antabuse in your system order viagra asp doxycycline hyclate oral tablet 100 mg information fertility drug like clomid for sale metohexal 50 mg zoloft can doxycycline hyclate 50 mg treat a sinus infection 1000 mg. metformin twice daily clomid dose missed can you buy clomid over counter australia do i need recipe to buy viagra in us cipla genric viagra store in india feline doxycycline hyclate 100 mg 2 times can doxycycline used treat yeast infection safe time between nitro and viagra viagra cialis prices ciprofloxacin difficulty urinating in the morning place in melbourne to buy viagra had a break with finasteride safe to start again can we buy viagra in a pharmacy in bangkok is cialis worth it billige viagra kaufen ohne propecia salusmaster hoh mg of prednisone do you give a 30lb dog prednisone 50 mg can it make me fertile dapoxetine in europe onde comprar cialis em brasilia cialis 20mg how maney rupese in india bestraling bijwerkingen prednisone estonian soviet socialist republic in square miles generico do viagra araujo y cost 75mg viagra diazepam tablets ip 10 mg prednisone cialis 5 mg ou 20 mg melatonin brandon marshall talking about viagra lasix 40 mg hunde tadalafil tablets india can anybody buy viagra does metformin really help diabetes best hotel in cipro cialis coupon discounts is zoloft best taken at night or morning amsterdam viagra for sale propranolol 20 mg bid cheap cialis same day shipping tubemaster alternatives to viagra nolvadex 10 mg tabletas electronicas should i take robitussin while on clomid how to avoid doxycycline nausea where to buy accutane no prescription how to ask your boyfriend to take viagra viagra online viagra buy prescription accutane for hormonal acne reviews claversal 500 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin how long viagra 25 mg works difference between generic brand name zoloft viagra get in uae cialis fast shipping glucophage corticosteroids herbal viagra pills review buy your viagra with paypal cpt code for cytotec delivery of fetus how long will prednisone stay in my system buy doxycycline combined with metronidazole over the counter viagra uk zoloft 75 mg to 100 mg gabapentin is 200 mg cialis too much to take maca vs viagra la metformina causa insuficiencia renal amoxil 250 mg capsules why do you take lasix prexanil combi 10 mg prednisone where can i buy viagra on the gold coast viagra sildenafil in india lowest order viagra low price diflucan usa can clomid be ordered online acne accutane treatment pastillas genericas de viagra amoxil howdotofound online prednisone hyperactivity in adults prednisone injection in the butt where to get clomid uk ciprofloxacin tablets uses cipro eye drops cialis in deutschland ohne rezept tadalafil may treat walgreen cialis cost sildenafil citrate 20 mg and bodybuilding what if you accidentally take two propecia in one day finasteride 1mg indian us propecia comparison phirst study tadalafil online use of finasteride in prostate cancer buy viagra for women uk donde comprar cytotec sin receta en guadalajara tia juana pharmacies price viagra 100mg cialis original 20mg kaufen prescriptions for propecia at costco who are the actors in the latest cialis ad to buy cipla produced cialis online clomid 100mg in a day is it ok to take viagra every day cialis over the counter in usa viagra substitute over the counter at gnc cialis on paypal viagra shops in nairobi shoppers drug mart canada cialis cost clomid best day availability of generic viagra in the united states safe take tylenol zoloft buy clomid thailand buy cheap pills cipro viagra generico da 25 mg can clomid cause you to miss a period shelf life of liquid doxycycline want to order viagra by phone how much doxycycline is safe to take kaletra truvada viagra generic free generic cialis pills quanto costa il cialis da 10 can i take viagra with cymbalta acrilato de potasio donde comprar viagra amoxicilline 250 mg bijsluiter viagra generic viagras from cyprus can you take antibiotics while on clomid detrusitol retard 4 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin substitute for viagra in indian viagra price in london viagra 100 mg dosing prednisolone 20 mg lamar buy cialis today com buy zithromax st.louis melhor generico sildenafil is 200 mg diflucan for yeast too strong where can i get viagra in batam can i take doxycycline with lansoprazole dicorvin 500 mg metformin ex pharmarx generic viagra como actua cialis 5 mg orde viagra online plan b or generic cialis 150 generic viagra cost of doxycycline at costco clomid where to order male clomid dosage glimepiride 1mg metformin 500 mg dosage validita sildenafil sandoz 100 mg can you take doxycycline with trimethoprim accutane sold usa teva sildenafil online 40 mg accutane initial breakout statistics cialis buy china im selling viagra in toronto apresoline 50 mg zoloft best indian viagra tablet margarine para hojaldre donde comprar viagra clomid price za generic cialis cost what is cialis black latest price of viagra in india amoxil in first trimester for sore throat cure comprare in italia on line il viagra donde consigo cialis generico mexico can generic viagra be purchased legally in uk allergic reaction to prednisone where to buy propecia in the uk price of 1tablet viagra in india cerealis viagra without doctor diflucan and candida in intestine why take doxycycline for malaria price for metformin er buy prednisone overseas pharmacy how does nolvadex work in males antenex 10 mg prednisone sildenafil comprimidos 50 mg buy mifegyne and misoprostol cytotec cialis 5mg kaina viagra and old man costume iwant to buy viagra in penang viagra in verbindung mit drogen buy viagra in malmo is viagra made in india compra cialis in svizzera ciprofloxacino en que casos se usa how many doses of viagra buy viagra online next day delivery uk buy viagra online in karachi what is the cost of cytotec cialis safe men high blood pressure cost of 100 mg of viagra can clomid make your period really light how much does viagra cost australia viagra price at walmart canada saroten retard 25 mg dosierung viagra viagra in 2 days why does cialis cause chest pain a list of retina specialist in fairfax va low cost alternatives and cialis cialis availability in pakistan cheap accutane sale lang en are there generic drugs for viagra prednisolone 2 mg preisers disease viagra buy 24.ru can you buy clomid in tj without where can i get viagra in canada doxycycline treats yeast infection manfaat vibramycin 100 mg digran tadalafil 20mg get viagra drug online does cialis cause itching finasteride comprar carro cheap sildenafil citrate generic release kann man viagra in der apotheke kaufen viagra savings and coupons arcoxia 120 mg wirkstoff cialis sildenafil tablets brands how much is viagra in the us viagra safe heart medication comprare zoloft online generic viagra nomes de bebe zovirax 400 mg dosing doxycycline hyclate safe take counteract stuffy nose from viagra can you take xanax with doxycycline how much is the 5mg cialis in walgreens what days of cycle to take clomid safe exercise while taking propranolol before bed neobrufen retard 800 mg 40 comprimidos viagra generic viagra cost comparison how to buy cialis discretely zithromax cost rite aid buy viagra wholesale what is the max dose of doxycycline puedo comprar cytotec en farmacias del ahorro can lasix cause constipation zithromax price mercury drug website viagra online compare prices como y cuando tomar viagra el viagra es de venta libre ct specialists in auto electrical problems 20 mg prednisone dosage for 7 days bobble water bottle review buy viagra online viagra rx finasteride 1.25 bestellen sealine s380 for sale in uk zithromax viagra canada use family care specialists in montebello famot 20 mg cialis buy viagra at tesco now viagra comprar mercado livre viagra price in taiwan viagra launch marketing does clomid or gonadotropins safer prednisone at walamrt prices indian aunty as viagra were to buy viagra chicago viagra availabile in kerala market much does viagra cost private prescription buy finasteride 1mg vertigon tablet 25 mg zoloft how to buy clomid in mexico cura di cialis da 5 mg saxagliptin metformin bioequivalence of generic drugs is it safe to take 30 mg cialis clomid means in hindi ampicillin use in obstetrics cheap viagra and delay spray buy finasteride trade shop clomid online using paypal account dolo specifico e generico de cialis clomid from the united states jersey city njpharmacy with discount on cialis wher could i get viagra her in jozi ampicillin dose in neonates propecia for menopausal women viagra to buy in qatar ciprofloxacin generic or brand name get prescription propecia canada where buy viagra los angeles danemark cialis 8 mg aprovel nombre generico de amoxil selgian 20 mg cialis come comprare il viagra senza ricetta medica std treatment with doxycycline ciprofloxacin hydrochloride tablets 500 mg ciprofloxacin 750 mg indication ciprodex otic 7.5 ml for dog ear doxycycline antimalarial costs abc pills nolvadex online ncelab generic cialis democratic socialism in the us mil 100 mg viagra apo tamox e clomid onde comprar papel sildenafil tablets 100 g nolvadex 20mg online how long before cialis for daily use works should accutane be taken at the same time everyday viagra shop pasha rabotaet cost of lasix 20 mg walmart propranolol eg 40 mg bijsluiter when do u use viagra pressure in head when taking viagra russkie pesni viagra online viagra price dropping how to use clomid properly zithromax baownbeuv price lasix 20 mg and mineral excretion farmacia online cialis svizzera map indian viagra dropshipper buy cialis using mastercard in china gow many mg of sildenafil in black ant want to buy clomid from the uk with out perscription cialis buy new zealand order cialis without prescription cod viagra dosage over 65 generic price on propecia riva 50 mg viagra price cialis retail viagra several days in a row prednisolone acetate 1 15 ml fluconazole diflucan price philippines finasteride 2 5mg doxycycline in kidney transplant patients effient 10 mg controindicazioni viagra particle size in ciprodex otic prednisolone 20 mg bijsluiter buscopan sildenafil genericon cosplay propecia johor bahru getting viagra australia inderal dosage in thyrotoxicosis cheapest generic tadalafil side best place to get cialis online doxycycline hyclate 100 mg bloody nose la cytotec puede causar la muerte ampicillin sale anxiolit 50 mg viagra kodein dak 25 mg bivirkninger av zoloft finasteride 5 mg and hair growth busik online viagra liquid tadalafil dosage forms metformin stada 500 mg nebenwirkungen generic accutane baownbeuv first time viagra users price viagra cialis azithromax price philippines should i take accutane quiz onde comprar cialis em porto alegre viagra for sale in usa stores find viagra 100mg cost in india can you buy viagra in barbados without a viagra best suppliers average cost of 20mg cialis tablet para que sirve el ciprofloxacino 750 mg can i carry viagra for someone else in a plane cialis other drugs cialis 5mg tablets australia metformin ukpds calculator zovirax ointment cost profenid 200 mg wirkung viagra can you cut cipro 500 mg in half cost viagra 50mg provera vs clomid diflucan price mercury drug philippines price viagra cebu delivery doxycycline for tick bite in dog cialis in pakistan phone number contramal retard 50 mg bijsluiter cialis best price pfizer 100mg viagra propecia online propecia price without insurance buy viagra uk lloyds pharmacy ireland nolvadex online kaufen priligy rezeptfrei bestellen how to buy generic viagra in south africa sildenafil 150 ml can you overdose on propranolol metformin mechanism of action drugbank database how to take prednisone pills viagra sales in europe clomid pills purchase online review sibutril 20 mg prednisone prednisone 10 mg dangerous metformin tablets in india zovirax in allattamento incinta dopo 4 mesi di clomid online can doxycycline treat tooth infection order cialis online europe clomid for women pregnancy delivery amoxicillin versus ampicillin cheap pfizer viagra online uk priligy in tschechien kaufen propranolol 80 mg cena zithromax package insert pdf in powerpoint viagra 25 mg teilen ciclopirox shampoo generico do viagra zithromax in tokyo is viagra safe for diabetes medline alternative to metformin hcl 500 mg tablet diferencia viagra 50 mg y 100mg zithromax price mercury drug side effect of metformin 500 mg klotrix generic propecia cheap glucophage hereisthebestin risks of clomid safe take viagra age 18 buy cytotec malaysia ag specialists in plato mn what happens if someone takes viagra how long does 10 mg of viagra last comprar cytotec en valledupar buy undergrund viagra in london sildenafil citrate 100mg gel viagra shop in dublin can you buy cialis over the counter in philippines can i buy cialis without prescription in doha viagra for sale shipping in canada huracan capsule 150 mg viagra best sight to buy viagra online causa y efecto de la pastilla cytotec generic metformin zydus zovirax 15 mg ointment specials where can i buy cialis in budapest black cobra sildenafil 120mg india doxycycline dosage to treat std ampicillin 1000 mg dosage what does a generic viagra pill look like separatis ciprofloxacin 500 mg where to buy viagra in christchurch cialis prostate cancer treatment buy prednisolone eye drops online anadrol for sale 50 mg zoloft dapoxetine brand names in pakistan iman zithromax 500 mg azithromycin dosage cheapest viagra overnight delivery viagra order cialis accutane reviews mayo clinic bee informed counter viagra substitute price para sirve metformina clorhidrato 850 mg use viagra for performance anxiety zithromax pediatrico prezzo london cipromed 500 usage zithromax out of body in how many days best price viagra uk viagra vs birth control counterfiet propecia medsafe data sheet metformin 500 sildenafil 50 mg srpski buy tadalafil turkey shipping in canada cheapest viagra can cialis cause priapism cost of prescription prednisone hard sell the evolution of a viagra salesman review comprar cialis generico urgente order ciprofloxin on line next day shipping buy doxycycline hyclate tablets without prescription case in vendita via cipro accutane cost south africa compare price of propecia can i buy in malaysia viagra at the pharmacy tadalafil 50mg online han tomado viagra online ratio metformin hcl 500 mg fincar vs propecia cost bayer cialis 2.5 mg how much does viagra cost in mexico city online viagra consumer check normal dosage clomid 8 doxycycline 100mg caps propecia brand on line cialis usa who sells zovirax in hong kong tamsulosin hcl 0.4 mg and viagra donde puedo comprar viagra en alicante propecia in black men best price propecia in uk 200mg viagra online ciprofloxacino 500 mg ariston para que sirve generic viagra ultrafarma medicamentos 200 mg clomid online necesito comprar viagra en chile cual es accutane pushing out blackheads in ears ciprofloxacin in treatment of gonorrhea cialis prix pharmacie cialis tablets price in pakistan lumia ampicillin brands in pakistan karachi where can i get liquid clomid viagra made in hongkong loratadine orifarm 10 mg bivirkninger av prednisolone lasix liquide diflucan is it over the counter pamorelin la 11 25 mg of zoloft nolvadex whartisthebestin for sale chances of having twins with clomid 100mg cost of real viagra at walmart propecia from india is it trustful buy generic viagra with a mastercard where shall i buy viagra in chennai zithromax 500mg price in pakistan viagra online australia legal age 100 mg prednisone to start getting pregnant on 150mg clomid Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Sacred illusions

Sacred illusions

datePosted on 11:03, March 22nd, 2010 by Lew

one man one votePita Sharples has severely undermined his own and his party’s credibility with his Race Relations Day speech criticising “one person, one vote”. As a minister in a democratic government, he has taken aim at one of democracy’s fundamental symbolic virtues, in such a way as to give the impression he (and his party) are anti-democracy. After years of fighting for the voices of mana whenua to be heard in democratic politics on strong principled grounds, Sharples seems now to have accepted the extreme right’s framing of that representation as antithetical to democracy.

Let’s just be clear: “one person, one vote” is no sort of actual democracy, it is an illusory ideal which persists only in hearts and minds, placed there by bold principles and the stirring oratories brought by democratic leaders of old looking to appeal to something bigger than they were. Even our present democracy, which is a very great deal closer to the ideal than the original American system, is pretty far from “one person, one vote” at a functional level. For a start, we have two votes. Even if you had one, what sort of vote would it be: first-past-the-post, where you’re at the mercy of geography; or single-transferable, where you’re not sure until after it’s all over who your vote actually got counted for; or what? For another thing, you can be a person and not have a vote — people under 18 don’t, prisoners convicted of serious offences don’t (and that could soon include all prisoners). There are more, but I won’t go on — the point is that “one person, one vote” is symbolic, not literal.

But neither are Sharples’ objections literal, they are symbolic. In the non-literal sense, what “one person, one vote” means is the opportunity for equality of input into the electoral process — whether that be by one or two votes, in a big electorate or a small one. What happens after that is democracy in action. In this regard, an electoral system which pays at least some regard to the principle of “one person, one vote” is a minimal bound for a modern democracy (though there are others also). Sharples’ criticism is that this isn’t enough — that democracy should be about equality of outcome rather than input. I agree — and I think very many other people do as well. Making democracy work takes much more than votes. But when it’s framed in the way he has framed it, this sort of discussion is political poison, because it attacks the heart of our political culture. This “race-based” framing of mana whenua political representation has been expressly developed in order to make those things seem indefensible in a liberal democratic context. Sharples has swallowed the hook, and instead of continuing to defend the Māori Seats and mana whenua representation on the existing and well-proven grounds (that it’s necessary for the establishment and maintenance of tino rangatiratanga, guaranteed by the Treaty) he has made a declaration which amounts to “yeah, they’re anti-democratic: so?” The most ridiculous aspect of it is that the existing mechanism which is so reviled complies with the principle of “one person, one vote”: electors on the Māori roll get get the same vote as anyone else, the only difference is in how they cast it. There is equality of input to the democratic process by Māori at the electoral level — it’s elsewhere in the process which is the problem.

I’ve argued before that the core symbolic and philosophical stuff of modern democracy is liberalism of one brand or another. No mainstream political concern can hope to win a democratic mandate without founding a lot of its agenda in liberalism. The symbolism of “one person, one vote” is crucial to this orthodoxy. Charles Elder and Roger Cobb, in The Political Uses of Symbols presented a typology of political symbols in the American context, organised into “political community” symbols which express political values at the highest level (“America”, “The Flag”, “The Constitution”); through “regime” symbols which express the political values of the current orthodoxy (in this case, American democracy, not a specific administration — the examples given are “The Presidency”, “Congress”, and “One Person, One Vote”); and three classes of “situational” symbols which express particular policy or administrational preferences of lesser affect (“The Reagan Administration; “gun control”, etc.) The higher up Elder and Cobb’s typology you go, the greater the degree of political consensus on the values imbued in a particular symbol. Nobody in American politics gets anywhere if they stand against “America”: the task of politics in that context is to convince people that what you stand for is “America”. “One person, one vote” is pretty high up that symbolic ladder. It is an illusion, but it’s a sacred illusion.

Every party in New Zealand’s parliament at present, except one, lays claim to this broad liberal tradition in one way or another. That one party which does not is the māori party. That is not to say that their agenda isn’t broadly liberal in function, but that it’s largely that way for non-Western-liberal philosophic reasons. This is the māori party’s great electoral purpose: to normalise an indigenous political-philosophical tradition. But they can’t do so this way, by attacking the liberal orthodoxy’s sacred illusions, the bedrock values held even by those who would never dream of calling themselves liberals. The māori party, more than any other, must recognise the value of “one person, one vote” as part of the history of democracy working for downtrodden minorities rather than against them, and adopt this as part of its own political basis.

