cost real viagra autoimmune progesterone dermatitis specialist uk doxycycline hyclate dosage lyme disease reviews online viagra ordering cipro hc otic buy online 0.5 mg propecia effective viagra on line united states lactic acidosis in metformin priligy quando prenderlo bulbos de azafran donde comprar viagra cipro tqeovertoz reviews amoxicillin versus ampicillin tadalafil overseas cheap cost ampicillin 500mg is liquid nolvadex injectable viagra in dragon mart prozac 40 mg starting dose of zoloft buy your viagra with paypal buy metformin from canada metformin 500 mg best time to take dapoxetine brand names in pakistan iman 100 clomid mg buy single pills online zithromax viagra replacements over counter where to buy viagra in hyderabad donde puedo comprar cytotec en caracas best price online viagra best time of the day to take cialis where to buy authentic viagra online deltasone hereisthebestin dosage research chemicals for sale nolvadex dosage online viagra consumer check sildenafil black market when do you start taking clomid in your steroid cycle viagra purchase nz generic medications accutane prednisolone dose mgkg credit card payment form generic viagra inderal 40 mg anxiety prednisolone 20 mg contre indication who sells zithromax in virginia dove acquistare viagra zithromax safe cardura and viagra does clomid cause swelling zoloft pills online where can i buy viagra in hong kong estimated viagra market can you buy tadalafil over the counter in toronto low dose cialis 5 mg post finasteride syndrome safe take viagra age 18 metformin xr available in canada finasteride indian pharmacy companies what is propranolol 60 mg viagra australia supplier zovirax suspension pediatrica 200 mg nhs prices viagra where to buy prednisone 5mg rotundine 60 mg prednisone cialis generic non generic when is the best time for older guys to take viagra propecia for women in canada medicament cialis prix en pharmacie viagra shops in sydney doxycycline online uk obat provula 50 mg viagra zovirax 200 mg tablets en walmart buy zithromax online using paypal deutschland online apotheke cialis cost cialis taking 40 mg types of viagra in egypt lasix causes kidney failure viagra camden london viagra effectiveness reviews azithromax price philippines where i can buy viagra in lahore pakistan artrolive generico do viagra cheap generic viagra 100mg canada generic finasteride sun pharma viagra over the counter belgium skinoren 150 mg generic viagra trinalin generic propecia dosering doxycycline vogels en farmacias similares vende tadalafil generic what is maximum viagra dose propecia brand on line glucophage 1000 mg merck serono zoloft show up in urine test cialis 5 mg how much cialis generika in frankreich kaufen medical code for pregnancy resulted in clomid metformina que efectos causa cipla generic viagra review costo de viagra en lima much does viagra cost private prescription accutane 10 mg for oily skin glucophage dergboadre australia metformin in coronary artery disease news on generic viagra metformin 500 mg for fertility viagra delivered in two days no prescription cialis 2.5 mg viagra non prescription ukulele superdrug viagra cost best time to take zoloft medication buying cialis in berlin georgia concealed carry reciprocating states acheter viagra en ligne avec paypal uk cialis 20mg how maney rupese in india pret propranolol 40 mg best way use propecia whats viagra pills in srilanka degenerics generic accutane vente viagra europe were to buy viagra chicago finasteride generic manufacturers of norco diunorm 25 mg of zoloft panca inderal lidah in english cialis 5 mg nota 75 finasteride 1.25 mg results buy zovirax canada viagra sildenafil in india lowest how does cialis cost buy generic propranolol la didrogesterona 10 mg prednisone doxycycline user reviews ubat clomid 50mg can i take 5 htp 100 mg with viagra how much does propecia cost uk clomid wrong dose secure online sights for lasix propranolol 10mg prices sildenafil citrate pills canada how many mg of tadalafil should i take propranolol hcl 40 mg para que sirve ortosamin generico do viagra where to buy viagra in tucson tadalafil professional review zithromax reviews when is priligy available in australia generika viagra test l ornitina l aspartato generico do viagra can i take cialis with atenolol lasix generic name and classification does the propecia generic brand work buy in uk viagra doxycycline hyclate 100 mg empty stomach effects of cialis on blood pressure buying clomid from mexico ampicillin and dicloxacillin tablets nolvadex australia suppliers cialis 28 cpr 5 mg prezzo 40 mg cialis dose response doe zithromax show up in a drug test ciprofloxacin uti price india how long dies it take viagra to work buying cytotec online clomid 50mg bebe viagra article in hindi black cobra sildenafil 120mg india purchse viagra in australia viagra dosage over 65 normal dose of amoxil metformin not digesting in system vitamins safely taken with prednisone zovirax 400 mg dosing buy cytotec online south africa retina specialist in manassas virginia how many mg of viagra how to use clomid and metformin viagra available as generic india diflucan online australia transit amlodipine 5mg safe with viagra can i take viagra with me into france from ireland pain in legs from prednisone 20mg safe take ciprofloxacin metronidazole how to get viagra over the counter in san clement walgreens cialis cost per pill propecia in jhb gold viagra 800 mg detrusitol retard 4 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin propecia in combination with marijuana ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg high performance cialis two 5 mg diodoquin generico do viagra viagra sold in utah safe to take 100mg viagra london ontario viagra 150 mgs clomid prices cialis how many days do you take ampicillin cialis 10 mg cpr pellic viagra accepting paypal ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg antibiotics espanol can you crush cialis and put in drink doxycycline hyclate acne 100 mg brandstiftung hamburg inderal medication most reliable place to buy cialis online buying clomid in thailand finasteride hair loss increase to 5 mg propecia genericode viagra online viagra buy prescription how to tell if liquid nolvadex is real or fake prednisolone 5mg tablets buy one get one free allergy to vibramycin zoloft costco pharmacy cheapest generic cialis 10mg cialis yearly sales viagra online bestellen hilversum why is lasix used for heart failure comprare cialis on line in italia cost of propecia and minnoxidol can you buy viagra over the counter in boots female viagra otc in mexico risks of clomid accutane smallest dose nolvadex for prohormones where to buy cheap thermoskin tem generico do viagra comprar viagra en madrid ciudad universitaria glucophage 500 mg pcos awareness how to buy viagra from walmart order viagra on the internet did justin timberlake take accutane prednisolone acetate 1 15 ml order accutane online uk how to know how many mg of cialis i need to take how much does nolvadex cost street price doxycycline dosage for sinus infections 1000 mg. metformin twice daily prednisone used for colds metformin 425 mg donde puedo comprar la pastilla priligy tadalafil troche 10 mg troches cost of prednisone tablets how to ask your boyfriend to take viagra cialis mezza dose ampicillin 100mg ml stability balls dermosolon 50 mg zoloft cialis online order dapoxetine brands in pakistan sick over the counter viagra countries with dual citizenship cialis 5 mg one day accutane acne treatments what happen when i taked 2 viagra in one day will 30 mg cialis hurt you propecia discount coupon prescription for clomid cost of doxycycline at costco isotretinoina 20 mg generico do viagra 25 mg viagra recreational capitalist socialism in islam religion amoxil injection price is lasix safe for breastfeeding how many cialis 5 mg can you take prednisolone acid 10 mg nebenwirkungen pille viagra purple triangle pill wholesale viagra sales revenue is ciprofloxacin safe in pregnancy ingesting tadalafil 20 mg first hour clomid challenge test with 50 mg clomid cialis daily how to use que es diflucan 200 mg is 160mg of prednisone be safe while pregant zithromax package insert pdf in powerpoint generic viagra how good is it getting a prescription for accutane prednisone and fluid in ear infecciones causadas por cytotec para que sirve metformin hydrochloride 1000 mg buying clomid 100 mg 10 pills propecia tablet price prednisone 40 mg dose where can i buy viagra over the counter in italy cialis depression treatment price clomid pasadena nausea after taking accutane can i take 2 pills of cialis in one day where to buy doxycycline with no prescription propecia price change why does metformin not dissolve in body cialis 5 mg apotek tadalafil counter cipro dergboadre canada zoloft in timpul sarcinii cialis de 5 mg uso diario aprovel tem generico do viagra cialis dosage 40 mg do you need a prescription for cialis in grand cayman rosacea treatment accutane where can you buy a viagra in sydney india online pharmacy zovirax 15g soft cialis usa generic of clomid propranolol 20 mg withdrawal from hydrocodone cipromed 500 usage cialis generic 5 mg como comprar cialis em portugal socialism in america author real name price of 5mg cialis how to get propecia in south africa clomid chemist warehouse reciprocating saw cordless sale indian viagra dropshipper shipped from usa generic viagra puede causar la muerte cytotec induction franca lai viagra generic buy sildenafil research raw powder zovirax in hong kong diflucan 150 mg used can clomid cause headaches cheapest generic viagra sent overnight cialis generic 10 mg without prescription cytotec for sale in kuwait shops vulvodynia specialists in clearwater florida communism vs socialism effects in world is viagra over the counter in jamaica viagra en mexico venta viagra monologues review consumo viagra in italia is 200 mg diflucan for yeast too strong what is diflucan used for in women generic finasteride or propecia cost viagra treatment for premature ejaculation cialis 4 hour erection how to get doxycycline in singapore viagra for sale in ottawa diffuse thinning propecia online pharmacy canada viagra pharmacy doxycycline without prescription in usa cialis daily use canadian pharmacies can you buy zovirax walgreens is fish oil safe to take with zoloft when is viagra available as generic classification of adrenocorticosteroids prednisone buy cialis pharmacy si puo usare zovirax gravidanza buy lasix without a perscription metformin er user reviews where can i buy online finasteride in liquid form u s cheap viagra novocaine buy online uk viagra getting viagra in las vegas viagra substitute over the counter at gnc cytotec argentinacomprar prednisone is for in leukaemia whats in cobra viagra 10 mgday accutane doxycycline hyclate 20mg tablets doxycycline hyclate cap 300 mg prednisone at walamrt prices buy doxycycline hyclate tablets without prescription sildenafil bubble gum price buyviagrapillsonline search does doxycycline hyclate 150 mg work for epididymitis how much does 1 30 day supply of 5mg cialis cost real viagra montreal finasteride take at night cialis dosage info does clomid or gonadotropins safer ridiculous high price of viagra using clomid purchase online lasix diuretic cost generic drug viagra inderal 40 mg and augmentin xbox one chile donde comprar viagra is sildenafil a generic drug kann viagra ohne rezept apotheke kaufen lopid 600 mg generico de cialis accutane in shanghai cialis soft tabs 5 mg zithromax 1 gm price cipro suspension generic manfaat vibramycin 100 mg tell fake viagra pills where buy clomid how many doses of cytotec is safe viagra in nassua viagraonline com viagra history in urdu lasix j code doxycycline online experience with generic tadalafil donde comprar cialis generico en colombia metformin 500 mg price philippines finasteride farmaco generico viagra availability in islamabad safety abra sildenafil citrate accutane acne generic venta de cytotec en costa rica most economical dosage of cialis to buy sildenafil from india finasteride in australia medicare feline doxycycline hyclate 100 mg 2 times zoloft 25 mg withdrawal from cymbalta viagra e ponte de safena liquid clomid numb tongue buy nolvadex post cycle therapy australia viagra availability in germany purchase metformin baownbeuv can a normal guy take viagra usar pastillas cytotec para abortar elite gain 350 viagra for sale finasteride indian.men cheap generic cialis c20 where to get viagra in qatar cialis on prescription in uk does clomid increase chances of getting pregnant espidifen nombre generico de amoxil what does a generic viagra pill look like viagra prices india us paracetamol cialis generika 20 mg kaufen dapoxetine in europe doxycycline mgkg 10mg accutane on cycle can buy viagra over counter australian viagra bad for you products with tadalafil in them average price viagra 100mg prednisone 50 mg for 5 days bronchitis medication diflucan cream available india hong kong viagra over the counter cialis raise blood pressure metformin 500 mg ne ise yarar order propecia men non generic metformin 1000mg generic viagra com can i bring viagra to costa rica how much liquid clomid for pct lasix used for pleural effusion drs who believe propecia is safe mechanism of action of propranolol in angina pectoris ebastine 20 mg comprimidos viagra clotrimazole 10mg generic cialis how long does a lasix renogram take usa pfizer viagra propranolol online kaufen boots sell viagra over counter can i eat cialis 2 20 mg can you safely take cialis and l arginine together comprar dapoxetine online want to buy cialis discount pills viagra for women available in lahore order tadalafil hereisthebestin can you buy viagra tenerife south zithromax 1000 mg liquid form peranex 20 mg prednisone viagra generika billig kaufen ciprofloxacin difficulty urinating in men viagra kamagra australia payment paypal betalol brand propranolol pengertian panca inderal lidah in english which european nations are socialist cialis 800 mg not real para que se receta el ciprofloxacino 500 mg zovirax suspension costo doxycycline sold online commonly found tadalafil tablets in india doxycycline 1 mg suspension for guinea pigs no script accutane 5 mg day lang en order free viagra sample betahistine long term usage of zoloft is testim safe to use with viagra propecia finasteride prezzo 2000 mg ampicillin voglibose and metformin hydrochloride tablets farmacie online per viagra coupon ciprofloxacino stada efg 500 mg camber zoloft 25 mg pill does doxycycline treat malaria discovery health viagra cialis 5mg kaina 2500 mg metformin how to purchase viagra in australia clomid cause delayed ovulation over the counter evuivalent to viagra can clomid cause excessive discharge tadalafil 20 mg description uso de doxycycline hyclate 100 mg best viagra pill splitter doxycycline swallowing problems metformin 4 mg viagra with out prescription paypal where can i buy doxycycline for humans dose kalenjin comedy propecia reviews can you buy viagra at stores viagra cialis in qatar kegunaan obat sildenafil tab 25 mg prednisone 10 mg dose pack 489 buy cialis auckland nz cipro antibiotic 750 mg prices 10 mg lasix bodybuilding does zoloft make you really tired thuoc viagra mua o dau is viagra available for pensioners in australia how much does 10 mg of cialis cost trustable generic viagra singapore where can buy viagra viagra in treatment of pulmonary hypertension fertility drug like clomid for sale Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Deconstructing the US Terrorism Meta-narrative.

Deconstructing the US Terrorism Meta-narrative.

datePosted on 17:50, April 19th, 2013 by Pablo

Broadly speaking, the way in which terrorists have been depicted in the US has some interesting, contrasting themes. White native-born (male) individuals who commit acts of politically-motivated lethal violence are generally depicted as marginalized sociopathic psychos rather than as individuals acting out of sincere ideological belief (I say “sincere” because homicidal individuals often attach themselves or attribute their actions to political causes without fully subscribing to the ideological precepts underpinning them). This lumps this type of terrorist in with genuinely insane psychopaths and allows the state to address their acts as criminal offenses rather than as political crimes.

For example, the Unabomber, Oklahoma City bombers and Atlanta Olympics bomber all acted out of sincere ideological conviction (Unabomber Ted Kaczynski published a 35,000 word manifesto of his beliefs). Yet, they were treated by the justice system less like al-Qaeda style fighters and more like the criminally deranged Tucson shooter who wounded Congresswoman Gabrielle Gifford and killed six others.

In the 1960s and 1970s groups like the Black Panthers, Symbionese Liberation Army and Weathermen were treated as guerrilla groups, which by definition recognizes that their challenges to authority are based on contrary political ideologies. These groups marshaled their opposition to the White Anglo Saxon Protestant Capitalist (WASP/C) status quo along racial and class lines. The used an unconventional war of position to convey their counter-hegemonic resistance to things as given. Because of this, the state saw them as an existential threat that challenged the socio-economic, cultural and political parameters of US society. They were treated accordingly, which in some cases slipped into extra-judicial punishment.

The predominant US born white male terrorist profile is that of a loner or small cell member whose ideological foundation is at the core of the WASP/C value system. The WASP/C terrorist believes in individual choice and natural rights in a free market unencumbered by tyranny. He may believe in God, a preferred religion and/or racial hierarchy. He despises the central (federal) government, foreign agencies and often times large corporations.

In effect, his armed critique of the system comes from deep within rather than from without. He sees the usurpation of traditional values and hierarchies as evidence of terminal moral decline, and he feels compelled to stand against it. He is a modern Minuteman.

This is why the WASP/C terrorist is treated like a psychopath rather than as a guerrilla or unconventional fighter. His values are too “close to the bone” of the US belief system to be treated first as an ideological critique rather than as deranged.  Instead, the WASP/C terrorist is profiled as having severe unresolved personal issues, to include sublimated or repressed sexual urges that are eventually expressed through anti-social violence. However he is portrayed, his political motivations are downplayed in favor of flawed personal psychological traits.

In recent times the terrorist challenge in the US has been seen by the state as coming from foreign-based Muslims and their domestic supporters. These have been treated much in the way the guerrilla groups of the 1960s and 1970s were. They are depicted as having an ideology that is anathema to the American way of life. They are held to hate US values and its freedoms. The fight against them is framed in existential and civilizational terms. Focus on the criminality of their acts is shared by focus on the ideological reasons for them. They are considered to be ideological enemies as much if not more than as criminals.

The two-track meta-narrative on terrorists allows the US to reaffirm its core beliefs without subjecting them to re-examination. It reinforces the dominant ideology by differentiating between criminal and political violence along lines that do not challenge core WASP/C values and beliefs, which are now shared by non-WASPs and WASPs alike (popularized in the “anyone can make it here” credo epitomized by the Obama presidency).

Although it is easy to see why the US would adopt this meta-narrative on terrorism, it is unfortunate. It creates two standards of justice, one political and one criminal, with which to treat terrorists. This is inimical to the equal justice underpinnings of liberal democracies and paves the way for the creation of parallel judicial systems such as that seen in the Guantanamo Bay military tribunals.

It would seem preferable to treat all terrorism as criminal offenses. The issue is not whether the perpetrators are foreign or domestic. The type and location of the crime is what matters, and issues of nationality or domicile are at most the justification for extradition requests. Political or psychological reasons can be offered as an explanation for why terrorist acts were committed, but they cannot be used for the purposes of meting our different standards of justice. That has the benefit of reassuring friend and foe alike that the focus will be on the crime, not the cause.

That, in of itself, can be a significant deterrent to those who would otherwise pursue terrorism as a form of political expression.

Postscript: It will be interesting to see which narrative emerges with regard to the Chechnyan brothers involved in the Boston bombings. Home grown, self-radicalized small cell jihadis, part of an international al-Qaeda plot, or siblings with some creepy inter-personal dynamics? The rightwing US media already see the Muslim -bashing angle as the preferred interpretation, but the official government response (so far) is to not be as quick to attribute ideological rather than criminal intent to their actions.

5 Responses to “Deconstructing the US Terrorism Meta-narrative.”

  1. Hugh on April 20th, 2013 at 20:33

    My guess is that the Tsarnaevs were ‘lone wolves’ – they probably admired Muslim groups like Al Qaeda or (more likely) Dokha Umarov’s Islamic Emirate of the Caucasus, but acted without any chain of command or support.

    As for the overarching narrative of terrorism, IMO Paul Pillar said it best (and he said it about 15 years ago, too):

    “[He] saw terrorism fundamentally as ‘a challenge to be managed, not solved’… Terrorist attacks seemed likely to become a permanent feature of American experience… He objected to the metaphor of waging ‘war’ against terrorism because ‘it is a war that cannot be won’ and also ‘unlike most wars, it has neither a fixed set of enemies nor the prospect of coming to closure’. A better analogy than war might be ‘the effort by public health authorities to control communicable diseases’. A lesson of American counterterrorism efforts since the 1980s was that the threat could not defeated, only ‘reduced, attenuated, and to some degree controlled’. Striving for zero terrorist attacks would be as unhealthy for American foreign policy as striving for zero unemployment would be for the economy…”

  2. Pablo on April 21st, 2013 at 08:51

    Hugh:

    Pillar’s argument is not a narrative. It is a proposed approach, one that I tend to agree with. Narratives are constructed as a means of interpreting events and assigning motivation, responsibility, causality etc. They can be legitimating or delegitimating depending on the subject and the narrator’s point of view. They may be related to the counter-terrorism approach but are not the same thing.

    The Tsarnaevs cannot be Lone Wolves because by definition the Lone Wolf operates alone. These fellows appear to be very typical WASP/C terrorists in small cell, self radicalized guise, with the wrinkle being that they are Muslim and Chechnyan. I would not be surprised if the official narrative treats them as WASP/C types.

  3. Lew on April 21st, 2013 at 09:36

    I would not be surprised if the official narrative treats them as WASP/C types.

    Indications that they (the brother who remains alive, and three others arrested in connection) are to be tried as criminals in civilian court, and not as post-9/11 enemy combatants, seem to confirm this view. The counter is Fox News and various conservative extremists shrieking about how Muslims is Muslims, and al-Qaeda has been trying to recruit Caucasians to defeat the authorities’ hugely-effective ethnic profiling strategy.

    L

  4. Pablo on April 21st, 2013 at 10:10

    Alan Dershowitz did a brilliant job of demolishing the enemy combatant suggestion as well as the FBI justification for not reading the younger brother his Miranda Rights under the public safety exception clause. He noted that the wounded suspect was a) no longer a threat to public safety; and b) a US citizen. He said that the FBI has already committed a major error by not reading him his rights and that even a public defender will have a field day with that violation as well as any attempt to classify him as an enemy combatant for the purposes of subjecting him to a military tribunal rather than a criminal court.

    Given the severity of his wounds, the rationale that he needed to be questioned without the Miranda warning in the interest of locating other conspirators will be grounds for legal challenge as well. He was down for the count, in shock, semi-conscious, and therefore unable to give consent much less a coherent answer to all but the most rudimentary question.

    Should he survive, be prepared for a lengthy court process because the challenges and arguments will be many and from both sides. It is, after all, the American way of litigation.

    The fact that Senators John McCain and Lindsey Graham (both Republicans) called for him to be treated as an enemy combatant shows how desperate the GOP is, as well as its disregard for fundamental protections under the law.

  5. Hugh on April 21st, 2013 at 17:52

    It saddens me that “He’s a US Citizen” is seen as an argument in favour of upholding Miranda rights. The Miranda ruling did not mention citizenship, and the rights it was intended to safeguard are not limited to US Citizens, but to anybody arrested by US authorities.

    Having said that, I think Jerry Seinfeld has a pretty significant point when he says that Miranda is so widespread in popular culture that everybody basically knows their rights in that situation anyway.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: