comprar cialis generico 10mg diazepam the cost of propecia merck doxycycline monohydrate reviews zoloft 50 mg efectos secundarios hovid montclair 10 mg prednisone sildenafil 20 mg ndc number vaigra sildenafil in hindi tralet dapoxetine hereisthebestin cost formoterol nombre generico de amoxil balkan pharmaceuticals strombafort 10 mg prednisone diflucan over the counter philippines star price of 50 mg doxycycline capsules best lip balm on accutane pyridium generico do viagra what are the generic names for viagra glucophage 500 mg pcos diet para que serve o medicamento imipramina 25 mg zoloft puedo tener relaciones despues de usar cytotec is cialis found in the urine can clomid cause an ectopic pregnancy over the counter zoloft women viagra pills in mexico prices of generic cialis azithromycin over the counter uk viagra why does cialis cost the same for 10 mg and 20 mg mp research accutane reviews for mild doxycycline treat uti dosage cialis 10 mg originale prezzo propecia dosage .5 mg prix viagra prix com zovirax in der ssw why is metformin discontinued in hospital cialis 20 mg prestazioni how much potassium to take with lasix 40 mg fildena sildenafil citrate 100 mg tadalafil immediate delivery ou acheter du cialis sur internet blurry vision in one eye accutane acne es posible quedar embarazada despues de usar cytotec heladeras kohinoor donde comprar viagra la pastilla viagra how to buy accutane in malaysia glucophage xr 750 mg dosis viagra online canada pharmacy paypal accepted bula viagra generico in farmacia doxycycline disp 100 mg bijwerkingen chemotherapie can doxycycline cause cloudy urine cialis 5 mg per ansia da prestazione descobri que meu namorado usa viagra cialis lowers price prednisone lyme disease contraindications of metformin use in non diabetics ciprofloxacin otic drops how fast does it take for viagra to work doxycycline dosage for malaria prophylaxis scoliosis specialists in nj nexplanon implant positive reviews of zoloft prednisolone 5 mg tabletki cheapest viagra for sale 20 mg clomid uk viagra sale en antidoping chances of getting pregnant 1st month on clomid does accutane cause keloids best price generic propecia pills import viagra legally australia liquid cialis fail a drug test ladinin ciprofloxacin 500 mg best viagra pills in uk viagra cape town over the counter best site buy generic viagra propranolol 20 mg tablet for hyperthyroid viagra aortic stenosis compare propecia prices regitine 10 mg prednisone viagra for men for sale in mumbai bula do remedio alektos 20 mg cialis cytotec online pharmacies monthly price of clomid prescription can you buy viagra at 17 can we take clomid 50 mg for siphene 100 watson in rawalpindi viagra prices ciprodex otic drops in india cialis e20 generics24 ohne wirkung von viagra will get in uae gastrologist specialist in joliet buy sildenafil from canada online viagra real cialis tablet cheap bipreterax 5mg 1 25 mg zoloft glucophage in treatment of pcos is generic clomid good vicodin generic version of zoloft long term usage doxycycline viagra online kaufen osterreich 4 cialis generic viagra how long for cialis daily to work real viagra online buy lasix in dialisi cobra 148 gtl dx for sale in uk zithromax buying sildenafil online zithromax 500 mg dosis perfume where to buy viagra for men in delhi how to counter back pain from cialis perfect generics propecia ciprofloxacin ratiopharm 250 mg alkoholi can i buy brand name cialis viagra tree in canada zarator 40 mg bivirkninger prednisolone is accutane available in mexico buy viagra toronto canada 200 mg zoloft per day claversal 500 mg dosierung viagra glumetza metformin cost ciprofloxacina cloridrato 500 mg 20 ml prednisone line prescriptions viagra viagra sydney buy buy cialis on internet sildenafil generico dr simi norwood zoloft obsessive compulsive disorder user reviews buying safe viagra safe viagra website generika viagra in deutschland pre seed lubricant and clomid for sale viagra kaise use kare brand name viagra women price of 50 mg doxycycline online rakhi to india cheap viagra active ingrdients in viagra menthol davis donde comprar viagra sildenafil 50 mg prices united states aborto con misoprostol generico do viagra viagra no prescription europe comprar pastillas cytotec en colombia comen when is the best time to take your zoloft ampicillin sodium price thuoc isonace 10 mg prednisone nolvadex in indian market finasteride really work cipro 250 mg bid definition prescription price of cialis at walmart thuoc glucophage xr 1000 mg buy finasteride and estrogen where to buy epistane and nolvadex stopping 50 mg zoloft cold turkey generic viagra poland was kostet cialis in luxemburg reviews on doxycycline hyclate depakine chrono 300 mg bijwerkingen cialis viagra next day delivery without prescription generiek cialis 5 mg daily i want viagra without prescription in brussel viagra online is it safe red indian viagra java method declaration generics for zoloft viagra canada cheapest car buy doxycycline in malaysia nolvadex review bodybuilding how long does propecia take to work for you dose ciprofloxacin 500 mg iv treatment leptospirosis cialis two tubs tranxene 10 mg bijsluiter cialis buy zithromax poder are there phamacy that sell viagra in botswana viagra generic free cialis in mercury drug how long for finasteride to take effect glucophage yeast infections best research chemicals nolvadex cialis monthly cost walmart cialis to come in effect cialis generic soft tabs viagra legal new zealand accutane isotretinoin cost colace nombre generico de amoxil secured clomid online ventajas y desventajas de usar sildenafil is prohormone and viagra safe buy lasix online without a prescription nekane chocolate donde comprar viagra brand viagra at ebay can i take doxycycline with benadryl real propecia for cheap no prescription buy viagra by pay pal dapoxetine indian company buy female cialis 90 pills prednisone 10 mg 5 times day banks safe meds viagra do many people take propecia in uk problems with metformin hcl 500 mg tadalafil order form in uk viagra 24 co uk half life of propranolol tadalafil tablets 20 mg e200 hard sell evolution of viagra salesman how to get propecia in australia glimepiride 2mg metformin 500mg in cipla india thuoc zithromax 250mg buy cialis 5 mg daily dose amoxil 125 mg syrup dispenser variants of viagra in mumbai zovirax pommade prix maroc cheapest cialis to canada doxycycline 200 mg quad tab vets iui clomid success stories doxycycline and order online viagra soft tabs kaufen doxycycline dosing in canines price of doxycycline malaria tablets comprar tadalafil en peru how to take dapoxetine tablets peligros del viagra cialis canada .99 migraine specialist in johnstown pa minoxidilfinasteride want price and competitor in india how long to take lasix for their generic propecia can general practitioner prescribe cialis online lady viagra uk price sildenafil eg 50 mg prix what is an over the counter alternative to viagra sufrexal pomada generico do viagra articles on viagra generika viagra tablets cost viagra in nyc buy cheap viagra online usa finasteride 1 mg alternate days cialis right dose taking 5mg of cialis where can you buy cialis in kuala lumpur metformin 1000 mg uses oraxim 6 cpr riv 500 mg metformin onde comprar viagra cialis efeitos causados cytotec cheap viagra next day viagra delivery viagra medicare part d sildenafil gel oral nolvadex tamoxifen paypal ciprofloxacino 500 mg sirve para infeccion urinaria cheapest and best cialis nausea from accutane retina specialist in pompano florida ims health brasil genericos do viagra comprar viagra hoy if buying cialis how much mg should you take propecia 1mg apteka tadalafil tablets 20 mg cipro 250 mg twice a day medication cost of 10mg cialis pill how quickly does clomid work in men dove comprare viagra generico generic viagra with greendot card sildenafil pulmonary hypertension cost buy cytotec in davao cialis price in pharmacies socialist organizations in the united states can i cut ciprofloxacin in half specialist marketing services propranolol in liver failure propranolol 20 mg withdrawal from zoloft cialis patent expiration date in canada liquid nolvadex citrate is it legal to sell viagra in the uk 40 mg dose of cialis viagra buy from cyprus lasix in houston viagra generico farmacias similares monterrey bula do remedio ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab cialis 2.5 mg reviews cost cialis prix 5mg metformin hcl 500 mg and clomiphene acrata viagra for sale viagra generico envio 24 horas propecia medsafe ciprofloxacin private prescription cost viagra indian tablets 500g is 0.5 mg of propecia effective indian brands of viagra available in at bangalore qualitest 20 mg prednisone lysate generico do viagra sermion 30 mg pfizer viagra can you buy viagra over counter bangkok cheep cialis from canada do you take zoloft in morning or night glucantime donde comprar viagra is it safe for a 30 year old to take viagra customer reviews for viagra cialis from boots uk buy clomid nolvadex kann jeder viagra kaufen where to buy nolvadex and hcg in south africa cheap alternative to propecia how much liquid cialis should i take a day buy genuine viagra from healthyman cialis 5 mg usos cipro buy online no prescription viagra super force generic average time it takes to get pregnant on clomid pregnancy symptoms with clomid noble labs accutane generic viagra in retailers s africa medsafe data sheet metformin 500mg 04 zoloft buy reacciones del viagra en el hombre propecia 1 mg resultados viagra dogase price buy tadalafil 20mg uk where to buy viagra in malaysia pharmacy donde se puede comprar viagra en chile existe tadalafil generico venta can i cut cialis 20mg in half propranolol 10 mg and paracetamol 500mg in migraines finasteride teva 1 mg prix accutane 20mg price in malaysia note can you cut cialis in two wholesale kamagra jelly viagra one a day cialis prices generic finasteride or propecia results jose wilker morreu usando viagra diclofenaco cinfa 50 mg comprimidos viagra propranolol clorhidrato 1 mg viagra in farmacia din moldova hiking sandals womens reviews on cialis mandirs for sale in uk zithromax prednisone 40 mg taper over 12 days pink discharge after taking clomid 1 mg of prednisone for copd highest dose for viagra where to buy viagra in sri lanka propecia safe not sertraline sandoz 50 mg same as zoloft side tesco pharmacy viagra prices viagra sildenafil uk low cost viagra 50mg cytotec el costo strongest dose viagra accutane costco price viagra usa canada cialis pills online pharmacy sildenafil generic canada zoloft tablet de 50 mg clomid 25 mg for male inertility lasix cheap how much does one 100mg viagra cost 5mg cialis best prices milk and cipro buy clomid medication cialis 2 5 mg effetti collaterali cialis prix officiel if woman takes viagra how long does daily cialis take to get in your system maticna mlec kako se koristi viagra how much costs viagra in india can you get viagra at the chemist sildenafil blue tablets ciprofloxacina megaflox 500 mg cialis sold shipped from canada buy viagra overnight shipping canada generic viagra united pharmacy vibramycin whartisthebestin no prescription buy viagra shanghai buy cost low viagra ciprofloxacin hereisthebestin without prescription ciprofloxacina 500 mg contenido time of day take clomid cytotec rezeptfrei kaufen ampicillin drug study nursing crib review viagra for buy from bangladesh doxycycline for lyme disease dosage 300 mg thailand online pharmacy propecia prices viagra comprar santiago clomid how long does it take to work costo promedio de cytotec where to buy clomid in thailand is the diflucan pill sold over the counter which is the best viagra for men viagra generikum kaufen viagra prices in hawaii viagra generico colombia generic drug viagra classification cost of clomid at target comprar viagra generico brasil yahoo cual es el mejor finasteride 1mg pro chem oxybol 50 mg viagra buy nolvadex cancer generico do viagra pramil singh propecia for hair growth in men viagra montreal buy classifieds cialis by cipla reviews ayurvedic viagra available in kerala chinese viagra in redbox para q se usa sildenafil there liquid form prednisone what ingredients are in zovirax zoloft has really helped me synonyms why does cialis cause back ache which costs more cialis or viagra 20 mg cialis make you where to get viagra discount coupons viagra valium kamagra discreet uk europe tadalafil effetti collaterali sildenafil 100 mg generico do viagra dosulepin 150 mg viagra donde comprar misoprostol cytotec mexico prednisone 100 mg tablet glibenclamide with metformin brands in india is cipro ordered for pancretitis con que frecuencia se puede usar cytotec can you buy cialis over the counter in france prices of viagra 25g at loyads or asda priligy hereisthebestin australia dermatologist acne treatment accutane when is best time to take cialis for maximum effect corticosteroids prednisone coming off clomid tablets do they work viagra online prescription required purchase viagra generico resolve zovirax 400 mg dosierung paracetamol ciprofloxacino 500 mg genfar para que sirve ciprofloxacina actavis 250 mg yahoo answers how to buy viagra buy livening com viagra health compra de viagra generica provera and clomid australia online viagra to canada safe take viagra beta blockers cheap deal pill pill viagra how much does viagra cost 2012 240 mg prednisone generic accutane results when do i take my viagra cialis uk shop prednisone 30 mg a day pregnancy helmiben generico do viagra prix cialis pharmacie lyon reviews for cialis black ciprofloxacin aristo 500 mg dosierungsanleitung thuoc metformin stada 850 mg liquidex and nolvadex same time buy real viagra canada propecia order in canada ampicillin in mice what is generic viagra called in brazil where to buy viagra in blackburn can you buy viagra bangkok prednisone baownbeuv reviews buying metformin natural form of viagra zwanger na clomid 50 mg clomid dosage 25mg ciprofloxacin eye drops used in ears viagra kaufen mit paypal viagra pharmacy online buy zovirax cream in canada 25 mg zoloft to 50mg fentanyl cheap and effective viagra safe to take viagra and advil glyburide and metformin in pregnancy buy viagra uk paypal generator propranolol brands in india para que se usa la tadalafil socialist realist painting how many books cialis in linz kaufen metformin price with medicare why is viagra so expensive uk doxycycline in breast feeding cialis 2.5 mg online using paypal doxycycline malaria pills cialis 2.5 prix lasix 20 mg markings zoloft and binge eating disorder buy cialis vietnam prednisone through mailorder metformin za regulaciju ciklusa viagra chemist mumbai safe take 150mg zoloft fluocinolone acetonide shampoo generic cialis lexapro after zoloft reviews serotonin syndrome from 25 mg zoloft help doxycycline 100 mg 500 count canada drinking on accutane zithromax uses treatments doxycycline hyclate 50 mg for blepharitis is viagra illegal in the bahamas priligy online pharmacy uk valium best time for taking finasteride nhs cost viagra legit websites to buy viagra buy diflucan one online costo generic propecia online priligy paypal zoloft 50 mg ultrafarma where can i get cytotec pills in malaysia cut the 20mg cialis tablet in half prednisone brand names in india priligy cost in india que es una pastilla de viagra for sale cialis 20 mg. best price cavalieri del reale ordine di cipro lisinopril and viagra without problems Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Isolated


datePosted on 12:01, November 10th, 2010 by Lew

This brief report from Radio Waatea brings into crispish focus a few issues regarding the māori party’s support for the new Marine & Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Bill, and perceived collaboration with the National-led government against its constituents’ own interests:

Sharples upset at Maori Media Ingratitude
Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples says he’s disappointed at the heat coming on him from the Maori media over the Marine and Coastal Area Bill.
Criticism of the bill by iwi such as Ngai Tahu and Ngati Kahungunu and from Taitokerau MP Hone Harawira has been extensively reported.
But Dr Sharples says it’s better than the existing Foreshore and Seabed Act, and the Maori media should reflect that.
“They forget we’re there on their side to do stuff for them. Instead of sort of helping us knock down the barriers, they try to knock us down as the barrier. And yet without as it were the initiation of us in there, there would be no efforts at all and in the context of past Maoris in government, we have really achieved outstanding results,” he says.
Dr Sharples says the Maori Party hasn’t got enough credit the whanau ora welfare delivery model and for his rehabilitation units in prisons, which will open next year.

Sharples is right in several important respects. The role the māori party party has played in getting take Māori and tino rangatiratanga on the government agenda has been crucial. The māori party really does have a unique claim to an “authentic” kaupapa Māori politics, and this should make Māori media such as Waatea, Māori Television and TVNZ’s Māori programming division (which produces Te Karere and Marae) should be strongly sympathetic towards their policy programmes. Should, I say, if the end policy result was seen to be consistent with those kaupapa.

But these agencies do not owe the māori party any favours. As media outlets their job is not to shill for a party line but to present a considered view of current events in context, and by reporting the deep dissatisfaction within Māoridom regarding the MCA bill they are doing just that. Māori media have generally shown a strong commitment to independence and impartiality — which is a particularly tricky thing to do given their cultural focus — and their coverage of the māori party’s policy platform is simply an extension of that commitment. Long may it continue, and would that it were more broadly shared.

What this episode really illustrates is the extent to which the māori party is isolated from its support structures with regard to its position on the MCA bill. Just as the party has failed to persuade its own constituency, and indeed its own caucus, that the MCA bill is worth supporting, it has failed to persuade the only media establishment which might be sympathetic to its cause as to the merits of that cause. All this illustrates one of two things: either the party is way off base; the strategy of supporting the bill is bad for Māori and Māori know it; or that the strategy of supporting the bill is actually a great deal better than anyone knows, but the party has largely failed to articulate this.

I know which I’m tending toward, and I invite readers to argue their case. But no matter which you believe, I think it’s clear that attacking the media is neither a mature nor a useful response. Successful actors in modern democracy lead the media, like they lead their electors — in the knowledge that both must follow willingly, by consent (however grudging), or not at all. If, as a politician, you ever find yourself running a sustained campaign of trying to shove either the media or your constituents in a certain direction against their will, berating or harassing or whipping them for their stupidity or intransigence or for simply failing to follow instructions — then you have very probably already failed.


27 Responses to “Isolated”

  1. Chris Trotter on November 10th, 2010 at 14:03

    I’m not sure, Lew, whether or not you have a lot of “hands on” experience of the news media, but having grown up in a media household (my Dad was a television producer) and having worked both with, and in, the news media for 30 years, I have to say: “It just don’t work that way!”

    The news media has a political agenda of its own. If what your political party stands for fits that agenda, you will prosper. If it doesn’t – you won’t.

    This is most true of those media organisations which are dependent upon advertising revenue, and least true of publicly-funded media like the Maori Television Service and Radio New Zealand. But, even in the latter organisations, there is always the unspoken threat of state funding withdrawal to prevent independent journalistic inquiry being given too free a rein.

    There’s nothing new in this. The NZ author, Robin Hyde, recalled her induction at the NZ Herald back in the 1920s, when the Chief Reporter told her that reporting anything positive about the Labour Party was a sacking offence.

    The only reason Labour was able to survive the unrelenting hostility of the print media and win the 1935 General Election was because it had grown, by the mid-1930s, into a genuine mass party with its own, independent, channels of communication. That, and the support of 1ZB’s “Uncle Scrim”.

    Nor was ‘The Herald’s’ blatant bias peculiar to NZ. David Halberstam, in his revealing study of the US media, “The Powers That Be”, recounts the following story:

    “In 1934, Turner Catledge, then a young political reporter for ‘The New York Times’, went out to the West Coast to do a story on Upton Sinclair and his radical political movement. Sinclair was running for governor in a passionate and heated campaign against Frank Merriman, the Republican candidate. Catledge picked up ‘The Los Angeles Times’ after he arrived, looking for news of Sinclair. There was none. He thereupon looked for a schedule for Sinclair so he could at least find out where the candidate was speaking and perhaps drive out to hear him. He found none. All he could find about Sinclair was a story saying that Sinclair was attacking the Bible and was un-Christian. That night Catledge went out to dinner with the ‘Times’ chief political correspondent, Kyle Palmer, and, still wanting to cover some Sinclair rallies, asked Palmer where Sinclair was speaking. Kyle who was very charming replied, ‘Turner, forget it. We don’t go in for that kind of crap that you have back in New York of being obliged to print both sides. We’re going to beat this son of a bitch Sinclair any way we can. We’re going to kill him.’ Which they did.”

    And you thought it all started with Fox News!

    As recently as a few months ago, a colleague told me about an exciting television project which had, after jumping through all the bureaucratic hoops, finally made its the way to the top of one of the major television networks, only to be told that it would not, after all, be proceeding “because it could hurt the Government”.

    Successful political “actors” don’t “lead” the news media, Lew, they merely read the script the news media gives them.

    If you don’t grasp that basic truth about modern politics, then you’re never going to fully understand what’s going on.

  2. Lew on November 10th, 2010 at 14:41

    A pretty good argument, Chris, and one with which I’m very familiar — but I disagree. And I certainly disagree that it’s a “basic truth”. I certainly don’t think it started with Fox News.

    The “basic truth”, as I see it, of the dynamic you describe is not a strictly hierarchical, unidirectional relationship between political and media agents but a feedback loop — both politics and the media lead and follow each other, with varying emphasis. In my experience many people working at the political coal face have an inflated view of the media’s influence and many of those in the media tend to overemphasise political actors’ media influence (though occasionally you get a megalomaniac like Murdoch or Hearst or Peters who sees it the opposite way). Moreover, partisans on either side tend to see “the media” as a unified whole; an entity with a single “political agenda” which provides everyone with a “script”. With due respect to you and to Mr Trotter Sr, I just don’t accept it’s that simple.

    I do agree entirely about the importance of a robust non-commercial media apparatus, and the susceptibility of commercial ad-driven media agencies to play the tunes their pipers call. I have a great deal of time in particular for Chomsky’s (& Herman’s) notion of manufactured consent (though I believe he draws many overlong bows in his book of the same name, the opening chapter ought to be required reading). So I am sympathetic to much of your argument, but I don’t buy it as a whole explanation. In particular, I’m disinclined to put down to ideological malice what can be adequately explained by deep, systemic flaws within the media industry apparatus (best documented recently by Nick Davies in his Flat Earth News).

    For what it’s worth, a large part of my work — “hands on”, as it were — is in helping folk here and abroad, particularly in government agencies but also in corporates and nonprofits — make sense of how this dynamic operates, and by extension help them to tune their actions and agendas and so on to use the system to their best advantage. So, once again, Chris, the disjunction between us here isn’t a matter of my not understanding the subject — it’s a matter of disagreeing about it.


  3. Chris Trotter on November 10th, 2010 at 15:54

    “For what it’s worth, a large part of my work — ‘hands on’, as it were — is in helping folk here and abroad, particularly in government agencies but also in corporates and nonprofits — make sense of how this dynamic operates, and by extension help them to tune their actions and agendas and so on to use the system to their best advantage.”

    Is that a polite description of public relations, Lew?

  4. Lew on November 10th, 2010 at 16:05

    No, it’s a vague and incomplete description of media intelligence.


  5. Chris Trotter on November 10th, 2010 at 18:01

    “Media Intelligence” – what, like “Military Intelligence”?

    Using skills and information your opponents would rather you didn’t have, while spreading disinformation you’d really like them to use, in order to outwit and/or defeat them?

    Hmmmm, sounds uncannily like Public Relations to me ;-)

  6. Lew on November 10th, 2010 at 18:55

    Well, Chris, I suppose you’ll just have to take my word that it’s not nearly as glamorous as all that.

    Care to comment on the issue raised in the post? I’d have thought it an argument you’d be drawn to, even if only to congratulate me for finally reaching the conclusion which was bleeding obvious all along.


  7. ak on November 10th, 2010 at 22:02

    “…the only media establishment which might be sympathetic to its cause…”

    The only. Might be.

    I’d say that’s a pretty clear admission right there, Lew, that Chris’s view is pretty well spot on – and one, incidentally, to which I could add my own wee bucket of anecdotes from the front line. The only “feedback loop” I see is the rare bone occasionaly thrown leftward to maintain the facade of impartiality required for “manufactured consent”, and there’s precious little meat on it.

  8. Lew on November 10th, 2010 at 22:15

    ak, not at all.

    The māori party speaks to a tiny constituency with a very particular set of perspectives and policy needs. Despite being within government, they’re by no means a mainstream political party. Their foundations — the basis for their actions and their mode of discourse — are alien to the established media ecology; they work to different rules, and and as such the conventional media and political actors simply don’t get them. Or, to put a finer point on it, they only get them if they can “map” their actions and motivations to an existing ideological template — and so we end up with the “Hori Tories” narrative which is a poor fit at best; and as I wrote last week, we have Hone Harawira, Annette Sykes and Moana Jackson shoehorned into the “radical leftist hero” box by people searching desperately for a story which suits their agenda. And so it goes.

    The lack of support in the media establishment for the māori party is largely not an ideological thing, it’s a cultural thing. And while that’s not true of the Māori media; their lack of support in cases like this is not really down to systemic ideological reasons — after all, most of those I named above respond to the same sorts of marketing/advertising imperatives as the conventional media.


  9. Chris Trotter on November 10th, 2010 at 23:29

    “[T]une their actions and agendas” – right there, Lew, right there is where the slippery slope to perdition begins.

    Tune them to what? The frequency of POWER-Fm, owned and operated by Free Market Capitalism Ltd?

    I think you’ve proved my case for me.

  10. Lew on November 10th, 2010 at 23:51

    Chris, no.

    For one thing, the two broadest-circulation mainstream news programmes in NZ — Morning Report and One News, which account for well over 50% of the news audience in their respective timeslots — both air on state-owned broadcasters who are required to adhere to a public service broadcast model. Of course this doesn’t mean they’re perfect, but they’re not really subject to your primary critique, which is that advertising corrupts news beyond the point of ideological usefulness by its simple existence.

    For another, I think that critique is simplistic and generally used as a crutch by people who have a beef with capitalism in general, but who aren’t willing to accept or critically examine the political left’s failure to adapt to the realities of the media and political environment in which they must exist. It’s an easy cop-out target to blame the capitalists, but ultimately useless when a successful political movement will find ways to thrive — both by developing its own channels, and by learning to operate within those which exist. This is not to say that the red carpet is rolled out — of course, you need to fight to get your message across. But it is usually possible to get it across. The old saying that capitalists will sell you the rope to hang them should be particularly resonant with you, Chris, since they’ve been paying you to measure out that rope for so long.


  11. Tom Semmens on November 11th, 2010 at 10:28

    Lew, If you are a unionist or left winger worth your salt then one day you’ll challenge the political status quo in a meaningful way. Then you’ll get a taste of what it is really all about. Until that day, no amount of telling you is going to convince of or prepare you for the shock you are going to get.

  12. Chris Trotter on November 11th, 2010 at 10:42

    Ah, Lew, if only you knew how TVNZ operates!

    If only you had been privy to the behind-the-scenes manipulation of public opinion engaged in by our chartered “public broadcaster” in the run up to the 2008 election.

    And you forget, I think, Lew, that I was one of those who helped to launch the NewLabour Party in 1989 – so I know a little bit about trying to “tune” an organisation’s “actions and agendas” to the requirements of the mainstream media.

    Shall I tell you what a senior journalist working for one of our major daily newspapers told me when I went to see him about his paper’s failure to carry any of the NLP’s press releases?

    He said: “I’m sorry, Chris, but in our judgement the NLP is a fringe party without the slightest chance of winning a seat – so we’re not giving it any space in our columns.”

    ‘Well, that’s true”, I replied, “but if your paper never prints anything the NLP sends you, what chance has it got of ever becoming more than a fringe party?”

    He just smiled. So I changed tack.

    “Okay then, at what point would the NLP cease to be a fringe party? At 5 percent support? At 10 percent? When would you consider its statements worthy of space in your paper?”

    He stroked his chin for a second or two.

    “If you were polling above 10 percent, I think we’d pay more attention.”

    “But we’re polling between 6 and 7 percent now. If you were to publish our releases that number could well rise to 10 percent – but you won’t, so we won’t.”

    Once again, he smiled.

    “Have you ever read ‘Catch 22’?” I asked him.

    “Oh yes”, he said, grinning broadly, “it’s one of my favourite books.”

  13. Lew on November 11th, 2010 at 10:56

    A great anecdote, Chris, and one I’ve heard many times in various forms. As I say — there’s never a guarantee it will be easy, but none of this changes the fact that there are other ways of getting into print. And with respect, upbraiding individual journalists about editorial decisions is rarely a winning strategy. Matt McCarten seems to have hit upon something, though.


  14. Lew on November 11th, 2010 at 11:12

    The leftier-than-thou no-true-Scotsman concern troll is as much as I’ve come to expect from you, Tom.


  15. Tiger Mountain on November 11th, 2010 at 11:30

    On thread for a moment I support the first suggestion in para 4
    “bad for Māori”. There was a situation at Taipa yesterday where Ngati Kahu were tresspassed off their own land! by cops egged on by a right wing Mayor. It is acknowledged in the Muriwhenua report 1997 and Waitangi tribunal hearings that title was never properly extinguished but various dubious ‘transfers’ to the Far North District Council are allowed to prevail.

    And what the hell, one more anecdote… a green friend of mine visited the editor of the local rag and asked if his 1080 article had been received, “Yes” said the editor pointing to his bottom desk draw, “it’s in there and thats where it will be staying”. Ed. being a notorious tory with allegedly his own key to the local police station.

    Matt and Unite do very well, direct action is all about the timing, not to be overdone and linked into a full strategy. If you have seen one Greenpeace abseiler you have seen them all.

  16. Chris Trotter on November 11th, 2010 at 13:57

    Wasn’t upbraiding the guy, Lew. I’d known him for years. I was just asking and he told me, honestly, what the story was.

    He was by no means at the top of the totem pole, just knew what was expected of him.

    And viv-a-vis Matt, if the roles were somehow reversed, do you think TV3 would have called a right-wing occupation a “stunt” or a “protest”?

    You can force yourself on to the news, Lew – but you can’t control the way it presents you.

  17. Lew on November 11th, 2010 at 14:30

    Chris, it is a stunt, or a protest, and it’s perfectly reasonable for the media to frame it as such.

    Though I agree that more attention should be on the issue in play — housing affordability and bureaucratic priorities — than the event of the protest itself, which was hardly controversial until the police turned up. But nevertheless: Matt set out to demonstrate the brutality of the present government, and he sure has done so.


  18. Chris Trotter on November 11th, 2010 at 16:07

    In an ideal world, I hope you will agree, Lew, it would not be necessary to occupy an unoccupied state house, risking arrest, in order to persuade the news media to pay some attention to the housing policies of by-election candidates.

    That this is very far from being an ideal world – especially as far as fairness in the mass media is concerned – was kinda my point.

  19. Lew on November 11th, 2010 at 20:16

    I do agree with all that, yes. But your raising it indicates that we’re arguing at cross-purposes. You’re essentially responding to what might be, or what ought to be, whereas I’m only really interested in talking about what is.

    While I don’t accept that the unfairness you’ve raised is as bad as you make it out to be, I accept that it exists. But politics at the sharp end is not fair. Wishing it were fair, and in particular complaining that it isn’t fair instead of simply getting on and making out as best you can is simply counterproductive. It is possible to make the system work for you; I know because I’ve seen it done. For all its biases and distortions, it is comprehensible and manipulable. So while I sympathise, I don’t have very much time for “the system is biased” sort of complaints. Yeah, it is. So? In order to make it fairer, you need to learn to work within it.


  20. Lew on November 11th, 2010 at 20:35

    TM, yes, that business up there is ugly; and how short are peoples’ memories for alienation? The fact that this expropriation by stealth — or by inertia — happened almost everywhere in the country in reasonably recent times. In many cases where it has been resisted by peaceful means such as these (Pakaitore, Whenuakite, Te Kuri o Paoa, Takaparawhau, eg) tangata whenua have prevailed, at least to an extent. And yet, every time, it is reported as if it’s a brand new dispute without precedent.


  21. George D on November 12th, 2010 at 05:16

    Firstly, to address your most recent comments.

    It is possible to make the system work for you; I know because I’ve seen it done. For all its biases and distortions, it is comprehensible and manipulable. So while I sympathise, I don’t have very much time for “the system is biased” sort of complaints. Yeah, it is. So? In order to make it fairer, you need to learn to work within it.

    It’s ****ing hard work.

    If you want to talk about something serious, it aint going to happen. Get ya tits out, and you’ve a chance. But media agendas in New Zealand are shockingly small, and no discussion of class (to take Tom Semmen’s discussion) will ever occur in overt terms – it will almost always be framed around issues such race or crime in ways that disempower lower classes. Most things are impossible to talk about in the media.

    To wave your hands and say “it’s just how it is” is ridiculous. New Zealand has a state-owned radio-station that fulfils its mandate very well. It also has a state owned television network that fails in its mandate very badly, because of deliberate decisions made by Dr Cullen to prioritise its revenue gathering function over any commitment to quality in public broadcasting. New Zealand once had other state-owned media outlets, and of course has created new ones in the last few years.

    All of which actually proves your original point – those media outlets which have a specific mandate or focus on Maori issues are qualified to comment and analyse these issues, and do so well. Other outlets have no desire to see things in anything other than exceedingly simple terms, because it suits their profit-making agendas – much of their audience has no desire for complexity or positions that challenge their preconceptions.

  22. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Lew, Lew. Lew said: On KP: Sharples' criticism of Māori media "ingratitude" re FSA replacement shows māori party is isolated from its base: […]

  23. Tom Semmens on November 12th, 2010 at 12:29

    If you want to talk about something serious, it aint going to happen. Get ya tits out, and you’ve a chance. But media agendas in New Zealand are shockingly small, and no discussion of class (to take Tom Semmen’s discussion) will ever occur in overt terms – it will almost always be framed around issues such race or crime in ways that disempower lower classes. Most things are impossible to talk about in the media.

    What is this?? An apostrophe in my name????

  24. George D on November 12th, 2010 at 14:42

    What is this?? An apostrophe in my name????

    Ouch. Sorry.

  25. Tom Semmens on November 12th, 2010 at 21:38

    Ouch. Sorry.

    That is OK. I am actually pretty dark on teh internet grammar Nazi routines. Being a Semmen’s is high on the novelty grammar index though.

  26. George D on November 13th, 2010 at 00:18

    Also sorry to Lew for swearing on your blog.

  27. Craig M on November 14th, 2010 at 17:13

    Criticism of various Maori media outlets need to be seen in the context that funding for Maori TV’s news and current affairs programming and TVNZ’s Maori programming is currently being reviewed by TPK and TMP, with a view to stopping the perceived double-up in State funding.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)