As libertarians have discovered, if you don’t really believe in democracy it’s best not to bother with it — then you get to maintain whatever you claim as high moral ground and leave the actual business of governing to those who lack your unshakeable principles. But that’s not what the māori party is about. They do believe in democracy; they do recognise the importance of engagement and compromise and consensus, and they do plenty of work toward it, and a misguided outburst like this one puts it all in jeopardy. “Race-based” is National’s catch-cry from just a few short years ago, and they will take any encouragement given them to reach out to New Zealand’s conservatives, who are already distrustful of the māori party. It will force Labour further down the path of attacking the māori party to try to recapture the centre ground, rather than encouraging cooperation and the mending of fences. Most critically, it could create a backlash against the very mechanism Sharples seeks to save, generating opposition to the Māori seats his party needs for its survival, and which exist only by the pleasure of the Pākehā majority whose sacred illusions he has slighted.

While it should have been underway already, the māori party must now redouble its efforts to appeal to voters outside the Māori electorates, and prepare to live in a world without them.

L

12 Responses to “Sacred illusions”

  1. StephenR on March 22nd, 2010 at 11:52

    That first link is broken.

  2. Lew on March 22nd, 2010 at 12:01

    SR, ta — fixed.

    L

  3. Stuart Mackey on March 22nd, 2010 at 19:18

    After years of fighting for the voices of mana whenua to be heard in democratic politics on strong principled grounds, Sharples seems now to have accepted the extreme right’s framing of that representation as antithetical to democracy.

    Extreme right? So whats the extreme lefts view , one person, no vote? If thats your view of peacefully removing an unpopular government, give me a funny mustache and call me Adolf.
    I would contend that the vast bulk of the public rather like the idea of one person one vote (or is it one vote used as two?)

  4. Lew on March 22nd, 2010 at 20:03

    Stuart, read it again — the post is in support of the principle behind “one person, one vote”, taking cognisance of the fact that the electoral system we have is no such thing in actual implementation.

    My reference to the ‘extreme right’ is with regard to the framing of the Māori electoral seats (and mana whenua representation in general) as antithetical to democracy, and abridging that principle. It doesn’t in theory and hasn’t in fact — but after years of hearing that it does, Sharples seems to have internalised it.

    And I’m at a loss to see where you get the reference to removing an unpopular government from. There’s nothing in here about the Clark government, and I think you’d struggle to make a case that they were removed for being too cozy with the natives.

    L

  5. Stuart Mackey on March 22nd, 2010 at 20:15

    Stuart, read it again — the post is in support of the principle behind “one person, one vote”, taking cognisance of the fact that the electoral system we have is no such thing in actual implementation.

    I think it can be read both ways, looks like the hedging of bets all round.

    My reference to the ‘extreme right’ is with regard to the framing of the Māori electoral seats (and mana whenua representation in general) as antithetical to democracy, and abridging that principle. It doesn’t in theory and hasn’t in fact — but after years of hearing that it does, Sharples seems to have internalised it.

    I think the Maori seats do violate the democratic principle if not in fact and defiantly in the principle
    of the colloquial modern meaning of democracy.

    And I’m at a loss to see where you get the reference to removing an unpopular government from. There’s nothing in here about the Clark government, and I think you’d struggle to make a case that they were removed for being too cozy with the natives.

    I did not mention Clark at all, I don’t know where you got that from. Elections, properly run, are a peaceful way of removing unpopular governments, I would have thought that was self evident.

  6. Lew on March 22nd, 2010 at 20:34

    Stuart, because I address the idea that “one person, one vote” is an actual factual reality, there’s no cause to think I’m somehow opposed to the principle of equal electoral input which underlies it.

    Māori electoral representation would violate the principle if the seats conferred some meaningful additional representation to each vote — but it remains one (or in our case two) vote per person, with those elected by this means having no greater or lesser powers than any other elected representative. As it stands, the disparity in electorate size and population is the main distortive factor, and that’s one which exists in the general seats also.

    I apologise for the assumption regarding Clark. A little too much reading-in on both our parts, I fear. I completely agree that democracy’s great advantage over other systems is the ability to chuck out a government without resorting to violence. I still haven’t the faintest idea how you might think otherwise from my post — especially given that it’s a virtue I’ve written about many times here and elsewhere.

    L

  7. Stuart Mackey on March 22nd, 2010 at 20:58

    Stuart, because I address the idea that “one person, one vote” is an actual factual reality, there’s no cause to think I’m somehow opposed to the principle of equal electoral input which underlies it.

    As you say perhaps too much reading in perhaps.

    Māori electoral representation would violate the principle if the seats conferred some meaningful additional representation to each vote — but it remains one (or in our case two) vote per person, with those elected by this means having no greater or lesser powers than any other elected representative. As it stands, the disparity in electorate size and population is the main distortive factor, and that’s one which exists in the general seats also.

    I don’t think that that is in any way right, morally or with respect to actual power.
    It is wrong morally because a person is in parliament on the basis of their ethnicity/culture, not upon the free debate of all New Zealanders on the merits of their argument.
    It is also wrong on the basis of actual power, be that by by the holding of office or by influence upon the formation of government and the inevitable tradoff’s that occur under the MMP electoral system.

    When we allow race to determine the nature of representation or the makeup of governemtents we, by definition, move away from the modern definitions of democracy.

  8. Ag on March 22nd, 2010 at 21:08

    We need to brush away all the overgrowth and look at the very simple distinction that underlies Sharples’ position. Anything else is just window dressing.

    But neither are Sharples’ objections literal, they are symbolic. In the non-literal sense, what “one person, one vote” means is the opportunity for equality of input into the electoral process — whether that be by one or two votes, in a big electorate or a small one. What happens after that is democracy in action. In this regard, an electoral system which pays at least some regard to the principle of “one person, one vote” is a minimal bound for a modern democracy (though there are others also).

    We should be clear that this is only a requirement for a deontological justification for democracy. In other words, the Kantian principle that all persons are to be treated as ends in themselves can only be satisfied by a political system based on “universal” consent (and not merely hypothetical consent, but real consent).

    I think everyone who supports democracy holds this as a core value, and this, as Lew said, is what makes democracy essentially liberal at its core. Let’s call it Principle (A).

    Now the other side.

    Sharples’ criticism is that this isn’t enough — that democracy should be about equality of outcome rather than input. I agree — and I think very many other people do as well. Making democracy work takes much more than votes.

    This is the consequentialist justification for democracy. The favoured consequences don’t have to be egalitarian, they could be maxmin or something else, but that doesn’t really matter. Let’s call a generic version of this Principle (B).

    The core of the problem as I see it is that it is an article of faith that (1), (A) and (B) are compatible, and moreover, (2) that enforcing (A) is the only reliable method of promoting (B). If we were honest about it, we would admit that both are articles of faith. Sharples appears to be attacking (2), and I would be more inclined to attack (1).

    My problem with responses to Sharples is that all they don’t address the possibility that underlies both (1) and (2), which is that the deontological conception of democracy (A) may fail to promote (B). All we get are faith based assertions that it will.

    But this is to ignore the broad social trends of the last 40 years. Our country has steadily increased its commitment to (A) in many areas by a general “democratizing” of institutions (school boards, MMP, etc.). However, the outcomes of these institutions have become less egalitarian and even less maximining (this is simply a fact, and is generally accepted by those who don’t have a specific axe to grind).

    The broad trend appears to count against the popular connection between (A) and (B). It appears that you can have a democracy that maximally promotes consent and equality in the process, or you can have one that maximally promotes a favoured outcome such as equality or maximin. It appears that you cannot have both.

    Sharples is probably right.

  9. Lew on March 23rd, 2010 at 10:29

    Stuart, what I’m saying it that while there’s an argument to be made that having the Māori seats is a bad thing in general, it doesn’t break the “one person, one vote” principle because the Māori seats’ electors still get the same vote as anyone else. That’s the framing which is false — that the Māori seats are inequal or additional to the general seats — when in fact they’re just the same, only in parallel. This is an artifact of history, and was implemented in order to prevent Māori from taking command of the colony, not to provide them some additional advantage.

    Ag, thanks for an excellent summation. Sharples might well be right — but it’s irrelevant whether or not he is, because the only outcome from his holding or expressing the position is to hasten his political failure. In essence, he works against his own agenda of steady, gradual progress and compromise within an imperfect system by criticising the fundamental symbolic laws of that system.

    In addition, I return to my common argument that where there’s a stark choice between discrete outcomes and the integrity of the systems which produce those outcomes, the systems must win. But this isn’t such a stark choice — it’s a matter of emphasis. Sharples needs to hold his nerve and keep working within — and being seen to believe in — the system which is serving him pretty well, because the alternative systems are far worse.

    L

  10. Ag on March 24th, 2010 at 20:07

    Ag, thanks for an excellent summation. Sharples might well be right — but it’s irrelevant whether or not he is, because the only outcome from his holding or expressing the position is to hasten his political failure. In essence, he works against his own agenda of steady, gradual progress and compromise within an imperfect system by criticising the fundamental symbolic laws of that system.

    Perhaps he conceives of non-democratic means of moving his political agenda forward. There are various options open to him.

    More to the point, if society refuses to answer Sharples’ criticism, then what legitimacy does democracy have other than the power of compulsion?

    In addition, I return to my common argument that where there’s a stark choice between discrete outcomes and the integrity of the systems which produce those outcomes, the systems must win. But this isn’t such a stark choice — it’s a matter of emphasis. Sharples needs to hold his nerve and keep working within — and being seen to believe in — the system which is serving him pretty well, because the alternative systems are far worse.

    I think that cannot work. Compromise isn’t really possible since they are pulling in opposite directions and preserving the integrity of the democratic system is not a realistic option (it would be nice if it were, but it should be patently obvious that this is untrue after the events of the last decade or so). What the voting public want doesn’t really matter, since they want what they cannot have.

    For me, Democrats don’t really have anything interesting to say these days. All they do is repeat the same old slogans. It’s nice to see a politician prepared to think in public for a change.

  11. Tom Semmens on March 25th, 2010 at 09:32

    I’ve always supported the Maori seats, on the basis of the treaty and because Maori got such a raw deal from the whole colonisation process that they needed a voice in parliament to be sure they would be heard. Lets face it – without the Maori seats, Maori would have roughly the same visibility and political power as the Pasifika community – i.e. not much at all! The PI community is basically an invisible, semi-third world underclass largely confined to certain near ghettoes. Our white, middle class corporate media treats reports from this twilight third world as if the events they are reporting on are occurring in another country we seldom hear from, which probably an accurate reflection on how much these people impinge on the conciousness of Pakeha New Zealand.

    Nowadays though I am questioning the relevance of the Maori seats. The willing capitulation of Maori Party to the reactionary corporate iwi elite means the Maori seats are no longer fufilling any meaningful role in representating a disadvantaged indigenous minority. The thriving Maori cultural renaissance means they are no longer required to protect and nurture a fragile and endangered culture.

    Maybe it is time to consider instead allocating some of the Maori seats instead to the Pasifika community, to raise their profile and let them push for significant economic change for their people? As long as equality of representation is maintained I don’t have a problem with that in the medium term.

    As for Sharples – I’ve never rated him. I’ve always thought him politically as an emotive, easily manipulated fool who tends to agree with whoever he last spoke to. When his foolishness is exposed he retreats to an unattractive bluster and a default grievance mode. He may have been a good and useful activist and academic, but as a politician he is an utter, ineffective, failure. His unhelpful comments on the “one man, one vote” thing are typical of his failure as a politician.

  12. […] that the initial purpose of the māori party wasn’t to effect sweeping policy change, but to create cultural and political space for kaupapa Māori politics, and to establish the credibility of same. For all their policy […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: