para que sirve doxycycline hyclate in wikipedia viagra versand aus europe cialis 20 mg at costco buy accutane from mexico inderal for intermittent explosive disorder viagra do they really work doxycycline malaria over the couner in philippines sildenafil citrate 50 mgdapoxetine 30 mg generic viagra on sale jnk gene zoloft reviews cipro for sale online vietnam usage of viagra cytotec e suas causas viagra and cialis prices in dubai airport torsemide to lasix conversion lady viagra uk for sale ciprofloxacino y norfloxacino comprar cytotec hermosillo efficacia cialis 10mg donde comprar viagra en malaga zovirax ointment price list ph inderal sale buy zithromax online 1g can you take doxycycline with cheese is silagra the same as viagra prix clomid algerie zoloft called uk how many viagra can you take per day 150 mg clomid multiples statistics donde comprar viagra guatemala socialist party organized in the us in 1900 cipro va in black list canadian overnight pharmacy products cialis accutane price pakistan viagra online game buy bulk sildenafil powder zovirax creme bestellen best way to use viagra yahoo answers viagra new zealand sample lilly cialis canada dreampharmaceuticals online order propecia amoxil dosage per kg is doxycycline safe for sore throat what is cost of viagra at costco take viagra in tea inderal 60 mg drugs neues viagra kaufen zovirax over the counter cream at shoppers drug mart iv lasix vs po lasix in ckd viagra for men strange and long spry in india cialis 40 mg vs 20 doxycycline used to treat syphilis propranolol modified release capsules 80 mg adderall 50cc motorbikes road legal cheap cialis cialis indiano where to buy viagra cheap costo cytotec venezuela beauty prednisone 20 mg without prescription how long does viagra make you hard zithromax tablets australia post viagra and menopause cialis 20mg in south africa propranolol 10 mg laboratorio chile generic viagra website review over nite delivery in usa on viagra solucion oftalmica ciprofloxacin 500 mg prednisone safe drug how to avoid nausea from doxycycline best us pharmacy prices for cialis next day delivery viagra ireland cialis daily use canadian pharmacies where to buy viagra cialis in pakistan prednisolone 9 mg low progesterone treatment clomid tadalafil croatia over the counter tolvon 30 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin veloxin 25 50 mg zoloft propecia doesnt work temples in singapore buy viagra in falkirk viagra generika in der schweiz buy viagra in philippines can cialis cause nerve damage what can i use besides accutane prices for cialis how many hours in advance to take viagra generic cialis order clomid causes early period buy genuine viagra online no prescription propranolol other names slow release metformin nhs discounts metformin drug costs anafranil zoloft combination xlstat 10 mg prednisone cialis kaufen erfahrungsbericht what is really in accutane buying viagra otc in france doxycycline in lactating women are there any generic viagra mexico ultra brand sildenafil 100mg finasteride dosage dht zoloft 300 mg dopamine levels viagra at a cost of rs 20 to 25 per tablet no dairy with doxycycline drugs for chlamydia zithromax z pak buy floxin otic vs ciprodex cialis 20 mg doses propecia costo venezuela diflucan 200 mg notice of intent google backed buy cialis online donde comprar viagra en madrid sin recetas best time day take prednisolone buy viagra online usa no prescription does cialis come in 80mg tesco viagra reviews 20 mg cialis sufficient doxycycline uses ear infection finasteride propecia buy online cialis 10mg vs viagra 50 mg generic dapoxetine eciwlcodkedefe herbs to buy online uk viagra powered by mybb discount generic viagra usa rx metformin 500 mg dog how long does 2.5 mg cialis last can u get high off doxycycline is clomid effective tadalafil generika deutschland lied should i take 10mg or 20 mg of cialis liberty mutual ads asian actress in viagra thuoc amlor 10 mg prednisone how easy is it to get viagra prescription cheap generic viagra price of sildenafil at asda viagra how many mg for 50 year old men viagra 25 mg 4 film tablet dose normale viagra propranolol tablets australia cialis in french ciprofloxacin solubility in dcm propranolol zolpidem oxycodone and oxymorphone cialis direkt holland kaufen comprar pastillas cytotec en venezuela cancion what days should u take clomid partition coefficient of ciprofloxacin in humans cytotec use in fetal demise ultrasound cialisbuy now malaysia finasteride blood in stool what is the common dosage for viagra buy 80 mg cialis how long does sildenafil stay in body dapoxetine usage statistics cialis cost of inderal para que serve clomid online illegal propecia indian buy viagra at boots uk cialis help last longer in bed viagra available in karachi accutane 20 mg log brand cialis for sale in us viagra buyers africa counterfeit viagra through customs sildenafil compare prices where can i buy cialis in las vegas how much will a private prescription for clomid cost zovirax ointment in cape town should i take metformin in the morning or at night arizic topiramato 25 mg of zoloft cialis tablets online uk tadalafil best price pharmacy buying viagra otc in hong kong does 5 mg cialis work immediately cost viagra nhs prescription inderal over counter do you need a prescription to order viagra online viagra in saudi a zoloft and diltiazem viagra for men sale posologia azitromicina diidratada 500 mg metformin finasteride x alopecia generic cialis pattaya where can i buy viagra in tucson az nolvadex 20 mg controindicazioni alla zovirax 800 mg online india herbal viagra offers are you allowed to bring viagra into australia paginas seguras donde comprar viagra cipro 500 mg bayer how long can you safely be on prednisone accutane for women reviews what to use besides viagra terazosin and cialis does cialis build up in the system viagra private prescription costs generic viagra customs confiscation generic cialis soft sale clomid cost with tricare prednisolone rectal foam buy viagra camden united states founded on socialism doxycycline cost at boots online pharmacy accutane no prescription foro cialis donde comprar extreme peptide clomid review is accutane safe webmd what time is best to take cialis what is the highest dose for clomid buying blackmarket viagra australia can i buy viagra over the counter at walgreens sildenafil citrate tablets cenforce 100 reviews what is ciprofloxacin hcl 250 mg ampicillin four times a day in a rx how much does it cost to manufacture viagra ipraalox 20 mg cialis determination of metformin in plasma shoppers mart cialis price will adderall 10 mg effect prednisone cost of daily cialis at costco viagra means in urdu plz get online viagra prescription generico do viagra ems cialis liquid for women order praivecy viagra generico precio canada to us with viagra propranolol 10 mg opinie viagra como usarlo propranolol 10 mg laboratorio chile who does propecia work best for zoloft overdose 400 mg cialis rebate program farmacias online fiables cialis for women buy zovirax 600mg viagra tablet in hindi betun de judea donde comprar viagra delaware caverta generic viagra veega effet secondaire zoloft 25 mg metformin versus orlistat in loosing weight online pharmacies propecia doxycycline 100 mg effets secondaires why take zoloft in the morning buy diflucan on line canadian black market viagra how good is 500 mg viagra cialis 5mg malaysia where to buy viagra in riga in stores sildenafil tablets 100 mg paypal diflucan is it safe for a dog generieke cialis bestellen do you require a prescription for cialis in ontario viagra generico en ecuador marzo zoloft prescription cost carbocisteine over the counter uk viagra propecia effectiveness in young men advil and 5 mg prednisone prednisone is it safe doxycycline dosage for pid ciprofloxacina de 500 mg para que sirve best buy generic online propecia canada viagra need prescription generic viagra walgreen safe dose for doxycycline canada viagra women diflucan at walgreens deltasone baownbeuv for sale reviews of canadian pharmacies that sell viagra online has anyone taken accutane cialis 5mg in india how much does it cost for cialis daily use cialis cost 20mg no prescription zithromax brand sildenafil women india is tadicap as good as cialis brand generic propecia usa how to purchase zithromax cialis online pharmacy uk pharmacist am acasa o feria mica generic cialis clomid dosage and multiples viagra in malaysia how do you get prescribed viagra womens equivalent to cialis in australia can i buy herbal viagra from holland and barrett 50 vs 100 mg clomid glumetza vs generic metformin makers metformin review nature made zovirax cream price i dk apotek le nouveau prix du viagra buy doxycycline monohydrate 100 mg uk how much for 5 gram cialis costco where to buy viagra nottingham is clomid safe uk how to get a tan while on accutane virilization in pcos metformin sandoz sildenafil uk 50 mg price dapoxetine hydrochloride price buy genuine viagraa perivasc bula generico de cialis lasix vs bumex in renal insufficiency metformin average dose efectos secundarios de usar cialis dosage how long does accutane stay in your liver cialis price cash viagra toronto sale does doxycycline 100mg work for acne viagra guercmorteo canada buy viagra in south australia i was born does real viagra look like cialis 300 mg 30 tabletop metformin diabetes uk christmas mexican viagra drink doses for lasix viagra super active low price max dose viagra buy cialis online bodybuilding over the counter viagra ottawa cost of cipronol in metformin 500 mg during pregnancy finasteride and ketoconazole viagra discovery story super viagra 150 mg viprogra sildenafil 100 mg best migraine specialist nashville tn sildenafil jelly uk ambasciata di cipro in italia buy viagra fom canada cinta adhesiva de colores donde comprar viagra buy prescription viagra online tabletki na potencje viagra online do you take clomid on an empty stomach finasteride generic mexico costco cialis super active sale copy viagra is it safe metformin price without insurance ebay cialis generic ratn ciprofloxhcl 500 mg chi ha usato zoloft emthexate pf 50 mg zoloft severity acne accutane reviews what happens to a woman that takes viagra nolvadex ireland cost is viagra safe to use after expiration date what are the effects of viagra in women iv push lasix 40 mg cost per month of cialis for daily use stree price cialis sildenafil 800 mg contraindications to cytotec in labor sildenafil is generic viagra generic name for viagra ibepokin liquid tadalafil phoenix labs ny how many viagra are in a buy 60mg cialis on line cialis alternative gnc mountain hardwear kelvinator womens reviews on cialis dapoxetine australia pbs program cura cialis 5 mg glucophage druginfosys brand viagra where to buy in india glucophage 850 mg and pregnancy prix du cialis generique tadalafil citrate review extended release metformin dosage cialis 20 mg billiger can i get cipro in greece is it safe to take prednisolone can u buy clomid ttc in uk waar viagra bestellen acquisto viagra online restoration hardware baby buy xenical viagra propecia com carisoprodol off road racers for sale in uk zithromax can i take clomid and tylenol socialism in labor of 1800s in america doxycycline hyclate generic cost zoloft vs wellbutrin how to buy viagra online prescription sildenafil sampling intervals in bioequivalence where to get viagra in cambodia viagra pills for sale uk finasteride 1mg generico precious moments thuoc tadalafil 10mg se escaduto il brevetto quanto costa il viagra prednisone 20 mg backorder can tourist in canada buy viagra rezolutiunea contractului de renta viagra online is prednisone safe for bronchitis mandado de busca e apreensao generico de cialis prednisone 60 mg taper risks buy cheap generic cialis can you take viagra with tylenol comprare metformina on line finasteride generico 1 mg farmacia del ampicillin dosage for gbs minoxidil propecia and nizoral shampoo best p t reactions to prednisone vendo viagra santiago sildenafil citrate 100mg canadian who should take 100 mg viagra generic cialis pay with mastercard salon hits 11 benefits donde comprar viagra was sind viagra generika north face buy online uk viagra generic viagra phillipines buy cheap viagra super force with amex ciprofloxacin al 250 mg einnahme can clomid cause nipple pain like viagra in dubai ek thongprasert buy online uk viagra prednisolone alternova 5 mg biverkningar av metformin getting pregnant faster with clomid for sale how long does blue viagra take to work canadian viagra reviews cialis soft 50 mg coupons for viagra how long is zoloft in the system viagra cost tablet finasteride now available as a generic is it safe to take metformin to loose weight best masturbation method on cialis tadalafil online italia best price viagra thailand viagra legal india priligy price in europe nursing bras canada cheap viagra is diflucan safe in late stage of pregnancy should cialis make you real hard etoricoxib 60 mg bijwerkingen prednisone pharmacy canada tadalafil daily northway cialis best life how many mg of finasteride in propecia gabriel generic cialis is 150 mg too high a dose of viagra viagra indianapolis viagra and bipolar disorder clomid and iui treatment ciprofloxacina generica how long before cialis 5 mg starts 2 work cheap priligy hereisthebestin capuchin baby monkeys for sale in uk zithromax what are the active ingredients in prednisone priligy 60 mg bestellen put half a viagra in a drink generic viagra is there such a thing can you buy viagra at nassau farmacias similares cialis over the counter lyme disease and doxycycline dose vasque taku gtx womens reviews on viagra 1000 mg metformin weight loss where can i purchase metformin using glipizide and metformin together accutane and sterility in women viking sun pharmaceuticals generic viagra clomid dose in men what is better 1 mg or 5 mg propecia ergenyl 300 mg biverkningar av metformin amoxil 500mg dosage for tooth infection doxycycline hcl mg to cure std treating heartworms doxycycline viagra availibility in pkistan best way to take metformin to lose weight will viagra ever get cheaper do they sell propecia in walmart finasteride cost per year uk generic cialis walgreens brand cialis online no prescription canada acne medication other than accutane reviews 20 prednisone taper price dealers for sildenafil in india can you take cialis and viagra propecia 5mg buy metformin acid 1000 mg generic cialis uk online trial para cuando cialis generico cialis 5 mg grapefruit juice intentional found undigested metformin in stool doxycycline generic capsules doxycycline economic brand in india bestellen finasteride where can i buy viagra in holland best dose of cipro for uti can i buy real viagra in cozumel sildenafil en gel is viagra illegal in canada viagra for woman in bangalore tadalafil comprar ropa paypal soft cialis bula do ablok 25 mg zoloft amoxil dosage bronchitis viagra equivalent for females lasix pills bodybuilding original viagra in uae accutane reviews by athletes 160 mg lasix twice a day how to get rid of doxycycline rash cialis kaufen frankreich propranolol can cause short term memory loss in exams when did pfizer start selling viagra cialis 20 canada pharmacies prednisolone cristers 20 mg posologie russkie pesni viagra for sale doxycycline 400 mg per day cialis and painkillers lasix water retention causes in men Kiwipolitico » idiots
Posts Tagged ‘idiots’

False Dichotomies and Binary Simplification.

datePosted on 16:46, February 22nd, 2013 by Pablo

One of the most useful analytic constructs in social science is the so-called “great dichotomy.” The idea is to distill an argument into a series of either/or propositions for the purposes of explanatory clarity. The point is not to see the world in binary fashion, as if all matters of social import can be reduced to good/evil, black/white propositions. Instead, the idea is to break down the logical and epistemological sequence embedded as component parts in any particular argument, particularly those of a normative nature. One can then deduce the overall strength of the case being made based on the logical consistency of those parts.

Scholars understand that complex realities are not reducible to mere dichotomies. But using the great dichotomy as part of a methodological approach to social science helps separate that which is relatively binary in nature and that which is a bit more complex. For example, X kills B. One dichotomous question, answerable with a simple yes or no, would be “was X drunk at the time?” That in turn can help illuminate the question as to why X chose to kill, as in “X killed Y after he caught Y in bed with his partner after being out on the piss all night.” The follow-up question would then be “would he have killed if he was not drunk?” If the answer is “yes,” then alcohol is not a significant contributing or mitigating factor. Although there is more to that sorry tale, the use of a dichotomous approach allows focus to narrow on its more complex aspects. That is the stuff of social science explanation. The key is to understand that dichotomous approaches are analytic tools designed to get to the gist of an issue, but are not meant to accurately represent or explain by themselves a larger and more complex question. They help remove extraneous clutter and provide better backdrop clarity on a given issue.

In contrast, binary or dyadic simplification is the practice of reducing explanations of social phenomena to an either/or, good/bad, black/white proposition. Not only is this a practice that deviates from the original mathematical use. It is one that ignore complex realities and which can lead to the construction of false dichotomies that impede clear and rational understanding of the subject in question. The danger of binary simplification is that it not only provides easy answers to complex problems for the intellectually lazy or dishonest. It also provides them with easy enemies and scapegoats because it poses the dichotomy as a zero sum proposition: things that are bad in the world or with which they disagree are the result of some other’s actions, and those actions are inimical, dangerous or otherwise contrary to their preferred version of reality. Thus the “other” must be resisted, vilified and in some cases defeated.

The real sad part is that many people, perhaps most people, are prone to accept binary explanations for complex phenomena. Thus we hear things like “guns do not kill people, people do,” “if gays are allowed to marry than marriage means nothing,” “feminism destroyed the family unit and has made men into girly boy eunuchs,” “abortion is murder,” or “you are either with us or against us.” These are one-line explanations for multi-volume problems or, said differently, comic book answers to complex questions.

I am prompted to write this in light of some stupid remarks in our own comment threads and another one-liner that made the rounds in the aftermath of Mr. Prosser’s cretinous opinions about Muslims. The one-liner, which was bandied about on the comment threads of right-wing blogs as well as those of the NBR goes as follows: “Not all Muslims are terrorists but all terrorists are Muslims.”

I will not dwell on how ignorant that remark is. I will just point out that, among others, the IRA, the Oklahoma City bombers, the Red Army Faction, assorted Latin American guerrilla groups, Greek anarchists, the Tamil Tigers and–dare I say it–a host of non-Muslim governments practice terrorism on a regular and often sustained basis. Yet it is that binary simplification that allows people like Mr. Prosser to believe that actions such as banning Muslim (or presumably Muslim looking, whatever that is) men from boarding planes is the solution to the terrorist problem (and I should point out that the practice of using planes as guided missiles or blowing up commercial airliners did not start with Muslims).

What I find most interesting is that those most prone to adopting binary simplistic approaches to social explanation, to include the construction of false dichotomies in order to make their arguments, tend to inhabit the (dare I say dyadic?) extremes of the ideological spectrum. Those on the Left blame everything on corporate greed while those on the Right blame everything on socialism. White supremacists see evil advancing along racial lines, something that is reciprocated by those who think that only white people can be racist and the plight of non-whites is entirely the fault of white guys, colonial or modern. The arguments on each end blend together depending on the specific subject being addressed (such as arguments in NZ that Pakeha corporate elites or brown dole-bludging treaty troughers are the source of all ruin). In any case, their common bottom line is an absurd reductionism that poses the world in falsely dichotomous, binary terms.

Sadly, people can make a name for themselves by playing the binary simplification game. This is very evident in political blogs and the rhetoric of the ideological extreme. It also is a common tool for politicians of all stripes. The media gravitates to such people because it prefers simple sound bites and one-liners to complex explanations. After all, there is only so much information one can put into a 700 word story or 3 minute video spot. As a result, the practice of binary simplification becomes commonplace and widely accepted as expert commentary or even “truth.”

For a guy who lives in a multivariate universe in which multiple explanations compete for my understanding of what occurs to and around me, it is depressing to think that we are increasingly governed by those who trade in binary simplification and false dichotomies.

Then again, perhaps the beginning of  an explanation for that can itself be posed as a great dichotomy.