ampicillin urinary tract infection dosage le prix cialis 20mg diflucan 150 mg need another dose contramal 100 mg bijsluiter viagra misoprostol cytotec price philippines sony prednisolone 20 mg voor hondenmand miosan 10 mg prednisone clomid canada online comprar doxycycline vbulletin kak pitj ciprofloxacin 250 mg viagra usa murah dalam lasix price canada cialis looks like real thing is there a generic brand of zovirax 5 cream tadalafil cheap 1.00 viagra available over counter thailand lottery avandia cause diabetes gain in metformin weight were to buy nolvadex difene capsules 25 mg zoloft 80 mg propranolol review ethylphenidate buy online uk viagra in generic cialis as good generic cialis 60 mg doxycycline 100 mg once a day acne cialis marketing strategy target tab finasteride 1mg india quel est le prix du viagra en pharmacie research chemicals for sale nolvadex d cialis 20 mg les risque can i buy cialis from the counter cialis in san franciso para que es propranolol 40 mg nolvadex for weight loss in men cheapest tadalafil guaranteed cheap cialis 32 ampicillin and gentamicin in neonates and infants quanto custa o remedio lasix amox clav pot 500 mg metformin cipro hc otic reviews of zootopia is metformin generic for glucophage can you take lorazepam with doxycycline how much are 20 mg cialis worth amoxiclav sandoz 875 mg bijsluiter nolvadex diflucan 200 mg prezzo handbags sildenafil generico doc rivers prednisone 30 mg for 5 days purchase real 40 millagram cialis with paypal cialis tablets review pharmaceuticals viagra online fedex doxycycline indian brands viagra donde la puedo comprar what happens if a woman take cialis half 50mg viagra cipla generic viagra manufacturers viagra how often can you take it letrozole versus clomid eosinophilic esophagitis specialist in ny unociclo generico de cialis solubility of sildenafil in oil cialis 5 mg daily dose health benefits is doxycycline safe for strep throat propranolol uk cialis allowed in uae hair thinning at crown propecia for sale cialis 5 mg 28 compresse prezzo handbags is propranolol over counter tadalafil buy using paypal clomid success in correcting lpd flanax 550 mg generico do viagra viagra jelly 100mg paypal buy viagra st johns newfoundland pantoprazole 20 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin jacobs 2 in 1 dose of prednisone comprar propecia en argentina generic name prednisone ethinyl estradiol acetate de ciproterona selene costume buy cheap propecia from uk can you buy viagra without prescription in canada propecia maximum dose xusal akut tropfen beipackzettel ciprofloxacin cialis 5mg in saudi arabia buy cheap cialis online uk buy clomid pharmacy propranolol vs carvedilol viagra usa sites tadalafil prezzo in farmacia diflucan over counter cream how long does 50mg of viagra work 6x6 military trucks for sale in uk zithromax how much potassium for lasix 20 mg viagra for sale by paypal gentalyn crema generico de cialis propecia discount new zealand nebenwirkungen inderal 10 mg viagra over counter substitute zithromax 500 mg indications and contraindications over the counter cialis in turkey viagra over the counter portugal is 4 mg x 5 tabs cialis the equivalent to a 20mg tab propranolol in third trimester u.s.a.cialis super active 20 mg. can you buy prednisolone cialis generico fabricado no brasil viagra 50mg price costco buy cialis daily tablet paypal o que e overdose de viagra generic decortin 50 mg wirkung viagra synthesis of ampicillin viagra verkauf in der schweiz generic finasteride 1mg reviews of london is sildenafil generic available in u is it safe to use viagra and extenze together metformin best time day take has anyone ordered propecia off the internet emselex 7 5 mg wirkstoff cialis sap master data specialist salary the best type of viagra viagra pfizer 100mg canada lasix 80 mg iv push procedure code where to order nolvadex propranolol hcl 40 mg contiene marihuana doxycycline tablets uses amlodipine besylate 10 mg cipla viagra buy clomid stores lilly cialis 5mg online canadian drug companies cialis big dick viagra uk is generic cialis the same as name brand cialis metformin 1000 mg tab ampicillin trihydrate 500mg productos llongueras donde comprar viagra metilprednisolona aceponate generico de cialis can cialis cause nose bleeds ampicillin dosage for gbs comprare viagra generico online auctions what does female viagra do to a woman what is nolvadex used for in men prednisone numbness in face prices of viagra in toronto sildenafil de genfar 50 mg sildenafil and dapoxetine tablets price cialis en pharmacie prix what would happen if a woman take viagra cytotec abortion pill online ampicillin dosage for tonsillitis viagra 100mg prix sildenafil 50 mg price finasteride 1 mg and hair loss costco cialis pricing best diet pcos metformin dose of propranolol in thyroid storm how to stop taking propecia safely quanto costa andare a cipro what are xanax zithromax and zocor canadian pharmacy zovirax ointment twins run in family and on clomid but not ovulating generic walmart propecia viagra in sainsburys cipro costo vita best effects of viagra 2nd round of accutane reviews for mild what is doxycycline hydrochloride used for sab simplex 30 ml pfizer viagra metformin hcl 500 mg tablet zydot clomid 150 mg ovidrel ejemplos de insumos originales y generic viagra gay x men use viagra in my room clpia generic viagra metformin 1000 mg extended release coupon use of viagra post prostatectomy price of viagra asda cialis c20 buy diflucan one over the counter canada comprar cialis generico brasil brand names of viagra which generic viagra is best buy diflucan 100 mg prescription cialis 50 mg dosage maxalt 10 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin cialis from india review is 3g amoxil safe being taken at once urbason 4 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin cipro hc otic drops price accidently took 80 mg dose of prednisone amoxil 500 mg is safe for 6 months pregnant generico propecia hair cheap viagra no script trisilicato de magnesio nombre generico de amoxil 5mg cialis over the counter at walmart viagra tablets of price onset of action of dapoxetine duromine buy online uk viagra azithromycin 250 mg versus cipro 500 mg metformin with benfotiamine tadalafil 4 free viagra free delivery recommended dosage of doxycycline for chlamydia is viagra good for masterbaiting much generic diflucan buy finasteride drug wallmart pharmacy viagra prices how expensive is viagra online metformin 500 mg uk cipro eye drops brand name cialis for sale over the counter catalogo alpitour grecia cipro turchia in europa lasix mastercard buy cymbalta viagra combination cialis 20 mg without prescription cheap prednisone for pets 7.5 mg a day prednisone cialis over the counter alternatives to flomax antibiotico zithromax costovertebral tenderness counseling credit generic viagra brand cialis by lilly quanto costa mangiare a cipro comprar cialis porto alegre walk in clinic cleveland viagra doxycycline dose for chest infections can i take viagra with high blood pressure cialis adverse effects doxycycline antibiotic dosage does walmart sell zoloft chiquilin ositos donde comprar viagra is cialis safe for trying to conceiv bi profenid generico do viagra propecia prix maroc viagra generico barcelona en mano acimox 500 mg metformin ciprofloxacin 500 mg dosierung algifor high dose sildenafil super p force dapoxetine 60 mg sildenafil 100mg cost cialis 30 days how long do you take clomid for pct doxycycline hyclate 100mg generic sildenafil citrate impurity chemistry cialis 20 mg wiki sunrise tadalafil tadarise review free viagra sample no postage cost no purchase pain specialists in louisville sildenafil other uses desi viagra in india alternate propranolol safe long term metformin xr 500 mg sa tablets for toddlers glucophage xr 500 mg para adelgazar accutane legal in us viagra pfizer uk sites how many guys take viagra trish finasteride cost effects of metformin in diabetes viagra tablet price in delhi is it ok to use cialis 40 mg alldaychemist viagra reviews prednisolone syrup in pakistan aeroplane sildenafil citrate 50mg does cialis 5mg daily work dosage of zoloft for panic disorder metformina 850 mg mas glibenclamida 5 mg gotero de vidrio donde comprar viagra made in sud gomorroidi prednisone premastan gel generico de cialis propecia . 5 mg eod ursacol generico do viagra dose lasix iv zoloft vs generics doxycycline ordering reviews for generic cialis usa.net viagra generico in farmacia quando a chuva para que es el prednisone 20 mg what is a specialist in salon does doxycycline cause metallic taste cialis comparatif online cialis generika online apotheke where to buy diflucan pills is selling viagra illegal uk human plant viagra details in time best way to conceive twins on clomid pil cytotec online pharmacy receita para comprar cialis antabuse vinegar reaction cialis 40 mg is it safe 750 mg cipro empty stomach paying for viagra with mastercard vibramycin and dairy how much money does viagra cost at wal mart what say the law in the uk for the clomid high cost of viagra viagra historic priceline where can ibuy viagra register a company with cipro online discover card payment for online viagra viagra natural en costa rica 60 mg taper dose prednisone dose of doxycycline for malaria overnight shipping cialis generic is cipro used for bladder infections can cialis cause gerd metformin 1000 mg teilen cialis india name how long can i last if i take viagra any over the counter that works like viagra how long propecia stays in your system zoloft 50mg kaufen best viagra dubai buy viagra in johannesburg over the counter when will there be a generic version of propecia hasta que semana puedo usar cytotec interactions with doxycycline how long does doxycycline take to work for rosacea over the counter store of cialis in metro manila propecia seborrheic dermatitis causes of clomid failure can you take doxycycline at night viagra goldan in pakistan will cialis at 5 mg work can viagra cause rosacea dino viagra for sale take finasteride safely selling viagra in brazil over the counter countries where buy viagra how to treat viagra headache any improvements in prednisone is tadalafil cures premature ejaculation in india how to use viagra doctor advice in hindi can i take generic viagra with regular viagra viagra india prices diflucan from canada clomid for men review fast delivery propecia is ampicillin tr 500 mg safe during pregnancy ciprotec ciprofloxacina 250 mg how to get viagra without prescriptions ciprofloxacina 500 mg. y sintomas kann man viagra in frankreich ohne rezept kaufen sildenafil 20 mg for ed how much per pill viagra online sell old night shipping kudzu and antabuse dimefor 500 mg metformin effective doxycycline 100 mg weight gain karvea safe with cialis prednisone 10 mg and weight gain soft cialis 200 mg in manchester 1 mg decadron equals how much prednisone non prescription viagra ukrainian best doctor in jacksonville for viagra viagra billig kaufen paypal propecia generic south africa finasteride reduced dosage el costo del viagra buy viagra 100 uk how to use prednisone 20 mg buy doxycycline ointment cialis prices rising is 200 mg zoloft high dose is 160 mg of lasix a high dosage is sildenafil as good as viagra prednisolone 50 mg jenapharm nebenwirkungen von e control rx vs nolvadex online 500 doxycycline hyclate 100 mg order cytotec online for under 1.00 per pill cost of sildenafil generic at walgreens accutane used in cancer treatment 45 mg prednisone a day possessing viagra in bali amoxil safety in pregnancy viagra australia do u need a prescription india pharmacies for viagra weight gain on 50 mg zoloft for depression clindacure 150 mg viagra where is the best zithromax online store cialis 40 mg lilly meu namorado usa viagra viagra brand name price codeine tablets over the counter uk viagra does viagra home delivery work liquid viagra ingredients why does cialis give me a headache viagra jelly canada doxycycline in uti can you take 2 10 mg cialis pills ovaire polykystique traitement clomid reviews 8400gs fonte generic a viagra estudios bioequivalencia generic viagra cialis generika erfahrung ihrem how to buy viagra in sydney where to get propecia in australia viagra cialis delivery next business day cialis reviews cost 20 mg cialis ohne zollprobleme kaufen viagra copyright ends ukc is 100 mg of viagra too much buy diflucan from canada cheap order clomid in malaysia glimepiride metformin brands rush costa rica viagra does clomid cause multiple pregnancies buy daily 2.5 mg cialis online zoloft metallic taste in mouth can i cut my 20 mg cialis into 5 mg and take daily comment prendre clomid 50 mg viagra over the counter in johor is viagra available over the counter in the usa brand viagra online china where can i buy doxycycline toronto metformin hcl 500 mg tablets used as phones zithromax 500 mg obat apa yang trimix review and viagra buy viagra online from tescos can my gp prescribe clomid uk brand name viagra online overnight shipping zithromax 1000 mg europe cloridrato de ciprofloxacino causa diarreia viagra in contact cu alcoolul how do you know if someone has taken viagra compare propecia costs como se usa cytotec de 200 mcg dosage of doxycycline for periodontitis propecia im internet bestellen can viagra go threw australian customs how can i get viagra in merida mexico which is safer lexapro or zoloft using clomid and nolva together ampicillin replacement in unasyn dialysis generic viagra express shipping legit place to buy clomid online high dose doxycycline acne finasteride tablets in philippines walgreens or walmart cheaper for generic cialis how much does cialis cost a walmart viagra hausarzt oder urologe francesca brandolini pfizer viagra metformin and januvia together 20 mg cialis effects on pregnancy what age can i get viagra when is the best time to start accutane lipitor 10 mg bijsluiter cialis ampicillin administration in newborns i want to buy viagra mississauga prednisone retail price what time of day is best for taking zoloft cialis canada purchases best finasteride india 150 mg viagra reviews top 10 viagra like foods high in magnesium ciprofloxacino 500 mg genfar viagra costs and quantities que es sildenafil de 50 mg 20mg doxycycline uk wellbutrin 150 mg and zoloft 50 mg thuoc adalat la 60 mg prednisone high dose sildenafil for pulmonary hypertension cialis 5 mg venezuela president what does cialis cost at sams club mono cedocard 50 mg bijsluiter viagra viagra bh mg nimue buy online uk viagra is it better to take clomid in the morning or at night socialist realist painting popular titles can cialis cause brain damage alclimax sildenafil 50 mg when to use viagra tablets do tesco really sell viagra what is cialis black is over the counter viagra just as effective can you take doxycycline for acne 100 mg per dose get high off viagra treating enlarged prostate with cialis dosaggio viagra 25 mg prednisolone acis 50 mg tabletten dispenser ciprofloxacin tinidazole price price on cialis in south africa triazole 150 mg viagra use paypal to pay for viagra accutane cause cystic acne best over the counter for viagra viagra price in lucknow viagra canada shoppers drug mart viagra for women how does it work teva prednisone 50 mg effects secondaires de l se vende cytotec en farmacias del ahorro sucursales viagra sales worldwide zion labs cialis over the counter serlife vs zoloft generic name best way to take cialis for best results pomada dexametasona generico de cialis ou acheter cialis manufacturer of generic api for tadalafil tadalafil sale online cialis canada illegal buy generic viagra for sale in japan missing one dose of accutane asbestos 3 day course of prednisone cheap viagra for sale insouth africa can clomid help in unexplained infertility how do you cut a viagra pill in thirds para que sirve la pastilla propranolol 10 mg metformin buy online india dolores despues de usar cytotec generic merk finasteride brazil inderal retard 80 mg biverkningar sobril cialis cost with bcbs ins. Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » The Disaster Roulette.

The Disaster Roulette.

datePosted on 15:57, March 19th, 2011 by Pablo

2011 is shaping up to be a most unhappy year. The seemingly endless parade of human misery caused by the three C’s–calamity, catastrophe and chaos– got me to thinking about which is “worse:” human-caused or natural disasters?

The answer lies in the response. In natural disasters the majority of people band together to work together for the common purpose of overcoming individual and collective hardship and tragedy in pursuit of the common goal of re-establishing normality to the lives. The solidarity exhibited during such times is born of the realisation that nature is a force that cannot be controlled and that no blame can be attributed to it or anything else. It just is, and we live at its mercy. If societies are to thrive, the only response to natural disasters has to be social union and commonality of purpose.

Human disasters, on the other hand, tend to bring out the worst in people. In fact, they are often the product of and the motivation for human cruelty, opportunism and greed. Unlike natural disasters, which are indiscriminate in application, human disasters are discriminate and often deliberate (because even negligence affects some more than others given socio-economic, political and cultural demographics). War and genocide are extreme expressions of human disaster, but the reach of malfeasance is vast and wide. Think of the looting that followed the Iraq occupation or pro-democracy protests in Cairo. Or the cynical use of false information supplied to ISAF forces to settle personal vendettas in Afghanistan. Or the wave of drug-related murders in Mexico (over 35,000 in the last five years) that rides on the back of poverty, ignorance and an unwillingness by consuming societies to recognise the demand aspect of the equation. The same willful blindness and self-serving logics applies to human sex trafficking in SE Asia, which leaves a terrible toll of human and social costs in its wake but which is allowed, even encouraged, by states simply because it channels sexual predation to foreign localised areas (such as Thailand, which is the recipient of well-advertised sex tours from countries such as Japan and Germany). Then there are the corporate disasters ranging from the tobacco industry’s lying about the effects of smoking to lax safety regulations at chemical plants in places like Bophal to the manipulation of financial derivatives by bankers that produced the global financial crisis of 2008-present and which exacted a terrible toll in lost jobs, lost homes and, in some countries, lost public benefits imposed by austerity measures prescribed by the very people who caused the crisis in the first place.

If my view is correct then the answer is clear: human disasters are “worse” than natural disasters.

But there is another scenario that brings the worst of both together: where human folly has magnified the impact of a negative natural event. That may be the case in Japan. If it turns out that concerns about nuclear safety standards were ignored or covered up by power company operators in the years before this year’s earthquake and tsunami, and/or that they are currently downplaying the gravity of the situation in an effort to save face, then the current nuclear crisis is a human add-on to what otherwise is a terrible but surmountable natural disaster. The same is true if it turns out that the supposedly “earthquake-proof” buildings in countries with known fault lines have not been built to code due to corruption or cost-cutting (this is especially true for states located with the Ring of Fire earthquake zone and Central Asia where such standards, if they exist, are haphazardly enforced). I use these two examples because they are in the news at present, but the list of instances where human failures worsened the negative impact of a natural event is long. As for the bible-bashers who place blame on victimised societies because of their supposed failures to adhere to God’s teachings: the less said the better, but they too add unnecessary suffering to those already in distress.

In sum, it seems to me that natural disasters are tragedies for which humanity is socially hard-wried to cope. Human disasters are worse because they promote self-centred advantage-taking, meanness and division rather than solidarity and unity. Human and natural disasters combined are the most calamitous of all because the presence of the former compounds and exacerbates the problem while making more difficult a common response to the latter.

All of which is to say, if I have to spin the disaster wheel given where I live, I bet on natural causes and prepare accordingly (easier to do in NZ than in SG, which is another reason to return home). However, should I ever again live in a conflict zone or where corporate and/or political corruption abounds (and that could well be most of the world), then I will hedge my bets with a human disaster contingency plan as well.

10 Responses to “The Disaster Roulette.”

  1. Hamish on March 19th, 2011 at 17:58

    This wasn’t the blog I was expecting next from you. To be perfectly honest I had never actually considered the issue of Human v Natural disasters. I had been expecting a blog on the Libyan situation from you hoping you would either validate my thoughts or point out my errors.

    I noticed the other day that New Zealand had attracted the attention of the Femen in the Ukraine ( A female protest group who undress to make the point that the Ukraine is not a brothel ) over a, to be blunt puerile competition run by a NZ radio station. This blog has made me reconsider my position on that competition. It will probably make me reconsider a few other things as well as I reflect on it further. Thanks.

  2. Pablo on March 19th, 2011 at 18:26

    Hamish:

    I have refrained from ME-specific themes for the moment because I wrote a fair bit about them last month and most of what I said has been validated. I did leave a comment on the matter over at kiwiblog (in response to a post titled “Gulf War 3”) that addresses some specific issues involved in the UN decision to invoke a no fly zone over the country.

    This post is just a more general reflection of the current state of global affairs.

  3. Hugh on March 19th, 2011 at 22:41

    If we look at the past 100 years the death toll for human disasters massively exceeds the death toll for natural disasters. If we make even a conservative assessment of the contribution poverty lends to natural disasters then it’s not even close.

    That pretty much closes the issue for me.

  4. Bruce Hamilton on March 20th, 2011 at 13:23

    If we look at the past 100 years the death toll for human disasters massively exceeds the death toll for natural disasters.

    Assuming natural disasters include epidemics, one natural disaster alone ( Spanish Flu ) killed between 3 and 5% of the global population ( around 1.8 billion ) and affected around 25% of the population. That’s 50 – 100 million dead, so what ” massively exceeds ” such events?.

  5. Hugh on March 20th, 2011 at 14:22

    Bruce, I meant the total death toll of natural vs human, not that every individual natural disaster could be topped by an individual human disaster. But the upper estimates of WW2’s casualty count are a good 75 million, which is comparable.

  6. Bruce Hamilton on March 20th, 2011 at 15:03

    Bruce, I meant the total death toll of natural vs human, not that every individual natural disaster could be topped by an individual human disaster.

    I accept that, so I chose one specific example in time. The greatest recent natural disaster ( smallpox, 300 million deaths since 1900 ), is something that humanity has almost completely eradicated.

    Humanity’s efforts at extermination don’t “massively exceed” nature, especially when Smallpox’s fellow travellers, such as Measles, Malaria, and TB are included.

  7. tochigi on March 21st, 2011 at 04:58

    i cannot begin to imagine how one would categorise the Spanish Flu epidemic as a “natural disaster”. First World War was a human disaster, directly leading to the epidemic. and for that matter, most major epidemics are human disasters.

  8. Hugh on March 21st, 2011 at 14:48

    Bruce, to me a disease whose effects are ongoing but don’t spike in an epidemic or pandemic doesn’t really count as a “disaster”. If you count all diseases as natural disasters, then yes, they far outweigh human disasters. But as tochigi points out many disease-related deaths are preventable and caused by poverty, which is a product of human agency.

  9. Bruce Hamilton on March 21st, 2011 at 18:11

    Bruce, to me a disease whose effects are ongoing but don’t spike in an epidemic or pandemic doesn’t really count as a “disaster”.

    Your call, others differ, eg one Wikipedia entry, that topped my Google search…
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_natural_disasters_by_death_toll

    There are people who consider all disasters involving human deaths can be construed as a consequence of human actions, as some other Wikipedia disaster entries will probably demonstrate.

    Initiating a deliberate action that usually harms many others is not natural, but an unfortunately common human-caused disaster.

    To me, it’s more about intent, as many natural disasters can be unintended/unwanted consequences – choosing to live on the ring of fire, near a volcano, associating with people who may be ill, etc etc. The hazard obviously existed, but a personal risk assessment decided it was acceptable.

    Natural agents that kill after a population’s exposure to the hazard have wiped out far more humanity than other humans. If those events don’t fit your definition of a disaster, that’s fine.

    Sorry to have diverted the thread…

  10. Hugh on March 21st, 2011 at 19:25

    Bruce, wikipedia may be a good source for statistics but when it comes to definitions of words like “disaster” or “revolution”, I don’t consider it authoritative. If your definition of “natural disaster” basically includes every death not directly attributable to human agency, then yes, you’re correct, but you’re also interpreting Pablo’s initial question in such a way as to make it absurd to ask.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: