pronil 30 dapoxetine buy cialis and prostate online no prescription cialis viagra for mens available in kolkata viagra bestellen in der schweiz how to make strongs viagra in house neonatal ampicillin and gentamicin cialis generico 5 order viagra baownbeuv how much is zithromax 250mg for 5 days cost at walmart viagra pro online canada can you take clomid with aspirin where to find viagra in tijuana viagra overdose in women can you take more than 2 viagra in a day what is the standard cialis dose metformin 1500 mg and pcos viagra cost in india what is dapoxetine and sildenafil tablets buy viagra online without prescription fast delivery where to buy pink viagra in lahore what mg is propecia how to take zithromax 500 mg dosage is cialis safe 20 mg hemangioma in infants propranolol hydrochloride best ed pill over counter with sildenafil cialis generico venezuela flag what time of day to take clomid pct cheapest way to get propecia by viagra in south africa buying doxycycline nomad gold viagra london cialis sample dosage tadalafil price in bangkok man takes viagra tsa pat down sildenafil cost at boots for women prix propecia pharmacie toulouse cipro and joint disorders what does woman viagra do average cost for viagra 12 pack what is socialism today in real terms top online pharmacies for cialis viagra kaufen rezept viagra hq in canada ciprofloxacina 750 mg costo priligy en belgique ciprofloxacin 250 mg 100 count bottle and bottega clomid reviews with pcos doxycycline monohydrate for acne reviews can you take cialis after eating bewirkt viagra for sale zoloft 50 mg taper fades type of viagra in india sildenafil rowcmoadreders canada when should you take doxycycline best alternative to viagra over the counter harga zithromax 500 mg dosage viagra dosage yahoo can you buy viagra over counter dubai taking cialis 5 mg every other day is it ok to take clomid at night caverta generic viagra generic viagra pillshoprxcom cialis fruta my online site co il reviews 100 mg cialis cialis 2.5 mg indications can you dilute viagra in water truth about how to use viagra best good place to buy welfil tadalafil aurochem budecort aqua generico do viagra i want information about viagra in urdu is viagra available in manila where can i get viagra in los angeles ca viagra made in singapore letrozole vs clomid cost zovirax suspension in egypt donde puedo comprar viagra en valencia finasteride young age donde comprar finasteride en madrid uiterste houdbaarheidsdatum viagra generic diflucan 100 mg prix is viagra over the counter medicine zoloft false positive generic and brand name for ciprofloxacin cialis paypal payment accepted cialis5mg in pakistan ciprofloxacin 250 mg tabl ciproxina tabletas 500 mg bayer buy viagra in pretoria cipla sildenafil citrate reviews can you buy cialis canada over counter 250 mg ciprofloxacin hcl where can i buy clomid without prescription in uk how many mg for viagra vorzeitiger samenerguss medikament priligy review buy female viagra online australian posologia ciproxin 500 mg prednisone 5 mg tabletki ulotka auchan socialism 19th century europe the best way to take prednisone is 5mg of prednisone safe can you take prenatal vitamins while on clomid cialis lilly uk generic cialis cost ireland best moisturiser for accutane metformin and aldactone for pcos lasix yan etkisi cialis cost per pill 5mg valium when to take clomid day or night clomid price in mercury drug philippines medicines zoloft use in menopause clomid 50 mg cipla treating low progesterone with clomid 5 off line order form sildenafil citrate does 50 mg zoloft work zithromax walmart over the counter texas ic doxycycline hyclate ingredients in gatorade what is clomid for pregnancy northern ireland bedding canada cheap viagra best starting dosage zoloft kamagra sildenafil and dapoxetine effect of ciprofloxacin in sperm how long can one take clomid generic equivalent clomid viagra safety vulvodynia specialists in pennsylvania valais blacknose sheep for sale in uk zithromax order cialis 10mg 10 tabs whats the difference between 1mg propecia and 5 mg sildenafil viagra generico tadalafil cheapest lowest price cialis or viagra cheaper ratiopharm viagra kaufen finasteride vs dutasteride in bph bank viagra generic about com tablet sildenafil citrate information in hindi in india doxycycline 100 mg blue capsules indocin doxycycline 100 mg safe with taking minocycline 100mg mtx hexal 15 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin cialis 10mg reviews order propecia fedex dental implant specialists in glenwood why do canine prescriptions taper off prednisone cost of cialis in manila panrazol 20 mg prednisone side effect of generic cialis lowest price pharmacy for viagra the 2x2 project cheapest cialis canada 75 mg of zoloft for anxiety what if i take two cialis tablets in three days glucophage 850 mg and weight loss 2 20 mg cialis where do i buy viagra in china sildenafil brands available in india i need to buy prednisone 64 chevy impala for sale in uk zithromax viagra availibility in dubai pharmacy 100 mg clomid iui success how much does a diflucan pill cost without insurance nike reax run 8 womens reviews on viagra comprar viagra legalmente ciego viagra in kolkata where to buyy diflucan 150 mg aspergillus buy zithromax powder form for clamidiya mal olor despues de usar cytotec viagra shops in newcastle quando devo usar viagra canadian pharmacies for viagra necesito comprar viagra en chile cl best time day clomid para que sirve cipro 500 mg zoloft early pregnancy cipro competence in processes historic price sildenafil viagra how long to take effect fake propecia pills from india kalenjin comedy propecia for sale common accutane dosage cytotec x aborto cialis online co lasix vs demadex how much is cialis at chemist year accutane put market purchase viagra in toronto clinic propranolol safe infants peptazol 20 mg effetti collaterali zoloft usar pastillas viagra viagra generico in farmacia prezzo kenya cannabinoid system in neuroprotection and tadalafil safe viagra source doxycycline 100 mg indonesia lopraz 40 mg gastro resistant prednisolone sildenafil in pregnancy nighttime eating disorder zoloft withdrawal symptoms donde comprar cialis generico dfas montelukast 10 mg tablet interaction with viagra average cost of viagra 100mg walmart safety taking viagra much mg propecia take how much is the cost of viagra cost clomid australia clomid 100mg headache comprar viagra generico contrareembolso significado buying generic viagra safely online amoxil amoxicillin 250 mg propranolol 60 mg dosage sildenafil de 50 mg contraindicaciones online chemist australia viagra correct dose of ampicillin deltacortene 25 mg compresse prednisone 10 compresse viagra online bg knigi where can i buy nolvadex online yahoo 50 mg apo prednisone for dog lymphoma how to take doxycycline without stomach upset doxycycline 100 mg information sheets blood in stool after prednisone does medicare cover viagra 2012 pharmacy where viagra is sold in manila buy viagra in washington difference between 5mg cialis and 10 mg cialis viagra purchase buy clomid cause uterine polyps find viagra in montreal were to buy viagra safely viagra 800 mg kaina which is best celexa or zoloft is it safe to give a woman a viagra that is for man bumex versus lasix in causing hyponatremia how to minimize nausea with doxycycline buying cialis on the web donde comprar viagra en uruguay ley viagra prices virginia costco buy accutane usa sildenafil 100 mg cena viagra 50 mg lang viagra available in arkansas el cytotec como se usa remedio labirin 24 mg prednisone cialis de 1 mg ciprofloxacin stada 500 mg beipackzettel viagra over the counter in manilla bangkok generic viagra where to buy propecia generic generic viagra 50mg online thesaurus ciprofloxacino 500 mg en espanol price list cialis walmart ciprofloxacin 500 mg mepha viagra 100mg panvel ciprofloxacin 250 mg 3 tage prednisone 40 mg tablet buy post cycle hcg and clomid brand names of ciprofloxacin eye drops tabletten haarausfall propecia for sale sildenafil walmart mexico how long to take doxycycline after tick bite cialis in bangladesh telomere shortening accutane reviews dosage clomid musculation how many doxycycline should i take a day augmentin duo tablet 500mg 125 mg zoloft is viagra legal to buy in mexico cialis 2 5mg 5 mg doxycycline treat balanitis erfahrungen mit cialis 10mg india viagra telugu com metformin 850 mg en espanol glyformin 500 mg metformin viagra kaufen biz la sportiva mythos womens reviews on cialis generic viagra availability cialis tabs for sale long does viagra 50 mg last what does cialis cost in south africa cialis de 5 mlg 20 mgs cialis online cialis generic buy cheap cialis 5 mg testimonials is cialis 20mg better than 10mg reviews where to get nolvadex clomid how to calculate accutane dosage prednisolone 20 mg und alkohol test viagra tablets in india online what happens if a girl uses viagra cialis 20 mg as needed propranolol 60 mg twice a day antibiotics generic viagra 50 mg 50 doxycycline salet is in which tablet finasteride taken with flomax priligy dapoxetine review canada pharmacy clomid is there an over the counter safe medicine like viagra bijsluiter ciprofloxacine sandoz 500 mg cheap generic online viagra soft tabs how to take 20 mg prednisone side ringing in the ears with ciprofloxacin eyedrops need viagra pills metformin 500 mg ttc trip tablet lesuride 25 mg zoloft apo prednisone 1 mg is it safe to take viagra 2 times a day when to take lasix are generic viagra pills full dtrength donde comprar sildenafil en buenos aires sin receta how long does viagra stays in your blood prednisone 22 10 mg pills dosage can you buy viagra in vietnam nombre de cialis generico en mexico cialis buy from medco where i can buy viagra in kolkata cialis da 10 o da 20 mg prednisone 5 mg while dog is pregnant gibt es viagra ohne rezept in der apotheke where to buy viagra over the counter in johannesburg assunzione di zoloft in gravidanza metformin in coronary artery disease blood in urine after taking cipro prix boite de cialis brand viagra pills where to buy cialis in china 25 to 50 mg zoloft pregnancy can i take viagra if im 25 getting pregnant with pcos clomid pantopan 14cpr gastr 20 mg prednisone doxycycline disp 100 mg bijwerkingen cocaine propecia kaufen europa biotech ciprofloacin 500 mg viagra in indian book through vp zoloft 200 mg daily for years accutane in my 40s cytotec for abortion online books doxycycline 100mg per day acne creamy discharge on clomid sildenafil generico cinfa pharmaceuticals delgra 100mg sildenafil from canada trying to conceive multiples clomid online cialis 5 mg acquistare propranolol safe during pregnancy class action against accutane canada would democratic socialism work in the us how was viagra first discovered buy generic viagra online delivery fast 300 mg of doxycycline acne 5mg generic cialis without prescription amoxil price ireland 20 mg prednisone and pregnancy generic viagra cheap accepts paypal can a girl use viagra clarinex redi tabs generic viagra how to order cialis canada what day did you ovulate on 100mg clomid buy cialis in portugal accutane dosage chart weight viagra safe epileptics red viagra 200mg tadalafil 20mgdapoxetine tadalafil 2.5mg pakistani brands why sildenafil is used price of zovirax buy liquid propecia walgreens how much does cialis cost telefono para comprar cytotec vermouth yzaguirre donde comprar viagra voli low cost per cipro da venezia generic cialis shipped from usa best face cleanser while on accutane order lasix no prescription wholesale cialis manufacturers zithromax price 2gram where you buy viagra in stores gkh pharmaceutical clomid for sale buy viagra lloyds pharmacy london viagra 100mg safeway svt in toddlers getting off propranolol generic cialis is good viagra causing infertility in males sildenafil hormosan 100 mg filmtabletten tmf heart specialist in tyler tx cost of cialis at osco bruno generic viagra prednisone buy uk karsivan 50 mg dosierung viagra 200 mg viagra pills is there an over the counter equivilant to viagra is it safe to cut zoloft in half propranolol anxiety mg trying to conceive on clomid 50 mg viagra clinic in indonesia pharmacy boots price of viagra order zithromax without a prescription propecia in female hair loss can you bey viagra over the counter how long does prednisone stay in system dog viagra india pill what all ingredients are in viagra walmart finasteride 1mg unchecked cast generics for accutane buy propecia and anavar zoloft mg daily accutane causes fibromyalgia ciprofloxacina clorhidrato 500 mg para que sirve viagra pfizer 100mg ohne rezept fda approved tadalafil canada prix du medicament propecia generic cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews canadian drugstore viagra cialis tbl 4x 20 mg anti malaria pills doxycycline is silagra as good as viagra cialis online statistics usage cialis mg price india viagra generic reviews buy cytotec abortion pill malaysia lupa de relojero donde comprar viagra viagrahome office in toronto canada best acne medicine other than accutane birth comprare viagra pagamento contrassegno disabili finasteride buy australia splitting cialis 20 mg viagra in gibralta asics gt 1000 3 womens reviews on cialis second round of accutane results reviews dosagem de lasix para caes viagra and pay with mastercard canadian healthcare viagra where can we buy viagra. in sydney amoxicillin 750 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin how long before sex should i take viagra 100mg nolvadex pct ebay review forms of viagra liquid is it legal to order viagra online in the us ciprofloxacin 250 mg 5 ml equals how many teaspoons is 30 mg of accutane enough 25mg generic viagra price of viagra in doha qatar zithromax online info best time to take glucophage for bodybuilder quality vibramycin online bye cialis montreal zoloft or lexapro for panic disorder can i cut 10mg cialis in half viagra buy shops prednisolone soluble tablets viagra herbal for men in bangalore dosage of doxycycline for uti generic viagra in india over the counter lovenox generic form of zoloft generic vega cream sildenafil online viagra jual viagra off brands of soda when is best time using cialis purchase doxycycline hyclate buy liquid cialis online movement in vision viagra pomada acheflan generico de cialis clomid 250mg fertility how to get viagra in a couple of days ul li doxycycline for pets over the counter alternative shipping to canada cialis buy cialis bulk effects of prednisone in canines prednisolone 15 mg5 ml dosage viagra active ingredient how well does generic propecia work dapoxetine working time how much the price of viagra in hongkong prednisone usage pregnancy zoloft has really helped me through onde comprar viagra no df comprar zithromax sin receta cialis women australia how much does prescription propecia cost ciprofloxacina teva 500 mg posologia 100 mg vs 50mg viagra zovirax generic form comprare viagra chiasso buy viagra online buy original viagra ohne rezept viagra works best when taken as rectal suppository prednisone in pregnancy ulcerative colitis ciprofloxacin mechanism of action drugbank finasteride donde comprar en chile ciprofloxacin and tinidazole wiki what if a healthy man takes viagra do need buy viagra when does propecia really start working viagra sale in malaysia pharmacy amoxi clavulan stada 875125 mg nebenwirkungen viagra metformin in hemodialysis patients propecia generico foro sol dbol cycle with nolvadex online medicamento magnus sildenafil 50 mg common viagra dose can you take probiotics with doxycycline premature ejaculation drug viagra australia kee klamp cheaper alternative to viagra where i can find viagra dublin sildenafil citrate 4 tablets 25 mg uk what is like to masterbate on cialis how much viagra in toronto the price of cialis comprar viagra online seguro Kiwipolitico » Blog Archive » A return to “our foreign policy is trade”?

A return to “our foreign policy is trade”?

datePosted on 23:57, May 1st, 2009 by Lew

Murray McCully hasn’t so much taken the razor to NZAid as taken the axe to its foundations, in one of the clearest indications so far of the new government’s ideological intentions:

Following a review process, the government has decided to change the mandate of NZAID, the government’s aid agency, to focus on sustainable economic growth.

Notice how he leaves out what the mandate was changed from. Good press release-writing. National Radio is more explicit, however:

The semi-autonomous body NZ Aid will be brought back under the control of the Foreign Affairs and Trade Ministry and its focus will change from poverty elimination to sustainable economic growth.

Now we see the dichotomy I theorised a while ago made plain: from from least harm to greatest good.

Now, in the context of foreign policy I don’t have a categorical problem with this approach, because foreign policy is different to domestic policy where the government bears a direct and explicit responsibility for the wellbeing of the worst-off of its citizens. NZ doesn’t necessarily have that responsibility to the worst-off citizens of its donee nations. While it serves NZ to look after them, fundamentally all foreign policy actions are taken with the home nation’s interests at the fore, not with the foreign nation’s interests. So I’m not going to argue against this change of mandate on the basis that it’s cruel or unjust or unfair on the poor of the Pacific, plenty of people are doing that. I’m going to argue against it on the basis that it’s short-sighted and bad for NZ in the context of our relationships with our Pacific neighbours.

The problem, paradoxically, is that the realignment of NZAid with the trade agenda prioritises immediate NZ commercial interests to the exclusion of other, more strategic goals. Like democracy, sustainable economic development isn’t something you can create by throwing money about. NZ’s aid agenda to provide an economic floor in (parts of) the Pacific has generally had three broad purposes: 1. maintain peace and order; 2. deter the advances of more predatory regional powers*; 3. enable people to develop economic structures on their own terms. Largely the first two have succeeded; the third remains a work in progress. The three points are in ascending strategic order; that is, the longest-term goal is to enable the people of the Pacific to develop their own economies and their own market structures, structures which serve them, rather then serving the interests of foreign entrepreneurs first. The changed NZAid mandate, which to my mind roughly reverses the order of the three priorities on the reasoning that if people have the third then the first and second will follow, seems unwise because I don’t think they will follow. Markets which exploit people’s vulnerability, or which concentrate wealth and power among the usual sorts of tin-pot third-world elites will not result in stability, and will render the disgruntled Pacific vulnerable to the aforementioned depredations. This policy realignment (by McCully’s own admission) will divert aid money from those at the subsistence line into private enterprise, most of which is owned outside the Pacific. It will result in a subclass of client entrepreneurs both here and in the Pacific, those with the connections to sign on early and sew up a section of the nascent market for themselves, with full government favour. The Pacific needs trade strategies for mutual benefit, driven by Pacific people to meet their own needs, not created artificially from outside with a territorial gold rush in mind. If we profit to the detriment of our neighbours, our trade might be healthy, but the wider Pacific situation will not, and we will suffer in other ways.

In this situation, trade wins and everything else loses. This is what I mean by the title: McCully has tacitly declared that nothing other than trade really matters, a return to Muldoon’s famous position on the matter. Although the aid agenda is more closely targeted to the Pacific, the focus on trade signals the beginning of a more arm’s length relationship based on cash rather than regional allegiance. This in tandem with a more realist positioning from the defence review, in which the “benign strategic environment” doctrine of Clark’s government has been discarded with, I think, little evidence. Those changes will result in less development and support work and a more hard-power focused defence strategy, with its eye on a phantom threat, and a consequent cooling of the excellent operational relationship the NZDF has with the Pacific. Of course, such a realignment will be necessary if the aid=trade agenda results in the sort of destabilisation I’ve talked about.

L

* Clearly, in this context I’m talking about China. I don’t typically ascribe to the Sinophobia so rampant in the West, but in the Pacific case I think it’s justified.

10 Responses to “A return to “our foreign policy is trade”?”

  1. SPC on May 2nd, 2009 at 01:22

    If only they had a sustainable economic development programme for New Zealand and thus increased both the wages of New Zealanders and our capability to deliver .7%GDP in foreign aid – and through independent and focused aid delivery at that.

    A focus on the South Pcific would make us somewhat unique amongst the OECD in having such a limited regional range. It also implies an overly defensive and almost territoral approach to being the ones who provide aid on our patch. It also borders on the sort of desperate jealous possessiveness which some resort to when their lesser one has become aware of more appealing options.

    Of course to then deliver the aid in relationship to trade, diminishes connections to both government and people in the Pacific to focus on doing good by doing mutually advantageous business with private sector partners.

    The worst of all worlds would be to seen as attempting to exploit aid to the region to service NZ Incorporated. Or is that a political party in New Zealand attempting to turn the aid budget into a vehicle for private sector profit for business partners. No wonder connection to charity groups had to be cut so starkly. It’s as if this is vengeance for the government being blocked from privatising within New Zealand.

  2. reid on May 2nd, 2009 at 02:54

    Markets which exploit people’s vulnerability, or which concentrate wealth and power among the usual sorts of tin-pot third-world elites will not result in stability, and will render the disgruntled Pacific vulnerable…. This policy realignment (by McCully’s own admission) will divert aid money from those at the subsistence line into private enterprise, most of which is owned outside the Pacific. It will result in a subclass of client entrepreneurs both here and in the Pacific, those with the connections to sign on early and sew up a section of the nascent market for themselves, with full government favour. The Pacific needs trade strategies for mutual benefit, driven by Pacific people to meet their own needs, not created artificially from outside with a territorial gold rush in mind. If we profit to the detriment of our neighbours, our trade might be healthy, but the wider Pacific situation will not, and we will suffer in other ways.

    I quite agree this is a risk Lew. Presumably however since we can work it out those who do this for a living also have (in far more detail) and have advised accordingly.

    It’s possible this is designed to weaken long-term, the Chinese-Fiji connection which is becoming a small but increasingly virulent abscess in the region. I don’t think this will work, but it’s a plausible strategy.

    There are many other possibilities.

    In this situation, trade wins and everything else loses.

    Lew do you see this as an inevitable across-the-board win-lose? I don’t quite see how, if so.

  3. jcuknz on May 2nd, 2009 at 09:14

    stop burbling on about the Pacific .. the story I heard suggested it would be South America and South Africa which MIGHT loose some aid … look after one’s own back yard I say. Though if they further the sanctions with aid cuts to Fuji I’d be unhappy.

  4. Lew on May 2nd, 2009 at 11:03

    SPC,

    The worst of all worlds would be to seen as attempting to exploit aid to the region to service NZ Incorporated.

    Indeed. The trouble is that there will be a great temptation from within Labour to employ this sort of rhetoric in attacking National, which will cause problems with certainty and continuity. One of the defining features of our foreign policy in the last two decades has been its remarkable bipartisan continuity; that’s been valuable, but it seems to no longer be a priority.

    It’s as if this is vengeance for the government being blocked from privatising within New Zealand.

    That’s a bit too black helicopter for me, but I wonder if a goal is to fly a few privatisation kites, establishing models for how things might work in NZ?

    reid,

    I quite agree this is a risk Lew. Presumably however since we can work it out those who do this for a living also have (in far more detail) and have advised accordingly.

    This is a question of whether you reflexively trust the government (in its current form) or not. I trust their abilities; I just don’t trust their ideological premises. This means I think they’re potentially more dangerous than if they were incompetent, since I think they’ll do a good job of implementing a bad strategy, whereas incompetents would do a bad job of implementing an indifferent strategy.

    It’s possible this is designed to weaken long-term, the Chinese-Fiji connection which is becoming a small but increasingly virulent abscess in the region. I don’t think this will work, but it’s a plausible strategy.

    It’s a very roundabout way of approaching Fiji, if that’s the case.

    Lew do you see this as an inevitable across-the-board win-lose? I don’t quite see how, if so.

    I hate making predictions, especially about the future :) No, of course, nothing is certain or inevitable – this is a judgement call based on the balance of probabilities as I see them. There are other possibilities, and it might work – McCully talked about the need for `discipline’ when it came to aid funds being used to support private enterprise and reducing the amount of governmental ticket-clipping associated with direct aid delivery. Presumably this means limiting potential for crony capitalism and associated corrupt and pseudo-corrupt practices and enforcing free and transparent trade systems as a condition of support. Again – it comes down to a matter of whether you believe them or not, or whether you think it’s even possible. I don’t really, on either count.

    jcuknz,

    stop burbling on about the Pacific ..

    Come again? The Pacific is what the new aid/trade strategy is all about.

    the story I heard suggested it would be South America and South Africa which MIGHT loose some aid … look after one’s own back yard I say.

    Perhaps you’d consider reading the linked press releases rather than listening to a `story’. There’s no `might’ about it.

    Though if they further the sanctions with aid cuts to Fuji I’d be unhappy.

    Assuming you mean Fiji, not a mountain in Japan, then prepare to be disappointed. The programme intends that aid be replaced by trade, and the state of diplomatic relations between NZ and Fiji doesn’t lend itself to the establishment of new and effective trade structures or relationships.

    L

  5. Tom Semmens on May 2nd, 2009 at 11:45

    I wonder if Jane Clifton will write anything about this.

  6. Pablo on May 2nd, 2009 at 13:11

    The subordination of foreign policy to trade is a bad move on several levels, and should be resisted by the professional diplomatic corps. If it is true that NZ Post CEO John Allen is to become the new Secretary of MFAT without any diplomatic credentials whatsoever, then the dye will clearly have been cast in that direction. The trouble is that this is an ideologically-driven project that does not take into account the fact that trade policy is embedded in a complex web of foreign relations and needs to be seen as such rather than as the end-all, be-all. For example, trade openings are used by other countries as part of a wider strategy of influence expansion. The PRC uses its trade networks as cover for intelligence-gathering in areas of strategic interest such as the South Pacific. It uses soft power (development aid) to buy influence in smaller nations of strategic interest such as Fiji and Tonga. Hence, subordinating broader strategic concerns to a trade-based NZ aid policy that “promotes growth” through private enterprise detracts from other areas such as the non-proliferation regime where NZ’s historical record has given in leverage in the diplomatic community, and in which it has used aid policy as a means of securing cooperation on disarmament and NPT issues (in other words, growth is not the issue). Hence to adopt a one-eyed approach to diplomatic endeavour rooted in an abject belief in the benefits of trade and privatized channels of soft power projection is not only ideologically rigid and naive. It is, at a minimum, potentially dangerous to NZ’s long-term security.

    The good news is that the professional diplomatic corps knows this, and can stymie the intrusions of ideologues like McCully should they choose to. The bad news is that continued public disinterest in foreign affairs allows the ideologues more room for maneuver than should rightfully be the case in a liberal democracy.

  7. SPC on May 2nd, 2009 at 18:55

    That’s a bit too black helicopter for me, but I wonder if a goal is to fly a few privatisation kites, establishing models for how things might work in NZ?

    Perhaps not in “vengeance”, its probably just the political ideologues looking for areas where they are not blocked by public resistance in New Zealand (and here can deliver proft making opportunities to their friends and sponsors). All while they are developing the way towards privatisation here as best they can meantime.

    On the foreign policy side of it, China’s approach has been to secure resource supply to its economy. The Pacific is not of much importance in this except for Australia and to a lesser extent New Zealand. One could take the view that their goal has so far been twofold – nuetralise Taiwan (which has some ties to Pacific colonisation) and otherwise not upset us or the Australians. If their relations with Taiwan improve, as they could well do so, our approach should be to welcome their economic development aid (which we cannot match) as neighbourliness from a fellow member of APEC and merely seek to be consulted about it.

  8. Lew on May 2nd, 2009 at 20:12

    SPC,

    I generally agree with what you’re saying here. I have one objection, though it’s tangential to the case in point:

    If their relations with Taiwan improve, as they could well do so

    At best, China’s relationship with Taiwan can hold steady, while the US remains a credible military force allied with Taiwanese independence (for its own strategic reasons). It’s a nasty situation. Alastair Iain Johnston has a neat argument (from a realist pragmatic position) for why all three parties to the Taiwanese situation engage in behaviour likely to result in eventual war although they would prefer to avoid war at all costs (hence the uneasy truce at present, founded on the fiction of `Chinese Taipei’). He argues that this fiction can be formalised, negating the likelihood of war – and while I don’t quite buy it, it goes some way to showing how complicated and convoluted things like this can get – and why saying `trade will make everything ok’ isn’t really an answer.

    L

  9. SPC on May 2nd, 2009 at 20:48

    It all depends on whether Taiwan adopts a bi-partisan position on their relationship with China. If the “mainland exile” party and the “local” nationalists can agree (as the competitors for local representative government) to enjoy continued autonomy without stressing any policy of independence.

    China appears to be be adopting a carrot and stick approach to move them to that position of co-existence with China. China’s goal appears to be to have them operate as if they will one day be an autonomous region within China (as per Hong Kong) – and provided Taiwan accepts this their reward is the suggestion that their existing autonomy is not at risk.

    The concern for Taiwan will be over whether China will continue with this benevolence should the power balance continue to move in their direction – or whether Taiwan will have to start operating as if they already an autonomous region within China to maintain good relations (though one suspects China will reward such behaviour and this process would occur without too much trauma).

    I think the nationalists in Taiwan will choose to settle for a gradual process of increasing co-operation while retaining some of their historic autonomy – to the extent that later this century we will regard Hong Kong and Taiwan as both similarly part of and yet apart from the rest of China.

    I think it will occur quite smoothly. If so, it will nuetralise the more militant of the Chinese leadership and be better for all of us.

  10. […] One the one hand National has embraced the idea of shifting its trade focus–which as Lew mentioned in an earlier post has once again become the basis for all foreign policy–towards Asia (and […]

Leave a Reply

Name: (required)
Email: (required) (will not be published)
Website:
Comment: