indian viagra in lahore buy viagra lloyds pharmacy online zithromax rowcmoadreders price cuong duong thuoc cialis 5mg viagra pill discounts viagra camden london viagra for men supply in perth best price viagra without prescription watermelon works as viagra farmacia online viagra argentina vs germany shelf life of liquid doxycycline bald truth talk finasteride cost black market vviagra galway buy viagra in pune viagra in verbindung mit drogen just started zoloft feeling weird where is the pineapple in psych viagra falls super viagra uk london ferrari sildenafil tablets 130 mg of ambien can viagra from india pass us customs generic viagra in sydney lasix online without prescription debit card order clomid fast buy prednisone otc viagra viagra uk sales generic viagra in sa cheap viagra american express hard viagra online best products use accutane order cialis 5mg online viagra best suppliers clomid dose to conceive twins 1000 mg metformin 50mg clomid with regular augmentin preferrred in england over cipro benefit of generic viagra in conception to impotent men viagra australia pharmacy jobs where can i bye viagra in london where to get antabuse tapones para oidos donde comprar viagra econazole nitrate cream 1 generic cialis cheep generic viagra india propranolol 80 mg modified release capsules nolvadex london how long does daily cialis take to get in your system southwest retina specialists in el paso texas how to get viagra at 18 zithromax liquid concentration when to take liquid nolvadex generic clomid name can cialis come in larger doses donde comprar cytotec sin receta en guadalajara tadalafil over the counter boots uk ciprofloxacin drug interactions why does metformin not dissolve in body fda approved generic sildenafil 100mg viagra in polonia is cialis worth it is mexican cialis real viagra availability in islamabad bio arct 50 mg zoloft viagra price in riyadh dapoxetine fda approval how long does effect of viagra last cialis canada sample viagra tablets in bangalore medical stores prednisone dosage mg poison ivy 60 mg of prednisone per day how long does inderal 20 mg last doxycycline dose renal impairment buy vibramycin hereisthebestin guaranteed lowest price generic cialis where can i get viagra in batam zithromax baownbeuv price prednisolone eye drops where to buy viagra in tirana buy propecia finasteride cheapest price on ebay viagra online viagra buy prescription finasteride in hair loss cheapest cialis usa in what can i get tadalafil in the united states cheap buy doxycyclinee canine melphalan prednisone bortezomib price 80 mg propranolol effects viagra tablets price in hyderabad where is lazer cuantas cytotec de 500 mg debo usar cipro breastfeeding safe purchase lasix almetec co generico do viagra good site buy viagra dose of doxycycline to prevent malaria prednisone eye drops in pregnancy cheap viagra online in uk ltd diflucan pill generic name i want to buy clomid online where can i buy clomid pills is 12 5 mg of zoloft therapeutic buy clomid 100mg 10 tablets buying cialis in berlin prednisone 40 mg for hearing loss can i start at 75 mg of clomid opana 20 mg er generic cialis generic viagra hk ciprofloxacin 500 ohne rezept kaufen tadalafil odt tablets viagra genericscheap ru classification of adrenocorticosteroids prednisone 500 mg cipro for 7 days with a prescriptipn ciprofloxacin ranbaxy 500 mg where can u buy viagra over the counter in lithuania viagra usage in women zoloft and zyrtec cheapest viagra in istanbul cipro liquid form dosage can i take clomid days 3 7 viagra for sale in usa stores find ratio metformin hcl 500 mg cialis cost 5 mg temazepam 20 mg bijwerkingen prednisone propranolol 80 mg modified release capsules anxiety is clomid available over the counter in any country prednisone online no perscription omizac 20 mg prednisone viagra in holland ohne rezept prednisone 20 mg 3 tablets daily cialis in bahrain paypal metformin hcl 500 mg obat clomid chances of getting pregnant clomid for women pregnancy delivery buy finasteride 1mg cipro guercmorteo online il generico del priligy forma adecuada de usar cytotec amount of vit. a in accutane viagra edmonton where to buy viagra generic price iframe viagra quel dosage prendre ciprofloxacin 250 mg capsulas de cafe generico propecia reviews order viagra by phone number cialis royal oak reviews of zootopia reliable place to buy clomid finasteride dr. reddy for sale canada and best sites to buy cialis apo doxycycline tablets discount viagra in stoke on trent uk. diflucan 100 mg pret venereal disease doxycycline cialis over the counter in usa what is the generic viagra look like accutane online pharmacy reviews how long after i eat to take viagra whens the best tome to take viagra what is ampicillin and sulbactam used for getting off antabuse buy propecia singapore buying generic cialis online using paypal glimepiride 2mg metformin 500mg pioglitazone 15 mg similar viagra over counter role of doxycycline in diarrhoea eusaprim forte bijsluiter viagra doxycycline cause liver damage jual cialis 80 mg what happens if someone takes viagra where to get finasteride in bangkok cialis 5 mg one day is viagra real online can i take 2 pills of cialis in one day prednisone 5 mg half life blue pill viagra uk london generic drug viagra prednisone 5 mg what is it used for is prednisone safe to use long term 20 buy mg nolvadex buy viagra pill in chicago comprar viagra farmacias ahumada recetario does cialis come in soft gel clomid where to order sildenafil teva 100 mg white tablets difference between generic brand propecia cialis montreal 3 days shipping price of viagra at wallmart metformin hydrochloride 500 mg in pregnancy medicament orapred 20 mg prednisone zoloft and benicar dobeven 500 mg metformin can i get pfizer viagra in blue print get viagra in edmonton without a prescription can you take a half a viagra viagra ersatz online bestellen colruyt propranolol 20 mg withdrawal from hydrocodone what brand of zithromax cures gonorrhea clomid 100mg after 50 mg why would a young guy take viagra zovirax pomada oftalmica onde comprar cialis ireland online has anyone order zithromax wihout a prescription what rate should you hang zithromax 500 mg lasix dosage per kg buy clomid in san antonio tx can you take viagra before surgery prescription drug prices on viagra can another country produce generic cialis brand viagra echeck does clomid or gonadotropins safer democratic socialism in the us diflucan online australia transit liquid research chemicals tadalafil comprar cialis para mujeres italia cialis generico quetiapina 25 mg 60 comprimidos viagra schedule chart for prednisone 10 mg how much is viagra at walmart in canada zovirax tablets australia flag prix du cialis lilly en pharmacie anadrol for sale 50 mg zoloft can i take atenolol with viagra cialis online same day shipping what if a woman takes viagra viagra mexico price como usar cytotec para abortar de 2 meses en venezuela howard stern 100m viagra generic woman accidentally takes cialis finasteride in drug test usual dosage of clomid where can i buy online finasteride in liquid form sildenafil or tadalafil can you overdose on propranolol tadalafil 9 mg med direkt24 viagra generika rezeptfrei kaufen prednisolone 20 mg jenapharm gmbh viagra available as generic india cialis rite aid price generic cialis best prices pneumatic reciprocating saw prices ciprofloxacin prospect de 500 mg controles wii genericos do viagra 1 month supply cost of accutane should viagra give me more than one erction in 4 hours cialis saving coupon viagrapaypal accepted were can i buy viagra liqued democratic socialist in history propecia finasteride prezzo viagra price 2012 achat viagra belgique cialis price retail viagra 50mg discount viagra price up generico del cialis en peru agua desmineralizada donde comprar viagra order doxycycline cod prednisone for bursitis in hip cigarette electronique cialis online liquid tadalafil dosage forms viagra patent expiry uk best buy viagra canada cytotec in der stillzeit can we get viagra in indian medical shops effect of metformin in cancer antibiotics doxycycline bestellen keralites topsyn gel generico de cialis viagra pessaries safe for women to take viginally viagra over the counter belgium prednisone 40 mg dose best foods take doxycycline axio labs generic viagra cheap cialis 5 mgpay pal when can i get pregnant after taking accutane normal dose of amoxil priligy uk can i take doxycycline with lansoprazole red viagra c200 price in karachi viagra 50 mg bivirkninger av antibiotika propecia testosterone precios san jose costa rica prednisolone for cough can you buy viagra at asda benefits of viagra in tamil cipro 500 mg diarrhea home wie lange wirkt viagra 50mg where to buy viagra online usa is it safe to take viagra and cialis zovirax ointment cost cialis in deutschland ohne rezept what cialis mg should i take is brand name adderall xr better than generic viagra ciprofloxacino 500 mg genexx priligy yan etkileri reduced cost cialis zovirax syrup online tab diflucan in pregnancy 50 mg versus 100 mg of clomid tadalafil troche 10 mg troches how much vitamin a does accutane have in it ingredients in generic viagra rite aid cost for 5mg cialis zovirax cream 5g in lloyds chemist who in the world sells the cheapest viagra what is the best time of the day to take prednisone can you take sleeping pills with doxycycline allergy to vibramycin metformin dosage in the elderly price viagra in pakistan price nolvadex in south africa pharmacy does 25 ml viagra work herbal viagra walgreens 5 mg de cialis community service form generic viagra finasteride 0 5 mg eod warrior 25 mg zoloft effective for ocd nombre generico de cytotec drugs going generic viagra week 9 accutane reviews cialis at canadian online pharmacies whats a nolvadex cycle cost viagra vs stendra cost cost doxycycline boots cialis 10 mg cpr pellic medicamento propranolol 10 mg buy cytotec malaysia buying viagra online noprescription when girl takes viagra buying cialis online no prescription what is viagra tablets used for doxycycline mono 100 mg c how do i get a prescription for clomid metformin lost pounds in weeks cipro costs annual returns canada pharmacy online cheap viagra ingredients in herbal viagra cialis original price what is safe dosage of cialis gift sample of sildenafil citrate in hyderabad can 25 mg zoloft cause serotonin syndrome what is the cost of cialis in nz thiabendazole pomada generico de cialis can you take protein shakes while on accutane how much of cialis for real hard erection glimepiride 1mg metformin 500 mg dosage cost viagra for kaiser members zoloft can buy prednisolone liquid inactive ingredients in mucinex how many mgs viagra buy generic viagra in united states serpafar clomid for sale moxiclav 1g 125 mg zoloft zithromax with penicillin allergy 10mg lexapro equal 50 mg zoloft for social anxiety zoloft other uses generic glucophage 500mg zithromax package insert pdf in powerpoint best lip moisturizer accutane users brandstiftung hamburg inderal medication safe dosage doxycycline the cheapest place to buy cialis buy priligy ebay buying clomid from mexico doxycycline dose in guinea pigs sildenafil black market comprare cialis in brasile zoloft goodrx prices european pharmacy generic cialis cheap lily lcos tadalafil cost of 30 2.5milcialis tablets viagra uk genuine viagra online ratings cialis generic 5 mg ciprodex otico generico do viagra generic finasteride 1 mg viagra online compare prices irisina donde comprar viagra metformin pills buy online thuoc flunarizine tablets 10 mg prednisone safely herbal viagra erection in ksa market cada cuanto puedo usar cytotec comprar citrato de sildenafil can i buy doxycycline purchase buy accutane guercmorteo is cialis over the counter in quebec generic viagra by ranbaxy comprar viagra economica should i take 1mg or 5 mg of propecia viagra 50 mg 4 comprimidos retseptita viagra for sale where can i buy clomid in a store se puede usar cytotec por tercera vez is 75 mg of zoloft a high dose prednisone dosing 500 mg zithromax priligy from india comparison chart for viagra from india misoprostol cytotec venta online rosacea treatment accutane price for real viagra doxycycline treating malaria generic sildenafil canada zithromax liquid flavored propecia in bulgaria comprar sildenafil en buenos aires manteca vegetal donde comprar viagra per quanto tempo si puo usare cialis generic black cialis next day delivery clomid cause delayed ovulation selling viagra legal where to buy clomid in tiajuana bid or buy johannesburg viagra viagra pill in chicago ampicillin in lactation diflucan 100 mg per 10 giorni settimana posologie prednisolone 20 mg allergie viagra non prescription ukulele risk of ovarian hyperstimulation with clomid online fincar vs propecia cost zoloft user reviews for anxiety cheapest price viagra deliverd uk prednisolone ubat untuk apa clomid 50 mg nakuur order clomid with no prescription sildenafil 50 mg licor viagra sildenafil in india lowest cuanto debe durar el sangrado despues de usar cytotec winstrol pct clomid for sale zoloft generic serdep 50 order clomid without a prescription do you need prescription cialis uk reviews on ridgid x4 18v reciprocating saw zithromax 900 mg prix why does cialis come in 20 mg and viagra in 50 mg how long till generic viagra tadalafil 40 mg for ed generic viagra soft tablets sale buy viagra boston zovirax herpes simplex price boots doxycycline singapure where can buy sildenafil citrate brand names include womenra sertraline zoloft generic soy and clomid in the same cycle deltacortene 25 mg compresse prednisone 10 viagra over counter in las vegas viagra professional at walmart spirotone tab 25 mg zoloft ear infection doxycycline finasteride safe dose doxycycline dosage in dog overnight viagra delivery in the usa how long does a.50mg generic viagra work for how much does accutane cost in california accutane 80 mg import viagra to uk viagra from canadian pharmacies no prescription online gonorrhea treated with doxycycline order cialis 10mg 20 tabs cost of cipro 500 availability of genuine viagra in chennai india ampicillin dose for bacterial meningitis atrial fibrillation and use of viagra doxycycline 150 mg acne viagra in shopper drug mart use of metformin in cancer is viagra over the counter in montreal safe take imitrex zoloft socialist realist painting famous written works inderal 40 mg preco buy nolvadex online uk no perscription does clomid cause multiples medicamentos propecia reviews jeednya enterprises viagra online cialis 20 mg look like metformin er 1000 price cialis cost comparisons zovirax dispersable 800 mg precio propecia buy online australia how much viagra cost at walmart pharmacy cialis generico mexico viagra in broad meadows metformin hydrochloride 500mg online lasix in livestock t cell lymphoma specialist in maryland pediatric zithromax dose take vitamin e with accutane rdy 273 generic cialis comprar viagra sin receta foro propranolol nome generico e comercial ampicillin dosage for throat infection can you buy cialis in canada over the counter zoloft dosage social anxiety disorder finasteride generic brands of valium doxycycline in birds order clomid next day delivery warrior viagra for sale in south africa shelf life of cialis tablets does cialis cause blindness substitute for viagra natural cialis lilly 20mg price order azithromax overnight buy viagra uk boots the chemist marketing viagra vs cialis amoxil for 7 years old price aldactone 25mg generico do viagra mantidan nome generico de cialis can i buy doxycycline over the counter in canada ciprobay ciprofloxacin price in phil Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Espiando nossos amigos (Spying on our friends).

Espiando nossos amigos (Spying on our friends).

datePosted on 11:58, October 10th, 2013 by Pablo

Well well well.

Edward Snowden has revealed that the Canadian signals intelligence agency Communications Security Establishment Canada (CSEC), a Five Eyes partner of New Zealand’s signals intelligence agency GCSB, has been electronically spying on a communications network operated by the Brazilian mines and energy ministry. Brazil has a strategy of using its natural resources exploitation to become a major power, and the Ministry of Mining and Energy (MME) is the coordination node for that strategy. The network connected the ministry, state run oil and mine companies and private Brazilian energy firms, and was a forum where subjects such as investment strategies, negotiating positions and other sensitive commercial information were discussed. This included comunications with firms such as Petrobras, the Brazilian state-owned oil conglomerate.

Needless to say, the MME communications network, presumably internet and telephonic in nature, would be of value to competitors or others seeking to countervail Brazilian economic growth and power projection. With its own energy sector comprising a vital part of Canada’s economy (often in competition with Brazilian interests), it should not be entirely surprising that the Canadian government authorized this instance of economic espionage.

CSEC shared what it obtained with its Five Eyes partners. That particular revelation follows on the heels of Snowden disclosing that the NSA tapped into the personal as well as official communications of Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff, although it is unclear if these were also shared with the other Five Eyes partners.

The CESC angle is interesting because Brazil is no adversary of the Five Eyes nations (in fact, it has a history of alliance with the US) and because Petrobras is a direct competitor of US and Canadian energy firms in a number of markets, including some in the Asia-Pacific. Petrobras has also been involved in pushing for off-shore oil and gas exploration rights in New Zealand, which means that the New Zealand government is quite possibly privy, in advance and thanks to the Canadians, to the Brazilian’s internal logics and bottom lines with regards to those ventures.

If so, it is possible that the recently passed legislation to severely curtail sea demonstrations against oil and gas exploration in New Zealand waters was motivated not by a direct request from Petrobras and other energy sector actors, but by direct knowledge of its internal concerns about the cost impact of such demonstrations if left unchecked. If this speculation is correct, it would be a twist to the economic espionage tale because the National government used the information gleaned by Echelon to help rather than hinder the activities of a foreign based private firm facing strong domestic opposition.

Whatever the specifics, the Canadian-Brazilian spy saga confirms what Snowden has previously disclosed, which is that the Five Eyes network routinely engages in economic espionage on allies as well as adversaries. Brazil has protested the intrusions vigorously, most recently by calling in the Canadian ambassador in Brasilia to complain about the breach of trust and previously by means of President Rousseff’s scathing speech to the UN General Assembly where she denounced the practice of spying on friends and partners. The Brazilians denunciations are not just rhetoric–they are actively looking for ways to create alternative internet routing systems that can circumvent US dominance of fiber optic cable networks. They have been joined in this initiative by–no surprises here–the Chinese.

Given these revelations, the questions begs as to what the GCSB is doing when it comes to economic espionage on allies or partners as well as adversaries. Given the Canadian revelations and given that Canada is considered to be a junior partner in Echelon/Five Eyes just like New Zealand, by what means does the GCSB do so and does it share the information that it collects with its Five Eyes counterparts?

We must remember that it is already known that the GCSB has eavesdropped on Japanese diplomatic communications regarding whaling and on UN communications in the build up to both Gulf Wars. Although this is a more traditional form of signals intelligence gathering in that it targeted diplomatic intercepts, the communications being intercepted were from a country that New Zealand is friendly with and an organization that New Zealand has been a champion of (and in which it is lobbying for a seat on the Security Council).

The revelations are important because it suggests that economic espionage by the Five Eyes network is pervasive and equally shared amongst the partners.

If I were involved with a Chinese firm, to say nothing of Petrobras and any number of other foreign commercial entities (state or private), I would be concerned about doing business in and with New Zealand given what we now know (so far–there is more to come). Forget milk powder contamination and other production snafus: the real issue is not so much product quality or reliability but whether New Zealand can be trusted to not use its signals intelligence capabilities and network to engage in the type of economic espionage the Canadians and Americans are clearly doing (and one would assume the Australians and British are doing as well). That the GCSB can now do it locally as well as from afar (thanks to the recently passed GCSB Act amendments) should double the concern.

The same concerns might be raised by the eight countries involved in negotiating the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) trade and investment agreement that are not Echelon members. Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the US are parties to the negotiations, which given the Snowden revelations raises questions as to what they might covertly know about the other countries’ negotiating positions and about how much of what they might know is shared exclusively amongst themselves in order to better coordinate their approaches to the negotiations.

It should also be remembered that the NSA used private telecommunications firms and other corporate entities to cast its signals trolling net overseas. Does the GCSB do the same?

Of course, other countries engage in economic espionage. The Chinese, Russians, French and Israelis are known for it. But none of these countries have had their means and targets exposed in public, nor do they have the reach of the Five Eyes network at their disposal.

It is a big difference. If the Chinese, Russians or many others, either directly via state agencies or through  any number of non-state (including corporate) fronts, want to obtain signals intelligence abroad, they have to do so covertly. But the Five Eyes partners freely share their signals intelligence. In other words, non-Five Eyes signals intelligence agencies have to try and sneak through back doors to access the sensitive information of others, whereas the Echelon members freely pass surreptitiously gathered information through the front doors of their respective signals intelligence agencies.

Perhaps that is why the GCSB and TSIC Bills have been pushed so hard and so fast by the National government. The concern was not about terrorism, which served as a good fig leaf. The concern was not just defensive, in countering cyber and signals espionage on New Zealand targets and interests No, the concern was as much if not more offensive in nature in that the new powers of the GCSB facilitates exactly the type of spying that the CSEC was engaged in with regard to Brazil.

More precisely, before the passage of the Bills (I am assuming that the TSIC bill will pass) the GCSB could engage in economic espionage on friendly countries and firms but the legality of it doing so was in question when it came to it engaging in such spying (as well as more traditional types of signals intelligence) on New Zealand soil. Now it can do so legally. Any country or firm not part of the Five Eyes network that proposes to do business with or in New Zealand needs to take account of that.

The bottom line is that the Snowden revelations increasingly point to GCSB involvement in economic espionage of the first order. It may be only a matter of time before he drops a bombshell about the who, what and where of GCSB espionage. For a minuscule isolated nation heavily dependent on trade with foreign partners for its economic prosperity, this could be a potentially disastrous development.

2 Responses to “Espiando nossos amigos (Spying on our friends).”

  1. Edward Main on October 14th, 2013 at 20:14

    ” revelations increasingly point to GCSB involvement in economic espionage of the first order ”

    Question: For the benefit of who??

    Certainly not for our country

    More than likely for our Prime Minister’s foreign pay masters

  2. Pablo on October 14th, 2013 at 20:42

    Edward:

    I also wonder about that. My impression is that the Five Eyes partners do not militarily or diplomatically spy on each other but instead share each other’s intelligence up to a point, and that they agree to not engage in economic espionage on each other but will share what they obtain from others via SIGINT, TECHINT or HUMINT collection. The beneficiaries, at least in the first instance, are elite economic interests.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: