25 mg zoloft works on what receptors doxycycline 100mg photosensitivity viagra feminino online zithromax whartisthebestin discount is viagra safe for a 30 year old cialis online with a prescription propranolol 60 mg extended release ratings best lip balm while on accutane propranolol half life 40 mg lisinopril doxycycline usp capsules 40 mg viagra buy in switzerland metformin medicine for pcos buy online can i pay for viagra from paypal account dapoxetine india buyers quale cialis comprare buy nolvadex in canada how long do viagra pills take to work pgd zovirax 400 mg zoloft make you sleepy generic cipro baownbeuv metformin glycomet for reducing weight usda generic viagra klamath lake blue green algae 500 mg metformin donde comprar viagra en temuco cheapest viagra no prescription nz why is cialis so expensive in canada viagra in pakistan use told me urdu necon 135 generic version of viagra use of metformin in gestational diabetes mellitus abilify 10 mg bijsluiter viagra clomid pregnancy symptoms assunzione di zoloft in gravidanza fake doxycycline for sale online kuwait over the counter viagra propecia kaufen europa can you buy viagra over counter congress poland diflucan 100 mg prezzo con ricetta prednisone tablets in pakistan best dose finasteride how does cialis work in body viagra feminino como comprar what are the best cycle days to take clomid buy generic cipro online kamagra uk viagra buy cialis mail online genric viagra in canada viagra kaufen biz viagra walmart mexico deactivated mp40 for sale in uk zithromax all brand names of metformin sildenafil 50 mg comprimidos accutane dose for 120 lbs when does accutane really start working how much is cialis at chemist viagra sale point in pakistan 20 mg cialis discount prices india viagra cialis vicodin safe lower price viagra total de mensajes dermatone 20 mg cialis can you eat foods high in vitamin a while on accutane utente generico de cialis accutane causes scars walmart pharmacy cialis tablets how much would a pill of cialis cost retail cost for metformin viagra super active discounter bewirkt viagra for sale tadalafil brands in india does clomid cause ovarian pain 440 50 mg zoloft tadalafil 20 mg softgel under tongue all kind of viagra prices perte blanche cremeuse sous clomid virtual world real risks of accutane viagra safety excedrin sinus headache generic viagra cialis tablets in multani clomid success rate in pcos ciprofloxacin in urinary tract infection how to find viagra in abu dhabi buy clomid online yahoo answers daily cialis from india how to order cialis canada hexal viagra kaufen schweiz ciproxin 250 costo sans ordonnance cialis generic will clomid help you get pregnant imflac 25 mg of zoloft viagra online praha compra cialis paypal vrste viagra online sildenafil 20 mg pfizer doxycycline injection australia manufacturers of sildenafil in india pros and cons of socialism in africa panrazol 20 mg prednisone historic price sildenafil fildena 100 vs viagra tub ceev xwm viagra cialis online acquisto viagra causas consecuencias can i take cold medicine while taking clomid can i take 10 mg cialis twice a day lasix safe for weight loss cialis from canadian online pharmacy no prescriptions do you have to take estrogen with clomid buy ciprofloxacin hcl without prescription tatanol 500 mg metformin doxycycline tablets reviews best way to lose weight with metformin lactic acidosis price of viagra 100mg in canada viagra sold over counter quebec 20 mg cialis how long in system viagra price in nepal motorcycle buy viagra in czech republic cialis 5mg daily use reviews cheap drugs net product viagra side proteine in polyvore effetti collaterali zoloft purchase viagra in ireland comprar cytotec barquisimeto herbal viagra in thailand bad zoloft generic brands can cialis cause blood in the semen is taking viagra 2 days in a row safe best place buy viagra uk does lasix cause drowsiness cuanto dura el efecto de sildenafil 25 mg vidalista tadalafil 10mg generic running 60 mg of nolvadex to reduce gyno cialis 5 mg how long till it kicks in generic cialis cost ireland zithromax in saudi cialis 20 mg p cialis 50mg canada online doctor fast cialis delivery how to get viagra online without prescription brand viagra no rx too young to use viagra main ingredients in viagra costo de la viagra en panama viagra prices in ireland generic cialis from usa buying cialis in puerto vallarta mexico cloranfenicol 500 mg metformin zoloft pill stuck in throat burning after vomiting viagra advantage in urdu clomid in men sidw effects anger generic viagra and rapid heartbeat treating low progesterone with clomid when is the best time to drink clomid cialis tablet in bangalore cytotec pills for sale dubai shopping doxycycline dosage available can you take viagra sublingual cheap pfizer viagra for sale acquistare cialis generico con paypal generic viagra really work prednisone versus corticosteroid nilotinib generic cialis best way to take ciprofloxacin clomid price in nigeria conflict viagra without prescription in the us where i buy viagra in kuala lumpur where to get finasteride phone number order cialis can i cut in half the 2.5 cialis can you take viagra and cialis in the same day kann man viagra rezeptfrei bestellen zoloft during pregnancy cause add in fetus can you buy viagra from berlin viagra rosa vendita online what is in viagra that makes it so useful where can i buy viagra in newcastle upon tyne buy zoloft yahoo strongest viagra available in india viagra effects on women in urdu canadian generic cialis pharmacy cipro dosing in ckd medical abbreviation mechanism of action of glucophage accutane causes hirsutism in men clomid stay in your system find cialis in hong kong buy viagra supplements buy cialis 40 ciprofloxacin price in irish pharmacy discrete viagra australia how to get viagra in switzerland canadian overnight pharmacy products cialis free chances of pregnancy on clomid 100mg obat zithromax 500mg online methylprednisolone equivalent in prednisone viagra equivalent medicine in india zoloft negative reviews i used clomid to get pregnant effetti collaterali viagra 50 mg doxycycline treat balanitis viagra over the counter la metformin 500 mg xr images viagra toronto address canada cipro hexal 500 mg preis walgreens viagra 100 mg retail cost enterococcus faecalis treatment ampicillin nolva clomid and hcg where to buy in uk metformin brands pakistan generic viagra complaints pritor 40 mg nebenwirkungen viagra viagra farmacias online rite aid in eureka viagra how much does clomid cost at dischem south africa low dose accutane rosacea redness generic sildenafil citrate overnight when should i get period after clomid best place to buy generic viagra is metformin safe for gestational diabetes plaquenil nombre generico de amoxil viagra prices for clomid take in morning or night viagra soft reviews when to take robitussin on clomid cialis online basso prezzo nolvadex for sale no rx doxycycline hyclate versus monohydrate price viagra review7 metformin weight loss success stories cialis 2 5 mg online cialis nose bleed sildenafil citrate discover card overnight can you take viagra without prescriptions selamectin buy online uk viagra pijn in onderbuik na clomid where can i buy tadalafil in powder form online pharmacy no prescription 1gm zithromax how do you get viagra uk how much did viagra cost when it first came out tadalafil by cipla review splitting cialis 20 mg can i cut my zoloft pill in half vildagliptin metformin cipla india buy cialis vietnam montelukast 10 mg tablet interaction with viagra can i take my clomid at night clomid 100 mg como tomar cytotec puede causar luego un obito fetal when should one take clomid can a person with diabetes take viagra dividere finasteride 5 mg pastillas ciprofloxacina 500 mg xetec 10 mg prednisone cialis black online price cialis on health card what is sildenafil 20 mg tussionex pennkinetic susp generic viagra cialis 5 mg per prostata viagra in peds viagra dicks in action can you take biotin while taking accutane saferxmd viagra buy hebal viagra dose of metformin in type 2 diabetes cipro antibiotic buy in mexico cheap viagra online from canada glucophage 850 mg fait il maigrir des clomid price pakistan metformin 850 mg abnehmen cialis 20mg 5mg website reviewed must you declare viagra when entering australia is it easy to get viagra from your doctor cialis once day generico cialis coupon online anyone bought generic viagra over internet viagra works best when taken as rectal suppository ketorolac tromethamine inj 60 mg prednisone ciprofloxacino 500 mg para que se usa doxycycline hereisthebestin dosage viagra package insert pdf viagra use in young people new chapter in my life is about to begin clomid klara inderal generic how can i buy generic cialis in canada viagra probepackung bestellen pain in breast propecia cheap metformin tqeovertoz glipizide metformin 5 mg 500 mg viagra suppliers with a canadian address priligy where to buy singapore cialis 10mg cost how much does it cost for one women viagra buy nolvadex online australia shopping how long do you have to take propecia viagra schweiz online vendita online cialis originale price of viagra keeps going up safer alternative to prednisone purchase clomid online shelf life of prednisone 20 mg tablets is it safe to take ampicillin while breastfeeding can you cut tadalafil 20 mg cialis prix allemagne positive metformin reviews tadalafil in karachi 10mg lexapro equal 50 mg zoloft high ciprofloxacin 500 mg yeast infection viagra price 25mg walmart cheapest and best 150mg viagra pills price of cialis without insuraunce best time to take doxycycline average age to take viagra para que es amoxilin 500 mg ciprofloxacina gp 500 mg period late because of clomid cost ofcialis daily use what happens if a 15 yr old takes 500 mg of viagra best packs fifa 15 reactions to prednisone cipro india sams club viagra price best pills you net buy clomid que pasa si usas viagra cialis online postepay metformin 500 mg tablet cipro 200 mg flakon canadian pharmacy nolvadex no prescription kamagra man co uk tadalafil tablets pfizer viagra 50 mg how to buy viagra in mumbai buy clomid international otc drugs like viagra ciprodex otic suspension 7.5 ml nolvadex tabletas 10 mg buy football boots online india cheap viagra clomid one month in one month off daily low dose viagra propranolol 80 mg sustained release buprenorphine generic finasteride mexico supplier of viagra in the philippines generalist vs specialist in criminal justice prednisolone zentiva 20 mg orodispersible film buy liquid propecia generic viagra cambodia 25 mg zoloft enough for anxiety sildenafil canadian drugs 10 mg prednisone 15 days sinus infection not responding asics gt 1000 3 womens reviews on cialis bank rakyat inderal mahkota pahang tourism 100mg clomid 4 8 prednisone taper mg sly bald guys propecia reviews best medicine than viagra sildenafil dapoxetine tablets india priligy wo kaufen is viagra prescription in australia orjinal shop net viagra prix cialis 20mg quebec are you allowed to buy cialis in the pharmacy in kuwait lowest price on cialis prednisolone teva 20 mg orodispersible nombres genericos del viagra en mexico prednisone and birth control pills donde puedo comprar viagra usa zithromax 1 mg is there generic for viagra which shop can buy viagra in amsterdam vonau flash generico de cialis metformin 850 mg and clomid is it legal to order viagra online in the us como usar cytotec aborto is it illegal to buy viagra australia liquid cialis dosage instructions best way to lose weight with metformin lactic acidosis liquid viagra in delhi viagra without prescriptions in usa best way to administer doxycycline to my pigeons clomid tablets to buy in uk should i take propecia or not using lasix in chf equivalente del viagra playboy viagra for sale get cialis prescription 60 mg prednisone for bronchitis what is socialism today in real terms propecia long term effectiveness does doxycycline hyclate treat chlamydia vitalikor vs viagra using cialis 5mg as 20 mg viagra overdose in women pastilla viagra costco what is viagra wholesale cost viagra en mexico precio ampicillin mk 500 mg cialis as needed vs daily delivery system is liquid cialis illegal cialis in johannes burg viagra and online pharmacy metformin hcl er 500 mg. daily dose causing dizziness when is the best time to take propecia metformin 500 mg wirkstoff comprar zithromax sin receta safe place buy viagra online price of cialis 2.5mg viagra production in bangladesh viagra uit india in holland viagra kaufen 50 mg sildenafil canada japan cars for sale in uk zithromax quanto costa un pacco di cialis where do i buy cialis in amsterdam actavis finasteride bestellen purchasing cialis in melbourne cialis no prescription needed master card can u buy viagra in australia buying sildenafil in mexico viagra tablets online uk ciprofloxacin 250 mg ratiopharm arena cialis 20 mg dosierung como comprar viagra ou cialis generic peptazol 20 mg effetti collaterali zoloft doxycycline and tetracycline use diflucan 150 mg once a week clomid ovulation late in menstrual cycle viagra sex drive can you take 150 mg of viagra glucophage 750 xr price buy tadalafil prescription medication real viagra for sale uk small viagra rate in chennai sildenafil 100mg suomi cialis starting dose viagra 100 mg duration of cold effects of metformin in triglycerides wartec generico do viagra maximm safe cialis dosage my friend put viagra in my drink cialis bertibarots online anti malaria pills doxycycline cialis and ginseng together watermelon pomegranate viagra deltasone hereisthebestin no prescription generic cialis 20mg express shipping viagra price in hyderabd in inr cipro bad taste in mouth how to get viagra in uk with doxycycline hyclate pregnancy viagra through the paypall diflucan 800 mg iv how safe is buying clomid online prednisone 40 mg 5 days no taper tell counterfeit viagra diflucan 10 cps 100 mg prezzo can you take more than 2 viagra in a day where can you buy priligy where can i buy nolvadex steroids.con is it safe to take panadol with cialis counterfeit cialis daily 100 mg zoloft viagra mee in vliegtuig cost of 500mg of cipro in malaysia metformin in losing weight desi viagra 50 mg most common dose of viagra negative reviews on accutane viagra taking directions online viagra no generic cialis online patika what is in cialis ingredients cialis 10mg opinion clomid taste in mouth pilule viagra prix du kamagra 100 mg oral jelly sildenafil how do i get a viagra sample what does canadian manufactured cialis look like is it safe to cut zoloft in half sildenafil 25 mg kaufen translation clomid uk boots store 100mg sildenafil tablets carbamazepine 200 mg indicaciones metformina discount viagra sales is there an over the counter equivilant to viagra will two 10 mg cialis equal 20 mg zovirax boots uk ricetta medica cialis online temazepam 20 mg bijsluiter cialis procerin vs propecia reviews side can lasix cause uti clomid ovulation calculator online retinal specialists in surprise az bird antibiotics doxycycline finasteride 1mg mexico cialis generico es fiable ciprofloxacino 250 mg via oral how to take prednisone 4 mg for 6 day pack ciprofloxacin hcl 250 mg tab para que sirve cialis 5 mg how long until it takes effect how long does liquid zithromax stay good viagra ireland boards herbal viagra uk cheap buy viagra over the counter australia metformin hcl 500 mg versus metformin buy claravis accutane discount how much is nolvadex in india price why use clomid for pct clomid test ovulation Kiwipolitico » media bias
Posts Tagged ‘media bias’

Poll dancing

datePosted on 20:51, November 10th, 2011 by Lew

Chris Trotter suggests that frequent and heavily-publicised polls favour the right and result in a self-fulfilling prophecy, depressing support for the left. Bomber Bradbury has made similar arguments in the past.

There are two parts to this: first, the question of whether polls are inaccurate vis-a-vis the actual views of the electorate, and if so whether they do in fact favour the right; and second, whether this, on its own, has a substantive impact on actual real-world support.

Lyndon Hood FTW

I am aware of no robust research on this topic in the NZ context (which isn’t to say that it doesn’t exist; although if it did I’d expect the many proponents of this line of argument to be citing it all day long.) So to kick off, let me concede that if there was a significant ideological bias to the polls it certainly could have an impact on voter behaviour. But I suspect any impact would be more complicated than the simple “low showing for a party causes low turnout and/or low support” reading of the “spiral of silence” model Chris cites (which is nevertheless a useful model). For one thing, it’s not clear that the impact is very strong in case of a secret ballot; also, the argument doesn’t take into account New Zealanders’ oft-cited peeriness about single-party majority governments in the wake of Muldoon, Lange and Bolger which could have a moderating effect, and it doesn’t take into consideration the usual “narrowing” that occurs in the latter stages of an election campaign as wavering voters begin to make up their minds. So I doubt the size of this effect on Labour’s polling at least; any shift should not be large, and certainly not sufficient to change the election outcome. However where NZ First is concerned it’s different — a percentage point or two makes all the difference in the world there, and whether NZ First returns to parliament or not rests on the collective spirit of Winston’s faithful. Assuming they still make up fiveish per cent of the voting population they must not waver, and must cast their votes together regardless of what they are told about the polls. If they fail to do so NZ First is out, and all those votes are wasted, and that is certainly an outcome that could result from widespread reporting of polls that show NZ First under the threshold (and one that could change the election outcome).

Note, however, that all that is contingent on those polls showing NZ First to be under the threshold actually being wrong. I’m not persuaded of this, and I’m also dubious about the contention that polls favour the right. As Bomber is fond of pointing out, the polls run in the leadup to the Auckland Supercity election favoured John Banks, while in the election Len Brown won handsomely. That’s important to remember, but it’s only one data point so I’m hesitant to draw meaningful conclusions from it, and if it’s evidence of anything, it’s against the simple reading of the “Spiral of Silence” thesis, according to which Brown’s demoralised supporters should have stayed home.

There is also some evidence out of the US to suggest that landline-only polls favour the Republican party over the Democrats (when compared to polling samples that include cellphones). It’s not clear is that this trend is also in effect in New Zealand. Based on no data, I think it has some influence, but our situation here differs in important ways; most notably, we have more than two parties so variance of this sort is more dilute and less zero-sum. And the likely effect would be ambivalent — if landline-only polls tend to exclude the young and the poor and tech-savvy urban liberals, they should overstate support for NZ First, not understate it.

The matter of bias isn’t readily testable because, as an Australian poll analyst put it recently when looking at bias between pollsters in that market, “we just don’t have elections every week to determine the true state of public opinion“.* There is also evidence to suggest that people’s voting behaviour differs in important ways from how they answer opinion polls. So we need to rely on other forms of measurement; proxies being measured against proxies. There are focus-groups, vox pop interviews and 75c text-polls and coffee-bean polls, and the Horizon poll with its radically different weighting system, but I see no firm grounds to believe any of these would be any more reliable than the major phone poll companies. One very strong point in favour of the usual sort of phone-based opinion polling is that it has remained more or less methodologically consistent for a very long time. This gives us extremely large, continuous datasets that we can plot against real-world events including policy releases, major speeches, current events and elections. In this regard they are much like audience/circulation ratings in the media. The utility of these well-established systems isn’t that they have no flaws — they certainly do, and much of the criticism is valid — it’s that they have a reasonably well-known set of flaws that are consistent over time, and we can use the historical record to make inferences about the present day (too few people, I think, are actually doing this, but that’s a different matter). By contrast other systems — Horizon, in particular — are less well-known, and serious questions need to be asked about the quality of their results. They’re worth watching, but they are not as yet a substitute for what we already have.

Returning to the argument. So if the polls systematically favour the right, and if they do so in such a way as doesn’t also favour NZ First’s older, wealthier and more conservative demographic, and if the extent of that bias is significant enough to have a significant zero-sum election night impact despite all the confounding variables of voter behaviour, then Chris might be right.

But that’s a lot of ifs, and a claim as bold as “polling companies and the media steal elections from the left” demands extremely robust evidence to be given credence. I’m open to the argument, but what we have here isn’t evidence, much less the robust kind; it’s supposition, and what’s more it’s supposition derived from partisan loyalty. The argument is unfalsifiable — if the election does deliver a substantial defeat to Labour and NZ First they will take that as proof-positive that they were right all along and the voters were robbed; if it doesn’t no doubt they will cheer those who battled valiantly and overcame the oppressive regime imposed by the forces of evil. In this regard the argument is nearly indistinguishable from that made in 2008 by the Free Speech Coalition who, despite their howls about Stalinist restrictions on political marketing, managed to help their political representatives to a handy win.

My view of Chris and Bomber’s general line of argument is that it’s more of the usual excuse-making and blame-shifting that I see from lefties who can’t bear that their tribe is staring down the barrel of a(nother) heavy defeat. It’s an attempt to make the evil media cabal responsible for poor performance, and to minimise the effect of weak leadership, institutional incompetence, lacklustre campaign and — in Peters’ case — public self-immolation during the last term. It’s a myth; something to keep the faithful warm at night, in the absence of actual victory. Myths certainly have a kernel of essential truth, but they should not be mistaken for evidence. Moreover, as regards Chris’ concerns about the election accurately reflecting voters’ wishes; these would have more credibility if his own history of respecting the solemn integrity of electoral politics was itself less one-eyed. He thunders:

hundreds-of-thousands of New Zealanders will not only be perfectly entitled to say “bugger the pollsters”, but they will also be entirely justified in asserting that the election has been stolen from them

This would ring less hollow if, following the 2005 election, he had not so cravenly excused the Labour party’s own admitted breach of electoral law as being “acceptable corruption” inasmuch as it served the greater ideological purpose of preventing National from being elected. Given that history, his complaints about polling and media conduct look like nothing more than an appeal to ideological tribalism with a bright red smear of electoral integrity lipstick on.

And yet, he has a strong point: if NZ First’s share of the party vote on November 26 comes in fractionally below the 5% threshold, democracy will have been poorly served in 2011, as it was in 2008. My personal views of that party aside, as a matter of natural justice anyone commanding a twentieth of the vote should be entitled to roughly a twentieth of the representation in Parliament. But however unsexy it might be, the solution to this isn’t injustice to attack the pollsters or the media. The argument isn’t supported by the evidence; even if it was nobody’s going to change on Chris and Bomber’s say-so, and we all saw what happened to the Clark government’s regulatory overreach. The pragmatic response here is to work towards reducing or removing the electoral threshold so as to ensure that natural justice is served and variance is less likely to simply exclude a party from representation, and to turn back to the process of returning political rigour to the political left by building competence, vision and leadership so it can succeed despite the obstacles before it. Less myth, more reality.

L

* Pollytics’ analysis plots polling companies against each other, measuring each pollster’s bias from the other polling companies. David Winter has had a go at doing something similar for the NZ context, though he has much less data to work with. While interesting, it’s important to reiterate that none of this addresses the concerns about poll accuracy vis-a-vis the electorate.)

Cruel irony: partisans and the media

datePosted on 21:25, November 5th, 2011 by Lew

Here’s a thing I don’t get. Lefty partisans (in New Zealand and elsewhere) are overwhelmingly convinced that the Main Stream Media is:

  • Run by a shadowy cabal of Dr Evil types whose main goal is to bring the political right to power and keep them there;
  • Obsessed with prurience, trivia, conflict (falsified or trumped-up if necessary), outrage and scandal to the total exclusion of “serious” topics like policy;
  • So credulous as to be unable (or so captured as to be unwilling) to distinguish between competing accounts of differing veracity, reporting all opinions as nominally equal;
  • Selective, punishing the left more harshly than the right; and
  • All of the above is strongly contributing to the decline of civilisation as we know it.

The right believes much the same, just with a different polarity.

And yet, despite these deeply-held beliefs, partisans on both sides react with shock and dismay whenever the terrible old Emm Ess Emm lives up to these expectations. They wail and they gnash their teeth, but they don’t adopt (and don’t require their political representatives to adopt) strategies to deny the Emm Ess Emm the opportunity to fulfil this brief, or to force it into “responsible coverage” mode, and they refuse to acknowledge any responsibility for giving the Emm Ess Emm exactly what it needs to do exactly what it does.

Seriously. As a political movement, the more you believe all of that list — and in general, the lower your opinion of the media — the more you should be obsessed with ensuring that your strategy is freaking watertight so you don’t fall foul of it. Moreover, if you believe the last point (that it’s hastening the end of the world) you should be all the more committed to getting into power so as to implement reforms that will change this state of affairs.

But enthusiastic adherence to these beliefs correlates strongly with a poor understanding of the function of the media and how it works in reality. So those most exercised by the media’s obvious bias against their team are those least able to remedy it. Because they don’t understand the system, they tend to misdiagnose the problem. Having misunderstood the problem they are unable to respond strategically, and the typical result is inchoate fury.

L

One man’s terrorist…

datePosted on 08:54, March 2nd, 2011 by Lew

Via Thomas Beagle, the following astonishing story:

In Libya, an unlikely hero of a youth-led revolution
BENGHAZI, LIBYA – Mehdi Mohammed Zeyo was the most unlikely of revolutionary heroes. The bespectacled 49-year-old worked in the supplies department of the state-owned oil company. He was a diabetic with two teenage daughters.
But something snapped inside him as a youth-led uprising in Libya against the government of Moammar Gaddafi quickly turned bloody.
[…]
On the morning of Feb. 20, he walked down the stairs of his apartment building with a gas canister hoisted on his shoulder, witnesses said. He put two canisters inside his trunk of his car, along with a tin can full of gunpowder. Driving toward the base, he flashed the victory sign to the young men protesting outside and hit the gas pedal.
Gaddafi’s security forces sprayed his black car with bullets, setting off a powerful explosion, witnesses said. The blast tore a hole in the base’s front gate, allowing scores of young protesters and soldiers who had defected to stream inside. That night, the opposition won the battle for the base, and for Benghazi, as Gaddafi’s forces retreated.
[…]
Zeyo had left a will listing the debts he owed so that they could be paid, but Hafidh said the community and the company where Zeyo worked would take care of his family. On Zeyo’s desk Monday was a printed piece of paper pasted to the computer screen.
“We are from God and we return to God,” it said.
At home, his wife put her head down.
“We had no sons to carry on his name. But this is how God works, and now his name is written in history,” she said.

That was published in the Washington Post, and syndicated to the front page of the international news section of today’s Dominion Post. Read the whole thing, it’s worth your time.

Then try to re-imagine this story if the protagonist was an uneducated working-class youth from the Palestinian Occupied Territories, rural Afghanistan or the Iran-Iraq borderlands.

L

On media bias and distortion

datePosted on 23:58, August 2nd, 2009 by Lew

BK Drinkwater has posted a good response to some of the comments on Bryce Edwards’ synopses of chapters from the book Informing Voters? Politics, Media and the New Zealand Election 2008 (edited by Chris Rudd, Janine Hayward and Geoff Craig of the University of Otago Politics department). In comments to BK’s post, Eric Crampton recommended Groseclose & Milyo‘s paper on the topic. Having not read the book, I’ll constrain my comments to the posts, comments and paper which I have read.

[Apologies, this is a long and dry post on a topic very dear to my heart. I also banged it up in a spare couple of hours while I ought to have been sleeping, and haven’t proofed it, so it may be incoherent. I reserve the right to subedit it without notice. The rest is over the break.]

Read the rest of this entry »

The BSA has upheld a complaint against TVNZ’s Breakfast on the grounds of balance after it allowed Garth McVicar the free and unopposed opportunity to rant about sentencing.

Complainant Roger Brooking argued that the programme privileged “the reactionary views of an unqualified right wing individual as if he was the oracle on sentencing law”, and that the show’s hosts were unduly sympathetic toward him. The authority upheld the complaint on the grounds that Breakfast producers and interviewers failed to challenge or question McVicar’s “controversial” views, simply accepting them at face value, and internalising them for use as a frame for viewer responses.

This is an excellent decision, for a couple of reasons. First, it reinforces the expectation that the media have a responsibility not to naïvely accept the statements of their commentators or interviewees; that the interview process ought to be adversarial. Secondly, it provides a line in the sand as to what constitutes a controversial topic of public discourse, by implicitly agreeing with Brooking’s characterisation of McVicar and his pronouncements. It goes counter to some previous decisions, such as the rather alarming case last year in which the authority effectively declared that talkback was legitimately a balance-free zone.

L

Shame on who?

datePosted on 15:07, April 2nd, 2009 by Lew

This image is attached to the Stuff story on the death of a protester during the G20 protests in London:

shame-crop

(Screenshot)

I know I’m not alone in noticing that since Stuff remodeled itself on the SMH that they’ve cranked up the alarm-o-meter somewhat, and this is an excellent example. A few facts are clear from the linked story, and a rudimentary bit of reading around reflects some others, to wit:

  1. The person who died during the protest was a man, not a pretty woman who happened to pose for the camera at the time. The shot was chosen purely because it’s a good image.
  2. The man apparently died of natural causes, not a bleeding head wound.
  3. The unstated `you’ in the headline of this image is the riot police. However the man who died was not killed by police or as any consequence of violence in the protest; in fact, protesters pelted police with bottles as they tried to resuscitate him.

This should serve as one more bit of evidence that the media are not intrinsically biased for or against anyone in particular – they follow the story, and in some cases they lead it, for their own purposes rather than those of their masters in transnational capital.

Edit: My mum points out that the composition evokes Brian Brake’s famous Monsoon Girl.

Edit 20090408: Commenter Rich has linked to footage of police attacking Ian Tomlinson just before he died, here. If it’s real and legitimate, and there’s no reason to assume it isn’t, then it more or less invalidates my objections 2 and 3 above. Objection 1 stands, for what little that’s worth.

L