viagra canada cheapest car eurospecialist usa viagra from canada 2 day delivery dapoxetine medicine in pakistan halal food corvasal generic cialis cialis in manila philippines finasteride 5mg filipino review metformin order online no prescription expert sildenafil 50 mg masticable en cialis price in pharmacies buy clomid research chemicals dove trovo il cialis generico walmart price.for.viagra cloridrato de prasugrel generico de cialis quaility propecia online safe pure to buy viagra online in australia zoloft 50 mg and aspirin viagra nederland bestellen buy viagra in melbourne vic can i take benadryl while taking doxycycline buy viagra with cashiers check nolvadex pct for sale sydney priligy dapoxetina acquisto occasione italia mastercard boom loader for sale in uk zithromax buy clenbuterol nolvadex online doxycycline in lupus viagra pills in india cost tab tadalafil 10mg prezzo del generico del viagra foundation to use with accutane buying viagra from a chemist indian sildenafil tablets for sale the best homemade replacement of viagra metformin 250 mg daily reciprocating gun carry states cialis to masterbate viagra price rise doxycycline hyclate used for bladder infection time day best take finasteride linezolid generico do viagra buy ciprofloxacin in mexico prednisone 10 mg for poison ivy how many to take a day free prescription viagra carry viagra in flight vibramycin 100 mg buy sildenafil 20 mg tablet can you buy over the counter viagra in vancouver canada cialis pharmacie en ligne canada buy azithromycin doxycycline viagra prices in france buy viagra san diego hiv specialists in dekalb county ga viagra for women put in drink online viagra ads do you take zoloft in morning or night acquistare viagra in parafarmacia morlan cost of viagra in dominican republic accutane in indonesia can i cut my 20 mg cialis in half effectiveness of liquid cialis can i take paracetamol with accutane can i take doxycycline and go in the sun es cialis help in premature ejaculation prednisone 1 mg pill description genericos do viagra comes viagra generico sms sildenafil using paypal where to buy propecia 0.5 mg in malaysia what would happen if a female takes viagra indian cipro tablets images viagra bestellen pillendienst legal purchase nolvadex if viagra comes in pfizer packaging is it real where can i buy cialis in toronto viagra spray available in india cialis generic china sildenafil canine dosage zoloft and binge eating disorder cialis generico es bueno cialis and bph metformin in third trimester pregnancy bula viagra generico in farmacia can doxycycline cause low blood sugar propecia generico prezzo vouchers cialis monthly cost walmart buy viagra online uk only suppliers metformin for weight loss in women viagra 100 mg 30 tablet fiyati clomid babycentre uk viagra uk over counter sildenafil generic expiration date viagra 50mg buying viagra for men in manchester where i can get viagra pill in philippines how can i buy 4 pills of zithromax coopman classification of corticosteroids prednisone sildenafil 50 mg tabletas masticables 1000 mg metformin for weight loss onlinedictionary datasegment com word doxycycline quanto costa cialis 20 mg farmacia what counteracts the prednisone induced dog panting legitamite place in oklahoma city to buy cialis propecia alternative 2013 which is the best viagra available in bangalore viagra tablets name for women in india zoloft 50 prix maroc zoloft treat anxiety disorder metformin in treating pcos s au scuturat toti trandafirii generic viagra what to watch for in generic cialis viagra cialis spam how to buy cialis online sinot 875 mg generico do viagra tadalafil generika deutschland germany would a 150 mg diflucan tablet cure oral thrush generic viagra priligy metformin taken with clomid viagra generico de la india cytotec in the united states not ovulation after miscarriage clomid online sildenafil generika rezeptfrei cheap indian viagra online generic cialis markings over the counter viagra chicago walmart viagra price 100mg breaking cialis tablets propecia for sale cheap diflucan 50 mg posologie amoxicilline beconase generic uk viagra can minors take viagra viagra online soft deos viagra come in syrup ampicillin drug study nursing crib review dove comprare viagra generico is 5 mg prednisone daily for pain too much for 8lb dog pfizer viagra 100mg test cozaar 50 mg generico do viagra ampicillin concentration in lb plates with kanamycin non prescription 40 mg lasix generic viagra works prescription dapoxetine uk boots cosmetics viagra by pfizer in lahore fluimucil pediatrico generico do viagra cost of viagra 25 mg cialis puede causar impotencia how many mg of viagra should a 280 man glucophage 500 mg pcos diet maximum recommended dosage viagra clomid como deve ser usado zoloft falling in love viagra pfizer europe viagra sale in toronto welche viagra kaufen where can i buy sildenafil 9 pm tablets excelentes resultados con finasteride cost priligy 30mg e 60 mg adderall cialis generic for daily use prednisone dose in kids donecil 10 mg prednisone sildenafil generico retirada translation does generic viagra work from canada cheapest generict viagra australia what is the maximum safe dose for viagra divalproex 500 mg tablet delayed release metformin ghb main ingredients in viagra cheap tadalafil whartisthebestin cialis 2 5 costo base ingredients in ciprofloxacin best time for taking finasteride buy zithromax canada pharmacy reviews on doxycycline for acne zovirax pommade prix maroc generico del viagra en colombia donde generic cialis price pro cytotec express en costa rica cheapest tadalafil .uk propecia cost year best site buy generic viagra viagra usa canada doxycycline dog india drug what happens if a 13 year old takes viagra acne scarring treatment after accutane tadalafil 20mg generic no prescription prednisone weight gain 5 mg buy nolvadex cheap from india what does the 20 mg tadalafil pill look like discount pill viagra viagra viagradrugs net generic finasteride 5mg reviews on windows can i get high off doxycycline hyclate finasteride 1 mg dosis buy viagra in australia review 15 mg prednisone olexar 10 mg prednisone ventajas y desventajas de usar sildenafil donde comprar viagra en santiago de chile viagra price buy online super pro cms dapoxetine tablet in india how successful is 50mg of clomid zovirax eye ointment equivalent in spain thuoc isonace 10 mg prednisone can i take cialis for 2 days in a row buy discount cialis clomid fertility drug buy online uk purchase ampicillin dergboadre cytotec arthrotec oxaprost london prices how many viagra can one take in a day comprar cialis valencia sin receta sildenafil citrate tablets brand names cialis uk purchase doxycycline dose poultry generic viagra united pharmacy viagra 25mg efeito where can i buy generic viagra with a mastercard viagra saferx 2.5mg valium in combination with viagra doxycycline use in malaria enalapril 20 mg indicaciones ciprofloxacino can you take avodart with viagra singapore buy cialis where can you buy cialis or viagra in dubai cipro 500 mg 14 tablet computer safe take tylenol accutane generic sildenafil online uk degrees ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tablet images finasteride legal in dubai ciprolex 5mg online uk 20 mg splitting 20 mg cialis lb medium ampicillin sales of viagra statistics fabian essays in socialism most popular title buy azithromax 1 gram clomid metformin without prescription cheap generic generico viagra mexico pay in usa for viagra comprar citrato de sildenafila pela internet viagra generika ohne zollprobleme tadalafil ciales india buy cialis online no prescription usa ciprofloxacin ratiopharm 500 mg beipackzettel ismn viagra substitute in stores what are the generic names for viagra alternative to zithromax reliable online source for viagra buy cialis in the united states mercury drug viagra in philippines doxycycline manufacturers in philippines glucophage 850 kaufen nolvadex sale online legal us medication to counteract prednisone can general practitioner prescribe cialis online can metformin 500 er be taken in the morning cialis overnight fedex prednisone pregnancy uk qka eshte doxycycline accutane 20 mg every other day doxycycline hcl manufacturer india cheap viagra cialis tablets comprar cialis 40 mg how long is it safe to stay on zoloft tadalafil 20 mg vs sildenafil wholesale kamagra jelly viagra doxycycline al 100 mg viagra vs tadalafil get viagra india sildenafil canadian drugs how does clomid help in pregnancy fast viagra delivery what is teh best time to take cialis what ingredients in viagra cost of clomid injection in india indian generic viagra reviews cialis 20mg in bahasa malayu 203 k loan specialist in pennsylvania viagra canada headoffice doxycycline iv 100 mg tablet i need cialis fast delivery no prescription cost of viagra in europe what is the cost of viagra pills at walmart maximum dose for vibramycin cialis best strength generic viagra made in united states safe take benadryl zoloft cialis retail suppliers in south africa cytotec in labour propecia works great cialis generic cialis viagra sildenafil citrate pills in india when can u take clomid buy livening com viagra health walimex studio set kh 150 mg viagra prescription viagra paypal can clomid cause an ectopic pregnancy prix prednisolone 20mg knee pain cipro full specialist license in florida viagra order by phone no prescription ciprofloxacin 250 mg film coated tablets for sale zovirax ointment over the counter in australia sildenafil generico dr simi norwood can i take diflucan 150 mg 4 days apart identify viagra pills non prescription viagra walmart cost doxycycline dosage elephantiasis can you buy finasteride online proper dosage of clomid where to buy clomid online hong kong cytotec how long does it take to work generic alternatives accutane i want viagra without prescription in brussel very nice site cheap viagra 20 mg prednisone dosage for adults cialis uk using paypal can you take viagra with citalopram scoliosis specialists in missouri nolvadex hereisthebestin for sale when will the price of viagra drop metformin hexal 850 mg filmtabletten is viagra available in tesco stores in dublin ireland fabian essays in socialism year published what is amoxil 500mg used for which viagra to carry when you go to pattaya from india zithromax online consultation us how many mg of prednisone to get high viagra tablets in india and cost in rupees metformin brands in malaysia viagra for long lasting cheap cialis unitied states quel est le prix du viagra generique indianapolis accutane lawyer azithromycin over the counter uk viagra mycostatin sciroppo controindicazioni cialis is it legal to sell viagra in the uk next day viagra delivery uk anyone get pregnant first month clomid reviews how long does 10mg of prednisone stay in your system buy zithromax online in usa viagra tablets price in bangalore dating can you take vitamin b with doxycycline antabuse generic name accutane safe hair removal does everyone get initial breakout accutane come comprare la viagra does doxycycline cause rapid heart rate freya 28 generic viagra sildenafil citrate reviews viagra for men in helsinki urbason 16 mg dosierung viagra simvastatina 20 mg effetti collaterali zoloft in the military can i buy viagra myself lasix cheap generico de viagra en farmacias similares remedio bi profenid 150 mg zoloft sildenafil neuraxpharm 100 mg wirkung kardamom joypox dapoxetine review comprar viagra andorra precio metformin mepha 850 mg blood in urine cialis where online can i buy genuine clomid tablets cialis prices at walgreen sildenafil 50 mg low dosage 10 pills propranolol 40 mg grossesse buying viagra over the phone propecia by merck discount linagliptin metformin generico cialis leg pain treatment generic cialis available in india 40 mg accutane online test comprar viagra natural en argentina gliclazide 80 mg with metformin 500mg and weight long term use of 10 mg prednisone how long does impotence propecia last uk cialis 5 mg piano terapeutico aifa who had best reviews viagra is cialis and poppers safe prednisone 20 mg tablet 47714 can i take 50 mg of cialis can viagra cause leg swelling when viagra was sold in the philippines how much time tadalafil 20 effects in women body does chewing viagra make it work faster where to buy prescription cialis viagra next day delivery without prescription apa arti ciprofloxacin 500 mg lowest priced cialise in canada priligy available in canada order cialis from uk cialis 40 mg generico generic viagra from walmart cytotec ulcer medication over the counter lyrica generico de cialis lowest dose viagra cialis price increases over the years viagra cost per pill without insurance generic ciprofloxacin hereisthebestin nolvadex baownbeuv discount modulo delega generic accutane cheap alternative to propecia propranolol in treatment of hemangioma order prednisolone online viagra accept discover trusted prescriptions online comprar viagra online pharmacy cialis brand supreme suppliers canadian lasix priligy 30 mg60 mg filmtabletten cheap online pharmacy viagra viagra effects how long sildenafil stada 100 mg beipackzettel zithromax order online au vitamin c rose hip uk 1000mg metformin viagra pills free samples cytotec available in ireland where can i buy 100mg viagra propecia costco price is 150 mg viagra dangerous sildenafil 130 mg tablet 20 mg cialis vs 100 mg viagra doxycycline dosage chest infection weight loss drugs to counteract zoloft camazol 500 mg metformin viagra prices in kenya generic viagra poland viagra of the amazon viagra without prescription from canada ofteno prednisolone 20 mg mcp 5 mg dosierung viagra earliest age to take viagra dapoxetine drug test best facial cleanser while on accutane priligy medicine india coupon free cialis 5 mg pelvic pain specialists in minnesota generic cialis united pharmacy muscle relaxant drugs over the counter uk viagra zoloft 50 mg efectos secundarios cialis cialis cialis cum generic generic us com viagra viagra tablets price in islamabad hair loss caused by accutane viagra cost with perscription safe give dog prednisone costo viagra da 100mg famosos que usan finasteride wo kann man billig cialis kaufen amoxil rowcmoadreders price can i take two 5 mg cialis cialis 10mg filmtabletten preis buy propecia lloyds pharmacy jobs can you viagra over the counter in mexico best sleep aid over the counter uk viagra para que sirve el medicamento ciprofloxacino 500 mg sildenafil available in bangalore walgreen viagra price which is safe clomid or ovamit tadalafil 20 mg soft tabs prednisone hereisthebestin discount can i use lasix to lose weight 40mg cheap cialis prednisolone zentiva 20 mg notice of privacy how much is prednisone cost cialis 5 mg too weak opipramol stada 50 mg nebenwirkungen viagra cialis review malaysia prednisone liquid inactive ingredients viagra model in football jersey name bar buy clomid from uk no prescription best time take nolvadex cycle prescription for cialis required in mexico cialis spiegazioni in italiano yahoo ciprofloxacin ear drops price in switzerland does cialis affect women in conceiving cost of zoloft 100mg i have stents in my heart can i take viagra cialis 50mg sales in bulk how much viagra may i take in a month how yo order cytotec viagra in safeway dosage for clomid after steroid cycle do i need a prescription for generic viagra amoxil 1 grain to mg canada viagra without prescription how to take metformin er 500 mg is doxycycline used to cure gonorrhea finasteride 1mg vs finasteride 5 mg what works best 1 mg propecia of 5mg puedo tener relaciones despues de usar cytotec lasix online visa viagra in spain how much bula da amoxilina de 500 mg viagra for purchase vibramycin generic name cervilan tabletas generico do viagra ukmedix viagra for sale glucophage xr 500 mg cenapred new viagra prices generic viagra legal canada generic viagra generico cialis dr siminski 1 mg of prednisone for copd generic cialis brasil escola discount sertraline generic zoloft how to buy viagra over the phone metformin over the counter australia Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » NATO toasts Putin.

NATO toasts Putin.

datePosted on 12:18, March 27th, 2014 by Pablo

The end of the Cold War left NATO without its raison d’être. Its creation was predicated on the existence of an existential threat emanating from the USSR, one that would take the military shape of high intensity warfare: waves of armored columns crossing the central European plains backed by massive infantry formations covered by blanketing air cover and even tactical nuclear weapons. NATO was designed as a collective security arrangement whereby superior counter-force on the part of the US and its Northern Hemisphere allies served as a deterrent to Soviet aggression. That strategic orientation was at the heart of the Cold War.

With the Soviet Union gone, so was the need for that strategy. NATO first sought to incorporate, over Russian objections, former Warsaw Pact states into its embrace. Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic joined first, followed by  Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovenia, Slovakia, Bulgaria, Romania and, most recently, Albania and Croatia. It shifted its focus towards multinational peace-keeping and peace-enforcement, irregular low-intensity conflict operations such as those in Kosovo in the late 1990s (the size, scope, pace, depth and range of weapons used in kinetic operations determine the relative intensity of combat). Later it cast its collective gaze further afield, involving itself in the International Security Assistance Force occupation of Afghanistan and the ouster of the Gaddafi regime in Libya.

The irony is that these strategic shifts did nothing to allay Russian concerns that NATO’s  primary focus remained on curtailing its ability to project force to its West and South, but in Western capitals the belief was that NATO needed to re-boot given the shifting geopolitical landscape and strategic priorities of the late 20th and early 21st centuries.

None of the new NATO missions substituted for those designed to counter the threat posed by the Soviet-led Warsaw Pact, and with the exception of the US, this was reflected in diminishing defense budgets, numbers of uniformed personnel and overall military significance within policy-making circles in member states. However it tried to redefine its core mission, NATO was increasingly seen by elites and public alike as a security organization without a purpose. Many felt that it should be disbanded and replaced by more flexible military agreements that would eliminate the costs of maintaining a permanent NATO infrastructure in Brussels and annually contributing, both militarily and financially, to its operations. It was believed in some quarters that this could be done without significantly impacting on any nation’s self-defense in what was seen as a largely benign European strategic environment where conflicts were more intra-rather than inter-state in nature.

It was for that reason that I penned this column as part of my late “Word from Afar” series as Scoop.

Now, thanks to the Russian invasion and annexation of Crimea, that has changed. In the eyes of its champions, NATO is once again confronted by hostile Russians on its Eastern flanks. Not surprisingly, US and European military-security officials, especially but not exclusively in places like Poland, have been quick to raise the specter of Russian imperialism in the former Eastern European bloc, calling for a revitalization of NATO’s original primary and core concern: containing the Bear.

The justification for NATO revitalization is based on the belief that Putin will not stop in Crimea or even the Eastern Ukraine, but has intentions to at the very least “Finlandize” a number of former Soviet Republics on Russia’s border that he feels have gotten too politically close to the EU and their Western neighbors. Given that the uprising in Ukraine was seen as a vote in favor of closer ties with the EU, the Russian response in Crimea is taken as indicative of its approach towards other “pro-EU” governments in its near abroad.

Just as Putin was able to capitalize on Russian nationalism as a generator of support for the invasion of Crimea, so too can conservative politicians in many European states use his actions as a catalyst for nationalistic appeals. Fear of the Bear is widespread and often visceral in many parts of Europe, especially those that suffered under Soviet occupation or at the hands of Soviet troops during the Great War. They and their descendants provide receptive audiences for anti-Russian appeals made on both politically opportunistic as well as principled grounds.

This is music to the ears of European defense bureaucrats, even if the US is not quite as capable of shouldering the burden of their collective defense in the measure that it once used to. For European security elites, the good ole days of robust defense spending, new weapons acquisitions, force expansion and significant military say in national policy making are now set to replace the politics of austerity and neglect that characterized the post Cold War period. Security decision-makers will make the argument that resurgent Russia is as much a threat today as it was back during the Cold War, even if its reach is now more regional than global in scope and its power is derived as much from its energy exports as it is from its military capabilities. Their argument will dove-tail nicely with those of anti-Russian nationalists, so the die is set for another re-casting of NATO’s mould.

Of course, while NATO went through contortions of re-defining itself after the Cold War, Russian strategists continued to focus primarily on defending their land borders and promoting Russian influence in neighboring states so as to provide a buffer to would-be aggressors, particularly from the West. For the Russians the “liberation” of Crimea is just a natural and justified reaction to the steady erosion of Russian influence in regions in which it has core historical, cultural and political interests. It is this “natural” reaction that has prompted the calls for NATO’s strategic re-orientation, which in turn means that the two strategic visions have once again been counterpoised.

This will be welcomed by Russian military and NATO officials because it marks the return to the common logics of collective defense that justify their positions and the arguments for counter-force deterrence that bound them together in opposition during the Cold War. However, for the citizens affected by a return to Cold War logics the prospects may not be so rosy.

Whatever the case, there are bound to be more than a  few NATO officials quietly hoisting a glass in honor of Vladimir Putin, for it is is he who has given them importance once again.

23 Responses to “NATO toasts Putin.”

  1. Wilson Ma on March 27th, 2014 at 21:48

    I suspect it is either that or more likely the final nail in the coffin of the NATO when we find the article 5 is just a blank cheque that bounce as there are a simple lack of wills & capability to honuor the Treaty.

    We are seeing a split of the NATO & EU opinion at the moment with the easten memebers states led by the Pole calling for stronger respond while the Western European led by German & French who prefer to more “engagement” with Uncle Vladmine. Even in Britain who tranditionally pro-war, there are no public support for the Ukriania in any sort and most quite happy to see the Russian “recover” Ukriane.

    The opinion of right-wing nationalist party in Britain, “UKIP” actually in favour of Putin action, they view EU as the enemy and the Russian model as a “liberiation” from the “EU imperialist”.

    and this view also share by most in Western & Southern Europe.

    And for those on the Left, as we all know they are just KGB/FSB funded morally bankrupted “fifth column”.

    There are no prospect incease of defence spending either after the event, there are no change of the planned budget cut as the put for reduction of national debt is what the government aiming for. And whatever few penny or cent that can spare are used for “vote-buying” in the “Grey” or “Mumnet” or “1st time homeowner” votes.

  2. Phil Sage on March 28th, 2014 at 00:36

    The best current article I have seen is China is making serious inroads into previous Russian influence in former Soviet Central Asia. Regaining Siberia is an obvious geostrategic target for China.

    How many divisions does NATO have? None. Although there may be a few junior staff officers attached to NATO who may welcome the career opportunities posed by Russian aggression the simple reality is that each soldier comes from a home nation. There is no state of NATO and there is no pan European defence force. Each soldier looks to their own culture.

    Merkel is following in Schroder footsteps and ensuring that Germany stays closer to Russia. I remain utterly bemused on why German leaders are following energy policies guaranteeing that the German economy is dependent on Russia.

    As Wilson noted the NATO article 5 promises are simply paper. How may American tanks remain in Europe? None is the answer. If the governments behind NATO were serious they would be moving existing German bases to Poland. That is almost as likely as Obama cancelling Obamacare.

    That said the point of your article is to note an increased likelihood of EU & NATO defence money and additional focus on security vs austerity. The UK Sec Def was on radio this morning ruling out any additional money or troops for armed forces. The likely Western next steps are for the mighty SEC rather than NATO. Putin seems to care less about money and more about pride so it is less likely SEC money moves rather than military are unlikely to have much impact on Putin. That said they are sensible actions.

    Putin seems like a little boy poking a chained dog with a stick to show how brave he is to his mates.

    Will NATO get more toys? I doubt it as far as anything substantial is concerned. The post cold war complacency and defence cost cutting mentality remains in European governments.

  3. Wilson Ma on March 28th, 2014 at 02:38

    Most competented, experienced junior officers & NCOs of our ages had left the forces & out to the big wide world of security consultancy. Those who stay are mostly the unemployable youngest sons of the trust-fund class who waiting to cash their end-salary penison.

    in reality NATO is just US Armed force in Europe with a few British, Nordic & token Eastern European Auxiliary. It always have been a case of US taxpayers paying for the defence the Freedom of European while the European feasting themselves on welfare states. But the age of Pax American is ending and it is now everyone for themselves, and most European choose surrender.

    Well, Mrs Merkel is an Ex-FDJ, Russian speaking academic from East Germany and who know how red is it under her bed.

    Putin is no little boy poking a dog. More like the EU is the fool who poking the Russian bear and running away from the bear craws crying now.

  4. Pablo on March 28th, 2014 at 07:32

    The point of the post is not that NATO can return to its Cold War deterrence posture or whether it can fight effectively. It is simply noting that defense/security bureaucrats and officials as well as conservative politicians will self-servingly use the Russian action as justification for renewed emphasis on collective defense.

  5. Wilson Ma on March 29th, 2014 at 02:30
  6. Chris Waugh on March 29th, 2014 at 13:17

    Pablo, I’m curious, how far do you think defence/security bureaucrats and conservative and nationalist politicians can push things? Back in the Cold War days there were no direct borders between the USSR and NATO (except of course the sea border in the Bering Strait – which hasn’t changed – and the Turkish borders with Georgia and Armenia), and I suppose one could argue that the Warsaw Pact states served as something of a limited buffer. Now Russia directly borders NATO members Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and, via Kaliningrad (the former East Prussian Koenigsberg), Poland. And, of course, Belarus sits conveniently between Lithuania, Poland, Ukraine and Kaliningrad and Russia-proper. Also, I have read of German moves to revisit ancestral homes in Kaliningrad/Koenigsberg, perhaps even reassert old ties there – perhaps giving a bit more fuel to ultra-nationalist types in Germany? Does the closer proximity of NATO assets to the Russian homeland combine with the Ukraine situation (important for Russian, Belarussian and Ukrainian historical and cultural identity – Kievan Rus, and all that) increase the chances of conflict turning hot if the defence/security bureaucrats get their way and conservative and nationalist hotheads manage to use this to gain more influence?

  7. Chris Waugh on March 29th, 2014 at 14:13

    Also: I’m curious as to how large ethnic Russian populations in the Baltics complicate matters, especially given Putin’s self-appointed role as Defender of All Russians. Could NATO hypothetically find itself fighting both a large, conventional battle like it was originally set up for and an irregular insurgency at the same time in the event of conflict in the Baltics?

  8. Pablo on March 29th, 2014 at 14:34


    Even if NATO bureaucrats, security officials and conservative nationalists succeed in raising defense budgets and restoring military prestige/voice in policy-making, there is no way that NATO is going to try and confront Russian forces on a battle field unless Russian forces tried to take a country like Estonia or Poland. The other Baltic states and places like Belorus are basically now hostage to Russian ambition and will not be defended by NATO (not that Belorus would want to be).

    All NATO can do by increasing its spending on collective defense is reprise the Reagan strategy of (out) spending the Russians into bankruptcy.

    Trouble is the Russian have money to burn on defense thanks to their energy export revenues, so a strong sanctions regime curbing exports coupled with massively increased NATO defense spending is the only way to get Russia to over-spend on defense relative to other policy areas. And given the politics of austerity and European dependence on Russian energy exports, that is not going to happen.

    So all NATO can do is bark from the sidelines.

  9. paul scott on March 30th, 2014 at 17:27

    I travel all over, As a redneck New Zealander I like the way Russia; you know he collected up his Russian people. We see this with our own eyes while USA was little, How come little people like me are looking at Russia and the world map.
    Is our currency Russia or China tell me now

  10. Phil Sage on March 30th, 2014 at 22:32

    Paul, would you mind re-writing that in English. I think you are making a point but not sure what.

    Pablo. You say there would not be a confrontation unless Russian forces decided to take Estonia or Poland. Russian armor could easily proceed overland to Kaliningrad through Latvia and Lithuania establishing new facts on the ground. NATO armor is at bases in Germany. Do you really believe that NATO would go to war over the Baltic states. They are balking at any kind of real economic sanctions let alone military action. There would be harsh words and probably real sanctions. Look at the geographic proximity of Estonia to Moscow. The reality is that only Poland would be the battlefield. It seems to me that the Baltic states are a sort of unspoken demilitarized zone. But just because Putin could go to Poland does not mean he would.
    Russia’s problem is demography not lebensraum. It simply does not have the people. Is it possible that Putin has a much longer term strategy to make Russia strong again. I came across this article on Russian demography. Really interesting to note the changes that have happened whilst Putin has been in power. Russians are not emulating the drunken Yeltsin any more.

    At 140m people Russia is not able to face down either EU/USA or China. He knows that. He also knows that nationalism is a highly effective tool. That makes him a rational actor. Why would he aim at the low population Baltic states when the price paid would be very high. He is far more likely to aim at the FSR states in Russian Central Asia. Vastly more populous and with energy to boot.

  11. Chris Waugh on March 30th, 2014 at 23:31

    Phil, why on Earth would Putin drive Russian tanks through Latvia and Lithuania to Kaliningrad? Kaliningrad already is Russian territory, has been since WW2, and he could drive them through the (mostly, but not always entirely) friendly Belarus much more easily. But don’t forget the ethnic Russian minorities in the Baltics – only about 6ish% in Lithuania, but roughly 1/4 of the populations of Latvia and Estonia.

    But I agree on the extra juiciness of Central Asia, and I’ve been reading for a while now about a “New Great Game”, with Russia, China and the US vying for influence in the region.

  12. Wilson on March 31st, 2014 at 08:27

    Because he just want to keep all 3 Baltic states out + Poland. It is a Russian thing, they just hate those people. Nothing rational about it.
    War is not about rationality, if anyone rational, no one go to war.

  13. Pablo on March 31st, 2014 at 08:29

    Phil: I may not have been clear in my comments, but I agree with you that NATO will do bumkus in the event of limited Russian incursions in Baltic states. If anything NATO should be acting now to bolster Baltic state defenses so as to raise the costs of even a limited Russian incursion. And that will not happen.

    Oh wait–I just read that the US is giving Moldova the equivalent of one fifth of John Key’s annual income to bolster its defenses. That will show Putin whose boss!

    I agree that Central Asia is a more important strategic arena.

  14. Lord Alloa on March 31st, 2014 at 11:09

    “If anything NATO should be acting now to bolster Baltic state defenses so as to raise the costs of even a limited Russian incursion. And that will not happen.”

    Actually, it is already happening:

  15. Pablo on March 31st, 2014 at 11:33


    Interesting. Let’s see if those rotations actually amount to something other than a token gesture of reassurance. When I wrote about bolstering defenses so as to raise the costs of Russian incursions I was thinking of something more permanent that would serve as a deterrent trip wire, but perhaps regular rotations of ground forces will suffice. Then again…

  16. Lord Alloa on March 31st, 2014 at 11:47

    Don’t forget the Baltic Air Policing mission, which sees permanent commitment of NATO forces to Siualai airbase in Lithuania. US forces are there now, to be relieved by a Polish-Danish-British squadron in May:

    PS: I read with interest Malcolm McKinnon’s article in the Dominion Post on Ukraine. Did you catch it? It seems to be gone from their website, but I can email you a transcript if you’d like.

  17. Pablo on March 31st, 2014 at 12:13


    I read that the troop rotations would be in addition to the BAP commitment, which could also be reinforced.

    I did not see the McKinnon article. Feel free to share it with me at

  18. Lord Alloa on March 31st, 2014 at 12:25

    The BAP has been reinforced in response to the Crimea crisis but it’s not clear if this is temporary or permanent. But BAP has always been seen as primarily a first-perimeter measure rather than a fully fledged defensive mechanism. It is the established policy of the militaries of all three Baltic states that, in the event of a Russian attack, they will not attempt to defend their entire territory but will concentrate on maintaining national redoubts in two or three strategic strongpoints and wait for NATO reinforcement.

    I’ve emailed you McKinnon’s article.

  19. Phil Sage on March 31st, 2014 at 20:40

    Chris – poor wording but my point was only Poland would be defended seriously in military terms and the possibility is moot because Putin is not stupid. EU would be forced to act with economic sanctions that would hit Russia. He will gain far more from taking over again in Central Asia. Do you have any references to decent articles on the new Great Game?

  20. Lord Alloa on April 3rd, 2014 at 00:45

    More signs of a permanent NATO presence in the Baltic States:

  21. paul scott on April 6th, 2014 at 08:53

    I think the big bear is looking East now, and after all why not, what a sell out the USSR was, I expect the bear to tell USA off, where is USA funding going to come from, US citizens? China?

  22. Pablo on April 6th, 2014 at 11:17

    Paul: Please refrain from using profanity and racist words. I have deleted them from your last comment.

  23. Chris Waugh on April 6th, 2014 at 18:16

    Phil, sorry for the late reply. No references, sorry, because I’m pretty sure I’ve never read any **decent** articles on the New Great Game. I was referring to stuff generally I’ve read on the topic on the always interesting but often dodgy internet.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)