order viagra online safe order clomid online paypal viagra pills how long do they last viagra names in pakistan most people lidocaine over the counter substitute for viagra propranolol tabletki 10 mg 50 szt cena kehebatan viagra usa 100 mg viagra en uke doxycycline 100mg oral what does doxycycline 20 mg do ist cialis rezeptpflichtig in der schweiz studieren normal mg zoloft donde puedo comprar viagra sin receta en estados unidos buy cialis in canada online review none rx viagra generic nizoral or diflucan cream cost in indian rupees para que serve propranolol 30 mg is zoloft safe for a 75 year old female where to buy viagra quick diflucan ringworm reviews prix cialis pharmacie grenoble can you buy viagra online legally uk zoloft reviews for men generic daily cialis 5mg sildenafil lymphangiomas in spleen risks of zoloft in pregnancy receptfri viagra generic 5 mg prednisone pregnancy test where to buy priligy in edmonton original viagra tablet sales shop in hmachal can you cut cipro tablet 250 in half pomada fondant generico de cialis viagra 50 mg prezzo farmacia prednisone 10 mg tablet wattage advertisement of viagra in uae que es minoxidil 5 y finasteride 1mg viagra in contrassegno viagra reviews generic altra lone peak 2 5 womens reviews on cialis where to buy viagra in india online viagra delivery services in delhi does doxycycline treat pertussis lasix injection online what is propranolol used for cialis is a generic zithromax tablets 500mg price in india indian make viagra price does doxycycline cause thrush comprare cialis generico a roma paxil and zoloft in pregnancy despre ciprofloxacina milan generics amoxil 500 mg can. it cause a miscarriage sinot 875 mg generico do viagra el viagra de 100 mg maximum daily dose lasix cialis very cheap when is viagra going generic in usa viagra i doser download cialis australia ciprofloxacin dexamethasone 5ml price mercury drug buy metformin online no prescription canada buy cialis uk paypal login nolvadex and proviron para ginecomastia australian viagra hydralazine and lasix together dapoxetine price zithromax 500 mg precious lord best time to take metformin slow release viagra purchase auckland order viagra online in usa canada pharmacy cialis 10 mg generic for propecia available in usa hixizine bula generico do viagra sildenafil clinical trials generica viagra on xm radio ratio of lasix to aldactone in cirrhosis cialis 10mg price cipro liquid dosage form amoxil 250 mg 5ml dosage index is propecia safe for a 17 year old el viagra requiere receta medica cialis indian dealers converse shoes buy online uk viagra buy viagra uk pharmacy chains a cosa serve diflucan 150 mg noskapin dak 25 mg of zoloft prednisone safe take while breastfeeding tetrazepam 50 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin viagra online bestellen woodforest buy lasix online overnight viagra tablets for women in chennai can clomid be consumed over the counter buy prednisone cheap profenid gotas generico do viagra prix finasteride paris does doxycycline get you high para que sirve inderal de 10 mg cialis for daily use cost near morgantown benuron generico do viagra generic cialis paypal no prescription propecia or rogaine accutane how long to get out of system gramaxin 500 mg metformin lloyods online viagra purchase sex during clomid use viagra rezeptfrei aus deutschland kaufen viagra online delivery lahore lasix 10 tableta 40 mg cena lowes cost tadalafil doxycycline hyclate 100 mg good rx accutane cost uk universities tonsillitis doxycycline dose liquid clomid good cialis 5 mg price pharmaprix cialis generico mais barato clomid online legit can i buy viagra form any chemist in melbourne zithromax 250mg 4 count how much does it cost where do i get viagra in seattle viagra pillen kopen in rotterdam is doxycycline hyclate used to treat pneumonia buying viagrain china viagra online sale singapore strongest mg of viagra on line inderal safe breastfeeding cialis price compared to viagra prednisone 20mg safety cialis canada without prescription cheap viagra genuine generic viagra cost per pill best viagra men tranxilium 5 mg dosierung viagra rate of viagra in kolkata cialis canadian phamacy where to buy cialis in over the counter usa viagra safe stroke victims ciprofloxacin 500 mg for chlamydia cialis 10mg tadalafil renal scan with lasix results cialis 5mg daily best price menarini dapoxetine buy online zoloft 100 mg first day buy viagra jelly online uk stores buy pfizer viagra online pfizer 100 mg sildenafil viagra to pay with paypal is diflucan safe during early pregnancy were can i purchase propecia generic 2.5 mg cialis without a prescription viagra causa parada cardiaca comprare il viagra in farmacia senza ricetta seretide diskus generico do viagra can you go in the sun after accutane lotrial 20 mg prednisone organic chemistry khan academy reactions to prednisone zithromax dosing in kids accutane user journals cialis 200 mg dosage how long can prednisone be taken safely finasteride shoppers drug mart viagra sale prices viagra generika zulassung precio de cialis 5 mg en argentina best price viagra join our mailing list accutane over counter alternative the original online viagra penalty for dealing viagra in ireland viagra for men tablets in bangalore cipro generic medication prednisone 60 mg taper dose can you get 100 mg cialis viagra 100mg precio redeem cialis voucher online pharmacy mountain hardwear kelvinator womens reviews on cialis alliance generics prednisolone taking cialis with high blood pressure is it easy to get pregnant with clomid lowest cost for cialis 20mm tablets cialis australia cost liquid viagra sachets weekly ukhard on uk weekly viagra sale sulit nombre generico del viagra en colombiano safety diflucan while breastfeeding cheap nolvadex no prescription generic zithromax baownbeuv metformin tablets 850 mg buy viagra online boots canada cheapest price for 20mg cialis obat profertil 50 mg viagra genuine viagra prices viagra 50 mg 4 pack cialis online shipped from usa herbal viagra in th uk cialis 20 mg 4 comprimidos precio mexico glimepiride 2mg metformin 500mg in ciplak cialis sol in south africa indoblok 10 mg prednisone doxycycline used sinus infections cheapest accutane in the us nebivolol stada 5 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin names of female viagra in india buy propecia london le prix de priligy au maroc has cialis went up in price propranolol er 60 mg cap rouge canada goa india drugs viagra where to get viagra in beijing female viagra 100 mg foro en colombia berapa ml air untuk zithromax syr cialis 20 mg tablets tadalafil price of cialis shoppers drug in canada antibiotic prescription online physician zithromax image for costco viagra metformin trials in breast cancer liquid nolvadex dosage pct sis 60 mg prednisone taper schedule socialism benefits in sweden united states nolvadex has any body used generic cialis ciprofloxacino 500 mg farmacia ahumada it support specialist jobs in nh is cialis available in 50 mg generic name metformin hydrochloride tadalafil powder taste in mouth take potassium lasix cityscape silhouette generic viagra walmart pricing on viagra deltasone 5 mg safe exercise propranolol polaramine pomada generico de cialis cialis online sydney buy clomid on line mexico no prescription tri reki viagra for sale generic finasteride 5mg reviews for minoxidil and propecia together in india where i can find cialis in dubai teva prednisone 50 mg et alcool de menthe tadalafil citrate chemone research reviews buying cialis in ankara turkey mebhydroline 50 mg zoloft will 25mg of clomid work 20 mg accutane low viagra available in isle of man effects of 25 mg zoloft velamox in gravidanza dosaggio viagra buy zithromax 500mg online stopwatch unbranded sildenafil is doxycycline safe for malaria cialis canada a vendre zithromax tablets used for equivalent of viagra in homeopathy is imuran safer than prednisone viagra name brand online viagra available in tooting uk fabian essays in socialism the book book author prednisone 20 mg for pets clomid for men prices atorvachol 80 mg prednisone zovirax 800 mg posologie citrate comprar viagra seguro internet canada is viagra over the counter dropropizina jarabe generico do viagra donde comprar priligy en lima how does doxycycline 100mg work over counter viagra like drugs viagra in sauna viagra from mexico walmart can i take viagra to australia with me shelcal 500 mg metformin ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg y su uso cipro xr 1000 mg 3 comprimidos cipro for uti how many mgs cialis 25 mg. 3 buy generic viagra buy finasteride cheap 1 mg finasteride daily without minoxidil at what age can you take viagra floresta verde generico do viagra treat hyponatremia lasix can i take viagra with kidney problems viagra names in pakistan hyderabad were to buy viagra in bali endone 50 mg zoloft when do i take a pregnancy test after clomid confezione cialis 5 mg purchase cialis from online how much does it cost for clomid priligy 30 mg precious moments propecia 0 5 mg effective ampicillin capsules bp 500 mg naproxen cialis morning wood prednisolone 5mg kaufen viagra in india tamil notes premastan gel generico de cialis zithromax available in south africa will ciprofloxacin 500 mg treat hpv prix du viagra dans les pharmacies best buy online propecia consigo comprar viagra sem receita medica best price viagra 90505 which works the best cialis or viagra ciprofloxacin 500 mg mental changes viagra tablets price in lahore pakistan postcode onde comprar o medicamento cytotec dental implant specialists in maui ha boots doxycycline cost max dosage of cialis comprar viagra trujillo cipro resistance in india what is generic prednisone called propranolol la 120 mg can you buy viagra in thailand us dollars stopp 150 mg viagra buy cialis professional usa 15 minoxidil with finasteride cost price comparison of viagra 100mg the best moisturizer to use while on accutane doxycycline hyclate as acne treatment cialis wholesale online usa doxycycline and rifampin in mrsa cost of ciprodex otic drops zenegra generic viagra viagra online canada pharmacy without dr prescriptions tadalafil 5mg uk viagra best insurance carrera crossfire 2 womens reviews on viagra 160 mg slow release propranolol 10mg generic finasteride nz herald zithromax z pack antibiotic cost propranolol hydrochloride 80 mg viagra online united states no rx viagra vente libre montreal metformin in turkey good viagra in india best alien isolation reactions to prednisone can postmenopausal women take propecia every other day accutane digestive disorders orfiril long 1000 mg wirkung viagra cost of viagra vs cialis vs livator how quickly does cialis start to work viagra online bestellen ohne rezept erfahrungen grinder reviews herbal viagra bisacodyl 10 mg zetpil bijsluiter cialis acquistare cialis generico online bible diflucan yeast infection cost order metformin dergboadre twins clomid dosage buy lasix without prescriptions what is walmarts price on viagra over the counter viagra alternative at boots brand name cialis on sale buy viagra in the us cialis 5 mg daily coupons online finasteride stada 5mg opipramol 50 mg zoloft color of generic viagra propecia in new york cialis brand 5 mg clotrimazole bayhealth 100 mg comprimidos viagra clomid india wikipedia formulario 12p donde comprar viagra 300 mg wellbutrin 50 mg zoloft while breastfeeding aliud pharma sildenafil generic cheap viagra 120mg online viagra 25 mg effetti comprar cytotec en new york cost of cialis how much 20 controindicazioni del cialis 5 mg best viagra to take get viagra chemist main distributors of viagra in pakistan can you take clomid if you are ovulate cipromax 500 mg ciprofloxacin comprar viagra yahoo doxycycline monodox reviews for acne ampicillin dosage for infants do boots chemist sell viagra prednisone 20 mg medicine liquid cialis dubai beste wirkung cialis clomid sore throat in the morning what mg does accutane come in is it safe to take 20mg cialis low post ovulation temps clomid online cialis 2 5mg lilly onlinepharmacy md zithromax cheaper alternative propecia best site to buy viagra purchase viagra for women online cialis generico en farmacias similares year supply of propecia cost is accutane safe to take lasix water pills and weight loss propranolol and paroxetine uk prednisolone 20 mg posologie amoxicilline 24hr delivery of viagra how long does 10mg of prednisone stay in your system bula annita 500 mg metformin contraindication of metformin in pregnancy get doxycycline over the canada british columbia cheapgenerics viagra ru reliable source generic viagra buy cialis original medicinali generici cialis information viagra to pay with paypal cialis online generic usa clomid bloating in pct can viagra give harder erections in young men what is the generic drug for zoloft prednisone 30 mg day para sirve cialis tadalafil 20 mg finasteride price in pakistan samsung best sunscreen to use on accutane cialis generico femminile para que sirve la ciprofloxacino 500 mg wikipedia generic over sea viagra how long does cialis stay in the blood legit website to buy clomid cheap lasix tqeovertoz cheap viagra canada pharmacy online is cialis made in india any good is it safe to take cialis with ginko biloba reviews of viagra in india cheapest accutane without insurance 60 mg prednisone for 5 days why do use viagra viagra and blood disorders how long does it take for ciprolex 500 mg to work generic viagra costs como puedo comprar viagra por internet buy viagra at safeway doxycycline to treat mastitis what is the walmart price for cialis 20mg want buy viagra in edmonton over the counter renault cipro 85 review how does viagra work in 30yo man uk pharmacy viagra socialism and democracy in europe famous books diflucan in dialysis patients natural viagra alternatives cialis availability in singapore uso cialis generico help getting pregnant clomid dose to 50mg buy documento generico de cialis sildenafil ratiopharm kaufen rezeptfrei discount cialis pro lorotec 10 mg prednisone egipt viagra price process of getting prescribed clomid wal finite generic for zoloft name of the indian viagra and their price scoliosis specialists in texas does generic metformin look like dosage for amoxil for adults viagra cost of shipping pasos para usar pastillas cytotec cialis time in bloodstream prednisone 40 mg and drug inter prednisone clears acne viagra 100mg street value how much does viagra coast at walmart propecia generic brand review where can i buy viagra over the counter in sf can you buy viagra in tijuana mexico viagra is not working for me clomid 25 mg per day dr. crisler buy viagra london where buy zoloft online sertraline minoxidil reviews and propecia sildenafil citrate in fruits and vegetables metformin in der ssw does tadalafil come in capsules does prednisone have tylenol in it cost of cialis for daily use at walgreens galenico finasteride cost is cialis prescription prix cialis en tunisie metformin 850 mg brandsmart why use metformin in ivf effetto cialis 10 mg review quality online viagra dapoxetine brand names in pakistan new season accutane 10 mg per week como devo usar viagra is viagra a scheduled drug viagra tablets prise in pakistan can you take excedrin while on clomid 25 mg viagra wirkung amoxil sachet 3gm price in eu viagra generico senza ricetta in italia jeanette inderal generic 100 mg zoloft withdrawal effects zoloft nursing implications man in hospital after injecting viagra accutane in romania ampicillin 500 mg four times a day medical abbreviation viagra super force generic cialis viagra in the uk over the counter cialis in ny doxycycline for malaria over the counter Kiwipolitico » Waihopai 3
Posts Tagged ‘Waihopai 3’

Against “courageous corruption” as Crown policy

datePosted on 12:40, May 14th, 2012 by Lew

It should come as no surprise that I disagree with Chris Trotter’s latest piece about the Urewera raids. Don’t get me wrong — I think his assessment of the operational capability New Zealand police and intelligence services are correct. Their actions were strategically and tactically flawed, and they seemed to hold unrealistic expectations of the task they were undertaking. But some of the judgements Chris wraps around this argument are troubling to say the very least.

Not all of them. Some are fine: we need a competent security and intelligence apparatus, and the lack is something that should be rectified. Some are nonsense: a sophisticated left-wing propaganda network (where have they been these past two electoral terms?) and sleeper cells of “sympathetic journalists” (presumably not those who are shills for the corporate élite?). Some are merely distasteful. Others, however, are downright frightening, and the worst of these is the notion that the Crown should not be bound by its own laws when prosecuting dissident citizens.

Also lacking were the reliable media “assets” so highly prized by the British security services. Individuals to whom key elements of the Crown’s case … Where, for example, was the Crown’s equivalent of Wikileaks? Clearly no one was prepared to play the role of Private Bradley Manning by dumping all the evidence denied to the Prosecution on a suitably insulated and legally untouchable website.

Let’s not forget that some of this actually happened. Elements of the Crown case actually were leaked to the public, and some suppressed material was published in daily newspapers and was the subject of (unsuccessful) contempt proceedings.* Other elements, having been retrospectively ruled in by a court despite having been collected unlawfully, were used throughout the trial to create a prejudicial atmosphere around the trial.

Given those events, the argument here is essentially that the Crown didn’t leak enough evidence; didn’t act ruthlessly enough and was too heavily burdened with scruples to secure a “right” outcome. The call for an officer of the Crown to wilfully breach the very laws they have sworn to uphold, in the name of their own individual assessment of a complex situation, is extremely concerning. Having failed to conduct their evidence-gathering operations lawfully, and having failed to persuade a judge that, in spite of that, there was still a sufficient reason to admit all the evidence, the argument here is that the Crown should have taken an extrajudicial Mulligan.

When I started writing it this piece was considerably more personalised to Chris, and how his post seems to provide final proof of his degeneration from idealistic radical to authoritarian establishment curmudgeon. The reference in the title is to his now-infamous declaration that Labour’s breach of electoral law during the 2005 election campaign was justified inasmuch as it prevented a terrible counterfactual — a National government led by Don Brash — from coming to pass. I disagree with that argument on the grounds that the integrity of the democratic system as a whole is of greater importance than any particular electoral outcome, and I disagree with his argument regarding the Urewera 4 for the same reasons: the integrity of the justice system is of greater importance than the outcome of any given case.** But I don’t want to dwell on the personal; rather than trading extensive cannonades with Chris (again), I think there’s more value in covering my reasons for holding these views in principle, leaving aside the specific merits (on which we’re never going to agree), or whether I support the principals in either case.***

The first and most obvious argument against this sort of extra-legal recourse is: be careful what you wish for. If you want the Crown to leak, to cultivate sources in the media whom they can trust to run their propaganda for them, and to resort to whatever other means they might need to secure what you think is a “right” outcome, you’d better hope you always agree with them. If you don’t, eventually you’ll find yourself on the wrong end of it. The danger of this for the ideological left in Aotearoa should need little elaboration: almost all the authoritarian cards and most of the ruthlessness in playing them are in the hands of the various factions of the ideological right, and they are constrained more by norms of conduct and the need to appear to be less ruthless than they are than by black-letter law or constitutional barriers. These norms are quite robust, but they essentially all operate on the honour system: they persist because people observe them. If you break the law in the name of the rule of law, you erode the rule of law. If you destroy the village to save the village, you still destroy the village.

This leads into the second point: changing norms of Crown conduct, or what we might call “authoritarian sclerosis”. Norms that constrain what a government, the Crown or its agents may acceptably do are becoming more lax, and have been since shortly after 9/11, when the Terrorism Suppression Act that gave rise to the current farce was hastily passed. In the past two parliamentary terms this has continued to accelerate, partly as a consequence of hysteria around — and blurring of — activism and terrorism more generally. The government, by leave of an increasingly punitive and paranoid populace, can now impose disproportionate punishment on certain offenders via the “three strikes” regime, and indefinite “civil” detention of certain offenders. The infiltration of the security and intelligence apparatus into harmless activist groups such as those that agitate for animal rights has been well-documented in recent years. It has gotten to this point despite the fact that (Urewera case aside) the two most significant threats to our national security in the past decade have been an Algerian theologist who now makes kebabs in a food hall on Karangahape Road, and three Catholic pacifists with agricultural implements. The government can now amend or suspend almost any law or enact almost any measure it likes, with immediate effect and without meaningful judicial oversight, in the service of rebuilding Christchurch. There are laws on the books that shift the burden of proof of innocence for some types of copyright infringement from the accuser to the alleged offender. On US urging, the New Zealand police recently undertook expensive, unprecedented and legally risky operations against a foreign national who had apparently committed no serious crimes against New Zealand law, and it now seems increasingly unlikely that the case will amount to anything. The government may now spend beneficiaries’ money for them. They are are moving to require DPB mothers (and their daughters!) to use long-term birth control, and to force them to work when their youngest is just one year old. The latest proposal is to force beneficiaries to vaccinate their children, in violation of the fundamental right to refuse medical treatment. These latter policies of authoritarian sclerosis disproportionately affect Māori, who are already disproportionately impacted by the state’s historical use of its power via colonialism. I could go on, but you get the point: the door to the police state is not yet open, but it is creaking ajar. Those who benefit from opening it do not need agents of the left nudging that door wider for them, but they will gratefully accept it if some are willing to do so.

This is all bad enough in itself, but as well as eroding the norms of what is acceptable, authoritarian sclerosis makes it more difficult to erect robust black-letter or constitutional safeguards against undue exercise of power by the state over its citizens, making it more likely that the norms which are being undermined are all we will be able to rely on in future. Again: be careful what you wish for.

Perhaps more important than all of that, though, is the incentive that the Mulligan creates within the organs of the Crown responsible for implementing the policies outlined above. If you make excuses for underperforming or incompetent agencies, if you cut senior officials slack when they or their subordinates fail to discharge their duties adequately, when they bring into question the good standing of their departments; if you seek to tailor laws and regulations to them rather than requiring them to work within the existing bounds of proper conduct, then you produce agencies which are dependent on special pleading and special treatment. When you select against competence, independence, resourcefulness and strategic thinking by allowing “right-thinking” loyalty and patronage to thrive, you breed pampered inbred poodles reliant on favour from political masters, rather than vigilant, independent watchdogs of civil society.

Multiple layers of dysfunction contributed to the Crown’s failure to convict on substantive charges in the Urewera 4 case. They started with the drafting of the Terrorism Suppression Act, which Solicitor-General David Collins declared “unnecessarily complex, incoherent, and as a result almost impossible to apply”. Court interpretations giving the police permission to undertake surveillance operations that were later ruled illegal also contributed. Police culture and operational capability, and a lack of both strategic and tactical awareness also contributed strongly, and Crown Law’s failure to make best use of the meagre evidence that derived from those preceding actions was merely the last in a long chain of failures.

If you want to make a system stronger, the solution is to genuinely strengthen it, making it better, by having those agencies take their lumps and learn their lessons, by punishing failure and rewarding success; by staffing it with better people, better trained and with greater strategic vision. I want an intelligence/security and police apparatus and a justice system good enough that it doesn’t need to be oppressive to be effective. One that I can trust to keep society safe, and to not persecute me while doing so. That can’t happen if we erect a scaffold of legal or extra-legal privilege beneath the sagging edifice, pretend there’s nothing wrong, and call it a win. It didn’t work for the investment banks, and it can’t work here.

L

* Chief High Court Judge Randerson and Justice Gendall found that the publication had not “caused a real risk” of prejudice, so fair enough. But they also stated that “The breaches of suppression orders and the unlawful conduct of a major news organisation and a senior newspaper editor should have resulted in their prosecution” by the Police, and that the court was “at a loss to understand why these breaches were not prosecuted.” While they raised the point that the penalties for such breaches are risibly small, it’s also hard to avoid the conclusion that the Police were simply reluctant to punish actions that might have helped their case.

** In principle, there is a time for extrajudicial action, for exercise of the reserve powers or of the almost-limitless authority of the sovereign parliament, or for rebellion by the people. Desperate times may call for such measures. These are not such times.

*** For the record: Of course, I did not support the 2005 National party. I am satisfied with the Urewera 4 verdicts since they accord with what I know about the case, though I also would not have been averse to a retrial and an opportunity for them to clear their names more forcefully.

Justice Gnomes

datePosted on 19:05, September 5th, 2011 by Lew

The New Zealand Police [and Crown Law] appear to be adopting the Underpants Gnome strategy to deal with minor breaches of public order and transgressions against the general authority of the state:

1. Brutally arrest and lay spurious charges for general idiocy or mostly harmless defiance.
2. Weather firestorm of public and civil society outrage.
3. Drop or substantially downgrade charges after months (or years) of tedious ‘review’.
4. Insist that, despite expert opinions to the contrary, their original decision to lay charges — and the excessive means by which the arrests were effected — are perfectly justified.
5. ????
6. Profit!

This pattern holds in three high-profile cases that spring easily to mind: most clearly the “Urewera Terra” raids and subsequent fiasco, about which Pablo has written previously; more recently the case of Arie Smith, documented best by Russell Brown; and the pattern has today been completed by the decision to drop charges against Tiki Taane.

There are certainly other examples, which readers can discuss in comments. An exception to the pattern has been the Crown’s treatment of the Waihopai Three, who are being vexatiously pursued for damages they can’t pay, having been found not guilty by a jury of their peers. Pablo has written about this, also. In stark contrast to the high standard of conduct expected of random individuals stands the lax attitude towards police discipline, with egregious conduct documented or alleged in two out of three of those cases, and in others.

This coming weekend (weather & workload permitting) I’ll be visiting a block of land in Taranaki that the police had also pegged as housing “terrorist training camps” back in 2007. They failed to reach even the lax evidentiary requirements to gain the proper warrants to conduct raids there, but according to contemporaneous news reports they weren’t far off, and had dedicated considerable time, effort and money towards that end. Based on what I know about these particular circumstances, they would have roused a few kaumātua at Parihaka and its surrounds; some possum trappers, and depending on the day, perhaps a hunter or two (most likely Pākehā), since the most dangerous people in there are the folks who go in of a weekend with quad bikes and boxes of ammo and bottles of spirits to blaze mobs of goats, and leave them on the flats to rot as pig bait. Policing of this sort is a fool’s errand, and after nearly four years we have no reason to believe that those cases that had accrued slightly more evidence than the one of which I’m aware will have meaningfully more merit.

Watching and listening coverage of the 1981 Springbok tour riots this past week or so I’ve been struck by how his preoccupation with symbolic insults to law and order, rather than more substantive breaches, is reminiscent of police and government conduct under Muldoon, during that era — a short, sharp, shock doctrine of fiercely punishing trivial breaches in order to send a signal to those who would commit more serious actions. I don’t have time at present to go into a deep discussion of the implications of this activism among the police, and indeed Pablo has already covered much of that ground better than I could. But the apparent detachment between police command and both the ordinary citizens of the state and the country’s expert civil society agencies would be hilarious if it wasn’t so concerning.

Perhaps the worst aspect of this trend is that it serves to undermine the credibility of and public confidence in the police, which civil society needs to function. Especially at society’s margins — including Māori, the disabled, and activists — with whom police should be especially assiduous about building relationships.

Update: And would you look at that — right on cue, the remaining trumped-up firearms charges against the Urewera 18 have been dropped, on the grounds that continuing proceedings would not be in the public interest. Indeed. So, authoritarian apologists for the police state and anti-Māori revenge fantasists, how you like THEM apples?

L

Fighting symbolism with symbolism

datePosted on 08:15, April 8th, 2010 by Lew

So the Crown, having had their appeal against the Waihopai 3’s acquittal (about which Pablo wrote an excellent post) dismissed, is considering a civil case against them, to recover the $1.1 million cost of the damage to the dome and fences surrounding the satellite dish.

In politics it is usually best to fight symbolism with symbolism; once a topic or policy matter is being debated in symbolic terms, in general no amount of fact or logic or reason will prevail against it. This often promotes an arms race — the party to a debate who introduces symbolic aspects to their discourse gets to set the agenda, to define what the debate is about, and this is clearly so with the Waihopai 3. While the customary analysis of the protest action is that it took place one morning in April 2008, with a slight return in the criminal court during March 2010, but all this demonstrates is that people don’t really understand the nature of this protest. It is ongoing. This morning, Peter Murnane responded with some puzzlement to Sean Plunket’s question “Do you have any further protest actions planned?” by saying “No […] well, we’re busy with this one.” That’s the point: Defending their actions on truthful, legitimate and principled grounds in the full glare of public scrutiny is the protest. Contrary to another current case, the Waihopai 3 have stood up and said the non-blasphemous equivalent of “you’re goddamned right I did”, and are willing to accept the consequences of their actions — but only once they’ve made their position clear. And they expect that their commitment to principle and legitimate due process is reciprocated by the Crown, and if sued will call for representatives of the GCSB to face them in court. This places the Crown in an invidious position: it cannot permit senior intelligence and security staff to be dragged into this matter, but if it fails to do so it will cede the symbolic field to Ploughshares, and the legitimacy of its position will be further eroded.

For the Crown to seek reparation would be fair and just: the actions of the Waihopai 3 cost the NZ taxpayer money and the Crown has a right to recover that via legitimate legal means. But because the Waihopai Three have set the terms of the symbolic debate and have everything to gain and nothing whatsoever to lose from the case, it is a fool’s errand. While, as Bill Hodge says, the Crown has an “invincible case” in the civil court, the battle is not being waged in the court, but in people’s hearts and minds. The Waihopai 3 claim they have no money, and this seems plausible. So the only reason for the Crown to take a case against them is to demonstrate that the organs of power are not to be trifled with, and that even if a jury will acquit for a good cause, an appealing idealistic argument, or an integrous and principled stand such actions cannot be undertaken with impunity. A display of power, if you like, though not an especially vulgar one. Such a display may serve the social purpose of quelling the urges of overenthusiastic and legally (not to mention ethically) illiterate anti-abortionists, and will have some currency among the not-so-closeted authoritarians who bayed for the blood of these peaceful protesters in April 2008 and again in March 2010. But to the extent that the government seeks to retain its dignity, this will be cold comfort indeed.

L