viagra in my system what is the difference between 10 and 20 mg cialis best online pharmacies for generic cialis comprar cialis porto alegre need to buy cytotec overnight prednisolone nephrotic syndrome worlds best pharmacy net buy viagra super dulux force mono amoxil rash viagra 100 mg asheboro drug nc best time in cycle to take clomid diflucan one do you need prescriptions cipro 500 mg fiyati places of viagra available in chennai were to buy viagra in bangkok viagra online espana viagra generic in usa sel 150 mg viagra priligy 30 mg notice cialis generic india soft tab is doxycycline effective for acne at 40 mg when should i get my period while on clomid herbal viagra mlm finasteride online australia visa generics viagra in philippines price of sildenafil citrate tablets in india zoloft generic manufacturers of wellbutrin can we buy cialis in singapore 7.5 mg a day prednisone safe take ciprofloxacin metronidazole where to buy nolvadex in india cialis pills in johannesburg cialis generico pago contrareembolso sildenafil actavis 50 mg deltacortene 5 mg prednisone daily 500 doxycycline hyclate 100 mg lasix maximum dosage dewalt 20v reciprocating saw review can you take viagra 3 days in a row bicarsim generic cialis cialis dosage mims how effective is clomid in achieving pregnancy gute online apotheke viagra side viagra and cialis generic doxycycline safety in breastfeeding can doxycycline and cefixime be taken together viagra in bulkk best doctor in jacksonville for viagra how can i get clomid for free viagra next day delivery ireland tadalafil from uk generic nolvadex 10 mg tab reviews dose doxycycline for urinary tract infection get cialis prescription when did viagra come on the market generic substitute for ciprodex otic suspension pet diflucan buy online viagra substitute in ayurveda cialis daily generic 5mg can i take clomid after birth control pills what does sildenafil citrate tablets work in the body rite aid cost doxycycline monohydrate should a 20 year old take viagra buy viagra online shop com donde comprar viagra mapuche en chile existe how much should sildenafil cost cytotec in bohol bula amoxil bd 200 mg morphine generico viagra contrareembolso cialis et montreal sertraline zoloft price philippines viagra made in usa for sale receita para comprar cialis 6 ton diggers for sale in uk zithromax viagra work for women uk clomid early pregnancy signs acidosis lactica causada por metformina cialis generika ohne rezept cialis 20 mg 8 tablet fiyati viagra sales dubai what day in your cycle do you start clomid doxycycline for chlamydia dose zoloft and plavix where to buy cialis in china where can i buy clomid for women finasteride de 1mg discount pharmacy purchase viagra the best cordless reciprocating saw cialis 20 mg 12 stk preis tadalafil in solution cheap viagra top nebenwirkungen inderal 10 mg white dianabol tablets 10 mg prednisone lyrica 150 mg wirkung viagra coping with prednisone book review doxycycline dosage for tooth abscess zithromax 500 mg obat apa yang prezzi del viagra generico in farmacia are generic tadalafil safe what is walgreens retail cost for cialis 5 mg viagra triangle chicago bars in los angeles buy viagra gel safely online uk can accutane cause floaters what is the brand name of finasteride x factor asian lady in viagra cialis royal oak reviews on can i buy viagra over the counter in morocco safest place order viagra sildenafil stores in chennai india sildenafil 50 mg price herbal cialis usa can you buy diflucan in france viagra zonder voorschrift viagra 25 mg o 50 mg cobra 130 mg sildenafil 6 tablet antibiotic prednisone 5 mg for 10 days azithromycin 250 mg versus cipro 500 mg viagra in usa without perscription should i use finasteride or dutasteride why doe viagra cost so much viagra hausarzt oder urologe viagra 100 mg tab can clomid help in unexplained infertility can i buy cipro in spain sildenafil teva 100mg opinie comprare cialis generico in contrassegno telematico generic cialis ervaringen rua sesamo generico do viagra hay akatinol generico do viagra pagar finasteride paypal when can i take clomid in a 28 day cycle viagra e cialis online farmaco generico propecia results order finasteride 1 mg without prescription inderalici tabletas 40 mg comprar cialis generico murcia buy clomid online buy cheap viagra for next day delivery ing lasix dose in body illegal to buy nolvadex where is the best zithromax online store bet cialis online can i take aleve with accutane vildagliptin and metformin hcl tablets in india generics van clomid for men websites for generic viagra tablets mono doxycycline blood in stool best way to split a viagra pill doxycycline in system donde comprar priligy en venezuela generic viagra in pune tadalafil generic alternative to cialis 10mg 24 cheap but effective alternative to viagra can you take doxycycline with bread para que se usa doxycycline hyclate 100mg espanol boots cialis prescription cost viagra in glaqsgow viagra india cart ciprofloxacin vs cephalexin dropshipper generic viagra where can i buy trial viagra in edmonton prednisone without a prescription mastercard accepted viagra 75 mg zoloft cialis professional 40 mg chf existe o generico do cialis pills quien usa viagra medicine cipro 500 mg sildenafil walmart list prednisone liquid dosage chart viagra effective dose best body lotion on accutane is 20mg accutane strong enough viagra online bestellen word prednisone 50mg cost is it illeagle in canada to order viagra online can viagra cause congestive heart failure accutane headset price philippines iphone what is the cost of generic viagra compra priligy online cialis daily how long to take effect purchase real 40 millagram cialis with paypal best way to get full effect from viagra doxycycline sun reaction treatment what is the use of clomid drug metformin hydrochloride 500 mg cost viagra pfizer uk sites cialis 15 mg first time 36 hr dosage purchase viagra c.o.d where do i get viagra in toronto zithromax out of pocket cost which pill is better viagra or cialis about generic cialis why would a female take viagra cialis buy europe dapoxetine ukmix ampicillin administration in newborns tadalafil cialis kaufen rezeptfrei contraindicaciones metformina clorhidrato 850 mg sildenafil 50 mg wirkungsdauer best price viagra name brand viagra in brussels where to buy generic cialis safely home inderal 60 mg er for anxiety help with cialis pill cost topiramate 50 mg comprimidos viagra manufacturer of generic api for tadalafil blindness viagra use metformin online without a prescription how much propecia should i take for best results can viagra be taken sublingually buy converse shoes online india cheap generic viagra 25 mg zoloft to 50mg tramadol viagra in celebrities como comprar viagra en farmacia sin receta comprar viagra online brasil ovulating on clomid not getting pregnant chemist warehouse sildenafil amoxil 400 mg 5 ml dosage get cialis in orlando how long can i last if i take viagra celebrity accutane users cipro 250 mg pille using clomid and nolva together sale of priligy dapoxetin in france clandestinos discovery channel doblaje cipro cost doxycycline malaria prevention mostaza guldens donde comprar viagra can you buy viagra argentina soccer does doxycycline have aspirin in it viagra in denmar comprar generico de cialis cialis 30 day supply cost gastrologist specialist in bastrop tx how long does cialis 40 mg prednisone taper schedule from 60 mgs where can we get viagra in south africa tadalafila x sildenafila how much is street uk tamoxifen clomid doxycycline strep throat treatment can you buy viagra taiwan il generico del priligy viagra verkauf in der schweiz cialis 50 mg dosage partamol 150 mg zoloft zovirax 200 mg tabletter mot en donde comprar el cytotec en peru que es generic viagra is doxycycline used to treat eye infections what is the price of propecia cheap liquid viagra for sale in ireland propecia on ebay uk donde puedo comprar cytotec en san pedro sula 30 mg of prednisone daily with vibramycin success of clomid with pcos clomid et ovulation cialis 20 mg when to take it can viagra be taken with norvasc is taking more than 100 mg viagra safe buy zithromax on line with payapl buying clomid without rx como comprar cytotec misoprostol can my gp prescribe clomid uk ampicillin trihydrate 250 mg prednisone psoriatic arthritis cialis information in arabic sildenafil citrate generic cobra 125 zithromax generic price 6 pills is it ok to use cialis 40 mg tadalafil work in women 50 mg zoloft libido loss walk in and buy viagra over the counter leeds contrabando de viagra a usa pastillas similares viagra in usa best liquid tadalafil doses cost of viagra in the pi prix officiel du cialis low cost 40 mg cialis tab urotone 25 mg of zoloft viagra 1 dollar in india walmaer cost of cialis chukar for sale in uk zithromax clorofila liquida controindicazioni viagra can i take viagra out of the uk doxycycline monohydrate dosage for acne how much does cialis cost a walmart viagra in nashville will prednisone help with fluid in ears doxycycline 100 mg pregnancy viagra online kaufen in deutschland buy viagra uk nhs card ciprofloxacin 750 mg for ear infection what is safer cialis or viagra viagra from soho london propecia rowcmoadreders online diflucan 50 mg notice of privacy cytotec and pregnancy buying viagra without prescription in spain no prescription needed cheap cialis viagra costco over the counter praxiten 15 mg nebenwirkungen viagra hycom 10 mg prednisone how much is cipro.at walmart best dosage of zoloft for depression what if a young person takes viagra how much are 20 mg cialis worth clomid 100mg follicles doxycycline monohydrate 100 mg dose doxycycline nausea help in pregnancy doxycycline capsules how to take sildenafil injection brands in india assunzione diflucan in gravidanza clomid and proviron in male infertility zithromax online in us cialis 2.5 mg erfahrungen accutane cases in fl les 2 visages d ana generique viagra generico do viagra nomes cialis at low cost cialis online offer lilly cialis 5mg online can you eat when you take doxycycline hong kong viagra buy where accidentally took 40 mg of prednisone price of generic zoloft viagra tablets in india for men generic cialis jamaica walmart prescription drug prices cialis how long does cialis pill stay in your system viagra en australia donde comprar viagra en guadalajara mexico getting immune to viagra female viagra online australia pharmacy viagra super active uk magnus sildenafil 100mg precio ulcedine 20 mg cialis como usar cytotec para abortar o lerk sildenafil 100mg precious metal prices lapela the generic cialis what is normal dose of cialis compra de cialis 5 mg viagra ohne rezept kaufen in holland zoloft 75 mg to 100mg is how many ml generic vs brand propecia can you dissolve doxycycline in water buy viagra online safely discount viagra kuala lumpur i want viagra tablet in chennai buy herbal viagra jellies dapoxetine whartisthebestin price donde puedo comprar cytotec en santa cruz cialis dosage rates propranolol in third trimester viagra pfizer patent prednisolone gr ec 5 mg original cialis 20mg price comprar golden max viagra feminino cialis online pharmacy scams tadalafil oral jelly 20mg generic viagra uk next day delivey is over the counter viagra just as effective viagra 100 mg oder 50 mg cipro otic hc causa mareos the best way to make viagra work ulcer in throat from doxycycline 100mg migliore farmacia online cialis diflucan over the counter australia flag diflucan safe liver corticoids vs corticosteroids prednisone terence renati rock hard sale viagra cheap soft tadalafil tablets viagra spray available in indian market pharmacy price accutane zithromax 2g how long it stays in your system how to taper off 20 mg of prednisone viagra canadian superstore is viagra can be bought over the counter extracto de almendra donde comprar viagra brand viagra pfizer cabergoline buy generic viagra viagra phone orders is viagra safe for over seventies order real generic cialis online doxycycline do not take with milk generic cipro sales cialis 5 mg daily dose australia 600 mg doxycycline single dose lasix 10 mg tablets 25 mg viagra fiyat depranil 25 mg of zoloft cialis daily use online reasons to use lasix northwest pharmacy cialis reviews ppm is sertraline generic for zoloft list of viagra for women in india how long will cialis be in your system current cost of viagra cialis use for what finasteride 1 mg peru viagra price with a prescription inderal dosage for anxiety canadian going blind over viagra is cytotec safe for abortion what is the best over the counter viagra at gnc doxycycline dosage in dog seo india cheap generic viagra diflucan 150 mg dopo quanto fa effetto viagra for pulmonary hypertension dose cialis filmtabl 5mg zithromax 500 mg prezzos milford buy cheap propecia from uk best supplement for viagra what is cialis black glimepirida metformina generico do viagra bangkok buying cialis viagra kaufen biz finasteride for hair growth buy nolvadex uk online no prescription viagra ads woman in football jersey best doxycycline 100 mg tablet india same day delivery cialis hong kong hotel viagra online ship to australia buy herpes zovirax medication overnight delivery usa sildenafil 50 mg mylan pharmaceuticals 150 mg zoloft highest cordarex generico do viagra is it safe to take diazepam and viagra ampicillin dicloxacillin dosage accutane 120 mg per day wellbutrin 150 mg and zoloft 50 mg how mouch the viagra cost in england how to get your boyfriend to take viagra buy metformin 1500mg on line without a prescription buying cialis at a pharmacy. can you mix liquid prednisone tinidazole 500 mg indicaciones metformina zovirax cream london what would happen if a woman take viagra propranolol safe take while pregnant amoxil price in pakistan lumia generic viagra australia coupon lasix whartisthebestin reviews bite half of a cialis in half right dosage of accutane ist viagra in holland rezeptpflichtig more potent than viagra online 200 mg. viagra online sitagliptin plus metformin blue cross price for viagra can you use cipro eye drops in the ear why take prednisone in the morning pompilio cirio viagra for sale viagra 1 tablet price in pakistan gymnema sylvestre reviews pcos and metformin viagra where to buy over the counter usa where can i buy nolvadex pct hdrol chi puo usare viagra metformin pill in bowel movement purchase glucophage guercmorteo doxycycline 100 mg how to take comprar sildenafilo singulair dosage of doxycycline for tick bite fever viagra gold in pakistan ms magazine founded buy cialis online can lasix cause vomiting braked trailers for sale in uk zithromax propecia dry scalp viagra the facts is diflucan over the counter in the philippines diflucan to buy online where can you buy zovirax cream amoxil 500 mg price in the philippines priligy in pune walmart pharmacy cialis pricing finasteride priceline car generic zovirax hereisthebestin tioconazole tinidazole secnidazol generico do viagra doxycycline dose guinea pigs can you get high off metformin hydrochloride 500 mg zoloft in renal failure does clomid really help generico do cialis na ultrafarma campinas prednisone 10 mg for sinus dolores despues de usar cytotec best place to order clomid is viagra safe for man best time of day to take clomid for pc cheap viagra substitutes managed to buy clomid can i use it viagra in blood test doxycycline can be taken with milk lower price tadalafil online buy viagra cialis wholesale why is it so hard to find sildenafil online first beta blocker propranolol reviews metformin type 1 diabetes pregnancy delivery f mg prednisone headaches viagra collection in london generic metformin zydus phar glucophage 500 mg metformin twice zovirax dispersible costovertebral tenderness ciprofar 500 mg amoxicillin dosage Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » The Agony of Defeat.

The Agony of Defeat.

datePosted on 11:43, November 29th, 2011 by Pablo

Well, it was a grim morning of the day after in my household on Sunday. The evil-doers prevailed and the forces of righteousness and progress were soundly spanked, with the exception of a formerly progressive party that now has gone managerial as it mainstreams to the political centre. Sure, there were some points of solace in the otherwise dark landscape of electoral outcomes, but overall the egalitarian side of the NZ political spectrum got hammered.

But all is not lost. In the scheme of things, this was not the worst election defeat I have experienced as a voter. For me, as an ex-pat Yank, that dubious honor rests with the election of Ronald Reagan in 1980. The idea that someone who epitomized prejudice, elitism, ignorance, racism, war-mongering, corporate-backed chickhawk cowardice and the utter insipidness of campaign promises could defeat a decent fellow such as Jimmy Carter actually made me fear for basic freedoms and civil rights in that country. Sure, it was not as bad as living through coups or revolutions in Latin America, where losers in the regime change had very real reason to fear for their lives. But is was as close as I have felt in a democracy to being politically at risk as a result of an election. That feeling was reaffirmed a few months later when Reagan was shot, where the response on the working class African American street where I lived was to “hope that a brother did not do it.” Such was the tone of the times that we worried more about the backlash then the fact that the president was almost killed off (and boy, were we relieved when it turned out to be a white nutter who fired the shots).

I felt nearly as bad when W. Bush was fraudulently installed as president after losing the US popular vote in 2000. However, by that time I had moved to NZ and did not have to worry about directly suffering the consequences of yet another silver spoon-fed corporate chickenhawk imperialist stealing his way into power. But I feared for what he was about to wreak on the US (where my family and close friends live) and the world at large. A decade later the proof of his folly is everywhere to be seen. Helen Clark was right: things would have been different had Al Gore rightfully been awarded the 2000 election. But all that is water under the bridge and the person copping the most flak in the aftermath is Barack Obama. Talk about inheriting a mess!

Given that backdrop I am not catatonic because the currency speculator and his band of money-grubbing bullies have been re-elected under the banner of “stability.” It could be worse, and I am thankful that when compared to the US, the bulk of the NZ political spectrum is less reactionary or retrograde. Even so, with expanded anti-terrorism laws and powers of search, surveillance and seizure all passed by the National government in recent years (something that went unnoticed in the buildup to the election), I can see encroaching authoritarianism in its second term. One only has to watch the Prime Minister’s response to hard questions to see his sense of arrogance and entitlement on display. This is a guy who is used to getting his way, however he can, without much regard for the consequences except with respect to his corporate peers. So regardless of public opinion, the PM will push his asset sales agenda, will continue to suck up to both the US and the Chinese while pursuing trade for trade’s sake, and will play as loose with the rules of the democratic game as his weakened opposition will allow him.  And by playing divide and conquer with the Maori Party and the Greens, he could well get his way across the board.

I take solace in the fact that electoral defeats are the lifeblood of democratic politics. It is not so much what the victor does after an election. It is how the losers respond that makes the difference. Losing allows parties to remove the sclerosis from their ranks and rejuvenate both personnel and policy platforms. Losing allows parties to reinvigorate in opposition. Losing forces parties to explore new policy options and ideological possibilities. Should Labour understand this simple law of democratic politics, it can regroup and compete more effectively in three years. If it does not, we could be saddled with the corporate-cuddling cabal for a third term. The question is: does Labour have it within itself to make the serious changes required for it to have relevance in the years forward?

I do see the Green Party vote increase as a positive sign even if its support is coming from disaffected Labour voters more than anywhere else. Between the Greens and Labour there is still a solid 35-37 percent of the vote, figures that could grow should National’s economic policies continue the trend of growing income disparities, elite enrichment, environmental degradation and foreign control. Since voter turnout was so low this year, a mere rise in those who vote in 2014 is bound to increase support for the Left (such as it is) because people tend to vote when they are unhappy about the status quo (apathy such as that seen in this year’s election had less to do with serious discontent and more to do with complacency and belief in a foregone outcome). Thus this moment of defeat is a ripe time for Labour to undertake the necessary changes required to come back and compete successfully in 2014. That means a major leadership shuffle as well as policy change away from the “National-lite” pro-market stance it has maintained for nearly 20 years. In other words, it needs to turn back Left, both in terms of recapturing a class line as well as more sincerely embracing post-modern progressive causes.

I do not claim any particular expertise in NZ politics and this ramble was merely sparked by my reflection on which electoral defeats were the worst for me as a voter in a democratic country. But I do think that one big redeeming feature of liberal democracy, no matter how manufactured, manipulated and corrupted it has become, is that losers are allowed to compete again at regular intervals, which gives them the opportunity to engage the internal reforms that will allow them to emerge from the ashes of even a catastrophic defeat in a better condition to win down the road. This holds true not only for the biggest loser in this year’s election, Labour, but also for such parties as ACT. After all, Winston Peters has shown that even political mummies can be resurrected without being reconstituted, so there is hope yet for even the smallest losers this time around.

3 Responses to “The Agony of Defeat.”

  1. Milos on November 29th, 2011 at 21:16

    Love the colourful language in this piece… “silver spoon-fed corporate chickenhawk imperialist” is a great description for George W.

    Before this election I though that if Labour got anything under 30% then they were out for 2014 as well, but now I’m not so sure. Their chances will largely rest on how well they can recapture the left vote and how sharply National declines.

    John Key’s arrogance and sense of entitlement has indeed been increasingly on display, and will serve to discredit the constructed Brand Key persona in the minds of many people. This will amplify over the next three years, for two main reasons. Firstly, the media will stop being so compliant and put him under more pressure, which he may not react well to (the teapot tapes fiasco could come to form something of a tipping point in the relationship). Secondly, he’ll be leading a government that will be doing more and more stuff that could annoy people. Helen Clark and Labour found out that the longer they were in power, the more likely people would find some policy that they didn’t like, and turn against them. The same thing will happen for National, and their support will degrade over time. And this says nothing of big ticket issues like asset sales / mixed ownership model, which could see isolated sharp declines in support when brought in. For me the question is not whether National’s support will decline over the next three years, but whether it will decline far enough to give Labour a shot in 2014.

    As for Labour, yes, now is the time to undertake the necessary changes, but what are those necessary changes? Goff is gone, but to be honest none of the possible replacements stand out from the rest at this stage. I broadly agree though, that a clear turn to the left is the best course of action. We saw elements of this in the campaign, with talk of creating “a fairer society” and references back to the Micky Savage days. The strong reaction to the documentary on child poverty, which aired during the campaign, gives an indication at least that this could be electorally feasible. National regained their support under Don Brash by swinging to the right, and Labour could well do the same by re-embracing their socialist roots and swinging to the left. This could be good for New Zealand society and (perhaps more rarely) good for Labour electorally. It could also mean a really stark contrast between the two main parties at the next election (and the dawn of a new age of another strongly reformist Labour government, though this may be wishful thinking on my part…).

  2. Jackal on November 30th, 2011 at 00:01

    A nice use of poetic embellishment in a most excellent post, which is far more than a ramble Pablo.

    I think the main problem that Labour faces is that the marginalized poor who are least likely to vote will be targeted once again by National because they lean towards the left. I don’t think the leadership issue is all that relevant in terms of Labours preference to stand on a policy platform instead of a cult of personality. Although a certain amount of showmanship is required… it is media bias and a very low turnout that has put National ahead. Countering that is the crux of the matter.

  3. Pablo on November 30th, 2011 at 08:53

    The post was written a bit tongue-in-cheek, hence the rhetorical flourishes. But the underlying issues are valid: some electoral defeats are worse than others, and all electoral defeats provide losing parties with an opportunity for regeneration.

    As the 5th Labour govt showed, winning continuously leads to policy and personal sclerosis. No one wants to rock the boat, leaders sit on the status quo and squash independent thought and initiatives from below, and the rot sets in. The genius of democracy, as an exercise in bounded institutional uncertainty, is that it gives losers regular opportunities to compete again. This not only makes for increased levels of accountability amongst winners (at least theoretically), but allows–in fact, provides a reason for–losing parties to break out of the organizational doldrums in which they are mired. The worse the defeat the ore the reason for whole-scale changes in policy and personnel.

    Labour did not use the 2008-11 period to that end and paid the price this past weekend. It now has conclusive proof that it must do so. But given the dearth of talent on the back benches and the list, it is an open question whether it can accomplish the task quick enough to be seriously competitive in 2014. If the Greens continue to drain support away from Labour, then more misery awaits it in 3 years (which of course means that Labour has to try and regain some of the ground lost to the Greens as well as put up a coherent counter-platform to the National govt).

    Given the leadership contest at this early stage, it does not appear that Labour have fully embraced the need for serious internal change, the vocalizations of some of the contenders notwithstanding.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: