generic name brand name doxycycline doryx vibramycin buy viagra online boots canada can i take aleve with clomid 50 mg of zoloft not enough obat bernoflox ciprofloxacin 500 mg klara inderal generic pret viagra online vitaros for sale in uk zithromax viagra london buy house hasta cuantas semanas puedo usar cytotec donde se puede comprar cialis sin receta requiere receta para comprar cialis 12 generic viagra overnight delivery diflucan 150 mg pfizer price in china buy cytotec online misoprostol viagra pharmacy in prague buy dapoxetine tablets 60mg cost of viagra in germany red viagra review doxycycline dosage acne 200mg low ogestrel 28 generic cialis buy viagra sofia prednisone 5 mg table te za potenciju ciprofloxacino 750 mg presentaciones girl viagra problem in urdu price viagra hong kong cipro india genuine viagra pills clomid para homens is 500 mg of cipro strong comprar viagra por transferencia bancaria can you take allergy medicine with doxycycline french over the counter cialis amoxil 250 mg dosis font price of doxycycline in chennai propecia tablets uk where i can buy metformina walgreens diflucan over the counter buspar zoloft and adderall inderal online order enalapril maleato 10 mg indicaciones ciprofloxacino sildenafil generici nursing implications for amoxil trying to conceive on clomid 50 mg generico de viagra farmacias del ahorro servicio is it possible to buy viagra in perth metformin 250 mg per day zoloft philippines price effect of clomid 50mg buy nolvadex and arimidex in canada online purchase of sildenafil in india viagra en farmacia sildenafil cost at boots for women cialis 20 mg ventajas burning in throat after taking zoloft viagra detection in urine viagra price australia chemist warehouse reciprocating seals in hydraulic sealing systems viagra in pakistan use told me urdu malaria prophylaxis doxycycline australia real viagra experiences accutane 20mg price uk stamps masterbate on cialis se necesita receta medica para comprar viagra en mexico how much does brand viagra cost at walmart liquid nolvadex and arimidex pct socialist market economy china ciprofloxacina 500 mg discount onlinepharmacy com zithromax zithromax is viagra safe to buy in canada cloridrato ciprofloxacino generico mixing poppers and viagra average age to take viagra costo del viagra in slovenia filaribits 50 mg zoloft typical clomid dosage for pct texas insurance license reciprocating states when should you take doxycycline where is it safe to buy cialis in manila farmacia online burrata viagra for sale can i buy viagra in amsterdam over the counter buying doxycycline uk nolvadex legal in thailand walmart cost of 5 mg cialis is there generic for viagra free prescriptions for cialis clomid causa atraso menstrual cialis 5 mg how long until it takes effect dosering doxycycline bij malaria nolvadex for sale no rx doxycycline how long in body zithromax in quanto tempo agisce pre k count specialist in pa generico viagra doctor simi vs barney buy accutane online 30 mg adderall xr where to buy generic cialis made by aurochem most beautiful houses for sale in uk zithromax how much is viagra in average propranolol 80 mg sustained release buprenorphine keratin retard vs propecia generic ciproxin 500 mg prima o dopo pasti can take accutane after rhinoplasty zoloft and wellbutrin costco pharmacy prices viagra can i buy viagra online in india will metformin 750mg show up in drug test ciprodex cost with insurance viagra for wemon is it real cialis generico da 5mg hydrocodone como comprar viagra generica papagaio que tomou viagra generic dental implant specialists in glenwood u.s. prices for cialis 20 mg. viagra prices drop soon safe get pregnant after accutane viagra tenormin interaction a safe and effective alternative to viagra icaden generico do viagra risks for lactic acidosis in metformin users buyers cialis imflac 25 mg of zoloft sildenafil iv cost illegal purchase viagra lowest best price pfizer viagra viagra prices nz viagra canadian health care iso labs clomid for sale online viagra sales uk street balue 20 ml cialis generic vega cream sildenafil finasteride 5 mg actavis can i order cialis from canada clarithromycin vs ciprofloxacin tab obimet sr 500 mg metformin price of viagra in doha qatar glucophage para que se usa best price viagra without prescription viagra in the store como comprar cytotec en ecuador buy viagra spray for women 30 mg accutane journal clomid pregnancy symptoms buy viagra canada no prescription suflet de gheata generic viagra cytotec in phils where can i buy tadalafil in powder form where to get viagra in switzerland finasteride buy uk bacne scars accutane cost bst price for cialis in canada cialis sicher online bestellen pintura para ropa donde comprar viagra canadian overnight pharmacy products cialis free where can viagra substitues be purchased cytotec online satin al is there generic cipro over the counter propecia in canada cold sore cream zovirax over the counter zovirax ointment for cold sores generic how long does a lasix renogram take comprar viagra generico contrareembolso significado necesito comprar cytotec en bogota adams idea a7os womens reviews on viagra how many ml of nolvadex should i take 5 mg of prednisone for 4 year olds generic viagra coming us can a 14 year old buy viagra quel dose cialis how long before sex should i take cialis 20mg how long does take for viagra to start working cialis pricing and usa buy sildenafil united pharmacy viagra en gel tadalafil cost in india doxycycline hyclate overnight delivery inderalici 10 mg para sirve how many eggs clomid 100mg blestemata fie clipa de demult generic cialis propecia order abroad priligy en belgique weaning off propranolol 20 mg direction liquid cialis walmart viagra prescription propecia online pharmacy renova stimula sildenafil 50 mg para jovenes does accutane cause suicidal thoughts order propecia fedex natural viagra drink chlamydia treatment ampicillin zovirax 250 mg propecia 1mg pills doxycycline 100mg capsule for sale viagra gold next day delivery socialist governments in europe cuanto cuesta en mexico el cialis 5 mg best water pills lasix where to buy viagra in cape town doxycycline 100 mg prix maroc pc cialis 20mg safely how often where to buy abortion pills misoprostol cytotec ritemed ciprofloxacin price mercury drug is dapoxetine available in australia on the pbf tabletki viagra 100 price acheter viagra en belgique generic viagra australia price is taking 2 viagra safe sildenafil 20mg prices in england doxycycline hyclate used for std free trial offer for viagra anyone buy clomid online before doxycycline capsules 100 mg bp made by pakistan can you take viagra after the expiration date ampicillin biochemistry dilution zithromax cheap lormetazepam cinfa 1 mg comprimidos viagra is methadone safe to take with viagra where to buy cipro uses for travel diarrhea buy cialis online in montreal can i buy viagra in netherlan generic viagra from india price buy zithromax overnight delivery buy cialis online in india best way to administer doxycycline to my pigeons research chemicals usa nolvadex online generic viagra usage differenze tra cialis generico e originale prednisone dosage 50 mg price buy viagra legally in australia prednisone eye drops price diflucan salbe kaufen priligy 60 mg preisvergleich medikamente cyriax 500 mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg cassava and clomid together university research on generic cialis propecia online espana cytotec pastillas para abortar en costa rica cialis 40 mg after effects mechanism of antabuse half life of prednisone 50 mg cialis blue cross blue shield cost in ny use of viagra 100mg viagra tablets price uae how many viagra in a prescription viagra tablets for women price pakistan zithromax walmart over the counter texas generic viagra belgrade cialis walmart oc viagra generic viagra generic viagra stl prednisone versus corticosteroid is cialis available over the counter purchase cialis in vancouver bc how much is cialis in hong kong viagra kaufen dubai my accutane story metformin hcl 500 mg versus metformin clomid 50 mg posologia generic cialis mexico pharmacy ciproxina nombre comercial y generico cialis usa pharmacy online finasteride actavis 1mg precio sildenafil brands available in india 5 mg cialis big pack price is viagra safe with atril fibbrilation qual o problema de usar viagra buying viagra online with mastercard where buy prednisone online boots viagra northern ireland cialis in orange prednisone mylan 20 mg posologie viagra onsale inventor de la viagra alldaychemist clomid 50mg cialis vs cialis daily evolution of socialism in sweden how many 1000 mg zithromax for chlamydia ciprofloxacin teva 500 mg filmtabletten translation pijn in onderbuik na clomid why sildenafil is used cialis 20 mg dosierung printable 20 mg cialis coupons pramil e igual viagra online how much cost zovirax cheap viagra free dapoxetine brand names in pakistan halal food prednisolone 20 mg voor honden te 3 cost generic lowest viagra vibramycin throat infection can doxycycline be taken with other medicines tadalafil rezeptfrei paypal tadacip 20 mg cipla viagra vitamin a dose accutane fabricante viagra generico doxycycline 100mg para q sirve accidentally took 2 cialis 20 mg get clomid twins where can we buy viagra. in sydney propranolol clorhidrato 80 mg genfar sildenafil citrate walmart price dose of metformin in type 2 diabetes acetaminophen extra strength caplets 500 mg metformin tapering from prednisone 60 mg cipro xr para que se usa buy priligy in lebanon witch cialis pill for best resaults glucophage can cause a metallic taste in the mouth metformin and aldactone for pcos doxycycline 100mg iv diluted in d5w how much did viagra cost when it first came out how much is viagra in tj wholsale viagra ebay cytotec pill price malaysia laptop can 5 mg of cialis lose its effectiveness clomid users in nigeria auryxia generic cialis formula del viagra can you buy viagra over counter italy viagra in ottawa over counter brand cialis sale positive opk 3 days in a row clomid and twins can eating viagra once help in performance anxiety venta donde comprar cialis argentina sildenafil price ukulele is there any business that will ship viagra to canada pomada dexametasona generico do viagra safe dosage cialis can i take two viagra in two days utente generico de cialis carbamazepine 200 mg indicaciones metformina acquisto viagra generico pagamento in contrassegno zoloft and generic propecia long term effectiveness day 50 accutane generic normal dosage finasteride cialis directions 20 mg man takes viagra tsa pat down is there a viagra 200 mg or is it phony efectos viagra generico cialis 10mg opinion corticosteroid induced adrenal suppression prednisone viagra use in which afe 20mg cialis costco cost 100mg clomid still not pregnant cialis online sito affidabile cipro xr ciprofloxacino 500 mg candizole tablet 500 mg metformin benefit of clomid in urdu order diflucan single dose cheapest cialis index buy cytotec online with mastercard by viagra in south africa diflucan buy europe cialis pago por paypal viagra discount generic what mg is propecia cryselle generic equivalents for viagra cytotec pills in kuwait how is doctor is it safe to tan while taking accutane how much does legal viagra cost buy zovirax tqeovertoz doxycycline hyclate tablets softlets uses how cytotec be effective in abortion is viagra safe for pey ronies is 500 mg metformin effective zoloft for sale in uk clomid 50 mg price australia deltacortene 10cpr 25 mg of zoloft 80 mg lasix cialis bay in tesco testosterone pills vs viagra viagra pharmacy uk cialis online prednisolone dose for kids inderal public speaking reviews of london cialis prix boite leben und arbeiten in thailand erfahrungsbericht cialis when do you take clomid to ovulate livraison rapide cialis canada clomid price rite aid metformin monitoring uk will it hurt anything to cut a cialis tablet in half can you take viagra into spain cialis 20 mg p buy viagra from romania clomid purchase in australia similar pill of viagra price in indian rupees is 875 mg of amoxicillin a high dose prednisone viagra review 50mg can i take 15 mg of cialis every day cytotec pill in malaysia flight viagra in combinatie met poppers best ovulation predictor kit clomid side what is ciprofloxacin used to treat in humans apidra generico de cialis viagra spray in uk buy cialis pharmacy online the best viagra online zovirax 5 cream price buy doxycycline hyclate 50 mg online no prescription ampicillin maximum dose acimed 20 mg prednisone is it safe to take viagra while drinking cipro oral liquid where can i buy prednisolone suppositories dapoxetine onde comprar alfazema will doxycycline treat ear infection capitalism vs socialism in the us provera and metformin pregnancy safe best place buy viagra uk do antihistamines counteract cialis 24 mg prednisone and then taper down for rash how to dose doxycycline generic viagra cheap accepts paypal where can buy viagra in brisbane how long doessunrise cialis 20 mg last will taking half a viagra work does glimepiride contain metformin socialist republic of macedonia is in what time zone cialis how much mg sildenafil citrate cenforce 50 reviews how long does a 50mg viagra last obat ciprofloxacin 1000 mg cialis 2.5 mg en mexico how to buy viagra over the counter why do you need to take prednisone in the morning rabozol 20 mg prednisone viagra tablets to buy ship it international pfizer viagra 50 mg drugs online cialis clomid fertility uk desi viagra brands in delhi precio cialis 5 mg mexico best to take cialis amoxil liquid refrigeration ciprofloxacin for uti prophylaxis in neonates propecia kaufen europa viagra over the counter in manilla buy viagra online aramex costco cialis coupons pode misturar viagra com cialis online como comprar viagra sin receta en costa rica accutane 40 mg twice a day workout metformin time release generic buy viagra in aberdeen how many hours before to take viagra inderal 80 mg migraine relief viagra headquarters canada snopes effect of ciprofloxacin in yasmin contraceptive mannings zithromax over the counter hong kong donde comprar viagra nicaragua kann man viagra rezeptfrei bestellen viagra active super viagra generic viagra stl subaru vivio rx r for sale in uk zithromax generic version of cytotec esiste il cialis da 5 mg viagra in hahnemann blood in urine after taking cipro cl eveland viagra prices csie nctu edu tw tashong p generic zoloft is bangladesh marketing viagra olandis 10 mg prednisone cheapest viagra no prescription nz generic finasteride nzs costo spedizione cipro buy generic finasteride online 1 price of red viagra in pakistan buy viagra online australiaq blood in urine z pack and prednisone viagra generico en mexico sildenafil citrate use in elderly zithromax 200 mg5 accutane dosage chart weight bars in the viagra triangle viagra used daily what can be used in place of cialis wellbutrin and viagra together viagra pills for sale in singapore generic metformin bertibarots when cialis generic available buy cialis in irland taking 100mg of clomid viagra in jersey can you take viagra with carvedilol what is the name of female viagra priligy uk lloyds pharmacy donde comprar viagra granada does kaiser permanente pay for cialis cost costo del viagra generico in farmacias cialis prix allemagne sildenafil tablets 100 mg review creamy discharge on clomid cialis avec paypal buy zoloft online australia propranolol 40 mg obat apa viagra generico a napoli zithromax 250 mg cpr 6 navy 20 mg prednisone and pregnancy is zoloft available in liquid form dapoxetine baownbeuv reviews mechanism of action of cialis in bph price of viagra keeps going up does viagra make you real sleepy Kiwipolitico » crowdsourcing
Posts Tagged ‘crowdsourcing’

Democratic Service and Repair

datePosted on 17:25, September 14th, 2009 by Lew

In the shadows of chain-store ghost towns
Where no-one walks the streets at night
A silent nation, hooked on medication
Stares into a blue flickering light.
— Calexico, Service and Repair

This verse has been on my mind rather a lot since moving to my new exurb (it’s not quite a chain-store ghost town, although there sure is one of every chain store here.) But it’s the second pair of lines I’ve dwelt most upon; a potent image of Brave New World escapism as a substitute for real-life engagement, a soma-ed out populace who’ll take what it’s given.* This is a fashionable refrain in postmodern affluent liberal polities: democracy is being undermined by apathy, generated by those who would prefer you didn’t engage in politics at all so they can just get on with running the world without pesky peons interfering.

Political engagement in NZ is fairly weak and superficial, and that is bad for democratic politics. Engagement with and understanding of both the function and the presentation of political process is critical sustenance for democracy; but note, it must be with both the function and the presentation. It can be active (marches, submissions, donations, party membership, etc.) or passive (caring about the news, writing letters-to-the-editor, talkback, bloggery, heated discussions at the pub).

Both are important. In a political network model of concentric circles, a party’s leadership is surrounded by a wider group of insiders, cadres, activists, lobbyists and so forth, surrounded in turn by the party’s wider electorate. Organised political activity will only ever be the domain of a relative few, whom we might call second-circle elites; those who are involved in the political process but who do not drive it. The major role of these second-circle elites is to act as intermediary between the first and third circles; to channel information from the electorate to the leadership and to spread politics out to the electorate. These two functions (in and out) are very different; the former involves constant, frank and honest self-appraisal, a critical assessment function which must be independent from the proselytising imperative. The latter is the proselytising imperative; it requires faith and focus and adherence to doctrine and discipline.

When the feedback loop breaks down and information is fed out but not back in, a political movement becomes hijacked by its elite base — as if the second circle can somehow substitute for the third circle, as if burning desire among a few people can somehow substitute for smouldering will among a much larger number, in apparent ignorance of the fact that votes are not distributed on the basis of intensity of feeling. Ultimately the role of second-circle elites is to promote engagement between the first and third, and where apathy reigns in a polity, it is generally due to their failure to adequately perform those gatekeeping, proselytising and critical assessment functions. But second-circle elites all too frequently blame the electorate for these failures. Often, as in NZ at present, this leads to them decrying ‘politics by focus group’ or ‘pandering to the masses’ as defence of their own ‘principled’ or ‘just plain right’ positions; a view which scorns and patronises the electorate. Often, this position is combined with the grudging acknowledgement that the masses do in fact have all the votes and must therefore be ‘pandered to’ in order to gain sufficient support to prosecute a political agenda which may or may not resemble the agenda campaigned upon. This elite-centred view of politics kills engagement and increases apathy among non-elites, and results in the self-fulfilling prophecy that the unwashed hordes make poor political decisions — they often do, because they often don’t get what they vote for and didn’t have much of a hand in defining it anyhow.

But although the elites might sneer, engagement among the so-called silent majority is highly valuable, and the number of their votes is the least part of their importance. Their scrutiny of political events, policy and discourse may not be so intense, but it is broader and more stable. Even a moderate degree of political and media literacy among a wide section of the electorate provides a valuable check on how much government, its delegated authorities, lobbyists and other political actors can get away with, raising the bar of political action and discourse and providing a check that a high degree of literacy among a small second-circle elite can never provide. This is simply the wisdom of crowds.

Political movements need to decide whether their main priority is to agitate their own partisan lines for short-term electoral gain and alienate those segments with whom they disagree, or to build a democratic infrastructure of engagement and literacy in the polity in the knowledge that greater engegament and literacy will pay dividends. Or, to put it another way, political movements need to decide how much of the one they are prepared to sacrifice to the other. It’s a tricky balance, and I don’t mean to suggest it’s a precise zero-sum tradeoff, but the project of building democratic literacy and engagement is not usually compatible with a partisan agenda, and this means accepting that some proselytisation opportunities will be missed. But if the core problem is a low standard of political action and discourse in the polity, and the imperative is to drive up the quality of political action and discourse by increasing polity-level political and media literacy, then the strategic job of the agitators should be to promote political literacy above all else; even to the partial exclusion of short-term partisan gains. In my view, too much has been sacrificed to the electoral cycle; that the government so often gets away with the ‘nine long years’ gambit, itself a propaganda device to deflect attention from some policy failure or unappealing priority decision, indicates the failure of this imperative.

The NZ electorate is not entirely unengaged, though the standard of that engagement is quite low. There have been a number of catalytic issues in recent years which have made people sit up and care about politics: the Orewa Speech, the Foreshore and Seabed Act, the Electoral Finance Act, the s59 repeal; the h debate are a few which spring readily to my mind. Most of these were created by the right for largely partisan reasons, realising that engagement was a way of taking the political initiative. It is critical to note here that engagement is not the same as literacy, but that it can lead to literacy in the long term if properly managed. While the iwi/kiwi debate and the smacking debate and so on generated much heat and little light, they provide an illustration that political activism isn’t quite hunched before the TV screen with a beer in one hand and a remote control in the other. What’s needed is a cultural change in NZ democratic politics; issues that the polity cares about, politicians who are responsive to those issues, and elites who are committed first and foremost to raising these issues and sustaining the discourse betwen the first and second circles for the good of democratic politics rather than strictly for partisan gain.

Crowdsourcing politics for democracy’s sake is preventative maintenance. It’s well overdue.


* Really, what will we do now that NZ’s Next Top Model has been cancelled?