can i take viagra at 16 what is difference cialis 10 and 20 mg viagra tablets for premature ejaculation doxycycline hyclate solubility in ethanol sildenafil cost australia visa metformin 2500 mg a day how much cialis cost in walgreens deca best dosage for cialis who takes clomid sildenafil north carolina tour di cipro in auto furosemide lasix prescriptions overnight multiple treatments of accutane cost o que e um viagra generic sildenafil citrate 50mg tablets 60 mg of prednisone for 5 days for sinus yj generics for viagra sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg kamagra pro 100 viagra how long before sex do you take it cost of propecia on nhs farmacia online italia cialis free ciproxin 250 mg bijsluiter mejor farmacia online cialis difference in viagra and cialis bascula de precision donde comprar viagra finasteride accord 5 mg tabletten pharma grade nolvadex online pharmacy a amoxil 500 mg can i find generic cialis cabo sildenafil ratiopharm bestellen closest to viagra over counter what does accutane cause trusted seller of cytotec in the philippines what is in the alchol shot viagra can you really buy real viagra online retail price for viagra 100mg crestor 20 mg obat apa methylprednisolone sam clubs price for viagra 25 mg what is the dosage for daily cialis viagra where can we buy is delayed backache really a side effect of cialis prednisone therapy in pregnancy viagra uk nhs how to treat heartburn caused by doxycycline amoxil 500 mg glaxosmithkline consumer longines watches buy online uk viagra cialis 10 mg vs 20g price snovitra 60 mg prednisone what does viagra cost is there an over the counter pill like viagra viagra online shop empfehlung wurde cheap generic viagra 150 mg sildenafil citrate tramadol tablets viagra online purchase in mumbai clomid from india memberdata portal portrait viagra vonline xquerynow com socialist party usa was founded in how to buy viagra in indonesia como comprar cytotec en nicaragua is there an over the counter propecia 500 mg metfomin and clomid is there a tadalafil generic cialis monohydrate de doxycycline prix phospha 250 neutral generic cialis how long it takes for accutane to start working is amoxil in the penicillin family buy online viagra from ireland by laser i want a price on viagra in south africa what is the average cost of cipro romania farmacie online viagra order cheap real viagra advisable to take amoxil at six months pregancy old doxycycline walmart 4 dollar list comprar sildenafil cordoba argentina viagra ou cialis lequel choisir viagra sale metro manila qg5 formula generic a viagra doxycycline 400 mg par jour viagra online to buy 150mg amoxil while breastfeeding can you get viagra at boots doxycycline hyclate 100mg information finasteride in postmenopausal women no insurance viagra cost at rite aid costumes for viagra best price viagra cialis nolvadex come si usa amoxil 500mg capsule price in pakistan will nolvadex show up in a drug test ringing in ears propranolol 40mg golf 6 gti for sale in uk zithromax viagra soft tabs usage a las cuantas semanas es recomendable usar cytotec viagra dose 150 mg acquisto viagra generico in contrassegno gelato accutane market withdrawal i doser viagra free download stilpane generic cialis corvasal generic viagra ciprofloxacino 250 mg dosis dias viagra professional 100mg pills buy sildenafil st. maarten zoloft 25 mg dose how do you take prednisone in asthma dosage clomid over the counter uk how many mg of ciprofloxacin cana 20 puond dog take is viagra prescription only is it safe to take viagra at 18 prednisone 5 mg tabletki dla dzieci purchase viagra online safe price per tablet of cialis chances getting pregnant twins clomid toko viagra online does generic sildenafil work for women viagra sales in chennai madras where in ireland can i buy viagra buy viagra with discover card generic prednisone 20mg dose prednisone equivalent india accutane and gastrointestinal disorders undigested metformin in stool price of 500mg viagra pill in indian rupees which pharmacy has the best price on viagra imovane 7 5 mg bijsluiter viagra generic cipro ear drops difference between viagra and cialis dosage what is the action of metformin in corps. cialis gold price zithromax generic cheap 200 mg dose of doxycycline for malaria viagra in sydeny canine use of doxycycline finasteride 5mg teilen best viagra capsule how long does cipro last in the bottle propecia for hair growth in men esomezol 20 mg prednisone how to buy viagra with a mastercard capval tropfen 25 mgg dosierung viagra cost of clomid iui lasix equine uk supplier doxycycline kegunaan 50 mg safety of viagra purchesed from hong kong sildenafil 100 cheap how to buy cialis online to india prix du viagra en pharmacie maroc brooks dyad 8 womens reviews on viagra images of cialis pills what dosage viagra to take quitaxon 25 mg zoloft doxycycline 100 mg 8 capsules ciprofloxacin hcl 250 mg ta gluten free viagra australia chemist online duane reade price for propecia thuoc teva prednisone 50 mg la thuoc gi viagra increased dosage phenoleptil 25 mg zoloft what is thr retail price of cialis how to use cialis 5mg muvinor 500 mg metformin pink viagra for women at canadian pharmacy can you take propecia once a week sample viagra australia queensland carprodyl 50 mg zoloft doxycycline mechanism action malaria in africa se puede usar cytotec a las 12 semanas accutane causes scarring online viagra purchase in uae boots viagra over the counter ezentia 10 mg prednisone propecia 1 mg foglio illustrativo lasix in thrombocytopenia alternative viagra drug reviews viagra over counter drug prednisone 50 mg per day of caffeine cialis originale comprare drug metformin 500 mg buy finasteride with visa card doxycycline price gouging during disasters where to buy cheap cytotec prospecto ebastel forte flas 20 mg prednisone ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tabs for crazy generic lasix 100mg x 120 furosemide drept de folosinta viagra generic annual sales for viagra does accutane cause bipolar yaz generico do viagra is zithromax a safe medicine for an 18 month old infant buy liquid sildenafil citrate where to buy amoxil pediatrico zithromax 500 mg opis doxycycline montreal diflucan online viagra kiev buy prescription cialis cost with medco sildenafil pfizer bestellen to find viagra in india can you purchase doxycycline over counter viagra tablet usage in the classroom viagra tablets available in peshawar is zovirax safe while pregnant doxycycline safe birth control viagra online snabb leverans dosage of doxycycline for skin infection pariet generico do viagra atenolol vs propranolol in essential tremor can you take doxycycline hyclate with milk finasteride in the uk para que serve o medicamento selozok 50 mg zoloft generic clomid tablet made over counter viagra new york misoprostol cytotec used in pediatric patients what is used in place of cialis side effect of propecia in philippines ampicillin action and target maxidex generic viagra online job application no response to clomid tadalafil tadacip cipla reviews buy viagra for men online tadalafil billig kaufen deutschland uber is viagra off patent purchase 30 doxycycline online with mastercard zithromax in the sun did cialis have a price increase maximum doxycycline dose sarasota buy genuine viagra getting viagra london informacion de medicamento cialis online viagra for women gujarat price metformin in type i dm herbs to take with clomid canadian pharmacy 100mg viagra 100 doxycycline mg amoxil 750 mg indian price use the word socialism in a sentence how do they work dapoxetine 60 mg tablets clomid decrease from 100 mg to 50 mg citrato de sildenafila 25 mg medley bula will i have to take accutane again buy cialis overnite las vegas cialis 20 mg cuanto cuesta dalacin c 300 mg bijsluiter viagra cialis and depoxitine tablet in india price of clomid in usa doxycycline hyclate 50mg capsules price why is propecia not over the counter yet nolvadex 20 mg uk propranolol brand name india sammas rinnassa diflucan generic cialis generic pas cher buy zithromax liquid form online viagra pills mga 100 doxycycline hyc 150 mg acne can i take two cialis 5 mg edmonton viagra fast delivery metformin 250 mg twice a day pill fake vs real cialis tadalafil in nature doxycycline for lyme disease treatment viagra generico online contrassegno restaurant is generic viagra any good canada order doxycycline for petsonline cipro cost without insurance at walmart metformin weight loss europe aldactone 100 mg pfizer viagra cialis 5 mg daily use cost cheapest viagra prices dark brown discharge on clomid where can i get viagra from soho london does viagra reall work prednisone 5mg sales propecia and impotence dosage of doxycycline for kidney infection c9891 25 mg of zoloft difference between cialis 20 mg and 5mg can u take doxycycline for a sinus infection propranolol in oesophageal varices viagra online pagamento in contrassegno iwant to buy viagra in penang best way lose weight metformin buy soft gel cialis is cialis an over the counter zoloft alternative brands buy generic cytotec online i want yp buy viagra proctozone generic cialis diflucan priceline credit tagliare pastiglia viagra for sale sildenafil 1a pharma 100 mg tabletten cytotec dublin phamachy cialis in malaysia generic sildenafil 2012 viagogo positive reviews of zoloft cipro cursos online cost diferince between cialis and viagra is a prescription for cialis needed in canada cost of using viagra doxycycline walgreens price 7.5 mg of prednisone can clomid cause high blood pressure if i take 100 mg viagra any side effect metformin dose for pcos weight loss cialis generico pericoli viagra substitute over the counter australian propecia costco montreal zithromax 500 mg treatment cialis buy in canada how to get finasteride uk name brand only viagra discount programs zovirax cream price increase costcoviagra coupons zithromax cost usa precisa de receita para comprar cialis generico what is the generic of amoxil cytotec pills price in south africa does cialis build up in the body zovia positive reviews on zoloft doxycycline 100 mg kullananlar order zithromax gonorrhea viagra in melbourne chemist finasteride and minoxidil in india para que sirve la ciproxina 500 mg substitute of viagra in homeopathy nolvadex cheap shipping how much clomid should you take generico de viagra precio mexico buy lasix potassium find lilly icos cialis at vendors price cialis differences in mg purchase doxycycline dergboadre difference entre viagra 25 mg et 50 mg catalog best sellers cialis how quick does clomid work in men viagra order without prescription opiniones comprar viagra por internet onde comprar viagra ou similar can i take doxycycline with advil where can i buy vega h cream sildenafil in bangalore ciproxin 500 mg sospensione orale need sample of cialis in georgetown ky. generic accutane will 100mg of clomid give more eggs price one viagra pill what is socialism in the 1800s mycostatin sciroppo dosaggio viagra how long does prednisone remain in body is clomid a prescription drug in south africa which countries cialis over the counter countries viagra rezept hausarzt 150 mg viagra overdose victim russkie pesni viagra for sale doxycycline antimalarial dose viagra mail order india what is the walmart price for zithromax can an 18 year old use viagra safety of canadian viagra viagra for diabetic impotence how much does zithromax cost in south africa nome do generico do viagra walgreens buy cialis how to get viagra in sri lanka finasteride without prescriptions propecia cancer prostate cialis buy mastercard where i can find viagra in kuala lumpur doxycycline hyclate 100mg images generic doxycycline for acne how much are cialis tablets finasteride for women reviews best price generic cialis can you get viagra in vietnam doxycycline online canada meds taking birth control pills before clomid tadalafil 5 mg manipulado depo provera amp 150 mg viagra generic tadalafil in the uk online clomid used steroids where to buy priligy in singapore can i get viagra from boots viagra generico mejor precio 4 semanas de embarazo aborto con cytotec online bacitracin over the counter uk viagra yeast infection medication over the counter uk viagra donde comprar cytotec en tuxtla gutierrez glucophage de 750 mg wills lasix cost insurance cost for viagra viagra sin receta en usa is it safe to use clomid after coming off birth control where to buy viagra in johannesburg south africa einfuhrbestimmungen deutschland viagra si puo dividere cialis 20 mg can you buy viagra online in uk united can u masterbate while taking doxycycline monohydrate generic cialis patent is avelox safe to take with prednisone difference between viagra and generic sildenafil how to get rid of dry skin on accutane bali viagra over counter how long after taking cialis does it work prexum generic viagra viagra meaning in gujarati how would viagra affect a woman can i order cialis without a prescription cialis vom hausarzt viagra price in india today metformin 500mg twice a day weight loss nasal spray like viagra over the counter australia cheap cialis thailand generic viagra in 3 days in tampa does cipro counteract birth control accutane uk nhs rates tryptizol 25 mg biverkningar av metformin clomid medicine cost when will viagra prices come down lasix cheap online no prescription brand name glucophage how can i get viagra samples meth in fake viagra mexico walmart price for everyday cialis prednisolone acis 50 mg nebenwirkungen antidepressiva anyone had had gain from propecia in temples buy cialis 20mg 60 tabs cialis 20 mg dosage how long does it take to work 50 mg prednisone dosage vs. answers on long ejaculation of viagra 50 mg street value cialis united states thinking of buying viagra ship cialis to canada ampicillin dosage skin infection cipro 500 cost metformin uk pharmacy online finasteride 30 mg oxycontin online pharmacy selling viagra generic viagra india cipla ltd doxycycline price uk boots finasteride over counter amoxil 875 cost prednisolone for asthma is it safe to take zoloft with trazodone viagra c best supplier veregen salbe rezeptfrei kaufen viagra metformin hcl er 500 mg drugs is 150 milligrams of viagra safe propecia works best prednisone taper in rheumatoid arthritis siphene 500 mg metformin how to increase zoloft safely does clomid increase fertility in men viagra canada overnight delivery tadalafil next day cheap uk para que sirve ciprofloxacino 500 mg tabletas how long before having sex do you take cialis best prices on cialis 5mg prednisone dose pack instructions how much is a 100 mg viagra worth on the street viagra tablet for man price in india inderal syrup brands doc123 viagra for sale generic viagra best price canadian pharmacy tadalafil 20 mg street value oral doxycycline buy cialis 10mg achat cialis in curacao what mg cialis use of finasteride in prostate cancer gm largest purchaser viagra clomid ovulation 100mg propecia 5mg or 1mg reviews use of ciprofloxacin in fever diflucan yeast infection in mouth can metformin be cut in half 100mg clomid days 2 6 does accutane cause swollen lips dosge clomid for men liquid herbal viagra in india online how to get nolvadex and clomid ampicillin treatment for gonorrhea sabril 500 mg bijsluiter viagra where to buy propecia in thailand ebay dding buy viagra getting pregnant while on doxycycline where to buy viagra on the high street donde comprar viagra puebla decadron injetavel generico de cialis viagra non perscription deal sale safe to stop prednisone prescription needed to buy viagra can you take doxycycline with zoloft propecia vs rogaine reviews how often can i take propranolol 40 mg vesix 500 mg metformin order cialis soft tabs what is doxycycline 100 mg used for where to buy clomid in uk prednisone zentiva 5 mg sildenafil in infants generic viagra issues where can i find cialis in uae buy nolvadex pct uk daily mail Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Beefing up in order to leave.

Beefing up in order to leave.

datePosted on 15:07, August 22nd, 2012 by Pablo

In the wake of the most recent NZDF deaths in Bamiyan Province, the Prime Minister has decided to accelerate the timetable for withdrawal of NZDF from the Bamiyan Provincial Reconstruction Team to April 2013. After that the PRT will remain in UN and local hands. The original withdrawal date, originally slated for 2014, had been moved up to late 2013 after discussions with the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) partners, but the April date represents a six month advance on that deadline. Even so, the PM says that his government will not “cut and run” on its obligations to ISAF, NATO and the UN (and presumably the Hazara people who are the majority in Bamiyan but who are an oft-oppressed ethnic and religious (Shiia) minority in Pashtun Sunni-dominated Afghanistan). That means that for the next eight months the NZDF will continue its mission regardless of what comes its way in Bamiyan.

The Prime Minister has said that the NZDF troops have adequate equipment with which to defend themselves and that no major increases in troop numbers is needed to fulfill the PRT mission requirements. He and the Chief of Defense Forces have also said that they will increase patrols, including into neighboring Baghlan province, in order to prevent and interdict cross-border incursions by Taliban such as those that have resulted in the deaths of the NZ soldiers this month (I shall leave aside the snide critique by the PM of the Hungarian PRT in Baghlan since its rules of engagement (ROE) never involved long-range patrols and the Hungarian government has never succumbed to the pressure to do so (seeing it for what it is: “mission creep”). Other Hungarian forces as well as those of ISAF partners did and do conduct day and night patrols in Baghlan). The government has gone on to say that the NZDF have been successfully engaged in a “hearts and minds” campaign as part of their patrols in Bamiyan, which is what has prompted the increase in attacks by the Taliban.

There are several aspects to the account that I find interesting. When the original timetable for withdrawal was announced by ISAF, the Taliban commander Mullah Omar and several of his lieutenants publicly stated that they would increase attacks on all coalition members in order to push them out earlier. They well understood that with a timetable fixed and with the Taliban, as an indigenous armed political force, in Afghanistan to stay, an increased tempo of attacks might force some coalition partners to depart earlier than schedule rather than suffer mounting losses. Add in the fact that the democratic policy-making processes of many ISAF coalition members make them very susceptible to public opinion, then a wave of increased attacks leading to increased losses could well move the political calculation with regards to withdrawal towards earlier rather the later. Indeed, some junior coalition partners have already departed.

In the past year, as the predicted attacks in Bamiyan increased, the nature of the PRT mission changed as well. From its primary objective of reconstruction and capacity-building it moved to force protection, indigenous security training and armed patrol. In recent months and in light of the anticipated withdrawal date, the latter functions–force protection, indigenous security training and armed patrol–have taken precedence over the reconstruction aspects of the mission (which are being handed over to civilian authority in any event).

In response, the last two PRT rotations (October 2011-April 2012, April 2012-present) have seen changes in force composition to more infantry troops and less engineers. Among other shifts, explosive ordinance disposal (EOD) specialists have been priority detailed to the mission. Infantry soldiers replaced engineers because the former are the means by which the hearts and minds, force protection and indigenous mentoring campaigns are undertaken, plus reconstruction work is already passing to civilian hands. Field medics are needed in equal or more numbers given their increasing combat requirement sharing space with the original public health orientation of the  PRT.

The armed Hiluxs that were initially used for “light” patrols were replaced by “up-armored” Humvees and then later by the infamous Light Armored Vehicles (LAVs, or as the US prefers to call them “Strykers”). Although reinforced in theater, neither of these type of vehicle have the V shaped hulls that are the best defense against IED blasts. The LAVs also are not suitable for steep narrow tracks or water crossings, so their presence is most effective in and around the capital of Bamiyan (Bamiyan City). Once NZDF patrols pushed further afield the onus of safety fell on the foot soldiers involved, since dismounted tactics are the most effective tools against small dispersed groups of insurgents given the challenging terrain in which the NZDF is forced to operate.

This shift in troop specialization was reasonable given the increasing pace of attacks, which included IED as well as small arms ambushes in growing numbers (besides the ambush in which Lt. Tim O’Donnell was killed in 2010, there have been multiple IED  and small arms attacks on NZDF convoys and patrols during the past 18 months). As independent observers have noted all along, the security situation in Bamiyan, as in the rest of Afghanistan, has deteriorated markedly since the withdrawal date was announced. It is therefore not surprising that the NZDF has come under increasing attack, and although sad, it is not surprising that it has suffered losses as a result. What is even more sad is that in spite of the worsening security situation, until very recently the NZ government insisted that the situation in Bamiyan was relatively stable and safe, perhaps because it feared what the public response would be if it told the truth.

Now confronted with the harsh reality of the situation, the government has announced its plan to extend NZDF patrols in Bamiyan and into Baghlan and to continue the hearts and minds approach to counter-insurgency. It also says that while doing so it will not significantly increase the combat force complement of the Bamiyan PRT nor raise overall troop numbers much above the 149 currently deployed. That seems odd.

The combination of extended patrols and hearts and minds is essentially the core of the inkblot counter-insurgency strategy that US generals David Petreus and Stanley McCrystal used in Iraq and Afghanistan. It involves stationing troops in villages or in forward outposts alongside local security forces, where they live and work amongst the local population. This gives them an extended armed presence that allows for better collection of local intelligence via the cultivation of personal ties with locals, and is seen as a way of incrementally denying the enemy control of territory in the measure that the various “dots” expand their areas of effective control and begin to merge jurisdictions. On the downside, it also makes the troops involved more vulnerable, particularly to so-called “green on blue” attacks in which local security personnel turn their arms on their foreign mentors (the Taliban have deliberately infiltrated both the Afghan National Army and National Police in order to engage this tactic, with remarkable success).

In order to undertake the inkblot counter-insurgency strategy, both Petreus and McCrystal argued that a “surge” in troops was necessary. That is, more armed “boots on the ground” were required in order to extend the range and scope of operations beyond the fixed bases and daily patrols that characterized the conventional approach to securing the countryside (which was premised on the attrition of enemy fighters resulting in a diminished level of armed conflict). Thus in Iraq and Afghanistan thousands of extra troops were deployed as part of the inkblot surge in order to push the enemy back and secure better conditions for both locals and foreign troops in the months ahead of the withdrawal date. The idea is to not only place the enemy on the defensive in order to give time and space to local forces to more effectively secure their own areas of responsibility, but also to set a more favorable stage for local authorities to negotiate the nature of the post-withdrawal regime. After all, it is better to negotiate from a position of strength than weakness. The inkblot surge is designed to provide the conditions for that to occur.

That is basically what the NZ government is arguing in favor of, but without the surge. In a place like Bamiyan, the stated intent to extend patrols as part of an upgraded hearts and minds campaign would appear to require more than the current number of soldiers. In fact, it would seem that an infantry company (around 130 soldiers) would be the basic minimum amount required to “surge.” The question is whether the NZDF has such a capability ready to deploy even if the government would like that to happen. And even if that is the case–that the government wants to undertake the surge and the NZDF can do so–the follow up question is whether that would be politically palatable to the NZ public. If the answer to any of these questions is no, then what exactly does the government think that the NZDF can do in Bamiyan to decrease the number of attacks on its troops?

At current levels the PRT cannot not cope with a rising wave of attacks. The IED on the NZDF medivac convoy was placed at night less than 15 kilometers from the PRT base in Bamiyan City.The placement of the IED appears to have been done after the medivac patrol headed out to retrieve the ill soldier from a forward post and in anticipation of its return. There were no LAVs on the medivac mission because they were too large and heavy for the dirt road leading to the post, so four Humvees were used.

The PM and CDF say that the IED had 20 kilos of explosives, so a LAV would not have survived the blast either. It is also possible that the triggering device did not act according to plan, resulting in a signal delay that transferred the  IED blast from the first to the last Humvee (and which could well have made impossible a small arms attack once the convoy stopped). Both may be true, but the ability of insurgents to carry, place and detonate  a 20 kilo IED close to the main Kiwi base in Bamiyan on a known route to and from an NZDF forward post without being detected should be a point of discussion in NZDF HQ. After all, mine sweeping is a requisite for mine defusing, and finding one after a fatal attack demonstrates that the NZDF EOD capability in Bamiyan is lagging behind that of the Taliban bomb-makers (one of whom is said to be the target of the previous fatal ambush and who is suspected of participating in the latest attack).

Since the NZDF cannot be everywhere at once, that means that the insurgents have at least partial control of the night very close to the PRT. Moreover, the IED appears to have been detonated by remote control rather than pressure plate, which means that the trigger man had a daylight line of sight on the convoy as it passed the blast zone. What that means, in sum, is that the Taliban operate very close to the PRT itself and can move with some impunity at night even when in close proximity to the very area in which the bulk of NZ troops are stationed. That is troubling.

The PM has given assurances that other country’s special forces will come to the aid of the NZDF if need be. I sure hope so, because the last time I looked other country’s special forces have their hands full in places like Kandahar and Helmand provinces. Be clear on this: the bulk of the fighting in Afghanistan is happening in the South and East, not in the Central Northwest where Bamiyan is located. That fighting occupies the full attention of the ISAF forces involved. Even if airborne reinforcements were sent from Kabul (which is about 100 kilometers away from Bamiyan), it may be too late for them to make the difference in any given confrontation.

Expanded combat patrols and increased forward basing mean more chances of contact with the enemy. More contact means more potential casualties. The best way to avoid losses is to have robust forces on the ground close to the point of contact(s) because air cover is not always available in real time, at the moment of engagement. That is why extended patrolling and variations of inkblot approaches to counter-insurgency require more ground troops in theater.

I find it unrealistic and dangerous for anyone to suggest that the NZDF will increase and expand its patrols in the months leading to the April 2013 withdrawal date without increasing the number of troops it will dedicate to that task. Perhaps there is something in the NZ government or NZDF game plan that I am not aware of that will do what even the US could not do, which is to embark on an inkblot counter-insurgency strategy without a troop surge in the six months before departure. That assumes that the NZ government and NZDF hierarchy are fully cognizant of what they are proposing to do, of what they are asking of their soldiers. I also hope that they will take full responsibility for whatever happens in the months ahead given the choices they have made.

In any event the NZDF soldiers in the next (and last) Bamiyan PRT rotation scheduled to begin in October are in for a very challenging six months. Let us hope that their training and resolve sees them through unscathed, and that they all return safely. However, while it is good to hope for the best, I also think that it is prudent for the NZ public to plan for the worst. There are trying days ahead.


categoryPosted in War | printPrint

8 Responses to “Beefing up in order to leave.”

  1. Dave Waugh on August 22nd, 2012 at 23:41

    I suspect that the Taleban will use the increased activity against coalition troops as a psychological/political tool against the local population to say “We pushed out the foreign invaders” to undermine the government and local tribal leaders power further.

  2. martin hector on August 23rd, 2012 at 19:40

    I was wondering how these IED can be detected by mine sweepers especially if they are line of sight controlled?
    Do you have a tank type vehicle going ahead thrashing heavy chains on the ground like in WW2?

  3. Pablo on August 24th, 2012 at 11:59


    I am not privy to what is used for EOD sweeps in Bamiyan but do know that electronic jammers are used by the NZDF to disrupt signals sent by remote control (often using cell phones), and of course foot soldiers doing walking sweeps. However, neither appear to have been in use during the latest incident.

  4. martin hector on August 24th, 2012 at 17:09

    May-be they could run some bomb detecting dogs as point men, 20kgs of explosives would be quite a bit i would of thought for a dog to smell out on the hoof

  5. The Peanut Monster on August 25th, 2012 at 02:40

    Very interesting comment. Key has said that the continued deployment was about the “defence” of New Zealand interests. What do you think this is based on? A genuine fear of terrorism, or a long term investment in the US as a key defence partner?

  6. Pablo on August 25th, 2012 at 12:28

    Peanut Monster:

    The latter.

  7. Mark on August 28th, 2012 at 13:23

    This might seem informative but to me it just gives intelligence to the enemy,even re deploymeent,our vulnerabilities etc-these are our men and women over there,make the enemy search hard for info-don’t give it to them on a plate. And I do wish you’d turn your spell check over to NZ/UK use and use favour rather than favor etc.Once they had cut and run we can all write books on the matter and welcome the refuges.

  8. Pablo on August 28th, 2012 at 14:49


    if I thought for a second that I was giving intel to the Taliban I would not do it. But I reckon that the Taliban have their own, much better intelligence on the NZDF in theater.

    As for the spelling. For a long time I wrote things in NZ english here at KP, but somewhere along the line my auto-correct (which I believe is on an updated version of Safari that I am using) reverted to US english. I got sick and tired of trying to correct the auto-correct and so gave up. Now I just write in US english, which if bothersome to purists is still comprehensible (my convoluted writing style notwithstanding).

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)