manslaughter. So it isn’t that they thought they couldn’t convict.

    Morgue,

    Thank you. I’ve been uncomfortable with the fact that those normally on the side of mercy are baying for Emery’s blood in a way of which the SST would be proud. Your argument, that everyone should be treated as `us’, rather than treating some people as `them’ is well-taken. It seems a lot of people want Emery to be demoted to `them’ in this case, rather than arguing for everyone else to be treated as he has been. It will come as cold comfort to the Cameron family, but this case does set very high-profile precedent for what constitutes manslaughter, what constitutes appropriate post-killing behaviour, and what constitutes mitigation. That standard can now apply equally to future cases.

    L

  11. morgue on February 16th, 2009 at 09:59

    Anita:

    …in the case of the public’s perception of crime aren’t marked and unmarked reversed?

    I’m not sure I follow this – can you unpack it for me a bit?

  12. morgue on February 16th, 2009 at 10:01

    Lew: thanks. Good points about the precedents, too.

  13. Psycho Milt on February 16th, 2009 at 10:32

    Well, you can’t prove a negative.

    No. But if bloggers are going to call this “institutional racism” or “white privilege,” isn’t there at least some obligation on them to make a case for it?

    Murder doesn’t require intent to kill, here’s the section of the Crimes Act.

    Presumably the prosecutor in opting for a murder charge (thanks Lew) was thinking item (b): If the offender means to cause to the person killed any bodily injury that is known to the offender to be likely to cause death, and is reckless whether death ensues or not:. The jury didn’t find that proven beyond reasonable doubt and so found manslaughter. Not exactly unprecedented, is it?

  14. What would Hayek say on February 16th, 2009 at 11:04

    Lew et al,

    I disagree that this case sets a high precedent.

    Prosecutors generally lay both a charge of murder and manslaughter. It is a two bites at the cherry approach. In itself it indicates uncertainty of evidence (if you where sure you had the evidence beyond reasonable doubt for murder, why do you need a fall back charge?).

    In this case we have a homicide (s 158 Crimes Act) – killing of a person directly or indirectly, it is a culpable homicide (s 160) – killing by an unlawful act, culpable homicide is either murder or manslaughter.

    With regards to s167 to sustain the charge of murder the prosecutor needs to prove that: the offender meaned to cause the death of the person, means to cause the person killed any bodily injury that is known to the offender to be likely to cause death or is reckless whether death ensues or not, there it two more subsections dealing with the instances of trying to causes death to someone else but having a secondary person killed and as a result of some other unlawful action but where such death was likely to cause death.

    Psycho Milt whilst probably appreviating was pointing out that the intent part of the murder charge was not proven. There reason Psycho provides sets out quite well the possible reasoning for a not guilty finding. Therefore the case falls back to manslaughter.

    Sentencing is based on precedent which looks to other cases for manslaughter as guidance. There is some scope for judicial descretion, however if the sentence is not in line it can be appealed by the Crown.

    There alraedy is significant precedent and sentencing reflects that precedent. Each cse will always depend onteh particular circumstances that effect intent, any defences e.g. self defence, provocation, and any mitigating circumstances.

    Reflecting on the wider story which relates to the recent post by Pablo – are we really a divided society and more than we have been historically? We have a more fearful society which may not reflect actual risks we face. In fact i’m willing to argue we live in a less risky world now than we ever have yet someone are paralysising ourselves with greater worries.

    This is not to say bad things don’t happen, they do, but are our worries a reflection on how much we have come to believe that everything is/should be safe, rather than there is some risk and as such we should have more personal caution. As a result when an instance like this case occurs the populace self identifies and says gosh that could be me/my child/my mother,father,daughter,son,uncle,aunt,cousin,friend. In effect we are bought back to the reality of risk.

    Personally I see the world more optimistically, things are getting better and the evidence supports this view, but there is always risk so we should always take each day as something special

  15. morgue on February 16th, 2009 at 12:49

    Anita – forgot to respond to this little bit

    Hm… I reckon I should put this on both our blogs, but I don’t know if that’s polite :)

    I think it’s probably not impolite in a general sense, and it’s definitely not impolite in the specific case of my blog!

    [Also – your comment got held for moderation by my crazy spam filter, now is published.]

  16. Another Bruce Emery? | No Right Turn on February 16th, 2009 at 13:29

    Another Bruce Emery?…

    Over the weekend the blogosphere has seen a number of excellent posts on child-killer Bruce Emery’s sentencing. Meanwhile, New Zealand saw another Emery-style incident. In New Plymouth, a group of teenagers engaged in the age-old prank of ringing some…

  17. BeShakey on February 16th, 2009 at 16:13

    Great post. This is something I’ve been thinking about for a while, although from a slightly different angle.

    It seems to me that by defining those who commit serious crimes as ‘evil’ and therefore’one of us’ we eliminate the need to do anything about it (I think others touched on this). For instance, Anotonie Dixon was ‘evil’ therefore the appropriate response is to punish him severely. This allows us to ignore his childhood (for those unfamiliar a quick google will bring up the gruesome details). Obviously in Dixons case it’s too late to do anything about this, but recognising the importance of it makes it more reasonable to invest heavily in trying to improve the lot of sections of society. In terms of reducing crime this would be a much more fruitful response than simply increasing punitiveness (although it wouldn’t deliver results for 10+ years). The problem is that it requires recognising that many (although perhaps not all) of those that committ heinous crimes aren’t fundamentally different to us in terms of character, but simply in terms of background.

  18. […] at Kiwipolitico: What does it mean that they’re “one of us”? Luddite Journo: You can only be a victim if you own a house Tane at The Standard: Institutional […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: