buy viagraa discreeetly viagras prix lerk jet sildenafil yahoo real estate can we get viagra pills in hyderabad where can i buy zithromax powder in brooklyn prednisolone liquid inactive ingredients in crest dosages for cialis generic zovirax pills doxycycline ulcerative colitis mail order real viagra from vipps zithromax 500 mg azithromycin side sorel boots buy online uk viagra buy cialis at walmart weaning off 25 mg zoloft desowen cream generico do viagra repeated use of doxycycline 77canadianpharmacy com buy zoloft cialis 5 mg x 14 viagra generico bonifico cipro pregnancy safety car get pregnant first course of clomid 0 5 mg di finasteride 5 zovirax patches ireland sildenafil se puede comprar sin receta medica can i get viagra over the counter in australia herbal viagra buy in sri lanka white and blue generic cialis address for viagra in lahore pakistan accutane two pills a day best price for cialis 25 mg can i buy a generic viagra in london viagra online with american express sildenafil vega extra 130 mg is how many ml generic cialis from india orange round prednisone steroid sale 5mg tab vs. 1 mg propecia tatanol 150 mg zoloft cytotec seller in qatar loxapac 25 mg of zoloft stopping zoloft at 50 mg generic 2.5 cialis propranolol in first trimester examples of writing prednisone prescriptions deutschland online apotheke cialis for daily use clomid ovulation kit can lasix and bumex be given together how to treat accutane hair loss does 5mg of cialis last as long as 20 mg what is the best dosage for zoloft pediatric dosage amoxil medexpress viagra reviews can you take viagra with amoxicillin donde puedo comprar cytotec en cartagena soft generic viagra sales ampicillin for gbs uti in early pregnancy nausea and accutane viagra for women available in ahmedabad buy zovirax generic online how soon does cialis take effect zovirax purchase on line take diflucan two days in a row cipro 5oo mg cytotec online from canada what happens when mixed viagra in someones drink cipro low cost voli zoloft for extreme social anxiety disorder buying generic doxycycline without a prescription round blue generic viagra paediatric dose of amoxil glottal 500 mg metformin viagra phizer buy cost viagra nigeria donde comprar viagra en andorra clomid 50 mg men 5 mg prednisone pregnancy side buying viagra online safely clomid uses and dosage metformin 500 mg b12 canada order prednisone csnsda can i take viagra with verapamil liquid doxycycline allergic reaction the price of propecia get viagra in edmonton quando il cialis generico viagra luxemburg rezeptfrei price of cialis per pill in us splitting 50 mg zoloft zovirax ointment cheap diflucan 150 mg e gravidanza paypal viagra spanien beta blocker propranolol reviews anxiety buy ciplai cialis ampicillin 500 mg instructions can i buy real cialis online clomid and ovidrel costs generic daily cialis 2.5mg zithromax azithromycin 1.0 gm 4 x 250 mg a single dose 5mg cialis not working clomid 50 mg tablet price in india is prednisone 10 mg safe for liver patient how to get hard with viagra cialis generico 20 mgrs. viagra generic any good registrazione utente generico de cialis best diet on zoloft when is a generic for viagra coming out how to buy viagra at singapore cialis lilly uk cheapest price for accutane dosage for sildenafil citrate do walmart sell clomid cialis reviews for older men how much rand does viagra cost in joburg s.a sildenafil otc products where to go to buy viagra in singapore sildenafil citrate tablets delgra 50 digoxin and lasix how can i buy cytotec is viagra available in swiss tadalafil cost europa orange colored tadalafil tadalafil sublingual 20 mg is it legal to buy viagra online from australia offbrand viagra reviews buy generic viagra in hyderabad blue zeus viagra review is ciprofloxacin safe to take while breastfeeding tamil doctor in viagra metformin uk pharmacy chains propecia warning label buying viagra frankfurt average cost melphalan and prednisone sildenafil in heart is it dangerous to take more than 20 mg cialis at once how much does viagra cost at walmart ca take 2 cialis 5mg ofirmev generic viagra can one take 2 cialis in 24 hours can i take viagra into the us es muy peligroso usar cytotec fake and real cialis cialis buy online in australia indian brands tadalafil and depoxitine viagra liquidian cipro 500 mg tab bayer ndc number viagra pills in delhi with price dapoxetine price in pakistan of lg sildenafil eciwlcodkedefe for sale cialis 20mg south africa how much does it cost cialis generico comprar en sevilla comprar cytotec en chihuahua doxycycline hyclate 100 mg efectos secundarios metformin upset stomach can you buy zithromax high doses of lasix qual o generico do clomid is cialis safe to take with hepatitis c viagra uk multiple orgasm male lasix para q se usa ovulate twice in one cycle clomid pregnancy how do i know if he has taken viagra indications for metformin zoloft 50 mg insomnia propranolol er for anxiety clomid 50mg success rate buying generic viagra online legal viagra order it cialis tables 20mgs how much to buy viagra free nhs prescription can a doctor refuse to prescribe viagra australia viagra buy from bangladesh diflucan 50 mg posologie definition viagra type drugs in india half inderal for anxiety propranolol 160 mg tablets propranolol for hemangioma in adults pharmacokinetic of tadalafil 20 mg tablet price of doxycycline malaria tablets pentasa generic alternatives for viagra can you buy viagra from canada dapoxetine 60 tablet name in mumbai cialis daily dosage metformin 250 mg day how far in advance should i take a viagra pill prednisone 20 mg indicaciones de afumix i want buy doxycycline in durban cialis delivery peru prednisone out of system use of zoloft in elderly can clomid cause period pain i want to buy viagra from rayh healthcare india alchemist viagra cialis original 40 mg ciprofloxacina in inglese fenprocoumon 3 mg bijwerkingen cialis tadalafil use in bphc metformin best time to take it is it safe to order viagra from canada on line uk generic zovirax pills sirve igual el generico de cytotec amoxil bd 400 mg 5ml buy viagra on line at tesco siti sicuri dove comprare cialis zithromax 250 mg dosage chlamydia symptoms se puede comprar viagra sin receta en francia experiencias usando cytotec zithromax london viagra india quora login breaking 100mg viagra half in de morning zovirax 800 mg spcc cialis generic 2.5 ciprofloxacin genericon 500 how much does viagra cost in the united states cipro hc ear drops sale generic viagra good brand name where to buy cialis in london cialis 5mg preis clomid 200 mg twins buy in person viagra melbourne cheapest india amoxil 500 purchase viagra in us cipro for india travel does cialis build up in system over time to work price of viagra in domincan repubic can you get high from zoloft 100 mg how long does a 100 mg viagra last for diclofenac 150 mg dosierung viagra skoda vrs for sale in uk zithromax low priced propecia free price viagra viagradrugs net how long does antabuse stay in your system cost for cialis canada is buying doxycycline online safe sildenafil citrate in pphn bekomme ich cialis in luxemburg amoxil dose for ear infection best serm clomid busik online viagra cialis 5mg daily loading dose 20 mg msds finasteride tablets usp 5 mg prednisolone acetate cost doxycycline many mg acne asphalt shingle price increases for viagra uk sales of viagra hatena 25 mg zoloft are metformin and actos in the same family ampicillin concentration liquid culture charleston comprar cialis generico 10mg valium doxycycline 100 mg tablet wsw what is the street value of a 50 mg viagra cialis 2 5 mg cpr 28 prix carburant que contiene la viagra ciprofloxacin buy prednisone and lasix is it safe to take nifedipine together with amoxil 1 tolindol 150 mg viagra diflucan tablete 50 mg nipple thrush aprovel 150 mg generico de cialis order finasteride rowcmoadreders buy cialis in singapore and address propecia generic effectiveness cheap viagra no prescription needed average price per pill of viagra cuanto vale el viagra en mexico where i can find viagra in japan is it safe to take ambien while on prednisone cialis daily new zealand ist viagra in italien rezeptpflichtig can i buy clomid from jhb pharmacy propecia get uk can i use viagra more than once a day priligy reviews name viagra tablet india will ampicillin treat a bladder infection zithromax mims thailand online arthrotec 75 mg pfizer viagra amoban 10 mg prednisone cheap viagra from canadian pharmacy buying viagra with pay pal doxycycline 50 mg acne effectiveness is viagra safe to use for a 18 year old lower dose of viagra best moisturizer to use on accutane can you take viagra if you take amlodipine tadalafil otc in florida generico de viagra en venezuela medida viagra female uk oraxim 500 mg metformin samsca 15 mg fiyati viagra ciprodex generic name cosco pharmacy price cialis can buy cipro over counter viagra cost decrease is viagra safe with depresion medication ladies viagra tablets name how long does viagra take to work in a 35year old male buy online generic propecia finpecia fincar com can ciprofloxacin 500 mg cure clap pfizer viagra purchase clomid uk pharmacy medicines nolvadex and arimidex together costo del viagra generico in farmacia guadalajara where to buy viagra over the counter in seattle buy viagra aberdeen scotland prolonged use of propecia tadalafil not working prednisone long safe take buy dapoxetine in pakistan hyderabad cheap cialis prices australia sildenafil home delivery in india diflucan price philippines nokia prednisone 10 mg 6 day directions for gout cheap generic viagra oscimin generic cialis prices in rupee of indian viagra diflucan 150 mg 1 dose of dmt que es misotrol cytotec online finasteride recommended dosage for hair loss abnormal menses accutane reviews zovirax cream glaxosmithkline philippines price costo de la pastilla cytotec lasix 40 mg dosierung tadalafil other brand name nolvadex pct dosage where to get cytotec pills in malaysia cialis 5 mg double obat diflucan 150 mg tablet viagra 50 mg keine wirkung buy 200 mg sildenafil cost of ciprofloxacin ear drops without insurance cheap viagra .99 cialis daily vs one time can you trust buying viagra online is cipro toxicity real roche glucophage no rx how to take prednisone for asthma prednisone 5 mg 12 day dose pack directions yahoo lasix 70 mg geriflox caps 500 mg metformin classification of glucophage is doxycycline safe for nursing mother is it ok to take viagra once comprare cialis opinioni inderal night sweats amoxil 500 is used for accutane buy online australia visa la spezia cap generico do viagra si joint specialist in chicago illinois propecia cost in nz i want to buy diamond viagra zithromax baownbeuv price nolvadex 20 mg astrazeneca teva canada viagra generic reviews of antabuse generic viagra canada legal pot what is the best way to buy viagra sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg buy silver medsafe data sheet metformin dosage health canada metformin socialism in bible glucophage in renal failure buy viagra brazil ciprofloxacin in pregnancy medscape zoloft and aricept cheap online pill viagra viagradrugs net how much does one pill of viagra cost with no insurance buy pfizer viagra online usa comprar pastillas cytotec en medellin scrub typhus treatment doxycycline nolvadex tamoxifen b p 10 mg how can i get some viagra i accidently took 2 25 mg cialis polls priligy originale online where to buy cialis online in germany dose of prednisone in sarcoidosis over the counter vitamins better than viagra doxycycline hereisthebestin online no period when do i take clomid how long for amoxil to take effect does viagra maintain an erection after ejaculation compra priligy online viagra sales in nigeria conflict accutane australia can metformin be used in chronic kidney disease finasteride trade name viagra and plants phenergan walmart otc viagra can you take more than 20 mgs of cialis riomet generic cialis zithromax suspension price walmart cipro hexal 500 mg und alkoholi pastillas cytotec costovertebral tenderness denavir vs zovirax vs abreva reviews clomid use in women who ovulate lasix water pill dosages how long can you take cialis is cialis safe in hep c 2g amoxil sachet australia bula do selozok 50 mg zoloft how much viagra can i bring into australia will taking 40 mg cialis work better indian cipro doxycycline cause gerd wal mart cialis price 5mg sildenafil package insert lasix without a prescription overnight delivery viagra other names viagra sold in mexico purchase cialis canada cialis bph study generic propecia from india propranolol 20 mg in morning withdrawal prednisone 5 days 10 ml toddler amoxil 500 mg glaxosmithkline bridges zovirax ointment for sale propecia si trova in farmacia india brand viagra cialis generika preiswert hixizine generico do viagra propecia generic walmart sleep buyingcialis for womenuk cost of cialis in manila dapoxetine available in pakistan lahore purchase dapoxetine hereisthebestin finasteride 1 mg safe faer pharmaceuticals cialis over the counter safe take klonopin zoloft cialis 5 mg 28 composite how much cialis 10 mg cost finasteride reviews for hair womens viagra wholesale suppliers canada viagra 50 mg in half doxycycline antibiotics uk fitness metamorfoza cialis cost is 100 mg too much prednisone for hives cialis pill wholesale enantone lp 11 25 mg of zoloft doxycycline and prednisone taken together pirbuterol generic viagra viagra sale online india low cost viagra free shipping cialis while trying to get pregnant what happens if you take 2 viagra in less than 24 hours do not take clomid is 1000 mg zithromax safe generico de cialis en farmacias similares matamoros order generic zithromax cialis how long before it kicks in sildenafil sale cipa propranolol hcl cap 60 mg cr viagra for men in which use it is came lowest price candian viagra how long does it take clomid to raise testosterone pill identifier lasix 40 mg why does clomid cause miscarriage mercedes benz c55 amg for sale in uk zithromax dosteril 10 mg prednisone cytotec monterrey costo can buy viagra duane reade how much is generic finasteride in the us finasteride 1 mg tablets inderal 40 india cialis lily buy how long is diflucan in body viagra in thailand rezeptfrei viagra off counter from walmart diflucan over the counter philippines airlines doxycycline treatment chronic fatigue syndrome prednisolone 20 mg effet secondaire vit propranolol 10 mg nhsp cialis generic cialis cost zovirax 750 mg musaril tetrazepam dosierung ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin 500 mg administrare finasteride dosage transsexual buy diflucan inj cost viagra super active plus 24 hour delivery original viagra price in pakistan cialis 5 mg brand name for sale prednisone 10 mg cost can clomid cause hypothyroidism mepartricina generico de cialis is it ok to take accutane at night drinking in clomid propecia the crack ho ciprofloxacin meaning in urdu 5 mg propranolol for heart how to order cialis online inderal 10 mg erfahrungen how much does a month does cialis cost cialis 5mg price in ksa farmacia online italia cialis dose where can i buy viagra in delhi miglior cialis generico prednisone 5 mg taper instructions drugbank metformin er can i take propranolol and metoprolol in a day promius pharma accutane cost cialis cost me cada cuanto tiempo se puede usar viagra ciproxin 500 mg e cistite Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Impunity, freedom and student body politics

Impunity, freedom and student body politics

datePosted on 14:21, March 20th, 2010 by Lew

fat_boy_slim_-_youve_come_aJust before the end of the university term last year, Peter McCaffrey and ACT On Campus gave the Victoria University of Wellington Student Association an object lesson in how democracy works. They successfully passed a resolution that VUWSA make a select committee submission in support of Roger Douglas’ Education (Freedom of Association) Amendment Bill (making student association voluntary) despite various machinations employed by the VUWSA members and officeholders there. These events were well documented in text by Jenna Raeburn and in video with a ridiculously triumphal soundtrack (irony noted by felix).

The fundamental problem of non-democratic (and poor-quality democratic) political systems is that they shelter those in power from the consequences of their actions. Authoritarianism (and authoritarian communism in particular) is deleterious not so much due to the economic failings of the system (such as the economic calculation problem) as due to the fact that in such systems there exists no mechanism to force, require or even encourage the leadership to act in its peoples’ interest. I’ve written a lot about the power transfer problem of orthodox Marxist pragma, and this is an aspect of it. When the leadership is invested with the monopoly power and authority to suppress a counter-revolution, how do you ever get them to relinquish it?

The effect of impunity is similarly evident in other fields; particularly in commerce, where the customary opposition of the terms “freedom” and “regulation” are little more than straw soldiers in a propaganda battle. Peter Drahos and John Braithwaite have written at length about the extent to which so-called free trade mechanisms such as TRIPS are instruments of international coercion more than they are of international trade, and how almost the entire intellectual property system of the modern world has been so thoroughly captured by existing rightsholders that it now functions as a form of privatised regulation by asserting near-impassable barriers to entry into the information marketplace. This suppresses competition, promotes the establishment and maintenance of cartels between existing participants, and all this breeds impunity, where participants have no (or few) reasons to develop their products and services to suit their users’ needs, and so they develop them to suit their own needs. The results are everywhere; for instance, in the fact that people are compelled to purchase Microsoft software with most new computers although they might hate and despise it, or simply not need it; or in the fact that those same users, having reluctantly purchased Windows since there are no easily-accessible alternatives (those having been shut out of the market years ago by patent thickets, bundling, cross-licensing, and so on) are then locked into using proprietary media formats, players, content distribution and communication systems with (in some cases well-known) surveillance functions and which are designed to restrict a users’ rights to their own hardware, content and communication, so that the system — and users’ participation in it — works in the provider’s interest, rather than the interests of its users.

That example is just one with which I’m familiar. Much more socially and economically important examples exist; particularly around medical development and crop research. But the point is that this whole system, billed as being about “freedom”, does not mean freedom for users so much as rightholders’ freedom from the need to cater to their users without fear of someone else eating their lunch.

Returning to student body politics. When a student union compels fees from its students, and when students who disagree with the union’s agenda are unable to withdraw their support, what incentive is there for the union to represent the interests of the student body? The political consequence of that system is a student body politic so complacent due to impunity in charge of millions of dollars a year in revenue that it literally cannot organise a SRC vote to save itself.

I am no great supporter of VSM; I view the threadbare rhetoric of “freedom” employed by Douglas, McCaffrey and so on with a jaundiced eye. I don’t believe people should simply be able to “opt out” of their society if they don’t like it, and I accept that the loss of revenue which will result from the (almost certain) passage of Douglas’ bill will place much of the genuinely good work student unions do in jeopardy. But the integrity of political systems is more important than discrete policy outcomes, and to be perfectly frank VUWSA, for its rank incompetence and duplicity in the face of legitimate challenge, deserves to be humiliated in this way.

I hope that the lesson about how democracy works will be well understood — that is: unless people make it work, it doesn’t. CSM as currently implemented promotes apathy and idiocy in student body politics, to a greater extent than it would exist in any case. That is bad for student body politics, and it’s bad for students. It depresses the quality of candidates and policy, and reduces the system to a comic farce which many students are justifiably ashamed of (if they care about it at all). Much better, for me, would be the the genuine politicisation of student politics, with groups organising and campaigning on their positions, winning a mandate and executing it, as in national and local body politics. If ACT on Campus want to campaign on “letting you keep more of your money”, let them do so, and good luck to them. (Of course, they have been, and it hasn’t been working out for them, so the parent party has resorted to regulation in the name of freedom. Plus ça change.)

So in my view the current threats to compulsory student unionism is largely the fault of the student unionists and their sense of entitlement to membership dues without the need to prove the value of their work to those who pay for it. The Douglas bill, while it will likely prove deleterious to the good work student unions do, may have a silver lining in that it will enforce greater discipline and competence upon student politicians, and require them to prove to their constituents that the work they do is actually valuable in order to win a mandate. If the work they do is genuinely valuable, as they say it is, such a mandate should be winnable. May they go forth and win it.

L

Postscript: Go and submit!
Select committee submissions on the bill close on 31 March 2010. Whatever your views, make them known. As I’ve said, I think it’s likely to pass (bloc support from ACT, National and UF), but that shouldn’t prevent you from making your views known. Incidentally, I approve of the relatively impartial editorial line taken by Salient, the VUWSA magazine. Especially given that this august [sic] organ depends on CSM for much of its funding, this is a bold and principled decision. Well done Sarah Robson.

13 Responses to “Impunity, freedom and student body politics”

  1. Ag on March 21st, 2010 at 02:09

    So in my view the current threats to compulsory student unionism is largely the fault of the student unionists and their sense of entitlement to membership dues without the need to prove the value of their work to those who pay for it.

    This is a mistake, Lew. I am pretty familiar with the VSM movement at Waikato, which ended with a student union that might as well have been abolished. Voluntary unionism doesn’t really work, and it didn’t work at Waikato. As I recall, it made life very difficult for the various non-political student clubs on campus. Student politics was a joke, but it was really a sideshow compared to the more important civic functions the union facilitated on campus.

    Eventually, the students voted to more or less return it to compulsory membership (dissenters can have the fee donated to charity IIRC). The experiment ended up costing a fortune, and among other things the union lost its radio station. More to the point, the pro VSM movement was lavishly funded by outsiders.

    The VSM folks didn’t want to make student politics right wing. They knew that they couldn’t, so they wanted to destroy it. That might not have been a bad thing, except for the collateral damage, which they didn’t give a hoot about.

  2. Lew on March 21st, 2010 at 08:32

    Ag, I recognise the harm it’ll do to the services and activities student union dues fund, many of which are much more important than clubs and suchlike. I also agree with your analysis of the politics — that ACT, realising they can’t win on the hustings, are trying to win by legislative fiat. I don’t support that, but I do support the exposure and humiliation of VUWSA for their sins (bearing in mind that Douglas’ bill is probably passing with or without VUWSA’s select committee submission in support).

    But my argument is that if student politics wasn’t such a sideshow, and wasn’t run by self-promoters who thrive on the fact that they get to dispose of millions in guaranteed revenue each year with few or no genuine checks on their behaviour, it might not be the subject of such scorn. If student body politics was done right, Roger Douglas wouldn’t be able to pass his VSM law, because he’d fail to get support from mainstream parties who can’t afford to alienate those at university who do benefit from union services — and those who recall their days at university, or with kids there.

    L

  3. dave on March 22nd, 2010 at 11:18

    I don’t think that to “expose and humiliate VUWSA for their sins” should be done by legislative fiat. Some student associations are open, accountable and frugal. They don’t have a sense of entitlement, but feel the need to prove the value of their work not only to those who pay for it, but the wider public as well. You may feel that VUWSA needs to be humiliated, but why should other associations and students also bear the brunt?

  4. Lew on March 22nd, 2010 at 11:20

    That wasn’t done by legislative fiat, Dave. It was done by ACT On Campus schooling them in how to pass a resolution at a meeting. The Douglas bill had already been drawn and passed its first reading by that time.

    L

  5. dave on March 22nd, 2010 at 11:46

    Well Lew, Roger Douglas first brought up VUWSA discretions when we last spoke and he said his legislation would fix these indiscretions and expose them for what the are. That legislation was the legislative fiat I was referring to, not the Act on Campus exposure.

  6. Lew on March 22nd, 2010 at 12:01

    Right, I’ve already said I don’t support the VSM bill, and I’ve been critical of Douglas (and ACT’s) decision to legislate because they can’t compete at student politics. So we agree on that.

    L

  7. Michael on March 22nd, 2010 at 22:54

    I think apathy is the cause of the institutional rot in student politics, not the result. If there were a level of engagement with student politics, student politicians wouldn’t be able to get away with the things they do.

    The solution is not to trash the institutions, but rather to get students to care. And I think that’s a far, far bigger issue than any amount of student leadership on its own can manage.

    As it is, most students won’t notice a thing until services like food banks and free bread provided by students’ associations disappear, and then it will be too late because there will no longer be any organisations able to advocate for them.

    Student culture has suffered a lot since the 1980s. At Victoria University, for example, there was once a thriving drama club that staged all sorts of productions, and many of its members have gone on to big things in the NZ theatre scene. All that’s gone now, of course, and what remains will disappear with the passage of this bill.

    The influence of students’ associations on the cultural and intellectual life of universities, as well as the services they provide to students, are generally greatly underestimated, I think. The apathy that has created the corruption and incompetence of the students’ associations is exactly what ACT and its campus cohorts is using to destroy them.

  8. Michael on March 23rd, 2010 at 00:26

    re-reading my post it’s not particularly clear what I mean when I say student leadership itself isn’t enough to fix the problem. What I think is that there is such a level of apathy that the most heroic leadership risks not being noticed.

    Over the last 20-30 years there’s been a real levelling off of student engagement not only through students’ associations but in general. There’s nothing like the culture of activism and engagement of the 1960s or 1970s.

    I can’t point with any sort of rigour at any likely causes of this change, but I do have my pet theories and prejudices, which tell me that it might just be a symptom of a much wider political disengagement since around 1980, coincident or not coincident with the stranglehold of the New Right on public discourse since that time.

    The students’ associations are rotten to the core, corrupt, venal, and petty, often a cringeworthy spectacle of nauseating ego, and yet they still do good work. Something must be done, but it’s not clear to me at all that the destruction of what remains of student life in New Zealand is that something.

  9. Lew on March 23rd, 2010 at 10:13

    Michael, thanks for a thoughtful comment.

    Don’t you think there’s a feedback loop in play, though? I see apathy as both a cause and a consequence of student politicians who use the institutions as their own personal piss-taking and self-promotion platform — the clowning and unaccountability undermines the institution, students don’t take it seriously, and the pool of competent people to run the institution gets shallower. This leads to the sort of egregious idiocy on display in Peter McCaffrey’s SRC video, and ultimately results in stronger public tolerance for the idea of simply scrapping them altogether, expressed in Douglas’ bill being supported by a National party which until now has been careful not to scare too many of the horses.

    L

  10. What would Hayek say on March 24th, 2010 at 10:53

    hmm – Micheals comment about student activism in the 60s and 70s being more engaged than today made me do a quick history/society recheck.

    Some people (well normally the 60s and 70s generation particularly represented by the public address commentators) make the same comment. I wonder was the 60s and 70s really the high point or has the number of activists remanined the same but the pool of students has grown significantly larger (and more diverse) therefore student activism as sought by the 60s and 70s crowd no longer having the same influence.

    In essence todays student activists are actually our modern social conservatives (by harking to a mythic golden age of 60s an 70s NZ) rather than the liberal/activists they label themselves as. They are are just another group who have missed the mesofact (http://www.mesofacts.org/) changes that have gone in the wider world.

    I suspect this is correct because if we look at wider NZ society in the 60s and 70s you will see that the influence of student activists was out of proportion to the wider voter base (largely conservative NZ society – robs mob and all that).

    Sorry this is a bit disjointed – its a quick comment, but one from which I think can be linked to many broader issues/threads of debate at present. This being that for significant parts of the commentariat (whichever tribe you support) are basing there views/thinking from a specific point in time and have then held the facts they knew then as constant, rather than that some of those facts have changed over time and so should the debate.

    You could say this goes to the heart of current labour party problems (largely a 70s/80s economic/social policy mindset with some sections e.g. unions harking back to the 50s). Parts of national, act and the greens again having the same problem.

    A reason why John Key was more successful than the other lot was that he represented more of where present day society is at, whereas Ms Clark and co (an so so many other MPs of all types) did not.

  11. Michael on March 25th, 2010 at 00:11

    Sorry about the much-delayed reply, Lew!

    Anyway, I’ll accept that there is a feedback loop now, but I think if you’re looking for an ultimate cause it’s got to be declining interest. The corruption and incompetence is a symptom of a wider problem. Twenty or thirty years ago or more students’ associations were respected institutions, and becoming president was generally a sign that you’d go far in public life. Something’s changed in the meantime, and I don’t think you can put the blame for a shift in the culture on, well, the shift in the culture itself.

    Just as an aside, I think the kinds of changes we’d see with the passage of VSM *are* actually going to be very unpopular with students, and I’ve got some evidence for that. A couple of years ago, the very same lot of ACT On Campus people who put through the VSM motion at VUWSA put up a slate of candidates for the VUWSA elections. It was a very slick, well-publicised and well-put together campaign, and their policies would more or less have destroyed VUWSA as it is at the moment.

    They succeeded in generating an enormous amount of interest. The vote doubled from the previous year, and they were comprehensively defeated. Not one of their candidates even came close to being elected. It was the first time that a lot of people, and I include myself, even took an interest in student politics.

    If they’d kept trying, they might even have started to get student politicians to clean up their act. I don’t think they’d ever have actually won, but it does go to show that a credible – or at least vocal – opposition is essential to reproduce democratic institutions.

    But even having said all that, the general malaise in contemporary student life runs so deep that it’d be difficult even to match, let alone sustain, the level of engagement and activism there was in the 60s and 70s. I think that’s a genuinely sad thing, and that it is the real problem; everything else is just a symptom.

  12. Owen on March 27th, 2010 at 03:43

    My impression is both that students are from a wider pool (percentage of students in population 40 years ago vs now?), plus workloads are a lot bigger these days. I did the last 2 years of a 3-yr philosophy degree while working fulltime: I don’t think I was particularly bright or hard-working. Interesting to discuss whether the engagement with politics is a cyclical thing or just something that came out of demographic changes after WW2.

  13. Hugh on March 27th, 2010 at 16:32

    Actually Owen I’d say there are notably less mature students now than there were 10 years ago. When admissions were relaxed in the 90s to make it easier for mature people to go to University there was something of a flood. I would regularly be in tutorials where nearly one third of the class were mature students. Now it’s unusual to have more than one or two per tute.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: