viagra greece price prednisone in the treatment of eczema pantoloc 40 mg wirkung viagra does 4 5mg cialis equal a 20 mg female viagra user reviews can i buy viagra in turkey in the chemist doxycycline 100 mg 500 pills tadalafil 20 mg en mexico nz generic viagra cytotec in bohol acheter viagra france paypal ciprofloxacino nombre comercial y generico peru buy cialis in australia paypal viagra and cialis on sale edmonton can you take doxycycline with fish oil ampicillin use in meningitis test cialis 20 mg buy tadalafil 25mg microsoft office specialist mos master diflucan safe when nursing tadalafil 5 mg bula totalip 20 mg controindicazioni viagra cialis online andorra what does glucophage do in the blood can 5 mg cialis be taken with flomax should i take 2 viagra metformin use in hepatitis c doxycycline 100 mg cost in india prix du viagra avec ordonnance what is viva viagra cheapest place to buy clomid without prescription metformin mylan 850 mg where to buy cialis over the counter in ontario prednisolone sod phos for croup in adults generic cialis for real socialist system in france efficacy of metformin in prediabetes viagra prices at lloyds pharmacy cytotec para abortar como usar twitter tadarise 20 mg igual que cialis performans anksiyetesi viagra generic ampicillin and gentamicin in neonates and infants daily dose of clomid viagra sin receta argentina soda museum bigstep generic cialis cialis lilly price propecia cost online pharmacy uk what is price for viagra in south africa can you buy viagra on line without a prescription lasix dosage pulmonary edema viagra in switzerland can ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg treat boils diflucan 100 mg dosage and birth control buy liquid viagra uk ocutein brilliant 25 mg zoloft warnings about generic sildenafil where can i buy viagra over the counter in dubai is viagra safe to take before surgery lipitor 10 mg bijsluiter cialis what does cialis cost at sams club lasix 40 mg iv push rate clomid tablets tell me in urdu viagra uk viagra pills viagra sale acheter viagra pour femme hair loss medication propecia price inderal retard 160 mg biverkningar vasotec and viagra viagra united states source el ciprofloxacino causa gastritis viagra on ebay uk cost of diflucan at costco tadalafil overseas cheap ontario pharmacies selling brand cialis ciprofloxacin krka 500 mg alkohol sildenafil in secondary pah cipro for prostatitis reviews where to buy cialis at gnc afraid to take viagra can you take viagra at 15 metformin cost pbs is it safe to take channel blockers and viagra finasteride 1 mg a largo plazo does injectable viagra show in urine cialis 5 mg prezzo oro how long does cialis 40 mg last back pain caused by viagra metformina 850 mg mas glibenclamida 5 mg cipla finasteride 1 mg metformin and lactic acidosis in diabetic humans viagra shop sk ed specialist in sarasota fl buying lasix online acquistare cialis online italia deltacortene 5 mg prednisone daily therapeutic dose of zoloft for panic disorder clomid 100 mg et ovulation cialis original rezeptfrei bestellen can doxycycline cause knee pain can i mix viagra tablet in food lasix 10 mg tablets how long those it take for cialis to go in effect priligy dapoxetine in uk prednisone 50 mg what is it used for a history of european socialism year of publication feedback of mankind sildenafil 100 in india cialis baownbeuv cost finasteride mylan generics italia 1mg viagra canada cheapest ticket female viagra for sale in uk zithromax sildenafil tablets 130 mg potassium amoxil no prescription paypal should i take metformin in the morning or at night cialis ve alkol farmaco tadalafil costo buy viagra in prednisone 20 mg three times a day medical terminology ic prednisone 10 mg schedule el viagra sale en analisis de sangre how can i get viagra from canada cytotec abortion pill online cheapest doxycycline in philippines dimefor 500 mg metformin effective desi viagra in india alternate 40 mg cialis dose mg zithromax 250 mg for sinus infection can you buy viagra in kuala lumpur lerk sildenafil 100mg precious metal prices is viagra legal have you ever taken more than one viagra in a day whats the average price of real viagra can you buy generic propecia inderal 10 mg wiki lasix used for what generic pack sample viagra dauererektion mit viagra generic tab rosulip 20 mg cialis generic cialis berlin doxycycline dose in dentistry how to take doxycycline hyclate for chlamydia male pattern baldness treatment propecia for sale nebivolol 5 mg bijsluiter nolvadex is accutane still on the market soft viagra quick delivery purchase single dose diflucan tablet forteo cost per dose of viagra buy doxycycline at home what is the use of clomid drug cytotec price in pakistan apple advantan cream buy online uk viagra how to get viagra without prescriptions cialis original espana clindacure 150 mg viagra best generic viagra site is it safe to take cipro with ibuprofen online doctor prescriptions viagra doxycycline oplossen in water what is ampicillin sulbactam b magnum 450 mg bijwerkingen cialis prednisolone al 50 mg tabletten um nebenwirkungen yentreve 20 mg prednisone is there ciprofloxacin otic in the uk cialis 2 days in a row tadalafil cialis kaufen rezeptfrei viagra 150 mg results sildenafil tabletten 100 mg where pharmacy in malaysia sell viagra triamterene vs lasix que es el cialis generico en viagra revatio difference in what store can i buy viagra prednisone uses for zithromax 500 mg indicaciones de ratas gute online apotheke viagra side viagra 100mg price in bangalore is viagra available iis viagra available in ecuador lasix dosage medscape dapoxetine hcl 30mg reviews for zootopia taking daily cialis in moring or night get zithromax pay with paypal female viagra india name meaning can i take tylenol with cialis lertus rl 150 mg viagra headphones or headphones which is safer viagra ovulating really late possible on clomid cytotec price in cebu pain specialists in lexington ky canada goose parka alternatives to viagra what is normal dose of cialis buy clomid online no percription with mastecard where to buy viagra in broadmeadows melbourne trok g creme generico de cialis metformin in new onset diabetes zoloft help sleep propecia sperma liquido doxycycline hyclate price killing candida with diflucan zovirax nursing interventions cialis 5 mg pas cher finasteride and steroid use socialism articles yuezhi zhao in monthly review viagra orderings south africa buy viagra delivery next day shoppin online for viagra for my husband within india walmart pharmacy cialis pricing costs of 100mg viagra fine vintage watches for sale in uk zithromax cialis generic indian where buy cheap viagra what is the generic drug for viagra brand name cialis 5 mg prezzo viagra in farmacia con ricetta how to use clomid and metformin viagra in india prize how to get cialis in ireland viagra patent expiring touteleurope missed dose of propecia best way apply zovirax diflucan 150 mg allattamento prednisone 20 mg po viagra 100mg duracion metformin und insulin zusammen signup cheap viagra viagra online danmark evonik werbung viagra for sale terence renati rock hard sale viagra price of 5 mg cialis acquisto viagra originale online thesaurus cipro 500 mg twice day buy cialis in las vegasw cost doxycycline thailand what happens if you take to much viagra what is finasteride 5 mg. used for buy male and female cialis ciprofloxacin 500mg expiration date safe cialis 50 mg precio cialis 20mg cpr4 prix prednisolone 5 mg feline can i take clomid days 6 10 cheap drug viagra metformin use in nash misoprostol cytotec como se usa does prednisone and fluconazole interact safely doxycycline hyclate 100 mg sunlight diflucan 200 mg bijsluiter dafalgan viagra samples walmart valium and propranolol aluminium hydroxide tablets 500 mg metformin indianviagra for men over counter pills work like viagra can i take 50mg of viagra and then another 50 mg is viagra available in ksa zithromax price australia comprar cialis de forma segura cipro 1000 mg bid dental abscess metoprolol retard 50 mg bijsluiter nolvadex will other co. make viagra in canada ciprofloxacin safe with protonix necesito comprar cytotec maturin venezuela galvus met 50 500mg generico de cialis is it safe for young people to take viagra viagra in koh samui buy prescription viagra online nolvadex buy australia buy lasix rx com can you buy cipro in usa without prescription generic viagra the same generique viagra pfizer prix du can viagra cause blue vision ganaric cialis 5 mg price online onlinepharmacy tv pharmacy viagra viagra china wholesale viagra pills zithromax 500 red pill order best site for cialis viagra zithromax 250 mg instructions for form generic cialis online safe drugs for chlamydia zithromax buy uveitis specialists in virginia viagra in sainsburys que es sildenafil de 50 mg viagra taken in hungry generic cialis 20 mg price viagra 50 mg sildenafil clomid price steroid cialis tablets review sante canada finasteride qual generico do cialis pills lixus clomid reviews cost of viagra medicine in india viagra online espana best way to take cialis for best results what is cialis in mexico folcress donde comprar viagra best reciprocating saw blade for metal chinese socialist market economy china begins socialist market economy reforms who knows trusted site to buy clomid price on cialis in south africa is it safe to switch from zoloft to prozac review of viagra falls stemetil over the counter uk viagra cytotec price in jordan he usado 6 pastillas cytotec cialis in surrey bc best facial moisturizer to use with accutane procytox 50 mg viagra urdu generic viagra tadalafil 20 mg dosage e20 metformin sa in stool onde comprar viagra em campo grande ms viagra reviews uk can you take vitamins with accutane will 500 mg of metformin help with pcos 10mgbrand cialis australia 400 mg of zoloft is that a overdose cialis daily use average cost uses of viagra in hindi what the differ between viagra 50 mg and 100 mg causas secundarias de la viagra 121doc viagra for sale cipro 250 mg pille generic viagra paypal next day delivery uk is cipro safe for toddlers viagra cost in ireland ulceral 20 mg cialis inderal brand generic tetracycline and zithromax is it safe to take nexium with metformin how to buy viagra pakistan walmart prescription drug prices cialis finasteride tablet available in ncr at what price propranolol in third trimester risks 100 mg clomid spotting before period while clomid online zoloft 75 mg to 100mg is how many ml dapoxetine kaufen wien post finasteride syndrome ukc brand viagra pfizer metformin 500 mg ivf doxycycline hyclate 100 mg buy 150mg clomid 1500 mg metformin pcos viagra uae online buy cheap clomid pills gocce otologiche ciprofloxacin 500 mg how do i get free samples of viagra generic viagra on internet why should you take metformin in the evening viagra sales dubai viagra by money order viagra 150 mg overnight when does viagra patent expiry in europe do you have to take prednisone in the morning viagra billig kaufen paypal buy viagra netherlands rogaine and propecia in delhi epocrates online doxycycline vomen viagra uk viagra in kaffee viagra order by paypal payment comprar viagra sin receta en mendoza argentina viagra sales pitch letter india pharmacies for viagra viagra generic off patent buy cialis male female chronic fatigue syndrome and zoloft generic name first beta blocker propranolol reviews propranolol 40 mg nhsp can fertile woman take clomid cialis over the counter walmart vision cipla viagra generico in italia viagra in deutschland kaufen ohne rezept sildenafil citrate in natural food can you donate blood if you take accutane is viagra testosterone doxycycline hyclate india green tablets panafcort prednisone 25 mg cialis 5 mg generico online order authenic viagra online now mexican pharmacy generic cialis zithromax zithromax anitbiotic buy cytotec for postpartum hemorrhage finasteride 0 5 mg work xanax and metformin canadian customs on cialis best sites to buy clomid on legit why does metformin come out in stool how do you cut a viagra pill in thirds cheap accutane india lang en buying cialis washington cialis generic timetable linagliptin metformin genericons what for prednisone tablets usp 5 mg walgreens cialis discounts cost of ciprodex drops cialis 5mg costs cialis canada australia clomid e nausea vendo finasteride 1 mg priligy romania pret tamox e clomid onde comprar fibra super lara counterfeit viagra 20 mg cialis effects on pregnancy serlife vs zoloft generic name celebrities who have taken propecia viagra door delivery in bangalore best price for accutane what happens if i take doxycycline with antacids viagra price with a prescription what is sildenafil troche 60 mg pill propecia lowest price buy online cost of viagra in thailand activiti webapp rest generic viagra glucophage xr vs glucophage viagra online bestellen schweizer cialis 5mg daily use us pharmacy prices ampicillin for uti treatment how long will 20 mg of cialis last is it safe to take antibiotics with cialis directions to use clomid bijsluiter cialis 5 mg where can i buy single viagra pills from donde comprar viagra en republica dominicana azithromycin 250 mg zithromax considered long term prednisone usage where can you buy viagra yahoo answers cheap viagra furthermore wellbutrin ordering online what price is viagra at boots glasses online canada cheap viagra viagra reviews treatment 5 50 mg of clomid success rate cuanto tiempo tarda en hacer efecto cialis 5 mg cialis 5mg prix belgique bula do higroton 25 mg of zoloft a amoxil cap 500mg inderal and pregnancy safety trisilicato de magnesio nombre generico de amoxil kilo sports clomid reviews doxycycline can be taken with milk priligy where to buy singapore postage is cialis available over the counter in germany what is the generic for zovirax can we get viagra in pattaya usar viagra sem necessidade is 1mg of tadalafil equal to 1 mg of cialis how long does prednisone injection stay in your system diuretic lasix blood in urine generic cialis retail at bangalore is viagra over the counter in canada yahoo tab urotone 25 mg of zoloft buy zithromax in maine viagra difficulty ejaculating can prednisone give you a bad taste in your mouth can you trust online cialis doxycycline 100 mg coupon brand cialis lilly pastillas zoloft 25 mg where to buy viagra over the counter at boots online pharmacy lasix generic propecia just good fraxiparine 0 3 ml bijsluiter nolvadex viagra alternatives pills viagra australia do u need a prescription panafcort generic of prednisone adhd specialist in tucson clomid to treat low testosterone in men homeopathic viagra india cialis 50 mg dosage dios viagra really work bisoprolol 5mg generic propecia 1000 mg metformin weight loss ciprohexal 500 mg anwendung lloyds pharmacy uk propecia coupon why did the cialis price double low cost 40 mg cialis doxycycline for treatment of malaria where to buy ciprofloxacin oral suspension online for how many months can i take clomid tadalafil generic vs cialis prednisone 10 mg get you high ciprofloxacino para que sirve de 250 mg tadalafil for men india young 30s advisable intazin 10 mg prednisone sildenafil genfar costs cialis overnight delivery ciproxin 500 mg effetti collaterali zoloft is the generic viagra from cipla is safe obtaining cialis in denver prednisone 5 mg for 10 days viagra in meaning is it safe to take advil with zoloft bronchitis doxycycline dosage prednisone canada no prescription can clomid cause fibroids pfizer ireland pharmaceuticals ringaskiddy viagra discount viagra kuala lumpur cialis pillenmaster safe place order cialis sildenafil de genfar 50 mg is 500 mgs of cipro for 3 days enough for a uti medistar cialis over the counter what is the price viagra in dubai Kiwipolitico » Urewera Terra
Posts Tagged ‘Urewera Terra’

Urewera Terror: epic fail

datePosted on 06:01, March 21st, 2012 by Lew

Whatever your opinion regarding the Urewera Terror raids, you have to admit that the Police and Crown Law have failed.

The so-called “Urewera 4” were convicted on about half of the least-serious charges brought, and the jury was hung on the more serious charges of participation in an organised criminal group. The defendants may be retried on these latter charges, and they may yet be found guilty. But the paucity of the Police and Crown Law operation is pretty clear regardless.

Let’s put this in context. The Crown sought initially to lay dozens more charges against many more people than the four who eventually stood trial; leave to bring charges under the Terrorism Suppression Act was not granted, and most of the other charges were dropped after the Supreme Court ruled that the evidence upon which they were founded had been illegally obtained. A year of fancy intensive surveillance; an extreme and unprecedented police assault on an unsuspecting community, including violent treatment of old people and children; four and a half years of lawyering comprising the most expensive trial in New Zealand history, held almost as far from the homes of the defendants as is possible; leaks and publicity tactics designed to bring about a de-facto trial-by-media — and the best they convict on is Arms Act offences such as about half the adult male population of rural New Zealand would be guilty of at some time or other? This, we are supposed to believe, is Aotearoa’s finest at work.

Not only did they fail at the nominal objective of securing convictions, they totally failed at the personal, punitive motive of punishing Tāme Iti and shaming him before his people. Iti has been literally the face of Māori activism, at least since Hone Harawira took the institutional path, and it is impossible to see this trial as anything other than utu for his temerity in escaping conviction for previous acts of defiant political theatre, most notably shooting a flag at a Waitangi Tribunal hearing in 2005. By going in loud and heavy, attempting to show them uppity Māoris who was boss, the Crown set themselves an ambitious target: they had to actually show who was boss. By failing to convict him on the serious charges at a canter, they failed. Tāme Iti is now a celebrity. His mythology is greater than his deeds, except inasmuch as resisting such a legal and ideological onslaught with dignity is a significant deed in itself. He has, in the view of a significant minority of the population, been victimised by the system, and that victimisation provides proof of Crown oppression he had previously struggled to demonstrate. For the rest of the population, Iti represents a brown, tattooed bogeyman, an object of fear, and of loathing that ranges from mild to virulent depending on who you talk to. Iti isn’t standing for office, he doesn’t need to be loved by 50%+1; he just needs to engender fervent support among an active minority, and vague feelings of unease in the rest. Notoriety differs from fame only in its polarity. The Police and the Crown have granted Tāme Iti this sort of fame. He should probably thank them for it.

As if the particular and the personal weren’t failures enough, the Crown also failed at the strategic project of redefining “activism” as “extremism”. Despite all the preceding factors weighing in the Crown’s favour, that a heavily-vetted jury was split indicates that they have failed to blur this crucial distinction, and failed to reframe left-wing and Māori activism* as a threat to civilisation, rather than a legitimate expression of dissent in an open society. This suggests that, in spite of years of Police infiltration and surveillance, of decades of stigmatisation and propagandisation of groups from Ngā Tamatoa to Ploughshares to SAFE, in spite of the better part of two centuries of official attempts to elide the gulf between dissent and insurrection, the public doesn’t really buy it. The jury — and, I would suggest, the people of Aotearoa — quite like and value that distinction and although it is been somewhat eroded, there it remains.

For that finding alone, and regardless of the result of any retrial, yesterday was a good day.

L

* Māori and leftist because, let us not forget, the Right Wing Resistance are free to continue with their training camps and their pseudo-secessionist projects, unmolested.

Justice Gnomes

datePosted on 19:05, September 5th, 2011 by Lew

The New Zealand Police [and Crown Law] appear to be adopting the Underpants Gnome strategy to deal with minor breaches of public order and transgressions against the general authority of the state:

1. Brutally arrest and lay spurious charges for general idiocy or mostly harmless defiance.
2. Weather firestorm of public and civil society outrage.
3. Drop or substantially downgrade charges after months (or years) of tedious ‘review’.
4. Insist that, despite expert opinions to the contrary, their original decision to lay charges — and the excessive means by which the arrests were effected — are perfectly justified.
5. ????
6. Profit!

This pattern holds in three high-profile cases that spring easily to mind: most clearly the “Urewera Terra” raids and subsequent fiasco, about which Pablo has written previously; more recently the case of Arie Smith, documented best by Russell Brown; and the pattern has today been completed by the decision to drop charges against Tiki Taane.

There are certainly other examples, which readers can discuss in comments. An exception to the pattern has been the Crown’s treatment of the Waihopai Three, who are being vexatiously pursued for damages they can’t pay, having been found not guilty by a jury of their peers. Pablo has written about this, also. In stark contrast to the high standard of conduct expected of random individuals stands the lax attitude towards police discipline, with egregious conduct documented or alleged in two out of three of those cases, and in others.

This coming weekend (weather & workload permitting) I’ll be visiting a block of land in Taranaki that the police had also pegged as housing “terrorist training camps” back in 2007. They failed to reach even the lax evidentiary requirements to gain the proper warrants to conduct raids there, but according to contemporaneous news reports they weren’t far off, and had dedicated considerable time, effort and money towards that end. Based on what I know about these particular circumstances, they would have roused a few kaumātua at Parihaka and its surrounds; some possum trappers, and depending on the day, perhaps a hunter or two (most likely Pākehā), since the most dangerous people in there are the folks who go in of a weekend with quad bikes and boxes of ammo and bottles of spirits to blaze mobs of goats, and leave them on the flats to rot as pig bait. Policing of this sort is a fool’s errand, and after nearly four years we have no reason to believe that those cases that had accrued slightly more evidence than the one of which I’m aware will have meaningfully more merit.

Watching and listening coverage of the 1981 Springbok tour riots this past week or so I’ve been struck by how his preoccupation with symbolic insults to law and order, rather than more substantive breaches, is reminiscent of police and government conduct under Muldoon, during that era — a short, sharp, shock doctrine of fiercely punishing trivial breaches in order to send a signal to those who would commit more serious actions. I don’t have time at present to go into a deep discussion of the implications of this activism among the police, and indeed Pablo has already covered much of that ground better than I could. But the apparent detachment between police command and both the ordinary citizens of the state and the country’s expert civil society agencies would be hilarious if it wasn’t so concerning.

Perhaps the worst aspect of this trend is that it serves to undermine the credibility of and public confidence in the police, which civil society needs to function. Especially at society’s margins — including Māori, the disabled, and activists — with whom police should be especially assiduous about building relationships.

Update: And would you look at that — right on cue, the remaining trumped-up firearms charges against the Urewera 18 have been dropped, on the grounds that continuing proceedings would not be in the public interest. Indeed. So, authoritarian apologists for the police state and anti-Māori revenge fantasists, how you like THEM apples?

L

The Big Wet

datePosted on 15:27, January 12th, 2011 by Lew

Having neglected my bloggerly duties these past six weeks (in fact, I’ve been neglecting all my duties which aren’t strictly in service of looking after my family and keeping my job), I had resolved to write something about one of the many momentous events which have taken place recently. There are many to choose from. Some topics (Pike River; Wikileaks; Foreshore and Seabed for instance) are no longer immediate; others (the re-emergence of Winston Peters, commencement of the NZ general election campaign and its forerunner the Botany by-election) are not yet sufficiently well-formed for me to quite know what to say about them yet. Yet others (notably the shooting of Gabrielle Giffords, Wikileaks and the Urewera Terra trials) have been more ably dealt with by Pablo and/or so many others, such that anything I could say would be redundant. There’s already enough peoples’ two cents rattling around in the hollow urn of internet discussion. In the context of these events other things I was meaning to write about (such as the manvertising topic Pablo discussed before the break) seem a bit trivial.

Add to all of this, today there is really only one story; that an area twice the size of Texas — the canonical measure of a really big thing — is underwater in Queensland; including much of Brisbane. The coverage put out by the Australian media, and in particular the ABC, is first-rate, and the best I can do is commend it to your attention.

There is one point, however, that I don’t think has been made strongly enough: and that’s that events such as these are a consequence of climate change. While it is fashionable for climate change deniers to mock those pointing to the increasing frequency and severity of snowstorms, cold snaps, hurricanes and torrential rainfall events as evidence for ‘global warming’; implying that climate science proponents try to take everything as evidence of ‘global warming’, the fact is that the term ‘global warming’ was retired and replaced with ‘climate change’ because the thesis isn’t just that the planet will get warmer.

That’s part of it, but the events — snowfall and what not — being pointed to are not climate; they are weather. The relationship between climate and weather is a lot like the relationship between mathematics and arithmetic — indistinguishable if you don’t understand them, but fundamentally of a different order. Weather, like arithmetic, is by and large small, trivial, unarguable stuff — stuff which is more or less self-evident. It rained this much last week; 2+2=4 — whereas climate, and mathematics, are bigger, more open-ended and by definition less quantifiable. Mistaking ‘weather’ for ‘climate’ is an immensely useful rhetorical device, and one which I believe has not been sufficiently well guarded-against by those whose task it is to argue the climate change case. But even though it may not have been made clear to the degree necessary for broad public and political comprehension, this distinction is well understood by those working in the field and anyone who cares to acquaint themselves even scarcely with the material. And fundamentally the take-away is this: climate change caused by the increased quantity of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, to the extent that it takes place, will have unpredictable flow-on effects such as increased frequency and severity of severe weather events, and not just heat waves and droughts such as ‘warming’ would suggest.

The XKCD comic above (of which some years ago, my wife bought me the t-shirt) shows the Cosmic Microwave Background radiation spectrum. This has nothing much to do with climate change, but it is a famous proof of the scientific method: a near-perfect agreement between theory and actuality which is pretty fundamental to our understanding of a bunch of stuff. Science’s only defence; the only thing which gives it any importance or makes it any use at all, is that it works. When properly applied, it predicts actual events. The Queensland floods, as well as other such events, are happening as predicted, and anyone who tells you otherwise is either ignorant, or having you on, or both. In Andrew Bolt‘s case, it’s both. Queenslanders — and others similarly impacted by such events — need neither.

L

‘Ethnographic’ TV: compare & contrast

datePosted on 11:30, September 28th, 2010 by Lew

At the risk of courting Pablo’s disappointment, I’m descending briefly from lofty theoretical heights to make a few rather rambly observations about two new examples of ‘ethnographic’ reality television in New Zealand: How the Other Half Lives and Are You My Tribe? (both of which screen on TV One, Monday nights).

First, the similarities: Both shows follow a pretty well-established format popularised most thoroughly by Louis Theroux: ‘gonzo anthropology’ for the television audience. Both are journeys of discovery undertaken by middle-aged celebrities who have made their names and reputations by being all-round Kiwi blokes — former All Black Marc Ellis and broadcaster Mikey Havoc. Both have enthusiastically embraced their ignorance of those aspects of life in New Zealand which form their shows’ subject matter. Both possess the superficial characteristic required for such an endeavour: the ability to establish and maintain rapport with people whilst simultaneously objectifying them; or, put another way, the ability to make the objectification not seem quite so objectionable.

In HTOHL Ellis is explicitly using his status as a cultural elite to investigate defined sub- or counter-cultures within New Zealand society. In AYMT Havoc uses the same cultural elite status to gain entry to te Ao Māori in an attempt to make up for 38 years of having (as one Ngāi Tūhoe kaumatua put it) not bothered. Both Havoc and Ellis speak to — and for — ordinary Pākehā middle-class New Zealand; that swathe of folk who are, by any objective definition, in charge of the country economically, politically and culturally; and who yet harbour considerable uncertainty about whether they are or not. There’s an unselfconscious normative aspect to this; HTOHL’s blurb declares that Ellis “reckons he’s pretty normal” but in the show “he jumps the fence of normality”; the word ‘other’ is even in the show’s title. AYMT pointedly started with the most ‘scary’ iwi for its first show, which went to some lengths to emphasise Tūhoetanga as a distinguishing characteristic. So the clear subtext of both shows is to firm up that shaky sense of cultural identity by emphasising the fact that the cultural objects of his investigation — those, by definition, with a strong and distinctly-articulated identity — are on the margins, outside society’s norms and not really wholly accountable to them. The screening of the two shows back-to-back is a bit troublesome here; I’m vaguely disturbed by the equation of Māori with the sort of fringe subcultural ‘others’ which are the objects of Ellis’ investigations — Neo-Nazi survivalists, witches, born-again Buddhists and so on.* One of the key things the last few decades should have taught Aotearoeans of all hues is that Māori aren’t just another fringe group.

So much for the similarities. There are some pretty fundamental differences between these two shows, which are also emphasised by their consecutive timeslots. The first and most obvious of these is the specific objects and the host’s relationship to them. Ellis is lighthearted and superficial; he’s more interested in the gonzo than in cultural engagement, and the choice of fringe subcultures as his objects permits him to be flippant and dismissive when it suits. Havoc, playing for much higher stakes, doesn’t have this luxury: he can’t treat his objects as cultural curiosities or as a freakshow. He has to take his objects seriously, and this requires him to engage more deeply and more honestly with them than Ellis does, to put more of himself on the line, drawing more out from the objects of his investigation.

That difference gives rise to the second major difference: the presence and extent of judgement as to life according to ‘other’ norms. The heart of programming like this — and of comparative ethnography in general — is in the carefully-contained judgement of the investigator. The point is to examine the cultural fronts, where norms butt up against each other; and the key attribute of a host isn’t so much to be a jovial wise-cracking ‘good bloke’, it’s to do so whilst gaining genuine insight into where the cultural fronts lie, how they might be negotiated, and indeed whether it’s possible to negotiate them. This is a pretty rare quality; one which Louis Theroux has in spades and which permits him to make such eye-opening television: the objects of his investigation don’t feel like they’re being objectified. As a rule they are disarmingly frank, and sometimes frighteningly so. Theroux achieves this sort of dynamic by carefully constraining his judgement, but not abandoning it altogether. Theroux asks the question which needs to be asked and holds his own cultural ground, but does so in a way which does not threaten or attack his objects. Theroux refuses to become complicit in admiring whatever edifices of self-delusion his objects erect, but also does not make it his business to tear them down.

For all that Havoc exhibits maudlin and faintly embarrassing envy for the strong and rooted sense of identity possessed by Ngāi Tūhoe (honestly, how many generations will it take for people to realise that being Pākehā is not the absence of culture; it is a culture in and of itself!), he enters into the discourse in good and robust faith to find out what that identity is, and what it tells him about his own. His aim is not to disabuse them of their stranger notions, but nor is it just to impassively observe. Havoc puts himself in uncomfortable situations (such as powhiri and a raucous kitchen-table drinking session) but does not relinquish his own cultural ground, finding ways to ask the question — like addressing the fact that one in four young Māori end up in prison, and asking “how is ‘exclusive’ different from ‘racist’?” — and expecting good answers, without alienating those who must provide them.

Ellis, on the other hand, is not required to do anything more than the superficial, so he doesn’t. He exhibits a much stronger sense of his own identity than than Havoc does, but there’s almost nothing of it in the programme. His own reality is never challenged: the cultural front never emerges because instead of engaging and standing firm on his own ground, he withdraws into jocular trivialities, avoiding the conflict which is necessary for this sort of exercise. Discomfort is limited to banalities like sitting through three-hour chanting ceremonies and sleeping rough in the bush. He gets through the entire first episode of this season with Kyle Chapman, former leader of the National Front and probably New Zealand’s best-known neo-Nazi, without once initiating discussion about the ideological and racist foundations of Chapman’s Survive Club. What’s more, when one of the club members talks about how the ‘maaris’ — and Ngāi Tūhoe in particular — are the leading threat to New Zealand’s civil society, he fails to ask the question (in fact, judging by a posting on Survive Club’s website it seems that not being a “media hate monger” was part of the deal.) It takes a special sort of obliviousness to not remark on the irony of a group of racial-supremacist armed wannabe commandos training for the coming apocalypse in a remote part of the Southern Alps who think some other group are the real threat.

You don’t get to be Louis Theroux without asking that question.

L

* I can certainly see the counter here: Tūhoe training camps; rongoa Māori and modern religions like Hauhau and Ratana.

In January and February 2008 my wife and I did a road trip the length of the country, twice — from Wellington to Bluff, back to Wellington, up to Cape Reinga, and back to Wellington again. For most of the trip, we flew a small Tino Rangatiratanga flag, one of those small ones which clip onto a car window. It was partly a matter of literally “flying the flag” of my political views at this time of year — I must note, with some misgivings on her part — and partly an experiment to see what response it would get.

Photo by Adrienne Rewi.
(Photo by Adrienne Rewi — because its surprisingly hard to take a shot of your own car-flag while driving and we didn’t take one. Used without permission but with thanks — I’ll take it down on request.)

Most obviously, traffic seemed to treat us somewhat differently, though this might be down to regional and seasonal driving variations. Some cars honked, some flashed their lights or waved; others rode closer behind or seemed to overtake more aggressively. Many times I saw drivers staring or otherwise reacting with surprise at seeing a couple of Pākehā in a white station wagon flying such a flag. Truck drivers were particularly well-represented in all these reactions; the road is their territory, and visual vehicular statements of identity or loyalty mean a lot to them.

This was especially true when driving around Otago and Southland with my ZZ Top-bearded and bemulleted uncle in the car. Mostly in the South, though, people were cool but not hostile, and too polite to mention anything they might have thought. The response, both positive and negative, was strongest in the central North Island, Northland and the Bay of Plenty. In Taumarunui we got into town late and a group of local Māori were drinking and singing karaoke at the hotel where we stopped. They were intrigued and after a few friendly waves and “kia ora bro”s a couple of kuia came over to suss us out — asking us who we were, where we were from, and so on. Learning that we were from Whanganui, and that I have family connections to Jerusalem put it in context and they treated us with easy amiability. Their only mention of the flag was to remark that it was probably a pretty good guard against theft; said with warmth and irony and humour. There were several of these sort of encounters. Later, stopping for side-of-the-road hāngi on the road between Wellsford and Whangarei, the young guy gave us $2 off and claimed it was because it was the last, though I could see there was plenty left and it was only just lunch time. Especially in the Far North, and through the Bay of Plenty from Te Puke through Whakatane down to about Rotorua, Māori pedestrians and kids playing near the street would shout and point and wave. Usually, this was in run-down areas, and the people waving and shouting “chur bro!” often wore gang colours.

The “anti-theft device” line was replayed unbidden in Tauranga while visiting some in-laws, though this time in all seriousness, with none of the warmth of the Māori in Taumarunui. This was combined with a rather heated debate as to the relative merits of the Clark government, Foreshore and Seabed Act and general state of the bicultural nation. The two events were on consecutive days, and the contrast could not have been more stark.

In a couple of cases — once in Lyttelton in the carpark of the Wunderbar, and again outside a petrol station in Whitianga — we were asked by random strangers if we were Māori, and if not, why were we flying the flag. In Lyttelton this was good-natured and curious; in the other case, the question was asked with gruff suspicion, and the answer — an explanation of what the flag means and its origin — didn’t cut any ice with the chap who looked and seemed rather like Garth George. I’ve encountered that sort of reaction before — once a guy called me a “race traitor” in Molly Malone’s because I was wearing a Tino Rangatiratanga hoodie — and that one didn’t even have the flag, just the words.

But on a trip of 7,500km on the busiest roads in the country, passing through all the main population centres at the time of our national holiday, in an election year, not long after the Urewera Terra arrests and with issues of racial separatism and colonialism very squarely on the agenda, the thing which was most obvious was how little such a statement changed anything. It reiterated to me that New Zealand is a pretty tolerant and easy society, as long as that tolerance is not stretched too far. Another example of this was this evening’s “Great Debate” on Māori TV between celebrities and comedians and such folks on the moot “now is the time for Aotearoa to close the immigration gates”. I won’t spoil the result, because it really is worth watching (and I assume Māori TV will put up a video), but while the moot was robustly (and often very personally) contested, it was all done in wonderful good humour. The same good humour as of a Māori joking ruefully about Māori crime — and the opposing siege mentality the following day. Happily, I think the former predominates in this country, and provides a sound basis for the ongoing development of a bicultural — and eventually multicultural — society.

L