viagra canada cheapest car eurospecialist usa viagra from canada 2 day delivery dapoxetine medicine in pakistan halal food corvasal generic cialis cialis in manila philippines finasteride 5mg filipino review metformin order online no prescription expert sildenafil 50 mg masticable en cialis price in pharmacies buy clomid research chemicals dove trovo il cialis generico walmart price.for.viagra cloridrato de prasugrel generico de cialis quaility propecia online safe pure to buy viagra online in australia zoloft 50 mg and aspirin viagra nederland bestellen buy viagra in melbourne vic can i take benadryl while taking doxycycline buy viagra with cashiers check nolvadex pct for sale sydney priligy dapoxetina acquisto occasione italia mastercard boom loader for sale in uk zithromax buy clenbuterol nolvadex online doxycycline in lupus viagra pills in india cost tab tadalafil 10mg prezzo del generico del viagra foundation to use with accutane buying viagra from a chemist indian sildenafil tablets for sale the best homemade replacement of viagra metformin 250 mg daily reciprocating gun carry states cialis to masterbate viagra price rise doxycycline hyclate used for bladder infection time day best take finasteride linezolid generico do viagra buy ciprofloxacin in mexico prednisone 10 mg for poison ivy how many to take a day free prescription viagra carry viagra in flight vibramycin 100 mg buy sildenafil 20 mg tablet can you buy over the counter viagra in vancouver canada cialis pharmacie en ligne canada buy azithromycin doxycycline viagra prices in france buy viagra san diego hiv specialists in dekalb county ga viagra for women put in drink online viagra ads do you take zoloft in morning or night acquistare viagra in parafarmacia morlan cost of viagra in dominican republic accutane in indonesia can i cut my 20 mg cialis in half effectiveness of liquid cialis can i take paracetamol with accutane can i take doxycycline and go in the sun es cialis help in premature ejaculation prednisone 1 mg pill description genericos do viagra comes viagra generico sms sildenafil using paypal where to buy propecia 0.5 mg in malaysia what would happen if a female takes viagra indian cipro tablets images viagra bestellen pillendienst legal purchase nolvadex if viagra comes in pfizer packaging is it real where can i buy cialis in toronto viagra spray available in india cialis generic china sildenafil canine dosage zoloft and binge eating disorder cialis generico es bueno cialis and bph metformin in third trimester pregnancy bula viagra generico in farmacia can doxycycline cause low blood sugar propecia generico prezzo vouchers cialis monthly cost walmart buy viagra online uk only suppliers metformin for weight loss in women viagra 100 mg 30 tablet fiyati clomid babycentre uk viagra uk over counter sildenafil generic expiration date viagra 50mg buying viagra for men in manchester where i can get viagra pill in philippines how can i buy 4 pills of zithromax coopman classification of corticosteroids prednisone sildenafil 50 mg tabletas masticables 1000 mg metformin for weight loss onlinedictionary datasegment com word doxycycline quanto costa cialis 20 mg farmacia what counteracts the prednisone induced dog panting legitamite place in oklahoma city to buy cialis propecia alternative 2013 which is the best viagra available in bangalore viagra tablets name for women in india zoloft 50 prix maroc zoloft treat anxiety disorder metformin in treating pcos s au scuturat toti trandafirii generic viagra what to watch for in generic cialis viagra cialis spam how to buy cialis online sinot 875 mg generico do viagra tadalafil generika deutschland germany would a 150 mg diflucan tablet cure oral thrush generic viagra priligy metformin taken with clomid viagra generico de la india cytotec in the united states not ovulation after miscarriage clomid online sildenafil generika rezeptfrei cheap indian viagra online generic cialis markings over the counter viagra chicago walmart viagra price 100mg breaking cialis tablets propecia for sale cheap diflucan 50 mg posologie amoxicilline beconase generic uk viagra can minors take viagra viagra online soft deos viagra come in syrup ampicillin drug study nursing crib review dove comprare viagra generico is 5 mg prednisone daily for pain too much for 8lb dog pfizer viagra 100mg test cozaar 50 mg generico do viagra ampicillin concentration in lb plates with kanamycin non prescription 40 mg lasix generic viagra works prescription dapoxetine uk boots cosmetics viagra by pfizer in lahore fluimucil pediatrico generico do viagra cost of viagra 25 mg cialis puede causar impotencia how many mg of viagra should a 280 man glucophage 500 mg pcos diet maximum recommended dosage viagra clomid como deve ser usado zoloft falling in love viagra pfizer europe viagra sale in toronto welche viagra kaufen where can i buy sildenafil 9 pm tablets excelentes resultados con finasteride cost priligy 30mg e 60 mg adderall cialis generic for daily use prednisone dose in kids donecil 10 mg prednisone sildenafil generico retirada translation does generic viagra work from canada cheapest generict viagra australia what is the maximum safe dose for viagra divalproex 500 mg tablet delayed release metformin ghb main ingredients in viagra cheap tadalafil whartisthebestin cialis 2 5 costo base ingredients in ciprofloxacin best time for taking finasteride buy zithromax canada pharmacy reviews on doxycycline for acne zovirax pommade prix maroc generico del viagra en colombia donde generic cialis price pro cytotec express en costa rica cheapest tadalafil .uk propecia cost year best site buy generic viagra viagra usa canada doxycycline dog india drug what happens if a 13 year old takes viagra acne scarring treatment after accutane tadalafil 20mg generic no prescription prednisone weight gain 5 mg buy nolvadex cheap from india what does the 20 mg tadalafil pill look like discount pill viagra viagra viagradrugs net generic finasteride 5mg reviews on windows can i get high off doxycycline hyclate finasteride 1 mg dosis buy viagra in australia review 15 mg prednisone olexar 10 mg prednisone ventajas y desventajas de usar sildenafil donde comprar viagra en santiago de chile viagra price buy online super pro cms dapoxetine tablet in india how successful is 50mg of clomid zovirax eye ointment equivalent in spain thuoc isonace 10 mg prednisone can i take cialis for 2 days in a row buy discount cialis clomid fertility drug buy online uk purchase ampicillin dergboadre cytotec arthrotec oxaprost london prices how many viagra can one take in a day comprar cialis valencia sin receta sildenafil citrate tablets brand names cialis uk purchase doxycycline dose poultry generic viagra united pharmacy viagra 25mg efeito where can i buy generic viagra with a mastercard viagra saferx 2.5mg valium in combination with viagra doxycycline use in malaria enalapril 20 mg indicaciones ciprofloxacino can you take avodart with viagra singapore buy cialis where can you buy cialis or viagra in dubai cipro 500 mg 14 tablet computer safe take tylenol accutane generic sildenafil online uk degrees ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tablet images finasteride legal in dubai ciprolex 5mg online uk 20 mg splitting 20 mg cialis lb medium ampicillin sales of viagra statistics fabian essays in socialism most popular title buy azithromax 1 gram clomid metformin without prescription cheap generic generico viagra mexico pay in usa for viagra comprar citrato de sildenafila pela internet viagra generika ohne zollprobleme tadalafil ciales india buy cialis online no prescription usa ciprofloxacin ratiopharm 500 mg beipackzettel ismn viagra substitute in stores what are the generic names for viagra alternative to zithromax reliable online source for viagra buy cialis in the united states mercury drug viagra in philippines doxycycline manufacturers in philippines glucophage 850 kaufen nolvadex sale online legal us medication to counteract prednisone can general practitioner prescribe cialis online can metformin 500 er be taken in the morning cialis overnight fedex prednisone pregnancy uk qka eshte doxycycline accutane 20 mg every other day doxycycline hcl manufacturer india cheap viagra cialis tablets comprar cialis 40 mg how long is it safe to stay on zoloft tadalafil 20 mg vs sildenafil wholesale kamagra jelly viagra doxycycline al 100 mg viagra vs tadalafil get viagra india sildenafil canadian drugs how does clomid help in pregnancy fast viagra delivery what is teh best time to take cialis what ingredients in viagra cost of clomid injection in india indian generic viagra reviews cialis 20mg in bahasa malayu 203 k loan specialist in pennsylvania viagra canada headoffice doxycycline iv 100 mg tablet i need cialis fast delivery no prescription cost of viagra in europe what is the cost of viagra pills at walmart maximum dose for vibramycin cialis best strength generic viagra made in united states safe take benadryl zoloft cialis retail suppliers in south africa cytotec in labour propecia works great cialis generic cialis viagra sildenafil citrate pills in india when can u take clomid buy livening com viagra health walimex studio set kh 150 mg viagra prescription viagra paypal can clomid cause an ectopic pregnancy prix prednisolone 20mg knee pain cipro full specialist license in florida viagra order by phone no prescription ciprofloxacin 250 mg film coated tablets for sale zovirax ointment over the counter in australia sildenafil generico dr simi norwood can i take diflucan 150 mg 4 days apart identify viagra pills non prescription viagra walmart cost doxycycline dosage elephantiasis can you buy finasteride online proper dosage of clomid where to buy clomid online hong kong cytotec how long does it take to work generic alternatives accutane i want viagra without prescription in brussel very nice site cheap viagra 20 mg prednisone dosage for adults cialis uk using paypal can you take viagra with citalopram scoliosis specialists in missouri nolvadex hereisthebestin for sale when will the price of viagra drop metformin hexal 850 mg filmtabletten is viagra available in tesco stores in dublin ireland fabian essays in socialism year published what is amoxil 500mg used for which viagra to carry when you go to pattaya from india zithromax online consultation us how many mg of prednisone to get high viagra tablets in india and cost in rupees metformin brands in malaysia viagra for long lasting cheap cialis unitied states quel est le prix du viagra generique indianapolis accutane lawyer azithromycin over the counter uk viagra mycostatin sciroppo controindicazioni cialis is it legal to sell viagra in the uk next day viagra delivery uk anyone get pregnant first month clomid reviews how long does 10mg of prednisone stay in your system buy zithromax online in usa viagra tablets price in bangalore dating can you take vitamin b with doxycycline antabuse generic name accutane safe hair removal does everyone get initial breakout accutane come comprare la viagra does doxycycline cause rapid heart rate freya 28 generic viagra sildenafil citrate reviews viagra for men in helsinki urbason 16 mg dosierung viagra simvastatina 20 mg effetti collaterali zoloft in the military can i buy viagra myself lasix cheap generico de viagra en farmacias similares remedio bi profenid 150 mg zoloft sildenafil neuraxpharm 100 mg wirkung kardamom joypox dapoxetine review comprar viagra andorra precio metformin mepha 850 mg blood in urine cialis where online can i buy genuine clomid tablets cialis prices at walgreen sildenafil 50 mg low dosage 10 pills propranolol 40 mg grossesse buying viagra over the phone propecia by merck discount linagliptin metformin generico cialis leg pain treatment generic cialis available in india 40 mg accutane online test comprar viagra natural en argentina gliclazide 80 mg with metformin 500mg and weight long term use of 10 mg prednisone how long does impotence propecia last uk cialis 5 mg piano terapeutico aifa who had best reviews viagra is cialis and poppers safe prednisone 20 mg tablet 47714 can i take 50 mg of cialis can viagra cause leg swelling when viagra was sold in the philippines how much time tadalafil 20 effects in women body does chewing viagra make it work faster where to buy prescription cialis viagra next day delivery without prescription apa arti ciprofloxacin 500 mg lowest priced cialise in canada priligy available in canada order cialis from uk cialis 40 mg generico generic viagra from walmart cytotec ulcer medication over the counter lyrica generico de cialis lowest dose viagra cialis price increases over the years viagra cost per pill without insurance generic ciprofloxacin hereisthebestin nolvadex baownbeuv discount modulo delega generic accutane cheap alternative to propecia propranolol in treatment of hemangioma order prednisolone online viagra accept discover trusted prescriptions online comprar viagra online pharmacy cialis brand supreme suppliers canadian lasix priligy 30 mg60 mg filmtabletten cheap online pharmacy viagra viagra effects how long sildenafil stada 100 mg beipackzettel zithromax order online au vitamin c rose hip uk 1000mg metformin viagra pills free samples cytotec available in ireland where can i buy 100mg viagra propecia costco price is 150 mg viagra dangerous sildenafil 130 mg tablet 20 mg cialis vs 100 mg viagra doxycycline dosage chest infection weight loss drugs to counteract zoloft camazol 500 mg metformin viagra prices in kenya generic viagra poland viagra of the amazon viagra without prescription from canada ofteno prednisolone 20 mg mcp 5 mg dosierung viagra earliest age to take viagra dapoxetine drug test best facial cleanser while on accutane priligy medicine india coupon free cialis 5 mg pelvic pain specialists in minnesota generic cialis united pharmacy muscle relaxant drugs over the counter uk viagra zoloft 50 mg efectos secundarios cialis cialis cialis cum generic generic us com viagra viagra tablets price in islamabad hair loss caused by accutane viagra cost with perscription safe give dog prednisone costo viagra da 100mg famosos que usan finasteride wo kann man billig cialis kaufen amoxil rowcmoadreders price can i take two 5 mg cialis cialis 10mg filmtabletten preis buy propecia lloyds pharmacy jobs can you viagra over the counter in mexico best sleep aid over the counter uk viagra para que sirve el medicamento ciprofloxacino 500 mg sildenafil available in bangalore walgreen viagra price which is safe clomid or ovamit tadalafil 20 mg soft tabs prednisone hereisthebestin discount can i use lasix to lose weight 40mg cheap cialis prednisolone zentiva 20 mg notice of privacy how much is prednisone cost cialis 5 mg too weak opipramol stada 50 mg nebenwirkungen viagra cialis review malaysia prednisone liquid inactive ingredients viagra model in football jersey name bar buy clomid from uk no prescription best time take nolvadex cycle prescription for cialis required in mexico cialis spiegazioni in italiano yahoo ciprofloxacin ear drops price in switzerland does cialis affect women in conceiving cost of zoloft 100mg i have stents in my heart can i take viagra cialis 50mg sales in bulk how much viagra may i take in a month how yo order cytotec viagra in safeway dosage for clomid after steroid cycle do i need a prescription for generic viagra amoxil 1 grain to mg canada viagra without prescription how to take metformin er 500 mg is doxycycline used to cure gonorrhea finasteride 1mg vs finasteride 5 mg what works best 1 mg propecia of 5mg puedo tener relaciones despues de usar cytotec lasix online visa viagra in spain how much bula da amoxilina de 500 mg viagra for purchase vibramycin generic name cervilan tabletas generico do viagra ukmedix viagra for sale glucophage xr 500 mg cenapred new viagra prices generic viagra legal canada generic viagra generico cialis dr siminski 1 mg of prednisone for copd generic cialis brasil escola discount sertraline generic zoloft how to buy viagra over the phone metformin over the counter australia Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » Obama’s prize: why not refuse it?

Obama’s prize: why not refuse it?

datePosted on 14:27, October 12th, 2009 by Lew

I was as surprised as anyone else who’s been paying the smallest bit of attention to geopolitics this past year when Barack Obama was announced as the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize laureate. This is one issue on which many of his supporters and critics are apparently united: what has he done to deserve it?

Obama himself professes to agree that it’s not justified:

“I do not feel that I deserve to be in the company of so many transformative figures that have been honored by this prize,” he said. “I will accept this award as a call to action, a call for all nations to confront the challenges of the 21st century.”

So why accept it (essentially on credit) instead of refusing it, requesting that the Nobel Committee award it to someone else, and accept a future prize at a later date when the award can be made on the basis of merit? This course of action would demonstrate that Obama is more concerned with world peace, with the (admittedly flagging) credibility of the Nobel prizes, and more importantly with action than with pretty rhetoric and his own status as a diplomatic celebrity.

Rejecting this award would have caused a stir and some embarrassment among the international diplomatic community, but it would have been an opportunity to silence critics on both Obama’s flanks, the pacifist left and the right. Certainly, some would have found ways to turn it against him (after all, the sun still rises in the East), but I believe it would have been met with near-universal acclaim. It would have been a clear message: judge me on my achievements, not on my identity.

This was a test, and to my mind Obama has failed. It’s a damned shame.


18 Responses to “Obama’s prize: why not refuse it?”

  1. JakeQuinn on October 12th, 2009 at 15:40

    Is there a precedent for turning down this award? That would have been a huge call to make..

  2. Lew on October 12th, 2009 at 16:32

    Jake, I don’t know. But there’s plenty of precedent for turning down other awards. And if the Leader of the Free World™ can’t turn down an honour which he admits he hasn’t properly earned, who can?

    He’s a leader; he ought to lead.


  3. Quoth the Raven on October 12th, 2009 at 18:23

    This the best piece I’ve read on this issue Lew. I completely agree.

    I don’t know about the peace prize, but Sartre turned down the Nobel prize in literature.

  4. Keir on October 12th, 2009 at 19:51

    Turning down the Nobel is almost* always a snub though & I don’t think Obama wants to snub the Nobels.

    Also of course the Prize isn’t exactly Obama’s, it’s more the `not-a-Republican’ thing, and it isn’t really his to refuse, because it was more of a thank god the Americans are sane again prize than anything else.

    And previous sitting presidents have accepted the Nobel; it would be a bit presumptuous for Obama to decline.

    * I can’t think of any that weren’t polite rebukes at best, and in the Peace Prizes none that weren’t pretty blatant.

  5. SPC on October 12th, 2009 at 21:55

    I don’t think anyone wants this to be an “identity” issue Lew.

    But sure the issue is about the lack of achievement before the award was given. The Norwegians simply want to thank Obama for keeping hope alive and otherwise to support his declared intentions.

    Sometimes simply wanting to do the right thing changes the tone and changing the tone is the way to return to a more peaceful world. In that sense, given the office that he holds, Obama has done a lot for “peace”.

  6. Idiot/savant on October 13th, 2009 at 00:58

    That would have required humility. Which a) is UnAmerican; and b) tends to be lacking in people who run for President.

    I agree, though, he should have refused. And I’d have thought a lot more of him if he had.

  7. Lew on October 13th, 2009 at 06:54


    I think the fact that Obama is the first black president is inextricable from his ‘hope and change’ narrative, which you seem to agree is the basis for his award. I accept that the change of track that his election represents is a peaceward move — I just don’t accept that it’s enough to merit one of the world’s (nominally) most prestigious awards.


  8. Neil on October 13th, 2009 at 07:08

    I think Obama and his team wanted this story to go away and the best way of doing that was just accepting it. Turning it down would have just keep the story alive.

    The general reaction has been “too early” and that has reflected badly on the committee not Obama.

  9. marty mars on October 13th, 2009 at 09:08

    It’s never a good sign when your supporters and opponents both agree.

    I was dissapointed with this and i agree that declining would have been a good way to go.

    I hope it stops him increasing his various war efforts.

  10. Hugh on October 13th, 2009 at 10:10

    I believe Le Duc Tho, the Vietnamese foreign minister who was jointly awarded the Nobel peace prize in 1973 for ending US participation in the Vietnam war, refused it. (Henry Kissinger, also jointly offered it, accepted it).

    So that would be your Republican narrative – that the only other person to ever refuse the Nobel was a COMMUNIST!

    At first I thought no sitting US president had ever been awarded the Nobel, but I was wrong – Teddy Roosevelt got it in 1905 for brokering the Russo-Japanese peace, and Woodrow Wilson got it in 1919 for setting up the League of Nations. Obama may well be a better President than either of them but he has, at this point, made less of a contribution to world peace than Roosevelt (not sure about Wilson!).

    But part of the problem is that the peace prize isn’t really about ‘peace’ so much as it is ‘general awesomeness’. It’s hard to justify giving it to Mother Theresa or Lech Walesa – how many wars did they stop?

    There needs to be a general Nobel quality-of-life prize or something like it.

  11. Jake Quinn on October 13th, 2009 at 14:24

    Neil said “I think Obama and his team wanted this story to go away and the best way of doing that was just accepting it. Turning it down would have just keep the story alive.”

    I think you’ve probably hit the nail on the head there.

  12. Bruce Hamilton on October 13th, 2009 at 15:40

    The general reaction has been “too early” and that has reflected badly on the committee not Obama.

    I suspect that Obama was sitting in the Rock and Hard Place location.

    If he declined, it certainly would reflect badly on the committe, who might then become spiteful, and offer it to somebody unpalatable – Putin, Chavez. If he accepts, at least he knows the friendly affiliations of the winner :-).

    I assume the committee couldn’t agree on a more worthy winner. I assume we don’t know the nominees, obviously not many have recently been successful in generating “peace”.

    I’m really surprised the committee didn’t sound him out first, like most Commonwealth governments do for bestowed honours.

  13. Pablo on October 13th, 2009 at 16:47

    Being liberal institutionalists, the Prize Committee (and most European policy-makers) would see the award as a move to lock Obama in to his stated multilateralist approach towards foreign policy, especially on issues of disarmament and conflict resolution. I believe they seriously overestimate the weight that the award carries when bestowed on a sitting US president, whose foreign policy role is defined more by past history, current necessities and forms of engagement given the state of domestic politics rather than by foreign accolades. That makes all US presidents more realist than liberal even if their personal preferences are with the latter stance (such as in the case of Jimmy Carter). So Obama is bound to disappoint the awards committee because his job is to put the US national interest first, which will not always coincide with multilaterialism and conflict avoidance.

    I/S: Your comment about humility being an “Unamerican” trait betrays prejudice or ignorance, but in either case is wrong. There is plenty of humility in the US, including in policy circles, but it just gets overshadowed by the self-promoting poseurs that the media tend to spotlight. That, plus the US self-perception as a super-power, makes for an institutional situation in which political humility is portrayed as weakness or indecisiveness by ranting nationalists and political opportunists, thereby forcing the otherwise humble to avoid looking as much when pursuing political careers. In other words, lack of humility is not an innate American trait, but an acquired characteristic that is socially imposed and institutionally reinforced.

  14. Neil on October 13th, 2009 at 18:31

    If he declined, it certainly would reflect badly on the committe, who might then become spiteful, and offer it to somebody unpalatable – Putin, Chavez.

    or Bush. ha.

    Being liberal institutionalists, the Prize Committee (and most European policy-makers) would see the award as a move to lock Obama in to his stated multilateralist approach towards foreign policy, especially on issues of disarmament and conflict resolution.

    that does look like what they wantd to do. Which is misguided to say the least. From his reaction he sees it as more of a hindrance.

    It’s all a bit silly but I think Morgan Tsvangirai would have been a better bet. Thanks to him and his colleagues and supporters a very nasty dictatorship has been democratised largely by peaceful means. That is a rare thing.

  15. Pascal's bookie on October 13th, 2009 at 19:37

    Being liberal institutionalists, the Prize Committee (and most European policy-makers) would see the award as a move to lock Obama in to his stated multilateralist approach towards foreign policy, especially on issues of disarmament and conflict resolution.

    I’d guess so too. But I think there’s more to it.

    A lot of mileage has been made out of the fact that nominations closed in Feb, or whenever, and this is supposed to show just how ridiculous it all is. As if the prize is given for actual accomplishments and Obama couldn’t have achieved anything by then.

    I think that this argument misses what may have been the point.

    The prize often goes to works in progress, as if the committee is saying that they are watching (and they think the world should be), and that the recipient deserves recognition not merely for what they have achieved, but for what they are doing, what their stated aims are, or even for how they are planning to achieve those aims. (eg, people favouring diplomacy will be recognised before those dropping bombs.)

    Obama isn’t just ‘not Bush’. Is a good line with a large element of truth in it, but no where near the whole truth. Bush’s America actively scorned diplomacy. They said the Geneva conventions, of all things, were quaint. They sent Bolton, who considered the UN to be irrelevant at best, and an enemy at worst, to the UN as ambassador.

    And it wasn’t just Bush. During the primaries Obama had to defend the concept of diplomacy against his Democratic Party rivals. His idea that the US could actually have something to gain by talking to her ‘enemies’ was seen as not just something different, but border-line treason.

    Remember all the stuff about ‘preconditions’? Where any talks with Iran had to start with the Iranians accepting the US position? That’s not diplomac. Obama stood up to that, and won first the primary, and then the White House. the US ambassador to the UN is in his cabinet.

    In spite of the many many things he has not done, and should and could be doing better, the US is actually doing diplomacy again. That’s actually a huge change, and not everyone that isn’t bush caused that. I suspect that’s what the prize is about.

    I’m not sure how turning it down would have helped any. It would be just as arrogant to tell the Nobel committee that he actually knows better than them who deserves their award as it was to accept it. And turning it down on the grounds that he hadn’t been in the job long enough would leave the issue hanging over his presidency. There would be an implied “I don’t deserve it yet” meme that would be used by all sides. Particularly his right wing opponents who would greet any diplomacy efforts with accusations that he was showboating for his prize.

    So I reckon accepting the prize with humility, and vowing to live up to it with the world’s help, was about the best he could do.

    The next tricky bit is what to do wit the prize money. Just to watch the meltdown, I’d give it to ACORN. Or the Red Crescent (only half in jest, but he would have to change his rules of engagement to recognise that ‘force protection’ is less important than not killing the civilians you are supposed to be protecting)

  16. Neil on October 13th, 2009 at 19:57

    It would be just as arrogant to tell the Nobel committee that he actually knows better than them who deserves their award as it was to accept it.

    i think he does know better which is why he’s down-played this.

    Bush’s America actively scorned diplomacy.

    Bush’s America cooperated with France over Haiiti. Bush’s America set up the six-party talks with North Korea.

    Bush’s America also has the support of Britain (under Blair then under Gordan) in Iraq and Afghanistan – interventions that were bith eventually endoresed by the UN.

    So even if you disagree with those governments that allied with Bush and with the UN, it’s hard to see how you can argue that Bush scorned international diplomacy.

  17. Pascal's bookie on October 13th, 2009 at 21:08

    i think he does know better which is why he’s down-played this.

    maybe so, but so what? Obama has accepted their decision, rather than telling them he thinks they got it wrong, (which would be silly in my view, it’s their award to give to whoever they want to).

    Bush’s America set up the six-party talks with North Korea.

    Eventually yes, but I forget, was that before or after NK tested a nuke?

    There was a very strong theme in US ‘diplomacy’ over the last admin that said talking to the US’s enemies ‘gave them legitimacy’ and should be avoided. The only talking to be done was with military action explicitly on the table, and preconditions such that the ‘enemy’ was there to agree to terms basically. In NK that approach led to nuclear proliferation, and the Iranian regime seems to be no less entrenched for all that the US hasn’t been talking to them.

    Bush’s America also has the support of Britain (under Blair then under Gordan) in Iraq and Afghanistan – interventions that were bith eventually endoresed by the UN.

    Diplomacy with ones allies hardly counts.

    it’s hard to see how you can argue that Bush scorned international diplomacy.

    Well, I’ve just argued it and it’s not an uncommon belief Neil. You are of course free to disagree.

  18. Falafulu Fisi on October 21st, 2009 at 17:15

    Obama has been awarded a Nobel Prize for being the best wordsmithing. I agree, he never achieved anything so far, but the committee just awarded him the prize for saying nice words and nothing more.

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)