how does clomid affect ovulation comprar cialis en farmacias getting pregnant on clomid 50 mg lasix 500 mg kaufen oder female viagra uk gold max spliting viagra in half viagra generic 100mg pills will clomid help me get pregnant prix cialis 20mg espagne viagra generica romania advantages of viagra pills priligy singapore online grocery phototoxicity doxycycline treatment diflucan vs ketoconazole cost neues viagra generika is it ok to use viagra once in awhile viagra nascar jacket for sale generico selozok 25 mg zoloft genital warts treatment over the counter uk viagra propranolol brand name in pakistan como se debe usar el sildenafil masticable ciprofloxacina 500 mg c where can you buy viagra in shops prix sildenafil generique en france generic cialis super active canada what time of day should take clomid onde comprar clomid sildenafil equivalent over the counter can i get clomid over the counter gauteng how does lasix cause gout comprar viagra contrareembolso en argentina yahoo comprar viagra en europa priligy 30 mg torrinomedica is it safe to take viagra with a mitral valve prolaplse viagra soft tabs 100mg review and herald kosten viagra 100mg is it safe to take 200 mg of zoloft can you buy cytotec online where can i buy zithromax in australia where can you buy viagra at walgreens canada generic tadalafil is it safe to take cytotec if not pregnant is cytotec available in nigeria viagra without a doctor 100 mg rx identifying viagra pills priligy 60 mg para que sirve cialis 10 mg pack zithromax how long does it stay in your system generico do ciprofloxacino 500mg la dapoxetine priligy can you take spironolactone and accutane together united states cheap cialis buy best k propecia ermhde weight gain on 5 mg prednisone angiotensin ii inhibitors generic viagra johannesburg and viagra price tadalafil sublingual 20 mg buy viagra store cinaflox ciprofloxacino 500 mg cialis generic versus brand prescrizione viagra generic pediatric dosage amoxil buy viagra athens viagra online australia customs regulations zithromax liquid color dye list of lung specialist in memphis tn tadalafil use in bph medications buy cialis in singapore and address zoloft beguiled in the bible cialis in israel viagra frei kaufen holland 14 ejemplos de dns genericos do viagra amoxicillin order ciprofloxacin 500mg best online site buy generic viagra apple cider vinegar safe to take with metformin tadalafil dissolve in water where to buy cytotec quickly prednisone usage asthma buy astrazeneca nolvadex viagra in uses lasix 40 mg tablet kullanma where can i buy clomid for men uk best herbal viagra blood flow buy viagra 100 online ciprodex ear drops cost walmart buyingcialis for womenuk best viagra for all womens in the india can you buy viagra in usa where to buy cialis in the philippines anavar hair loss propecia cost can a walk in clinic prescribe cialis cipro tingling in legs prednisone buy online without rx clomid uk pharmacy residents cialis is it over the counter buy viagra trial cost of viagra medicine in india comprimidos cialis 20 mg how long does it take to see results accutane viagra stays in you systenm prednisolone acetate cost metformin in polycystic ovary prednisone 15 mg tablet can i take fish oil with accutane female viagra paypal diflucan used to treat cipro taste in mouth cialis online bestellen wo is viagra a prescription in malaysia how do you taper off 25 mg of zoloft propecia online legit generic cialis ultrafarma sp glucophage for diabetes price of glucophage in nigeria nolvadex 10 mgday isotretinoin lasix in treatment of chf cipro 500 mg dosage and administration viagra over the counter in edmonton buy zithromax online generic como usar lysto sildenafil spray zoloft 50 mg user reviews buy viagra dallas free women viagra samples in uk ega generics for zoloft zovirax purchase on line viagra 50mg where i get in medical stores pune review can i get pregnant after one cycle of clomid cipro hc ear drops sale sito sicuro per comprare cialis italia viagra sales malaysia priligy 30 mg effetti collaterali puedo comprar viagra en farmacias del ahorro cancun cialis kaufen 10mg flexeril donde comprar priligy online forgot to take clomid pill can you take accutane with prednisone how long we can take clomid viagra uk patent expiry tocilizumab introduction viagra in sri lanka viagra price in inr does tadalafil 40 mg exist really light period after clomid stopping zoloft at 25 mg priligy in the philippines cosopt colirio generico de cialis uses for prednisone 10 mg buy generic viagra with fast delivery toprol xl 50 mg cialis prix boite viagra 100mg doxycycline antibiotics uk are 100 mg clomid tablets from china real can take viagra beta blockers buy dianabol and nolvadex uk cialis tadalis tanio aerografo para maquillaje donde comprar viagra usar sildenafil 50 cipro 1a pharma 500 mg kosten puerto rico cialis online buy cheap finasteride online best brand of finasteride liquid tadalafil 5 mg prostata does slovenia sell viagra over the counter monthly cost for cialis daily what happens when mixed viagra in someones drink how to get viagra in south korea are cipro and bactrim in the same drug class efectos secundarios de sildenafil ascorbic acid tablets bp 500 mg metformin wich age finasteride best result what time of day to take cialis does watermelon work like viagra sildenafil 100mg tablets uk review generic viagra vendors online best serm clomid accutane isotretinoin gel online viagramax co uk tadalafil generika aus indien propecia generic effectiveness xyzal tabletas generico do viagra can i take propranolol and metoprolol in a day what is viagra for para que se utiliza la ciprofloxacina 500 mg how much does metformin cost out of pocket fruit ingredient in viagra prednisone 50 mg cost cytotec in iran buy clomid no prescription england uk anyone know how much viagra cost in philippines doxycycline 50 mg acne effectiveness how often to take viagra is cialis safe in hep c is sildenafil needs prescription in italy ciri ciri viagra asli usa eli lilly malaysia cialis price metformin 500 mg po bid prn cost accutane per month propecia marketing campaign buying viagra in aberdeen scotland how long does sildenafil 50 mg last once taken amoxiden 500 mg metformin geriflox caps 500 mg metformin boots viagra cost birth control pills after clomid zoloft difficulty concentrating in adults information about generic zoloft can i take doxycycline with the pill material safety data sheet sildenafil citrate where can u buy viagra from canada glucophage xr 500 mg efectos secundarios bumetanide 1 mg bijwerkingen prednisone mal que o viagra pode causar clomid 50 mg tablet price in india no sperm in sampleclomid how long will 200mg viagra last in your system viagra 200mg sale purchase aventis clomid prescribed viagra online sorel boots buy online uk viagra price of viagra at shoppers mart calcitriol 0 25 generico de cialis kemphor donde comprar viagra cetirizina dihidrocloruro generico do viagra what is ampicillin resistance qual o generico do clomid cost of metformin xr glifor 850 mg metformin hcl sildenafil for women in india much does propecia prescription cost quiero usar cialis buy clomid dubai what time of day should i take cialis boots over counter viagra viagra za mlade buying cialis vancouver propecia baldness treatment best online pharmacy for finasteride generic cheapest cialis 36 hour online priligy legal australia cialis generico el pais einnehmen cialis online risk management specialist in nc cialis viagra in dubai legal how many ml should i take of cialis starting off highest safe cialis dose cialis and masterbation is it ok to do viagra wholesalers in china ampicillin for gbs uti in early pregnancy glucophage xr generic list viagra dosage when to take informacion de medicamento cialis canada wieviel kostet viagra in apotheke can doxycycline cause gerd safe daily dosage prednisone bula do zelix 150 mg zoloft side effect of prednisolone in nephrotic syndrome cytotec bertibarots canada dosage for nolvadex and clomid dosages for cialis where can i buy viagra in toronto over the counter clomid can cause miscarriage cialis 5 mg double prednisolone 50 mg ratiopharm inc cialis generico 40 mg accutane causes rosacea nolvadex dosage price uk what is the mg in a prednisone 5 day pack predsim generico prednisolone tablets 120 mg sildenafil propranolol 20 mg blood pressure prednisone 10 mg without prescription girls viagra how to create in hindi propranolol 80 mg twice a day workouts accutane to treat moderate acne sildenafil generico retirada champus zovirax invisiseal reviews cialis 5 mg prezzo voucher prices of cialis in uk buying cialis from india zithromax price target obat antibiotik ciprofloxacin 500 mg accuretic generic cialis viagra effects in the morning purchase tadalafil on the net viagra in my twenties where to buy cialis in the us is cialis made in india any good best viagra brand india prednisone 5 mg brand name does amoxil have penicillin in it generic clomid names sildenafil oral jelly o long 100 1 capsule diflucan price in ottawa where can buy viagra in ottawa zithromax baownbeuv price liquid nolvadex for pct pay with paypal to buy viagra generico de cialis en farmacias similares matamoros clomid and cancer same type requirement makes generic cialis diflucan 200 mg bijsluiter methotrexaat finasteride 1 mg safe buy cheap viagra online ireland pharmacy selling cytotec in malaysia taxes in socialism diademas telefonicas accutane cost generico viagra femenino what is the cost of cialis viagra online di indonesia prednisone 5 mg 6 day pack directions from mapquest generic cialis canadian cialis 60 mg kaufen oder propranolol dosage anxiety 80 mg op common use of ampicillin metformina xr 750 mg what causes spotting after taking clomid find viagra in dubai obat metformin xr 750 mg prednisone 10 mg prospect compare cialis prices walgreens can 20 mg cialis be cut 10 mg of cialis equals what dosage of viagra doxycycline for blepharitis treatment 60 mg prednisone at one time price of viagra in domincan repubic doxycycline antibiotic reviews acne treatments generic name glucophage azithromycin zithromax for sale what is the safest site to order cialis from viagra seized in dubai caixa de medicamento generico zoloft cialis 5 mg kohlpharma finasteride and hair loss in older men does lilly have a generic for cialis 20 floxacin generico de cialis diffuse unpatterned alopecia and propecia cost cost for cialis canada generic propecia shedding wal mart price cialis how to get cheap viagra viagra 100 mg duration calendar powered by mybb discount generic viagra panama half life of prednisone 20 mg tablet why was diflucan one discontinued in the uk is it safe to use cialis 2 days in a row best way to make clomid work order doxycycline from canada migraine specialists in virginia how long before take viagra generic ciprofloxacin bertibarots want to order zithromax z pak is viagra safe for one time use cialis after radical prostatectomy teva viagra price aerofast sildenafil 50 mg getting viagra in manil glucophage 850 mg fait il maigrir kenalog vs prednisone doxycycline hyclate 100mg for flu can cipro tablets be cut in half viagra cost in usa violetta penhaligons donde comprar viagra zithromax sale uk delivery nolvadex 20 cpr riv 20 mg cialis 10 mg or 5mg enquiry at viagraaustralia dot com is it safe to take viagra after taking 20mg of diazepam how long does a 8 mg cialis take to work is it safe to take viagra on meth can you buy cialis in indonesia ovarian cyst clomid treatment propranolol hcl cap 60 mg cr nitoman 25 mg zoloft can you take cialis and lorazepam can doxycycline cause yellow tongue is 1 zithromax 600 mg pill enough to treat chlamydia getting rid of viagra spam does viagra work for women clomid time of day to take generic viagra 10 pack omeprazole sandoz 20 mg bijsluiter viagra clomid in mercury drug does zoloft get in breast milk how to get zithromax in canada no prescription cialis 05 mg fiyati what is the best time to take cialis before intercourse prednisone 5 mg twice a day cialis brand buy online gkh pharmaceutical clomid online finasteride 1 mg tablets se necesita receta para comprar viagra en chile palo what is the brand name of female viagra whats in a name viagra propecia availability in pakistan best place to purchase viagra on line 40 mg prednisone taper for allergic reaction farmaco generico equivalente viagra prednisone dose mgkg venta pastillas cytotec costa rica how many daily cialis can i take in one day viagra para mujeres en liquido ethamolin generico do viagra dideral 40 mg tablet fiyati viagra dapoxetine sildenafilcompetitor brand name generic viagra uk pharmacy residents propranolol in first trimester zithromax price costco viagra 50 mg 30 tablet doxycycline use for std cialis 2 5 mg cpr 28 prix carburant is viagra effective in veinous leak colonia farala donde comprar viagra diflucan in canines lowest dose viagra in canada best face wash to use with accutane how much does viagra cost in alabama prices cialis 5mg user reviews on zoloft prednisone in treatment of copd cialis overnight fedex costs metformin hcl 500 mg tablet solco pharmaceuticals best price for viagra generic viagra in venlo kaufen can i get viagra off the shelf is it ok to take lasix daily usual dose for lasix priligy 60 mg nedir how long is diflucan active in your system ciprofloxacin 250 mg what is it for cheapest generic viagra 150 mg generic cialis tadalafil 20mg ladies viagra tablets name how much viagra do i take viagra best empty stomach metformin 500 mg pill size viagra for men pricein hyderabad united pharmacy generic viagra can you buy viagra without a script 10 mg tadalafil generic starting zoloft 50 mg viagra available in batam doctors in chicago that prescribe viagra viagra online dr fox viagra pills in zimbabwe supra generic viagra prednisone tapering schedule from 60 mg cialis over the counter thailand hotels best online pharmacy cialis sirve el viagra para durar mas what is generic name for prednisone cialis 20mg 12 stk buying viagra in st martins how much viagra cost with prescription lasix 10 mg price does zithromax liquid have to be refrigerated ciprofloxacina 500 mg precio argentina stop taking 50 mg zoloft can a healthy person take viagra how safe is taking 2 5mg cialis in a day arthrotec 75 mg pfizer viagra safe dosage prednisone generic viagra lowest price sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg buy silver buy indian viagra online onde comprar pramil viagra no rio de janeiro tadalafil maximum daily dosage high dose finasteride doxycycline 50 mg acne dosage purchase dapoxetine hereisthebestin cialis dosage duration nolvadex vs nolvadren pen vk 500 mg dosing of cipro propecia warning label what will happen by using tadalafil in normal person common viagra dosage which european nations are socialist fast way to get pregnant on clomid cost of cialis in manila ampicillin 500 mg cap calcium carbonate tablets 1250 mg prednisone is viagra on the 4 dollar plan at walmart propecia tablets works clomid is it safe metformin hcl 500 mg savings cialis nederland online finasteride genericode retina specialists in el paso tx cialis 5 mgr belgie 2 mg dose of propecia zoloft anxiety uk cialis kaufen test donde puedo comprar cytotec en cartagena clavulin bd generico de cialis sildenafil citrate chemical structure where do we get sildenafil with dapoxetine in chennai cialis 5 mg priapism ordering authentic propecia safely are you allowed to take viagra abroad rash from ampicillin vitamin b12 deficiency in metformin jotronic propecia cost Kiwipolitico » Waitangi Day
Posts Tagged ‘Waitangi Day’

Selections matter

datePosted on 22:22, March 20th, 2013 by Lew

Justice Minister Judith Collins has appointed Dame Susan Devoy as Race Relations Commissioner.

She replaces Joris de Bres, who has served two five-year terms and is very well-regarded in Māoridom (at least) because (in part) he understands the importance of his own Dutch whakapapa, and the complexity of his place as an immigrant in Aotearoa. As Bryce Edwards and Morgan Godfery have noted, he has also shown an unusual willingness to comment on issues related to his mandate of opposing racism.

No doubt this fact has informed Collins’ decision to appoint someone less feisty. Dame Susan has little or no high-level experience in the field, and I suppose the thinking is that she brings a clean slate to the role or, to put it another way, her thinking and the degree of her engegement with the issues will be more easily influenced by the prevailing governmental culture. But Dame Susan is not a blank slate. A week ahead of Paul Holmes’ now-infamous Waitangi Day a complete waste column, she wrote one of her own that, although it employed language more befitting a Dame, nevertheless expressed similar sentiments. One year ago our new Race Relations Commissioner wished that instead of Waitangi Day we could have “a day that we don’t feel ashamed to be a New Zealander” and pined after a holiday like that celebrated in Australia, where — a few recent and grudging obeisances aside — 50,000 years of history and the brutal facts of the settlement of that land are blithely ignored in a jingoistic celebration of Ocker Pride.

That would be bad enough, but it gets worse: Dame Susan doesn’t have a clue what she’s doing:

Jacob McSweeney: “She admits she doesn’t have a wealth of experience in race relations, but she says the job isn’t overly complicated.”
Susan Devoy: “I don’t think it’ll make it any more difficult than dealing with any other issues, I mean, you know, this is all under the Chief Human Rights Commission [sic], and so therefore whether it’s disability or gender or employment or race, you know, the issues are not dissimilar. This is just about making it right for every New Zealander.”

(From Checkpoint.)

This is a terrible appointment. Anyone who thinks Aotearoa’s race-relations culture isn’t complicated is by definition not equipped for the job of guiding and guarding it. Not only is our new Race Relations Commissioner ashamed of our national day, but as far as she’s concerned it’s just another ism — revealing how little she must know about disability, employment or gender issues into the bargain.

So as far as that goes, she looks like the perfect post-ideological, post-identity selection for such a job: a common-sense managerialist who, to the limited extent that she understands the issues in play, finds them distasteful.

What a good opportunity for Labour! The National government, at a time when racial and cultural tensions are a major issue, clearly doesn’t value race relations sufficiently to put anyone competent in the job. But the Labour party has selection problems of its own: an Ethnic Affairs spokesperson who is a former race relations commissioner (Rajen Prasad) so far down the list that he doesn’t get a ranking; and a Māori Affairs spokesperson — and former minister — Parekura Horomia, also unranked. Labour is perilously short on brown faces, with none in the top five and one — Shane Jones — in the top 10, and him only recently returned from purgatory. Morgan Jack McDonald has some advice on this topic.

The hard truth is that Labour isn’t in a position to criticise the government on race relations issues. This is due to their internal failures of strategy, not due to exigencies forced upon them. For all that the appointment of Dame Susan Devoy to Race Relations Commissioner is terrible, the Key government has done a lot more than expected in other areas of race relations, particularly with regard to progressing Treaty settlements. That gives them cover. They’ve gotten away with worse than this appointment, and they’ll keep getting away with it as long as the major party of opposition lets them.


(Thanks to James Macbeth Dann for drawing my attention to Dame Susan’s column, which was plucked from obscurity by Coley Tangerina.)

Maori Socialism versus Maori Capitalism?

datePosted on 13:18, February 6th, 2013 by Pablo

Woe be it for me to venture into the minefield of Maori politics on Waitangi Day. Yet the ructions around “Escortgate” at Te Tii Marae got me to thinking that perhaps there is more to the story than arguments within Ngapuhi and the inevitable displays of division that seem to mark the yearly event. At risk of stating the obvious, it is not just about different forms of identity politics.

Instead, what may be on display is the fundamental conflict between what might be called maori socialism and maori capitalism. By that I mean maori identity superimposed on a class base. Maori socialism is a view that is working class and lumpenproletarian in perspective, while Maori capitalism is propertied and bourgeois in orientation. The Hareweras and the Mana Party are a good examples of the former while the Maori Party and entities such as the so-called “Brown Table,” to say nothing of numerous trusts and boards, constitute examples of the latter. The conflict between them is not so much rooted in personalities, iwi and hapu (although there is clearly a strong element of that), but in fundamental differences in economic perspective and the proper approach to the Pakeha-dominated socio-economic and political status quo.

To be clear, I am not referring in this instance to pure forms of socialist or capitalist thought. Communal and egalitarian beliefs are as strongly represented in maori economics and society as are ownership and hierarchy. In the realm of Maori politics it seems that hybrid approaches rooted in one or the other ideological perspective have come to dominate political discourse. But the broad division between “Left” and “Right” seem fairly distinct.

The “militant” (although it is not truly that), “socialist” (although it is also not really that) approach is to largely reject the Pakeha rules of the game as given while working on what generously can be called a war of position strategy: raising consciousness amongst subaltern groups within whom lower class maori constitute the core around which issues of praxis are addressed. In this strategy alliances with Pakeha leftists are feasible because the ideological line vis a vis the common class enemy is roughly the same.

The “moderate” (phrased nicely) capitalist approach is one of pragmatic accommodation and incremental gains within the elite system as given. Alliance with Pakeha elites is possible given the division of potential spoils available in a system constructed by and for elites, but which increasingly has the potential to be colour and ethnicity-blind. Here the strategy is also one of a war of position, but in this case from within rather than from without.

Needless to say, there is some blurring between the two (e.g. Mana plays within the institutional rules of the political system and the Maori Party is not averse to relying on extra-institutional means of getting their point across). There are also significant agent-principal problems on both sides.

Even so, it seems that the main source of conflict within maoridom is grounded in class orientation and its corresponding strategic approach as much if not more than anything else. Put vulgarly in leftist terms, it is a conflict between the staunch and the sell-outs. Put bluntly in capitalist terms, it is a conflict between losers and realists.

From a practical standpoint, the underlying class differences are more difficult to resolve than other aspects of maori identity. It is in the Pakeha elite interest to keep things so.

Given my ignorance of Maori politics I could be wrong. I defer to Lew, Anita and more informed readers in any event. My intent is not to stir.  Instead, this post is written as an inquiry rather than a statement. Your views on the issue are therefore welcome.

Underclass Redux

datePosted on 02:05, February 5th, 2011 by Lew

Campbell Live tonight returned to McGehan Close (see the report, by Tony Field, here). This street in Mt Albert — on the boundary of Helen Clark’s and Phil Goff’s electorates — was visited by then-opposition leader John Key before Waitangi weekend 2007 for a particularly cynical stunt. This was Key’s first big symbolic play as leader of the opposition, and it was a hum-dinger. He had already singled out the residents of this street in that year’s State of the Nation address at a whitebread rugby club in faraway Christchurch, branding them archetypal members of the New Zealand ‘underclass’, and the visit saw him glad-handing and patronising a bunch of poor brown people who’d already been used as shot in the National party propaganda cannons.

The purpose of the speech, and visit, was to install one of the core planks of the National party narrative about the Clark government — that it was at best unconcerned with the plight of said underclass; and at worst, actively cultivated such a demographic, which would be permanently dependent on Labour’s welfare policies and would therefore be a permanent source of electoral support for the Labour party. (So the ‘bribing the bludgers to breed’ theme goes, rarely uttered by anyone with authority in public but a commonplace among the usual proxies; check almost any General Debate thread on Kiwiblog from around that time for instance.) This is absurd in more ways than it’s feasible to explain here, so I won’t bother. Let’s just leave it at ‘the underclass doesn’t really vote’.

Nevertheless, the visit was a roaring success. Key, bearing smiles and gifts and wearing a tiki t-shirt, charmed the residents of McGehan Close and evidently persuaded them both of his party’s goodwill toward them and of its social and economic plan to lift them from their grim circumstances. The event culminated in Key taking 12 year-old Aroha to the Waitangi Day celebrations — a move full of potent symbolism, even if it was seen to be somewhat exploitative. Drawn out over a full week of coverage (at the time a rare commodity for Key, who had replaced Don Brash as leader just before the Christmas break) this was a highly successful stunt and should have been an early warning of Key’s great talent for making cheesy set-piece events ‘work’ and feel human. The sentiment he evoked in the people of McGehan Close was certainly real.

It’s just a pity the ‘ambitious’, ‘aspirational’ policy programme Key promised them wasn’t.

Joan Nathan, Aroha’s mother, remains on the DPB (having been let go from her hastily-arranged job working for National MP Jackie Blue) and struggles more than ever to cope, now with a sixth child. Aroha, now 16, is living in the care of Child, Youth and Family, which Joan says is the best thing for her, since she is unable to provide a decent life for her daughter. Nathan and others, although they believed in and voted for Key, are now disenchanted and universally express the sentiment that the government’s policies favour the rich, not the poor, and that they haven’t been helped one iota by the change of government; in fact, things have gotten worse. Not much of this is different than it was this time last year, when the Sunday Star Times visited the Close.

So far, so obvious, you might say — and it is; indeed this sort of outcome was very widely predicted at the time. But this is important because it is as strong a counter-narrative as exists for the opposition in this election year. It reframes Key as a faker, a charlatan, an opportunist who’ll exploit whatever circumstances will advantage him, without loyalty or the willingness or ability to follow through on his word; as someone whose focus is on boardroom issues rather than on peoples’ wellbeing. Discussing and reading around the topic on twitter this evening I’ve seen considerable criticism of this Campbell Live story as a cheap human-interest stunt, as opportunistic and exploitative (or moreso) than the original event. I couldn’t agree less. It is a clear, unambiguous example of an investigative journalist simply revisiting a story where much was promised, and measuring it against what has actually happened. This is crucial to its narrative value: these events reframe Key by measuring his own defining stunt — his signature trick — against the objective reality of lived experience. Theory and rhetoric versus real people, living in the real world governed by the policy built from that theory and rhetoric. It is a reality check in its purest form.

There are disadvantages to this narrative line, also, and the virulent responses to the Campbell Live report this evening — I believe I saw presenter Rachel Smalley shudder a little whilst reading some of them out — hint at them. One is the obvious suggestion that Joan Nathan and the other residents of McGehan Close could have done better for themselves, but have chosen not to; the victim-blaming routinely visited upon the poor by the less-poor. A more serious and related line of critique is that there’s a recession on, and everyone’s hurting. Or that it’s only been three years, and change takes time.

But hang on a minute — wasn’t the point of the whole point of electing a Key-led National government to take advantage of the resulting step-change which would boost economic growth, job growth, provide better opportunities, an end to welfare dependency, safer communities and a general increase in general socio-economic mobility and wellbeing? Key made all these promises quite explicitly, not just in person to the residents of McGehan Close, but to the whole nation throughout the campaign and at almost every opportunity since. There are no jobs. There are no higher wages, and without these things you can’t exactly buy shares in SOEs. There is no greater social mobility. The ‘underclass’, as exploitatively defined by Key, still exists.

Having failed McGehan Close, John Key has failed all of us. Quite apart from the fact that we were all promised these things, or things like them, and by and large have yet to receive them, a central theme of the ‘underclass’ policy argument was that by lifting people out of poverty and bringing then into the ‘overclass’ (? — this shows just how meaningless ‘underclass’ is except as a propaganda term), the government would make society better for everyone. This is a noble goal, and one I agree with in its idealistic entirety. I think you would go a long way to find someone in a position of any political credibility who’d publicly disagree with it. The first order of business for any opposition should be to hold John Key to those promises, and demand of Key the wealthier, more mobile, and socially healthier society we were promised.

But the most vicious response will be the one which the initial stunt in 2007 was meant to evoke — the notion that the ‘underclass’ are breeding in order to get more welfare from the Labour party. The core of this line of reasoning, if I may call it that, will be attacks on Nathan herself as a mother, having had a sixth baby and having had Aroha, the subject of the initial stunt, removed from her care. The attacks will be highly personalised, racist and gendered, and they will be lashed closely to Labour party policy and doctrine. But, assuming a competent and spirited opposition, that’s ok — the National party aren’t in opposition, 18 months out from an election; they’re in government in election year. Having been elected on a moderate, sympathetic platform with strong support from women and Māori, and looking to consolidate that platform into a strong and honestly-won mandate means that the government no longer has such freedom to dog-whistle. Particularly given that an opposition counter-narrative would cast doubt on all those sympathetic characteristics, the resort to the divisive tactics of 2008, such as trying to wedge ‘hard-working kiwis’ against the ‘underclass’, and so on, would be extremely risky for the government.

In light of my last post, perhaps it is a little glib to assume a competent and spirited opposition, and in perfect truth I don’t really think Labour has this fight in them (although Grant Robertson saw the Campbell Live piece and seems to have had a similar response to mine, which is heartening). But it is an argument waiting to be had, and one which must be had sooner or later. The boundaries are drawn up; media interest is already piqued, and this is a bread-and-butter social and economic justice issue for Labour. There’s a wealth of symbolic material and slogans to employ — ‘reality check’ and ‘by failing McGehan Close Key has failed us all’ are two they can have for free, and if a Labour party can’t base a campaign around ‘underclass‘ then they’re not worthy of the name.

Time to engage.


In January and February 2008 my wife and I did a road trip the length of the country, twice — from Wellington to Bluff, back to Wellington, up to Cape Reinga, and back to Wellington again. For most of the trip, we flew a small Tino Rangatiratanga flag, one of those small ones which clip onto a car window. It was partly a matter of literally “flying the flag” of my political views at this time of year — I must note, with some misgivings on her part — and partly an experiment to see what response it would get.

Photo by Adrienne Rewi.
(Photo by Adrienne Rewi — because its surprisingly hard to take a shot of your own car-flag while driving and we didn’t take one. Used without permission but with thanks — I’ll take it down on request.)

Most obviously, traffic seemed to treat us somewhat differently, though this might be down to regional and seasonal driving variations. Some cars honked, some flashed their lights or waved; others rode closer behind or seemed to overtake more aggressively. Many times I saw drivers staring or otherwise reacting with surprise at seeing a couple of Pākehā in a white station wagon flying such a flag. Truck drivers were particularly well-represented in all these reactions; the road is their territory, and visual vehicular statements of identity or loyalty mean a lot to them.

This was especially true when driving around Otago and Southland with my ZZ Top-bearded and bemulleted uncle in the car. Mostly in the South, though, people were cool but not hostile, and too polite to mention anything they might have thought. The response, both positive and negative, was strongest in the central North Island, Northland and the Bay of Plenty. In Taumarunui we got into town late and a group of local Māori were drinking and singing karaoke at the hotel where we stopped. They were intrigued and after a few friendly waves and “kia ora bro”s a couple of kuia came over to suss us out — asking us who we were, where we were from, and so on. Learning that we were from Whanganui, and that I have family connections to Jerusalem put it in context and they treated us with easy amiability. Their only mention of the flag was to remark that it was probably a pretty good guard against theft; said with warmth and irony and humour. There were several of these sort of encounters. Later, stopping for side-of-the-road hāngi on the road between Wellsford and Whangarei, the young guy gave us $2 off and claimed it was because it was the last, though I could see there was plenty left and it was only just lunch time. Especially in the Far North, and through the Bay of Plenty from Te Puke through Whakatane down to about Rotorua, Māori pedestrians and kids playing near the street would shout and point and wave. Usually, this was in run-down areas, and the people waving and shouting “chur bro!” often wore gang colours.

The “anti-theft device” line was replayed unbidden in Tauranga while visiting some in-laws, though this time in all seriousness, with none of the warmth of the Māori in Taumarunui. This was combined with a rather heated debate as to the relative merits of the Clark government, Foreshore and Seabed Act and general state of the bicultural nation. The two events were on consecutive days, and the contrast could not have been more stark.

In a couple of cases — once in Lyttelton in the carpark of the Wunderbar, and again outside a petrol station in Whitianga — we were asked by random strangers if we were Māori, and if not, why were we flying the flag. In Lyttelton this was good-natured and curious; in the other case, the question was asked with gruff suspicion, and the answer — an explanation of what the flag means and its origin — didn’t cut any ice with the chap who looked and seemed rather like Garth George. I’ve encountered that sort of reaction before — once a guy called me a “race traitor” in Molly Malone’s because I was wearing a Tino Rangatiratanga hoodie — and that one didn’t even have the flag, just the words.

But on a trip of 7,500km on the busiest roads in the country, passing through all the main population centres at the time of our national holiday, in an election year, not long after the Urewera Terra arrests and with issues of racial separatism and colonialism very squarely on the agenda, the thing which was most obvious was how little such a statement changed anything. It reiterated to me that New Zealand is a pretty tolerant and easy society, as long as that tolerance is not stretched too far. Another example of this was this evening’s “Great Debate” on Māori TV between celebrities and comedians and such folks on the moot “now is the time for Aotearoa to close the immigration gates”. I won’t spoil the result, because it really is worth watching (and I assume Māori TV will put up a video), but while the moot was robustly (and often very personally) contested, it was all done in wonderful good humour. The same good humour as of a Māori joking ruefully about Māori crime — and the opposing siege mentality the following day. Happily, I think the former predominates in this country, and provides a sound basis for the ongoing development of a bicultural — and eventually multicultural — society.